Coleman Hughes Pushes Back on "False Flag" Claims About Israel-Hamas Attack

JRE #2130 w/Coleman Hughes
KZbin: • Joe Rogan Experience #...
JRE on Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/4rOoJ6E...

[@PKAClips]

“All the soldiers had to be at a protest somewhere else so that’s why they left the world’s most sophisticated border wide open and didn’t respond for hours” yeah okay 😂

[@meltedsnowman9637]

It wasn’t wide open. There was still a huge wall there and IDF soldiers there. It’s just when you have probably the most threats against your country in the entire world,at some point some of these threats are going to be successful. They’ve realised they got complacent now though which is why they’re neutralising the threats.

[@PKAClips]

@@meltedsnowman9637 why do they have the most threats against their 'country' in the entire world?

[@TP-pq9xx]

@@meltedsnowman9637 Those humanitarian workers that Israel keep drone striking are the true threat. I see.

[@alitharealist4730]

@@meltedsnowman9637 Okay.. so it wasn't wide open? They had a while to make a opening at the most sophisticated border witch gives them more time to respond and they didn't.. witch isn't helping your case here btw.

[@adamsprung6524]

@@PKAClips Because they are surrounded by Hezbollah, hamas, Islamic Jihad, Syria. Must be horrible to not get along with those psycho terrorists

[@ckneasel]

No response for 7 hours…? Stop it… Might not have been a false flag but they knew and did nothing… Netanyahu is not popular in Isreal…

[@Frenchfeast]

worst response time during war in recorded history They let it happen

[@Santirata]

It was Simcha Torah and Shabbat with many soldiers on leave for the holiday. Many observant jews don't use technology on the Sabbath, which is the most logical answer as to why the response took longer than one would expect. But of course, the rats of Hamas choose to attack on Jewish holidays and then cry like babies to the world when Israel contemplates counterattacking during Ramadan.

[@user-yu6mu6hw1s]

He said there were troops in the West Bank due to the protests. This is not true. They were in the West Bank due to rising tensions with settlers.

[@Beamken]

It’s almost like the people trying to take your homes by force might no be so nice

[@karlburmeister1552]

How is your first sentence different from your second? Protests and tensions are synonymous in this context.

[@speezy6442]

​@@BeamkenI don't see any native Americans running through houses murdering people without regard, or burning babies alive. Or Mexicans invading Texas, taking hostages and torturing people, nor any Eskimo, or Pacific islander. The past is the past, doesn't justify anything a bunch of Islamic extremist terrorists do. If your home and land is where your ethic group or race claims to be from, or somewhere that's considered a holy site for your religion, you're gonna have to redo the entire world map. Has Israel don't fucked up things? Absolutely, but of someone came to house you currently lived in, said there family lived there 100 years ago so it's there's, then proceedes to try and murder you and your family every day at any time, you might take some crazy measures to prevent that wouldn't you?

[@MizrahimJudean]

Palestinian Islamic Jihad and Hamas are in the West Bank. Literally there is tons of footage in the last month showing so.

[@The_jed8897]

Hamas is in the West Bank

[@Updualusain]

Isreal's pr is at its lowest😂😂😂

[@chipdiesel9788]

Like they give a shit, they're busy being the only not barbaric country in the mid east

[@ETAisNOW]

Emojis are gay

[@TalReu]

then leave

[@bags9419]

@@ETAisNOW👉🏻👌🏻

[@beshaxhaj2897]

The way he says netehyahooo sounds like he sucks his balls all day long.

[@simba8665]

This guy is soo delusional. You can see him catching himself trying to explain something that isn't making any sense.

[@MarineScoutSniper]

Absolutely. You can see the gears spinning as he is spinning. 😂

[@shaykh_Mahboob]

Them AIPAC shekels got him tripping.

[@georgeperez5662]

So the information you received on TikTok is 100% true 😂

[@MercurialStatic]

@@georgeperez5662 Brainrot response.

[@buakawfan333]

You can just imagine the briefing room where all these intelligence agents are gathered around brainstorming why people aren't lapping up their 🐂

[@MrEmperorApples]

I do not know what happened fully, but for him to say there is NO chance that it was one, I have no idea how he is so certain about his opinions

[@timberwolfmountaineer873]

Just like any other "expert" these days, Coleman confuses his personal opinion with document based facts. he has a "feeling', a "hunch", you know. So it must be true.

[@kobalt77]

Agreed !

[@captainhydra4291]

For people to say it DID happen as a matter of fact, I have no idea how they are so certain of their opinion

[@MrEmperorApples]

@@captainhydra4291 agreed. Both sides claiming 100% certitude is very troublesome. I doubt anyone knows 100% what happened

[@Aaerys]

My Israeli propagandist senses are tingling.

