REFRESHED RIVALS! -- 2024 BMW X5 vs. 2024 Mercedes GLE: Comparison

[@egzonsalihu1451]

Both are super great but for me i love Mercedes GLE.

[@jeremysantaana859]

I'm going for the BMW X5 😍😍😍

[@hellkitty1014]

BMW FTW here. Yes, we all know the B58 is standard(love that BMW didn't try to have the 2.0t as standard), but the BMW just seems to check the boxes better than the MB. It handles better, is quieter, sounds so much better, etc. The only thing that frustrates me with the BMW is the removal of the physical controls for climate. I loathe cars that have everything controlled via touchscreen. But it makes up for it with the open-pore American walnut wood over the black-laqueur in the MB that comes across as yet another vehicle with piano-black plastic(although it is not). Considering that the GLE450 would be substantially more expensive than the X5 as equipped yet be slower and about equal on efficiency, the Bimmer just seems like the better buy. **I still believe the X5 should be awarded at least a half-point for the split-tailgate. It is a very unique option in all of the midsize SUV class. I could be wrong, but I believe only the $100K+ Range Rover(aside from the other BMW models) is the only other SUV to have the feature since the new LX600 abandoned it.

[@ayushmalpeddi2793]

Rivian R1S and BMW X7 have the feature. Pre-price hike R1S costed 75.5K but they do come fully loaded. X7 well equipped is also under 100K.

[@ajprudence6235]

Same reason for me to order the BMW

[@doctordetroit4339]

Not really. I have owned both types. For many in the actual demographic that buys these cars the replacement of everything onto a screen is a show stopper. Also the second row in a Benz easily outpaces the Beemer, and if you get the 3rd row option for the Benz, the second row adjusts (the only luxury car of its size that does so apparently). Again, this can be a show stopper. Especially if you have a family and go on long trips. Comfort factor is huge. Why in the hell both do not have adjustable second row seats as standard is a disgrace at this price point. Finally, if any of you have owned both types.....you know the deal in terms of "wow" factor. Build out the GLE with all the trimmings (not like the one in this video) and it will cost $10K more than the comparable X5....but you will DEFINITELY know where that money went. So will anyone you drive around.

[@hellkitty1014]

@@doctordetroit4339 while I've not owned both of the latest GLE and X5s, I've extensively tested both. The second row space disparity is not the large to make a difference in the real world, and I appreciate the standard climate adjustment of the X5 vs the GLE that forced you to pay for yet another pricey option pkg. As for the power seats, they are sloooww if your moving to the 3rd row, speaking of which is so tight, I don't know why someone would rob themselves of cargo space for such an inefficient use of a seat. If that is necessary often, the GLS is far more suitable. The interior of the GLE is good, but does not seem to impart a feeling of being better vs the X5. I do believe the GLE rides better than the X5(without the air springs), but the X5 certainly drives better. I'm a huge MB fan, but I was hoping for more on the GLE refresh.

[@doctordetroit4339]

@@hellkitty1014 You get the third row simply to be able to adjust the seats of the second row, not to actually use the third row as it is generally useless. You are correct about the MB interior. But that has always been the case. You have to go AMG level (not the engine---that is insanely pricey, just the badging) to get super-nice leather and whatnot. At that point, it exceeds the X5 (quite easily) but it costs $15-20K more. At that point you may as well get an X7 or GLS, you are talking $100K!! I would add that my BMW nappa and marino leathers (that I paid a lot for and long wait times) looks rough only after a few years. I am not that hard on my cars, but soft leather is a real liability. Regardless of brand I think. My Benz had Tex, which although I did not like it as much as leather, it held up great and you couldn't really tell the difference between it and the "normal" leather (not marino or nappa). I would consider staying with fake or basic leather, it can take some hits. As for driving....you are correct. A century from now....BMWs will still be a car that you drive.....the Benz (aside from AMG models) will be the car that drives you. take care.

[@BeNice76]

I switched from GLS to X7 and the change has been very positive. X7 is a better family daily hauler by far!!

