Do Sikhs Really Want Independence? And Lives Of Ethnic Koreans From Central Asia | CNA Correspondent

  Рет қаралды 44,820

CNA Insider

CNA Insider

Күн бұрын

An ethnic minority that is feeling the draw of home from a land they have only heard of but have never seen. A people with a common faith that are divided on their vision of the future. In a world of divisions, ‘us’ and ‘them’ exist not only between nations, but also within a community and a country’s borders. CNA Correspondent visits two unique communities to explore the parts that make our identities whole.
00:00 Introduction
00:47 Canadian Sikh leader's killing still felt across the world in India
05:56 Sikh community divided on idea of Sikh state of Khalistan
11:16 Ethnic Korean community living in Central Asia
17:35 Koryo Saram migrate from Central Asia back to South Korea
=================
About CNA Correspondent: Highlights of news stories and features by CNA's network of Correspondents based in major cities across the region.
=================
#CNAInsider #CNACorrespondent #Sikh #Canada #CentralAsia #SouthKorea
For more, SUBSCRIBE to CNA INSIDER
cna.asia/insideryoutubesub
Follow CNA INSIDER on:
Instagram: / cnainsider
Facebook: / cnainsider
Website: cna.asia/cnainsider

Пікірлер: 448
@BHARATIYA_TIGER
@BHARATIYA_TIGER 7 ай бұрын
I'm Sikh i also hate what happens in 80s or 90s but what does that have to do with current Government? people are still supporting the government that did that horrible things.
@Idontexist-tg7gs
@Idontexist-tg7gs 7 ай бұрын
and they support sidhu moosewala who contested elections on Congress ticket.
@truthspeaker-qi6ku
@truthspeaker-qi6ku 7 ай бұрын
Sikhism is a harami community, snakes are breading in india
@user-miko777
@user-miko777 4 ай бұрын
Hello ?? have you forgotten farmers protest aka new age sikh genocide ??? where was your current gov then ??? shame on you for being a sikh that doesn't take stand . Yk these were the same ppl who called even the farmers khalistani . They feed your country cmon
@ParminderSingh-ft3cc
@ParminderSingh-ft3cc 2 ай бұрын
It has very little to do with parties. It was a Sikh genocide carried out by Hindus.
@manikaur3277
@manikaur3277 7 ай бұрын
I am a Sikh from India Punjab. These radicalized Khalistanis do not represent us Sikhs. India/Bharat is our motherland and we will protect her from these extremists. These people don’t know a thing about Sikhism just because they have long beards and wear pagg doesn’t mean they are Sikhs of guru Nanak so please stop calling these terrorists Sikhs activists. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
@SeptonFi
@SeptonFi 7 ай бұрын
They are ISI funded agents. We do not see regular Sikhs as Khalistanis and respect the true Khalsa followers. You are the descendants of our first sons who joined the Gurus in their war against the Mughals. There is no way we will ever let them divide us xD. Jinko jaada khujli hai, unka treatment sidhe Canada mein karenge. Sikhs are our brothers and sisters. We have defended each other since hundreds of years, and they think that they can divide us with a few shitty PR videos and through influence agents from a particular country which is always kept running through aid, loans, begging and drug money.
@manikaur3277
@manikaur3277 7 ай бұрын
@@SeptonFi thanks brother. Means alot ❤️
@moonlightrathore
@moonlightrathore 7 ай бұрын
Even Pakistan has Sikh population and guess where this radicalisation is getting it's supply from
@Truth-Sikher
@Truth-Sikher 7 ай бұрын
@@manikaur3277another fake Sikh account 😂
@Truth-Sikher
@Truth-Sikher 7 ай бұрын
@@moonlightrathoreremember that Hindus are famous for being the best scammers 😂
@Meghnaaad
@Meghnaaad 7 ай бұрын
India had Sikh Army General, Prime Minister and president, I don't think people who suffer persecution can even think of getting to the top posts. Its evident that Sikhs are flourishing in India, and not just them, people of all religions.
@harpreetsinghmann
@harpreetsinghmann 7 ай бұрын
Jews were prosperous too, until genocide!
@rmot2911
@rmot2911 7 ай бұрын
@@harpreetsinghmann Jews Worldwide are the World's Richest and Amongst the Most Technologically Advanced who face challenges within Middle East where Now the World is Divided with their Opinions on Them. Punjabi Sikhs Especially from Outside India who Want a Separate Nation are Neither the World's Richest Nor Amongst the Most Technologically Advanced
@manvirsv
@manvirsv 7 ай бұрын
Sikhs were also genocided in India, by the government.
@WanglembaElangbam-xj7yl
@WanglembaElangbam-xj7yl 7 ай бұрын
Except for the racial minorities of North East India
@Meghnaaad
@Meghnaaad 7 ай бұрын
@@WanglembaElangbam-xj7yl That region is not well connected. Bit I think thinks are improving, don't you think so?
@RationalismIsFuture
@RationalismIsFuture 7 ай бұрын
Sikh are one of the richest community. Major contributor to defence, and economy None of hindu think sikh as separatist or terrorist I agree that what happened to sikhs in 90s and 80s is horrific and totally wrong. And justice should be given
@RR-wp8jt
@RR-wp8jt 7 ай бұрын
Then What about what happened to Panjabi Hindus during that time Khalistanion ki tatte chaat te raho
@user-uf6wc2zf6r
@user-uf6wc2zf6r 7 ай бұрын
what does terrorist word have anything to do here?
@YoutubeMusic-in9xz
@YoutubeMusic-in9xz 7 ай бұрын
Thanks 🙏🏽 Keishnavani
@harpreetsinghmann
@harpreetsinghmann 7 ай бұрын
and when will that happen?i thought you had laws, democracy?
@daniyalbbd5281
@daniyalbbd5281 7 ай бұрын
​@@harpreetsinghmannwhat does the current government has to do with that ? I am an Indian Muslim here but even I understand the reality
@ratnakamal1
@ratnakamal1 7 ай бұрын
Pannu’s argument that until 1849 there was an independent Sikh kingdom when it was annexed by the British is rather self-serving. There were independent kingdoms of Travencore and Cochin, Mysore, Jaipur, and many other kingdoms. To justify restoration of something back to what it was more than 175 years doesn’t make sense. May be, it would be a good idea to establish an independent Sikh State in BC, Canada.
@_GMP_
@_GMP_ 7 ай бұрын
Yes there were 100 s of separate kingdoms inside so according to that idiot India should not exist all 100 kingdoms should become independent countries . And from the top 5 in the Economy & Military to 100 th when the country gets divided
@AshleyKanda-kc5mn
@AshleyKanda-kc5mn 7 ай бұрын
It was not a Sikh Kingdom. Ranjit Singh had Hindu and Muslim wives and the rule only lasted about 40 years. Gurdwaras were run by Hindus at the time and had Idols etc within them. Sikhism as we know it only started in 1945.
@_GMP_
@_GMP_ 7 ай бұрын
@@AshleyKanda-kc5mn started in 1945 how ? explain it
@AshleyKanda-kc5mn
@AshleyKanda-kc5mn 7 ай бұрын
@@_GMP_ Read some history.
@newvivo4613
@newvivo4613 6 ай бұрын
I am Punjabi Hindu from Punjab and Believe me Punjab is more danger for Punjabi Hindus than The Movie Kashmir Files Show. People in other states due to lack of cultural exchange think Jaat, Sindhi and Sikh are same as Punjabi Hindus.. But let me tell them Because of their Bad Image they call own self as Punjabi but actually they use our Hindu Language of Punjabi. Do you know even in Sikh Religion only Hindu served the Gurus on Last day and Battle Fields.. All Panj Pyaare (5 Disciples of Gurus that are awarded as Preacher of Guru Knowledge are also not know Gurumukhi because they are Hindus) Sikhs initially have 5 different communities Rehdasi, Kabira, Sevak, Kshatriya and Bhakti.. But now fake sikh history only teach about 10 Gurus. Radhaswami are also sikh but they are not violent and narrow minded like khalistani. Muslims are more Good than back Stabbing Sikh. Sikh are actually communist meaning kill and rull others. I am Hindu and I feel Indians are not safe with Sikh Community narrow thinking of killing and ruling others. Sikh community always shows Muslims as Bad but they are more Danger for Akhand Bhārat (India + Pakistan) than Muslims. According to Guru Nanak Dev Universities professors who are also Sikh.. Sikh have already killed 100 times more Hindu than they Claim their Guru have saved even before Sikh Riots of 1984 or Khalistan Movement of 1970s. See Many Children, Young and Old die daily in India for Protection of Community for Communism/Hate Violence of Control in the name of Maaowaadi and Naxalism.. but not all Become Guru Like them.. and self worship! They are just product of thinking Kill others and Rule.. and I(Sikh) am Good because other is Bad. They Now take biggest advantage of Reservation by Showing self as fake disadvantaged. They now Consider Gurudwara Prabandak Committee bigger than their Own Gurus teachings. They feel shame on Krishna based names of their Guru. They had broken Hindus statutes in Hari Mandir of Amritsar.. because they thought 🤔 that they're more intelligent than dumb Gurus who worship Gods of All Religion. Maratha Empire saved whole India without any ego. That's a Hindu.
