BTS - Spring Day (MV & MV Explained) Reaction | it hurts...

[@cora7480]

I'm so glad you enjoyed it. 💜💜 It is a very powerful story and the MV is a work of art. I liked what you were talking about hope. When you think about, a lot of the BU storyline is about hope really. If you ever get to read the webtoon and The Notes (and then all the MVs will make sense. I promise you), you'll see. There's a line from The Notes, when they are talking about their dreams (and most of them say they don't have any), and they look up the word "dream" in the dictionary, and then Yoongi says "That's weird. How can something that you want to achieve most in your life and something that is unlikely to come true both be called a dream?". Your talking about hope reminded me of that quote. 💜☂️

[@nnnnnn496]

Would have been better if you had suggested the Italian Army version. It gives an even better and nuanced explanation. She was even invited to Seoul to speak about the Tragedy because of this video. Have you watched it yourself? kzbin.info/www/bejne/fKO3ZZSVe9xppqc

[@cora7480]

@@nnnnnn496 yes, I have! It is an awesome video. I usually don't suggest it for reactions because it can be a bit triggering depending on the audience. But I'll tell him to watch it sometime if I have the chance 🤗

[@victoriaallen8840]

Spring Day has never left the charts in Korea to thus day it will surge towards the top... Also the person who made the explanation video also did 2 great videos to help with the BU you should check them out too

[@screamthename_1772]

@@404gram She/he never said its a part of BU bruh

[@Ashes1343]

If you want to explore the explanation deeper, there’s a longer video by a KZbinr called Italian Army that goes into much deeper detail about the tragedy and the visual connections within the video. I learned so much more about the government and corruption surrounding the tragedy, and why BTS had to be relatively vague when creating this video due to censorship restraints. If you have time, I highly recommend it. She put so much work into it, and it really shows how purposeful every single scene is in the Spring Day MV. It really broadened my appreciation for both the song and BTS as artists and storytellers.

[@chasingautumns]

Thanks for posting this, I had missed this explanation video. Warning, tho: slow down the playback speed!!!

[@kidu9443]

I concur , it's the most exhaustive out there.

[@armyonpluto]

Seconded! My heart was hurting and I had goosebumps the whole time I watched it

[@dnsr9870]

Little late but yes please try if you can watch this video

[@adventurousbananafish9418]

The clock in the laundry room is also stopped at the time the ferry began sinking. There was a lot of media black out and anyone who talked about it was black balled. Journalists were fired and news stations deterred. Someone even volunteered in the search and rescue and brought an expensive equipment for the search and was turned away. So even musicians had to be careful with what they said. BTS 100% made this for those who endured the tragedy, they just found a creative way to tell it. Winter = grief Spring = moving away from grief, I think it is a very relatable song for anyone to hear. Truly the Queen of their discography 💜

[@ebony7177]

RM wrote the song while walking in a park. He was thinking of Suga and his friends. You were probably told to watch this as a part of the storyline and the explained only gave you the Sewol Ferry theories. I want to explain to you the parts that pertain to the story because even though it's not officially BU the guys have mentioned that there are storyline elements in it. Remember the overarching theme of the storyline is growing up: leaving childhood for the uncertainty of adulthood. Also that the guys are happiest when together. Snowpiercer is also about stagnation and how you have to keep moving forward in life. There were many who were fine staying in the back of the train but the protag knew for any change to happen they must leave what they know for a world of unknowns. Like leaving the comfort of childhood for the world of grownups. Omelas: The boy in this instance is Jin. Remember he is forever apart from them. He suffers trying to fix everyone's life. He is at the bottom of the stairs while the guys run from him and he is viewing them like always thru his "camera" (his hands making the camera shape). The cake throwing scene is like a passage in The Notes (the album notes that gave further insight into the story). They were having a party, happy to be together but eventually something happens and they split apart. Jungkook is running, looking for everyone. Once he finds them he is happy and they are together running towards something now. What they come to is the train with the versions of themselves now heading towards adulthood. Finally not riding in a loop, allowed to finally press forward (like snowpiercer). The clothing mound they sit on represents all the clothes and things they are going to have to leave behind when they finally embrace adulthood. There are probably some I'm forgetting but I finished the storyline so long ago not every thing remains in my head. Oh aspects of the song: when we saw JHope on the train it was Jin singing then Jimin. Live versions of this song give that part to Hobi, along with RM's sorta vocal part in the beginning. Hobi did a lot of background vocals for this song so for lives they gave him parts from the others so on stage he has parts.

[@flyushkifly]

The layers of meaning and relevance will always stun me. Thx for the info. I've never delved into the BU side of Spring Day. 😘💜

[@JAD_BTS_ARMY]

you are amazing your comment explain everything well,, even if an bts mv is not related to the BU they always put some references to the storyline

[@bltotrs92]

But why show the sea with the shoes that jimin founds then. That reminds me so much of the found shoes pairs of the dead on the beach where the ferry sunk😥

[@ebony7177]

@@bltotrs92 And that belongs in the theory section for the ferry tragedy. I was only discussing the parts that could pertain to storyline. Besides Lumpens the director of the MV said the shoes represented apathy not death.

