Pumpkin Spice New York Cookie Recipe | Cupcake Jemma

Pumpkin Spice and all things niceeee 👀🎃
We could not wait to share the recipe for these seasonal delights - everybody's favourite autumnal treat.. Pumpkin Spice NY Cookies! They're thicccc, packed full of white chocolate, pumpkin and of course all the spices - the ingredients you'll need to make your own Pumpkin Spice Mix is listed below! If you want to learn how to make your own pumpkin puree (instead of buying it in a can) we've linked a video below to show you just how to do it!
Happy Baking! x
How to make Pumpkin Puree - • Classic Pumpkin Pie fr...
PUMPKIN SPICE MIX
2 tbsp Cinnamon
2 tsp Ginger
1 tsp Cloves
1 tsp Nutmeg
MAKES 12 COOKIES
COOKIE DOUGH
230g Cold Butter
160g Light Brown Sugar
160g Caster Sugar
360g White Chocolate
480g Plain Flour
2 tsp Baking Powder
1 tsp Salt
1 tbsp Pumpkin Spice Mix
100g Pumpkin Puree
1/2 tsp Vanilla
Orange Food Colouring
Roll in Demerara Sugar
-----------
Become a Patreon BAKE CLUB member for a pdf download of this and other recipes, as well as Bake-Alongs, extra content, baking tips and more.
BAKE CLUB: / cupcakejemma
BAKE AT HOME: cupcakejemma
CAKES: www.crumbsanddo...
INSTAGRAM: @cupcakejemma
CAKESTAGRAM: @crumbsanddoilies

[@wajihbadri5112]

A very big thank you to everyone working on this channel. You are all amazing, guys.

[@nikkicoyne5513]

❤❤❤

[@CupcakeJemma]

You're very welcome!

[@BaeSe-mm5tx]

I really love to see Sally and Dane together. They are so cheereful while showing us how to bake some tasty things. Thank you ❤

[@thatsmycloud9169]

The Cookie Dreamteam is back! Sally and Dane, so great to see you and will try the cookies.

[@Stephen_Lafferty]

Hilarious energy between Sally and Dane! It's always good to have them give a two-hander baking demo!

[@humanbeing5928]

Yes please bake Sally’s favorite Autumnal NY cookie together. Y’all are the best together, so funny and easy going. ❤

[@dfontanesi]

YESSSS!!! Please do the Apple compote thingy cookie :)

[@lesliedausey]

I made this one last year, and they are absolutely scrumptious!

[@xiniaobando3160]

Hola chicos, recién me uno a este canal y me encanta la energía que transmiten, fabulosa receta se las voy a preparar a mis hijos, aunque en mi país no tenemos otoño aun así las voy hacer, mil gracias saludos🙋‍♀️ de Costa Rica 🇨🇷

[@CupcakeJemma]

Ok then 😏👌🏼

[@naomithompson2302]

Sally, I find it necessary to point out that you said both "fanny" AND "crack" in one cookie video and I laughed as hard as you did. I adore seeing you guys back together.

[@michelepeznowski9594]

Yes, yes, yes please make the Apple NY cookies!!!! Always sooooooooooo great when you guys are back together!! Always so much fun!! ❤️❤️

[@CupcakeJemma]

Woohoo!!

[@melaniebrooks6071]

Me and my children made these this morning... We have just eaten them now and are all in agreement that they are awesome! Thank you for the recipe. We love pumpkin spiced everything.

[@peachbyko]

Omg thank you so much Jemma and gang 😍☺️! Thank you for making this cookie easily vegan! Looks like im baking as soon as my toddler gets out of ballet! What a treat!!

[@CupcakeJemma]

Love this!!

[@gigigelvosa5023]

Great to see both Sally and Dane. Thanks for the recipe 😊

[@camillanielsen2415]

apple-compost-cookiiiiieeee!!!!🍪🥳✨🍏💕 such a fun video - dreamteam those two✨💕

[@lisasallery7860]

Dya mean apple compote? Compost would be a whole different taste 😂

[@camillanielsen2415]

@@lisasallery7860😂👌🏼

[@CupcakeJemma]

We will absolutely share the apple compote cookie!!

[@sandiecollins1261]

I made these for Canadian thanksgiving. They were a HIT. The kitchen smelled amazing. On,y thing I noticed is that 100 😮 of pumpkin purée wasn’t enough. The cookie dough wouldn’t bind together so I another tablespoon or so. Amazing. I’ll make these again.

