Child Broke Clavicle, But Driver Wants Money for Mirror! | Part 1

Robin says 9-year-old Emy ran into her car during school pickup. Emy broke her clavicle, but Robin wants money for her broken mirror!
#JudgeJudy
The Original! There’s only ONE Judge Judy. Visit our website for where to watch, weekdays.
Subscribe to Judge Judy on KZbin: / @judgejudy

[@13lilfrogslvr]

I'd be upset about having to pay for my mirror, but being thankful the child wasn't hurt worse would outweigh me being upset.

[@brianna9687]

Cars are replaceable people are not. My father has always taught me that

[@TheNichq]

Who said shes not upset? That doesnt change the fact that the mirror is broken and it was the little girls fault. Her moms insurance should simply be paying for this.

[@beverlyarcher3744]

​@@brianna9687not the way stupid parents raise their brats but then again their always distracted and ignore their brats when they haven't made sure they had the right to move before crossing anywheres they get hit it should be automatic jaywalking

[@ErnestPiffel]

I’d be upset about my mirror too but gees… I’d just be thankful it wasn’t my kid who had been hit! That woman has som gall!

[@oldschool1993]

All this for a mirror??? She should find a mirror and take a long look at herself.

[@StrongnBeautiful]

😄 I like that 👌🏾

[@nigelT16]

1000%

[@Damechtia]

Maybe that's why she's suing for the mirror because that was the only mirror she had XD

[@gypsydeoriginal366]

Well said.

[@annameade8570]

Agree 100%😂

[@lanceplaxton6967]

A child's safety is more important than a broken mirror.

[@EricK-tb2dn]

Depends on the mirror.

[@Chobbie15]

@@EricK-tb2dn It could be the most expensive mirror on the planet, and it still wouldn't even be 0.1% as important as a childs safety.

[@nthgth]

The child's safety was already verified. After that, it was time to assess damage to the mirror.

[@EricK-tb2dn]

@@Chobbie15 Depends on the child.

[@egujugapupfh7543]

she still deserves to be payed back?

[@jjmah7]

I always love it when people on this show are like “I have video evidence!” Then the video is absolutely worthless 😂 cracks me up

[@ScottNapolitan]

I noticed that, too, the video showed no evidence. Plus, I posted a comment on Part 3 about something I'd put together in my head that doesn't make sense about the testimony. Like a mistake in a movie that goes against logic.

[@_stxrblazerr]

Nah fr

[@DonGrigorianFishing]

Seriously??? You're suing for a broken mirror on a beat up minivan when the kid ended up in the hospital? I know it wasn't the Plaintiffs fault but, sometimes you have to say thank God nobody died and move on...🤦‍♂

[@rainey2042]

I agree with you 100% those mirrors are cheap to replace a child not you only get one life

[@teelove2564]

EXACTLY!!

[@CanuckTony]

@@rainey2042 I know right? Poor girl. I would have just wrote it off vs being right and making mom pay for it. You may have hit her too! That’s even worse

[@rainey2042]

@@CanuckTony 100% definitely

[@trekgirl65]

Plaintiff was in a hurry and did not worry about the injured child, only about the broken mirror. Sad when this shady plaintiff is not worried about other children.

[@napoleon32]

"If you were going so slow, explain her broken clavicle." The plaintiff has not gotten off to a good start here...

[@trinity72gp]

🙈

[@HIpSPANIC]

She has a broken clavicle BECAUSE she was a moron running towards a car!!!!

[@HALee-]

The plaintiff could have explained that a clavicle is not a very strong bone. It’s not a weight bearing area. For that reason it doesn’t take much to break a clavicle. However, I doubt it would’ve helped her case very much.

[@jamsaidemelo1367]

I've broken my arm by running into a door as a child. They didn't have to go fast.

[@raimeyewens7518]

@@jamsaidemelo1367 I got a leg fracture playing red light, green light lol.

[@cathygretch7824]

I was stopped, completely, when a kid hit me on his bike. I was sobbing before I opened the door and made sure he was okay before I insisted on following him home and telling his parents what had happened, and gave them my name and number just in case. To his credit, the kid owned up immediately to his parents and everything was okay.

[@rebeccahicks2392]

yeah, it's not always a driver's fault---cars and kids don't mix. But you had the reaction of a normal decent human person. This lady didn't.