[@zsar2662]

Wow. I always thought the reference to Omelas was a bit stretched, but I never tried to analyse spring day from a BU standpoint. Its so obvious now that the boy is clearly Jin. I should be expecting this at this point but as @flyushkifly said above, the layers in BTS songs always is mind boggling. Even the BU certified songs can be interpreted in two ways, one of course referencing the storyline and the other directly related to what the boys were feeling irl

[@oneshysquish9409]

The film “Snowpiercer” came out in 2013 is actually on Netflix. I know that there are a lot of people involved in making the movie but the majority of the main cast were American. But because of the Korean director I do believe it has both Korean and American influences which make it quite a great and thought-provoking film. I would definitely recommend.

[@madkrakatoa]

Wait... the movie is still available on Netflix? Which country? It was removed from Latin America like 2 years ago? I watched back then because of Chris Evans, and weeks later it was gone...

[@oneshysquish9409]

Golden Hyung it’s still available in the U.S

[@madkrakatoa]

@@oneshysquish9409 Netflix Boomer..long long time ago I used to use VPN to watch other countries options

[@broo2691]

The time you said it was Jungkook it was Jimin, and the time you thought it was J-Hope it was Jin.

[@TheBethm01]

I believe the captain is in jail for what he did, thankfully. Along with other crew members involved in that horrific decision. After learning about all of that you definitely listen to Spring Day differently

[@adventurousbananafish9418]

Beth McKigen i think the owner of the boat also committed suicide

[@Michelen7]

@@adventurousbananafish9418 - It was a teacher or headmaster of the school that committed suicide.

[@ashleyder9164]

The captain was charged with murder and sent to prison, yes. The other crew members were given lesser sentences under the argument that they had to obey their captain, but they were also punished. I just don't remember how. I know one of the divers who worked to retrieve bodies ended up committing suicide :(

[@ragnhildmd5063]

@@ashleyder9164 let's not forget that not all of the crew members were punished. Some of them did everything in their power to evacuate passangers, where some of them even lost their life on the process of doing so.

[@rennymullally328]

The captain got life in prison. When he realised the boat was sinking he sent a mayday signal and got his crew off the boat. The coast guard recieving the mayday messaged back to confirm what was happening and no one replied as they had left. So they thought it was a hoax. It took them 90 minutes to realise there was a problem. The first responders were near by fishermen from jeju island. 270 people lost their lives that day of which 250 were middle schoolers from the same school. My heart goes out to the families of the deceased . They will never be forgotten💜💔💕

[@MarinaEariel]

You should check a live version because they changed up a bit. J-Hope starts with some of the lines RM has on the studio version.

[@victoriaallen8840]

Snowpiercer is not an old movie, I believe Chris Evans stars in it. Joon-ho Bong , directed Parasite, the Best Picture at the Academey Awards this year

[@queensaharaice7376]

Yes, Chris is in it! As well as Octavia Spencer, Tilda Swinston (the Ancient One in Marvel), and John Hurt.

[@fruehlingsbotin]

It's from 2013

[@EvieKng]

It is kinda old though. Released in 2013.

[@swanhill5759]

Eve Kng Lol 7 years is not old. Especially since he was talking about his experience with films from the 40’s and 50’s.

[@sandys1890]

He Directed the Movie Snow piercer (2014) and Parasite ..The explanation video shows a clip from the movie...You are confusing it with new Netflix series based on the Movie

[@thegeekoutgirl]

If you ever want to know more about the sewol ferry tragedy there's this video on youtube that I thought was good, but be prepared to cry: "What Went Wrong in the South Korean Ferry Disaster?" by The New Yorker. You will get so angry with how the government dealt with the situation, how they lied and faked everything, and how it led to the president being impeached. You just feel so bad for the families. I remember a part where they mentioned that some of the kids could have been surviving in the air pockets of the sinking ship, but no one was doing anything to save them. And the civilian divers who tried to help were so traumatized by the experience. It's all so tragic. The youtube channel, Italian Army, also had a good video that goes deeper into the symbols spread throughout the music video: "What you STILL DON'T KNOW about BTS SPRING DAY MV".

[@Nevermind_-]

This video is so depressing in so many ways. You can attribute it specifically to losing someone in your life, whether too early or when it's simply their time, and you can also take it wholeheartedly as specifically for the Sewol Ferry issue. For me specifically, I lost my best friend in a horrible car accident (on 8/31 it will have been 3 years) and every time I listen to this song, especially Suga's part where he says pretty much "I hate you because you're gone, but I miss you so, so, SO much".

[@crystalsnow1138]

When they sing Spring Day live J Hope sings the first part that RM does in the beginning because in the studio version he doesn't have any lines besides harmonizing.

[@Moon-cc1un]

i see

[@shiene.]

The reason why they made it look like a fun scene and they made the whole mv not obvious is because at that time they release the song and mv.. It is not allowed or it is illegal to have songs about sewol ferry tragedy and make songs that criticizes the government in korea because if so.. The artists who made songs like that will be banned. But bighit and bts did something amazing. They made an mv and song that criticize the goverment without the goverment noticing it. It really shows that bts always ready to help even when they know they will get banned. Fun fact: Bighit once stated that bts themselves said that they want to donate $85,000 to those victim's families silently.

