Uncle Causes Abigail To Cry At The Mention of Arthur Plus More Interesting Interactions - RDR2

[@louksirluna4556]

best 5 first seconds ever

[@ChengTeoh]

It made me laugh the first time I came across it, so I had to put it in here. :D

[@gamingempire443]

jEsUs UnCLe, DiD yOu JuSt FaRt?

[@sendmags2640]

JoHn, YoU'rE eMbArRaSsInG yOuRsElF

[@southeastvirginiarailfan2110]

@@sendmags2640 get rekt John.

[@Oxtiy]

It's probably from his lumbago

[@MrBadApple999]

Using Arthur's ring to propose really was a nice twist

[@moisessalvador7195]

Really? Didnt know how he was able to get the ring

[@TbYolo]

Blood orphan Mary gives Arthur the ring and a photograph of both them when they were young. She sent a letter to Arthur in Chapter 6. I think its cool how they pay homage to Arthur in subtle ways

[@TbYolo]

I’d like to see Red Dead Redemption 1 to be remastered with RDR2 graphics and controls. They could add in a few more things like Arthur being mentioned here and there and John talking more in depth about the gang. They should change the story slightly and have more time with Javier and Dutch. I feel like Javier was underdeveloped in RDR1 and RDR2 which is disappointing it feels like they focused more on Bill then Javier which I don’t get because Bill is boring and dumb and he gets angry over nothing. Javier is more interesting then Bill

[@VoltainLP]

@@TbYolo then = after (First Jack got his milk THEN Josiah) // than = more (Jack got more milk THAN Josiah)

[@dvelas1011]

@@moisessalvador7195 Mary sends it to him in chapter 6 and at the end Arthur gives his satchel to John

[@PrimusPicklebal]

Beginning of game: “i wanna play as John Marston” End of the game: “i wanna play as Arthur Morgan”

[@hosseintm165]

Totally correct !!!

[@williamwen3477]

Thats the way it is.......:'(

[@Anetusn]

ArnorAteBscotch :(

[@thiccElite]

rdr3: I wanna play as mac callander

[@ilhandaanish2381]

srgtdonut rdr4: I WANNA PLAY AS UNCLE

[@topblokehere6579]

She's really good at roasting John. And they say she cant cook.

[@manuj2868]

Top Blokehere underrated comment

[@afuea-qg5yo]

actually underrated lmao

[@societyizbroken9723]

Truly Underrated Cx

[@oneinfinitesoul]

The noise I made was ungodly

[@terminator6552]

*softly* don't..

[@davidrichardson3040]

I love how the ring is the one that Mary gave back to Arthur...tying Arthur into their lives forever...along with his hat

[@ChengTeoh]

It is a nice touch.

[@Kazeromaru]

His hat that John will lose sometime in the next few years, I like to roleplay it gets shot off on the mountains as he's going after Micah and he loses it in the snow.

[@asgardninja9674]

That he doesn't wear

[@viego29]

David Richardson after I completed the game I make cool outfits but I always use Arthur’s hat, at first I thought it looked ugly when I started the game but now I just think that it’s the most beautiful things ever

[@erikallen3804]

Sajirou Plays Eventhough you made this up, John never lost Arthur’s hat in the snow. So either he sold it to fund the Ranch, or he hid it in a lockbox to hide away the past.

[@MrBlack252]

"Jesus uncle did you just fart?" "John you're embarrassing yourself" uncles deflect game is on point

[@FBPG]

hahahah

[@ottovonbismarck8460]

hahahah

[@platesalesmanthevi6756]

hahahah

[@nok4799]

Uncles lumbago couldn't be reflected though...

[@iwasgroomed]

hahaha

[@mike72ulyas]

I killed Micah using Arthur’s pistol. I got to Micah using Arthur’s weapons. I worked on the farm wearing Arthur’s hat. I proposed to my girl using Arthur’s ring.

[@Profligateslayer]

WolfRaider definition of a freeloader

[@officerburrito6786]

Steve the Killer of Ender Dragons bruh

[@Profligateslayer]

OfficerBurrito7 HQ can’t take the fact I’m spitting straight facts?

[@officerburrito6786]

Steve the Killer of Ender Dragons your facts are straight up right

[@rustedtooth3015]

@@Profligateslayer 😂

[@xJangoUnchained1313x]

I love how Abigail consistently shits on john, and he takes it with such sarcastic grace. Love these characters.

[@WanderSeth]

I'm starting to think that's the norm in long-term relationships. My beloved spends almost every waking moment letting me know how dumb and forgetful I am. Maybe that's why, or maybe because, I take every single chance I get to be snarky with her. From accidentally kicking the cat while sleeping ("Of course the cat doesn't listen to you, you kick the hell out of it") to dying in co-op Minecraft ("Gee, it's like I told you how to play the game and you just flat out ignored me, but you'd NEVER do that, would you, love?"), we paralelled John and Abigale before we even knew they existed. So do my parents.

[@EpicMinecraftFail]

If John goes to jail they say this to each other. Abigail: Your an idiot John, don't come home for a while. John: I love you too honey.

[@blakechandler167]

@@WanderSeth most people I know that are still married say it basically is the norm. Happy wife happy life

[@dutchvanderlinde7238]

That's marriage for ya

[@VoltainLP]

She's joking around but in every joke there is truth. And John knows that. It reminds him of what he did to them in the past. It's important to know that he started loving Abigail and Jack more and more because of Arthur. That's the reason he wants to safe them in RDR1 and works for the agency

[@nonethewiser4431]

John: The idea I got now involves you and a hammer *Uncle and John proceed to build another house*

[@paumpaumwerson3191]

we worked so hard to build a little house together

[@zidhanoctora9569]

*_LUMBAGO_*

[@fafafagat]

@@paumpaumwerson3191 no matter.... THE WEATHER.... we're together

[@jinalisdiva]

He can’t work he’s got lumbago

[@tiramisu1p4pgoat6]

I'll climp up a ladder with a hammer a nail and I'll nail it.

[@rogersbryant1507]

0:40 The way John's standing behind the wall listening.. and the way he turns his head when Uncle says he's the luckiest man alive.. I know it was just the idle animation, but that was perfect time.

[@djaejones8785]

Not even just that. When she storms off and bumps into him and he apologizes, and then he goes on to ask her if she’s okay, like it legit was almost a movie scene

[@Whocares158]

Looking way too deep into this dude.