[@kaylag8335]

Yeah like a normal person with a heart. My kids babysitter literally texts me in a panic if they get hurt there, and the worst they’ve ever done is my oldest ran into her toddler playing tag and got a bloody nose, my 18’month old had just started walking and fell and bit through his lip and then my oldest busted his elbow outside Monday. You’d think they about died the way she texts me sobbing with them and snuggles them afterward. I can’t imagine worrying about a cheap ass mirror if I hit a kid with my car. A cheap mirror is much better than a literal kids life this woman is insane lol

[@beverlyarcher3744]

My dad hit a kid in the dark on a bike for some dumb reason he decided to go out in the dark on a bike dark clothing no helmet and no reflectors on bike by time dad knew kid was there was when kid hit his windshield kid knew he was in the wrong

[@beverlyarcher3744]

​@@kaylag8335oof I bit through my lip when I was 2 years old lost the tooth and it took years for it's replacement which I ended up having to go to speech class to learn how to speak with one tooth the th was my worse nightmare and I hated my last speech teacher she was harsher on me then the other kids every time she forgot when she kept saying speed up at that point I had more years of not saying th then I did having with it

[@Berighteousone]

@@beverlyarcher3744 You weren't very bright as a child

[@coolkid3844]

The nerve of that disgusting woman to put financial pressure on a family that is already paying thousands for that girls hospital bills. I hope she feels ashamed and embarrassed with herself.

[@joefriday1586]

You can't embarrass people like her.

[@coolkid3844]

@@joefriday1586 I can if it’s for the right reason. That woman should of looked where she was going

[@sarads7877]

How do you know she doesn’t have her own hospital bills to pay? We don’t know her story, or the story of her family. What if that woman is under financial pressure herself, and on top of that she now has to find money to pay for a mirror, even tho, if the events occurred as she described (and i believe they did), she is not at fault.

[@Cell287]

@@highcountrydelatite do you know right of way? Blaming the kid for thinking it’s safe isn’t a good troll. Pedestrians have the right of way.

[@coolkid3844]

@@highcountrydelatite I highly doubt it was her fault. Even if it was, you wouldn’t go demanding payment for your wrecked car from someone who just got run over.

[@chloee3529]

Unbelievable. I love how the audience is equally disgusted with her

[@fjccommish]

Exactly. The defendant is ridiculous. It isn't the driver's fault when a kid runs out into the street.

[@Juicetheeunuch]

I had to rewind to see if I heard that universal groan.

[@fjccommish]

@@Juicetheeunuch Yes. There should be a groan at the defendant for her attitude, and at the daughter for hers. She learned nothing.

[@kyoto32001]

@@fjccommish agreed

[@kyoto32001]

@@fjccommish yes!

[@_PAIGE94]

Aww his little wave was so cute

[@teria84]

Ikr 🤗

[@RuthLovesJesus]

Very cute ❤

[@ttheresa1023]

I am impressed with Emmy's mother for staying calm through this. I was getting frustrated and cannot imagine how upset she must have felt. Good on her for keeping her composure for her daughter and not escalating the situation even more.

[@Swnsasy]

The things people sue over is ridiculous.. This child broke a bone and she wants the hurt child to pay for the mirror that was broken by the child's body! Wow, just wow..

[@Transformers2Fan1]

Broke a bone in her *NECK*. It's not like she broke her wrist or her leg.

[@Swnsasy]

@@Transformers2Fan1 Huh??? I'm so lost at your comment

[@Transformers2Fan1]

@@Swnsasy I'll use small words, then: Neck bone if hurt = bad Leg bone if hurt = much less bad The clavicle is part of the neck. The neck is an incredibly vulnerable part of the body. This isn't some "oh noes I can't use my hand until my wrist heals!" bitch fest, this is a CHILD'S NECK.

[@SteampunkHorse]

She wants the hurt child’s mother to pay. But it’s still ridiculous.

[@missthang4982]

I just rolled my eyes so hard I think I saw my brain. JJ is gonna wipe the floor with this plaintiff. 🤣🤣

[@kentara_excelsior]

Wipe. The. Floor.

[@prophetmathis9436]

That's what keeps me watching. I like a good floor wiping. No ones does it like J.J.!

[@anitagu21]

I'm stealing the roll the eyes so hard😂😂😂

[@GrandmaLoves2Scuba]

😂😂😂

[@keianoire6631]

Just reading the title of this case, I was immediately disgusted by the plaintiff… I’ve had a couple of instances where children have run out in front of my car and it was terrifying. The only thing I’ve ever cared about is that they weren’t hurt. This plaintiff is heartless.☹️

[@TigerLily12345]

I read it and thought "I already hate her"

[@ScottNapolitan]

@@highcountrydelatite Just a thought, that was all.