[@lux3226]

It wasn't that it wasn't allowed, and it wasn't illegal. The government (at the time - the Korean president ended up getting impeached) was black listing any artists who spoke out on the tragedy. And it wasn't that BTS somehow did something that the rest of Korea and the world noticed, but somehow, the government didn't have a clue - it was because there were no direct references other than some POSSIBLE symbols. By that time, BTS had enough clout, and the president was under enough backlash, for anyone in the government to do anything about it - and if they had, it would only have made things that much worse. And it wouldn't have been a silent donation, if BigHit made an announcement about it. Not to downplay the song, music video, or the empathy and generosity of BTS and BigHit - but I don't think it's necessary to stretch the truth when praising our boys. The truth of them is just as beautiful, if not more so.

[@shiene.]

@@lux3226 oh okay.. I just get it from the article i've read and some of if it i just copy paste it from the article.. But okay💜 thankyou for the info💜

[@lux3226]

@@shiene. Np. Didn't mean to call you out on anything, just wanted to clarify. :)

[@shiene.]

@@lux3226 yes, yes.. Its okay💜 thankyou💜

[@Moon-cc1un]

cause they are brilliant

[@helenscott8202]

I realize I’m close to a year late, but I wanted you to know how much I enjoyed your exploration of Spring Day. I remember the Sewol Ferry Disaster very well. I’m in Dallas, but it made headlines in U.S. news for days. I grew up in the military, around a lot of Asians. That disaster, the government’s actions, the ferry’s captain and crew were constantly in the news. Worse, I really understood what I was reading. This song and BTS sort of complete the circle. Yes, I have looked at all of the BTS stuff on this, and watched a number of reactors. But you have hit the closest to where I am. Thanks.

[@alyshajohnson7010]

When he pauses and says cute. That made my day.

[@Umla80]

I do love this song, i perfer Italianarmy's explanation more its more extensive but i can understand why its not as popular since its in Italian with English subs. She brings up alot more facts and links and explain more i find this explanation video is more emotional (and Italianarmy picks up on more details like the clock in the laundrymat showing the time the ship went down). for those interested kzbin.info/www/bejne/fKO3ZZSVe9xppqc (that fairy tale btw "Little Match girl" is one sad sad story... about a girl seeing her dead loved ones each time she strikes a match and at the end of the night they find her dead with a smile on her face... old fairy tales were not the disney kind :P )

[@toanzhou]

The little match girl seeing her dead loved ones is not a gift or a curse. She was seeing things as she was dying, so it wasn’t something she could normally do. It’s a Hans Christian Anderson story - like the emperors new clothes, the ugly duckling, the little mermaid.

[@Moon-cc1un]

ahh ty for this. i felt like i heard the name but not. Made me confused.

[@1obsessionafteranother794]

“The ones who walk away from Omelas” never return Edit: sorry, I’m paraphrasing but towards the end of the short story there is actually this line below: “They leave Omelas, they walk ahead into the darkness, and they don’t come back”

[@JAD_BTS_ARMY]

yeah absolutly

[@riajhart]

Ursula K. Le Guin is one of my favorite writers, she wrote so many good stories. I'm sad we lost a mind like hers but that's life.

[@1obsessionafteranother794]

MVHeart I confess I’ve only read “Omelas” for obvious reasons. I like to read fantasy fiction myself so I was aware of her name but hadn’t actually read anything by her. I understand the scope of her work is wide. Even “Omelas” alone is so affecting though. I read it once and in my head “never return” were the words that popped into my head the very next time I saw the title

[@riajhart]

@@1obsessionafteranother794 Give her series Earthsea a try then when you have time, it's my favorite of hers. I read it when I was a teenager and it made me love the genre even more. The first book of the series is "A Wizard of Earthsea"

[@JAD_BTS_ARMY]

@@riajhart i think i will check it you made me curious

[@AngelaSealana]

Bro, this was one of my favorite reactions of yours. Really wouldn't have minded if you had continued some of your thoughts on those deep topics. Thanks for this.

[@erikoenglish1651]

325 highschool students were on the board. 75 students only survived but 250 students were not. Vice principal was survived but he committed suicide.

[@thegeekoutgirl]

22:45 If you have Netflix, "Snowpiercer" is on there at the moment. Chris Evans (Captain America) is the protagonist. The director, Bong Joon Ho, also did the movie "Parasite" which made big news this year by winning four awards at the Oscars. Awesome since it's a foreign film XD

[@flyushkifly]

The Little Match Girl was freezing to death as she lit match after match (the only thing of value she had to sell) to try to stay warm. You're welcome.

[@inacialimadasilva7521]

There is a documentary about the accident! One of the men who have rescued some people took his life after some time.He was in depression cause he never forgot that scene and the ones he couldn`t save!! It´s so sad!

[@ishasaxena4144]

Spring day is one of their if not their one n only Forever Powerful song ... spring day is our Queen who never gets out of army’s hearts and never gets off of music charts 😌☺️

[@karnihiggins835]

I just want to say I love your reactions and the insight you seem to have. You often speak out the same thoughts that I am thinking when I listen to a song. This is nice as I am a more mature kpop listener, shall we say, I think it is refreshing to have a guy be open about his struggles and vulnerabilities, thank you so much. Until next time.