@rmot2911
@rmot2911 7 ай бұрын
For those Indians and Pakistanis who have left India and Pakistan, you have NO RIGHTS TO DEMAND FOR A SEPARATE NATION out of India and Pakistan as YOU GAVE UP YOUR CITIZENSHIP ESPECIALLY INDIA'S. If anyone including SIKHS WANT LAND, ask your new countries - THAT INCLUDES CANADA which is DONG WORSE THAN AUSTRALIA where Australia has the Highest Median Wealth in the World followed by Belgium and then New Zealand (Yes, Australia is now facing challenges as Australia Too Depended on China a Lot But Australia is CLOSER to ASIA where 21st Century Economic Growth and Power Challenges have been. Canada hasn't had a Good Prime Minister UNLIKE Australia though in recent times, it's New Zealand that has had a good leader whose name starts with 'J'. For a country that is the World's 2nd Largest by area, maybe Canada should sell off part of its land which it doesn't use well to the Sikhs whom many Canadians, Britishers and others support for wanting a separate region).
@Kevin-fq3zh
@Kevin-fq3zh 7 ай бұрын
cope
@rmot2911
@rmot2911 7 ай бұрын
@@Kevin-fq3zh What am I supposed to cope on? When I see the World who fights based on Religions, Linguistics/Languages, Other Cultural Values, I feel So Grateful and Thankful I come from a Family of Whites, Blacks and Browns who are Oriental Christians, Orthodox Christians, Protestant Christians, Catholic Christians with Some Sikhs, Some Hindus, Some Muslims, Some Atheists, Some Agnostics etc with Citizenship of USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, India, Singapore, Malaysia, Jordan, Oman, UAE, South Africa, Norway, Denmark, UK etc through Family Spreading Worldwide in Last 100 Years where Intercultural, Interracial and Interreligious Marriages happened where we Cousins, Uncles, Aunts, Granduncles etc are Descendants of Aristocratic Families including where 1 of those family members married a Princess of a Royal Family - VERY GRATEFUL and THANKFUL that DESPITE DIFFERENCES, WE LIVE WITH LOVE including FORGIVENESS. Fact Also of Today is India has the World's 2nd Largest Number of Middle Middle Class People, Upper Middle Class People and Rich of 200 to 300 Million who live Worldwide (China Leads with 500 to 600 Million of Middle Middle Class, Upper Middle Class and Rich who live Worldwide while Pakistan got thrashed by Bangladesh too in South Asia). Heard of the Vice President of USA/America? Her name is Kamala Harris who has an Indian Background through HER MOTHER. Heard of American Tech CEOs who have Indian Background and are linked back to India too? Heard of ex-Pepsi CEO Indra Nooyi who has Indian Background again? Doesn't end there as it goes on in USA including the 2024 Republican Candidates too. UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak whose wife is a Non-Residential Indian and the daughter of Billionaire Founder of Infosys, Narayana Murthy, well he has Indian Background through his parents. There are couple more World Leaders including from Europe that have had or who still are with Indian background including Portugal, Malaysia and so on. Current Chanel's CEO Leena Nair herself has Indian Background and she is the Mentee of Indra Nooyi. 1 of Australia’s Top 15 Richest Persons is Vivek Sehgal with Indian Background while Melanie Perkins, the Co-founder of Canva is another Top 15th Richest Australian whose father has Malaysian Background with Both Sri Lankan and Filipino Heritage. And it goes on for Indian Middle Middle Class, Upper Middle Class and Rich whose Stronghold has been USA FOLLOWED BY UK though they are Citizens of Other Nations Too. Chinese Stronghold is in SOUTHEAST ASIA/ASEAN COUNTRIES - Richest Singaporeans, Indonesians, Malaysians, Filipinos etc are CHINESE followed by WESTERN BACKGROUND including Spanish Filipinos and INDIAN MONEY-LENDERS including Indian Money-Lender Filipinos. The Richest in the World is a person with South African background and Not Just Pure White-Elon Musk. But the Asian Americans starting with Asian Indian Americans followed by Filipino Americans, Vietnamese Americans, Chinese Americans, Japanese Americans, South Korean Americans, Pakistani Americans etc are challenging the Whites including Latinos for (1) Median Wealth, (2) Higher Standards of Living, (3) Less Broken Marriages and Relationships (There are Global Research and Studies even by Harvard University and other US Universities showing the Correlation between Broken Marriages and Relationships to Single Moms and Correlation between Single Moms to Poverty as Very Few Single Moms Worldwide succeed-Philippines is 1 exception to an Asian Country that has High % of Single Moms including Single Teen Moms where Poverty is High too while South Korea though rising with Single Parenting has Lower Poverty Issues related to Single Moms), (4) Better Education and Skills where Many of the Whites Especially Latinos and Hispanics face Poverty though yes some of the Latinos are European Jews where some of them do well in USA just like some of the Asian Jews who too do well in America as Judaism started from Middle East of Asia where Jews are Asians, Europeans, etc.
@chocolatemilkshake9168
@chocolatemilkshake9168 7 ай бұрын
Fair enough ... Probably they are doing this to keep funds coming in
@wazukyan7696
@wazukyan7696 7 ай бұрын
So those living in India can demand for a separate county! But some have died doing that
@rmot2911
@rmot2911 7 ай бұрын
@@wazukyan7696 When? About 76 years ago. Ones inside India DON'T WANT A SEPARATE COUNTRY where SEPARATE STATES have COME ABOUT TOO like Jharkhand, Telangana, Chhattisgarh, etc. It's only Pakistanis who have been thrashed by Bangladeshis too for Human and Economic Development that still tries so desperately to get Indian land and have messed themselves up where Pakistan is Currently 1 of the Worst Asian Nations
@unknownperson8541
@unknownperson8541 7 ай бұрын
Operation Blue Star was a mistake almost every Indian politician believes that especially the current BJP government every security personnel believes that it was caused by Indra Gandhi's arrogance but I don't think she hated the Sikh community because She trusted them with her life 😐😐😐
@truthspeaker-qi6ku
@truthspeaker-qi6ku 7 ай бұрын
Nope it was right, following Bhindrawla and killing innocent Hindus was wrong
@fullaranag
@fullaranag 6 ай бұрын
​@@truthspeaker-qi6kunot a congress supporter. But what else could have been done given that the temple had been turned into a fortress.
@user-miko777
@user-miko777 4 ай бұрын
Obviously . they'll do thw same thing. We have already seen what all these hindus can do when a pm died lmao . if it was for a temple these hypocrite p1gs would've done alot worse@@fullaranag
@shubham7419
@shubham7419 7 ай бұрын
Proud on Indian sikhs......99.99% sikhs are true Indian..... these 0.01% doesn't represent the whole community......in every religion such seperatist elements exist......
@R_t-99
@R_t-99 7 ай бұрын
As a Bengali indian i have immense respect for sikh people and their culture. They have significant contribution for india and they are part of our past and present and hopefully future. I really wish all the problems ends❤️
@Devilishlybenevolent
@Devilishlybenevolent 4 ай бұрын
I've always admire Sikhs, I hope they get their own country soon 🙏
@sanjeevp
@sanjeevp 7 ай бұрын
Do you wonder why the Khalistani movement is almost nonexistent in India but exists only in countries like Canada, UK, and Australia? It is basically an immigration/human trafficking scandal. Nobody has published any figures on how many people have been granted asylum in these countries based on Khalistan persecution. I think somebody needs to dwell on this aspect in detail and publish all the statistics. Hopefully, in a few years, they will ask Khalistan to be carved out in Canada!
@krantsharma8455
@krantsharma8455 6 ай бұрын
It is non existent because it was violently stopped, read about the fake encounters that happened in Punjab when 10000+ Sikh youths were killed
@Devilishlybenevolent
@Devilishlybenevolent 4 ай бұрын
Did you just watch the video? It exist but is hush hush since the state is hindu nationalists who are actively oppressing Muslims and Sikhs. Why WOULD they be open about it? Its funny how Indians rail against Khalistan but you guys supporting Tibetians with the EXACT SAME ISSUE they have with China.
@ramaliya197
@ramaliya197 7 ай бұрын
If SJF want Khalistan and going back to original Punjab Kingdom, start with Lahore and Pakistan Punjab...afterall ,that was the largest part of Punjab. But not a whisper on that..
@SeptonFi
@SeptonFi 7 ай бұрын
Pata hai na, Pakistani army inki maa chod degi jaise 1947 mein pure Pakistani Punjab mein dauda dauda ke maara tha. 😂
@UtkarshOjha-rr7xz
@UtkarshOjha-rr7xz 7 ай бұрын
FOAL, there is no literally NO separatist movement in India! And it's the terror coming from Canada that concerns us
@Devilishlybenevolent
@Devilishlybenevolent 4 ай бұрын
What terror? Would you like it if China called Indians terrorist supporters for supporting Tibetans? NO? It's the exact same thing. Freedom of speech. Free Tibet, free Khalistan!