[@MoroccanAnwar]

😂😂😂

[@Santirata]

No rebuttal except to claim he's being paid? Just means you know he's correct and you don't have a factual comeback

[@Aaerys]

@@Santirata nice hasbara mr low level mossad agent

[@Aaerys]

@@Santirata look at the general sentiment from the comments on this video, and stop trying.

[@Aaerys]

@@Santirata nice hasbara from a low level mossad recruit

[@PKAClips]

2:36 - Joe brings up a great question

[@chickengenius4202]

My guy!!! Love the clips. I couldn’t deal with Woody for 3 hours

[@sweettantle8455]

If a bug comes near that fence they have a lock on it. Shits weird

[@arighteousname5882]

And it was answered

[@armandiic791]

@@arighteousname5882 great question, shitty answere

[@MarkTheLamplighter]

Only took them 7 hours to shut it down, in a place the size of New Jersey. They are either utterly incompetent or allowed maximum casualties as it would be psychological fodder for the complete annihilation of Gaza, which is absolutely a war Israel had wanted, hence Israel fomenting the entire Hamas situation and the stress that would inevitably lead to violent resistance. Israel is built off terrorism and thievery; King David Hotel, USS Liberty, the Lavon Affair, foreknowledge of “the greatest day for Israel” 9/11 (Urban Moving Systems, Mossad, Dominick Suter), Apollo affair, 1990s spy ring, Epstein, … Keep in mind Netanyahu’s opponent, Yitzhak Rabin, who sought peace with Palestinians was assassinated and his wife directly blamed Netanyahu.

[@user-qu9yp8pj1k]

Glad to see the aipac representative step in after joe went rogue

[@zdough1070]

So tell me Coleman Hughes what was the IDF doing in West Bank?

[@beshaxhaj2897]

They were building new homes for the Palestinians 🤣

[@MizrahimJudean]

PIJ and Hamas are in WB

[@succatash]

Following a treaty made between the PA and Israel.

[@juliocortazar8143]

@@MizrahimJudean Hamas is not in the West Bank...

[@The_jed8897]

Hamas sure is in the West Bank, you can simply google it. Either you are trying to hide the truth or just spreading misinformation on the internet without giving 5 minutes of research

[@balsham137]

An event that just allowed Netanyahu and israel to go full blast....fellas parachuting over the border with AKs against the most sophisticated border surveillance in the world as joe points out.

[@GOODJMR]

Most sophisticated doesn't mean shit if you're relying on AI tech. Which they were..

[@3rd_Base_Investigators]

Bro is glazing Netanyahu hard 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@shamekabenjamin8010]

🤣 😂

[@alancham4]

Bibi would appreciate it until he saw him.

[@joeyjonesSoCal]

@@alancham4lol

[@Kehvan]

Pally simp said what?

[@xavierb9061]

Blame black praise isreal..he knows where $$ is

[@PTracer921]

3:06 joe trying to act dumb here lol..

[@avramcs]

First time? I love Joe Rogan but any time anyone smarter than a rock starts questioning his belief in aliens, conspiracies, pyramids, covid, he all of a sudden doesn’t know shit and he isn’t “attached” to anything

[@erickmsuya8769]

They'll freeze his assets

[@kobalt77]

he has to for the show to not get cancelled.

[@akram2658]

So what’s up with the red heifer? What’s the deal with all of that?

[@vapormissile]

Fact: Heifers don't fit in rabbit-shaped tunnels. Act accordingly.

[@NorthLVLowRoller]

There's some pretty decent YT videos that cover it in depth, it's alot of information. Just the process of finding this perfect red heifer is pretty wild. Supposedly there are 3 candidates for it right now.

[@flymetothemoon9541]

They need the red heifers and the Muslims holy site that is the reason for this war , not Hamas

[@flymetothemoon9541]

The Zionist are trying to bring the antichrist in the end of the world with the red cows and third temple

[@theneighborguy]

That is the center of this entire lie.

[@JuliGts11]

I dont think it was false flag, but Israel knew that it was going to happen and let it happen. No doubts

[@mikeymike4sophie]

Ok internet guy

[@pkz420]

Your source is TikToc, isn't it?

[@JuliGts11]

@@mikeymike4sophie no problem internet bro

[@robertharper6481]

They were told by multiple intellegence agencies and Netanyahu government suppoters (the far right in Israel who believe that Palastine should not exist) had just stormed the AlAxar mosque...​@mikeymike4sophie

[@MustKillallHumans]

​@@mikeymike4sophieBest Intel in the world and even Egypt tried to tell them. Ok Sherlock

[@COJW516]

I'm sure this will be a civil comment section

[@michaelbays4419]

The Joe Rogan Experience I want a job with the UFC not fighting but anything else Backpage well

[@aidandaniels02]

Hamas did not outsmart the CIA, the Mossad and the IDF.