[@SDav21]

Can you also confirm that the X7 has far better build and material quality? I sat in the GLS and X7 and was shocked by how much plastic is in the GLS and some parts felt loose. Horrible.

[@BeNice76]

@@SDav21 absolutely. X7 is a total different breed. Better quality for sure. Drives better. Handles better. Materials feel nicer. Quality is better as well. No rattlings like I had in the GLS after I put 10k miles on it, I won't be going back to MB anytime soon!! Being in late 40s that needs a 3 row SUV GLS feels like a grandpa SUV in comparison to the amazing X7.

[@SDav21]

@@BeNice76 I can't understand how reviewers rarely mention the quality issues with the GLS. It's clear then that the X7 and X5 is far above the Mercedes equivalent. I am so sad for Mercedes because it was the brand that I always loved and was so loyal to. But after having test driven their new models to see if I should replace my 2014 E Class, they just feel like a huge step down in quality. I'll definitely consider BMW next.

[@tanzil88]

​@@SDav21 because they have the Maybach version of GLS, that's why. Probably strategic marketing choice from MB.

[@SDav21]

@@tanzil88 The Maybach GLS costs a lot more. People looking at the normal GLS won't be looking at a Maybach version. Even a normal GLS costs more than the X7 yet is a significantly poorer car in all aspects. It's just Mercedes cost cutting and throwing away their brand reputation. They have no excuse for such a poor quality product at these prices.

[@MauriceBln1]

I would take the BMW. The car optimally combines sportiness and luxury. Great review by the way!!

[@conservativegirl3371]

It was between these two for me...and I ordered a 2024 BMW X5. What sold me was new interior, m sport and pro package, steering wheel with those packages, and the seats are so good. The update interior and technology on the X5 won me over. Plus 3 year service! On a past Mercedes I had to buy a service package for $1500...not doing that this time! I ordered a mineral white with 22 inch black wheels, m packages, coffee interior. Super excited!!!

[@preoksaha4504]

Ouff sounds deadly!! Enjoy my man!!

[@TechnoBrown]

That's good setup 👌

[@Integratedcraig]

Kay- it was for me as well- I went with the X5 50e, Saphire Black/silverstone Sensafin all options with 20inch wheels- I too went Msport! Love the looks of the refreshed X5- best interior in the biz!

[@conservativegirl3371]

@@Integratedcraig That sounds amazing!

[@vincedemo2752]

That’s the blueprint you laid out. Roger that 🙏🏾

[@rolfbakaitis3886]

This is not a fair comparison, the GLE450 is the model to compare to the BMW X5 40i. It would have been a more fair match up,

[@Cars_with_max]

It is these are both the base models

[@michaelv6870]

And a $ 15,000 price delta.

[@bingohhhhhhhhhhhh]

Stupid - price for price and even with the 6 the Merc falls behind the much less pricey BMW.

[@FCM415]

The biggest thing separating them now is reliability. BMW has vastly improved in this regard and Merc has gotten even worse.

[@fico3093]

The b58 engine in the bmw has been one of the best engines for bmw recently

[@Trackhawk_Gle53]

Really the X5 is more reliable than the GLE ? I’ve heard that the GLE was more reliable and more safe

[@batmore1]

@@Trackhawk_Gle53 Consumer Reports rates the X5 as in the top for reliability. Can't speak to safety tests.

[@FCM415]

@@Trackhawk_Gle53 They’re both rated top safety picks. I own a ‘23 X5 and before purchase I did research and the X5 and BMW as a whole has become one of the most reliable brands (surprising right?). This doesn’t come from a place of bias or hate on Mercedes because even with its reported quality issues, I plan on replacing my wife’s car with a GLE53, hopefully they improve their reliability when that time comes.

[@Boston_canon]

@@Trackhawk_Gle53 that’s ml and previous gle. (Thanks to m274/m270 Inline-four engine, Mercedes became the least reliable car ever )

[@Mike-yk4yq]

I test drove both the X5 40i and GLE 450...I ended up with the X5. All around a better vehicle. It has the looks, features, performance and price with 3 yr maint thrown in. A no brainer of a choice. Really love it!