[@beckiemoore8990]

This women is an idiot. Worrying about a stupid mirror that probably insurance would cover

[@ScottNapolitan]

@NathanTomago I stopped posting comments on this thing months ago, and I've put it behind me. I think I need to go down my history and delete all of them with only one exception, and that one is on part 3.

[@ScottNapolitan]

@NathanTomago Actually, never mind that, I'll tell you what. I'll just give this response to any more un-wished-for responses. I posted a comment on part 3 stating an error I noticed that basically gives away that this is staged anyway. (Going against logic.)

[@kencooper3481]

Wow. The stupidity of people suing over pennies is beyond shocking. "A child ran into my car and damaged my mirror." Never mind the child's injury -- this is beyond ridiculous.

[@JoltYourLife]

i bet she just wants to feel right. she hit a child. the narcissism some people walk around with creates scenarios like this.

[@colinremmer2417]

She sounds like a really caring, loving and considerate parent. I hope that her kids don't have an accident because she'd probably tell them to make their own way to the emergency room as they did it themselves

[@Kifflington]

Very telling that when the Judge asked her who the 'adorable boys' were she just replied, 'My boys' instead of their names. Not people, just 'these things belong to me'.

[@73cidalia]

@@KifflingtonI don’t like her, but you’re reading too much into that.

[@shaunwhitehead1485]

20 seconds in and I can already see those two boys are there to sway Judy’s mind

[@kirsty-anderson]

Judy begins with questioning the plaintiff, you automatically know it's not her case 😂

[@lordlossize]

bit of a dumb logic, considering most cases she starts with the plaintiff and they still win its when she starts with the defendant that there is usually trouble

[@MrCamp]

@@lordlossizenot always. She usually summarizes the claims before she starts questioning. When she jumps right into questioning and then reviews the claims, it’s a wrap

[@sherethadaniels473]

​@watering4879 Well, thank God she's in America.

[@taylercumings547]

I just love Judge Judy. The main thing I love about her is that she takes no crap from anyone, especially when it comes to people blaming or trying to sue children

[@kindram.9445]

Welcome to America. SUE HAPPY COUNTRY.

[@jroqueta9223]

She’s forever going to be “that parent.” 😂

[@colind7678]

Yes, there are no consequences for damaging other people's property.

[@daisysummer514]

@@colind7678sorry is a broken bone not consenquence enough? Did a pack of wolves raise you?

[@robbarber7253]

​@@colind7678 Imagine siding with this lunatic 😂 she literally flew through a school zone hit a hit causing hospitalization then sues for the mirror ffs

[@vajayna_eklhabouh]

0:03 The 8 year old is so adorable!!! Haha The way he waved his hand when Judge Judy acknowledged them! :D

[@kimberlys5266]

His mom coached him for hours!! Too bad Judge Judy don't care about that cute kid, just about the girl who ended up in the hospital.

[@truth4004]

@@kimberlys5266 The kids seemed innocent and nothing to do with their mom's mess.

[@preciouspayne723]

😂 these two adorable boys are so cute how old are they now

[@vajayna_eklhabouh]

​@@kimberlys5266 You said it yourself HAHAHA i would only care for the kid that ended up in the hospital too! Plus the cute kid's mom is a effing moron.

[@Ava0908]

Feel sorry for him for a having her for a mother.

[@Phyoomz]

Omg the first lil kid waving is the cutest thing I've seen on judge judy. 😂 😂 😂

[@coffeeaddictexpress5038]

They’re all adorable lol. So freaking innocent before puberty lol.

[@HankHill1]

they both look like mini band drummers or skateboarders haha

[@LoveByNicole]

I said awww when he started waving lol, he seemed like such a sweet child. Let's just hope his ignorant mom doesn't tarnish that

[@bbypeaxh33]

2:13😭 and his brother with his messy hair, so cute

[@smiley27b]

❤

[@littlelady.7vidhyavishal376]

Her concern is not if the child is ok, but she wants her mirror fix. Wow

[@aso3892]

As it should. She owes nothing to the kid??

[@sarads7877]

The child is clearly okay, she’s literally standing there

[@bigmacdaddy1234]

The mother didn't care about her own child so why should she?

[@JuMiMi86]

Who said she wasn't concerned? This is long after the accident...

