DARK SOULS: Was it Really That Good?

[@mrt.1903]

Saying that ds1 has a bad second half has to be the biggest internet hoax/collective hallucination I've ever seen

[@cyruz7704]

Yeah, only Demon Ruins and Lost Izalith were bad.

[@CassidyDylyn]

On the modern internet, "not as good" or "lesser" are equivalent to "bad".

[@danithefoot633]

Nothing really tops Anor Londo half way through tho, and running into 30 dragon butts is kinda weird

[@coolkid9967]

The second half had enough serious problems that I can understand the sentiment. If you consider DLC though, it’s really the second third of the game that’s bad. Tomb of the Giants, Lost Izalith, and New Londo Ruins, and Demon Ruins kinda suck imo. Lost Izalith is the worst by far, New Londo is the best of the worst due to the creepy vibe and 4 kings ( the ghosts suck though). They just can’t compare with Undead Burg, or Anor Londo. They are of substantially lower quality. Similarly, they are worse than every DLC area.

[@tezereth]

I will forever be a tomb of the giant defender when stuff like the literal light spell and sunlight maggots are a thing

[@ShahidAljoker]

Do you A. Get gaslit by the gods and sacrifice yourself ( the canon ending B. Say no and “see a red Door and want it to turn black”

[@Guyinthetie]

The gods had their time! It's time for the moustache monster arc 💪🏻👔

[@ShinoTheMindless]

Short answer: Yes

[@Guyinthetie]

Long answer: 40 mins of cringe British VO that is also yes

[@thedarethnator2216]

Nahhhhh really ?

[@ogemaweyaus4105]

It felt like going back. To the NES days. Where everything was tough. Most don't understand that era of games. Mega Man, Castlevanias, Double Dragons, etc. Dark Souls is a return to what games were. That's why I love it. Tough but fair.

[@sparkls4492]

Pyromacers: Killing every boss before they get the chance to breath.

[@TheFloodFourm]

@@sparkls4492 it was quite a challenge to compile all the information required to pull that off though, right? Oh wait, you didn’t do that you probably just looked it up.

[@tezereth]

One thing that's important to note about the second half was that just..... there was budget and time constraint issue. It's not much the devs stopped trying but rather they didn't had much of a choice and had to rush, so some area's like the demon ruins and especially bed of chaos ended up pretty terribly.

[@Guyinthetie]

It does heavily feel rushed, though the DLC and the painted world do help with the second half being manageable like i said people call it boring but I'd say just luke warm 💪🏻👔

[@Spectrum0122]

I feel Gwyn being underwhelming is intentional. He's a god who turned hollow desperately clinging to the age of fire only to be taken out by a normal undead. A bit ironic since he created the darksign to keep undead weak

[@Guyinthetie]

That's actually a great take! Love the irony on it 💪🏻👔

[@BloodyCinder]

Yes, an amazing game but wish the remastered edition had been a better improvement than it was

[@Guyinthetie]

It does a sub par job ngl but at least it's not running on games for windows anymore 💪🏻👔

[@Brooksey1992]

Us console people went from Blightown’s 4fps to 60fps, that’s the only thing i need

[@andrei.242]

I think its perfect the way it is

[@darkinviolet]

And props to you for entertaining me with your old play-through of the game! This game will always have a special place in my heart, one of the first games I've ever played on the 360. It just clicked for me and I've been a fan of the souls series ever since. Good video man, love the editing. 💜

[@Guyinthetie]

Thanks dark! One of the OGs here!! Mad appreciation to you for all the support 💪🏻👔

[@razorstargazer]

I started playing dark souls last week! I absolutely love it so much, Im glad someone else is enjoying it! I was a biiit late to the souls party 😅

[@thecr3at0r75]

Never too late to play some souls. Keep at it, and don’t you dare go hollow.

[@smokey12823]

I'm loving all these new generation of youtubers playing Dark Souls 1

[@quartzninja]

You can get to Sif if you're incredibly lucky, or if you kill the Darkroot Basin Hydra first. There's a ladder on the other side of the waterfall to the left of where you fight it, and that leads up to the area beyond the locked door.