[@martygreen3145]

I keep telling people BMW has gotten pretty serious over the past 5 yrs and upped their game moving closer to Porsche performance levels compared to the other German and Imports upscale Brands.

[@Trackhawk_Gle53]

You really tested the gle ?

[@joseayalam.1897]

​@@Trackhawk_Gle53MB is not what it used to... open your eyes.

[@Trackhawk_Gle53]

@@joseayalam.1897 Yes you’re right now BMW is far better and more luxurious than MB and Audi but is the AWD system of the new X5 better than the Quattro system?

[@heinman6250]

Having driven a GLE53 and X5 M60i quite a bit, the GLE feels so much better to drive. Tighter, more natural steering with more feedback, more playful handling, and way less body roll. The interior is much better too and more passenger space

[@joseayalam.1897]

Does it? May be you are unique, because no body else seems to feel the GLE drives better than the X5.

[@hamiddavari1491]

you're absolutely right and that was the reason I purchased the GLE. it's lovely

[@lakittawoods7457]

Not what they compared today

[@carcareproductssverige]

@@joseayalam.1897I owned a x5 modell 2023 and now owns GLE 53AMG and it is by far so much better then the BMW.

[@AaronJiju64]

Can’t wait. I ordered my x5 yesterday. It’s probably gonna be here in August

[@keanumunteanu]

Bmw for me. Looks sharper and More sporty an comfortable enough

[@RandoGallz]

It’s the Bimmer for me! Especially now that we have more options to configure the gauge cluster & a magnificent interior along with the refined engines sealed it😉

[@Integratedcraig]

I love that they upgraded idrive- and upgraded driver assist/hands free- in So. Cal with heavy traffic, I’m gonna love it! Great choice! Best 6cyl in the game- Yes!

[@AidenRZ777]

Y not buy a tesla

[@AbdulazizAbdullah-rn7oh]

@@AidenRZ777 Who buys an ugly useless unreliable shitbox that made for the fat soccer moms over the two most advanced technology suv’s in the world?

[@atulyaop2803]

Great comparison between the two. I would now go for the Mercedes Benz GLE because the X5 front looks not so nice. I have to go for the GLE for the design and tech on the inside. Keep up the good work.

[@Integratedcraig]

Outstanding work on the comparo-Gents! Love both of these SUVs- I placed an order for the X5 50e (M sport)- I love the bigger backseat in the GLE- but the X5 with the 3 yr free maintenance was just a better overall “get” for our family- I really don’t think you can go wrong with either choice - Thanks CC!!

[@Andymam]

How did you get 3 years free maintenance? I’m placing my order for 50e next week

[@Drostyles7676]

How did you get the 3 year maintenance free mate?

[@ganouyang]

BMW has halted X5 50e production from Dec 2023 to March 2024.

[@glenngross605]

I ordered a X5-50e PHEV, although I would have considered the MB hybrid version of the GLE also, but it isn’t available yet in the US. I prefer buttons as well, but it isn’t a deal breaker. I’d rather not be limited to the touchscreen and voice control, and am happy that BMW still has the iDrive controller on the center console.

[@bradleyscarreviews]

How is it

[@bobcharkas3310]

Folks, Stay away from 2024 X5 model. Received mine on 6/2/23 and its back in the shop with 165 miles on 6/8/2023. Faulty Turbo gateway. More to follow in next few days

[@keska01]

any updates ?

[@matthewgrayson8]

The X5 is a beast

[@rahul199329]

X5 :- Driving dynamics, better road grip, fun to drive , quality finishes Gle :- fun To drive, better off roader, comfy, better rear passenger features , better driving stance for driver .

[@tahran5782]

Sorry, Mercedes, I am going to have to go for D b m w because it has the upgraded Technology Mercedes step up your game

[@MercOne]

What do you think Mercedes needs to step up?

[@tahran5782]

@@MercOne It's the technology that's the old system

[@MercOne]

@@tahran5782 It’s still MBUX only the interface is older.