@MaTara01
@MaTara01 7 ай бұрын
Nijjar was a convicted terrorist in India and had escaped to Canada. The Canadian government gave asylum to a convicted terrorist and refused to cooperate with India regarding his extradition. Canada should be on the FATF list for supporting & sheltering convicted terrorists from India ,Bangladesh ,Sri Lanka & for honouring Nazis in their Parliament. Shame on Canada!
@majormajor7925
@majormajor7925 7 ай бұрын
Ok boomer
@MaTara01
@MaTara01 7 ай бұрын
@@majormajor7925 here's looking at you, loser!
@asmirann3636
@asmirann3636 7 ай бұрын
​@@majormajor7925You can't deny the facts. All of what he wrote is true. Now go and cry behind your mother.
@Kevin-fq3zh
@Kevin-fq3zh 7 ай бұрын
@@asmirann3636you are the one crying not him
@Allthekingshorses2
@Allthekingshorses2 7 ай бұрын
I am Canadian and unfortunately, i agree with you… I am realizing more and more now that Justin Trudeau has turned Canada into a terrorist haven. It is common to see protesters openly supporting Hamas on the streets in any major city here. He rewarded a jihadi terrorist $5M in the 2010s and now this….
@RationalismIsFuture
@RationalismIsFuture 7 ай бұрын
None of hindu consider khalistani as sikhs.
@manikaur3277
@manikaur3277 7 ай бұрын
I am a Sikh and i myself do not consider these dogs to be Sikhs. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
@user-nm3vu1sh9q
@user-nm3vu1sh9q 7 ай бұрын
It's a disgrace for cna to call a terrorist who recently threatened to bomb Air India an activist...
@JEET6576
@JEET6576 2 ай бұрын
What is your problem wei, you gaumutra ka aulad?
@user-km1bs4my1y
@user-km1bs4my1y 7 ай бұрын
Nijjar is plumber and osama bin Laden is construction worker!
@BomBoyzhiphop
@BomBoyzhiphop 7 ай бұрын
And Obama is the Nobel Peace Prize winner 🤣✌️
@mexicanmomo
@mexicanmomo 7 ай бұрын
I know sikh community very well. They can give life for justice, peace. These fringe elements should be punished, but never ever doubt a common sikh. During violence time, both sikhs and hindus were killed, but that is politically motivated and most sikhs reject it.
@Devilishlybenevolent
@Devilishlybenevolent 4 ай бұрын
Sikhs were brutally oppressed more. You know how you guys support Tibet? Well that is the exact situation with Khalistan. If you support one, you should support the other. They're both in the exact same situation.
@WanglembaElangbam-xj7yl
@WanglembaElangbam-xj7yl 7 ай бұрын
I thought there were only oversease large Korean community in America and Japan. I never knew about Koryo saram. Nice video
@jinxedpenguin
@jinxedpenguin 7 ай бұрын
Koreans in Central Asia blow my mind, like not that they're there but that they've done so much to maintain their cultural identity. I get that Koreans live everywhere (and that Canada and the US have a lot of them) but I guess since a lot of them travel back to Korea frequently it seems a bit different.
@hui-an-xin
@hui-an-xin 7 ай бұрын
Koreans/Koryo Saram were forcibly relocated by Soviets, while Korean immigration to North America is often voluntary, with a different dynamic and incentive to assimilate. While in some ways the USSR was far from supporting nationalism, one could still maintain a degree of cultural heritage and identity.
@manchu-qu9mw
@manchu-qu9mw 7 ай бұрын
It is heartwarming to feel back home to the motherland. No matter what background, religion or color, humans are fundamentally the same with universal emotions of fear and hope. It would be nice to enjoy and experience the various culture from each other. Life is beautiful. Not needless suffering and pains through insane conflict.
@surajpingle7670
@surajpingle7670 6 ай бұрын
Are you sikh?
@carlossantos6683
@carlossantos6683 7 ай бұрын
Although the report end in a light note, it is still ironic how those central asian koreans needed to go to South Korea to realise they're as much culturally Kazahks as they're ethnically Koreans. It is exaclty like those overseas grandchildren of Japanese immigrants that settle in the Americas long ago, most of them grew up with a deep sense of being japanese first and Brazilians, Americans or Peruvians second. And then when they finnaly ressetle in Japan for they astonishment they discovery their are not as Japanese as they once thought and the native Japanese for their part look at them as just another group of foreigners. As for India and the Sikhs, it is obvious the West wish to galvanize the separatism sentiments of expatriate Sikhs as a weapon to foster discontent inside India and undermine her role as a Global leader. But India also needs to resist the push to fell in the trap of reinforce her national identity on a majority religious ground over the risk of marginalize minority groups and turn narratives in real problems. One just need to look at Myammar to see how much trouble things can get once diversity is overrun by chauvinism and mismanegement.
@manikaur3277
@manikaur3277 7 ай бұрын
Hi I am a Sikh from Punjab and these so Khalistanis are actually the ones who entered Canada by marrying their sisters and buying out letters from so called politicians to stay in Canada/America on the basis of political differences. If you take each of them individually and study them then you’ll realize that majority of them have links with Pakistan(Isis). These goofers don’t even know the history of Sikhism. Just beacuse they all took refugee status in Canada they can not enter India and meet their relatives and all. So this is nothing but a political and side hustle for them that gives them pocket money. We Sikhs love our motherland india/Bharat. It is our Dhram to protect her and we will live and die for her. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
@gurjotss98
@gurjotss98 6 ай бұрын
An independent sikh state will solve half our problems in 1 day but we will face new problems and challenges in a small landlocked state border with 2 nuclear powers
@ankitvidlogs
@ankitvidlogs 5 ай бұрын
There are many issues in this report. Separatists with weapons are called terrorists. The terrorists are termed as "preachers" and "plumbers". A joker named Pannu, who openly threatens Hindus and Indians, gets his voice heard here. Sikhs were, are, and will remain true patriots of India.
@ShaneCallum
@ShaneCallum 7 ай бұрын
You have gotta be kidding me. Since when Punjab was annexed by the British. Situation of Punjab was similar to that of rest of India. In fact Punjab was a presidency similar to Bombay, Madras and Calcutta. Punjab also had Pakistani Punjab in it. I mean CNA should avoid garbage reporting just for the sake of views.
@aseeker8742
@aseeker8742 5 ай бұрын
As a rajput i want rajsthan as a separate nation.....
@mathskafunda4383
@mathskafunda4383 3 ай бұрын
LOL!
@pikachuthunderbolt3919
@pikachuthunderbolt3919 Ай бұрын
Go away Lol There is no limit to hunger for power
@tokorojj
@tokorojj 7 ай бұрын
I would change sikhs for muslims every single time: hard working, way less conflictive and not agressive at all.
@truthspeaker-qi6ku
@truthspeaker-qi6ku 7 ай бұрын
CNA thanks from showing the view of Pannu who has threatened to blow up air India 2 days before, while showing no view from indian side.
@_GMP_
@_GMP_ 7 ай бұрын
These people left India and took up Canadian And other countries citizenship. Have no right demand for a separate country in India. Go ask Local Sikhs in Punjab they are no longer interested in separate country
@shubhamnarayan2077
@shubhamnarayan2077 7 ай бұрын
You are interviewing pannu ? Don't you know this guy released a video threatening air india and asking sikhs to not travel by air india ( eerily similar to what a khalistani told before kanishka bombing ). And Indians don't suppress the idea of khalistan, we are only against the militant movement. This is the reason why you can still find khalistan booklets in india as it is an idea and is protected under freedom of expression guaranteed by iur supreme court and constitution. The problem is the millitany wing which advocates violence for a separate state. Trudeau looks down on Indian democracy and acts as if canaduan democracy is superior and only canada is culturally diverse. Trudeau has no idea what diversity actually means. India literally has over 400 languages, all the religions , only place where jews were never persecuted till this day. Our history is bloody & not perfect, but we are trying our best to keep it together. Just let us live in peace and stop this politics of hatred by allowing people celebrating the death if my former prime minister. Enough is enough
@krantsharma8455
@krantsharma8455 6 ай бұрын
You are blinded by the fact that India routinely kills and suppresses anyone who talks of grievance and dissent. Just look at the 10,000+ Sikh killed in fake encounters in Punjab, read about Jaswant Singh Khalra. Ofc, it hurts when a foreign leader tells you the truth that govt propaganda won't
@awesomestevie27
@awesomestevie27 7 ай бұрын
Why are non Panjabi telling us Panjabis we shouldn’t have our old country back Its still treated like a colony If you can’t see it you’ve been brainwashed by propaganda
@webdeveloper2432
@webdeveloper2432 7 ай бұрын
Sikhs and Khalistani terrorists are different. Please don't join Sikhs and Khalistanis and disrespect Sikhs. We are already independent as Indians and We love India and we will be loving India.