[@shredder9643]

​@@michaelbays4419.tf are you on about?

[@alitharealist4730]

@@shredder9643 Drugs.. To much is bad🧠🍳

[@shredder9643]

@@alitharealist4730 im saying. My guy didnt even form a proper sentence and was asking for a job? Like.... HELLO?! ME - "how much drugs did you smoke sir?" Him- "YES"

[@MrImaghost]

Spoken like a 24 year old. Gullible!

[@ChelseaFootballClub1905]

I’m 26 and was no where near as gullible as this guy 2 years ago

[@erickmsuya8769]

He's one of the paid off blacks used to spew this nonsense

[@DrillMondrian]

This is the foremost critical thinker on race in America according to the US Congress. He's not that gullible. He works for Bari Weiss. BTW he's 28.

[@MrImaghost]

@@DrillMondrian i don't care about his critical thinking on race, he's completely gullible when it comes to Israel.

[@DrillMondrian]

@@MrImaghost You obviously missed my point. Again, Bari Weiss signs his check. Gullible is not what he is.

[@Clarkem1]

The thought process of "thinks didn't end very well for the Israel so it couldn't be a f flag." Is a incredibly ignorant take. Regardless of what side you support.

[@Irish0wl]

💯

[@PTracer921]

Exactly the idea that Netanyahu gives 2 💩 about his public perception and isn't beholden to the MIC is crazy

[@vapormissile]

Literally supports the opposite

[@ethimself5064]

If Joe ever reads this - The Israeli government did know about the attack by Hamas for months beforehand as well as highly suspected one for a year and did NOTHING. So who is responsible? I have a solid link if you like. Nobody wants to knowledge this for some reason

[@MercurialStatic]

Hannibal directive, writ large.

[@TheBaldOne]

This guy speaks like he's making as he go...

[@MrDjmaidi]

He’s a known charlatan.

[@JuliGts11]

He's probably doing it

[@goodfella328]

Sorry he isn't sounding as convincing as your tiktok videos

[@MrDjmaidi]

@@goodfella328 you really think this guy is legit?

[@seanydoogs]

@@goodfella328 Only braindead dumbasses get news from tiktok, i get mine from my friend's little brother who watches tiktok. My facts are right! 😡

[@imanujakku]

All I know is Netanyahu was in deep trouble before the war and now has a chance to fulfill a lifelong ambition because of the war. The think tanks in Washington wanted to complete the work bush sr. started in the ME and then weirdly the exact thing they predicted would be the mandate to return happened …9/11. 🤷‍♂️

[@kellenwaters9087]

Used to enjoy Coleman, but his Mossad talking points are ridiculous. He needs to register as a foreign agent at this point.

[@kelleygreengrass]

Oh my god you're just childish

[@kellenwaters9087]

@@kelleygreengrass I guess I should keep an eye out for the IDF since they have a thing for killing kids...

[@AlexanderY18]

OMG he has a different opinion than mine...

[@kellenwaters9087]

@@AlexanderY18 Yeah. A sh!t opinion on a topic of enormous consequences. I otherwise wouldn't care if he doesn't like vanilla ice cream. You see the obvious difference?

[@AlexanderY18]

@@kellenwaters9087 do you understand that he would say the same about your side?

[@AlexanderY18]

Joe fans in the comments won't let a good opportunity for a conspiracy theory go to waste...😂😂😂

[@My_music_hannel]

Yeah. They holdin on strongly.

[@emotionaldamage_instantkarma]

Especially a conspiracy about Israel and Jews. Couldn't get any better.

[@Y.Alexander-gx7gn]

I think it's more about hatred towards Israel.

[@SandraI-tz6sy]

And all that, not knowing shit about Israel. Most people commenting are just repeating what they saw on the Internet and tiktok.

[@Uriel-Septim.]

Sayanim.

[@Themayseffect]

I've never heard anyone more brainwashed and delusional in my life.

[@Santirata]

You must be talking about yourself because Coleman has his head screwed on straight.

[@Aaerys]

@@Santirata look at you tryna fight everyone in the comments LMAO Israeli propagandist loser

[@KMFNYC]

@@Santirata nop, Coleman is clearly clueless of the ME geopolitics, he basically listens to western media and what it feeds him...I would assume you do the same too!

[@Santirata]

@@KMFNYC Sigh. You wouldn't be able to tell the truth if it slapped you across the face.

[@GOODJMR]

And you are not?.. Ever spent time checking yourself?