[@MTetzke]

Please, please, please read the short Fictional story "Those Who Walked Away from Omelas." It will make you think and rethink your standpoint. 1st I put my own child as the one suffering. Then I rethought it with my son and loved ones as townspeople. This book is incredibly thought provoking. Great Read!🙏😷💜♾

[@KimberlyMichelle3]

You should absolutely watch "Snowpiercer" it has Chris Evans as the main character and is so so so good!!

[@queensaharaice7376]

I agree! I saw it for the first time this year and WOW I loved it. And that ending👀

[@shr2310]

Yes It's such a good movie Like I literally was shocked how amazing it was I actually studied it alot to see what was the exact point of the movie A masterpiece

[@nancyhennes]

Would love it if you also listen to the brit rock version of this song and maybe add a live performance. There are many beautiful ones but i have a soft spot for the class of 2020 one because it was a total surprise to us all, that they sang spring day again after almost 3 years since their last performance of it in 2017.

[@Moon-cc1un]

Nice. I love this song and MV. In Dear Class 2020 they sing this song too. It's beautiful. I love the fact that this song never left the charts either. It's played in shops in Korea. Ppl want to remember and BTS helps them and makes ppl aware of the truth. Brilliant. -baby army brklyn, NY

[@fernrouintree563]

Spring Day is one of my absolute favorite BTS songs. It's so heartbreakingly beautiful and carries such a powerful message for those of us who have unexpectedly lost loved ones. It makes me cry but at the same time soothes my heart 💜

[@inactive1393]

glad you checked out this song and the explanation. this one is kind of hard for me to listen to- it took on a whole different meaning for me after my best friend committed suicide. i couldnt really relate to this song before, but it hits way too close to home now.

[@runefrooninckx5736]

Thank you for being so open to talk about depression and mental health, it's important people know it's okay to talk about it

[@xmxcxxmxcx]

Our queen has arrived 🥺👑

[@riajhart]

Reading is a good way to teach someone indirectly, it's even better than the kind of teaching that mostly occurs in school because it's a journey where you asks yourself the questions and see the answers for yourself, there's no one telling them to you (at least good writers do that, and there's a lot of good writers out there). I don't know how old your son is, but you could even read the books you find appropriate to him, and make that moment a time you spend together reading and asking yourselves questions about it. When I was very young, my dad did that with me and that's how I became to love books before I learned to read. My dad isn't into reading at all though, he did that because he didn't want my first experience with books to be the one schools offer and he loved reading them to me. Thanks to him I discovered a world that has given me so many priceless things, it opened me as a person. This tragedy was really a tragedy... but one that could have been avoided so easily... I saw a documentary about it and... oh boy, was it infuriating to see the incompetence of everyone involved. If the students had jumped out of that ferry, they would be alive, but instead they were told to wait and they did, because you believe that the person in charge has your best interest in mind. Some even texted with their parents, and the parents themselves told them to listen to their teachers and well, that's such a heartbreaking burden to have with you for the rest of your life. It's not the parents' fault, of course, but the mother that said "If only I had told her another thing" in the documentary broke my heart. Also, most of the messages the students sent their parents were saying "I'm afraid" and "I miss you", the whole thing is heartbreaking.

[@samormiston3887]

How to not lose all your personal time? Maybe line up some related videos (I'd suggest sticking to one artist each time) so maybe MV, (DKDKTV/xCeleste) Explain Vid, Dance Practice, Live/Comeback/Award Performance and do it as a live stream ... do it as is, raw and cut our the editing time factor .... I'd be careful around the live aspects (as you know) but there are ways to group songs together logically. I don't know how much time you spend editing but this might help? re how you teach your children to not focus on their needs? wow it's so hard ... my main teaching points with mine is .. loving themselves (given), always taking responsibility for their actions even if it means they get in trouble and finally, treating others as they want to be treated so I guess this means that their happiness and successes can not and should not ever ever be at the expense of others. Mine are 8 & 10 so conversations are still fairly tame but I stick to the same points. It's hard teaching them resilience and responsibility so young and it's been hit and miss over the years but eventually I hope they will be self reflecting and aware adults who consider the needs of the many over their personal needs. COVID19 has actually been a huge teaching point for the last part in the family. Considering how our actions impact others etc. Thank you for the video, it is emotional to understand what it all means and it's why Spring Day is our Queen and has been on Melon charts since release. There is a live performance at an awards show that shows other idols reacting to the song .. it is such a powerful emotive song (I can't recall which one though). Take care.

[@lisab.6164]

You were incredibly insightful and I so appreciated your appreciation for this beautiful song. 💜

[@stargazelisa]

lol I just want to say just bc it shows one member on the screen doesn't mean it's that member singing or rapping. love your reactions i just spent the past 2 days binging on your bts videos!

