Compare the BMW M2C vs 1M: the ultimate BMW M Car comparison!

[@blairheaton9042]

Brilliant review and inside knowledges. I've owned many sunday driver cars (Peugeot 205 gti, renault 200 cup, c63, e39 m5 and now a 1M. Whilst the e39 M5 is the only 1 i truly regret selling.... and the 1M high riding/seating position takes some adjuating too, it is a phenomenal car; at this price point. Not gonna sell this gem of a car. Thanks again for your content.

[@PointShiftDrive]

Glad you liked it... and thank you for watching! It means a lot. feel free to subscribe because I got lots more coming :)

[@caggianogroup9176]

@@PointShiftDrive Amazing video and comparison. I realize this is an old video but wanted to see if you had any thoughts on the new 2023 M2 versus these two cars. My only concern with the 1M and the M2 Comp is that most of them are now out of warranty. Thanks!

[@freedbeefpontoons]

This is a fun comparison. The other day I was sitting in my M2 Competition when a 1M pulled up and parked a half a block up from me. I couldn't help myself, once I got out of my car I had to make a detour in order to snap a quick photo with my phone. As much as I love my M2 Comp, I really doubt anyone is going to bother to go out of their way to take a photo of one. It's just never going to be THAT special of an automobile. Cool? sure. Different and a little rare? Sure. But it won't ever have that OG unicorn aura about it. Now for my use case, as my only street legal vehicle, I couldn't justify a 1M over something with a warranty. And even then the allure of all that horsepower and torque would've maybe steered me towards the M2 anyway. But the 1M remains undoubtedly the cooler vehicle and i'm sure it'll hold its value better. Still, its nice that BMW continues to build small, good looking, reasonably practical performance cars available with a manual transmission in 2020. I somehow doubt that will be the case for much longer.

[@PointShiftDrive]

I tend to agree with you. While we dont know what the future will hold... I think if we want BMW or any car company for that matter to continue to make great cars, we need to make sure we buy them new in greater numbers.... otherwise, we will all be driving appliances with no personality in the future.

[@wisruteb]

It's great to see a comparison direct from an owner, so thank you for taking the time to do this and to share with us. I own a 1M from new, and an M2 (DSG) from 2016. I finally sold the M2 just because I feel that the DSG does take away a layer of involvement and fun vs the 1M. I find both the power delivery and the suspension of the 1M more linear than the M2. The passive suspension is just simply very predictable despite a performance biased set up. Like you said, once it is loaded up, the steering and the seat of your pants tell you exactly what the front and the rear are doing. I find the M2 suspension to be overly busy both during low and high speed, and that's not the case on the 1M. The DSG 'box on the M2 also seems to shift at too high of an RPM even in normal driving. I find myself short-shifting every now and then to avoid the boomy sound from the engine. There's certainly enough torque, so I'm not sure why the default shift points are so high up the rev range. That becomes tiring and annoying very quickly. (Disclaimer: We bought the DSG variant mainly because my wife was the main driver of the M2.) Having owned the 1M for a decade now, I have two complaints. One is related to the fact that it struggles to put the power down a little too often. Even in a straight line, when the road is a little bumpy, the traction control light comes on way too often. The second complain is related to the quality of the parts on the car. Mine is parked indoor most of its life, yet I've had the rear BMW badge came off, roof lining came off, and the wheel cap badge came off. Other than that, the 1M will remain in my permanent collection.

[@PointShiftDrive]

Glad to hear you have a nice collection and that you have an appreciation for these cars. I actually had 2 1Ms at one time and never had an issue but as for build materials and quality, though I didnt have any issues, we have to remind ourselves these cars were entry level M cars. so they were build accordingly. You are also right, the traction light can be annoying,. just turn it off all together and get used to how the car behaves with no TC. you will become a more competent driver because of it. Thanks for watching

[@stevesas632]

DSG? Don't you mean DCT?

[@wisruteb]

@@stevesas632 Yes, DCT. 👍🏼

[@patricsteele]

If you ever get a chance to test drive the M2 CS I'd be great to hear how it measures up against the 1M.