[@King_Pingus]

“We defeat boogie2988”😭

[@Guyinthetie]

Kinda feel bad.. but not really 😂

[@King_Pingus]

@@Guyinthetie don’t feel bad you earned my sub

[@bigiron1990]

I just started my own play through yesterday. The older slower combat while “easy” now is so refreshing. Something about the art direction in this game also is just timeless. Dark souls will always hold a special place in my heart…. Except the bed of chaos, F… off and die 😊

[@Guyinthetie]

I'm not a fan of the slower paced combat anymore but I agree with art design being on point in DS1 💪🏻👔

[@peinceoffreaks1093]

2:00 yes, please 🥹

[@tonesdad0408]

2:32 he's in the Backrooms now

[@fadpanda3873]

Hopping a remake where we're not forced to kill Sif and a better Part 2

[@Guyinthetie]

Not having to kill sif would make it the best version of DS1

[@crabbypatty10fefrefe]

I’m playing it currently. YES is was really THAT good!

[@quartzninja]

The bells signify other players, and you'll get estus whenever folks kindle bonfires.

[@Lardzor]

Luckily, there is a great area for farming humanity next to the Manus boss fight.

[@hilmalumay]

Question: Do I really need to play DS1 and 2 to play DS3? the graphics are not doing it for me on the 1st 2. Coming from Bloodborne, my very first Soulsborne, I fell in love with the eeriness and the mystery of the world and the lore of it. I love it, trying to plat it now. But going back to DS, I already have a DS3 copy..So do I need to play the first 2? what's your honest opinion?

[@Guyinthetie]

You don't NEED to play them first but there are nods to the previous titles in DS3, so it just down to of you want that stuff to go over your head or not But I wouldn't say you need to play them at all 💪🏻👔

[@aliyan247]

This game is very weird, I played this game at the start of 2023 and absolutely hated it for the first 60 hrs where majority of it was spent on not know where to go and wandering around aimlessly to find the second bell of awakening and getting into anor londo castle but as soon as I defeated O&S for the first time after god knows how many tries, the game finally clicked for me and I finished the second half(dlc included) in 20 hrs. Now I've done many playthough of this game that are less than a quarter of the total time that took me to finish it at first and now it is one of my favorite games of all time. So do I recommend this game as your first souls game, if you have the patience and can deal with the bs it throws on you then yes, but if not then play the other games since the start is quite hard to get pass through without guidance

[@Guyinthetie]

It's really hard to recommend to gamers who haven't played titles like this nowadays but it is a classic so if you can look past it worts and all it's definitely worth the time to learn 💪🏻👔

[@TheShane209]

Thanks again for my favorite D list KZbinr and a great video. If I didn’t get one soon I was gonna buy a tie and end things quicker than my dad left us

[@CassidyDylyn]

3:32 You chose to heal directly in the attack range of a boss that you know would knock you into a death plain. Bed of Chaos obviously has design faults, but that is quite literally a skill issue, not a dev issue.

[@Spectrum0122]

Random nitpick irrelevant comment

[@StormOfSin]

is yulia the name of his bucket. is this the undead merchant lore ive been looking for

[@Guyinthetie]

That man does love his bucket 🪣

[@yearoldsinger]

16:51 you’re saying this from someone with years of experience on the game potentially skewing your views, a new player it’d take awhile to realize the meta for bosses and would just try to learn their attacks or ways to counter them, giving them the hard time, especially when the series was new and nobody knew about it or players coming from Bloodborne after where that doesn’t fly, you’ve got to think about it or hear about it before exploiting it

[@Guyinthetie]

Won't deny it seems more arbitrary for me having played the game a few times but I do feel the game sets you up in the first fight with the asylum demon to focus the back weak spot and it's a trend with most the bosses after 💪🏻👔

[@iainkilcar7463]

@@GuyinthetieI played dark souls after having beat dark souls 3 and played part of dark souls 2. The first dark souls has some of the biggest level road blocks in the form of blightown, sens fortress and the silver kniight archers in anor londo. Everything else in the game isn't too much of an ordeal for first time playthroughs but these three areas definitely lived up to their reputations (though only anor londo keeps it's challenge on repeat playthroughs dye to the master key blightown skip and the fact that you will have the sens fortress timing seared into your brain after the first time). Though the npc questlines are awkward but what souls game has intuitive questlines?