[@j.k.asbill6131]

Unbelievable. Even if it was the little girl's fault, she's just a kid, and got badly hurt. The fact this woman wants a new mirror out of it is just sick.

[@thaphreak]

Right? who care about accountability and responsibility for the damages our kids do.

[@aso3892]

@@thaphreak No we care about the accountability and responsibility of the parent of the kid. If you don't show your kid to be careful, stuff like this might happen. As it did.

[@beverlyarcher3744]

Oh she's just a little girl? At that age I KNEW BETTER THEN TO RUN OUT IN FRONT OF A VEHICLE

[@catladynikki2024]

@@beverlyarcher3744you blame little child girl?! You must be one Karen woman.

[@catladynikki2024]

@@beverlyarcher3744Judge Judy are smart 🧠 brain than you. She knew what child are. You are not because you don’t know what child is.

[@Juicetheeunuch]

Even if the kid were 100 perfect at fault, if I were driving, I would run out, hug the child and thank God she wasn’t killed. I’d have a stern talking to the parents and the child and go home happy that my life didn’t fall apart in seconds.

[@williamxie771]

And then you would pay $350 to replace your mirror

[@Juicetheeunuch]

@@williamxie771 Absolutely not... I'd probably tape it up.

[@missbradicah]

The word is percent, not "perfect".

[@emirom2]

@@Juicetheeunuch Depending on the car, she probably could have even found one at a junk yard.

[@teresmajor6954]

@@williamxie771 It seems you care more about money than about a life. That child’s is more valuable than any amount you’d pay. Small price to pay for going ‘very very very slow’ and end up giving a child a broken clavicle. Our brains cells are there for a reason, let’s use them more often.

[@CJSmallz41]

The plaintiff is a true Karen!! She's more worried about her damn mirror than the lil girl

[@benjie128]

There was one JJ case where the defendant's daughter died, and the plaintiff was suing for a car wreck.

[@NYNC88]

The girl is okay, and she ran into the car.

[@vanessarickford6260]

​@@benjie128😮

[@andrealegg2527]

​@@benjie128 yeah I saw that episode, I was so disgusted with that woman. The other lady lost her daughter and that moron had the audacity to sue her. Her son survived with minor injuries and it happened on their own land.

[@alexisdominey6487]

​@@benjie128 Which episode was that.

[@brandylongan86]

Even the audience in the background gave side eye. 😂 This lady suing for her mirror is freaking ridiculous.

[@emilyme23455]

This is a perfect example of the lack of empathy so many people have .... more concerned over a mirror than a child's health

[@magentaglow1724]

How long has this child been attending this school?? I would think she should know the rules. How would she meet up with her mom if mom was picking her up??? ....and she was in a different area. Did mom tell her to meet her in a certain place so she wouldnt have to wait in the pick up lane. I've seen this happen.

[@ashotofwhiskey219]

Empathy is for the stupid.

[@Ava0908]

Lack of a lot more than empathy.m, decent humanity for starters.

[@rd24life]

@@magentaglow1724you are as evil as the suer

[@GamingChaosVibes]

I can't believe the plaintiff is suing them she should be gracious that she didn't hurt that little girl even more then she already had

[@DyNaStYCaRl]

She can't sue for damages and be glad the kid wasn't more hurt? Hmmm

[@pisto30]

@@DyNaStYCaRl She can but she shouldn't. It's a mirror. Pay the money and move on with your life.

[@kallahari7542]

@@pisto30 Agree

[@DyNaStYCaRl]

@@pisto30 would you say that if she didn't get hurt?

[@pisto30]

@@DyNaStYCaRl But she did, didn't she? And I would say the same thing either way. People are so lawsuit happy it's insane.

[@deana1938]

Remember, folks, when you're in a school zone, you must do your due diligence not to hit a child. If you do, don't expect a judge to side with you. It's probably not going to happen. School zones are meant to keep children safe, not your car.

[@Poppyseed0990]

Deana you’re making too much sense. The Karens can’t understand logic. 😅

[@sandlotkrew8778]

How do you prepare for a kid running into the side of your car ?!... Kids are reckless, and impulsive.

[@HIpSPANIC]

That little girl looks evil. She knew EXACTLY WHAT SHE DID. I’d sue as well

[@Poppyseed0990]

@@HIpSPANIC She looks nervous. Not evil.