[@Rosamrisen]

When you try to act smart at the dinner table

[@TerryTibbs57]

They brought this guy back 🤦‍♂️🤡

[@SuqAdiq]

but not because he's black

[@Zak-ku7sq]

Why did he bring back this clown? Why not bring a Palestinian?

[@neon0025]

lol his points make no sense whatsoever. who even is this guy

[@kelleygreengrass]

He's making perfect sense you just have a confirmation bias

[@TP-pq9xx]

⁠@@kelleygreengrass The guy admits that Netanyahu helped Hamas maintain power, excuses that by calling it a mistake, and admits that Netanyahu pulled troops away from the border at the time of the attack. But then he also says Netanyahu is so smart and would never have done something to cause his polling numbers to fall. You can’t tell me that makes sense.

[@kelleygreengrass]

@@TP-pq9xx womp womp you're simple

[@myhandlehasbeenmishandled]

​@@TP-pq9xxthis is a know fact and it's been happening for decades. This is taught in most universities. And most of the west European politicians agree with it. Only American politicians act like it's not happening. Hamas would start losing Palestinian support. Israeli government would start losing support of their voters. Hamas would fire a few rockets into Israel. Israel would level a part of Gaza. Hamas would get money from Israel and other foreign nations to rebuild. At least up to now, we'll see if it continues. Suddenly, Palestinians see Hamas as heros for rebuilding Gaza and helping poor. And Israel did their military response against Hamas so their voter support is back up again.

[@Earl_wolf]

@@kelleygreengrasshow’s your settler family in Israel did they come back to their seconds home yet back in Europe?

[@httr94]

It was allowed to happen. There's no way Israeli intelligence wasn't aware of the situation.

[@joeyjonesSoCal]

100%

[@shmuelrosenbluth9741]

Did you not listen to what he said? Many pieces of information about an alleged upcoming attack were received. Thing is, No one knew when. He said that IDF were in the west bank because of protests, which was not the case. Many troops left the border to the west bank BECAUSE of information of something big that was going to happen. Hamas's spokesperson said in an interview they have been planning this for over a year underground, while overground, making Israel and the world think they have given up on their mission to destroy Israel, and focus on the wellbeing of their people in Gaza. Obviously turned out to not be true, as they didn't even use some of the billions of dollars they got every year to build shelters for their own people. Using the money to build terror tunnels, which the civilians can't even use as shelter

[@arighteousname5882]

Shut up. You obviously dont know shit about Israeli intelligence much less your intelligence at that.😂

[@lawrencefrost9063]

You are a moron if you think that

[@Mutawa95]

I think it was allowed so that Netenyahu could come off as a hero, and they severely underestimated Hamas's abilities. They probably thought itd be another 30 day war.

[@GeneralBlorp]

Oops I think he just committed a basic logical fallacy 🤦‍♂️ His contention that Bibi’s calculation “would have been so stupid” and therefore unlikely has little or nothing to do with Bibis actual mindset and potential to MISCALCULATE a situation’s downstream consequences. His miscalculation does not a refutation make, sorry Mr Hughes ya been got😅

[@leondb1443]

You can tell where Coleman is getting his talking points by how he (wrongly) explains why the IDF relocated from the Gaza border. They weren’t in the West Bank because of “the protests.” They were relocated to the WB to back up expansionist settlers.

[@justinrussell851]

100% IMO Coleman will be gainfully employed as long as he sticks with the script.

[@reboslilbro]

IDF always has troops by every border, a big factor of why there wasn’t a strong presence along the border was due to the fact that the attack happened on a Jewish holiday when all non essential personnel went home to their families

[@SunsetSheen]

So basically it was a false flag

[@Kreid5]

To many "Oops" for me...not to mention the Hannibal directive of shelling their own citizens...without Oct 7th they couldn't do what they're doing now...and I promise you they will take Gaza's Land when it's all over, that's the main objective...."The Greater Israel" plan BiBi has brought up several times... expanding Israel into neighboring Land...

[@TP-pq9xx]

Netanyahu is smart so there’s no chance that he didn’t perfectly predict how this would all play out. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@joebot2127]

Not a false flag, but they defo let it happen.

[@Psyfi85]

@@TP-pq9xxI.e. 9/11.

[@porter9494]

Palestine will be free... Free from Hamas and palestinians. From the River to the Sea Israel is all that will be. 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱 Mauslemz lost the war. Right now gazans are running, crying and praying to their pdf-file prophet and his 6yo wife. Will he save them? Nope. Justice for Aisha (she was 6).

[@lrza9953]

Israel can do no wrong. This brother is weird. Point blank period!!!!

[@madadisr]

Bro I don't like what they are going either. But it would be hypocritical for us to say anything seeing what we did to Iraq in the early 2000's.