[@mr.lassig3671]

GLE for sure 🔥 🔥🔥🔥 the interior is more luxury and the exterior looks more sporty. The bmw x5 is for old guys or for mummys who take kids to school. The Benz is for Mens 💪🏼💪🏼

[@DerTyp006]

thats right 👍🏼

[@michaelv6870]

The GLE looks totally gay so yes, I guess you`re right.

[@승리인간-n1l]

This is the lamest comment I ever heard 😂.

[@maxl3865]

Are you kidding? gle is car for grandfather!!

[@raphaelsanchez4797]

I enjoy your comparisons more than any else's. One thing to consider: larger wheels should not equal a plus, or it shouldn't in my book, because larger wheels can often sacrifice ride. Instead, larger wheels or different wheels should be a plus when they add an enhancement, such as weight or special material. Thanks for all these great comparisons.

[@CarGeek360]

Larger wheels with low-profile tires that go flat easily on bad roads (like those present on the MDX Type-S for example) are even worse, especially in a family SUV, I would personally deduct points for the large wheels

[@akshatkumaroraon4365]

dude i just love this channel, the way you guys bring the comparison videos is way more satisfying than could be imagined... love you guys🥰😘

[@CarConfections]

Thanks so much!

[@timothybracken1728]

I would pick the X5, it's a no brainer. Lease that thing and you're set.

[@jazzyflorida3757]

I’ve owned 2019 GLE 450, 2021 GLS 580, and now 2023 BMW x7 m60i. BMW I’ve had for 11 months, ordered it last August delivered in October 2022. has been fun to drive, def different than Benz. I did have issues with Mercedes constantly with screen, and tires, and service lights always going on.

[@ajprudence6235]

Waiting to pick up a X5 m60i in a few weeks. Struggled a bit on choosing either brand. Bothers me MB would use a weak inline 4 to compete with the 375 HP BMW, all the while having the same fuel economy and price. Another proof that BMW is more sporty in heart.

[@FamilyMan938]

Objective comparison with right amount of subjectivity! Thank you for this awesome video. Please compare Porsche Cayenne to BMW X5.

[@normanchan1099]

It should be BMW X6 to Porsche Cayenne

[@johnsoltau620]

I’m 6’ 8” tall. Don’t fit in an X5, plenty of room in the GLE. I currently have a 2021 GLE, looking forward to getting the 2024.

[@A5TRO_IN4NIMAT3]

Exactly. The x5 is only a two row while the Gle can option a third row which means there’s more room

[@johnsoltau620]

@@A5TRO_IN4NIMAT3 third row has nothing to do with it. The drivers seat is the same distance from the pedals in both, but the steering wheel in the GLE can rotate up 2 inches higher making room for my knees.

[@A5TRO_IN4NIMAT3]

@@johnsoltau620 well that too

[@bobrodriguez9317]

Great review, we looked at both and could have gone either way. A review of the X5 xDrive 40i on another channel convinced us to get the X5. Also, could not get past the unnecessary grab handles in the console of the Mercedes and the slightly droopy looking rear styling.

[@Massachusettsrailfanner-t2p]

A 2.0t with a mild hybrid that can tow 7,700 lbs is impressive

[@phillybreed]

I wouldn't compare the GLE to the x5 because one it more of a sports vehicle and the other is luxury. I would like to see GLE AMG coupe and the m x6. I think that would be a better comparison. Or at least try the 450 against BMX. 😂😂😂. Personally I'm taking the GLE

[@maureencora1]

I Take the 2024 BMW X5.

[@b286guy]

X5. The Merc looks like it’s on stilts or something 😧

[@SayYoJ]

GLE for me 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@romanzzzz2]

2 things why Mercedes is far behind: 1) the interior is obsolete. Glc, S, E have gorgeous new interiors but gle and gls have old. 2) The same with the sittings - X5 has top chairs like x7 and 7, while gle and gls have obsolete chairs that are much simpler then in S and E.