@narindersinghmarway9332
@narindersinghmarway9332 Ай бұрын
We sikhs are ruler of Punjab region Up to 1849, when British annex Punjab. When British left Sikhs were promised special autonomy powers for Punjab state, but after the independence India's politicians denied everything to Sikhs instead Sikhs were declared a criminal community. A dossier was circulated within Indian government offices that to keep eye on Sikhs.
@skywlkinson2128
@skywlkinson2128 3 ай бұрын
Many of my kiths have both Hindu and Sikh relatives, this particular demand is bizzare and is primarily spearheaded by subsection of particular community!
@bpatel4434
@bpatel4434 7 ай бұрын
I want to make toronto as separate country - name - Torontostan😂
@munawarl4386
@munawarl4386 6 ай бұрын
BJP COUGH PLENTY OF DOUGH TO LAWMAKERS TO IGNORE KHALISTAN MOVEMENT. THIS GUY CAUGHT IS A BJP GUY AND WITH 24K WILL BE FREE LIKE A BIRD. watch
@lmaonoobs3779
@lmaonoobs3779 7 ай бұрын
02:43 You literally interviewed a terrorist who is a part of same terrorist organisation that planned the 1985 Aur India bombing. This guy literally openly threatened of bombing Air India flights again and is still not arrested by Canada. Shows a lot about that country.
@krantsharma8455
@krantsharma8455 6 ай бұрын
Telling someone not to fly Air India vs bombing are two different things, think you get your information from govt propaganda
@lmaonoobs3779
@lmaonoobs3779 6 ай бұрын
@@krantsharma8455 what else do you think he meant when he said this? Instead of denying everything, you should try to open your eyes and get back to reality.
@krantsharma8455
@krantsharma8455 6 ай бұрын
​@@lmaonoobs3779kzbin.info/www/bejne/rn-XiIuNoLqepbcfeature=shared Perhaps this is what he meant by not flying Air India 😂😂😂😂
@krantsharma8455
@krantsharma8455 6 ай бұрын
​@@lmaonoobs3779Did you actually see the whole video or just read it from the godi media channel....Telling someone to boycott Air India is the same as India telling its citizens to boycott Chinese goods. And the fact that India asked Interpol to put him on the Terrorist list only to get shut down by Interpol over and over again....This guy is a free citizen of America and he can say the things that he wasn't allowed in India.... agreed he is a clown though
@lmaonoobs3779
@lmaonoobs3779 6 ай бұрын
@@krantsharma8455 I don't care if you call it godi media but I don't watch those comedy shows.
@subhranshuganguly2246
@subhranshuganguly2246 6 ай бұрын
We want a Sardarji PM who does away with all reservation and provide free visa on arrival for all Indians in Canada.
@kzm-cb5mr
@kzm-cb5mr 7 ай бұрын
Somehow, it's always the British, always connected in this world's territorial disputes...
@vjsubbiah
@vjsubbiah 7 ай бұрын
They did divide and ruled. So obviously it's always British
@gniranjank
@gniranjank 6 ай бұрын
I think only some of those Sikhs who left India want Khalistan. They thought their lives would change after leaving India and couldn't take how the Sikhs in India are doing miles better than them. Any common Indian from any part of the country will regard Sikhs the highest for their loyalty, courage and honesty. They've led the Indian Army to success, they've reformed Indian economy and have become the PM of the country too.
@GrandmasterTigerfist
@GrandmasterTigerfist 2 ай бұрын
Khalistan as a tiny Punjab wont even work in todays world. It would be sorrounded with arch rivals like Pakistan and india. Also Khalistan would have to ask persmission for almost everything from either pakistan or India for trades and even permission for airspace.. Most funny part would be Sikhs applying for visas to visit their shrines almost located everywhere in India. That would be a good income for Hindus at least
@JEET6576
@JEET6576 2 ай бұрын
It will, trust waheguruji and all will be OK Raj karega khalsa KHALISTAN ZINDABAD!!!!!
@GrandmasterTigerfist
@GrandmasterTigerfist 2 ай бұрын
@@JEET6576 Ye waheguru will put up a good business for Hindus when sikhs have to stand in line for visas to visit over 20 Gurdwaras allover India. 😄
@user-sp1tv8bi8f
@user-sp1tv8bi8f Ай бұрын
Hindus are always with Sikh brothers, they are our brothers... In good times Elder Brother became the Sikh from Hindu... so how we can leave these brothers? A few Khalistani brothers doing this but because of some bad times, they had seen. we are always there to welcome them with warm hearts. Please keep in mind we are kids of single Mother... Please mere Sikh brothers world is planning to break us fully like did with Muslims. Be united.
@sdaiwepm
@sdaiwepm 7 ай бұрын
1:23 Bro - it's the "Sikh" religion, not a "seekh" kebab!
@rajeshn5653
@rajeshn5653 7 ай бұрын
Punjab is safest state as long as part of India
@asmirann3636
@asmirann3636 7 ай бұрын
Gujarat, Maharashtra, Karnataka are the safest states.
@Kevin-fq3zh
@Kevin-fq3zh 7 ай бұрын
by indian standards of course
@sheevpalps3846
@sheevpalps3846 7 ай бұрын
@Kevin-fq3zh Nah, by worldwide standards. India is slightly safer than the average country esp in violent crime. Even if you adjust for uncounted crime rates
@Kevin-fq3zh
@Kevin-fq3zh 7 ай бұрын
@@sheevpalps3846 dream on
@jithinpoliyedathmohanan7237
@jithinpoliyedathmohanan7237 2 ай бұрын
There was injustice done to Sikhs in 1980s and 1990s and it’s still a wound to many Sikhs but I don’t think most Sikhs in India is against the idea of a secular and inclusive India 🇮🇳 .. Sikhs don’t like assimilation or oppression of others which BJP is exceptionally good at
@aadityathakker8605
@aadityathakker8605 27 күн бұрын
Make Khalistan out of India anywhere, full support.
@PHEROMONE-wz9bz
@PHEROMONE-wz9bz 7 ай бұрын
Khalistan Zindabad ❤
@BomBoyzhiphop
@BomBoyzhiphop 7 ай бұрын
🤣🤣🤣🤣🫴
@chander3338
@chander3338 7 ай бұрын
Lahore was the capital when Maharaja Ranjit Singh ruled undivided Punjab. I will support Khalistan only when Pakistan’s Punjab is converted into Khalistan.
@JEET6576
@JEET6576 2 ай бұрын
Yes, agreed
@blogical4320
@blogical4320 6 ай бұрын
Seriously? Taking statements from pannu? Have u seen his videos? Openly supporting terrorism now are we?
@anilkkumar54
@anilkkumar54 7 ай бұрын
It's Sikh not Sek
@user-bo8tq5zz3w
@user-bo8tq5zz3w 7 ай бұрын
Punjab is india n state Punjab is the integral part of india
@user-xe5se4os5b
@user-xe5se4os5b 6 ай бұрын
We will get Khalistan
@shubham7419
@shubham7419 7 ай бұрын
Pannu should demand state of punjab from pakistan.....actual punjab is in pakistan.....but these people are illiterate.....
@hassanj1861
@hassanj1861 6 ай бұрын
Free Khalistan, free palestine, free kashmir
@mathskafunda4383
@mathskafunda4383 3 ай бұрын
Free Balochistan, Free KPK. Also Khalistanis claim Pakistani Punjab too.
@anoopkumar8957
@anoopkumar8957 6 ай бұрын
This is what called showing terrorists as activists. Show the video of Pannu where he is announcing to bomb blast Air India two times, during Ind vs Pak and Ind vs Aus cricket match. Or Nijjar shooting banned Ak47 in Canada. And for Canadian who cares about their fellow gangster Canadian where were your PM when a baloch lady activist was killed in Canada. Her investigation was closed silently. Guess Canadian rule of law didn't receive money from ISI or Jagmeet Singh for that.
@shin4655
@shin4655 7 ай бұрын
5th largest religion which is only 0.6% in total religion statistic compare to Hinduism which is the 3rd largest with 14%. CNA is trying hard to promote them by picking a favorable figure to present and evading the comprehensive facts.
@simonphoenix3789
@simonphoenix3789 3 ай бұрын
It would be really unwise for sikhs to break apart from India. It would create a new weak state to be taken advantage of by Pakistan and China. Plus Sikhs are genetically no different from Indians given that the religion originated relatively recently in India.
@RamCharan-qg3vp
@RamCharan-qg3vp 7 ай бұрын
Pannu advising not go on air india and threatening Indians showing him as activist😂🙏🙏
@jamesb9499
@jamesb9499 6 ай бұрын
Do all family oriented Sikh have AK-47 at home and teach it at Gurudwara?