[@Michelle-bk2hx]

Funny you should mention the oppressive school system - that was actually the first topic BTS covered! Their first 3 albums revolved around school, as they were all high school/university students at the time. Check out N.O. - released in 2013, it criticizes the harsh Korean school system, where students spend all day and night studying to try and get into a ‘S.K.Y’ university (acronym for the ‘top 3’ schools in Korea)

[@WillowTree1215]

i would love if you watched spring day performed live

[@WillowTree1215]

ooh and the dance practices are great

[@kisi9121]

I´ll cry everytime when i see this video, still after several times. I was 18 years old when i was in very bad accident with my friends. One was my very close friend 16 year old Marika. Evening was so nice we talked about everything what happened earlier. Told how we loved one another. We was going to our friends house to spending happy evening. In gas station buying some snacks and suddenly i did´nt want to sit in that place in car anymore, so my fried moved. Later we didn´t find the intersection right a way so driver stopped the car to do u-turn. Didn´t he see that big truck that comed?Anyway he turned car to front of truck and both my friends died next to my. My good friend Marika and driver samuli 19years old. Me and my ex-boyfriend survived with little damages. I was so hard times, thats why i feel still quite same like those young teens who survived. Now im 45 years and i still thinking allmoust every day about my friend, she is allways with me where ever i go. sometimes i still keep thinking why i survived , not my young friends. My surviving skills have been that i think after that , i have things what i have to do in my life. now i´m practical nurse helping other people how needs help, this make me happy somehow. and i got 4 lovely children . maybe because of this accident i have come to better person. i believe that everybody have their jobs to do in their livetime and when you die, its your time to die . its realism i guess. but my childhood ended in that day and that thought that survivor some way suiside himself, i have feel that. after that life will go on. you are allways in my memory dear friends Marika and Samuli

[@lux3226]

RM wrote Spring Day while sitting in a park one day. He was reminiscing about old friends, specifically, a painful experience he and Suga had in their past. He wrote the song as a way to help listeners cope with the pain of having lost loved ones, and a reminder that despite the darkness, light will one day come again, winter will eventually turn to spring, and happiness will once again be a part of your life. All it takes is time, and the determination and faith to wait for it to happen. The music video pays homage to Korea's Sewol Ferry tragedy, which had happened a few years prior to this music video, as it was still a very current pain for all Koreans, so it became a balm to help ease that pain. It is a very special song in Korea to Koreans, which explains why it stays at the top of Korea's music rankings, as it is a very beautiful song, but the "meaning" of it is simply what I said previously, to speak of lost loved ones, and the hope for joy to return. At the risk of sounding waspish - why do people immediately think "omg, suicide!" when they see a person put their ear to train rails? Maybe because I'm a bit older than most ARMY, but I remember that people used to put their ear to train rails to feel the vibrations of the rails and hear if there is a train rumbling on its way on that line (a bit like the 2 paper cups on a string concept - amplifies sound and carries it along the line). I'm happy this is no longer a thing, as it was dangerous, but it was never about suicide. And while suicide makes the news article of the survivor that much more impactful, that wasn't the intention when Tae put his ear to the rail. JUST as poignant would have been to think he did it because he wanted to hear the train of those who'd been lost, but knowing he'd never hear it again.

[@legende827]

Yes you re so right about the principal subject of Asian movies and drama. I watch a lot of Korean and Chinese drama and movies and I also notice that. It’s why I love these much better than American movies. They re very deep about human relation. If you are not to sensitive, there are actually two series , Japanese :Alice in borderland and korean Sweet home, action and fantastic series but the scenarist have made an amazing job about relationship and how deal between survival and helping others. It’s the best part of these series for me, better than the effect, the events etc...and If I have one drama to recommend about human relation , it’s : it’s okay to not be okay. Four exemple of relation, the romance, the brotherhood, the friendship and the manipulation one in a very particular way for all these relations. . Don’t worry, I have to pause too to read the explanation. That’s to fast to process. 😁

[@kaycicaldy7190]

The Sewol disaster is truly heartbreaking. There are actually voice recordings of students calling their parents in panic and you can hear the crew on speakers in the background telling them to go back to their cabins and not evacuate. Meanwhile the captain and many crew steadily snuck off the ship. The few passengers who survived were actually rescued by commercial fishing boats because the crew hadn’t even alerted the coast guard that the ship was capsizing until they were already away from the scene on the life boats! It’s like a modern day titanic, where the lower classes are locked below while the upper classes are up top getting the life boats. The captain and many crew did eventually get convicted.

[@marinal.]

I also learned what the shoes mean. I never knew and I see them a lot in my area. Sad. Love this song. They are amazing for making this. Yes, we need to remember. -baby army NY USA

[@LoveYoonMin]

The Sewol tragedy happened on my son's birthday. This really made me 😭. 💜💐

[@wolf0fdreams1026]

Going to have to look into BTS now, this video may have made me a fan lol I love groups that have deeper meanings in their songs, and they did a superb job. Props to everyone who worked on the MV. Another great video Champ!

[@kunikuzushis]

BTS is generally known for having deeper messages in their music.