[@anakinskinwalker1724]

@@Whocares158shut up, you fool

[@KarlPHorse]

Can we just talk about how tragic it is that abigail probably thought, "We have settled down, the west is becoming civilized, and my son is intelligent and loves books. There is no way he will end up a gunslinger." And 7 years later the kid becomes essentially the last great gunslinger in one of the last pockets of old west in the country. It's like having your kid turn 18 in 1945 and thinking they won't have to fight in WW2, and they end up dropping the bomb on Hiroshima.

[@MrImastinker]

Karl P. Horse But if the Easter egg in GTA V is to be believed, Jack did what his father and Arthur couldn’t do, and finally settled down for real, even writing books like he’d wanted.

[@Scoffslaphead72]

Jack doesnt become a gunslinger. He kills edgar ross and becomes a writer.

[@who7th]

The worst part is that Jack actually became depressed... If you think about it, he really doesn't has no one. When in combat, he quotes: "Go ahead! I got nothin' to live for anyway!".

[@NikephorosCaesar]

People still believe RDR and GTA are in the same universe? Many things in each game say otherwise

[@connorbool6179]

@@NikephorosCaesar such as?

[@Tazmo99]

Even if Arthur is the main protagonist of Red Dead 2, it is still very much John’s story. How he got his scars, how he went from being pretty distant with his family to getting close to them etc.. And what is very beautiful is how much Arthur affected him. Arthur saved him on the mountains, Arthur made sure Jack and Abigail survived, and Arthur did everything he could with his ticking clock that John would survive. Without Arthur, there wouldn’t be no ranch. No normal life for the Marston’s. No second chance. This game hits you hard at the places you least expect.

[@ioneven]

TAZMO99 perfect way to explain it

[@sa-we9oq]

How did he get his scars ?

[@jcjc501]

Sanaa remember he got eaten by wolves

[@windowsdotexe4444]

@@sa-we9oq second mission of rdr2

[@26lekent]

Sanaa wolves

[@Mojason_]

I remembered when Jack got kidnapped John said something like "we gotta get Jack back or she'll kill us all!" like holy shit John was more afraid of Abigail than anything, even losing his own son XD

[@dankamisko5032]

No he wanted to say I will say kill u all but dident want to show that he loved jack so said that watch the cutscean

[@jacobdominguez7808]

Haha I loved that part😁

[@astronaut-n1c]

@@dankamisko5032 true

[@VRALLSTARS17]

Lol

[@R_-qs4fo]

probably John's epic sense of humour XD

[@BiggsTheOwl]

When 12 year old jack has a deeper voice than 17 year old jack

[@grapefruitjuice9473]

Biggs Media weird

[@alexdeghost2729]

He doesn't tho

[@salvatoreprocopio6700]

Biggs Media it’s like a demon

[@MrJames1034]

Most boys have their balls drop. His shot right back up.

[@spekalluke5739]

Common sense^facts and logic

[@Tobbs96]

I love Uncle as a character in the second game. He may still be a lazy alcoholic with lumbago, but there's a lot of wisdom in that old man, if only you'd take the time to listen for it.

[@danielyoung6778]

He really is one of the smartest members of the gang, Dutch even calls him out on his jester act and he drops it at one point in a conversation with Pearson where he talks about his childhood. He tries giving John advice a few times throughout the early game as well.

[@obsidiankrystal3308]

In the first game he was annoying.

[@TobiasBräutigam]

Uncle knows the best ways to avoid work

[@jinmause206]

@@obsidiankrystal3308 that's the whole point. He's an annoying old man that nobody would mind emptying a bullet into, but he's wise, and tries to help where he can(and wants)

[@Vicky-kk8hp]

He guided them to build the house

[@trevthekidd]

Abigail: *Sings the hellbound train song* Arthur: *THERE'S ALWAYS A GODDAMN TRAIN*

[@trevthekidd]

@ *_OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH_*

[@nomar6628]

CJ:ah shit here we go again.

[@KING-jx4jb]

JuSt OnE mOrE lItTlE sCoRe

[@amir.h84gamer78]

big smoke: Follow the dAMn tRaIN

[@punishercastle5487]

The John and Abigail moments make the ending of RDR1 even sadder. And I didn’t know that was possible

[@BanishedSilentShadow3318]

Gotta give it to rockstar for they made the best moments in rdr2 on how they handle the relationship between John and Abigail till the events of rdr1

[@punishercastle5487]

Reaper it’s funny because seeing that there were times where they were genuinely happy is very heartwarming, and good to see, since we as fans want John and Abigail to be happy (both separately and together). But all of that concurrently, like I said, makes RDR1s ending sadder because those moments won’t continue. Like RDR2 gave us a “happily ever after” for them that we already know isnt “ever after”

[@XDG]

Exactly it's inhumane!

[@tylerseiders4534]

Dude now I’m sad because you reminded me

[@punishercastle5487]

Tyler Seiders I envy you for being able to forget lol

[@jameswang1]

“John marston is the luckiest man alive” arthur told me a long, long time ago

[@blacky8987]

Damn that was Hard

[@chris.hartliss]

During the prologue when Arthur says "You don't have to ever worry about John. Things have a way of always working out for him" Lol

[@BetaBoyBill]

@@chris.hartliss when you think about it he's kinda right, while he did die in the end he successfully saved his wife and son

[@billybob8113]

no he isn't . . . *J I M M I L T O N* is.

[@salvatoreprocopio6700]

Billy Bob be serious and pay respects to the King of the west

[@jakeblake1021]

Arthur had a family before but they died by robbers thats why arthur got angry at John about ignoring his family and thats also why he told uncle that john was the luckiest man. Man was arthur a gold hearted man it honestly makes you wanna think and live your life different

[@uBpGK]

He was gold hearted but he lived a life of crime that diminished the goodness to the people who only see the outside of his character. People could know the real you but if outsiders don’t know that the how could they really know fro what they were told. Idk dude red dead has the most human stpey out of all fictional figures. Humans are idiots an we only see what we wanna see. Idk seeing stories like this makes me feel hopeful about the human race that there are some of us who know how it is but we can still love our lives in spite of that

[@chrisbreezy-ryanbarbosa4320]

Honestly the game has changed my whole outlook on life. After the game i started doing more chores around the house like Arthur at camp or John on the farm, taking extra work hours to make more money like Dutch. Apprrciating a good country song too haha. RDR2 best game ever.