@cadworld5783
@cadworld5783 7 ай бұрын
Make Khalistan in Canada
@Igloo683
@Igloo683 6 ай бұрын
Khalistan is a Pakistan agenda. Just look at the so called Khalistan map - it doesn't include one inch of Pakistan territory whereas the Sikh empire was mostly based in modern day Pakistan. Comical to say the least.
@BigOil18
@BigOil18 6 ай бұрын
They can have independence if they want but need to use some logic and brain, 90% of Sikh holy sites are in Pakistan Punjab so they can get their Khalistan there. Hinduism is 10 times older than Sikhism so there is no obligation to surrender any land. A landlocked Khalistan would amount to nothing as nation regardless.
@metromaster7025
@metromaster7025 6 ай бұрын
Only one question though, why khalistanis only wants Indian side of Punjab and not include pakistan side of Punjab?
@anshumanjaiswal5787
@anshumanjaiswal5787 6 ай бұрын
They do
@pavankumarnandamuri8087
@pavankumarnandamuri8087 6 ай бұрын
Why these Khalistani separatists only want carve separate country from Punjab region of India, why don't they ask for Punjab region present in current day Pakistan which is very large than Punjab region of India.............. Simple answer is these Khalistani separatists are totally funded by Pakistan...... What does a plumber got to do with AK-47 ?? why nobody questions their intent ?? what sought of freedom of expression does an AK-47 represent ??
@mahendrashukla5466
@mahendrashukla5466 6 ай бұрын
Well I have recently came to know that they are different religions I have always viewed Sikhs and Hindus under one umbrella with no difference infact in indore gurudwara I have eaten multiple times and never come to know any difference
@sonalikokane5735
@sonalikokane5735 7 ай бұрын
Canada is the future Khalistan Canada banega khalistan
@northatlanticterroristorga1222
@northatlanticterroristorga1222 6 ай бұрын
Free khalistan
@pranavgandhar4604
@pranavgandhar4604 6 ай бұрын
Can't even show on map😂
@stephenkikon1475
@stephenkikon1475 6 ай бұрын
Yes absolutely. They need independence from Canada govt
@thefive2509
@thefive2509 5 ай бұрын
Independent Khalistan 💪🏻!!!
@raptor00ful
@raptor00ful 3 ай бұрын
Tattistan
@umarumair1818
@umarumair1818 7 ай бұрын
We want Khalistan ❤❤❤❤
@blogical4320
@blogical4320 6 ай бұрын
Abe chutiye u are muslim😂😂
@omgomg3002
@omgomg3002 6 ай бұрын
Sikhs and hindus need to have dialogue, thats it. Issues remain on both sides and this problem needs to be discussed and sorted out
@krantsharma8455
@krantsharma8455 6 ай бұрын
Exactly 💯
@user-zs2cr6ir6r
@user-zs2cr6ir6r 7 ай бұрын
Kalistan bangla pakistan butan tibet arunachal maldives ceylon and napal are inseparable children of Barathmata. They are HERS
@sonalikokane5735
@sonalikokane5735 7 ай бұрын
Pannu. Come on Air India no? tera bhaichara karenge
@tejasaher6431
@tejasaher6431 7 ай бұрын
Nijjar was a terrorist and if canada supporting nijjar then it's really concerning.
@vilasgije5484
@vilasgije5484 7 ай бұрын
First try to make Khalistan from the Punjab part of Pakistan.
@iracture
@iracture 2 ай бұрын
Again one more religion formed because Hindus don't like equality. Hindus must learn to treat people with equality. Hope the Sikhs are happy in India. SC Bose build army staying in Japan because people in India supported that idea. If Canada based leaders talk of Khalistan - who in India is supports that ? Who indeed will run Punjab after it gains so called freedom from India/Pakistan ? Most punjabis will say we were happy in India - what is this new thing. It appears Khalistani movement exists only to deepen the pocket of certain people funded by western security organizations to maintain balance of power of minorities in India. Wow politics can indeed get very complicated. And now BJP govt is accusing its arch political nemesis of supporting khalistanis. Plot thickens.. Religion based politics needs to be banned immediately.
@GrandmasterTigerfist
@GrandmasterTigerfist 2 ай бұрын
In Punjab alone Punjabi Christians and Hindus are way more educated than majority sikhs. Even Simranjeet Singh maan admitted to this fact under an interview with Khalsa tv. He also said that Christians and Hindus are the backbone of Punjab economy.
@iracture
@iracture 2 ай бұрын
@@GrandmasterTigerfist I have seen highly educated Hindus who are very passionate about their religious ways. Education does not help alleviate religious fervour nor will it help remove poverty. Tolerance is mindset that is learnt after centuries of co-existing together. The Indian diaspora must pressure on western politicians to respect wishes of the majority in Sikh community and the wishes of the majority of people in Punjab region. If 5% sikhs call for Khalistan glorifying that in media is injustice to the 95% who want to live peacefully in India. This channel appears undemocratic.
@GrandmasterTigerfist
@GrandmasterTigerfist 2 ай бұрын
@@iracture Khalistan is just a feel good slogan. And If you put Christians and Hindus togheter then they make up more than sikhs in Punjab. Sikhs in Punjab have a problem with everyone and this hatred in Punjab is fueled by Jattwaadis and SGPC. Christians and Hindus makes up most of the taxpayers in Punjab who work and pay taxes to the same Punjab govt who crap on their heads. This is only a game to gain more political power. This refrendrum is all nonsense. West is the core reason for the whole Khalistan mess why should they want to do anything? Poverty will always exist this is how the world works and in my opinion Hitler had more knowledge about the world than Guru Nanak.
@GrandmasterTigerfist
@GrandmasterTigerfist 2 ай бұрын
@@iracture Even if sikhs make Khalistan it will be a landlocked country and their most holiest shrines are located allover India. Today they have to pay pakistan visa to visit 3 main Gurdwaras while others are destroyed. Its only good for India that Sikhs later have to apply for visas to visit their shrines but that wont happen 50-60 years ahead since Hindus will be angry over this. HIndus have nothing to loose only to gain while its Sikhs who will have har times asking permission for almost everything from trade routes to permission to airspace. Im a Punjabi minority myself.
@GrandmasterTigerfist
@GrandmasterTigerfist 2 ай бұрын
@@iracture Even Europe is becoming conservative everyone is fed up by Muslims.
@peace-hu5pn
@peace-hu5pn 7 ай бұрын
Reality is middle of these
@Prashant_Pandey4
@Prashant_Pandey4 7 ай бұрын
Ik khalistan doesn't represent Sikhs
@lakshaytomar4817
@lakshaytomar4817 7 ай бұрын
4:10 reality
@PUNJABREGIONKHALISTAN
@PUNJABREGIONKHALISTAN 7 ай бұрын
❤❤❤❤Khalistan zindabad ❤❤❤❤United Punjab Khalistan
@rmot2911
@rmot2911 7 ай бұрын
Punjabis who still remain in India, Pakistan DON'T WANT A SEPARATE REGION. And for those Indians and Pakistanis who have left India and Pakistan, you have NO RIGHTS TO DEMAND FOR A SEPARATE NATION out of India and Pakistan as YOU GAVE UP YOUR CITIZENSHIP ESPECIALLY INDIA'S. If anyone including SIKHS WANT LAND, ask your new countries - THAT INCLUDES CANADA which is DONG WORSE THAN AUSTRALIA where Australia has the Highest Median Wealth in the World followed by Belgium and then New Zealand (Yes, Australia is now facing challenges as Australia Too Depended on China a Lot But Australia is CLOSER to ASIA where 21st Century Economic Growth and Power Challenges have been. Canada hasn't had a Good Prime Minister UNLIKE Australia though in recent times, it's New Zealand that has had a good leader whose name is Jacinda Arden. For a country that is the World's 2nd Largest by area, maybe Canada should sell off part of its land which it doesn't use well to the Sikhs whom many Canadians, Britishers and others support for wanting a separate region). Once again fact is India has the World's 2nd Largest Number of Middle Middle Class People, Upper Middle Class People and Rich of 200 to 300 Million who live Worldwide (China Leads with 500 to 600 Million of Middle Middle Class, Upper Middle Class and Rich who live Worldwide while Pakistan got thrashed by Bangladesh too in South Asia). Heard of the Vice President of USA/America? Her name is Kamala Harris who has an Indian Background through HER MOTHER. Heard of American Tech CEOs who have Indian Background and are linked back to India too? Heard of ex-Pepsi CEO Indra Nooyi who has Indian Background again? Doesn't end there as it goes on in USA including the 2024 Republican Candidates too. UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak whose wife is a Non-Residential Indian and the daughter of Billionaire Founder of Infosys, Narayana Murthy, well he has Indian Background through his parents. There are couple more World Leaders including from Europe that have had or who still are with Indian background including Portugal, Malaysia and so on. Current Chanel's CEO Leena Nair herself has Indian Background and she is the Mentee of Indra Nooyi. 1 of Australia’s Top 15 Richest Persons is Vivek Sehgal with Indian Background while Melanie Perkins, the Co-founder of Canva is another Top 15th Richest Australian whose father has Malaysian Background with Both Sri Lankan and Filipino Heritage. And it goes on for Indian Middle Middle Class, Upper Middle Class and Rich whose Stronghold has been USA FOLLOWED BY UK though they are Citizens of Other Nations Too. Chinese Stronghold is in SOUTHEAST ASIA/ASEAN COUNTRIES - Richest Singaporeans, Indonesians, Malaysians, Filipinos etc are CHINESE followed by WESTERN BACKGROUND including Spanish Filipinos and INDIAN MONEY-LENDERS including Indian Money-Lender Filipinos. The Richest in the World is a person with South African background and Not Just Pure White-Elon Musk. But the Asian Americans starting with Asian Indian Americans followed by Filipino Americans, Vietnamese Americans, Chinese Americans, Japanese Americans, South Korean Americans, Pakistani Americans etc are challenging the Whites including Latinos for (1) Median Wealth, (2) Higher Standards of Living, (3) Less Broken Marriages and Relationships (There are Global Research and Studies even by Harvard University and other US Universities showing the Correlation between Broken Marriages and Relationships to Single Moms and Correlation between Single Moms to Poverty as Very Few Single Moms Worldwide succeed-Philippines is 1 exception to an Asian Country that has High % of Single Moms including Single Teen Moms where Poverty is High too while South Korea though rising with Single Parenting has Lower Poverty Issues related to Single Moms), (4) Better Education and Skills where Many of the Whites Especially Latinos and Hispanics face Poverty though yes some of the Latinos are European Jews where some of them do well in USA just like some of the Asian Jews who too do well in America as Judaism started from Middle East of Asia where Jews are Asians, Europeans, etc.