[@sarahcunningham5649]

Yes please for the Apple NY cookie. Can’t wait to make these 😊

[@sharijd726]

I've been making my own version of this flavor for about a year! Love taking the base and recreating my own flavors!! So good to see you two!!!! 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@eszz38]

Thank you for the amazing cookie recipes! We also neeed a almond croissant coookie!!

[@CupcakeJemma]

Oooh almond croissant would be dreamy!

[@mitchlippman4382]

Absolutely terrific! You two are just so loveable. The recipe looks amazing - I’m going to have to try it! Thank you for brightening my day!!

[@CupcakeJemma]

Our pleasure! Thanks so much for watching Mitch!

[@nataliehamer2930]

Yay! More cookie recipes! These are my favorite 🥰😋 I am making these ASAP

[@Jettonx]

Dane doing the wink killed me, I love it when you two are in the channel together always laugh so much, these cookies look so delicious!!

[@CupcakeJemma]

Haha it's always a good time with these guys! 🍪

[@rumbanisse]

Oh I had to make these right away, I’m addicted to pumpkin Spice. And OMG they are SO good ☺️🤩 And yes yes yes please to the Apple NY cookies 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@dipaschall]

Yes, the apple ones please!!!!!

[@tarryngee11]

Oh my GOODNESS! These are going to make my tummy sooooo happy!

[@CupcakeJemma]

Haha yes they will!!

[@zacharywong483]

Those look absolutely incredible! The sugar on the outside looks so good too!

[@CupcakeJemma]

They look all sparkly and cute with the sugar 😍

[@WhiteCrownlessQueen]

OMG colour me stoked for this recipe, can't wait to try it soon, looks gorgeous!

[@MrJamesreeves63]

Literally had one of these today and they are phe👏nom👏enal

[@CupcakeJemma]

That makes me very happy!!

[@MaricaLolli]

I love the videos where they are together and I would love to see them prepare the apple cookies!!!! They made me soo curious now!!! 😮😮😮

[@catherinechisholm6208]

So glad to see Sally and Dane together again; I have missed you two so much. I definitely would love to see the apple compote cookie. ❤

[@CupcakeJemma]

Well then we must film it!!

[@gemgem2705]

You both put a smile on my face, 😊❤

[@purdeen]

“Let’s show you the crack” 😂 great fun video! Love to all x

[@CupcakeJemma]

😂😂

[@dcd7511]

Can’t wait to try these! And yes please on the Apple NYC cookie

[@CupcakeJemma]

You got it!

[@hasnabam263]

thank you Dane and Sally for this recipe, look delicious! yes! please, the apple cookie recipe !

[@janehicks2266]

Omg I am all for this cookie!! I am in London at the end of the month and can't wait to find you and grab some cookies ❤

[@CupcakeJemma]

Woohoo! We can't wait to see you in store!

[@trinesvarechristiansen699]

Oh yes, big YES to the Apple Cookies 🍪🍎

[@helenjennings9190]

yes! The apple!! Love you two so much

[@adalahi]

I'll be making this soon for sure

[@katherinearthur7171]

Pleaaase do a minced pie chunky cookie for Christmas😍

[@vanessav.4996]

I'm totally making these this weekend!

[@islandangel]

Made these today. Substituted cream cheese flavoured chips for the white chocolate chips; so good. Will try the cream cheese flavoured chips in the red velvet NY cookies next time as well. Thanks for sharing another great NY cookie recipe!

[@CupcakeJemma]

Cream Cheese flavoured chips?!?! WHAT!! We need these 😂👌🏼

[@islandangel]

@@CupcakeJemma Yes, something new I found in our grocery stores here in Canada. Not a high quality product like Callebaut as they are made by Hershey, but was good none the less 😊.

[@Choungie]

OMG, yes I would love the apple cookie recipe ❤🎉😊

[@CupcakeJemma]

😏🍎

[@drgeorgeian1888]

Mmm, Yes ! ! ! Apple ! ! ! Thank You ! ! !

[@pamestes2119]

These sound tremendous. I think cinnamon chips would be amazing in them too. Trying tomorrow 😃Love yall🥰

[@CupcakeJemma]

Ooh cinnamon chips?! They sounds like a bit of us!

[@lesliedausey]

I can't wait to make these! I may swap the white chocolate for toasted pecans and pie crumb.

[@CupcakeJemma]

Delicious!

[@maddypham]

I like the conversation of these 2 amazing buddies, they bring me joy before my bedtime. BTW, which temperature is the best for 70g cookie? Thank you so much.

[@beverlyhess611]

Of course we want the apple crumble cookie!