[@JAD_BTS_ARMY]

the abandoned carriage is a reference to j.hope mom cuz she abandonnated him there with a sneaker when he was 4 u see him in fake love too, i recomand u xCELEST channel she did full videos about the BU she explained it very well also the webtoon SAVE ME will make you understand many things from the storyline, DKDKTV is a very good channel too they explained many BTS songs and mvs

[@triana3679]

but this MV is not related to BU

[@JAD_BTS_ARMY]

@@triana3679 yes .. but in fake love there are many references to it ,, remember that jungkook was also running and watching the member from above, and trying to save them from their sadness and miserie it is a methaphore and a reference to the Omelas child in the book, also like i said the abandoned carriage is a reference to j.hope story with his mom .. there is alot

[@RiSaRx85]

This song made me fall in love with V's voice.

[@Maria-ir1wq]

This is my favorite music video It's just so special to me idk

[@user-ur8mb6bh7u]

This song has never left the Korean charts ever since 2017 and it is THE spring song of every year from then. No other idols wanted to speak out on the tragedy as they felt like they might get blacklisted by the THEN Korean Govt (who is in jail now) but bangtan has always conveyed their messages through their music. They never really said anything about the tragedy through this mv but the theory were really almost on point with all of the msgs that they showed us in the song. They also quietly donated to the survivors of the tragedy. They have always been the ones to stand up for the youths of today and ppl have been respecting them slowly as artists (not idols) because of the positive messages that they have always given to us. The captain of the ship actually committed suicide after the tragedy because he felt too guilty and the rest went to jail.

[@MrKaibaoh]

Who is gonna tell him that there are theories where it fits spring day within the storyline 👀😂

[@thegeekoutgirl]

23:30 That is very interesting. I'm the opposite because we probably have different life experiences with religion lol. I found hope outside of the oppressive nature of organized religion to be honest. But I know that religion has helped a lot of people so I think that's nice.

[@TheChampOfMedium]

I'm not a religious person... but I do hope. And I believe organized religion is generally a negative on the impact of what religion is supposed to be about, Faith and Morality. I am in agreement with you though.

[@thegeekoutgirl]

@@TheChampOfMedium Ah, I misunderstood what you said. My bad

[@tinajezee3807]

U should watch spring day love perform... J-hope sings so beautiful, & if u listen carefully to this song, u xan hear j-hope's voice in chorus mix with Jk...i can hear his voice clearly..

[@momclg]

It happened April 16, 2014. There a video on the 7th anniversary

[@ChrisTine-xu1rh]

Watching this while drinking my coffee because its raining outside and im crying 😭

[@ankiec4354]

I came as fast as I could 💜

[@moninaninanina8201]

The Snowpiercer movie is a bit new and also directed by the same director of Parasite, which won an oscar for best picture just this year. also, thanks for sharing about depression and suicide as not many talk about this topic even though a lot of us experience this. Going through depression myself, the song Answer: Love Myself by BTS really helped me a lot! I hope you'd give it a listen as it is an underrated song and not all youtubers react to it but some who do ends up crying happy tears because the message is about loving yourself despite all your flaws and mistakes and that you are beautiful. there is no MV for this song but you can check the color coded lyrics. and if you do, prepare some tissues.

[@doodledoomoo]

Beautiful reaction! This BTS song is so powerful!

[@Michelen7]

The Queen. I always get chills listening to this beautiful, sad song. Watching the explanation video always makes me teary. I loved your thoughts on it and the subject.

[@azlianabitriz1]

So many connect this song mv to the ferry tragedy.. but for me its related to their HYYH BU storyline. its about how they missed each other when they being apart especially after jhope left the village. if u read the notes u can really relate to it. anyway thank u so much for this reaction video. Spring Day always be beautiful in Army hearts.

[@adorexjoon4840]

Can you watch "No More Dream MV"? It is their first music video ever and it is awesome.

[@TheChampOfMedium]

It's someone's Patreon request this month... so I got you.

[@adorexjoon4840]

@@TheChampOfMedium Yay!!!! I am super excited. Sorry I can't support you on Patreon.

[@LynnHermione]

@@TheChampOfMedium Also, NO, I am always in awe that MV was released.

[@Kauritree08]

When i understood the meaning and the weight of the message these story tellers were sharing with us, it became one of my most favourite songs of all time. Although not South Korean, I feel connected in a very human way to it and protective of this song because of it's tragic beauty. This is important work.

[@owedawn76]

In regards to the snowpiercer movie i HIGHLY suggest you watch it! It's on Netflix and is definitely an interesting movie. It makes you really think. I'd be interested to know what you think.

[@minyoongistan5852]

And also the drama version on Netflix...the 1st season just finished a few weeks ago

[@napofagalaxy]

I think people tend to forget that Spring Day was never technically confirmed to be about the Sewol tragedy, though it is true that many people interpreted it that way! There are definitely a ton of things that point to it as that “explained” video showed, as well as BTS and BH privately donating towards the tragedy. Yoongi’s verse, however, was about his own personal story with someone he used to be friends with (see: the same lines used in his D-2 track “Dear My Friend”), and Namjoon has said that the song in general is about missing friends and comforting people. He wrote most of it while at a park watching leaves fall and later changed “leaves” to “snowflakes” falling in the lyrics. I personally think it’s really cool that BTS can bring so many different meanings together for a single song, allowing even more people to feel a connection with it. Glad you enjoyed it even if it wouldn’t normally be your cup of tea!