@adv.shravanvijayakumar8352
@adv.shravanvijayakumar8352 7 ай бұрын
Does your defention of Khalistan include lahore or Karthapur which should have also idelly been part of your Khalistan.
@satvikyadav7530
@satvikyadav7530 7 ай бұрын
Plumber😂😂😂😂😂😂 2:59
@PARTHASARATHISAMANTARAY
@PARTHASARATHISAMANTARAY 6 ай бұрын
CNA showing pannu . how much terrorist supporting agency can you be ?
@Viprgod4775
@Viprgod4775 7 ай бұрын
I don't know why cna is talking with terrorist, if u want real Sikh talk to reald Indian Sikh not West propagandist terrorist
@ttbrown9700
@ttbrown9700 7 ай бұрын
India is famous for scammers and cheaters so no one can really trust you to speak the truth
@SlashGamingftw
@SlashGamingftw 7 ай бұрын
Looks like u didn’t even watch the video
@jinxedpenguin
@jinxedpenguin 7 ай бұрын
this is such an insane reply, did you even watch the video? they literally talked MOSTLY to Sikh's in India that were like "ya, no we don't really want a separate state"
@SlashGamingftw
@SlashGamingftw 7 ай бұрын
@@jinxedpenguinsame andhbhakts like him spam Khalistan on every Punjabi they see on the internet, actually ridiculous
@Viprgod4775
@Viprgod4775 7 ай бұрын
Terrorist r terrorist, no talking to them n understand their logic on separate state
@abhinavsrivastava5881
@abhinavsrivastava5881 6 ай бұрын
Pannu next.
@babajikaghanta8842
@babajikaghanta8842 3 ай бұрын
Nikhil Gupta got caught, mission failed. 😂You should be more concerned about Indian citizens gets killed in US and western countries and media doesn't give a dam 😂
@anmolsingh3768
@anmolsingh3768 7 ай бұрын
Let give khalistan to pannu alone by putting him in jail 😂for the rest of his life
@awesomestevie27
@awesomestevie27 7 ай бұрын
Ima sikh and I wouldn’t allowed to even protest peacefully about the topic without being arrested without trial under antinational laws So ofc there is more support out of India where people have the freedom to express opinions Indians also were colonized by the uk and what if I told them they had no rights to want independence if they were calling for it in a place they had more freedom So the whole “you don’t live there you have no right to call it” makes no sense
@anubhavgangwar1383
@anubhavgangwar1383 7 ай бұрын
But where u will make khalistan??? Whenever I ask this question no khalistani has proper answer to it
@buwburbhbjeqbb6790
@buwburbhbjeqbb6790 7 ай бұрын
Start demanding of making Khalistan on Canadian soil and then check reaction of Canadian government. Besides why don't you people demand Khalistan in Pakistani Punjab? You will get full support from indians.
@anshuraj4277
@anshuraj4277 6 ай бұрын
Go protest in Lahore
@babajikaghanta8842
@babajikaghanta8842 3 ай бұрын
​@@anubhavgangwar1383don't ask for Hindu rashtra that is completely anti constitutional and there will be no khalistan either.
@TJandDally
@TJandDally 7 ай бұрын
This all goes back to the anandpur sahib resolution. Sikhs want to be recognized a religion not sub of Hinduism. That's the basis of all this
@RationalismIsFuture
@RationalismIsFuture 7 ай бұрын
No more partitions
@Kevin-fq3zh
@Kevin-fq3zh 7 ай бұрын
free manipur!
@prajwal1341
@prajwal1341 7 ай бұрын
​@@Kevin-fq3zhFree hong Kong🇭🇰🇭🇰🇭🇰
@user-uf6wc2zf6r
@user-uf6wc2zf6r 7 ай бұрын
free manipur, kashmir and panjab
@sheevpalps3846
@sheevpalps3846 7 ай бұрын
Manipur and Punjab do not want independence, when Indian military intervened in ethnic riots people were rejoicing. Most Punjabis do not support them either. Kashmir is debatable though. Interesting to see a referendum now
@harpreetsinghmann
@harpreetsinghmann 7 ай бұрын
You have no claim over Punjab,
@jinxedpenguin
@jinxedpenguin 7 ай бұрын
I feel like self determination should be the motivating factor for all parties. It doesn't seem like a lot of people in Punjab actually want an independent state. They should just have, at the very least a non-binding democratic referendum to see (that way it isn't enforceable if things go south.) every time that has happened in Quebec or Scotland, most people vote to stay. Also, there's a reason why a lot of people outside of India see a lot of you as "indian nationalists". This video was not even critical of India and all of the top comments are being super defensive. Chill.
@Kevin-fq3zh
@Kevin-fq3zh 7 ай бұрын
many indian commentators on YT are defensive & insecure
@gjoswal256
@gjoswal256 7 ай бұрын
It's not gonna happen, it's not part of Indian constitution.
@user-uf6wc2zf6r
@user-uf6wc2zf6r 7 ай бұрын
Believe me a lot of people do support idea of independent state. But they are scared of the government and so not many accept it publically on camera that they want independent country. Indian state uses violence to crush the movement and peaceful protests. They have done it in the past and they are doing it today as well. Indian government and Indian nationalists claim there is very less support for indepent state for sikhs. But they have never done even a survey on it. And Yet India claims to be a democracy.
@randombully3798
@randombully3798 7 ай бұрын
​@user-uf6wc2zf6r our constitution does not allow separatist moments to exist. And the same constitution give us the right to use force to protect our land and our borders. And again the land of punjab belongs to india, and we will protect our land with force if required. So if there are people that are separatist they are a security threat on the same category as pakistan and China.
@Fgghhnh2345
@Fgghhnh2345 7 ай бұрын
@@user-uf6wc2zf6r nobody supports that Idea and if anybody does , they just leave the country
@00-_-_-_-00
@00-_-_-_-00 7 ай бұрын
Why not? South Asia is basically divided amongst religious lines anyways. Why is West Bengal part of India and Bangladesh a separate country? Urdu speakers and Hindi speakers could literally understand each other when they're talking, on the other hand speaking Hindi in Tamil Nadu is more of a Taboo than pineapple pizza in Italy. But Pakistan and India are different countries whilst Tamil Nadu is an Indian state. Sri Lanka could well be just another Indian state, but the fact that it's predominantly Buddhist really sticks out on why it's a separate country. If Sikhs in Punjabi want to go at it alone it's just nature taking its course more than anything
@user-ej4nx9ik5l
@user-ej4nx9ik5l 7 ай бұрын
lol 40% of the people living inside their state in punjab are hindu, how could they possibly ever form a state for sikhs without genociding that 40% hmmm
@bickynt7930
@bickynt7930 7 ай бұрын
Lol....your hand and leg should not be part of one (ur) body?