[@hotsquirrel4277]

@@madadisrfine but let’s not aid them in this or any other way. leave them to fin for themselves simple

[@jopo7996]

I would find it way easier to listen to Coleman's viewpoints, if he would just calm down a little.

[@skepticalhippo6376]

😂

[@benfranklin100]

and guess who owns the companies this guy works for...

[@Itiswhatitis569]

Exactly- once he said he was on Bari Weiss’ payroll I knew his political leanings immediately.

[@mmd2156]

But if october the 7th had not happened, Netanyahu would have been charged with corruption and he would have been in jail by now. So every extra day in government is an extra day out of jail for Netanyahu! As for the intelligence agencies onky knowing that there was going to be an attack but didn't know how big or when it was going to happen is not true. Egypt and the CIA had goven the Israelis the heads up. The Egyptians even told them exactly how big this thing was going to be. And it was actually discussed within the government but was disregarded on the basis of their assessment which concluded that Hamas did not have the resources, logistics, manpower or the actual will to pull off such an attack. This is public knowledge it's been written on widely within Israel.

[@qigong1001]

Do you realize how many of these “reports” come in every year for decades?

[@mmd2156]

@@qigong1001 yes plenty, but it doesn't mean you should disregard them. Because it is their job to go through these "reports" and find actual threats and they let it slip. And there lies the culpability of the Israeli government!

[@qigong1001]

@@mmd2156 Monday morning quarterbacking, my friend.

[@mmd2156]

@@qigong1001 lol... True. But its not like we were playing on saturday night! The ones who were playing will have to face the wrath of the fans 😁

[@techhawk1543]

Bro graduated on Middle East Studies from the FOX News parking lot !

[@Ge0rge_0rwell]

FOX? The news organization?

[@Hothifa90]

Like literally, this guy sounds like a boring ass robot.

[@alitharealist4730]

Lmaoooo

[@alitharealist4730]

@@Hothifa90 fr there is some people that the more you hear them talk the more the boredom bs meter starts to flicker..

[@Eric-yi1px]

He works for cnn tho…

[@AriaDaStallion]

I wonder if this guy gets paid from AIPAC

[@WaqarKhanHD]

To answer you in Joe's style, it's definitely not 0 😂

[@scummymulisha]

By proxy yes, he works for cnn and Bari Weiss. Bari is pretty radical in that she'll go after and slander you if you criticize Israeli in any way.

[@Itiswhatitis569]

He works for Bari Weiss- might as well

[@devworlddaily]

i mean at this point who DOESNT lol

[@moamed2006]

ahhhhh it all makes sense now, every one of these grifters is on the zionist payroll, they pay a lot of people and celebrities to do their bidding when palestinians only need their cameras to show it all@@Itiswhatitis569

[@Daniel_B79]

Why is Joe listening to this guy?

[@alang4190]

cuz he recently made a book advocating ending race base politics which joe agrees with, & someone on the view called him a pawn for right wingers, snd joe hates the view

[@tonybanks1035]

because he's right

[@succatash]

Because he is a critical thinker, he listens to everyone one of his guests. Doesn't mean he agrees or disagrees.

[@dandaddalyon12]

Because he annoyed the left on some race stuff, unfortunately when someone annoys libs people then want their opinion on other things which they have no real knowledge on

[@jonlipi9669]

@@succatash he is not a critical thinker, he just repeats talking points that he heard.

[@beshaxhaj2897]

This guy belongs on the view 🤣

[@mulan2010]

Lol

[@toddileelee6935]

All i heard from him was : it wasn't a false flag because.....it just wasn't, trust me bro.

[@richardbently7236]

What about the red heifers?

[@DurzoBlunts]

And the altar? Pure coincidence haha

[@chickengenius4202]

This is the question

[@2bears1duck]

It's a very thought-out plan put into motion around WW2.

[@AlexanderY18]

Nothing. Just Palestinian propaganda trying to build an alternate narrative. In fact most Israelis have no idea such a thing even exists. Complete bullshit.

[@peterryan5606]

This guy is clueless!!

[@benfranklin100]

The worlds most advanced security system couldn't pick up 3 guys and a paraglider...

[@purdysanchez]

Israel claims 3000 Hamas fighters invaded on October 7. That seems like quite a lot to go largely unnoticed. Israel shoots children if they come within 300 meters of the border.

[@PatoMan1477]

3500 "guys"..

[@amsz6326]

3 guys 😂 ...3,000 gazans which infiltrated in different ways

[@BubbaGanooshhh]

@benfranklin100 couldn’t stomach the footage? A lot more than 3 guys and a lot more than paragliders.