[@HeldrikBoldhart]

Kings Field is actually the true 1st... Also try the armored core games

[@Guyinthetie]

Never tried it but heard it's pretty tough worth looking back at in your opinion? 💪🏻👔

[@prodbyANT]

Yes. Hope this helps!

[@Guyinthetie]

Where were you before I spent 2 weeks on this video 💪🏻👔

[@Hugo_Tate]

He’s worried about gaping dragon until ceaseless discharge lol

[@jesusarmandocontreras2742]

The series didn't go mainstream until * Names the least selling game of them all * P.s. Yes sales don't have to do anything with quality but IMO what happened between DS1 and III (and even until Elden Ring)was that a lot knew the games existed but didn't play it themselves.

[@skipper9676]

i love your videos, do bloodborne next :)

[@Guyinthetie]

Oh Bloodborne is 100% on the table love that game to death 💪🏻👔

[@William-Sunderland]

Yes, a masterpiece.

[@Guyinthetie]

Flawed masterpiece 💪🏻👔

[@alitatoe]

Me when I eat good with another tie video 💅 let’s go

[@Guyinthetie]

I aim to please 💪🏻👔

[@dragontrainer-ng1tc]

One the time travel I am stuck on the end boss and I have been playing for 1-2 years now

[@Guyinthetie]

Manus is super tough! Honestly I managed it in a couple of hours purely down to the superior dodge roll 💪🏻👔

[@dragontrainer-ng1tc]

@@Guyinthetie a few hours of making this comment I tried again and managed to kill manus (I was looking at the time of when I started and ended so in half an hour I managed to kill manus

[@Guyinthetie]

Congrats man! Ngl taking out manis is an achievement! Wear it with honour 💪🏻👔

[@jasperfox6821]

Lost Izalith....more like, rushed Izalith, am I right gamers? 😎

[@Guyinthetie]

That's good! Write that down 💪🏻👔

[@OtterMachine]

Great video. I love DS1. As someone that started on Elden Ring, then after played DS1 I have to disagree about the clunkyness, its not that bad. I found DS2 way more clunkier and after a few hours of DS2 I quit playing cause it didnt play like DS1 (backstabs and parries felt weird, hit boxes are weird, movement is weird). Playing DS1 after Elden Ring was a smooth transition for me personally. I also found the world as magical and engaging as Elden Ring (just not as epic).

[@ethandesangles]

DUDE! I love SSoHPKC! The first KZbinr I subbed to.

[@Guyinthetie]

Same here! Shame he took a break from content creation but I refuse to ever unsub 💪🏻👔

[@InfestedJester]

Yes

[@Guyinthetie]

True

[@smoothyodaproductions4373]

Yes. Dark Souls was great and it still is

[@AtreyusNinja]

ds1 is just good ( actually very good ) for a first, maybe second experience, that's it. no replayability.

[@Spookiyomi]

Love the game but yea the second half is very lack luster especially the final boss

[@Guyinthetie]

Only downside to DS1 imo 💪🏻👔

[@guillaumeinjjuz1744]

Im sorry but I cant enjoy DS1 and DS2 . I started with bloodborne than ds3 than sekiro than elden ring and ds1 and 2 feel to old to me to enjoy. Needed to be there at that time to enjoy them

[@Guyinthetie]

This is why I find the game hard to recommend to players coming from the newer titles 💪🏻👔

[@kelpyg7301]

Dark souls should of took notes from Elden ring

[@JoyTuub]

TLDW: Yea.

[@fabiopaizante1087]

Loving the content, the stuff you make is actually the bomb and I’m surprised you don’t have at least 6 digit subs. Manifesting the best for you 🙏

[@SurprisedMan.]

Yes it was and still is really that good…

[@gingerknight4753]

Gwyn is Hispanic

[@allenwilhelm7799]

"... old white guy" I acknowledge your virtue

[@Surelynotcat]

Sekiro?

[@jamesygamesy5124]

dark souls 2 better🥱🥱

[@Guyinthetie]

Actually agree and I feel dirty for it 💪🏻👔

[@nuperaa6617]

Incredible for it's time, even DS 2 was better than every crap from its time 😂

[@ryandavid9850]

Terrible

[@Guyinthetie]

The game, the video or the content creator? 👀

[@ryandavid9850]

@@Guyinthetie the game is excellent, the video is top notch, you're fine, the pov is terrible