[@asves4536]

@@uBpGK yes he did live a life of crime, but the game is called red dead REDEMPTION, arthur at the end became good when he knew he was gonna die, helped the native americans, sacrificed his life so that john could have a family, and helped so many people. that doesent escuse what he has done in the past, but shows how he went from a bad person to a good one

[@brucesnow7125]

@@uBpGK they were in that life out of desperation. They had to feed many people, people that government and rich folk would throw out like trash. They are all outsiders. Don't forget that they used to be different. The way we see the gang in this game ain't the way they used to be. As Hosea says, things changed even before Blackwater. They used to help folk too and only target rich pricks. As the civilization started rapidly expanding, gang started getting desperate. That's why they started working with likes of Strauss. That's why Dutch started getting more insecure and couldn't accept that they will be squashed. Arthur, unlike Dutch, started truly living by their original code by the end of the game. While Dutch abandoned any sense of morality.

[@Denis-kd6cv]

From playing red dead 2 i wanted do get tuberculosis it may sound a bit psychotic but it is what it is

[@imadebananabread9568]

“It would make me very happy” - Arthur to John on the ridge “It would make me very happy” - John to Abigail on the boat

[@keknov5555]

I made banana bread Arthur said to John “it would mean a lot to me”

[@beatstar2]

I made banana bread “Mister” every RDR2 character LOL

[@saiyik9493]

@@beatstar2 You Sir, are a fish!

[@caleeb4495]

That came right up when I saw this comment

[@MrBean8100]

I wish Arthur was mentioned a little bit more

[@spectralassassin6030]

You have to keep in mind that while for us, Arthurs death just happened so it's still fresh in our minds, but for them, it's been a few years since his death. They've all moved on at this point.

[@aligamerable]

@@spectralassassin6030 To be Precise, 8 Years. The Epilogue takes place in 1907 while rest takes place in 1899.

[@spectralassassin6030]

@@aligamerable Thanks.

[@acr7780]

After building the house they should have toasted to Arthur

[@jmponte9775]

If you go talk to the people that Arthur talked to once (ex. The Homeless Vet, The beggar in Rhodes etc) as John. They will mention Arthur or a reference to Arthur.

[@mohammadhussien5223]

Goddamnit she really loved John. I'm even more sad that John dies in the first red dead redemption and she died from depression 5 years later at least Jack was an Adult when she died.

[@suriyaap5011]

3 years later and she died from TB.

[@fegeleinherman8587]

@@suriyaap5011 No she died from *Lumbago*

[@TheMellowGamer]

@@fegeleinherman8587 No, she died because she didn't have a PLAN

[@harroldbogharry9867]

@@TheMellowGamer no she died because she didn’t have a BOAH

[@FattyMcLangy]

no she died because she didn't settle down in TAHITI and eat MANGOES.

[@CassieMalibu]

One of my favorite interactions after Arthur dies is going to visit the widowed women up north of Annesburg Arthur helps out before he passes away. It’s sweet to know she still remembers Arthur even after 7 years. And another one is the boy he ran into skipping rocks at the river talking about some girl. Arthur gives him advice to get the girl and when John runs into him years later and the boy married the girl he was after but it turned out she was a horrible wife and he blames Arthur for ruining his life. I found that one real funny. 😂

[@ChengTeoh]

Do you remember where you came across the widow during the epilogue, because I just tried going back to her place and there is no one there.

[@CassieMalibu]

Cheng Teoh when I first started playing as John, visiting her was one of the first things I did because I was so curious. When I arrived at her cabin, she was sitting on her porch either writing or reading. I also visited her in the afternoon so maybe her interaction is only during the day

[@ChengTeoh]

It's strange, I haven't seen her at the cabin and I've gone during the mornings & middle of the day. Did you happen to absolve and give her money?

[@CassieMalibu]

Cheng Teoh Oh you must be talking about the widow who you were supposed to recover her debt from. The lady I am talking about is the widow that Arthur helped hunt and skin animals. She is the widow that’s all the way at the very top northeast corner of the map

[@ChengTeoh]

Ah, okay lol. I was going a bit nuts trying to get something to happen that doesn't exist. XD Yeah I did see the widow Charlotte. Thank goodness I'm not going crazy.

[@dutch1627]

Their is a sad part if you finish the epilogue you visit the campsites and you can hear the voices of the old group it’s sad and you also hear Arthur say “ go on go be your your family”

[@dutch1627]

Goron when you complete the game you can visit the old campsites and hear the old gang voices it’s sad and scary

[@arthurmorgan1830]

I did my best dutch

[@dutch1627]

Arthur Morgan I know son, I know.

[@bigjizz6997]

@@dutch1627 You two got me feelin sad now :(

[@kellerproductions8527]

You left me to die!

[@flamingmonkey7712]

I think Arthur and Abigail had some history. I remember in the last chapter when Arthur's sick, Abigail said to Arthur "I have you" and then changed her tone followed with "as a friend". And in the first chapter when Abigail went to ask Arthur for helping finding John, Arthur seemed a little unpleased even before Abigail started talking.

[@affiqfirdaus4664]

Arthur did say he should've married abigail when he had the chance, but mary linton was sorta in the way (he wrote it in his journal)

[@petergriffin613]

He be S I M P I N'

[@flamingmonkey7712]

@@affiqfirdaus4664 Maybe that is one of the reasons that John didn't want to talk about Arthur with Abigail? Of course regardless of the fact that Arthur's character didn't exist when RDR came out. And sure, John missed Arthur and was grateful for what he did

[@solareclipse9379]

@Vic that's why i still want to believe that is Arthur's son

[@fartrulz4854]

I mean it’s like what Dutch said in the first game “ we all had her”

[@silvergraphz8458]

Seeing John and Abigail kiss on the boat was more heartwarming than the chicken pot pie soup I was eating

[@ryanwells5348]

Xd

[@jacqueline6475]

What the heck is chicken pot pie soup?

[@silvergraphz8458]

@@jacqueline6475 GET A SPOON MY BOY

[@dominickcruces9077]

DEADKICKMC32 Games may I also have some?

[@rivaraptor4277]

aw man, Pot pie soup is THE SHIT

[@rkmenace6816]

**Lumbago has been added to your dictionary**

[@Liam-ey4og]

It’s lower back pain

[@Buugzy]

😂😂

[@susmemer1032]

U mean compendium?