[@achromaticwraps]

Just found your channel! Was really looking for this comparison video, thank you! Well thought through comparison. Keep the good work up

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thanks for checking out this vid and some of my channel. I really appreciate you watching.

[@FreshdriveGeoff]

Love the vid! You deserve more subs 🤘🏼 Was your LSB E46 M3 on BAT a few years back?

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thank you so much. I am working on growing the channel and people like you help me make it happen. Much appreciated! I don’t know if my LSB was on BAT or not. But I’d love to buy it back some day. It was a great car

[@BrakRulesAll]

I can totally relate to the hydraulic steering vs electric thing. My "fun" car is a Z4M coupe and it has fantastic hydraulic steering. Jumping back into it after driving my Golf R, which has a very good rack for an electric one, emphasizes just how much better the hydraulic setup is. It's a crying shame that modern M cars no longer include it.

[@PointShiftDrive]

Agreed. The good news is that electrics are getting better. But not fast enough.

[@Franzino]

Sold my Z4M, kept my (manual) M2...the only thing I miss is the steering feel of the Z4M, but that's it...nothing else ;)

[@almandog]

Awesome Production. I remember back in 2012 I went on BMW website and built me a White 1M for about $50,000.00. I then went to the BMW dealer here in Honolulu to order a 1M and the sales person laughed out: No you can't get those cars anywhere, they are all gone. Feeling humiliated, I left the dealership and called up BMW Head Office in USA and butched about how disappointed I was that I can't get a 1M and they still have it on their website. They said only about 700+ came to the USA. How could that happen? But that was it. So after searching for a 1M to no avail, I had to settle for a 135i in 2012; which I bought brand new and still have today with only 47000 miles. I am still looking for a 1M at an affordable price. Your 1M is just awesome and I see that you are a real BIMMER. The M2 is out of the question for me. I don't like how they look. Just my opinion. But who knows, I might come around.

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thanks for watching! Yes, the 1M really is something special. I think it’s still under the radar for appreciation but drive enthusiasts love this car. It just feels special all the time

[@qiknish]

I agree. I have a few cars ...but my 1M feels special. Mine is a totally bare bones no option car which I love. Especially when you look at the premium you pay today for an M4 CS or GTS with stripped down interior. The 1M had that back in 2011 and didn't make a song and dance about it. Simple get in and drive car...

[@PointShiftDrive]

The 1M is one of those cars that can’t be made again. Enjoy every minute of driving it.

[@adamcrain-MTB]

Swap out the seats and you will love it even more. The only issue with my 1M was how high you sit - the Recaro's made me realize how much more connected you are when your sitting "in it". Now the JB4 tune and other stuff doesn't hurt but the seats...MUST be done.

[@PointShiftDrive]

All bmws have high seats. I would love to swap in some CS Sportsters and maybe I will someday. I just don’t want to deal with airbag lights etc. and yes you can get the modules to fix that but just expensive and a bit annoying. But I know it would be worth it when you drive it.

[@tarquin161234]

Everyone says the 1m seat is high but I've never found that! My actual problem is I couldn;t have the steering wheel as low as I wanted because then the top of it would block my view of the speedo dashboard

[@mikedockal8978]

Great video, you got yourself a new subscriber. I'm very familiar with the M2 so here are my inputs on some of the things you mentioned: Looks compared to OG - I hated it at first, after some time (and seeing what they did to M3/M4) I actually like the aggressive grille and bumper. Revmatch - 3 ways to disable - DSC off, aftermarket tune like MHD or BM3, or just code out the shift pedal sensor (that has downsides like having to push the start button twice, no hill hold, etc ...). I actually like the rev match, on the track its great. Sound - the OG sounds 10 times better, equal length mid pipes are the answer for S55

[@PointShiftDrive]

Yeah those are more or less the main ways I read about if you want to remove auto blipping but like I said, I dig it now. Also thank you for watching and I am glad you enjoyed. More to come!

[@timmellor6411]

Don’t forget to post up the 1m into song details pls. I have the n52 e61 wagon warming up in the dark for a Sunday dawn drive 🤣

[@JoshuaM23]

Lovely video! I have a '19 M2 Comp and absolutely love it. I am scared to get in, or drive, a 1M though. Doubt I would want to get out of it....ever!