[@richardrhineberger8891]

Long story short, I lived in a trailer park where kids were left unsupervised. They liked to hide and jump in front of cars as they entered the park. A gentlemen swerved to avoid the one, and went right into her sister as she jumped from a tree. Kids gone, the young driver scarred for life. Some times, it is the kids.

[@starlightequestrian6729]

This woman is proof that people will always believe that there must always be someone at fault. Sometimes, accidents happen. Why most there always be a fault?

[@voltage6405]

Even if the defendant offered to pay for the mirror I think most of us would say don’t worry about it, things happen. The child’s well-being is way more important

[@agapereign]

Unbelievable. I wouldn’t dare sue for that!!! OAN: all three of the kids are adorable.

[@bedroomkandibytre2993]

No way would I sue for this. I would be so happy if wasn't more serious. Thank God she is alive.

[@Sook995]

Due😂😂😂😂😂

[@bedroomkandibytre2993]

@@Sook995 sorry was typing and working

[@BMarie774]

The mom holding the daughters hand, stroking it to comfort her is so cute. My god, I can’t imagine being this damn sue crazy. I’d just be so thankful that child is okay. It’s a damn mirror. Their family just had way more trauma in their life, why make it worse?

[@At_the_races]

I can’t believe the pettiness of this woman she must really be desperate for money.

[@futureguy7281]

Fix your own mirror she's a child and she even hurt herself very badly. This lady is outrageous

[@thaphreak]

OK! I'm gonna teach my kid to ride a bike, but only beside YOUR car.

[@peteryanes3413]

She a kearn that why

[@nthgth]

I agree. A kid can do as much damage as they want to my stuff as long as they also hurt themself in the process. This is a viable and sustainable setup.

[@robbarber7253]

​@@thaphreakShe wasn't on a bike did you even watch the video 🤦 wtf

[@Juicetheeunuch]

As a person who has picked up kids after school and been irresponsible and impatient, I guarantee you she just wanted to get the hell out of there and was frustrated with slow cars. We have all been there. We need to be more careful…and…uh…not squeeze money out of the family we almost ruined.

[@SoloLeaux]

100% !!!! I am the oldest of 8 siblings, have driving anxiety and am always frustrated with being in that traffic, all the people walking by, the buses it can be overwhelming! But I can’t imagine hitting a kid and then demanding money from their family!!! I would feel so bad, I’m not sure I would ever want to drive again!

[@Lauren-vd4qe]

not at all, the kid hit the SIDE of the car, was NOT hit by the FRONT of the car

[@fashiondiva6972]

@@Lauren-vd4qe that you, Karen?🙄 I hate to break it to you but the laws of motion and physics don’t support your version of reality. The story would be “Child hurls herself at side of barely moving car” resulting in severe injuries. I’ve litigated more than a few vehicular homicides in my 26 years in practice as an attorney and judge and to get on board with your little narrative requires suspending both intelligence and common sense.

[@SteampunkHorse]

@@Lauren-vd4qeeven so, why make so much fuss about it? Children are young. They do dumb shit. They learn their lessons. The girl went to hospital with a broken bone n had to get stitches. Even though the fault was with her, she’s a dang child!

[@amberjohnson4820]

The plaintiff is HORRIBLE! 😡My heart goes out to the defendant’s family.

[@jjmah7]

What do you mean? Defendants are fine now.

[@justanotherviewer7117]

And the plaintiff's family. Her kids are stuck with a mother who is basically a walking pile of cow dung! 💩

[@caro-zw1vb]

I love when Judy says "shhh" lmao

[@julissaarredondo6444]

Saying “very very slow” a hundred times let’s me know she wants us to believe that knowing she wasn’t

[@jeannethompson4048]

Yup

[@MikeB-Android-Teacher]

I really don't believe she was going slow. No way she caused all that damage going just 2mph i doubt it unless that little girl is capable of running at 10mph or something..

[@ThomasFerrugia]

You all realize that the fact that the kid got hurt by running out into the street and smashing into the woman's car is totally irrelevant? So would she be responsible if she hadn't gotten hurt?

[@ScottNapolitan]

I like the way JJ kicked the whole thing off with a compliment.

[@dginn7640]

Is this woman completed stupid? Who in their right mind sues for a broken mirror when a child is/was injured??? SMH

[@blondegiraffe2023]

If it was the child's fault why should she pay for damages?

[@robbarber7253]

​@@blondegiraffe2023The fault was clearly split. If a toddler runs into a car from the side that would fold the mirror in at best it would certainly not have enough force to completely dismount the mirror and hospitalize the child. The lady MUSTVE been going way too fast.