[@countme1235]

What a dumb comment by the op 🙄

[@MarkTheLamplighter]

@JoeRogan please consider having on any of the following: * Bassem Youssef Max Blumenthal Gabor Mate / Aaron Mate Norman Finkelstein Jeffrey Sachs John Mearscheimer Col. Douglas Macgregor Ray McGovern Ryan Dawson Scott Ritter Miko Peled There are so many interesting conversations to have here, please consider inviting on any of these people.

[@EatonDix]

What a load of horseshit

[@zbtb4l]

Hughes is usually a pretty intelligent dude, but he has absolute no clue about this conflict, stay in your lane bruh

[@krustykrabfrycook7690]

Through the disbelief of American media and social media I cannot take anything that comes out of Israel at face value. Live, unedited video is a hell of a thing and its not in Israels favor.

[@jopo7996]

Free Young Jamie!

[@ehnoobsemaj7774]

He's been held hostage for far too long

[@vapormissile]

Jamie Lives Matter

[@SuqAdiq]

I even forgot what he looks like

[@artsho]

What happened to young Jamie? Is he OK?

[@jacobkrogstad9122]

Free Jamie from likely the best opportunity he ever had? gtfo of here.

[@balsham137]

why does this guy speak with so much authority and confidence

[@bigm317]

It’s called shekels

[@robertfaler7081]

It’s called common sense. The conspiracy theory just doesn’t make sense.

[@buakawfan333]

He was like this last time. I don't know why he was even invited back he seems so naive, the kind of person that normally winds Joe up. Yeah I dunno wtf Joe seems so interested in hearing this guy just waffle on like this. Weird.

[@kylen4701]

Yeah it's a bit weird. He's just an "internet guy" really. Not saying he is dumb or anything, but he is speaking like he is some sort of geopolitical genius with a decade in the military, foreign relations, economic forecasting, or something. Those ppl are all wrong half the time too lol!

[@joshwinninger3125]

I guess the same reason youtube commentors speak with so much authority and confidence lmao

[@angelozachos8777]

Suddenly , a dude in his 20’s is an expert on a 75 year old conflict !!!! 😂 Dudes on AIPAC’s payroll , too obvious

[@johnhodgdon2434]

The conflicts goes back thousands of years, but you are the expert, right...

[@threedragonstalk2123]

Were you not only alive in 1948 when the first modern war in this conflict broke out but also old enough to remember it and you were reading the news at the time and can recall how the event was covered when it was breaking news? If not, then what room do you have to speak?

[@mahmoudhijaz9890]

@@johnhodgdon2434it ain’t 1000 of years, four 5 centuries until 1917 it was ruled by the Othman empire where Muslims, Christian’s and Jews lived happily, until the Zionist movement came along.

[@TheAlbinoskunk]

Some guy on KZbin who learned about this conflict 6 months ago is suddenly an expert!

[@promisewanogho]

Are u up to 75 or u have to be old before you comment or u don't just like his opinion clown 🤡🤡🤡🤡

[@levilevikoo3708]

I served at Gaza Strip, 10 years ago that would never happened I can’t and I won’t go to deep but it just make no sense that they did not were aware. Its blows my freaking mind thinking that some dude from another country talking bulshit about even bigger bullshit which is my country This life is just surreal I would give my life away to show joe what bibi showed Elon but from my point of view

[@purdysanchez]

They were definitely aware. Egyptian intelligence warn them of an imminent attack 3 days before it happened.

[@moblessings5073]

We just gonna forget Israel is an European “settlement” in the Middle East? How do people just over look the facts

[@comment3711]

Honest question, couldn’t you say the same about the Ottoman Empire?

[@krisf4969]

USA is also a European settlement, nobody cares

[@moblessings5073]

@@comment3711 two wrongs make a right ? That’s the justification for continuing modern day colonialism? “Turkey aka Ottoman Empire did it”. We got learn from the wrongs and not use them to justify making the same mistakes.

[@Booyakasha5]

probably because it's not true. there are settlements in the area ,but Israel as a country is 100% not a settlement. "Palestine" on the other hand...

[@comment3711]

@@moblessings5073 This is a perfect example of reading into what someone is saying rather than addressing what they have actually said.

[@newgunguy4176]

They knew like a year before. They definitely allowed it to happen. It's the most convenient excuse.

[@LE-gs9mo]

Tell me something is a false flag without telling me something is a false flag.

[@Beantownpatsy]

An Occupied Ireland will never be at peace

[@adamcraig1468]

Ireland isn't occupied

[@sakibc1787]

​@@adamcraig1468 it was

[@Cantbearsed447]

Half of dublin is foreign at this point. Face it you fought for nothing.

[@navara5040]

Who is occupying Ireland?