[@PointShiftDrive]

So glad you liked it... thank you for watching. consider subscribing for more~

[@Vision_3030]

Great video! I gotta say however that I love the more pronounced fangs of the OG M2.

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thanks for watching

[@gerlachjacob9957]

what steering do you have for the m2? great video

[@PointShiftDrive]

I have the M2CS wheel

[@draude48]

Great video and thank you for that. I also enjoyed the pictures - the best I've ever seen. The 1M is beside the E30M3 one of the best drivers cars I own and ever had. But now it's time to have a look on the M2C ;-) Keep on going with your Vids - love them

[@neelshah8417]

Awesome comparison. I noticed the car seat in the back of the M2, do you also use it in the 1M? Is it a pain loading your kid in and out of the back?

[@PointShiftDrive]

I actually have 2 car seats in the M2 for both kids. The M2 is tight but doable as a daily. In the 1M I have another kids seat since that car is more of an 'occasion' car for me. So to answer your question, yes... its a pain to load the kids in. BUT once they are in, we are all snug and happy. Its a small price to pay in my mind for such a fun car. Also the kids love it!

[@tumishangmaraks6490]

Through the end I just love how you tell a story abt 1M❤❤❤

[@joonkookim2826]

Great video. I am willing to buy 1m used car. Could u let me know the 1m got the auto rev matching function?

[@PointShiftDrive]

Nope! The 1M is full analog. Rev matching is on the driver. And it’s super easy to do in the 1M

[@victorlouzon5495]

what a work, seriously, only 3 900 subs ? So underated ! Good job ! Greetings from France !

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thank you for your support! Please share :)

[@murrayhiggins3061]

Great review, very nice edit, great content and sound. I'm 1M all the way. Currently have a 2009 128i and LOVE it. If finances make it possible I'll happily acquire a 1M as I think their scarcity and fantastic performance and build quality and future price appreciation is lovely.

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thanks for watching! Get your hands on one ASAP. Life is too short!

[@oliiverbetts]

I prefer the look of the standard M2, the comp looks longer and has a slightly different front end. But that engine and that silver is amazing.

[@luxsasha]

great comparison and solid videp

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thanks for watching!

[@timmellor6411]

What song is that at the start of the 1m intro.? Great review 👍

[@233815]

im 1M owner from China。love your video！

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thank you for watching! Please subscribe and share :)

[@vnaidoo5734]

Awesome video content!

[@PointShiftDrive]

I’m glad you enjoyed it. Thank you for watching

[@kaiichinose9590]

The OG M2 LCI looks damn near identicle to the m2 comp. I went with the m2 lci as i absolutely love the n55b (reworked). The sound is incredible. I did add the m2comp seats, s55 aluminum and carbon braces and returned the sterring to m2. I also did upgraded pure 750 turbo, vrsf catless downpipe, turner motor sports carbon intake, stage 2 hpfp, lpfp, upgraded charge pipe, new sparks gapped and tune and man this car is an absolute rocket. 545whp on 93 and 660whp flex fuel e50 blend. Its the perfect m2 in my opinion. Oh and also have the m2 comp mirrors and gts hood. Its very OEM plus. If i ever did an s55 engine i would do it in an m4 with a top mount single turbo otherwise as good as the s55 is the cransk hub needs to be addressed and it just doesnt sound great even with EL midpipes and the one good akrapovic exhaust costs damn near as much as the mods on my car lol. But lets just appreciate thag bmw is still giving us petrol and manual cars for now. Btw 1M is a legend. Love the video keep up the great content.

[@dmytrozhukov6743]

Excellent overview, thank you. I found the video useful. Well done, keep going

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thank you for the kind words. That means a lot.

[@JM-xx1pf]

Great video! I’m battling myself with selling my original owner 1M to get the CS. Side note did you do the n55 mid pipe on your 1M ?

