Bye, I'm moving channels

[@BobbyChiu]

I have no plans on deleting any content. I may redo or move content to my new channel and the Schoolism channel though. Is that ok for everyone? Links are in the description for those looking. Thank you everyone.

[@silverdrago6399]

Thank you for everything Bobby! This channel has been so helpful for me and so many other artists. ❤

[@savimochi]

I'm excited to follow your new journey! Keeping this channel as an archive and adding new/renewed/old-favorites to your active channels sounds good to me. 😊

[@julio1148]

Yes, most important thing is that the content is available ❤

[@samankucher5117]

ill follow you:)

[@trannguyennhatnam]

Thank you so much❤

[@TheEtherny]

If you delete this channel, please reupload the old content to the new channel. Your lessons and interviews are amazing resources

[@PuripuriDrawings]

My thoughts!! I consider unfair he has zero monetisation with their old amazing videos, but I don't wanna lose such great content... Re-uploading could be a bit of an extra work for him, but that could solve both issues 😊

[@studiohq]

@@PuripuriDrawings Agreed

[@thepearlking4417]

Pls

[@SunCrawler.]

Please don't remove this channel tho

[@uberartist538]

💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯 This channel is gold🥇🪙

[@Cellardoor_]

I hope he doesn't! There's so much rewatchability here

[@FoxytronicArts]

Please dont remove all the great content already on this channel! Save it as an archive, but I'm more than willing to follow any new stuff you do, here's to the future! :)

[@rairaitheflyguy]

what?! your channel has been a wealth of knowledge for so many people - thats crazy that they won't even let you remonetize. i'm so sorry this was your experience, and i wish you well in your next steps to great art education!

[@rien3201]

Just wonder, by any chance signing a petition could help Bobby to appeal with YT to reconsider pulling back the demonetization?

[@nathanhollow0]

@@rien3201 considering he's tried atleast 4 times on fixing it before, i'd say a petition would have 0 chance on doing anything

[@immortalgraveyard2099]

@@rien3201 Dude, KZbin doesn't care about us, simple people.

[@rayhslim]

Can’t believe the channel wasn’t monetized all these years. Thanks for all the great content over the years. G’luck with the new channel, see ya there!

[@MohammadFaramarzian]

What duuuude? You got me through the most challenging times. I was with you when you lost your portfolio. I was with you when you visited the events where you found your calling. At the same time, I went from 2D animation to 3D and now finishing my PhD. I teach animation now and always talk about you in my classes. Thanks for being there through my journey and thanks for sharing your journey. At times I can say you were the only one in my life that kept me know going through the long hours and shitty pay. All the best to you, and know you have a friend who is very invested in your success and wishes the best for you, mate.

[@jackiehonda]

Please don't delete this channel, Bobby! Even nowadays sometimes I need to bump into a 12-years-old video from this channel, your contet is very helpful and unique. Wishing you the best on your new journey!!

[@Joao-hm5dp]

Bro just made the whole art community skip a heartbeat 💀

[@Cains_sin365]

I loved his interviews he failed me 😂

[@MariaIsabel_Fufuria]

Thank you for all the videos over the years, Bobby. I’m the artist I am now partly because I’ve been a long-term subscriber…since around 2012 I believe. Being from the Philippines, I’ve always wanted to enroll in Schoolism, but life had other plans. I now work as a character vis-dev artist and I have you to thank in part. Good luck to your future plans! Hoping to someday meet you and thank you in person.

[@rencycadigal4183]

Why did this have to happen. Your channel has produced many of the most inspiring contents for artists out there. I'll support your "Chiu on this"!

[@ArtsIntrinsikh]

Bobby!!! Thank you so much for all you've done for us, your videos, podcasts, schoolism, you in general, have done so much for my art journey! Really excited to see what's to come on your new channel🙌

You don't deserve that demonitizing movement, you are legend indigital painting since the sijun era iirw, already YT history.

[@Charly_Chive]

1:45 Why are your Eyes AI generated, Wish you the best with the new channel!

[@osep5581]

Subbed to the new channel. Lets goo!! Glad you'll be able to be compensated for you awesome content!

[@jeremyschaefer]

That demonetization rule is brutal, but glad to hear you'll still be here on KZbin. Looking forward to the new videos on the new channels 💪

[@Oppurtunafish]

damn Bobby. Huge respect for you to keep making videos all this time despite being demonitised. Thank you for so so many years of inspiring videos

[@J.5in]

Please don't remove this channel. Yes, I'll follow you on the new one but I always come back to this channel's old videos. Just let this channel be as it is.