[@yikesyikes5974]

Poor taste to sue this child’s mother

[@thaphreak]

Poor taste for the mother to refuse to pay for the damages her kid incurred, it's poor taste to vilify a victim because the damages was done by a child. Imagine using your child as a shield from financial responsibility, 100% mom of the year. smh My parents had to paid for my f***ups, even when I got injured in the process. Accidents happen, that doesn't mean parents are not liable.

[@aso3892]

@@thaphreak THANK YOU

[@satsumamoon]

The girls mother should have offered to get her a new mirror and she should not be in this position of having to sue. Legally the girl s mother is liable, or is that not the case in this state?

[@aso3892]

THANK YOU

[@thewoolverine4420]

Thank god that baby is ok. All I have to say about this is I hope she gets treated with the same amount of grace and mercy as she’s shown that poor baby girl. Not only is she a monster, she felt so confident in her “rightness” she brought her babies to witness and learn how to be a monster too

[@TT.x8]

Tyler’s little wave 🥺 so sweet!

[@user-qo8ko5sx3e]

Point?

[@gtfoh1802]

Im so glad that baby girl is doing better 🤗 Those 3 children are so adorable and cute💜💙💚 Hopefully the plaintiffs humble themselves enough to not allow greed and non compassion take over…🙏🏾

[@dinahbrown902]

That little girl is learning how some of her fellow humans are, best to learn young. Glad she’s physically okay

[@blaqueathena]

JJ’s slow blink sent me😂😂😂

[@damascus9876]

Lmao everyone’s faces in the background. I’m glad everyone else in the courtroom had common sense. I feel bad for her kids.

[@purgatoriprytania5382]

She'd have to be in the top 5 most ridiculous plaintiffs of all time.

[@trinity72gp]

Oh my days the Plaintiff is doomed 🙈

[@deana1938]

Yes, she is. Here's what I want to know: What on God's green earth made her think she could hit a child in a school zone and then sue because her mirror was damaged? Doesn't she realize school zones are meant for children to be safe, not your car? The audacity!

[@bobsburgers8497]

You gotta be another kind of dumb to try and sue the parent of a child that got hit by your car🤦‍♀️ Something’s wrong with her

[@monicavillarreal3902]

@@deana1938 But the child didn't use the crosswalk. She batted out and ran into the street. Either way I wouldn't sue if she did this to my mirror. But I would defend myself if they are blaming her for hitting the child.

[@immealldayeveryday9425]

It’s just the side mirror like is she serious, some things you just let it go and thank god everyone was ok

[@deana1938]

@monicavillarreal3902 She's 9, and kids are stupid. They do stuff like that, and it's why adults have to look out for them. And when I say stupid, I don't mean it derogatory. I mean, they do stupid stuff.

[@lucyb7929]

OMG I can't imagine suing over a broken mirror when a child suffered as SHE DID with a broken clavicle. Try your car insurance and see if they won't get a NEW mirror for you without dragging a child into court!

[@TheGreekPianist]

I love how Judge Judy just stares at her at 1:36 😠 the ridiculousness of the situation. How dare she

[@lr1967]

Why I thought the video was about the accident and have the nerve to ask for new mirrors, that lady has the audacity !

[@ajfoodiesaiyan]

The plaintiff is the epitome of a Karen in every single regard. 🤦🏼‍♂️

[@annakenny2213]

She's definitely an entitled person with a mostly bad story. However, Emmy should've known better than to run out onto the street like that.

[@robbarber7253]

​@@annakenny2213Combined fault but she was clearly going way too fast

[@1996jacksparrow]

A broken collarbone outweighs a broken mirror, that lady is crazy.

[@mc-rn8ro]

1:55 I will bet MONEY that that guard was screaming at the driver, not the little girl; because yeah, like Judy Justice said, if she was driving so slowly then how did the little girl get so hurt she required hospitalization? Unless the little tike has super speed. Also lol @ the little girl's face "oh, so we're telling lies now?!"

[@ScottNapolitan]

Hmm, okay, here's a thought. Not to be rude now, just honest, but you can tell the crossing guard is probably in his sixties or something, and the plaintiff is young enough to have 8 yo twins, thus maybe the crossing guard is the plaintiff's father, a fact that they are withholding, and perhaps that is why he is protecting her. Just a thought.🤷‍♂ (Robin Misonznick-Brook?)

