Buttermilk Pie Southern Style - 100 Year Old Recipe - The Hillbilly Kitchen

A traditional southern pie with a unique flavor all its own. It's simple to make and a favorite among country people. My granny always made this pie just for me. I was her pick of the litter, so I got special treatment :)
You can serve this pie hot or cold, fancy looking or just plain country looking. If you have family or friends who have never tasted Buttermilk Pie, then treat them to a cut of it. They'll love you for it!
Ingredients:
1 to 2 cups - Sugar (You decide how sweet you want it)
1/2 cup - Melted real butter
3 tablespoons - All purpose flour
3 - Eggs
1/4 teaspoon - Salt
1 teaspoon - Vanilla extract
1 cup - Buttermilk
A 9 inch deep dish pie crust or make your own • Pie Crust - Made With ...
If you want to make it fancy top it with some caramel sauce • Caramel Sauce - The Hi...
and some fresh whipped cream • How to Make Fresh Home...
Don't forget to give thanks to God above before you tear into your pie :)
The Hillbilly Kitchen Teespring Store - Tees, Hoodies, Mugs, Bags and more - teespring.com/stores/the-hill...
The Hillbilly Kitchen Verses and Vittles: Down Home Country Cooking - www.amazon.com/Hillbilly-Kitc...
Business inquires: The Hillbilly Kitchen
P.O. Box 243
New Tazewell, TN 37824
[e-mail]
#PutGodFirst #TheHillbillyKitchen #CountryCooking #VersesAndVittles #HomeCooking #SouthernCooking #Recipe #VideoCookingTutorial #Cooking #Food #Foodie #HowToCook #HowToMake #MomsCooking #GrandmasCooking #GrannysRecipes #OldFashionedCooking #ComfortFood #StruggleFood #BestRecipe #Yummy #DeliciousRecipe #Tasty #BudgetRecipe #EasyRecipe #SimpleCooking #NoFailRecipe #BeginnerCookTutorial #RealFood #SimpleRecipe #QuarantineCooking #HeirloomRecipe #100YearOldRecipe #Frying #Baking #SundayDinner #PotLuck #ChurchDinners #CookingTipsAndTricks #DepressionCooking #CastIronCooking #MealsForHardTimes

[@julietteyork3721]

I just happen to have an unopened carton of buttermilk in the frig and wasn’t sure what to make for tonight’s dessert! Discovering one of your recipes that I haven’t seen before is like finding an unopened gift. God bless you! ❣️🇺🇸

[@pennypeters7808]

Making these pies with my mom is a wonderful childhood memory for me. These will always be my favorite pie. ❤

[@ivonne6493]

This video is 6 yrs old….and the recipes are great 👍 ❤❤❤❤❤thank you over and over again ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@samryon3615]

I have been watching you quite a while now. Last year I was on hospice when i found you and much to sick to try any of your recipes. By the Grace of God, i am off hospice now and on palliative care and have energy sometimes to bake(cook). I have always loved your channel because you love The Lord. I am going to try this recipe this week and cant wait! Thank you so much for all you do, you brighten my days. 🙏❤ God bless you

[@mcbeed2770]

Prayed for you. Be Healed in Jesus Name & by the Blood of the Lamb 🙏😇

[@robind8149]

Hillbilly Kitchen - Vittles and Verses! This used to be called Butter Chess pie at Furr’s Cafeteria... it has always been my favorite, and is one of the pies we have without fail on holidays!!! Looking through the 100 year-old recipes made me realize that I needed to subscribe, since we share lots of recipes from childhood!😊 God Bless...

[@DonaldMaggart]

Bekki fastest Egg Whoopper In East Tennessee, Thank You for bringing back these Ole Recipes...

[@Johannseb41]

I saw your show while I was recuperating from surgery a few weeks ago and then again yesterday, your show for Buttermilk pie came up again so I decided to try it. I am no cook but this was both extremely fun and even relaxing and everyone loved it! Anyway, can’t thank you enough! Jim Jordan

[@glendagonzalez2469]

You are a fountain of knowledge and recipes. Thank you for sharing.