[@kelleygreengrass]

Israel isn't occupied by the jews. It's their land. Get over it.

[@rp8164]

Really weird that there's almost no likes on the majority of these comments. Basically, they're being hidden.

[@MikeTython369]

That guys logic seems pretty flawed. Who TF is this guy?? Who's paying him to say this BS?!

[@tonybanks1035]

flawed? lol

[@MizrahimJudean]

So using stats and information backed by verified sources is flawed logic in this generation? 🤣

[@jonlipi9669]

@@MizrahimJudean he only repeats what he 'heard.' and we know who he 'heard' it from.

[@gohanson27]

I dont think guys understand what a false flag is.

[@beshaxhaj2897]

🤣 seems like he left the view to soon

[@stargazerh112]

Ask why they have “security threats “?

[@AbdallahBoufassa]

that's exactly what i was thinking

[@Ge0rge_0rwell]

Every country has "security threats". What were you referring to?

[@stargazerh112]

@@Ge0rge_0rwell to Coleman’s fake alarm

[@swisscheeseneutral6820]

Because Islam is a religion of peace

[@stargazerh112]

@@swisscheeseneutral6820 it’s not about islam v Judaism…nice try🤦‍♂️

[@anklebreaka03]

they moved the festival all the way across the country to put it conveniently right next to the boarder like 2 days before it happened.....wonder why

[@trkddy]

Why does the USA love Israel so much ?

[@fatemeh.06]

AIPAC

[@alitharealist4730]

@@fatemeh.06 Exactly This.. Money. they sell out people over money.. disgusting

[@TrevorMauk]

USA doesn't. The politicians do.

[@beratradinglog]

they run the Federeal Reserve, Also most powerful lobbys like AIPAC, Evangelicals. The Christian zios believe a sole J state will trigger return of Jesus.

[@RNG-999]

AIPAC owns 98% of all American politicians. I am not kidding.

[@Finishhim343]

Joe's been sitting on the fence for too long, he's got four cheeks.

[@ItsDooby]

My boy is yappin

[@Irish0wl]

So it's not a false flag... even though the iron dome was down? 😂

[@2bears1duck]

And they funded them 😂

[@yaakd]

it was not down

[@joshwinninger3125]

You think it was down...even tough it intercepted hundreds and hundreds of rockets that day?....lmao people just making it up as they go along now

[@AlexanderY18]

It wasn't. Nice try though.

[@2bears1duck]

@@AlexanderY18 I mean they just funded them and looked the other way.....

[@freetheworld2000]

This guy loves Israel.

[@adamcraig1468]

So do I

[@freetheworld2000]

I’d say he loves Israel more than America.

[@kelleygreengrass]

Me too man

[@domsanchez148]

Funded by Paul Singer.

[@Finishhim343]

It is the gayest country on earth

[@jacobtaylor7506]

Remember the US in Afghanistan bombed the wrong people, even when they have cameras on them the whole time.

[@Blashmack]

What is your reference point of success for 'the most sophisticated surveillance system' in the world? Do you know with certainty it will be able to catch everything? Even near the border? What about the other systems needed to suddenly mobilize, brief and send your troops to certain areas? These things are probably more difficult to do than we'd suspect.

[@tonygibson5171]

The second theory still holds up for this and 911

[@Unklephish29]

Definitely

[@Finishhim343]

Sadly, once again, Israel is not sending her finest.

[@purdysanchez]

Even the most skilled liars can only do so much when the counter argument is digitally documented with mountains of evidence.

[@21972012145525]

I'm so confused about his credentials to speak on this. What are his qualifications I v p? Genuinely curious

[@amrika7684]

Does Coleman Hughes work for Netanyahu

[@zakil25]

The guy prepared a "convincing enough answer to be said on a pod and can't be refuted unless you're really educated on the subject" which Joe clearly isn't not he should be tbh. Not the guest I'd have for the subject though.

[@AlexanderY18]

And yet the whole comments section is full of people who are clearly not educated on the subject, accusing Israel of everything possible...

[@musti3383]

Bro the way this guy is explaining things its like his trying to justify Israel's war crimes pre and post October 7th

[@MarineScoutSniper]

Coleman Hughes has no idea what he is talking about😂😂

[@jonlipi9669]

i noted on several occasions he responded with 'well what I heard was' or 'the information that i got was.' basically he's parroting what his handlers fed him.

[@Urelasir]

This coleman fella is full of himself

[@em3sis]

Lol are you serious

[@Urelasir]

@@em3sis Yup

[@davidmuro9029]

I'm sad that Joe didn't even try debating this kid. He just let this kid make up lies with nothing backing up his claims

[@kelleygreengrass]

He didn't lie

[@kobalt77]

because Joe knows we can read between the lines without him getting taken down

[@mj23926]

@@kelleygreengrasssounds like a bunch of lies to me. Nothing he said even made sense

[@rossmanchario4874]

He has a full beard and he s balding that’s not a kid.

[@kelleygreengrass]

@mj23926 it made total sense, you just hate Israel for suspicious reasons

[@gagediffee2722]

100% Netanyahu wanted to keep Hamas in power. Just look at his own quotes. He along with financial minister bezalel smotrich. “We control the height of the flame…”

[@AddieP91]

I'm a liberal Israeli (very anti Netanyahu), a Zionist, a patriot of my country, and I second that. Finally a based take.

[@emasee1]

His whole premise really depends if Netanyahu cares about his reputation.

[@operationb.e.n6480]

Its funny how Joe would have intelligent people like Dave Smith on the pod, and then sometimes would bring in this guy lmao

[@daratl5238]

Why did they delete the full episode?

[@denisovic4049]

Because to much truth was said from Coleman

[@jonlipi9669]

@@denisovic4049 lol

[@lplt]

this guy thinks he's so smart but he crumbles 3 mins in

[@aakuster]

What a simpleton 😂

[@2bears1duck]

It's not a false flag because we didn't do it ourselves, we just paid and looked the other way.😂

[@Parjesh888]

dude is certified yapper

[@oleyullah]

Judging by the comments, the number of people that allowed the JRE to be a replacement for their personality, news and intellect is truly astounding.

[@bubbles4769]

The Israeli government allows the attack to happen, but it had nothing to do with Netanyahu. They did it because they want the land. It's very valuable, and Israel is tired of pretending like they care. Coleman Hughes is laughably naive on this area.

[@TheAlbinoskunk]

If they want the land so much, why did they give it back to Gazans in 2005? They dismantled 20+ settlements and pulled every Jew out of Gaza, but you think it was just some 4D chess move to eventually take over the whole strip. Read a book

[@liamjones9115]

Guess who is never getting a second appearance on JRE. For claiming to know something about a subject they don't have enough acumen in.

[@Inosix]

They literally did have fore knowledge of 9/11. It's even in the officially story 9/11 commission release. Read it.

[@EatonDix]

When you wake up and realize it’s been five decades of this, you know this guy is full of shit

[@orenthalsimpson]

I wish Dave Smith was there correct him

[@MilaMath]

They can’t even make new stories anymore. The amount of crimes they made against humanity is so staggering. I wonder why they keep pressuring Joe to bring such idiots to the show

[@waroenkkini3358]

This is the main core question that people have to answer, what do u call people who fight for US independence in 1776?how long the war last?did those people blend with civilians?who did US war against?was it occupier, colonizer? So it was almost 250 years ago, US may forget as it was a looooong time ago. While for Indonesia we had our independence 78 years ago, so with humility let me remind you, in our country we called people who fought as our heroes, our freedom fighters. Further, the people who were heavily armed, slaved us, treated us like animals whom we called colonizer. Similar to all countries being colonized had experienced same pattern. Some just was too looooong ago so they forget or pretend to forget.

[@TimmyRue-bn3xe]

He argued against reparations. Yeah, I can’t vote for him. 3billion a year to Israel,argue that.

[@SuqAdiq]

$$$ make you argue for anything

[@Uglier.]

Curtis vs Allen gonna be crazy this weekend

[@hallahr]

He doesn’t mention that the guy had a court procedure that would’ve found him criminally liable that currently halted because of this. He also doesn’t mention the fact it took six hours for them to react and when they reacted, they attack their own people to make the situation way worse, who this guy is but he’s not speaking the truth

[@johnhodgdon2434]

Right sure, the point of a court hearing is to bring evidence, and see if it sticks, to say he WOULD have been found guilty tells me everything I need to know about your opinion, people you don't like are guilty until proven innocent, the worst kind of bastardization of a judicial system, thank God you have no actual power.

[@forsaken650]

The CNN came out of Coleman

[@peters4115]

“How do you know which one is a real threat?” Probably when the President of Egypt calls you personally to tell you about said threat lol c’mon bro this is some weak ass astroturfing

[@donniehutchens6700]

This country should stop funding Israel and Ukraine We need to worry about our own country's problems 1st amd formost. Especially being our own country is being invaded every day and has been for 4years. Smdh God help us before it's to late. 😢

[@ki2the2nd]

Guy is talking out of his ass on this one 😂😂😂

[@sondrax]

Ok… maybe. But someone tell us why it took ISREAL - touted as THE MOST ‘READY’ - 7+ HOURS to respond??? This starts to remind one of how long it took Bush to respond to 9/11…