[@NOCALGooN916]

Apparently, she was going very, very, very, very slow! 😂😂

[@onyeomachinyeremaka6809]

*May this Month take you to a place of freedom where dreams come true. Happy New Month reading this and May GOD bless you.*

[@ericheine2414]

I love Judge Judy. "if you were going slow explain the broken clavicle?" - and then "This high-speed little girl came out of nowhere and broke my mirror."

[@JAZZnMOTION]

Yo idk what’s up with these comments that’s little girl getting hurt was the consequences of her own actions and so it laying for the mirror … like I’m sorry your kid got her but she still caused damage. This is why I can’t stand Judge Judy she makes her verdict before they even tell her what happened because “she’s been doing this for so long” Like maybe she needs to step down as she not even listening to the evidence which is the whole point of going to court

[@zkarebear]

Oh my GOsH I am a minute and a half in. I cannot imagine, I don’t care if everything happened exactly as the plaintiff says, I cannot conceive of asking for money for a mirror, I would be on my knees thanking God that the girl wasn’t more severely injured

[@SurahOnline]

*The little boy waving at JJ 😅😂 lol*

[@kylewilson2819]

I’ve gotten into a few fender benders with fellow adults, and the first question everyone has always asked is “Are you ok?”. We can work out responsibility and repairs later, but someone’s health takes priority. I can’t imagine hitting a child, causing such a severe injury like a broken clavicle, and being concerned about a broken mirror. Just shameful behavior

[@NexForemose]

The look on that girl's face when the lady accused her of not listening to the crossing guard...poor kiddo. Also, lady sounds slightly slurred too.

[@lordlossize]

im honestly surprised JJ allowed the plaintiffs kids to stay in the room, she usually has them taken out before she rips their parents a new hole.

[@Transformers2Fan1]

Maybe hoping they will see how crazy their mom is and not turn out like her.

[@billbunnel9884]

Just maybe JJ want the boys to see how nasty there mother is

[@thebigorangecouch6261]

This is ridiculous!!! That mother might have two kids to melt the heart but she's setting a crap example for them when it comes to taking responsibility for your actions.

[@holyexperience1976]

Youth need examples more so than rules. Yes, they need rules and stability, but they need to not watch the adults practicing hypocrisy. When they become adults, they'll remember the behavior of parents/guardians more than the rules and consequences.

[@sarads7877]

I’m sorry but if the kid rammed into her car, the responsibility is not hers

[@bigmacdaddy1234]

Um,... no. The mother is giving her children a real life example that parents need to be held accountable for their child's stupid actions. The bigger concern now is why you didn't see this for yourself.

[@allyivy1784]

The child ran into the car, not cars fault. As far as suing for a mirror, I can understand that as well, an unexpected $600 bill can be hard and most times insurance doesn’t cover until damage is at least $1000.

[@RogueT-Rex8468]

I’m so upset that that poor woman didn’t get her poor irreplaceable car mirror paid for. Omg the long sleepless nights knowing her vehicle will never be the same again 🙄🙄🙄 Seriously. I swear Judy was inwardly wondering how tf they even got that far into the courtroom with the premise of that case. I mean- sheesh.

[@melissachatwin9673]

Are there really people like this in the community?! Who in their right mind would care about a mirror on their car after hitting a child? In my mind you would say, "thank good the child wasn't seriously hurt, a mirror is insignificant."

[@aprilmccain3632]

SMH this is ridiculous!!! She automatically lost this case when the judge said the child was is the hospital.

[@mariafox9226]

To have that amount of damage to your car and to a kid, you HAD to have been speeding in the school zone.

[@metaphoricheart]

As someone who got hit by a car when I was a pedestrian and almost died from the injuries....I just want to point out that it's not just about the injuries. I'm traumatized and that little girl is also traumatized. It does a lot of emotional and mental damage.

[@trinity72gp]

Lunch crew😂

[@markbrandon7359]

who doesn't teach their kids not to run out in the street? or watch where their going how do you run into a car?

[@zariaeda007]

Kids are kids. You tell them not to do a lot of things but that doesn't mean they'll listen.

[@joywebster2678]

Kids are impulsive, with poor judgement. So they may know the rules but heybthere us mom saying hurry we have to go,...a d so she darts out not remembering her rules.

[@shendisackett]

​@@joywebster2678 exactly she probably got excited she saw her Mum or a friend, she's a child. I cannot believe this woman is suing.