[@TheHillbillyKitchen]

Thank you and God bless you!

[@Lady_A.R.Browne]

Good morning, Mrs. Becky! Thank you for sharing this delicious and most memorably scrumptious buttermilk pie. My great grand aunts often made this pie for the fall and winter months. This takes me back over five decades. Wow! 🤣 ❤️❤️❤️👍💯

[@jamessheridan4306]

The first time I made buttermilk pie I used skim buttermilk because that's all my local grocery store was selling at the time. The custard separated and became watery. Now that my local grocery carries the full-fat variety, my pies come out perfect every time.

[@oakmaiden2133]

I add the light version to whole milk, about a 1/4 cup to a quart. In a mason jar, let it set o;the counter til thickened. A day or two. I let my set to almost yogurt consistency.

[@bt464]

Made this today and I love it without the nutmeg and lemon! I used a cup of Sugar and a half cup of brown sugar. A friend said it tasted like Dulce de Leche! We all enjoyed it! Thank you fir sharing!

[@danieladam5524]

So my wife and I just keep talking about how freakin' delicious this pie is.... after eating half. Thanks so much for the recipe!

[@sharonslye6609]

I agree 👍💯 that buttermilk pie is the you've ever had!!!

[@tinagiaramita9486]

My favorite pie! My grandmother made this and it was the first pie I learned to make as an eight year old little girl! Brings back so many wonderful childhood memories of my grandmother's kitchen in the Missouri Ozarks! Thank you for the video!

[@N2Mtns2]

I love this recipe when the hens eggs basket gets full. It freezes good and they’re handed out as seen fit. God bless you. 😊

[@marissavallejo2987]

I’ve made this and it is absolutely delicious. I like that I don’t need to use a mixer and it doesn’t take a whole lot of ingredients. Most of them I always have on hand. And I use a Mexican vanilla and it is just scrumptious!! Awesome recipe!!

[@bethwillard7795]

Blessings always

[@karensweet6530]

I Absolutely love Buttermilk Pie! I like mine really brown on top n cold also! Us country gals know how to bake n eat a good Buttermilk Pie! Lol. Now, I gotta go make me one real quick! It won't take but a minute to throw it together n a lol bit to bake it! Thank you again Becky! Love n Prayers God Bless. 🙏🙏❤❤🇺🇸

[@debbiekerr3989]

I also like a buttermilk pie cold,and plain. It's delicious just by itself no dressing required.

[@bethbnolan]

LOVE Buttermilk Pie!

[@oluwadare12]

Great aluminum foil tent tip...amazing really love how thoroughly you explain the recipe. Great video!😉

[@janicemyers1647]

Good Bless you Beckie! Thank you for sharing this pie receipe ~ it is now my husband’s FAVORITE!! Thanks for helping me make my partner HAPPY!!!!

[@trustingod9160]

My son's mother in law makes this pie and it is so good 😊,

[@dplj4428]

I remember when buttermilk came with butter bits. Also churning to make butter. Thanks for sharing your recipe.

[@louiseferrell1555]

My mama used to make buttermilk pies YUM YUM

[@roboliver7936]

Hey Becky! Thanks so much for this video! Just a couple comments (if I may be so bold!) I think if you reduced your oven temperature to 350 degrees, you may find you do not have to "tent" the pie for 30 minutes, or worry about getting an overly brown pie after an hour. It's ok if the pie jiggles (a little) when done, but not all loosey-goosey (which means it needs a little more time in the oven). Regardless, I love the simplicity of this recipe! I will definitely try it :)

[@Sangreaalstube]

This is my grandma's recipe, and in my humble opinion, the best recipe there is. THANK YOU for making the video. I've got two pies in the oven right now. :)

[@TheHillbillyKitchen]