[@PointShiftDrive]

I am running the Evo Akra kit. that replaces the midpipe with the Akra version. Its still not load though. CS or 1M... thats a tough one. I think the 1M is closer to going up in value to significant levels over the CS. both are rare and desirable but I do think the CS needs 30 more years to be a $150k car. The 1M might be there in the next 10. just my $.02

[@dee1251]

Very nice review. Could you tell me what front splitter and trunk spoiler you have ?

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thanks for checking it out! Please share! The front lip is Slek and the rear lip is BMW Performance

[@Iplayforfood88]

You sure are a BMW fanatic owning both a 1M & M2. The next car’s gotta have XDrive & Adaptive Suspension to go alongside my 135i 1M Clone. Great Video!

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thank you! I’m glad you enjoyed it. Yes those cars are pretty special. I was blessed to have to opportunity with both of them

[@ModMINI]

Just got a black one just like this. Love the car. it's a monster.

[@drdavediehl1]

Great video. And great story. Two awesome cars.

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thanks for watching

[@burningtoken]

Great video, sick cars and epic driving roads.

[@JustinHEMI05]

M2C all day any day for me.

[@PointShiftDrive]

I mean... you can’t go wrong with either one. 👍🏼

[@amintakruri6929]

Well made, very nice content. Thanks :)

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thanks for watching

[@amintakruri6929]

@@PointShiftDrive you mentioned that the M2 comp outperforms the 1M from the handling perspective, is this difference so obvious, like day and night? or it is just a little better due to new tech?

[@PointShiftDrive]

@@amintakruri6929 well without testing it’s just my opinion. However I can say with confidence that the M2 does every corner the 1M does but just at higher speeds. Sometimes significantly higher speeds. Therefore I feel comfortable saying the M2 handles “better.” But it doesn’t mean it’s more fun. The 1M has a more organic feeling. Exactly how you think a car should feel and behave, it does. The M2 feels like it’s a machine you have to learn to drive fast. I’m the end with enough money and r&d you can make either car a kitten on Velcro.

[@dp2901]

Had my 1M since 2011. People still sweat the car whenever I bust it out for a drive.

[@PointShiftDrive]

Great to see others like yourself want to hold on to these great cars!

[@pettersten1137]

Awsome video!

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thank you for watching and I appreciate that very much!

[@timmellor6411]

Nick I need the song from the start pls mate. Cheers bro

[@PointShiftDrive]

timecode?

[@PointShiftDrive]

"Go time" by Oliver Michael

[@timmellor6411]

@@PointShiftDrive yeah mate that’s the one cheers from Oz mate 👍

[@PetrolHeadBe]

Owned both ! I can only say i really miss my 1M ;) Gr8 video !!

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thank you. And please consider subscribing and sharing the video. Really helps my channel grow

[@xtlmad]

good video! well done

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thank you

[@blessingmtiza4659]

best review

[@Dominator775]

Valiant effort, but my god you need to chill with the color grading. Just increase the saturation and call it a day.

[@PointShiftDrive]

Ha! Yeah this was one of my first videos. I was learning how to make films and I could have made some better decisions but it was a bit of an artistic choice at the time. I’d make different choices today

[@martindiaz8330]

I have a 220i, my dream car is an mt m2

[@PointShiftDrive]

you really cant go wrong there...

[@kwaki82]

Nice video, happy to see 1m win again:) But disappointed, as you are afficionado and should shed a light over this, that you say it has e92 brakes, which never had 6pots, neither 1m.

[@PointShiftDrive]

I think I was referring to the 1M having the brake system from the E9X M3. The M2C had its own. Either way, thanks for watching

[@hotdognobun]

Manual OG M2 for me. It’s as is with no steering or suspension adjustment which is my kind of driving car. But if you gave me a choice i’ll take the stock 1M

[@PointShiftDrive]

Yeah. The 1M is just about perfect. Thanks for watching.

[@2006chunming]

Pretty much the best BMW ever created!

[@MihneaStoian]

One will increase in value, the other will not. ;)

[@PointShiftDrive]

Agreed.

[@ricowswave1324]

Hard to beat an N54 platform

[@PointShiftDrive]

Isn’t it funny how an older car can still compete with the latest and greatest?