[@ScottNapolitan]

@@shendisackett Exactly, and I think that's why her mother should have taken a different and safer approach to picking her up. Maybe looked for a reasonable place to park her car, then just gotten out and walked over to get her daughter instead of being lazy and expecting her daughter to go across the road to her.

[@blueyes6474]

Being this petty should be a crime in itself

[@zedmarlen]

While technically it might be true that the girl ran into the plaintiff's car (as opposed to the car hitting the kid), it is still wrong for the driver to sue for her broken mirror.

[@kimberlys5266]

I have a comment that you may want to read. Lady had to be speeding...

[@aso3892]

@@kimberlys5266 Not true.

[@davidcaruso2517]

Audience members shaking their heads just like the rest of us.

[@kentara_excelsior]

😂

[@viniciuslima9430]

The audacity of the plaintiff is making me choke with my lunch. 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅 Still thank you the channel for posting it.

[@dingdongfootball5331]

This is literally that episode of home movies where brendon gets hit by a car on his bike and the car owners sue him 😂

[@annhedges4243]

Absolutely heartless.. She should have been more concerned that the child was hurt than worried about a broken mirror.

[@frenchgirl75000]

La mère pense juste à la vitre de sa voiture 🤦🏿‍♀️

[@supalognon]

Rétroviseur, plutôt 😅

[@frenchgirl75000]

@@supalognon encore pire Elle vient pour un rétro c'est pathétique

[@myroom4640]

What an ordeal !!!! There’s NO WAY I’d be suing someone for small change , nor for ANY money at all to be honest , the woman should just be grateful that precious little girl is ok. 😡😡😡😡😡

[@rocknrolljunkie1000]

i love when judy shushes people who obviously have never been told no before XD

[@samanthacrump1976]

If the child really did run into her car and broke the mirror her parents should pay for a new mirror and hopefully her daughter learned her lesson. To replace anything on a car is ridiculously expensive. Also schools have crossing guards, lights, painted lines on the road. So for this little girl ran into her car it’s because she wasn’t paying attention. I have a little boy that thinks it’s ok to run in the street, he’s told at least 2 times a day to stop and look both ways. If he neglects to heed our warning and runs into the street it’s his fault and our fault because he’s our son. I’m so blessed and grateful that he’s never been hurt but it will probably happen to him someday if he doesn’t learn.

[@Neptune5667]

If you look closely at the little girl and her mom, you can see her holding her moms hand. Poor baby.

[@nikkicole3331]

This is so outrageous! Americans values have so deteriorated. When this kind of thing happened when I was a kid the parents would have been worried about THE CHILD GETTING HURT instead of a stupid mirror. No one likes "old-fashioned values" but we need them.

[@mariusfacktor3597]

Children don't break their own clavicle from their own body mass going at running speed. The plaintiff definitely hit the girl with her car. She should get her license revoked and go to jail.

[@Ava0908]

Good lord wtf is wrong with people. Lady, you’re a real piece of work.

[@667mumble]

Plaintiff has a lot of nerve suing the defendant after hitting their child

[@joyaustin6581]

So she should pay all fees associated with the child and parents being negligent?

[@Lauren-vd4qe]

the plaintiff DIDNT hit the child, the CHILD HIT the side of her CAR

[@667mumble]

@@joyaustin6581 defendant's kid should have been more careful when running out in the street

[@667mumble]

@@Lauren-vd4qe lol 🤣🤣🤣

[@Lauren-vd4qe]

@@667mumble kid should NOT have run out into the street.

[@Lave_cake]

Some people have zero shame like just despicable human beings it's scary to think that plaintiff is a mother .

[@nicoladavis580]

Is this woman for real? she took a mother to court to replace her mirror after a child was hurt. Even if the child ran into your vehicle mam that's just wrong on every level. What? this is crazy.

[@megalopolis2015]

That child must have been speeding pretty fast to have broken this poor woman's mirror. *EYE ROLL*

[@suelopez2704]

I was playing cartoon freeze tag at my aunts house when I was about the same age, and ran into her parked car mirror in the driveway, and it didn't break. Newtons law! You would've had to be going at least 20 to get the result if your mirror breaking, and her clavical fractured. Stop lying!

[@dulcequintanar3488]

20 mph is slow, that’s actually the correct speed limit for school zones.

[@hondaqueen21]

This woman is a monster 😢

[@marocaina]

She can’t blame the kid, she is just a kid

[@sakilynn]

That little girl's face said it all: woman was lying.