[@kurohebie3161]

Like any great art it can be done about a personal feeling of the artist but be speaking to people for their own feelings. That is why I like that BTS don't give explanation.

[@moomakemoney]

I've been trying to get used yo this genre.. no doubt there are gems in there, but I'm com0keyely new to it all... Dreamcatcher, there's a couple of theird that I was really impressed with...you named one of the songs at the beginning of your marathon video... I looked through your list of videos, but I didn't see this...have you reviewed Kard - Red Moon? kzbin.info/www/bejne/kHKoooSGdqqeq8k

[@rubymiragernhuber4774]

Try and listen to Ysabell, she sang. Spring day in English..and it will give you a better understanding of Spring Day by BTS..she does a lot of BTS English version 💜

[@veeva99]

To this day Spring Day is still my favorite BTS song. I was there when it came out, and I'm still here for it now.

[@mariematthews7571]

If you listen real close Jhopes vocals are behind a lot of the vocalists (I believe it's him) it's like on the lower octave so it kinda mixes with the others' voices. Although they did him dirty imo. BUT in the live performance J-hope sings, mainly the beginning part where Namjoon sings

[@HerQuietLife]

I know I’m commenting on an old af video but I’ve been going through a bunch of your BTS reactions since watching this one and I’m curious to know if you’ve reacted to N.O? It deals with the criticism of Koreas school system and might be something you’d love (especially since it’s from their second album) given your comments about our own school systems.Anyway your sincere reactions have been a pleasure to watch. I also hope you get a chance to listen to their mtv unplugged soon if you haven’t already! Edit: lol never mind I see you just uploaded it 🤦‍♀️

[@Rockerbaby1031]

I definitely recommend watching Snowpiercer. It's by the same director of the movie Parasite, but it's in English. Has Chris whatshisname that plays Captain America as the lead character in the movie. Its definitely.....interesting & memorable.

[@AsHope-wy5nr]

spring day Song the studio version: J-Hope voice is in the background JK& J-hope V & J-hope Jin & J-hope Jimin & J-hope J-Hope's voice has always been deep in his vocal background If you hide the vocal, you can clearly hear his voice You have to watch it in the live performance

[@that-weirdogirl]

j-hope sings live performances of this song, BUT you can definitely hear his hidden/background vocals throughout the track

[@BikroKosmos]

Artists whom came out and spoke/wrote about the tragedy were blacklisted so BTS found away to NEVER FORGET those whom died and using the book, movie, and BU Universe was truly an ingenious way.

[@forgotaboutdrea]

This song is so emotional, and I definitely didn't appreciate it before I learned more of the story behind it. Honestly, it's just amazing that BTS has created something that can be interpreted so many ways. Other theory videos I think are really interesting: Justt Ally's theory video that ties it into the entire BU (kzbin.info/www/bejne/gKWzfJ-gerqbl8U). I especially like how she points out the possibility of Jungkook as the child that powers Omelas and shows all the shot-for-shot parallels. Rosacea's theory that explores parallels (kzbin.info/www/bejne/fXvKp4l9r5pmjqM). This one seems to have a lot of support from the Mnet performance BTS did, with JK as the victim, Jimin as a survivor, Jin and V as Life and Death, and the rapline as Hope/Despair/Time. It's also 3x as dark as bulletproof vibes' original video, so just a warning. The Mnet performance (kzbin.info/www/bejne/mX7UnqGenLN_jrs), which has a set that looks like a ferry but also has the Omelas sign. Hobi sings the opening, and parts of the choreo seem to show Jimin as the survivor, but other parts have Jin comforting V, so it gets even more confusing.

[@theajane6444]

I knew who BTS was before 2017--but this is the song/MV that made me fall in love with them and brought me into the fandom. Spring Day will always be my favorite BTS song. Thanks for reacting to it--and for whatever pain you have had to move through in your life: sending you lots of love and light.

[@cofradehospitalet]

I'm not really a fan of K-pop, but, if you want to enjoy the songs in a diferent way you must see the coreographied version of some songs for the group K-Tigers, it's a group of younger taekwondists doing K-pop versions of their dances. You can try this Momoland-BBoom-BBoom version kzbin.info/www/bejne/pIS7p4qLd9OEmK8

[@sush07]

It's a bittersweet song. Aka the chart queen. I am going to touch on the book "those who walked away from Omelas". It's a short story, you can read it in like 30ish minutes. So please read it. Although the gist of the story has been mentioned here, the effect of feeling the emotions while reading is so much more powerful. Especially, you mentioned you wanted to touch on this subject with your child. The book leaves you thinking. This song amazes me with the layers of storytelling. There is the sewol tragedy, the snowpiercer movie references, the Omelas. But the most powerful factor is the message of Hope.

[@karulicius19]

This song hit me every time I listen or watch the video even if I listen the instrumental.. .... this song make me so emotional (I cry every time) because reminds me of my loves one who are gone, especially the first part where said, I Miss you, Saying this makes me miss you even more, I Miss you Even though I’m looking at your photo, Time’s so cruel... 🖤 sorry for my English 😬 Borahae 💜

[@croceyzx2433]

6:04 is Jin singing. J-hope had no lines (major lines like the others) instead he did the backing track/backing vocals. In the live performances however, he sings RMs part (2:20 - 2:46) then RM does the rapping.