[@lolyankovic6952]

I actually did

[@rkmenace6816]

SusMemer10 yeah I guess so, I’m not the smartest lumbagonator in the world

[@hotpockethunter4886]

It’s amazing to see how Abigail still loves John and breaks him out after all the shit he pulls.

[@xx-footcmpsf.c3693]

Other way round imo

[@Idkisayrandomshitforlikes]

​​@@xx-footcmpsf.c3693 both ways around

[@johnmarston5905]

This makes rdr1 story even sadder..that part when abigail is singing with uncle and jack is beautiful..they we're so happy..i know it's just a game but now..seeing abigail , uncle and john's graves it's..harder

[@johnmarston5905]

@Arthur morgan not again..

[@Tyler_DurdenK]

John Marston When the time comes leave and don’t look back

[@shitpost-ki9kr]

@@johnmarston5905 hi i am the high honor version of yours

[@seila5083]

Hey joohn

[@johnmarston5905]

@@seila5083 arthur..been a long time😑

[@MagicalPuddinPops]

Uncle: “Exactly.... it all starts with a good woman.” Random man on banjo: “Here’s my moment.”

[@TheKingofbrooklin]

Uncle was literally the only friend Jack had.

[@isachan834]

The only friend you'll need!

[@mrP040DX]

What about Rufus?

[@unbreakablemanlet8043]

He has Mr.Terminal Lumbago, he doesn't need anyone else.

[@WhiskeyTango76s]

@Raul Victor I think he was talking about John

[@jixiden1292]

No secretly i hated him

[@ghostface6226]

If you have good karma John mentions that he found the ring in Arthur’s things!

[@ChengTeoh]

Really? That's pretty cool.

[@jneflotterus1946]

Chris Conte and he shows the young picture of arthur and mary with the ring

[@punctuationman334]

Cheng Teoh why the hell didn’t you try to get high honor.

[@jordankuttler1859]

I Hate To Float when John pulled out the picture of Arthur and Mary I cried like a baby that was so beautiful, such great storytelling

[@JuanKnight]

Yeah, i have the good ending and John talks to Sadie about the ring, her response is that her marriage make her very happy and that maybe it could make John too

[@crisa9612]

11:07 “The Reverend spoke about eagles.” “Even youths grow tired and weary, and young men stumble and fall; but those who hope in the Lord will renew their strength. They will soar on wings like eagles; they will run and not grow weary, they will walk and not be faint.” ‭‭Isaiah‬ ‭40:30-31‬

[@ratsoncoke7993]

Aaa thank you I was wondering about that

[@shadowcangaming526]

Abigail:"How was your day?" John:"Fine" Abigail:"You kept out of trouble?" John:"Yeah" *next scene is john shooting somebody

[@kaiser1817]

Next shot shows john in jail *record scratch* *Freezeframe* John : Yep thats me, you’re probably wondering how I got here.

[@andresalgado3002]

*chuckles* *always*

[@TrystonJackson2005]

So you getting busted in Red Dead like getting busted in GTA

[@Sean-qt1sd]

yeah that's the joke

[@rupertstoddart4876]

As longa s you don't get caught

[@theonattrass2207]

"Have you kept out of trouble?" cuts to him shooting someone and getting arrested.

[@ChengTeoh]

I had to insert that clip in since it had the wagon running over and causing an npc to ragdoll so spectacularly silly. XD

[@ChengTeoh]

@Larry, sometimes a clip is just too good to leave on the cutting room floor. XD

[@Revan-eb1wb]

thanks, captain obvious....

[@bladennmoyle6251]

😂😂😂

[@ijustworkhere1008]

“John Marston is the luckiest man alive” *Always sunny theme starts playing* “The last enemy that shall be destroyed”

[@SardonicJosh]

Why. Must. You. Hurt. Me. Like. This?

[@nananderson7259]

I honestly didnt care for Abigail that much in RDR1, I only cared because John did. But after playing RDR2 I have so much more appreciation for Abigail. I keep thinking about the first time I played RDR1, I was stunned at how angry Abigail was when John went back home - then after RDR2 I understood the scene for what it was. Such a good game. -gimme Arthur back tho-

[@TheJotaroKujo]

Abigail was the original "doubter" and Arthur and John would have most likely end up being pieces of shit as well if not for her.

[@hayleewiley7215]

Agreed. I used to always think Bonnie was a better match for John but seeing Abigail in RDR2, especially when he proposes, shows that most of the bickering between them is just how they show they love each other. But I would gladly trade Abigail and Jack if it meant I would have Arthur and John back. Sorry, not sorry! 😂

[@user-sp2jg9rx8r]

I still don't care much about her. She isn't interesting as the other's.

[@nananderson7259]

@@user-sp2jg9rx8r I think she is definitely not made to be as interesting as the 'new'characters in RDR2 but that's really just because she isn't 'new' to the series. They spent more time developing her to realistically be a younger woman than the spitfire we met in RD1.

[@teehee3657]

Red Dead Series Games she has reasons to be angry 🤡

[@arthurmorgan5569]

Ah. John Marston. It's good to see you doing well after my death.

[@blacky8987]

Damn bruh you make me cry with that.

[@Killerswisscheese]

Should we tell him...

[@jirendagreat5508]

We know u ain’t too keen on revenge but...

[@lmhmomma]

@@Killerswisscheese yeah let's tell Arthur about the 1st game.

[@arthurmorgan5569]

What are you folks talking about?

[@moisesfreire6408]

2:52 I really want to see Abigail's opinion on Rip Van Winkle and Tacitus Kilgore too.

[@mr.sltrskid]

why does everyone say "rip van winkle" what does it even mean

[@CasualFag]

@@mr.sltrskid in chapter 3 when the pinkertons find the camp near rhodes they dont recognize john and he calls himself rip van winkle

[@mr.sltrskid]

@@CasualFag what mission?

[@selfexplanatory6459]

His old life began to die in that failed ferry robbery on the waters of Blackwater. Maybe I’m reading too much into it but his proposal on those same waters was also the birth of his new life.

[@alfredorivas1768]

Self Explanatory Then he screwed up his new life by seeking revenge

[@DO-mw6ju]

Sh rek how did he ruin his new life

[@walldimsbenitez6758]

Sh rek no he closed his old one like arthur seas you cant be tow people at once.