+Fisher Queen Thank you :) It really is the best recipe and I think it is time to buy some more buttermilk

[@lynnhowdeshell2641]

Fisher Queen, buttermilk pie is my favorite and I am looking for one that is like my mother use to make. I lost her when I was 4 and I am now 70 so I can not get it from her. If you want to share your grandma's recipe so I can try I would enjoy that. Is it topped with nutmeg? Lynn [e-mail]

[@jenniferv618]

@@lynnhowdeshell2641 Lynn, she said that this was also her families recipe so just follow what the video says 💕

[@dwp138]

Thank you! I love buttermilk pie. I just bought a pie pan and a rolling pin and measuring cups to make this. I like a browned pie! I also like it with caramel and strawberries, raspberries and or blackberries

[@jessicaballerstadttaylor1975]

My OCD is satisfied that she scraped the bowl with her spatula ♥ thank you so much! This looks simple and delicious! Thank you so much for your video!

[@dizzydaff]

This is my hubby's favorite dessert. The first time he tried it, I told him it was "Southern Sweetie pie" as he despises buttermilk. He had never had it until I made it the way my grandma did, using real butter and real vanilla extract. Since he is diabetic, we make this using Splenda and it still turns out superb! One note - do not try using margarine - it doesn't set up properly. I cook mine at 350, for 55 minutes and don't use the foil. One other thing, I've found if I set the pie shell and (under pan) on the oven rack before pouring it into the shell, I'm less likely to spill any. Perfect every time.

[@margaretclyde1916]

This is my families favorite pie. I've been making it for forty years.

[@offline1114]

Your channel is really helping me learn how to cook some great stuff!!! Thanks and GOD bless you and your wonderful family!!!

[@christinaburton9297]

Much better than the custard tart we have in England! I served this with a few raspberries. God bless !

[@gloriabell2864]

All your cooking explanations are the best!

[@MysticalMe131]

Beautiful Pie. Love this pie. And really like the tent idea.

[@lisabowen5697]

I so want to make this pie. Yummy. My mom has made it . Didn't know how. Now I do.!

[@andreamills2638]

Hello Becky my grandma Mills always made that for my dad. I live in Pennsylvania. 😀

[@crisstacy4967]

Enjoy watching you cook. Thank you

[@jjgibson9547]

This pie is delicious thank you for the recipe me and my daughters love it

[@christie368]

Made this pie last night. First time making a buttermilk pie.Used your recipe. Turned out so yummy! Thanks for your videos enjoy watching them❤

[@sammyhakimvlogs5608]

This Southern Style Buttermilk Pie recipe looks so delicious 😋 Ms. Becky.

[@skmerwitz4758]

Becky so love your show. My grandma was from west Virginia she cooked country. Never followed recipe. She throw things together. When I. Got older I wanted the recipe she used to say just put little of this

[@mrs.h3]

I discovered this pie when I visited Alabama last year. I am so excited that you have a recipe for it. Thank you and God bless.

[@lindaroper2654]

I have that same table cloth on my kitchen table. 👌

[@TheHillbillyKitchen]

That's odd, mine's missing. 😁 Thank you for watching. God bless you!

[@kyamani9434]

Thank you so much for this recipe. I just made this pie and my sister and I could not wait till it cooled. This pie only lasted 1 day in our house everyone loved it. It is now our go to pie. So easy to make. Thank you so much God bless you and your family in 2021.

[@barbaracotham2342]

Love it 👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@AllThingsFoodwithJohnWoods]

Delicious and easy. Thanks for sharing this fun recipe.

[@ragingblazemaster]

Just made this pie this morning….sooo good, and such a beautiful pie!

[@andrewchristensen6295]

I love buttermilk pie...dang holidays

[@marybowman6637]

Becky this is my favorite pie in the whole world. I never knew it was a buttermilk pie. I just called it a custard pie. I am Soooo happy to see this video. Now I know how to make it. God bless you and the family.