[@keelydennis275]

Those look amazing! ❤❤

[@beatrixweis6509]

I love this dreamteam!!! I love the Gang too!❤

[@CupcakeJemma]

Thanks 💖

[@mominetti]

Yes, the apple compote and oat crumble cookie, please! 🍪🍏🤤

[@CupcakeJemma]

You got it 🫡

[@Sarahxkop]

Yay! Been waiting for this!!! 😋

[@nicolabarnes1787]

I LOVE this channel so much. Thank you so much for using regular flour instead of self rising because I always have a/p flour on hand. I will make these and tag you guys on Instagram. 💃

[@CupcakeJemma]

Woohoo! We can't wait to see how you get on!

[@neverstopasking8424]

Way, WAY, too long since your last New York style cookie. Absolutely love pumpkin spice baked treats. I'm definitely making a batch this weekend with some of your caramelized white chocolate.

[@CupcakeJemma]

Oooh that sounds absolutely divine!! Enjoy 😘

[@Brandon-oy1zj]

Thank you so much for fulfilling my request.

[@PinkCircleO8]

I have to say that Sally reminds me so much of one of my friends from high school in terms of personality. I showed that friend a video that was just Sally and she said to me, "She's like my British twin!"

[@CupcakeJemma]

😂😂😂

[@denisebatalha3552]

Thank you! More brownie cookies!

[@BlahBlah-cn3cs]

I was just looking for an autumnal/halloween bake to try out!

[@CupcakeJemma]

Well I'm glad we could assist 😏

[@lynnbarendsen3648]

SO yummy! Yes, pls do the apple compote cookies (I have the cookbook, have made them, love them!). Also: what do you think about a filling for these pumpkin spice cookies? Caramel? Biscoff?

[@CupcakeJemma]

a biscoff filling would be lovely - or some sort of cream cheese/cheesecake?!

[@lynnbarendsen3648]

@@CupcakeJemma oooo-yum!!!

[@elisejegou-barr6971]

It's just such a joy to see you two together! Just one question, you say it's important to use unsalted butter, coming from Brittany this isn't something we use at all, always salted butter. So why should we use unsalted butter instead?

[@zoec8796]

It's because salted butter can contain different amounts of salt - some are extremely salty, others much less so, even within the same brand. Because they want to control the amount of salt, they use unsalted butter and then add salt into the dry ingredients, that way they know they always have the same flavour every time they bake. But if you only have salted butter, of course the recipe will still work with that! Just leave out the salt when mixing the dry ingredients.

[@CupcakeJemma]

Exactly this!

[@mmakomanyatja5213]

Wow you two work together very well nd Tha k you so much for Superb recipe always nay the lord bless your family's

[@giovanaschuler]

yaaaaaaaas 🤩 thank you so much, guys!!! 🧡

[@CupcakeJemma]

You are very welcome!! 🧡

[@RufaidaAnsariaNusra]

My forever favorites! ❤️

[@AdhorleKitchen]

Yummy cookies Watching from Italy

[@duanesarah1028]

Yes to the apple ones!

[@lovelylangers]

Oh Sally you are so funny. Good bit of UK innuendo ! 😝

[@CupcakeJemma]

😂😂

[@gettingleanwithjanine922]

Can’t wait to make this one. Thank you so much these are the perfect complement to the season. Where can we get those cookie containers for the freezer? Ty

[@CupcakeJemma]

Any food storage containers will work for these - we got ours online from a website called Nisbets 👌🏼

[@jodiehall4191]

Fantastic! Thank you both!

[@CupcakeJemma]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@tammybozza4703]

These look so good! Did you blot any of the liquid out of the pumpkin purée or just use it straight from the can?

[@CupcakeJemma]

Just straight from the can 👌🏼

[@tammybozza4703]

@@CupcakeJemmaThank you! Makes them that much quicker to prep. 😊

[@miryamamar3420]

Another great cookie recipe. Please make us the Almond Croissant Cookie. Thank you.

[@littlellama7]

Love all the combos you come up with ❤ I'm wondering why you haven't been baking on hot pans in the last couple cookie videos?

[@CupcakeJemma]

We're trying a few things to see what makes a difference to the outcome of the cookies and found that preheating the tray isn't always necessary!

[@thebigmeringuetheoryelliot595]

Thanks guys for another amazing video. Will definitely be giving these a try, hopefully they are as good or even better than the rest velvet cookies!!! 😏

[@CupcakeJemma]

Ooh we love a good red velvet cookie - they are different, possibly better 👀 personal preference I guess 🤷🏼‍♀️

[@kirbyimage1]

You guys are fun to watch! I tried the recipe but mine came out a bit claggy instead of oooey and gooey. They were crisp on the outside but too under done on the inside. Any suggestions?