[@arthvader1]

New X5 interior is terrible compared to the previous model, which I have now. The lack of physical climate control buttons is a deal breaker. Lack of physical shifter is not ideal. There was no need to remove the physical buttons other than cost savings which just make the interior look cheap. You should also be comparing the 450 not 350 to the 4.0.

[@andrewcheng2676]

Great video. GLE need to use 450 the 6 cylinders to compare with X5. 😂 350 is lack of power with 4 cylinder.

[@Mike-yk4yq]

Even comparing the GLE 450 with the Base X5 X40i, the MB loses out. BMW is much quicker and responsive and significantly more fun to drive.

[@scotts6955]

The point is that they are the same price and BMW comes standard with a V6. Add the V6 to the Merc and ur paying more.

[@GabrielGomez-l8e]

After 10 years with MB (C class followed by my current GLC) where both cars have been solid and reliable, I’m going to have to go X5 here. Plus, want a PHEV which MB doesn’t offer. Just that gives BMW the lead, plus the PHEV is even more powerful. The upgrade to the X5 interior also made a huge improvement for 2024 as it was starting to feel very dated. Can’t wait to get to the dealer and place my order…!

[@CookandBakewithSamer]

I'm also very happy with my GLC. Thinking of moving to a GLE. I owned in the past an ML320 for 18 years. Loved it. The GLE does offer a PHEV for 2024 and I am already able to order it. I am debating between the GLE450 or the PHEV. The 450 is much faster. Prices are the same, start at $69,500 or so.

[@CarGeek360]

Mercedes added a GLE PHEV with a 4 cylinder, I personally call it a disappointment

[@CarGeek360]

Congrats on the Beemer! I hope you’re enjoying it!

[@EastWood2004]

The gle350 has a 4 cyl engine. These are in different leagues.

[@CarGeek360]

They should’ve 100% compared the GLE450 to the X5 40i, it’s more fair also I don’t see the point of the GLE350 even existing atp, 450 should be the base if you ask me

[@scooter5940]

Perhaps “less expensive” would be a better comparison than “cheaper” at this price point, but still a nice comparison!

[@MrRensan404]

Great comparison review. I prefer the luxury look and features provided by the GLE as well as its understated exterior lines. To be a better match, the GLE 450 with 6 cylinders should be used to compare with the X5's 6 cylinders.

[@lakittawoods7457]

They were comparing base models

[@SDav21]

For me the Mercedes loses out immediately for its poor quality of materials on the doors and poor build quality. The plastic on the lower half of the doors is a terrible hard scratchy plastic.

[@rolexhulk1774]

Glass shifter no longer available on BMW site. Must be a supply issue..

[@kelanter]

Interesting. The one I have on order should have those. Major production delay, but I was told it had to do with the climate package.

[@choward7158]

GLE 350 for the past 3 vehicles !!! . Gearing up for the next one !!!

[@shoja2009]

BMW has clearly much better lineup than MBZ in general...

[@FullsendOffroad]

The GLE just floats through the air and it rides so much smoother, and not having a spare tire on the BMW is a deal breaker for me. Plus Mercedes Air Suspension is top notch. However that Split Tailgate on the BMW is awesome.

[@juelzm149]

X5! I'll get used to the lack of buttons lol

[@driodebeica9225]

GLE is my choice .BMW doesn't look update it that much

[@mannjaye]

Why would anyone buy the Mercedes with a less powerful, less fuel efficient drivetrain? Plus the X5 looks much better.

[@saeedahrabi2174]

Mercedes is famous to be more reliable and durable and BMWs are not

[@easternbeast3615]

I drove both and decided to get an X7, bimmer is a lot more fun to drive, especially in sport mode. Also - consider stepping up to Bowers & Wilkins stereo, sound is amazing. My only complaint is iDrive 8 carplay connectivity, very buggy.

[@pamwright9806]

I chose the X5 because of the window views. I could see better when looking before turning and backing up.

[@bigdogpete43]

Bought the X5. You can't even compare the handling and performance.

[@chunpingli8235]

Absolutely I choose BMW X5

[@rdefacendis]

I am always puzzled by the ongoing and often noisy debate about whether climate buttons should be hard or is it ok to have them embedded in a touch screen. These cars (and most cars nowadays) have climate control. It is "set and forget" most of the time. It is not something you are adjusting two or three times during a single trip. The exception would be winter driving and defrost functions. But if you live in a moderate climate without snow or frost - you aren't touching those controls! I go months without touching climate functions.

[@tahran5782]

Hey cars confection once you get done This video tell your mom happy mother's day

[@treydrier3169]

The X5's lack of physical buttons for volume and climate control along with the lack of leg room in the rear seats are a show stopper for me. No buttons, no go.

[@olaf2046]

Subscribed because you didn't review these based on a silly drag race but on practical everyday features 99% of buyers need info on!

[@CarConfections]

Thank you! Welcome to the Car Confections family!

[@nathanwardia3144]

IMO you guys were biased to the BMW 😉 and here's why: 1- Noise was measured on two different roads which could make a difference ❌️ 2- 9 speed transmission offers a smoother ride than the 8 speed trans. (The point goes to the GLE) ✅️ 3- less expense factor should be added to your comparison, and since the X5 needs a maintenance every 6 months the GLE is a winner here✅️ 4- Overall look factor should be considered, and it goes to the GLE then a 10 year old look X5✅️ Finally, thank you for the video, but I think to be fair there are too many factors like 3rd row seats option and much more could've been added to your comparison.

[@CarGeek360]

Omg this is such a lie, the Merc is unreliable (with bad build quality) and looks are subjective, also I’ve been in the X5 and the transmission is buttery smooth, my parents are cross-shopping the new X5 and new Cayenne but we have absolutely NO interest in the GLE or RX, also what’s your proof that the noise was measured on two different roads? It could’ve been the same exact road but two different sections of the road. Regardless, both are going to be extremely quiet and 90% of people aren’t gonna notice a diff, X5 takes the win here, the Cayenne is gonna be better than both but it’s $20k more when comparably speced (weather the extra $20k is worth it or not, up to the client)

[@CarGeek360]

I do slightly agree with your comment tbf bc as much as I prefer the BMW over the Mercedes the Mercedes deserved an extra point for having an optional 3rd row.

[@scotts6955]

No way Merc gets a point on looks. And the interior vents are atrocious, way too busy looking.

[@CarGeek360]

@@scotts6955 the BMW is better, end of discussion, regardless of personal preferences (which I understand differ from person to person), the BMW is the only one of the two with actual good build quality

[@of-fj6vf]

Which one is easier to get in and out of? Can vehicle height be lowered/raised? Is gle thick/silent glass option worthwhile? Is massage seat truly useful more comfortable or just a gimmick? If riding in back seat, is it correct gle is more comfortable? How do i get answers please?

[@pascachi]

I guess I would pick GLE than X5, 2 of my brothers had X5 that became a headache.

[@anthonym9470]

BMW all the way

[@lestercaldera3776]

If you factor price and being more reliable and more fun to drive X5 takes it

[@indianshersingh7790]

Bro BMW driving experience has its own class.. No comparison to that...

[@michaelv6870]

Ordered a 50E. Car is build and should be on the truck in the next few days. I looked at the GLE but for the same money I get an inline six.Why would I even consider the Merc? Besides, the Merc comes with fake leather as well and it`s nowhere near as nice as the one in the BMW. And last but not least, the reliabilty rating in the GLE are atrocious.

[@rdefacendis]

I would also add as a X5 owner... the AC is inadequate in warm weather climates... the merc does a better job keeping the cabin cool. If you live in a hot climate - it matters!

[@deepseadweller687]

Daughter has both and says BMW is better ac

[@Russ-ex8so]

BMW wins in the power train category, hands down.

[@s_one607]

I don’t get why people hate the X5, for example that the old interior looks better and stuff. Time moves on and cars just get more futuristic, thats not smt bad or makes them not good. The new X5 is a great car with a design meant for the time it came out to. People always have something to complain but this car is what I imagine when I think about a good car that was made in 2023.