[@sarahgivens7182]

My favorite pie

[@cinmcafee2216]

Made your buttermilk pie today! Mouths are watering as it cools. Thank you for sharing and God bless you and your family.

[@TnAngelii]

Making this tomorrow! More memories...thank you and God Bless. x

[@rubymccaslin6841]

An old time treat

[@N2Mtns2]

Amen. And it freezes well too when the the egg basket gets full. Everyone loves a yummy gift. 😊

[@jessiehaislet3625]

I love buttermilk pie. I sprinkle a little nutmeg on top.

[@ladya1953]

My sweet Daddy *loved* Buttermilk Pie, so for Christmas one year, I made up a bunch of mini-pies and froze them. He would come in and pop one in the toaster oven. He was a haaapppy camper!

[@stephanienuce7711]

I LOVE buttermilk pie!! Thank you!!

[@TheHillbillyKitchen]

+Stephanie Nuce Me too :)

[@gooey65]

Thank you for keeping it simple. Delish.

[@junebug2195]

Taking this to my son’s in-laws for Thanksgiving Day🌹

[@ashlepenojalapeno4608]

YAAAASSS!! This is my kinda pie. I remember loving them! Haven't had one in a long time...like probably ten years. Thank you for triggering both my nostalgia and my taste buds ☺😻 Looks DELISH! And I'm one that likes the brown on top 😊

[@mrs.cracker4622]

Wonderful pie recipe! Thank you so much and God bless!

[@janetmcabee]

Another pie with a strange name is vinegar pie...yes I said vinegar pie. It is DELICIOUS, like pecan pie with a unique taste. There are videos on here of people making them & sometimes the name scares people off but like I said, it is a delicious pie. 🥧

[@joangullion2988]

Love vinegar pie,

[@awesomenana4298]

I just love your videos. I love how down to earth you are. Debbie

[@pattishelton3169]

My favorite too

[@TheHillbillyKitchen]

Thank you for watching. God bless you!

[@figmo397]

I’ve never had buttermilk pie, but I was intrigued by it. Now I can’t wait to try it!

[@julialynch2328]

My favorite pie of all! Thanks for your channel, I love it. God bless ya'll.

[@myrtisfunderburg8355]

Love buttermilk pie. I have made one several times.

[@corinnecardoza3521]

Not only EASY, but looks absolutely delicious. I'll be making this for Sunday supper at grandpa's house. ❤️

[@albertstandish1439]

I like this video and I love southern cooking .you did a great job explaining this recipe for buttermilk pie,thank you.

[@pattythompson8344]

I make this alot. It's so yummy. I also add shopped pecans.

[@gloriabell2864]

Hi Becky. God Bless you and your family. Thanks for all ya’lls love for God and good work. Love your videos. I’m here in Tampa watching this video while listening to Jimmy Swaggart, Frances and Friends.

[@donnaperales371]

GOD BLESS YOU 🙏🕊️❣️

[@ronaldgraham6346]

We have always called this an "Egg Custard Pie" in Birmingham, Alabama...but it's is just delicious regardless if what you call it. 😊😊

[@centauri9458]

It is awesome. Howdy neighbor from Quinton Al

[@keithmoore7948]

Mobile,Al too.😁

[@susancompton5672]

I'm in Coosa Co AL & this is my families favorite pie. I think the difference in a buttermilk pie & egg custard is the buttermilk. I don't like ehh custard, but I love buttermilk pie!

[@centauri9458]

@@susancompton5672 I agree. I do like coconut custard and lemon. But buttermilk pie is my favorite. I make a buttermilk cake sometimes when I want something sweet. Its nothing like this pie though. 🤤

[@Pteromandias]

Egg custard pie has more nutmeg. A buttermilk doesn't have any, or just very little.

[@kimwalders8781]

I have never have Buttermilk pie. Love Buttermilk and Custard . This will be on my Bucket list. I have never seen the foil tent made like that . Nice ! Thanks so much. Blessing to you and you family !💕 hugs

[@WanderingWanda4329]

This looks and sounds wonderful! Thanks for sharing.