[@victoriacaedo1626]

Please don't delete this channel! It has been my core and soul listening to all your amazing podcasts ToT We appreciate you sir Bobby!

[@brother-tico4363]

I'm very sorry that this happened to you. I'm going to support your new channel right away.

[@loredo182]

Will always follow all your platforms, you have been for so many years someone who shared knowledge, advice, not only for art but also for life, with your classes, schoolism, interviews and so on. Thank you so much for everything and I hope this new channel and everything in your life brings you wealth and health as well Bobby, thank you!

[@buffienguyen]

Your channel and Schoolism have been an important part of my artist journey for more than 7 years now :) Excited to check out your content on other channels!

[@ezenart]

Good luck on this new endeavor! Schoolism and you have helped me tons over the years so I’m happy to continue supporting you on another channel as well.

[@susurakocy_art]

here I was afraid this is the absolute end of schoolism and your artist interviews which are my favourite

[@Baltasar88]

Thank you for getting me into the path of art! Good luck with the new chanel!

[@tinustinus571]

as long as you have a youtube channel, I don't care how it is named! 😆😆😆 your content is great, and your way to interview other artists is unique. So, I've subscribed to your new channel.

[@Lobstrique]

i almost had a heart attack 😂😂 very excited for the new turn you are taking in your journey ❤❤❤ i can't believe you were demonetized for all these years.... MAN what dedication 🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲

[@longstrideillustration]

Subscribed! Thanks for all your great work Bobby

[@mounthive]

You are wonderful and thank you for the ongoing valuable content that you have been supplying us! 🤩 Apart from monetising there are other ways to make moneys on youtube - creating exclusive content for subscriptions, partnering with relevant sponsors, selling your products etc. I personally find most ads to be outdated and annoying and would prefer to remove them altogether

[@JaredCullum]

Thank you for all you did here. Happy to jump over to the new channel.

[@bubzzydraws]

Wow I never knew that happened. This channel has been one that I've always come back to for inspiration in some of my darker times. Can't wait to see what you do on this new journey! Best of luck and I'll 100% hit that subscribe button ^^

[@Pixelhorizon]

Thx man! Will subscribe! I think the first time I´ve heard someone talking about human growth and to try to be a better human being was on your channel. Regardless of Art related content that stayed with me, so thank you :)

[@GodLovesComics]

KZbin's monetization and content policies are so Byzantine and intentionally vague that no one can ever know when they will be in violation somehow. Granted I only have a very tiny channel and yet I have had my channel completely deleted from the platform (restored after a long month) because of a single video about the comic series Saga. I've had videos about art Age-Restricted, instantly killing the views. And the piece de resistance was recently having my application to be monetized rejected for "reused content", although I do a lot of totally original content. So that's KZbin, kids. If you're thinking about making videos as a "career", please just go back to community college ;)

[@vivek06media]

Oh man, I was shocked for a minute. But, great that you're continuing.👍Best of luck Bobby for the new channel !! really really looking forward. & THANKYOU very much for giving us such wonderful content in all these years, can't thankyou enough as I learnt a lot from this platform 🙏 You & your team is incredible, keep rocking! Lots of love ❤️❤️❤️ Hope this channel and it's content stays, I'll keep coming back here.

[@crybirb]

Followed immediately. Unfair that they struck this channel, but specifying content is always good, I prefer to watch and follow channels that are consistent on what they post. Love your work man, for years.

[@XC999_Akainu]

Subscribed! You are the reason why I get to know some of the brightest artists out there.

[@MatthewPaltoo]

Thank you for everything sir. Your generosity for all the valuable information and interviews was beyond incredible. Looking forward to the new videos. Also, schoolism is an amazing resource for the entire art community, thank for for sharing your journey these past years. Best of luck going forward.

[@tintinabulle1942]

Thank you for all the videos on this channel, i've been watching and sometimes participating to your streams for years, and often come back to them from time to time. This channel will remain a goldmine of info and inspirations for the future generations of artists. I'll gladly follow you on your New channel, i'm glad you are not leaving youtube definitely

[@quachmylinh3054]

Thanks for all the videos you made I'll support both channel🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@mikemess7486]

It's like you're moving but your still in the same city. I can dig it. I hope the new channel helps out! I'm looking forward to what you add.

[@_blank___]

thanks for everything on this channel and the transparency Bobby! I’ve learned so much from this channel and am excited for a new direction ☺️ (if this channel’s videos and wealth of knowledge could stay up, that’d be amazing!!) best of luck for the new channel

[@ShinobiWan1]

Will be following whatever channel you post on! Thanks for all of the amazing art content!

[@pencil3202]

Thank you Bobby~, I have learned a lot from your channel, all those first-hand experence sharing from artist interveiws also changed and extended my perspective .Your channel is really helpful and valueable ,thank you I will love to suscribe the new channel,bye~:).

[@dinoblaster736]

Ive been watching all your interviews recently i hope whatever you choose to do forward goes great!

[@mariebunny]

Your videos have helped me grow & have motivated me so much! Can’t wait to see what you come up with next!

[@milktea_gang]

Definitely gonna support you on your new venture, I wish you luck! Your channel is the reason I fully decided to commit to pursuing an industry career.

[@TechOutAdam]

I love doing tech reviews but holy cow the momentum is so tough to gain in this niche. So many problems depending on the niche but this video nailed it. It's TOTALLY FINE to start over and even have MULTIPLE channels. Once a content creators, ALWAYS a content creator.

[@j897j]

Following you to your new yt home base!! Excited to see you start fresh with more videos from you. Hope the ones on this channel will remain available tho, there is a wealth of knowledge here that kept me going through college, and still many more I haven't had the chance to dive into yet

[@wumblebumblebee]

Hi Bobby, I cant find a link to the schoolism channel and the website brings me back to this channel... I dont want to miss out on new content! And I agree with the masses here! Im still working thru all the great content here so please dont delete

[@muddasheep]

Why are his eyes shining through his arm at 1:46, something strange is going on 👀

[@tonydejesus2134]

Subscribed to both channels, but please don’t delete the content on this channel

[@Triadx_]

Thank you for everything Bobby

[@xpiderxhan]

Thanks for all the knowledge and inspiration you have passed on over the years Bobby! Wishing you the very best of luck for the new channel!!

[@literallymike_]

Your Borat painting videos are what flipped my switch. GREAT technique, as well as VERY inspiring commentary.

[@SpeedyBunnyz]

Followed new channel for sure. I loved the content in this channel, especially the short thought videos. You are an inspiration.

[@christiebecerril8113]

I'm excited for the new channel! I'm sad to see this one end, I loved watching your content and interviews and it's a great resource in a lot of ways

[@comicsgrinder]

Bobby, you are an inspiration for all I try to do on my own channel. Of course, I'll follow you onward to your new channel!

[@surajmistry7078]

Soon as I heard your new channel I immediately subbed. I really hope you leave all your videos up bc your stuff is pure gold ;-; Also looking forward how you evolve the new channel! Thanks for everything you've done for us Bobby! We still praise you at Sheridan : D

[@ignifero]

subscribed and subscribed!! haha. I've done 2 years (separately) of your courses due to this chanel, and I've learned tons of things thanks to Schoolism. Thanks for all the content provided here and there, man. :)

[@Meraxes6]

Best of luck moving forward and thank you for the years and years of great content!!!

[@Fantasy2012dz]

i just watched few of your videos and they are really inspiring . thank you for what you have done for the community. Farewell

[@DarinKarkawatli]

Damn that sucks, I will definitely subscribe to the new channel keep up the good work!

[@itsamaniarts]

Thank you so much for your content and your work. I know we all appreciate it. Good luck with your new channel! Can't wait to watch content on your new channel!

[@3cigarros1]

GOOD 4 YOU BOBBY!!! Thank you for all the years of great content, you are truly an inspiration and a roll model for artist. Cant wait to see what you do next, Greetings from Peru.

[@anna_petrov]

Wow! I'm sorry that happened Bobby, what I a shame, I never knew! But I'm really glad you're being proacitve about this, I just subbed to Chiu-on-this! Excited to see more great stuff from you Bobby! =)

[@75fernandomc]

I'm sure your new channel will have the same success as this one, good luck in this new adventure.

[@witcht]

thank you so much for all the work u have done on this channel, and all the work u continue to do on the new channels!!

[@lauritaeart]

Just hearing about this! Can't believe all these years you've been unable to monetize these extremely valuable videos :c so sorry to hear and I'll be 100% supporting your new channel . Thank you so much for sharing your work and knowledge with us

[@irismuddyhehe]

Bobby, thank you for everything you have shared with us all over the years! all of the ideas and inspiration discussed here have really influenced so many of us and benefited the community so much. Hopefully everyone here, and many more new people, will follow wherever you go next to continue to enjoy the growth!

[@shuinama]

Sad to see this channel stop but I'm glad for all the things you provided us over the years!!

[@lisayoni5990]

I respect you so much. Been following for a decade or more, the knowledge I've got from your videos alone is immeasurable and I think they've played a big role in my life and a reason I've never stopped drawing. Thank you for everything and hooray for the new beginnings!

[@Geloyart]

All your hardwork on this channel man, it sucks that you got demonitized. Hopefully everything would work fine on your new channel, I'll be supporting you.

[@GeenoGab]

Thank you for all the valuable lessons that help me in my own career.

[@CreativeSteve69]

I'm so glad I found you and your channel via Instagram back in 2015 Bobby. Thanks for these tip videos. I'll definitely be following you on your new channel journey.

[@rosezif]

Oh I didn't knew 😢😢😢 of course I am going to subscribe asap to your new channel, thank you so much for all youve done to this channel and reupload all the videos you want from here to your new channel we will give them so much love there too🎉🎉🎉

[@vogita78]

Ive legit been subbed to this channel since High school. I still follow some of the advice from this channel when it comes to digital illustration. Please dont remove the channel, your content will help tons of peeps in the future!

[@JWMCMLXXX]

Good for you man. Sorry you took a wrong turn down the line. Much luck to you

[@moosequeen]

Omggg noooo I just started watching your channel since last week. Thank you for creating these

[@OkamiKuma]

Good luck with Chui On This! Great title haha Thanks for all the amazing interviews here! Love you

[@phantomapprentice6749]

Thank you for your candor

[@jospargo8417]

Wow - I'm sad it took so long for you to make this move - fully support this action. Love your content - looking forward to the next 17 years!

[@estherviola]

Wow, that was such a rollercoaster of emotions! For a moment I thought you would leave YT completely. So relieved you're going to move to another channel (although it's sad that you can't monetize this one). Wishing you all the best on the other channels (and of course I'm subscribing)!

[@edasda-i4r]

yay im so glad youre not leaving completely!!!! i just recently found your account two weeks ago and its been so helpful, ive already felt like ive grown so much and my mindset on art has become so much more postive since finding your account!! im so excited for your fresh start and what it brings!!!!

[@artofandrewguerrero]

For a minute there, I thought I was gonna choke on something. But yeah, always looking for the art community as always Bobby. A lot of us will always support you!

[@jessewinchester]

Your commitment to supporting artists and artistic culture shone bright through this channel. Thank you!

[@timbye]

Thanks for the inspiration Bobby! Looking forward to the new channel! 😀

[@ben-9503]

I’ll watch no matter where it is, just glad you’re making content! Also can’t wait to go to lightbox next year!

[@IgayahArt]

You are an inspiration, Bobby! Good luck on this new path and see you at Lightbox soon!!

[@MistaManlyGuy]

So sorry about that. Thank you for continuing through it. You still got your name out there. I've seen people say to click on the ads for revenue as well and they are still monetized. I never knew about that rule. F'd up

[@evgeniy9867]

Thank you so much Bobby for all the amazing content & information you've provided for this channel. I've learnt quite a bit thanks to you, as i'm sure others have too! Wishing you well with in next steps

[@dustinjones9696]

Definitely have no problem supporting the new channel. Sucks to know you haven't been monetized for all the amazing tips and insight you've given to us artists.

[@valerievalentova]

cant wait for your new channel to grow. this one helped me so so much! :)

[@Alyona-rl1gt]

Best wishes Bobby! ❤ I'll follow you on new channels. Please don't remove this one 🙏🙏🙏 or reupload your great content to new channels, it's GOLD for artist's community 💛

[@CO-kd6sd]

Please keep this channel accessible for the amazing content!

[@iriscompiet3551]

I've always enjoyed your videos here, glad you're not completely stopping but rather moving. Good luck with everything

[@JacobHalton]

Ugh that sucks! I know you work incredibly hard, so congrats on the new channel, and hope it pays off!

[@SenElric]

Wish you the best for the new channel! 🎉❤

[@divijay8]

Hey Bobby, Just wanted to say that you are among three artists who kept me driven to follow a career in Animation. I'd study after my full time job in Advertising listening to your youtube videos on loop back in 2007-2008! I still go back to them from time to time and they're still gold :)

[@sandischw7474]

Hi Bobby, I love your videos and will definitely follow you on your new channel! Good Luck! I can't wait to see the new stuff. I hope this channel can stay. I always love to go back and watch some of the old videos :)

[@TURBONERD]

Haha that sucks man. KZbin is honestly so awful for this kind of stuff. Can't wait to watch on the new channels, thanks for the heads up!