[@defyyourlogic487]

The OG M2 is the proper 1M comparison. The comp is an overweight and shortened M4.

[@PointShiftDrive]

I agree

[@johnstape4488]

There's only 50-75kg between an f series M2 comp and a 1M though? I much prefer 1M for what's its worth.

[@Be22ThePig]

M2 Comp definitely looks better then the predecessor and makes the OG look dated. Also very good review very natural and professionally produced I was impressed, not that that means much from me 🤣

[@PointShiftDrive]

completely agree... its interesting to me that the little changes really add up to a superior car

[@defyyourlogic487]

No it doesn’t it. Terrible modern BMW pig grills, wheels that look like the wish version of what you’d find on the M4.

[@TheGenelive]

Dinan upgrades is the only 1M I would buy.

[@PointShiftDrive]

Dinan, when it was run by Steve was awesome. Now not as sure I’d put that much stock into the name.

[@aster5031]

1M

[@autobahngringo]

Love the video, love the 1M - well done!

[@PointShiftDrive]

I appreciate the feedback!

[@Bmw_1M]

The 1M still the best and Most unique M car

[@PointShiftDrive]

Hard to beat it.

[@Redline360]

M2C all the way!

[@PointShiftDrive]

Hard to argue. Both are so good.

[@billymania11]

Around here the 1M is considered to be goofy looking but everybody knows they are supposed to like it. The M2 (all variants) has a better look and appears more balanced. Both are good cars obviously but isn't the 1M getting long in the tooth?

[@PointShiftDrive]

The looks of any car are subjective but I hear you. The 1M isn’t for everyone. But that really isn’t it’s strength. I think if you drive it, all gets forgiven. It’s just not like anything else.

[@TheKillWizard]

The baby seat in the back. Lol. Just awesome, that’s how you raise petrol heads.

[@PointShiftDrive]

Both my kids will grow up knowing their sports cars ;)

[@aster5031]

10/10

[@PointShiftDrive]

Thank you for watching!

[@davidhunternyc1]

What? I gave a 1/2 hour of my life away and you still did not conclusively say which car you preferred? 😆 No subscribe from me until you come out with it.

[@nickpsaros9853]

I am sorry if it wasn’t more clear that I prefer the 1M. I guess I could have been more direct. Thanks for the feedback. Sorry if it felt like a waste of time but I appreciate your watching. Have a great weekend!

[@davidhunternyc1]

@@nickpsaros9853 No, it wasn't a waste of time. It was awesome but there was the build up only to be left hanging. Yes, I thought you preferred the 1M more but you were being so diplomatic I didn't know for sure. Thanks for the clarification! Oh, and the production quality of this video is top notch! Wow, the photography, the music, the font style and animation... really impressive. I'm subscribed! 👍🏻

[@nickpsaros9853]

@@davidhunternyc1 thank you sir!

[@DjNikGnashers]

I'm a BMW serial owner and love the brand. If I could afford to buy a 1M, erm no I couldn't drive something that ugly, with such a cheap nasty interior, without a proper M engine. You can get an M2C for less, and that is a much better car in every way in my opinion, looks amazing, proper interior, proper M engine. The only reason the 1M commands such high values is because it's rare, that's all.

[@DjNikGnashers]

Bought an OG M2, almost as fast as an M2C but sounds much better (and I think looks better).

[@glennt1962]

Is this guy married, otherwise he needs a woman real bad ,,😂🤣😅

[@roblynch165]

would you likr to try my 135i running stage 1 390 hp 500 mm torque ?

[@S58PSHIFTING]

Oh man if that's even close or better than my tuned up 2011 135I i will die, do you know the difference between these two cars? Also that e46 has nothing on that 1M, that one M needs to come back stronger and newer, they need a 2023 version of that car that will blow the doors off the M2, its gotta, they gotta make it, if they dont BMW is just going gay. Also question, i just saw you have a N54 twin turbo on that car, do you know you can make that car so much faster than the M2 with just a small tune and a couple of engine plastic parts switched to aluminum so they wont crack and lose pressure under all that extra power, have you tuned this car? But that M2 is my next favorite car of all time.