[@TheHillbillyKitchen]

+sandi johnson It is pretty good I just had my first slice of the third one that I made this week. I have got to use the rest of that buttermilk or I am going to need a wide angle lens on my camera :)

[@jennifermiller7813]

I love that you have a recipe with your video, I wish everyone had that. Thank you for that

[@toniatalley1977]

Thank you for this video. I'm gonna try to make this for my husband this week. This is his second favorite pie ever

[@sarar371]

Love your channel! Thanks for the recipes and simple way of instruction you give.

[@Bernie339]

Thank you for sharing

[@vipcouponer1463]

hi, I want to thank you for all of your videos. You describe everything so well. I have never been able to follow someone like this whose recipes turn out every single time. I am totally blind so there is a learning curve for me and most people so not go into such detail as you do. I purchased your cookbook not long ago and have been going through adding QR codes to each page to that if I need to refer to your video for verbal instructions I can do so. It is also useful for my 3 boys that I homeschool and they are able to use the recipes a lot more efficiently.

[@johnlasso2151]

that looks so good can't wait to try it out thanks

[@conniebarber4582]

I've always wanted to try and make a buttermilk pie. Thank you for this video and the incouragement to try to make it. God bless you

[@patty4709]

Never heard of buttermilk pie but Sounds good.

[@devinsummer3022]

I am so glad I found you! My friends & have a potluck dinner every month & we choose a region for the entire meal and cocktails this month it's Southern Cuisine. We also anonymously pull tags to determine what course we are responsible for and I have dessert... Thank you

[@suannedorman621]

Sounds wonderful! I've never heard of it before.

[@richardduvall6512]

Great recipe thanks for sharing and God bless

[@candyparton9230]

Hey Becky, I hope you are doing very well and you are making a very favorite pie of mine that I growed making with my granny and great granny. God bless and love you.

[@sharanindirveerkaur5350]

Thanks so much for this recipe and your great baking details. I made butter today so I know what I'll be doing with the buttermilk. I lost my Mom's recipe... so glad you shared yours. Great video!!! P.S. I love my buttermilk pie cold too,

[@anijohnson8082]

Beautiful pie

[@MickeySightings]

I have always wanted to bake this and just never tried...now I have confidence to give it a try.

[@gowest5145]

I'm trying this today. Thanks!

[@georgiapines7906]

Thanks, Becky! I've wanted a "tried and true" recipe for Buttermilk Pie for a while now, and here it is! Can't wait to try it! Y'all have a blessed Thanksgiving!😘🙏

[@junebug2195]

Update: Wow, the Buttermilk pie was great Thanksgiving Day dessert, a most delicious big hit at my son’s In-laws, especially his wife’s granny. PS: cold is best, I tried it both ways👍Thanks for sharing 🦃🌹🥧 🌹🦃

[@darlene9084]

I was one of those people that was like , "buttermilk pie?" Huh , what?" Then I decided to try a piece from our local Cracker Barrel.. I've been missing out. They serve theirs with strawberries and whipped cream. Oh wow, my favorite pie now. I am happy to have found your recipe for it. Now I can bake my own.

[@steve7settle394]

Yum yum that looks good

[@nancysrios]

I made this pie as I was watching your video. I did not know about the pie tent. That is very useful information. I’m looking forward to serving it. Thank you for the recipe.

[@billyeast6819]

Fantastic! I made 2 ate them both after chilling them in the refrigerator.

[@vickiey4561]

I agree that it is best cold and plain! I also like it more on the darker side. It makes it taste almost like butterscotch to me! Great job!

[@TheHillbillyKitchen]

+vickie Yaroch Butterscotch is exactly what it tastes like. Chiefs have convinced people that looks are more important than taste. I don't eat with my eyes :)) Thank you!

[@FatgirlMickey]

That looks wonderful