[@Daysleeper00]

You are one of the smartest reactors ive watched so far. I can see how sincere you are in wanting to dig deeper into the meanings of the BTS songs, performances and MVs. To top it all, i appreciate how much you want to know the members individually. Thank you. I am a baby Army myself and is still learning. ❤️😎

[@TheJourneyTo-Me]

Great wouldbe if You would watch Bangtan Universe summary made by Rosan on xCeleste channel please it is a worth watching summary which can direct you on a right path

[@sollyrose]

This song has clear references to the sewol ferry. But like most of BTS songs, there's many different ways to understand it. It's basically about the pain of missing somebody. Also about suicide or about the guilty feeling that you often feel when you're alive and somebody you loved not anymore.

[@skier___7843]

Here’s a link to a video about the backstory of the tragedy: kzbin.info/www/bejne/a5CkaZenZ8t0a9E

[@blaublaubeere]

If I remember correctly the song itself doesn't refer to the tragedy, but RM wrote it about his friends (Yoongi in particular, I feel like he mentioned), but seeing it with the MV kinda changes the meaning more towards the tragedy - at least all the Koreans I've seen reacting to it/telling about it immediately saw the connection between them. Also yeah there's already a comment about the storyline elements in this, so Im not gonna dive into that. But it is one of my favourites of their MV's and songs regardless, and people can relate to it in many different ways which is just beautiful. I personally I'm not religious at all, but what you said about hope and faith was something I feel like I can understand too

[@sandys1890]

The Coastguard smoked cigarettes on the deck of their ship while parents screamed for them to help the children...They even prevented others in small boats from helping...The birth rate in Korea is only about 1%

[@crowpearl571]

A copy paste of my own comment from another video. I watched the video of the clips taken by the kids, when the ship was in the process of shipping. A miracle that those phones survived. One kept saying that they should prepare because this is reality, and that they could die. One was saying how he hadn't gotten a girlfriend yet. One mentioned how he still had anime to watch. One shouted that they still had dreams. Many were already recording last regards to their parents, siblings and people they were close with. A lot of them were breaking down, at this point the boat was on such a tilt that the toilet water had poured out and it was difficult to get around. Another girl wanted them to all meet up after they survived, but in an interview with a survivor, she was one of the picture frames at the memorial. There was one instance where the students inquired about the friends on the ship's deck, speculating that they might have fallen off. Instead, those might have been the ones who were rescued. You could hear from the P.A. that the captain kept telling the children to "never" move or get our of their quarters. In fact, one boy began to really curse the captain multiple times, saying that his death will be caused by "this devastating captain". I would say, a good choice of last farewells. Currently, 2 scuba divers have lost their lives in search for missing bodies, which stands at 5 as of now. The crew have sentences of several years, while the captain dodged the death sentence. He has been sentenced to prison for life. BigHit and BTS have donated to the families.

[@monika95302]

No matter how many times I have watched it already,I am gonna end crying anyway 😭😭💜💜

[@momclg]

250 kids died and a total of 300 and 5 have never been found, the captain got 36 yrs in prison and the principal of the school committed suicide

[@kemipue]

I was taught at school that shoes hanging from power lines indicates where you can meet to get drugs with different coloured shoes representing different substances... Don’t think commemorating the dead would be the reason for the shoes where I live in England, not sure about where you live...

[@ashleyder9164]

While I think the explanation is important, I think it is equally important to understand firstly that the explanation is about the *music video* imagery, not the song itself, which was intended to comfort people suffering loss for a variety of reasons and not solely for one specific incident. Also, I will say that while I think the explanation video is accurate on some points, that it takes it too far and stretches the symbolism or assigns incorrect meaning to some of the imagery in the MV. There are a few explanation videos out there and each of them has different valuable interpretations. I think while it is good to acknowledge the Sewol Ferry disaster as something they clearly made reference to in some of the imagery used, we do a disservice to the song and the MV to make it *all* and *only* about that.

[@chencalo]

I'm so glad you did this. This song and explanation is what made me an Army last year. I was introduced to them when Dynamite came out but then I found this and then there was no turning back for me since then. 💜💔

[@freedomsh]

Who starts singing is not Rm,is JHOPE..I don’t get it why they used RM for the opening of the video.

[@Purplynne613]

Queen Spring Day. The Queen of all BTS’ songs💜

[@linneamai4862]

How about using something like google doxy or doodle to write down requests. You could share a link in the inbox and we tick the songs we request?

[@anickia12]

What makes this theory more believable is the fact that BTS donated to the victims of the incident around the time this mv was released.

[@ABCav-n9f]

In my country (Argentina) if you see shoes in the cables in the block, it means that you can buy drugs lol

[@sandymartinez5434]

Go to xCeleste’s channel to learn more about BTS’ storylines.

[@winterlate9915]

I feel you. and thanks for sharing this. I hope that people will more open about mental health issues, cz it s not a shame to talk about it.

[@ericaelizalde1544]

💝💝💝🇦🇷