@rmot2911
@rmot2911 7 ай бұрын
Well, there have been No Fighting from Inside India for a SEPARATE COUNTRY for 60 odd years Though yes there has been Fighting for Separate States within India. NOBODY WANTS TO GO THROUGH THAT PARTITION again which happened during 1947 Independence Day. BUT PAKISTAN Desperately Keeps Trying where PAKISTAN is 1 of Asia's Worst Regions that GOT THRASHED BY BANGLADESH TOO for Economic and Human Development. Jharkhand, Telangana, Chhattisgarh etc are the Separate States that came about too
@rmot2911
@rmot2911 7 ай бұрын
India is divided based on Languages. Using your logic, why don't we get rid of the Whites in Many Western Countries especially USA, Australia, Canada, New Zealand where the Whites are Migrants too as Blacks were 1st in those places? After all, the Whites are going through Ageing Process where many of them will be Minorities by 2050 or so in USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, etc. Also, fact today India has the World's 2nd Largest Number of Middle Middle Class People, Upper Middle Class People and Rich of 200 to 300 Million who live Worldwide including being Citizens of Other Nations (China Leads with 500 to 600 Million of Middle Middle Class, Upper Middle Class and Rich who live Worldwide while Pakistan got thrashed by Bangladesh too in South Asia). Heard of the Vice President of USA/America? Her name is Kamala Harris who has an Indian Background through HER MOTHER. Heard of American Tech CEOs who have Indian Background and are linked back to India too? Heard of ex-Pepsi CEO Indra Nooyi who has Indian Background again? Doesn't end there as it goes on in USA including the 2024 Republican Candidates too. UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak whose wife is a Non-Residential Indian and the daughter of Billionaire Founder of Infosys, Narayana Murthy, well he has Indian Background through his parents. There are couple more World Leaders including from Europe that have had or who still are with Indian background including Portugal, Malaysia and so on. Current Chanel's CEO Leena Nair herself has Indian Background and she is the Mentee of Indra Nooyi. 1 of Australia’s Top 15 Richest Persons is Vivek Sehgal with Indian Background while Melanie Perkins, the Co-founder of Canva is another Top 15th Richest Australian whose father has Malaysian Background with Both Sri Lankan and Filipino Heritage. And it goes on for Indian Middle Middle Class, Upper Middle Class and Rich whose Stronghold has been USA FOLLOWED BY UK though they are Citizens of Other Nations Too. Chinese Stronghold is in SOUTHEAST ASIA/ASEAN COUNTRIES - Richest Singaporeans, Indonesians, Malaysians, Filipinos etc are CHINESE followed by WESTERN BACKGROUND including Spanish Filipinos and INDIAN MONEY-LENDERS including Indian Money-Lender Filipinos. The Richest in the World is a person with South African background and Not Just Pure White-Elon Musk. But the Asian Americans starting with Asian Indian Americans followed by Filipino Americans, Vietnamese Americans, Chinese Americans, Japanese Americans, South Korean Americans, Pakistani Americans etc are challenging the Whites including Latinos for (1) Median Wealth, (2) Higher Standards of Living, (3) Less Broken Marriages and Relationships (There are Global Research and Studies even by Harvard University and other US Universities showing the Correlation between Broken Marriages and Relationships to Single Moms and Correlation between Single Moms to Poverty as Very Few Single Moms Worldwide succeed-Philippines is 1 exception to an Asian Country that has High % of Single Moms including Single Teen Moms where Poverty is High too while South Korea though rising with Single Parenting has Lower Poverty Issues related to Single Moms), (4) Better Education and Skills where Many of the Whites Especially Latinos and Hispanics face Poverty though yes some of the Latinos are European Jews where some of them do well in USA just like some of the Asian Jews who too do well in America as Judaism started from Middle East of Asia where Jews are Asians, Europeans, etc.
@phaddu7737
@phaddu7737 7 ай бұрын
Awww having wet dreams now, your most welcome to India, do come and try.
@harpreetsinghmann
@harpreetsinghmann 7 ай бұрын
Yes, we want our Nation Independent once again!
@rmot2911
@rmot2911 7 ай бұрын
When? Way before Britishers too. And even before that, Punjab was part of Other Kingdoms too. Anyway, Punjabis who still remain in India, Pakistan DON'T WANT A SEPARATE REGION. And for those Indians and Pakistanis who have LEFT India and Pakistan, you have NO RIGHTS TO DEMAND FOR A SEPARATE NATION out of India and Pakistan as YOU GAVE UP YOUR CITIZENSHIP ESPECIALLY INDIA'S. If anyone including SIKHS WANT LAND, ASK YOUR NEW NATIONS - THAT INCLUDES CANADA which is DONG WORSE THAN AUSTRALIA where Australia has the Highest Median Wealth in the World followed by Belgium and then New Zealand (Yes, Australia is now facing challenges as Australia Too Depended on China a Lot But Australia is CLOSER to ASIA where 21st Century Economic Growth and Power Challenges have been. Canada hasn't had a Good Prime Minister UNLIKE Australia though in recent times, it's New Zealand that has had a good leader whose name is Jacinda Arden. For a country that is the World's 2nd Largest by area, maybe Canada should sell off part of its land which it doesn't use well to the Sikhs whom many Canadians, Britishers and others support for wanting a separate region). Once again fact is India has the World's 2nd Largest Number of Middle Middle Class People, Upper Middle Class People and Rich of 200 to 300 Million who live Worldwide (China Leads with 500 to 600 Million of Middle Middle Class, Upper Middle Class and Rich who live Worldwide while Pakistan got thrashed by Bangladesh too in South Asia). Heard of the Vice President of USA/America? Her name is Kamala Harris who has an Indian Background through HER MOTHER. Heard of American Tech CEOs who have Indian Background and are linked back to India too? Heard of ex-Pepsi CEO Indra Nooyi who has Indian Background again? Doesn't end there as it goes on in USA including the 2024 Republican Candidates too. UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak whose wife is a Non-Residential Indian and the daughter of Billionaire Founder of Infosys, Narayana Murthy, well he has Indian Background through his parents. There are couple more World Leaders including from Europe that have had or who still are with Indian background including Portugal, Malaysia and so on. Current Chanel's CEO Leena Nair herself has Indian Background and she is the Mentee of Indra Nooyi. 1 of Australia’s Top 15 Richest Persons is Vivek Sehgal with Indian Background while Melanie Perkins, the Co-founder of Canva is another Top 15th Richest Australian whose father has Malaysian Background with Both Sri Lankan and Filipino Heritage. And it goes on for Indian Middle Middle Class, Upper Middle Class and Rich whose Stronghold has been USA FOLLOWED BY UK though they are Citizens of Other Nations Too. Chinese Stronghold is in SOUTHEAST ASIA/ASEAN COUNTRIES - Richest Singaporeans, Indonesians, Malaysians, Filipinos etc are CHINESE followed by WESTERN BACKGROUND including Spanish Filipinos and INDIAN MONEY-LENDERS including Indian Money-Lender Filipinos. The Richest in the World is a person with South African background and Not Just Pure White-Elon Musk. But the Asian Americans starting with Asian Indian Americans followed by Filipino Americans, Vietnamese Americans, Chinese Americans, Japanese Americans, South Korean Americans, Pakistani Americans etc are challenging the Whites including Latinos for (1) Median Wealth, (2) Higher Standards of Living, (3) Less Broken Marriages and Relationships (There are Global Research and Studies even by Harvard University and other US Universities showing the Correlation between Broken Marriages and Relationships to Single Moms and Correlation between Single Moms to Poverty as Very Few Single Moms Worldwide succeed-Philippines is 1 exception to an Asian Country that has High % of Single Moms including Single Teen Moms where Poverty is High too while South Korea though rising with Single Parenting has Lower Poverty Issues related to Single Moms), (4) Better Education and Skills where Many of the Whites Especially Latinos and Hispanics face Poverty though yes some of the Latinos are European Jews where some of them do well in USA just like some of the Asian Jews who too do well in America as Judaism started from Middle East of Asia where Jews are Asians, Europeans, etc.
@durgeshsss
@durgeshsss 7 ай бұрын
Toh aa na india le le ...jh2 paidaish
@user-id3ff1wb7s
@user-id3ff1wb7s 7 ай бұрын
Hahhahaha.😂😂😂
@mka2032
@mka2032 7 ай бұрын
Before Sikh Kingdom it was someone else Kingdom ,so let's go back more, there was no Sikh before, so let's go back much more
@amarpreetsingh5927
@amarpreetsingh5927 7 ай бұрын
@@durgeshsss ja bhai ek chilled glass moot pee ur thanda ho ja
@acloudpilot
@acloudpilot 7 ай бұрын
Maro sardaro ki😂
@nishantsharma7832
@nishantsharma7832 7 ай бұрын
Ther r our brothers ❤ They r our pride❤❤
@vikaspanwar624
@vikaspanwar624 7 ай бұрын
Chup kar chutiye. Sabse pehle moot tumhara hi nikalega ladaayi hoti hai toh
@Hup8y4
@Hup8y4 7 ай бұрын
Ur disgusting
@Hitu2002
@Hitu2002 6 ай бұрын
Teri bund mare sale pandat gandu sabse bde madarchod tum pandu ho india ke sale jaatiwadi keede
@SinghAujla-cm9yk
@SinghAujla-cm9yk 7 ай бұрын
but you have insulted them.by decimating sikh religion sovereignty status in india,india constitution Article 25 you jackbooted sikhs as Hindus.disregard for sikh religious sovereignty.