[@nicolasflores7322]

dylkeen When he goes after Micah, the pinkertons (Edgar Ross) find his body. Ask around and him on his ranch. Thats why in RD1 he gets caught at his ranch. Hope this cleared thing up.

[@thecritic3959]

“Revenge is a fool’s game.” -Arthur (1899)

[@thegourd9296]

the proposal is almost like arthur telling john to run because he says "It would mean a lot to me." and john says "It would make me very happy

[@theohdtv9834]

Uhhh yeh

[@nomadichippie1930]

I was actually kind of sad when I ended the game. I spent a lot of the game at camp around the fire with the gang listening to stories and jokes, the story just adds to the effect of family. But at the end, after avenging John and killing Micah, I went and sat at the fire outside of the house and thought about how well the game made me miss the group I traveled around the map with

[@LynnHarrod]

There’s so much more to the “Endless Summer” than most players will ever realize. After finishing the epilogue, if you treat John and his family and ranch like the real thing (doing chores, coming to dinner, going to bed with Abigail, etc.) and continue playing daily, there are lots of little details to discover. This video does a good job of covering many of them, but there’s actually a lot more.

[@ChengTeoh]

Really, could you give an example? I'm extremely curious now.

[@plasticbottle4270]

Oh, really? What a luck I kept my last 3 saves with John after I restarted the game. I guess I will go back to it, and visit some old caracters.

[@IsabellaShortleaf]

wicked, sounds like you need to get a life rather than scrolling through comments on a video you dislike about a game you dislike. try just leaving the video next time, rather than beating on people who enjoyed the game?

[@TheCaptain008]

Shoot. I should have done that. I deleted and removed the game completely from my PS4 the day after finishing the epilogue.

[@Raptorclaw000x]

@@IsabellaShortleaf if you don't mind me asking what does he say

[@tanneraitken3768]

Everyone talks about the main story which is undoubtedly in a league of it's own but I think in the long run I will remember the Epilogue the most. It the most beautiful yet tragic story in video game history in my honest opinion Arthur gives his life so John can live. And in return puts literally everything he has into building a life for the his family and it is destroyed because of past mistakes. Such a fantastic video game.

[@ChengTeoh]

It is a great game, the only problem I have with it is that there isn't a way to skip certain cutscenes once you've seen it a couple of times already.

[@thescoundrel793]

Arthur gave John the chance to have everything Arthur gave up

[@davidleroth8644]

gets destroyed because of the American government*

[@1polyron1]

@@thescoundrel793 I just realized that John is literally living the life Arthur envisioned for himself.

[@Unstable_Luis]

@@1polyron1 You just blew my mind with this one

[@BigDave18]

Some reason I nearly cried at Abigail actually loving something that Reverend Swanson use to read

[@mariomorgan6083]

One night I was frisky

[@a_not_so_amazingperson9900]

@@mariomorgan6083 over some potent whiskey

[@nowieus]

@@a_not_so_amazingperson9900 Like waves of the bay of Biscay

[@joemountfort1166]

@@nowieus I began to tumble and roar

[@chadjones967]

I couldn't imagine being on a boat not knowing how to swim. I feel like that would scare the shit out of me.

[@infidelheretic923]

Chad Jones Almost as scary as proposing.

[@quuuuro]

Abigail could prolly carry him to shore haha

[@chadjones967]

@@CSlaught02 The chances of a plane crash and that rickety ass boat tipping over are colossally different lol

[@chadjones967]

@@CSlaught02 Nooooo it is not. I tipped a boat over just by patling that bitch the wrong way. A plane has a 1 in 11 million chance to crash😂

[@nutella7644]

i did kayaking with a friend last year and i can't swim either like john (im not scared of water, i was just never taught how to lol) but at least my friend knows so it wasn't that scary

[@sebastianpowers5353]

If Arthur was mentioned in RD1 we would wonder who he was

[@caydenobrien9671]

Sebastian Powers I remember the first time I saw him in a trailer and I thought I would hate him, oh how wrong I was.

[@Jordan-mq4wj]

@@caydenobrien9671 the trailers did make him unlikable

[@Archenw]

"You've forgot more important people than me John"

[@ppface7221]

If only bill said “no more Dutch, no more Arthur, and no more YOU”

[@ppface7221]

Montez Demarrco same

[@Luciferdesrea]

"Get lost! But just for a bit. Begone. Get lost!" That's a relationship in a nutshell.

[@Sadoodi]

Maybe I am overthinking it but the Bible part reminds me of Arthur. Especially when Abigail mentions the Reverend spoke about eagles. Arthur has an eagle on his grave when you visit him

[@christopherwood3793]

Depends on your honor level

[@josephzayas3715]

That's only if you had max high honor before Arthur died. If you had low honor then a wolf is standing by the grave.

[@christopherwood3793]

@@josephzayas3715 you get the buck if you've been through the game with high honor

[@marcomaliqi9844]

@@josephzayas3715and no flowers

[@Briayawna]

Saad Atiq o

[@equinoxturtlez379]

I broke into a house to ask a kid if he wanted a Sprite Cranberry

[@kylotrap3920]

@@ricardoahr5459 John gets shot like 100 time in rdr. But can't take 25 bullets in the end

[@flushersundew5143]

I wish I could like this comment but it’s already at 420, too perfect

[@zakmiller3755]

Equinox Turtlez sounds like an ad aha

[@Tronter6000]

@@ricardoahr5459 lmao

[@TheMrhExperience1920]

Im ur 666th like

[@Yougotcaged102]

This really gives an example of how good of an impression Arthur makes on people. Uncle wouldn't be serious about anything if you payed him to and he still speaks in a respectful tone about Arthur

[@rooshavik9133]

This game....*sniff*....It keeps on shooting me in the heart

[@tinopacheco2617]

Pussy

[@fishyfishy3140]

Microsoft Sony if that’s the case then I’ve been shot by a Gatling gun

[@thewhompingwampa2671]

Literally and metaphorically.