[@Rube1181]

I'd love to see limoncello tiramisu 🍋🍋🍋😍

[@deborahwood4728]

Mountainous terrain love it

[@marthaluciaviana1524]

Felicidades lo hacen súper bien me encanta todo lo que hacen ya hecho varias preparaciones y queda deliciosas . Lástima que los productos que ustedes venden por Amazon no tienen cobertura para el país donde vivo Colombia😢🫶🏻🥰

[@dianisima27]

I drop everything to make them asap 😂❤

[@CupcakeJemma]

Haha I would do the same!

[@advadvary]

Yay!! Thank you!❤

[@nicolabarnes1787]

I would love seeing more cookies that is not NY style thank you.

[@susan-s5x7g]

We want them xx

[@drgeorgeian1888]

Hi! What is best option for baking in a non-convection oven? Lower heat? or Lower time? Thank You!

[@YouTubetail]

Delicious 👍🏼

[@millalamilla]

Thanks for the recipe! I’m looking forward to Ube New York Cookies if that’s possible

[@CupcakeJemma]

Ooh we'd love to make some Ube cookies!

[@brigittekomara9036]

Yes, please do the apple cookies!

[@CupcakeJemma]

You got it! 🍎🍪

[@patriciaunsworth2203]

Dream team

[@davidhensley76]

I wish you had access to homegrown pumpkins. They tasty so much better than the canned/tinned varieties.

[@CupcakeJemma]

I wish we did too! I mean we can buy pumpkins in the store but ya know.. 🤷🏼‍♀️

[@filomenacavallaro408]

Looks really yummyyyy 😋😋😋😋🥲🥲🥲🥲 Bravissima Sally and Dane💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯🥰😘😘

[@missvanmartins]

Is he Brazilian? 🫶🏼🫶🏼 lovely recipe

[@hannah-nr6oz]

omg sally 😂❤️❤️

[@CupcakeJemma]

😂😂 she was on one that day!

[@ethna69]

Please do a pumpkin basque cheesecake

[@kaylaruthhall38]

We're all.messy cooks 🍳 it's alright ..... I've done it before 😊

[@matthewthompson936]

apple cookie!

[@danavillani7720]

Yummy will you do an Apple flavour???

[@CupcakeJemma]

We will!! 🍎

[@lisasallery7860]

I baked these cookies and had a strange thing happen. I had some cookies spread and some stay high. From the same batch, cooked in a fan assisted oven, with an oven thermometer. I thought it might be one half of my oven was heating more than the other half. But the next day I put 4 more in out of the freezer and the side of the oven where the cookies spread previously hadn’t, they had spread the other side. It wasn’t this flavour. It was the extra chocolate flavour. With cocoa in the dry ingredients. Any ideas?? 💡

[@jaynehall5592]

More cookies please

[@paulettediaz9087]

😮😮😮😮

[@nathanmcduffus]

Is there a reason you haven’t pre heated the baking tray for these?? I wanna make them and always preheat the baking tray but noticed you didn’t on this one??

[@CupcakeJemma]

No reason at all, we're trying new things and found that these cookies didn't need it!

[@benoosthuizen4961]

Apple compote cookies please! 😊

[@betseygirard8878]

These cookies do look amazing. I am not a fan of white chocolate so I will need to substitute cinnamon chips.

[@CupcakeJemma]

Oh I love the sound of that!!

[@chondraalmeida28]

I would have to sub sweet potato for pumpkin because my family won't eat pumpkin 😂

[@CupcakeJemma]

You totally can!

[@tpronko1]

Not using eggs is very unconventional and would seem to not work. I'm tempted to bake these with an egg. Sally and Dane, did you experiment with eggs? If so, how come you opted not to include them? Very curious.

[@CupcakeJemma]

Eggs aren't necessary for this recipe - the pumpkin puree acts the same way an egg would - much like with eggless/vegan baking 👌🏼. give the a go and see what you think!

[@zenobiavyas9568]

Thanku

[@LifeofMaria3]

They don’t sell demera sugar in the Netherlands. What can I use?

[@CupcakeJemma]

You could use a granulated sugar instead - basically any corse sugar 👌🏼

[@itrytobeuniqueful]

please please show the apple compote cookies :)

[@CupcakeJemma]

okaaaaaay you've twisted our arms 😏