@subhranshuganguly2246
@subhranshuganguly2246 6 ай бұрын
Khalistanis remeber 40% of Punjab is still Hindu.
@venti5722
@venti5722 Ай бұрын
And?
@ttbrown9700
@ttbrown9700 7 ай бұрын
Free the Sikhs from India's oppression
@karankrishnakanth
@karankrishnakanth 7 ай бұрын
😂lol about about 52 % in porkistan
@ttbrown9700
@ttbrown9700 7 ай бұрын
@@karankrishnakanth i'm not from Pakistan. Both India and Pakistan are wastelands
@GTXSUPER-gp1ul
@GTXSUPER-gp1ul 7 ай бұрын
When did india even oppress the sikh community....maybe the RSS but apart from that none of Indians have ever oppress the sikh community
@kitcarsonscout7737
@kitcarsonscout7737 7 ай бұрын
Move to canada
@sheevpalps3846
@sheevpalps3846 7 ай бұрын
What oppression?
@PUNJABREGIONKHALISTAN
@PUNJABREGIONKHALISTAN 7 ай бұрын
Punjab was independent country and will be again ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Khalistan zindabad
@rmot2911
@rmot2911 7 ай бұрын
When? Way before Britishers too. And even before that, Punjab was part of Other Kingdoms too. Anyway, Punjabis who still remain in India, Pakistan DON'T WANT A SEPARATE REGION. And for those Indians and Pakistanis who have left India and Pakistan, you have NO RIGHTS TO DEMAND FOR A SEPARATE NATION out of India and Pakistan as YOU GAVE UP YOUR CITIZENSHIP ESPECIALLY INDIA'S. If anyone including SIKHS WANT LAND, ask your new countries - THAT INCLUDES CANADA which is DONG WORSE THAN AUSTRALIA where Australia has the Highest Median Wealth in the World followed by Belgium and then New Zealand (Yes, Australia is now facing challenges as Australia Too Depended on China a Lot But Australia is CLOSER to ASIA where 21st Century Economic Growth and Power Challenges have been. Canada hasn't had a Good Prime Minister UNLIKE Australia though in recent times, it's New Zealand that has had a good leader whose name is Jacinda Arden. For a country that is the World's 2nd Largest by area, maybe Canada should sell off part of its land which it doesn't use well to the Sikhs whom many Canadians, Britishers and others support for wanting a separate region). Once again fact is India has the World's 2nd Largest Number of Middle Middle Class People, Upper Middle Class People and Rich of 200 to 300 Million who live Worldwide (China Leads with 500 to 600 Million of Middle Middle Class, Upper Middle Class and Rich who live Worldwide while Pakistan got thrashed by Bangladesh too in South Asia). Heard of the Vice President of USA/America? Her name is Kamala Harris who has an Indian Background through HER MOTHER. Heard of American Tech CEOs who have Indian Background and are linked back to India too? Heard of ex-Pepsi CEO Indra Nooyi who has Indian Background again? Doesn't end there as it goes on in USA including the 2024 Republican Candidates too. UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak whose wife is a Non-Residential Indian and the daughter of Billionaire Founder of Infosys, Narayana Murthy, well he has Indian Background through his parents. There are couple more World Leaders including from Europe that have had or who still are with Indian background including Portugal, Malaysia and so on. Current Chanel's CEO Leena Nair herself has Indian Background and she is the Mentee of Indra Nooyi. 1 of Australia’s Top 15 Richest Persons is Vivek Sehgal with Indian Background while Melanie Perkins, the Co-founder of Canva is another Top 15th Richest Australian whose father has Malaysian Background with Both Sri Lankan and Filipino Heritage. And it goes on for Indian Middle Middle Class, Upper Middle Class and Rich whose Stronghold has been USA FOLLOWED BY UK though they are Citizens of Other Nations Too. Chinese Stronghold is in SOUTHEAST ASIA/ASEAN COUNTRIES - Richest Singaporeans, Indonesians, Malaysians, Filipinos etc are CHINESE followed by WESTERN BACKGROUND including Spanish Filipinos and INDIAN MONEY-LENDERS including Indian Money-Lender Filipinos. The Richest in the World is a person with South African background and Not Just Pure White-Elon Musk. But the Asian Americans starting with Asian Indian Americans followed by Filipino Americans, Vietnamese Americans, Chinese Americans, Japanese Americans, South Korean Americans, Pakistani Americans etc are challenging the Whites including Latinos for (1) Median Wealth, (2) Higher Standards of Living, (3) Less Broken Marriages and Relationships (There are Global Research and Studies even by Harvard University and other US Universities showing the Correlation between Broken Marriages and Relationships to Single Moms and Correlation between Single Moms to Poverty as Very Few Single Moms Worldwide succeed-Philippines is 1 exception to an Asian Country that has High % of Single Moms including Single Teen Moms where Poverty is High too while South Korea though rising with Single Parenting has Lower Poverty Issues related to Single Moms), (4) Better Education and Skills where Many of the Whites Especially Latinos and Hispanics face Poverty though yes some of the Latinos are European Jews where some of them do well in USA just like some of the Asian Jews who too do well in America as Judaism started from Middle East of Asia where Jews are Asians, Europeans, etc.
@ramaliya197
@ramaliya197 7 ай бұрын
Start with Pakistan Punjab and Lahore..that was heart of original punajab..why are you khalistani silent about that
@KrishnaGupta-oq4fo
@KrishnaGupta-oq4fo 7 ай бұрын
hope khalistan rise
@manikaur3277
@manikaur3277 7 ай бұрын
@@KrishnaGupta-oq4foin Canada 🤣🤣🤣
@infinix2003
@infinix2003 7 ай бұрын
Your like far right Hindus dreaming of AKHAND BHARAT
@ArabicReja973
@ArabicReja973 7 ай бұрын
Canada 🇨🇦 is a country with rules of laws, and no one is above the laws, including Modi. - Will Mr Modi be charged and issued with an *arrest warrant* if he got involved? That wouldn't be ruled out!
@axel3895
@axel3895 7 ай бұрын
Canada lol
@9694218247
@9694218247 7 ай бұрын
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@gjoswal256
@gjoswal256 7 ай бұрын
😀😀😂
@johnutube5651
@johnutube5651 7 ай бұрын
Police in Canada do not know who killed Nijjar. Apparantly false allegation was made against India to gain votes in the forthcoming election. Canada is engaging in separatist activities in India by harboring terrorists. Eventually there will be a demand for K-stan in Canda as well.
@kun14al07
@kun14al07 7 ай бұрын
Lol.. what can a weak country like Canada do anyway 😂
@KrishnaGupta-oq4fo
@KrishnaGupta-oq4fo 7 ай бұрын
see Khalistan is a right for millions of sikh , hope Khalistan would becomes a reality , Khalistan gives an identity .
@blogical4320
@blogical4320 6 ай бұрын
Abe 6kke😂😂 alsi username se ane me sharam ati hai 🐖
@oceanwave4502
@oceanwave4502 7 ай бұрын
Kashmir (Muslims), Punjab (Sikhs), and Manipur should be independent off India.
@ramanrana9189
@ramanrana9189 7 ай бұрын
In your dreams
@donjames7678
@donjames7678 7 ай бұрын
Independent in dreams
@saigovind3006
@saigovind3006 7 ай бұрын
Balochistan zindabad, Pashtunistan zindabad sindhudesh zindabad
@user-rd5yc1zm4c
@user-rd5yc1zm4c 7 ай бұрын
Please take it
@kitcarsonscout7737
@kitcarsonscout7737 7 ай бұрын
These tatus won't survive without india
@parivel9724
@parivel9724 3 ай бұрын
Sikh culture is being diminished by chiristian conversion....in Punjab
@ercanbanka5377
@ercanbanka5377 7 ай бұрын
further east is the pacific ocean
Why Punjabis Go To Canada?
31:26
Nitish Rajput
Рет қаралды 4,1 МЛН
Sprinting with More and More Money
00:29
MrBeast
Рет қаралды 180 МЛН
🌊Насколько Глубокий Океан ? #shorts
00:42
King jr
Рет қаралды 3,4 МЛН
How to bring sweets anywhere 😋🍰🍫
00:32
TooTool
Рет қаралды 48 МЛН
Gravitas Plus: What is the Khalistan movement?
9:58
WION
Рет қаралды 2,5 МЛН
INDIA | Punjab's Sikh Separatism?
13:35
Prof James Ker-Lindsay
Рет қаралды 77 М.
Russlanddeutsche, die AfD und ich | Doku | NDR Story
44:49
NDR Doku
Рет қаралды 432 М.
Forgotten History: the Romani (Gypsy) Migration from India to Europe
15:51
Punjab Khalistan Movement Explained
35:08
Nitish Rajput
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН