Dead By Christmas Morning: The Brutal Silencing of Sameena Imam

🌍 Get exclusive NordVPN deal here - nordvpn.com/eleanor It’s risk free with Nord’s 30 day money-back guarantee! ✌️
On Christmas Eve, two brothers orchestrated a vicious murder. Sameena Imam was enjoying a secret affair with her Costco colleague Roger, whilst he was plotting her death. She thought they were in love, but he just wanted to shut her up.
Listen to my true crime episodes as a podcast:
bit.ly/3qtVG20
Request a case - www.videoask.com/fsuda4gnk
My second channel - @ellieneale1
My Links - linktr.ee/eleanorneale
Business - [e-mail]
Disclaimer: I mean no disrespect to anyone that I talk about in this video. Everything in this video is publicly available information that myself and my team have found and compiled into one piece. This video will cover especially sensitive topics, viewer discretion is advised.While we make every effort to fact-check our sources and make sure all our information is correct - no action should be taken in reliance upon the information in this video. Please keep the comments respectful and kind. All opinions in this video are mine alone.
Thank you for watching!! Xx

[@EleanorNeale]

🌍 Get exclusive NordVPN deal here - nordvpn.com/eleanor It’s risk free with Nord’s 30 day money-back guarantee! ✌

[@ruthrandall2451]

Do you know what Eleanor, you need to look into Jonbenét Ramsey. I think you would do a good job of it.

[@jadestannard5250]

I have an allotment, here in the uk. If you don’t have a lot of space in your garden, you can rent a space on a dedicated patch of land to grow your own produce. I have chickens on mine aswell :)

[@Siennamai14]

Please consider looking into my brother, Dean Williamson. Killed by his gf a week before Xmas ten years ago today. She walked free. So much wasn’t said or used in court which should have been.

[@roderickfields2139]

This is truly a sad case btw Really appreciate you're work

[@justinwalker4475]

no

[@CompleteDispair]

How is this man pulling in 3 women at the same time? 😭

[@lucastm1631]

Well that just shows how power-thirsty some men are to go out in the world looking for women that would submit completely for them and they would never get enough so they still hunting for submissive women who don't know any better. All of the women involved in this kind of relationships are victims even if they are aware of what they're getting into. Manipulation is a big and dangerous weapon

[@gretchenkiley6615]

I wondered also....

[@jackieacheson4928]

Magic member probably.

[@bananabrain364]

Manipulation, I'm assuming

[@phenomskllz2502]

They need to interview that man ASAP

[@haliensexist]

"It wasn't a real affair. They were just having sex." That sir.... is an affair.

[@sharongrigg5336]

Looking at this bloke i can't believe he actually had one girlfriend let alone 3 on the go.. some women need to up their standards, you deserve far better my lovelies.

[@shahfibre]

You mean the man is bald? I'm bald too and I am offended by your comment

[@sharongrigg5336]

@@shahfibre considering my hubby's totally bald this was not what I was referring to, his lack of hair wasn't his problem, everything else was. He was just vile through n through.

[@AbianahAlmeida]

He’s hideous idk what these women were thinking.

[@sophieb6239]

@@shahfibrevery strange you’re so offended at a random persons comment that has nothing to do with you or what you thought she meant…find some self love ❤

[@winniefaye4715]

@@shahfibreno his face is just clapped

[@StinaMarie87]

I normally don't comment asking questions, but I happened to came across a very very sick & twisted case that came to light in 2022 and it happened few hours from me in a town called Norton Shores, MI. The victims name is Timothy Ferguson, he was a 15 year old boy, who was starved and horribly tortured to death pretty much by his MOM and his BROTHER!!! I would love it if you did an episode on this story.

[@shannylove4856]

Sounds tragic! Honestly Eleanor is one of the best to bring these kinda cases. She's so respectful and professional.

[@laineycarson7314]

Stories in my own state always hit hard. I might have to do my own research on this one

[@StinaMarie87]

@@shannylove4856 Yes & she has SO much respect not only for the victim(s)m but also their familes as well.

[@laurencolburn5495]

So weird that I happened to look at the comments (i usually don’t) and see this! I live in the next city over! I’ve never heard of that case either 😮

[@KMcKenzie9]

How have I not heard about this?! Has this been on the news?

[@abbie3604]

I worked in cov Costco when all of this happened. Roger was walking around the store, talking with customers as if nothing happened. He was vile. It was shocking but not surprising when we all found out.

[@philly1076]

did you suspect, that they were having an affair?

[@user-we7vm9yh3m]

I worked at a similar sore to cost co for years we always knew who were having so called secret affairs

[@abbie3604]

@@philly1076 no, as I worked for the demonstrating company inside Costco unfortunately I never met sameena, I think she was more of an area manager so wasn’t always in the cov Costco if that makes sense. I don’t think anyone really suspected anything! When she went missing I believe a couple people suspected he had something to do with it though.

[@colettebell894]

Shandra vandaark and Paul, there’s loads of this horrendous case on KZbin, it’s a heavy one

[@SoCalJellybean]

I don’t know who needs to hear this, but if you’re having an affair, THEY ARE NEVER GOING TO LEAVE THEIR SPOUSE… EVER!!! Move on now and find someone who wants to give everything to you; you deserve that. ♥️♥️♥️

[@TheGeekDotCom]

And even if they do.. they will do the same thing to you.. no one is “special” enough to make a cheater not cheat

[@miroviolet6607]

@@TheGeekDotCom Well said!!

[@JayFal68]

If they'll do it with you they'll do it to you. There'd never be any trust

[@catT5236]

If they'll cheat with you then they'll cheat on you, so even if they did leave all you've won yourself is future pain.

[@Rtt2muchh]

​@@TheGeekDotComi dated cheaters but they never cheated on me or the girl after. Not sure why but maybe because i dated them while they were single

[@introusas]

“After a secret affair, her man was finally ready to leave his girlfriend for her” Wooooooooow 🎉 SO ROMANTIC

[@CharlieHorse4363]

😂😭☠️

[@electricanimeenergy3567]

I was thinking the same thing lol like wtf

[@TripleR250]

So many of these women keep going for taken men though they like the excitement or something it's as if they think single men are losers.

[@tv-21]

She's a homewrecker! Stay in your lane girl!

[@introusas]

@@TripleR250 Take your pathetic incel bullshit elsewhere.

[@jmae3263]

I’ll never understand why men like Roger are so determined to keep the woman they’re cheating with or on when given an ultimatum. When Sameena said leave your gf or I’m done, he still had two other women. She could’ve left and found someone who really appreciated her. But instead he said “I want you, but I also want the other women” It’s just pure greed.

[@vegan_guac]

Yeah also they don't want to lose their "original" gf but don't give enough crap about her to not cheat in the first place 🤡🤦🏼‍♀️

[@JayFal68]

​@@vegan_guacit's an ego boost to have so many women and probably exciting for him

[@vegan_guac]

@@JayFal68 oh definitely that!🙄

[@galinaatanasova1779]

They feel like they own us. We are objects to them and we are not allowed to do as we please nor "belong" to someone else

[@tezzanoia]

It's the entitlement of men who learned all their life that they can have whatever they want, that the world revolves around them and who never truly learnt rejection and moving on from it. It's also the entitlement of men who feel like they have a right to women and sex and that they can own women

[@lulianaxx]

These brothers are disgusting but the brother that got himself involved with murder for no damn personal gain is crazy. So what if his brother gets caught cheating, that doesn't effect him. He should of stayed out of it yet alone called the damn cops on his brother for even approaching him to murder someone!

[@strawberrycakeland]

I believe he was simply as sick as his brother & just wanted to murder someone. Some people are truly not okay in the head

[@maxwellstefan8868]

Haven't finished the video yet but what kills me here is that the entire motivation was just to keep a relationship secret that she wasn't even threatening to expose in the first place, and then BY KILLING HER, he drew investigative attention to her life and relationships and not only exposed it himself but made the consequences on his life so much worse. But I guess guys like this are thinking less about actual problem solving and more about controlling and punishing the women in their lives

[@SevenReads007]

This. They wanted to kill and they wanted to control her, it was a chaotic storm of violence and a lust for power.

[@haileenowacki5202]

I was wondering why they had just made the decision to murder her at all... like she didn't even know about the third girl. He probably just wanted to kill someone, and he found an excuse.

[@BriEMcN]

@haileenowacki5202 I think the issue he was worried about was her telling girl 1 that he lived with

[@sofifi43999]

"bought chloroform off of E-Bay, which side-note: HOW THE FUCK IS THAT LEGAL" i burst out laughing lol

[@HobieInTheBox]

Imagine getting broken up with on Christmas.... And then imagine your bf not only having a mistress but murdering her. This whole situation is just fucked

[@HoPeZz_N_DrEaMzz]

Don't forget the 3RD girlfriend eas well lol wow people have lost the plot for real.

[@sunheart_aquarelle]

I got broken up with on valentines. It sucked, but not as much as this must have.

[@Sam-du7cm]

the original gf/wife is the only one i have sympathy for here

[@darcicampbell7530]

@@Sam-du7cmnot even the one who got murdered?

[@Sam-du7cm]

​@@darcicampbell7530 Who willingly is a mistress/side-chick waiting and pleading for the day the boy will leave his wife? If you choose this kind of life, you're choosing to surround yourself with bad people. Sounds like she had it coming. not saying she deserved it but had it coming to her. Bad apples attract bad apples. 🤷‍♀

[@endlessjes]

wait... so she said "leave your gf or it's over" and he was like "guess i have to murder her"

[@AmyAberrant]

He could have just ended it and gone back to his gf and she would be none the wiser

[@LouiseBelch]

he was scared she'd expose him for cheating. But instead of owning up to it, he decided murder was the best solution.🙄

[@Pt-11]

I will never understand how someone can have the thought process of “breakup or murder.. breakup or murder” and come out on the other side of that convo with murder.

[@jeannemariethompson424]

So he killed her because he didn't want to admit the affair. But his alibi is they were having an affair 😂. How did he manage to have 3 girlfriends? Were they equally stupid? His alibi is he fought with her and was the last person to see her. He is not very bright. If all criminals were this dumb. Lol.

[@RandomSwiftie13]

People who are are having an affair in general are not very brightest of the bulbs.

[@PurpleHazePro]

Not stupid. These women didn’t know their worth. He was an ugly man

[@samanthahunter1759]

I'm not blaming Sameena for her murder, nothing justifies the taking of life but I do feel it necessary to say don't get involved in affairs. This is a very extreme example but these things never end well for any of the parties involved. You deserve someone who wants you and only you. If you are conflicted by feelings for more than one person take time to be alone and really think. Don't play with people's hearts keep your integrity

[@L_i_o_n_e_s_s]

Such a sad story, I believe Sameena really loved him. How terrified and heartbroken she must have been when the truth finally clicked into place seconds too late. My condolences to her family.

[@lovelynells5148]

She’s only a victim to murder but she aided in her own demise by playing this game.

[@kolponabegum1334]

​@@lovelynells5148100%!

[@daniella1243]

I love that she can be sarcastic and empathetic at the same time. I enjoy her storytelling so much!

[@cici.ngxenge]

I bet it's hard not to be sarcastic, some of these criminals are really dumb that she probably can't help it

[@louw.6526]

The way Eleanor was so mad abt how stupid of a criminal he is 😂

[@trekstarsam2494]

I never understood people who actually think they’re special enough to make a man stop cheating. If he’ll cheat with you he’ll cheat on you or WITH others at the same time as you. Her death was 100% on her murderer. I’m not blaming her. But my mind reverts to the question, what if she had chosen to walk instead of giving him an ultimatum? Would she still be here today?

[@smoxthybweh]

Right, like Eleanor kinda made it seem romantic when it's really not. Like dateing a guy you know is in a relationship is trashy, but she shouldn't have been murdered for being a homewrecker.

[@trekstarsam2494]

Absolutely. I’m not blaming her. But I feel that if she had just gotten out herself instead of trying to change the man she would still be here today. It’s too late for poor sameena but I’m thinking of how other women can avoid such a possible horrible situation. I know several women dating married men and want him to leave their wives. I tell them all the time to walk away and find someone who loves them enough to not have them in the other woman position. If the man snaps from the pressure or his wife finds out and snaps, blaming the other woman for their husband’s infidelity they possibly could be in a terrible situation. People are just too emotionally unhinged these days and a man who can’t even claim you is not worth risking your life over.

[@bec7080]

​@@smoxthybwehI don't know that she was making it sound romantic. This is how the victim was seeing things

[@Han-lp6iq]

I commented something similar and people are raging that I'm "shaming a dead woman". I will openly shame homewrecking, ALWAYS, but it doesn't mean I agree with anyone being killed because of it. My advice is don't get involved with anyone you know is already involved with someone else, it never ends well, you're disrespecting yourself, and it's DANGEROUS - this case is one of THOUSANDS that end the exact same way. Being someone's side piece is not worth risking your life for. Have some self respect and find someone who only wants you.

[@peach3117]

i understand that youre not blaming it on her, but the question is very weird. if she had chosen to walk away, his fear of being exposed would still linger. it was the reason why he decided to kill her in the first place, it was his action that caused sameena's death, not her inaction.

[@A.minah123]

Your usual disclaimer is literally implanted in my brain at this point 😅! Everytime i watch the cases you cover i always say the disclaimer along with you !!

[@avery4116]

real ones remember her shorter original disclaimer😂

[@honeybee416]

I fast forward through it. I can't stand how repetitive it is! I can't stand repetitive things in general though.

[@carolynemohamed7056]

Me too most of the true crime videos I always repeat the intro

[@safffxo]

@@avery4116YES 😂

[@dinoforest8222]

​@@avery4116omd I remember that, in lockdown I swear I watch every single video she had 😂, and now I'm in uni for forensics science (it helps that it was a field I was somewhat interested in for years but I wanted to do chemical engineering till I hit alevel maths then nope time to slove crimes!)

[@Maya-Hayden]

I hate hearing cases where there’s cheating involved cause the entire case could’ve literally been avoided. Always disgusting.

[@fayewitt9881]

I'm not terribly crazy about cases like this myself I mean this just shows how stupid and how senseless cheating really is and how it can a lot of the time lead to murder in which case it does in this case. Definitely could have all been avoided. I hope these two men especially that Roger creep riot in hell for all they've done. And all this just so Roger can save face and keep the other two women from finding out what a slimebucket, a dirtbag which is what this man really is and I wouldn't even call him a man he's a coward! Too much of a coward to face the truth he has to result to murder to clean up his mess that he got himself into and getting his brother into this mess I mean who does that but of course his brother is no better if he can agree to helping to commit such a horrible crime as murder. These two aren't men they're animals, monsters! Who think murder is the answer to everything!

[@madisonholtze7344]

This man decides he's so desperate to cover up the affair that he needs to kill his affair partner, but then his alibi is that he got into a fight with his affair partner... Honestly seems like it was more about the murder itself and wanting to kill her and the excuse of 'wanting to cover it up' was just that- a hair-brained excuse.

[@Daaaanielle]

He was just an ahole tbh.

[@angelinelowe9159]

I was thinking the same!

[@SevenReads007]

Yup, I totally agree. Either they are SO INCREDIBLY DUMB that they don’t realize they’ve defeated the whole point, and I don’t think they are because you have to be good at lying to have 3 partners at once who all don’t know about each other… I think they just wanted to kill.

[@claraaguilarfuentes8057]

Did I stay up purely waiting for this to post. Yes yes I did

[@Moon-eh7hv]

@@SimplyLeahxthere r timezones did u forget?

[@Asher_Sv]

@@SimplyLeahxmaybe they don’t live in the uk…. Maybe where they live it’s a different time?.. use your brain

[@cortlin3304]

same😂

[@Sheherazadeh91]

Same here

[@Chillilii]

It’s half 8

[@Cloudystxrr]

i’m not blaming her because it’s %100 not her fault, but after watching so many true crime cases where an affair ends deadly, you really start to get suspicious of people who cheat.

[@alexandran6009]

Their morals are so twisted. We had a guy at work who was always gushing about how much he loves his wife and that she's the best person etc but then he was cheating with a co worker . So how can u say that you love someone but then disrespect them like that . He was a charming guy everyone loved him so he was very suprised when I didn't give him the time of the day knowing all of this .

[@JayFal68]

​@@alexandran6009I think people put their lives in little boxes, that's a person with zero empathy, they're selfish and only care about themselves

[@JayFal68]

​@@alexandran6009a lot of these types of people are narcissistic and have zero compassion for anyone

[@christinetitus6388]

I agree. If they cheat with you, they will most likely cheat on you too.

[@mmhr7731]

@@alexandran6009was this person Ned from try guys

[@LilyJean28]

Hearing you say “Saran wrap” in an American accent was hilarious to me 😂

[@alainafitzgerald6271]

I was looking for this. I had to watch it twice

[@colombiana_loca]

I just HAD to reply that part a few times it was hilarious!!

[@0oFlicko0]

Imagine being (the official) girlfriend when this came to light. Imagine being the other side-chick, who probably also new about the official gf, knowing this could have been you

[@leighrebecca3008]

My autistic brain literally stopped retaining information for like 5 minutes after Eleanor referred to Crime Watch as ‘Crime Stoppers’ 😭 On another note, I can’t believe this poor woman lost her life over a man who looks like someone tried to draw Nicolas Cage from memory.

[@emmalu22]

your description of him 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@AmyAberrant]

💀

[@nancysimon5330]

😂😂😋

[@pegasusgenesis360]

"....Draw Nicholas Cage from memory !!!???" Stopppppppit! 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣 That is the best thing I've heard in a while......thanks for the laugh- esp At that jerks expense.....

[@karmayt8956]

His first girlfriend must have been his meal ticket. It wasn’t like he was married with children and could have lost financially if his other affairs became known. Girls must be desperate to settle for a clown like this.

[@Jessy-rx9bi]

Keep in mind he was highly manipulative and likely love bombed all 3 . They didn't see the monster or true him.

[@aftonrae4038]

For the first probably few months that I was watching Eleanor and also Danielle Kirsty they kept talking about how people found dead bodies in bin bags and the whole time I’m sitting here thinking that they’re saying the word bean instead of bin and I’m wondering why are so many murderers putting bodies inside of beanbags??

[@joyous1011]

😂 you must be from US like me. It took me a minute to figure out what a " boot" was 😂 I love Danielle Kirsty too!

[@lindashaw3796]

😅

[@nataliewilkie6599]

I had a shite night and it's really nice to have someone who feels like a friend telling you a story as you fall asleep. May both sides of your pillow always be cool, thanks for sharing your work with us ❤

[@ladymallowyt]

Yes, its horrible what happened to Sameena but how could she think she was going to live happily with a man who is already cheating on another woman with you? We've heard of similar true crime stories of people who are having an affair which ends with them being murdered. I wonder if Sameena ever felt pressured to be with him because he wouldn't stop asking her out? They worked in the same place which means they saw each other frequently

[@AllisaChance]

Yeah hence why they say love is blind because She was so blind that she was willing to be with a man who are was cheating. But I wondered if she just could have walked away, she would be alive today. ​@@theashwoodfaerie

[@anony16]

As unfortunate and as brutal as this is, I think its important to point out that when you're immoral enough to have a full blown affair with a man/or a woman whose also immoral enough to cheat with you on their partner, then any game can play. Never trust someone who already comes with red flags

[@HazelB338_]

Exactly!

[@erinbrockbank5631]

yeah red flags doesnt really include murder like u dont expect to really get murdered

[@nataliapiasta6895]

not the victim blaming.

[@d3m0l1t10n_]

dude what’s wrong with you blaming a victim of a brutal murder bc she had an affair???????? are you sane????

[@anony16]

@@d3m0l1t10n_ are you?...because it seems like your comprehension skills are non-existent. Explain where the blaming came in

[@JessicaOlzzon004]

It’s you and rotten mango podcast that are the best when it comes to true crime, I love how you both take time and show emotion talking about the victims. Much love❤️

[@Daaan09]

Yes i'm sure the victims family will appreciate Eleanor making this video as some sort of Christmas special lol.

[@DivineSpiritual1989]

It would be awesome if Ellenor and Stephanie did a crossover together ❤

[@douknodawae7805]

Same bur for me I love danielle kirsty and Bailey Sarian too ❤

[@tuptupscafe1487]

YES!!! ​@@douknodawae7805

[@zoejohnson-ry3qm]

yes! try danielle kirsty! she’s also one of my faves!

[@user-ny7cr1zc8g]

This way the most chaotic story line case I have ever heard 😂😂 the brothers reallllly didn't have much thought behind this one huh 😅 eleanor is the best at portraying these cases ❤❤

[@francescadifeo7859]

Yo man laughing emojis, really? Somebody died

[@hestererlank8354]

I think she's laughing at how stupid these guys were.

[@Hereandlearning]

This is unbelievable.. promising basically starting a life together to end up ripping her life away and just tossing her aside like garbage. I feel for her family so much, the holidays will never be the same for them again. Glad they were caught and prosecuted, but honestly there can be no real justice because Sameena is gone now. Great video Eleanor, as usual in depth coverage of backstory and awesome delivery of information. Always with utmost respect to the victims and their families. Happy to have found your channel!! Merry Christmas to you and yours ❤

[@ahkariedwards5715]

The way they did this so coldly then went back home acting completely normal makes me think could it be not their first

[@nadinekeating3255]

Everytime I hear a true crime case out of the UK, im amazed (not in a good way) by the ridiculously lenient sentences they hand out to people who *should* be spending the rest of their life (without the possibility of parole) in prison.

[@samarshad2081]

What exactly did she see in him. To lose your life over that.

[@tokofukawa4654]

ew dont blame her for what happened to her bro

[@slow.and.hot717]

There are inexplicable things in life... Some people are drawn to others like "moth to a flame". It happens, nothing is her fault, that's certain.

[@ririschannelx]

Victim blaming is foul

[@samarshad2081]

Absolutely. @@slow.and.hot717

[@samarshad2081]

So is falsely accusing someone of victim blaming. @@ririschannelx

[@jasonrublaitus7144]

3 Costco girlfriends?! He’s must’ve gotten the bulk Costco deal. 😆

[@alyxxa6182]

Moral of the story: Don’t try to steal someone’s boyfriend. And don’t cheat on your girlfriend. Oh…and don’t commit murder I suppose.

[@bj.reo87]

😂

[@AllisaChance]

More moral of the story: there is always an option to walk away. And please don't try to hang on to the "i can CHANGE them!!" and don't think you are special because someone is willing to leave their gf/bf just for you. The way you got them, the way you lose them.

[@katebrande]

I’ve been LOVING your freaky Fridays. I talk about them all the time with my sister who also watches your vids. Thank you for all of the amazing hard work you put into these!!

[@Asher_Sv]

I love your videos so much! You’re so respectful and kind and have helped me through a lot of tough times. No one could ever tell true crime stories as respectfully and careful as you and I love you for that💗

[@loribrooks5596]

If you love her, you’ll also love Danielle Kirsty! These ladies are my favorite.

[@Boing2699]

@DontReadMyProfilePicture.57don’t worry, no one is going to read your name. No one cares.

[@vanessavargas634]

@@loribrooks5596Danielle Kirsty is amazing I wouldn’t compare her to this women this girl laughs alot on her videos where we are talking about a woman getting murdered. I’ll stick to Danielle and Kendall Rae

[@Asher_Sv]

@@vanessavargas634 no one said you had to watch Eleanor if it makes you so upset go watch someone else😭

[@neesh304]

I love listening to these while i work As someone who has been cheated on multiple times, this makes me feel sick, that poor girl not knowing for TWO years! Poor girl.. 💔

[@calliemarie9921]

I only watched true crime here and there, but the way you talk about these victims is so respectful. I love watching you and Wendigoon as you two are by far the most thoughtful when talking about victims, and giving them a story and making them human. I’ve been watching you every day now, and just subscribed! I also LOVE YOUR ACCENT, makes it so entertaining to watch!

[@Morticia1313]

Omg I totally always think the same thing. Mt favorite is when someone will just ring up a friend at 2am & say to a friend or family member, " I need you to help me bury a body" and the other person is like , ok give me 5 minutes. I'll be right there. I'm always like , what the actual Hell!

[@slow.and.hot717]

It must depend on the kind of relationship you have with that person. You never know until you are in that situation.... It makes me remember the best friend of the kid who killed his parents to throw a party. After his friend confided to him about the murders and after he realized it was real.... He felt sad because he knew their friendship is over. They spent some time hanging out that night, they got a selfie... They both knew they weren't gonna see each other again. After that night, he went home and reported his friend to the police. I guess it's hard to imagine someone you know and love is capable of something horrific. As for the brother in this case... They are probably very similar, morally loose characters and they know that the other one is the same. This is why there was no doubt in joining him in crime. That was probably their relationship growing up, just doing smaller bad things together as children.

[@honeycrispsnail4032]

i say it as a joke all the time like “haha i’d grab the garbage bags!”, but i genuinely do not know what i’d do in that nightmare situation if it were to come true. obviously i’d call the police but i’d be devastated at the same time.

[@jdsteppenzyde]

If you could chat with the brothers’ parents, you’d probably have a few answers to your questions. They probably have done many daft and cruel things before.

[@BlueEyedMomof378]

Any woman that dates a man, that's in a relationship, hoping he'll leave his partner is just plain wrong. Not to mention none too bright. Don't get me wrong, he's a dog. I just cannot abide a woman that chooses to be with a taken man. How many stories do we know where a man says he'll leave his partner to be with them. Men like that lie. It doesn't justify what he did. He's a monster. But girls, please wake up. Stop going after dogs that cheat on their women. Sometimes they're just cheaters, and they'll cheat on you too. Other times, they're like this animal.

[@abbyyoung2642]

Genuinely can not work out how that thing got a steady girlfriend and then 2 other mistresses in the first place..

[@alexandran6009]

My first thought when i saw his photo

[@kallijames-wyrick6900]

The way you said ‘Saran wrap’ 😂 we call it plastic wrap mostly

[@TripleR250]

Eleanor's intro sponsorship advert is so long that I actually take off my headphones to make a cup of tea during the intro 😂

[@slumpedsloth3233]

I always tell myself I have crazy strength when I’m mad bc in the hospital it took 4 men but this SCARES me so much that poor girl I would’ve been terrified

[@Fluffy-Fluffy]

Now I'm curious why you got this angry at the hospital...

[@PryorS]

@@Fluffy-FluffyI know sometimes if you need mental health help and are going to hurt yourself or someone else they can restrain you. Maybe they told them they couldn’t leave 😂

[@user-th6uv7zm7v]

I’m literally so so proud of how far you have come Eleanor! I’ve been a viewer since 2019 and seeing how your videos have improved and how the research has become more detailed etc, just makes me really really proud. This video was such a sad one 😢 as they all are! I just can’t imagine what must have been going through her head in those final moments, how scared she must have been, how betrayed and confused she must have felt. Thank you for telling another innocent persons story. Sending love and light for Christmas and the new year❤

[@lovisa1015]

I've followed you for maybe years but never watched too much, but these last two months I swear I hear your voice more than my own mother's (dw I love her just not at home)! Absolutely love your takes on these cases - you've got such a refreshing tone on everything and I especially felt your frustration on this one....!

[@antiquesrestoration3874]

"DEADline" is an understatement.

[@thatdivineoraclegirl1622]

How funny about an hour ago I was sitting here checking your page to see if I missed an upload. I always appreciate the way you tell the victims stories ❤

[@danniconrad3486]

the way you naturally said "saran wrap" like you're from the most southern of states has me rolliingggg

[@Schnooks83]

I have to say that you really do your research. I like that you are always respectful but still manage to convey your disgust at a situation. And that you are presenting this info wearing a Betty Boop shirt is priceless.

[@fabiwilliams4644]

This isn't the first time a man has done this. There was a married man having an affair except his girlfriend had no idea he was married. They went as far as organising a wedding, buying an engagement ring & wedding dress. When the day approached she was then murdered

[@claudiaalexandraa]

molly watson:( such a sad case!

[@felbicky6333]

I wish she’d never met him. RIP Sameena 💔

[@scottadams6003]

Eleanor is so beautiful. Her partner is so lucky. I love her storytelling, too. The emotion and passion that she brings is so entertaining.

[@aftonrae4038]

I never understand these idiots that somehow believe that being labeled a murderer is better than being labeled a cheater? How does that make any logic sense?? I know they don’t plan on getting caught but even a minor amount of research would show them that 99% of the people that murder their partner because of an affair get caught! Even the ones that believe they are geniuses that would definitely outsmart the investigators normally get caught pretty quickly.

[@BugletsEnclosure]

yay new Eleanor Neale video! I love the way you cover cases respectfully, and i know this one will be good too. rest in peace Sameena.

[@nevexxx3437]

I think his reasoning behind the text would be that he knew their affair would come to light via texts read, maybe she told a friend (more than likely) plus to explain any of his belongings at her house as you said he was always there plus finger prints if the police did that. I think he was thinking ahead and not just involving himself unnecessarily. Her poor family, obviously never a good time but at Christmas 😢 Their lives will never be the same.

[@hunnybunn4358]

You saying Saran Wrap made my day lmaooo😂 I love your videos I’ve been watching you since 2020 💗

[@kwittyaudios]

this story is so heartbreaking. sameena was yearning for love, thats all she had wanted, and instead of roger growing up and owning up to his bullshit he murdered her. my heart breaks for her, her family, her friends and everyone else that loved this beautiful woman. rest in peace sameena

[@mentallydisturbedllama473]

Well said.. incredibly sad.

[@zzboonono]

Yea she wanted love but..she was also homewrecking..I don’t think anyone in this case is a saint smh

[@kxixxrt]

@@zzboononopretty sure homewrecking is SIGNIFICANTLY less evil than straight up torture and murder. You did not know this woman. Check yourself and be respectful.

[@zzboonono]

@@kxixxrt girl please gtfo and re read my comment before you come smart I specifically said no one was a saint in this case my comment wasn’t not justifying what that despicable man did if that’s what you got from my comment it seem like you need to check yourself and take your own advice.

[@_______unknown_______]

​@@kxixxrtbut shes still a horrible woman

[@kayleighstickland7613]

I absolutely love your content 🥰for someone with mental health and don’t get out all I watch is your channel and your attitude and the way you explain the story is good and the facial expressions are comical 😂❤ love to you ell xx

[@luna-bella.50s44]

I just wanted to say that I’ve been watching your videos for years and I’ll truly never get tired of them, you are great at what you do ❤️ happy holidays Eleanor!

[@krumnut]

Watching Ellie lose her mind at how stupid he was is absolutely gold. 10/10 content.

[@rivervan]

Thank you so much for the respect you show Eleanor! I’ve been waiting for the notification of your video to post 😭 Affairs aren’t right but murder is no way to get about your shame of being in one…

[@mayam4281]

you should do the case on Ruby Franke… a pretty famous youtuber who was found guilty of child ab*se

[@JoshRazauskas]

Such an awful needless, stupid and heartless case! I hope her family has been able to find some peace! Thanks as always for your wonderful work covering Eleanor!

[@flaky9999]

I've noticed in a lot of cases that the chemicals used in cases are like ridiculously easy to buy like i remember hearing a case where someone bought a rlly dangerous one from like b&q i think, i understand some are used in building and medical stuff but it should not be so easy when there is so many murder cases as well as acid attacks.

[@maartjevandeursen4744]

this woman literally is my therapy. no matter what you talk about or what you're doing, just your entire presence is so comforting and calming and helps me through so much anxiety and stress. you're an absolutely wonderful person and THE BEST social media person on the planet imo. love you ellie 🩷

[@GenXfrom75]

Listen, I'm 5'2" and ALWAYS push my driver's seat back when getting out of my car. The seat being pushed back is always mentioned but it's not ALWAYS an indication of a tall driver. Yes, here it WAS but when it's brought up as a sign every single time, it's kinda frustrating.... As a short driver who might go missing one day (theoretically) & who's driver seat WILL be pushed all the way back, I need to say some of us short girls like the extra entry room. 😅

[@laurataylor8179]

I'm 5'2 also I never do that and I can't thing of any of my girlfriends doing that

[@GenXfrom75]

@@laurataylor8179 ok? I didn’t say everyone did that. I said I DO THAT. And know quite a few shorties who also do that. So pushing the seat back isn’t always an accurate indicator that a tall person had been driving the car.

[@Trenddagod]

One thing I love about your videos is your presentation. You are a GREAT storyteller. You know exactly when to give details, what to keep short, and where to add input. Very entertaining and informative at the same time. If there was someone I would want telling my story it would be you lol ❤😂.

[@tenku_power]

Hey Ellie, your videos are wonderful! I always get shivers watching your videos and you always give me something to listen to, in the background while doing things.

[@miryana79]

7 minutes in ,and my mind is going back to my ex boyfriend who had someone else behind my back. It gives these cheaters a power/ control ?! Awful. Women have instincts and guys who cheat ,not a good karma. A form of Sin,Adultery. 🌹 Rip s Happy holidays Eleanor.🎉

[@hearmeoutbro]

Sins and karma aren’t real lol

[@HoPeZz_N_DrEaMzz]

Killed her to hide from his other gfs yet told on himself by texting himself with her phone.... then what was the murder for dudes?

[@brownsugar4412]

Just plain evil 😢

[@asorneyramsay2864]

Never let anyone say they will leave anybody for you. I know from experience they won’t. Had been on the other side of this situation as the current gf and I knew the dude was lying to the girl at work. I had to tell her to stop the crap of it

[@BrandonBrooker]

Lucky us getting a true crime video and a second channel video in the same day. Ellie we love you ❤️

[@nukemmy]

thank you so much for these respectful case coverings, you’re the best!! Happy holidays from new york!! ❤️❤️

[@elfiebees]

eleanor can i just say that ur personality is really shining through in your videos lately? youre a ray of sunshine :')

[@SkookieCat_Arts]

Oh hey I’m not 3 years late :0. I only started watching your channel recently, been binging your videos while studying, I love how respectful you are while talking about these cases ❤

[@oliviajayward]

the comment section on this video is so disgusting. how can people blame the victim and not the idiot who decided to cheat on his girlfriend and murder one of his side chicks? You really don’t understand what lies that man could be telling Sameena and the other side chicks to stay with him. These type of relationships are really hard to get out of due to the person who’s cheating making up false promises and feeding lies as well. These type of evil people target the most vulnerable people to manipulate who just want a loving partner and it’s just so heartbreaking.

[@lithia4483]

Exactly. This man is a manipulative liar. But at this point it doesn't even matter what she knew, she didn't deserve to be murdered.

[@helenbartoszek243]

She knew he had a girlfriend but still chose to have a relationship with him. Obviously doesn't deserve to be murdered, but how about being nice to other women? Plenty of other single men she could have had as a fuck buddy. We women need to stick together and not cut other women's lunches. Same goes for blokes too.

[@mariahgonzales5547]

@@helenbartoszek243 I mean she was in love and believed that she was the one he wanted regardless of him being w another girl so it’s not her fault anyways

[@AllisaChance]

Majority of the comments I have seen were not nice but they did speak of reality. You cannot be with a man who is cheating on you and you KNOW this and then expect them to change. I do not condone what happened to her, in fact I'm so heartbroken because she didn't deserve to die. Although she is a victim of a very cowardly man who doesn't know how to keep it in his pants, let's not act she is all innocent either. Being involved with him was wrong and she knew it! She could have walked away and probably lived to see another day.

[@honeycrispsnail4032]

big agree but a lot of people are confusing “victim-blaming” and “future advice with others”.

[@EryberrieTrueCrime]

Knocking it out of the park again. Happy holidays, Ms Neale xx

[@nataliereid5262]

Imagine going through the trouble of completely wiping down a car and not thinking to move the seat back to where it should be.

[@cierrawalker1792]

yk it's a good day when ellie posts 💗

[@lilifuentes7126]

His name is WADEA AL FAYOUME🇵🇸‼️After 4 years of religiously watching ur content, I have never made a suggestion but with so many scary things going on in the world I was wondering if u could cover the recent hate crime against poor little 6 yr old WADEA AL FAYOUME and his mother in Chicago. The conflict in palestine is something i would love to see u bring awareness to the channel as i think u would do an amazing job and have it well received by an amazing fanbase.

[@d0n0tdisturb]

AGREED

[@ladylauren4989]

Yay! Thank you for all your hard work this year. Happy Holidays!!

[@Miss_ESL]

In cases of duo killers, there is usually a power imbalance to start with, either older/younger siblings, somebody more invested and easily manipulated in a relationship. With Hindley, she was by all accounts a completely different person before meeting Brady, but after meeting him and "falling in love" with him, she would do anything to keep him, including their horrific crimes. One partner usually starts out with the more violent "desires" and uses the partner to fantasise and eventually commit the crime, which then becomes a "bonding" experience in their minds. The same is true in the case of the Wests. Fred was already a violent r..ist when he met Rose who also had perversions of her own. She was most certainly he one pulling the strings in that relationship and while I don't doubt Fred would have ended up in prison without meeting Rose, I don't think they would have become the monsters they did together had they not met. These relationships are symbiotic, one is usually controlling and manipulative and "tests" their desires out on the partner who goes along because the risk of losing/upsetting the dominant partner is unthinkable to them, which feeds the desire of the dominant partner until something terrible happens. Sorry for the essay, I studied Criminal Psych at uni lol.

[@kaitlynlucy]

Was hoping you were going to post today, always get excited when you do. Your videos are unmatched, favourite youtuber ❤️

[@johnwells5414]

Thanks for all your insight! My wife and I recently discovered this channel and we’ve been binging when we can haha

[@angeline-ei5le]

the way you described this man was literally my ex the whole time. cheating lying having a whole other life. manipulating everyone around her. had work gfs. 2 of them. and everything.

[@MissGoldee]

The amount of men out there like this is scary

[@honeycrispsnail4032]

yikes, i’m glad he’s an ex now 😭

[@eden20111]

It’s truly awful what happened to Sameena. It’s clear they both had deep psychological problems. It’s such a shame cuz all of this could have been avoided if he never cheated and just remained faithful. Her continuous obsession with him while he was with someone was also mentally unhealthy for herself. I feel so bad for Roger’s wife. I can’t imagine the shock and betrayal she must’ve felt to find out your spouse was not seeing 1 but 2 other people, and then him and his brother plot to kill one of the women. I really hope she is doing ok, as well as the family of Sameena who didn’t deserve their daughter to be taken away from them so soon.

[@christinac2652]

Her name is Sameena.

[@wolfzmusic9706]

​@@jodierenee6994Why are you so angry? It's clear they both had issues imo.

[@christopherlucas1661]

⁠@@jodierenee6994umm it’s clear they BOTH had issues… your pathetic attempt at attacking the OP with your unnecessary rant was not needed.

[@melissamoonchild9216]

​@@jodierenee6994this sounds like projection..

[@hollychamberlain2878]

I don’t agree it could have been avoided if he’d stayed faithful. Someone as messed up as him would find a reason to “justify” killing someone eventually.

[@RandomVideoz1231]

love when you and bella upload on the same day !!!

[@kalenwood-qd9ub]

i look forward to your videos every week and youre doing great eleanor!! love you!!

[@Han-cj2jp]

Hi Eleanor, This story was just horrible that 2 men are willing to just kill an innocent woman, like it was nothing. This story is just scary.

[@Camey71073]

My fave UK true crimer. Ty for all you do to bring us these cases.❤ your channel❤ from Oklahoma