[@francisco3601]

Oh shit never mind I just cried

[@shalinado]

*mEdIc!*

[@AgentDigits]

John: Well we've seen it... *gets up from seat* Abigail: OH NO YOU DON'T *PULLS JOHN BACK INTO HIS SEAT*

[@wilbysot343]

*busts in to door* WHERE IS HE YOU USELESS PIECE OF CRAP, JIM MILTON

[@AgentDigits]

@OrphanMolester You fucking scrooge... People like sharing their favourite moments

[@ayylmao8375]

Such a contrast to the theatre scene with Mary

[@scorchclasstitan6727]

JW Makes *WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH YOU THROWING ME INTO A CHAIR LIKE THAT*

[@izek402]

@OrphanMolester2009 im calling lester the molester

[@TehSkeletonKing187]

4:27 It reminds me of Arthur's last words to John and knowing it's Arthur's ring makes it so much worse ;-;

[@ericnunes9104]

14:52 And begged devil to stop the train. (In my head) Dutch leaps out of a bush and say: Did somebody say rob a train?

[@cameronferrell5722]

Eric Nunes “just one more train Arthur” “THERES ALWAYS ANOTHER GOD DAMN TRAIN”

[@Mrblacksnow9295]

@@cameronferrell5722 The damn train...

[@rajneshchapatikumar3924]

WE NEED MORE MONEY

[@strongbear3369]

trust the plan...

[@jinx0710]

All of you better have some god damn FAITH

[@OneReallyGrumpyJill]

Kinda sad that they don't mention Arthur that much but hey, I love how dry-sarcastic their relationship can get. Abigail is a good woman.

[@ragingcomrade6823]

It would make sense for the rdr 1 story because arthur wasnt even created. John mentions how he thinks of arthur but doesnt like to talk about him and what happened. It sucks but its the only way to make the stories make sense

[@spectralassassin6030]

@Kaeble She more than likely chose to become a better person after she had Jack.

[@dathunderman4]

Kaeble remember what Edith downes had to resort to? You gotta remember back in those days women weren't able to just get a job so easily. Idk Abigail's backstory exactly but she was obviously poor and she alludes to how she never seen her parents around. She probably didn't have much other choices.

[@dasfritzchen9059]

I think its like in Real life...the first days weeks and months after someone passed away you cant stop thinking about....but over the years....you start to Remember this people from time to time...like my grandma and my other grandpa.....we dont talk everytime about them....but we remember. and people you love are never really gone...they are here *points on his heart*

[@dasfritzchen9059]

@Kaeble a good person does not define himself over what he does....look at arthur...he was a good person with a bad life. but as you said....each to their own...even ignorant fucks like you

[@steveburns9939]

I’m watching this video nearly 10 months after everyone else has finished the game and it gives me so much joy to see how many anonymous people on KZbin are able to love these characters so much. Rockstar did an amazing thing with this game .

[@ChengTeoh]

It is a fun game. Too bad there doesn't seem to be a story driven DLC like Undead Nightmare in the near future.

[@steveburns9939]

Cheng Teoh I’m actually okay without the DLC. There is so much to do and see in the game already. More might cheapen an already perfect experience. The zombies also wouldn’t fit in the ultra realistic world Rockstar built.

[@fvansoldt]

@@ChengTeoh The zombie DLC sucked. Never finished it. It doesn't fit in the lore anyway. Might be nice to have a DLC where one of the other characters life is emphasized.

[@soter8164]

Why nobody just said that Abigail is hell of a good singer? Her voice is beautiful and the way she sings is just heart touching.

[@nikosmoon]

Soter ikr! i can’t find that song she sang

[@EthanBradburyVlogs]

Mediocre

[@eddiediaz5518]

She can also play the piano

[@namenotavailable_1275]

I loved Karen's singing when she sang "Lorena" too

[@coolrank12]

Honestly I could not agree with you more and Uncle was right about John being the luckiest man ever to marry a beautiful woman like Abigail 🙂

[@HeTurnsWhiteRulersBrown]

*uncle did u just fart* Me: aaannnddd we’re off to a good start

[@ChengTeoh]

It an attention getting for sure. XD

[@skyezone3429]

Lol

[@Kevin-rj5zp]

I love the epilogue. It really made me feel as though I had a wife and son who I need to provide for and keep safe, and that feeling of family only got bigger when Uncle, Charles and Sadie came along.

[@Ivbo]

Why do I feel like Abigail and Arthur had a thing at one point in the past ... the way she started crying at the mention of him just seemed like he meant a lot more to her then this story led us to believe, I would not be surprised if anything at all went on between those two at some point...

[@xhiddenshadz8221]

Wel he did save john and stayed by him instead of dutch

[@coreycasciano3255]

Select Obvi you gotta remember that Arthur took care of jack when John ran off so she has a lot of care for him and tbh I kinda like Arthur more then John and I never thought that was possible but rockstar really made me care for Arthur the scenes when he was coughing till he passed out were actually hard for me to watch, but I still love Johns character I just wished Arthur and John could have both survived and got to live the life that they were longing for in a long time Arthur gets to live with Mary and John, Abigail, and Jack get to live a peaceful life *sorry if this was a long message just wanted to share my opinion

[@thebrunssss]

Arthur mentions in this journal that he should have married Abigail before John did. Also i think its because Arthur just always treated her well and looked after her John and jake

[@mryoutube4399]

There is no good way to put this but Arthur,John and Dutch all had sex with Abigail.Abagail was the camp whore for a while.Arthur probably treated her with the most respect before he saved her,John and Jack's life.

[@jamesroper4952]

Well Arthur was the one who held everyone together. He was always busting his ass day in and day out, trying keep everyone fed, bringing in money. Not to mention trying keep everyone's spirits up, with a kind word and a smile. Despite knowing how fucked up everything is. Then there's the whole taking the time out of his daily tasks, to take Jack fishing. There's no doubt that Arthur left quite an impression on everyone, even those who hated him.

[@bunsonbaker4156]

The way Arthur cared for and was a guardian angel to their family makes me emotional. Both John and Abigail clearly loved Arthur very much.

[@Kevininabhuddi]

The entire time I was playing the epilogue I was crying especially when they were living on the ranch. I just kept remembering the scene where Arthur sends John off to safety and then...y'know. I kept wandering around the ranch wondering if Arthur was looking down on them smiling because even if he was gone he saw exactly what it was that he gave John, Abigail and Jack. He gave them a true shot at happiness. At a peaceful life away from the running, hiding, and all the chaos. I just know he was up there laughing his head off at his brother trying to get Uncle to help them build a house. ;-; I never heard Uncle talk to Abigail about Arthur though. Arthur had a family but they were killed and so it makes perfect sense why he would tell Uncle that about John. I'm going to go cry now.

[@andersongames0237]

and those who betrayed arthur and john, they got exactly what they deserved. arthur was a good man underneath the tough skin

[@MARYWTHER]

I legit burst down crying when John proposes to Abigail. Like, all the tears of sadness I hadn't gotten out of Arthur's death already. It's literally the moment he makes a choice to honor Arthur's sacrifice and choose to honor his wife as well. The moment where everything is technically worth it, because John and Abigail are happy and it's all what Arthur wanted. And that picture of young Arthur and Mary... Jesus, pulled my heart strings way too hard. Arthur sacrificed his life for John and his happiness after having lost it himself... It's just so sad.

[@grillpills1294]

7:17 John: I hope Abigail doesnt find out about me getting arrested. Abigail: *w* *h* *a* *t*

[@marssmarts6554]

You just made my day:)

[@bryanthebroker880]

😂😂😂😂Thank you for it good one!

[@brandonrobson2000]

The Bible passage is Isiah 40:31 "But those who hope in the LORD will renew their strength. They will soar on wings like eagles; they will run and not grow weary, they will walk and not be faint."

[@Spaxecowboy]

VivaLaVita555 Isn't there a eagle for high honor Arthur next to his grave

[@brandonrobson2000]

@@Spaxecowboy Yeah, you don't see it as a spirit animal but it is connotated with high honor. The passage is moreso talking about giving the gang strength as they keep running from the pinkertons

[@Newchallengestore]

@VivaLaVita555 Soatson reverend Read the passage in Couter, in Begining of the game

[@namename9769]

When jack reads that part from the Bible it sounds a lot like he is speaking about Arthur.. is it just me?

[@notjohncena6492]

Doctor: it's OK hee hee heetler isn't real he can't hurt you Name name: hee hee

[@stevemccann4166]

It’s a Messiac prophecy from the Old Testament predicting Jesus’ crucifixion. Just thought I would enlighten you with that bit of info😇 I’m guessing the verse Rev Swanson quoted was probably “but those who hope in the Lord will renew their strength. They will soar on wings like eagles; they will run and not grow weary, they will walk and not be faint.” from Isaiah‬ ‭40, 31‬‬ but I never heard him say it as probably out looking for rock carvings or something of that ilk

[@popefrancis8153]

@@stevemccann4166 Rev Swanson is a good example of Protestants pastors They barley know their bibles properly They usually become alcoholics Then end up getting people into their congregation anyways

[@stevemccann4166]

@@popefrancis8153 Bit of a sweeping statement. Like saying all RC priests are paedos. Obviously not true and neither is your comment about proddie ministers😀 Pastor is more of a Pentecostal title.

[@popefrancis8153]

@@stevemccann4166 It’s mostly true I know a few converts And their pastor has a very similar experience Again not all priests are pedos Since you can accuse and sue the church for good money Even if your not victim

[@LordZoth6292]

Man the story as a whole of the RDR franchise is just so heartbreaking

[@ChengTeoh]

Agreed.

[@kimichrist]

LordZoth6292 everyone dies eventually

[@santank4]

@@ChengTeoh but did uncle just fart?

[@marconadayao9730]

@@santank4 😱😱😱

[@Christian-97]

Shows how the criminal life brings good for mostly no one. GTA 4 also states that pretty well.

[@khalidq8245]

11:36 for a moment, i thought he was naked lol

[@ChengTeoh]

LOL, that's understandable.

[@brodey1004]

Thanks know I can’t get that image out of my mind

[@aprilcastillo9895]

I thought I was the only one! Haha

[@benjaminavila2075]

;v; looking that exact time dude, he really looks like he is naked.

[@Kaline3659]

@Ercan Teke how do you know that?

[@Drakrau_TheDerg]

The proposal is honestly one of the cutest moments ever. It's just so adorable. 🥰🥰

[@ducktnt7690]

3:12 we learned that from the first game

[@jinx0710]

The pain of accidentally slipping in water

[@notjohncena6492]

Tommy vercitty can't swim either At least John can stay for like 40 sec

[@Ancienregime8090]

I love the epilogue of this game. I really wraps up the story and lets it end with a happy ending.

[@martincooper2175]

Rajid Mohandas Until rdr

[@danielyoung6778]

@@martincooper2175 even then it wasn't in vain. Jack grew up raised well enough that he will eventually hang up his gun and become an author. He doesn't repeat his father or Arthur's mistakes and apparently writes an American classic most likely about John and the gangs story. If that GTA V Easter egg is Canon at least.

[@martincooper2175]

YoDa BaKi Hope so

[@kalvinkalvarino9536]

The first play through was kinda annoying but the second play through is very beautiful. I guess i was just trying to beat the game the fist time.

[@anthonylomeli9272]

@@kalvinkalvarino9536 I can't wait til I have enough money to afford this game, so close! But tell me, is the online aspect of it any good or is it trash like everyone says?

[@boxerchester8920]

gotta love how john is so desperate that Abigail doesnt leave him again that he apologises to her when she brushes past him at 1:01

[@mxrcures]

that’s just the artificial intelligence response to brushing past someone as high honor John, he does the same in the city and anywhere else

[@iiDABEAN]

Abigail says, "The Reverend spoke of eagles", which is coincidentally the bird type that sits upon the rock near Arthur's grave if you complete the chapter 6 with high/good honor. Also the same bird that Rains Fall sees in one of the cut scenes of the credits.

[@wardenunknown]

3 years too late but you can also hear the vary same scripture he recites in chapter 1 as he reads it besides john while he heals

[@nahreally_yeah]

you can also find a eagle in the mountain where arthur died.

[@FreeAimDog]

lol she thought john was going to take her out near the water and kill her, she said *mighty strange* and look at her face when she gets on the boat

[@griz312]

Elite GamingWolf she knows John can't swim too

[@erikallen3804]

What kind of outlaw can’t swim? If he was living in an orphanage for most of his life, they surely tried to teach him how to swim.

[@vguyver2]

@Agustin Rossetti I would like to add that it seems he spent most of his life in the west away from water. He seems to be a land lover.

[@WavemDafoe]

I love their relationship. It’s so broken but nicely meshed together.

[@caydenleboeuf3664]

Damn...it hurts seeing John wearing Arthur’s hat, knowing that he’s dead

[@OverkillNu]

Wait a moment... *flashbacks to Red Dead 1* OH SHIT JOHN REALLY CANT SWIM BAHAHHAA

[@smileforthecamera90]

OverkillNu lol I decided to test that out whilst police were looking for me and I drowned. It be like that sometimes

[@TheRealestEric]

... You only just figured it out?

[@smileforthecamera90]

The Realist yes.

[@leedoes3380]

this game is not about Arthurs story, its about Arthur helping John on his.

[@notjohncena6492]

Ok

[@waffelsaregood821]

John: jesus uncle did you just fart. Best line of the game in my opinion

[@Rapsha100]

6:28 NO PILLOWS?!?!? MY MMERSION!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@ChengTeoh]

LOL, okay you are one heck of an eagle-eyed viewer. I DIDN'T even notice that. [ my perception special is a 0 ] XD

[@lukemoynan5262]

No there are pillows they're just thin

[@neurodivergentape4425]

@@ChengTeoh there actually are pillows, for half a frame where abigail goes to hug john you can see the edge of a pillow

[@highcookiess]

Those look like pillows to meee....

[@micahbell2466]

6:31 I think I see a little bit of a ... P I L L O W

[@knucklestheechidna3303]

Like Arthur told him. Get the hell outta here and be a goddamn man! Then John proposed properly. Bravo indeed 👏😄

[@Shadowdragon_TV]

R.I.P. Arthur Morgan.

[@kantagious3133]

No

[@hallieblair3563]

Abigail: are you serious..? *_No, no I am not abigail I brought you all this way and brought a ring for nothin._*

[@vermark8719]

Ikr gawd also um.... you may want to move to Mexico or Tahiti before 1911 John...

[@erikallen3804]

*I stole it off some guy I murdered in the street of Blackwater*

[@erikallen3804]

@@vermark8719 The B.O.I would've probably tracked down John if he fled the U.S.

[@TheTrooper115]

@@erikallen3804 Not a chance. Only reason he got caught was because he decided it'd be a grand idea to settle down in the area that was literally locked down thanks to the Van Der Linde gang (of which Marston was a part). Sadie got out and wasn't hunted down, and with her work its not exactly like she'd be keeping a low profile. Charles also got out, fucked off to Canada and made a life for himself. Arthur implores John to leave, to take Dutch's cash and GTFO the country. He doesn't and that is what causes his ultimate downfall. Should have fucked off to Argentina or something along those lines. Obviously the real reason why he doesn't is because the story (Of RDRed1) would make absolutely no sense if he did. Pretty much all of the gangs issues (and by extension its members) are caused by them knowing what needs to be done but for some reason not doing it or half-arsing it (John's homestead is a perfect example of halfarsing) and instead causing more trouble and noise. Dutch losing his mind didn't help matters either, tbf.

[@themandance293]

Yeah this was all a prank bro haha

[@JesyofAura]

2:29 looks like you're playing as Abigail

[@TNMx22]

It is so beautiful to see that arthur kept Mary's ring and john found it in his satchel and now Abigail's wearing it ❤

[@brandonlee7536]

You have earned a subscriber i like how you show every little detail i missed during my honorable playthrough

[@ChengTeoh]

Glad to have you aboard.

[@mickeynotmouse]

me in 2010: "I wish I could play as john marston at the end of red dead redemption :(" *monkey's paw finger curls*

[@RaizeN95]

Arthur, the best senpai 😭

[@juangaming-xw3zl]

Yup

[@leblanc69069]

Archur-kun

[@shiraziwineco.6683]

"I love you too darling", Thats actually what I say when ever my girlfriend yells at me 😅

[@NamFoService]

We don't give a f :D

[@spaghettispaghetti8775]

@@NamFoService who's the we?

[@fawnieee]

I wish someone called me darling :(

[@justgottachanceit7534]

Usually say that when she yells "fuck off" or "go sick a dick"

[@fegeleinherman8587]

You guys got girlfriend?

[@Chris-yr6io]

Nobody: Uncle: “I got lumbago!”

[@huntertheassassin6065]

9:31 ABIGAIL 3 WTF John

[@Bigjosher_poo]

He owns a cloning factory so that he has an unlimited supply of women incase anything happens to his current wife.

[@shizar998]

@@Bigjosher_poo he destroy the machine once he accidentally created uncle 2 1:15

[@sixty-four]

@The Weird Whale that explains how he respawns when he dies

[@yvldusty]

Hunter The Assassin John marston side chick

[@Mr-Man2608]

Lmao

[@elynnorbragg272]

9:01 the first “Me. Never.” Joke ever told

[@Drelam]

10:10 strong foreshadowing for John in RDR, and the story of Arthur.

[@scaressell6880]

This videos fake stupid. Rockstar didint invent Arthur back then

[@a_not_so_amazingperson9900]

@@scaressell6880 dude what the fuck are you talking about

[@em-156]

I hope Rockstar make a mini-game, that the only thing you can do is to torture Micah and Dutch. I will buy it even if it will be 200$+

[@klutzycactusgaming1188]

Most likely Micah will be tortured the most

[@skrimp.]

Dutch is still a good man I forgive him now Micah he...he will never be forgived

[@vermark8719]

@@skrimp. he was, until he went batshit and shot up Blackwater (again) and killed that lady in cold blood in the federal building

[@erikallen3804]

Dutch wasn’t a bad guy. Micah turned him into one.

[@inshan3st3r]

Counterpoint: Dutch was a moderately bad man, Hosea made him a more noble one. Once Micah takes Hosea's place Dutch loses it.

[@Optykful]

2:20 "well we've seen it" I mustve wake up my neighbors, I laughed out loud at this LMAOOO He just took her at the teather to make her pleased but cant handle this shit anymore 😂😂😂

[@AesirUnlimited]

5:42 always brings me such sadness. This is the life John could’ve kept. The life that Arthur sacrificed everything for him to have, all to be ruined by John going for revenge. Agent Ross didn’t know that John Marston was still alive, John’s massacre of the Micah Bell gang left Ross without a big gang arrest. So he was forced to keep looking for some other big bust. If John just listened to Arthur, he could’ve kept his peaceful farm life.

[@drewp.johnson9834]

“Why you finally gonna drown yourself?” “In a manner of speaking I guess I am. Happily so.” 😂 this writing is killer

[@pabloenrikay]

I miss you Arthur Morgan. RIP my dude.

[@notmisterepicface4308]

6:16 That is a beautiful shot.

[@nathing03]

"Jesus, Uncle did you just fart" 😂😂😂

[@ChengTeoh]

Almost the best line! XD