[@harshareddy8312]

Which one is more reliable and has low issues in long term ? Fully confused.. please suggest

[@MvpAcceleration21]

X5 40i B58 is very reliable engine😃 Gle is worse in reliability

[@nathanwardia3144]

Make a friendship with a good mechanic if you're planing to own a BMW, period

[@saeedahrabi2174]

MB is more famous for being reliable long term but God knows the reality

[@feliciabrown2208]

BMW X5 is my choice love love the BMW X5 ❤🎉

[@florinrad4647]

X5 for me, thanks 😊

[@hamidmghazi]

I was a x5 fan before the new climate set up. I just can't get over it. Smh 🤦‍♂️

[@doctordetroit4339]

Yup, that is a show stopper.

[@brooklynknightss]

I love the look of the GLE

[@sakethreddy4450]

Mercedes has good leg space and feels more spacious but BMW isn’t that spacious specially in the back. Leg spaces feel too congested for an X5 size

[@dondamond7151]

Nice job gents. When comparing stereo sound, you need to use the same exact song. Just a suggestion. Helpful review.

[@grisellimay]

The Mercedes has amber turn signals in the rear. Should be an automatic +1 tbh

[@w-josh]

Many Americans like red turn signals better, and see it as luxury. This is probably why it is not an automatic plus.

[@grisellimay]

@@w-josh that's only partially true , I don't think Americans see red turn signals as luxurious

[@kingwillbisthebest]

Merc steering wheel takes the win but all else goes to the BMW. That said both sexy

[@bassemkhozam]

I would pick the BMW X5 for sure

[@dano660top]

Presently drive a 2021 BMW X5 M Sport. Plan on replacing in December with a 2024 BMW X5 Sport. This will be my 4th new BMW, all of which are safe, reliable, luxury vehicles. I also appreciate the free 3 year/36 months of free maintenance.

[@ashfordkofi8933]

I think the comparison should have been between the X5 and GLE 450. I will like to see you consider 2024 Porche cayenne base model in your comparison.

[@lakittawoods7457]

They were comparing base models

[@CarGeek360]

The Cayenne is awesome but $20k more comparably speced, weather the Cayenne is worth the extra $20k or not if fully subjective, I would love to see a X5 vs Cayenne comparison however

[@CarGeek360]

It should’ve been X5 40i vs GLE450 tbh, I still don’t get why the GLE350 exists tbh

[@rickflare6736]

I have owned 4 BMW X5’s. I have been very happy with the overall quality & performance. My current ones are a Regular 2020 X5 3.0 Turbo X-Drive & a 2021 X5 3.0 Turbo X-Drive M Package. Both are awesome & enjoyable. If you want more of a harder cornering X5 then get the M-Package, M50, M60, or X5M. Otherwise get the 3.0 Turbo X5 X-Drive like my 2020 and most drivers will be very happy indeed. 😎😊👍

[@nishitdevelopers4144]

You guys do very good comparison and review about the car in very detailed information. Like about the audio quality rare people give review about it . One thing you must add in your videos is the suspension comfort the ride quality of the car.

[@CarConfections]

Thanks!

[@cyclone3444]

Thanks for making the comparison between the 2024 models. Now that X5 has a curved wide screen, lets see what GLE has on in

[@nayanshankar755]

I would like to know if the GLE will be more quiet than the X5 with the comfort Acoustic Package. Was the comfort acoustic package added to this model ? Thanks

[@DeeeBeee123]

😳😳😳 I'm a Mercedes fan myself, but BMW is swinging hard! Wow. Who would have ever thought that bmw would be flashier , have more quality, and more amenities than Mercedes-Benz 😑 come on Mercedes!

[@ryanfrisby7389]

Great comparison as per usual!

[@kinanhiaouassenan9314]

Dear brothers, No point for the MB with that leather/wood steering wheel? But a point for the one in the BMW with center leather cover.

[@nathanwardia3144]

Brutally biased!

[@Baka_Oppai]

I bought a 2024 X5 a couple weeks ago, unfortunately I have to wait for it to be built. A few weeks to wait yet. :(

[@MartinStockel-k6f]

I like the rounded corners on the Mercedes dash instrument cluster. If I was buying one right now it would be the Mercedes-Benz without question. The BMW tailgate belongs on a pickup. I also don't like the slick looking steering wheel on the Mercedes. Looks cheap compared to the BMW. Nice review between the two vehicles.

[@jim-qs9br]

That tailgate is my favorite! Brings the load floor out and makes it way easier to load without scratching the bumper. Not to mention a nice seat without getting your pants dirty rubbing on the bumper. I think more SUVs should have a tailgate like the X5.

[@MartinStockel-k6f]

@@jim-qs9br Glad you like the tailgate. We both have opinions on what we like and that is great.

[@MattK-xs4hx]

The lack of HVAC buttons on the x5 is so hard to look past. The GLE is definitely not as sporty but it is more roomy.

[@Lydric21]

Choosing Merc over BMW this time. Mostly because of the softer ride and something that is more subjective a way it makes me feel behind the wheel. But as stated already one can't go wrong which ever they choose. PS: I'd still compare 450 and 40i and not 350 because in Europe their prices are same as 350 is a cheaper option.

[@marioyteresa6853]

I’m going with the BMW X5 40i 👨🏻❤️‍🔥👍🏼

[@AaronJiju64]

Which one do you think I should buy. I live in Ireland and here the base X5 model is the M sport for €99,000. The Xdrive is €107,000. Then for Mercedes the GLE 350 is €105,000

[@RiadQa47]

I I own a 2016 GLE 350 and I have been very happy with it. Consequently, Iam planning to up grade to Model 2024 in near future. BMW maintenance is way over priced than Mercedes.

[@jwflaherty2251]

Just replaced my 2015 X5 with a 2024 X5, and it’s incredible!

[@keska01]

did you have many problems with your 2015 X5? Often in the shop for repairs, electronics etc ?

[@pete64041]

Why did you not test the autonomous drive on both? Thanks

[@caglar_panus]

Thanks for the review, guys! I think it would be a better review if you could compare GLE 450 vs X5 i40. That way test drive would be more accurate comparison. Also, noise, and the price comparison would be better. Still with these two models BMW makes more sense. FYI, never owned any of these models, but I am planning to have one of these. It would be awesome if you could compare 450 vs i40, just like you guys did for 2023 models. Thanks again!

[@curiously1510]

If the comparison was focused on powertrain then you would be correct. However these represent the entry-level trims of this class, and as such are fair to be compared given similar pricing and standard equipment.

[@CookandBakewithSamer]

@@curiously1510 I agree with both Caglar and Dan. The issue I see here, the GLE450 starts at $69,500 while the BMW starts at $67,500. Speeds wise, is where they would have been identical here. The BMW does have a lot more standard equipment than the GLE. Good comparison though. :)

[@doggedlydetermined7022]

GLE is the better vehicle overall for an SUVs intended purpose

[@kenmoore8877]

Mercedes Is STILL King! The X5 Is Nice But its No Benz Lol Mercedes Is And Always Will Be Top Tier In Design, Performance, And Reliability!

[@seansiew5629]

😂no, as I sat in the new w206 c class and w223 s class compared to their rivalling counterparts, both have one thing is common is their plasticky galore interior which the g20 3 series and g70 7 series has less of those plastic, coming from a w221 and w222 S class owner

[@ajprudence6235]

@@seansiew5629 agreed, visited MB dealership yesterday and checked out all the GL models. Was quite shocked (had not rode in one for years) by the lack of quality material. I’m glad I ordered my 24’ X5 M60.

[@seansiew5629]

@@ajprudence6235 glad you enjoy your purchase!

[@blueb4829]

I'm looking at both for my next vehicle. I test drove the GLE this past weekend and liked it. Will test drive thr x5 soon.

[@OlsenOfficial]

If you buy in Canada,, you can add another audio system to yours build other than the one available in the US that's much better. In the US is picky available for cars such as iX and XM.