Did these scientists love Hinduism? | Oppenheimer, Carl Sagan, Schrodinger etc.

[@scienceisdope]

Support me at: Buymeacoffee: buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope Patreon: www.patreon.com/scienceisdope_ YT Membership: kzbin.info/door/g--ENXdDpXh5LyLigolg2gjoin UPI: scienceisdope@icici (QR Code available on www.scienceisdope.com/support )

[@anantverma3428]

Will support once I start earning ❤️

[@chbilly4465]

@science is dope: Well, if you are asking where Schrodinger's quote came from, it took less than 5 mins to find out it came from his semi-autobiographical work "what is life?". He has a chapter in it where he says the single most challenging part of his research was to develop a continuous function (solution of schrodinger's equation) for the spatial probability of discrete electrons and how to connect continuous functions with discrete results using ingenious functions like kronecker delta function. He did explicitly mention that the inspiration came from pedantic concept of all pervading (continuous) consciousness manifesting in discrete individual beings. That is a profound thought. Every same individual knows that vedanta was not talking of science but metaphysics . If anybody made a claim that vedanta is a precursor to science, you are using idiotic arguments by rank morons to discredit the profundity of thought in vedanta. Vedanta is a deeply well thought metaphysics. Metaphysics is not science and not based on evidence. It is the depth and profundity of thought within vedanta that is indeed beautiful and inspirational to great minds like Scheodinger, Oppenheimer and Schopenhauer. Why are you dismissing it? That is ludicrous.

[@chbilly4465]

@Science is Dope: Also, the comment on authority is misleading. What is your achievement in science? What is the number of highly cited and peer reviewed journal publications you have produced in high impact factor journals? This matters a lot in terms of whether your assertions carry weight as such achievements are a minor guarantee of your capabilities in science. So, what Scheodinger or Oppenheimer say does matter simply on the basis of their scientific achievements. This is the worst video I have found on internet in terms of exploring relationship between science and religion. I hope you dont take it down since as a professor of physics, when I teach pupils regarding this topic, i know to show this video as the worst possible example that is there so far.

[@anantverma3428]

@@chbilly4465 Why is the comment on authority misleading? If you're saying the right thing scientifically you don't need a formal degree or citations....science doesn't have different interpretations like religions.

[@chbilly4465]

@anantverma3428 Stop reading comments half way and reacting. I already answered your question. Any Tom Dick and Harry can make any nonsense claim they want. It has zero impact unless it goes through a peer review process in a decently reputed journal. That is the authority and that is how science works. Incapable people who have zero contributions in the field of science making illogical arguments like the speaker in the video here (read the comment I made on the logical fallacy pranav made by connecting metaphysics and science in the wrong way) have zero impact on the actual progress of science. If Pranav has some meaningful contributions to science (decently cited papers in high impact factor journals), let him come out with it. I will write to those journals regarding this video.

[@udit5948]

Gita, Vedas and Upanishads are philisophical texts, meaning they delve into fields like existentialism, mind, reasoning, etc. The scientists mentioned in above video come from the era when Germany and Austria were known for advancing the field of quantum mechanics. This field of physics at that time required thought experiments and thinking deeply into tiny world of matter. Also during that time, Sanskrit and Hindu texts were being researched by the German philosophical society, so it is evident that the scientists got hold of these texts. I am not saying that ancient Hindu texts had any quantum field theory or physics mentioned, just that by reading the philosophy behind those texts, the scientists were capable to bring more clarity on their thought experiments and bring about their discoveries. On the other hand, you won't hear the British and American scientists of that time mentioning much about Hinduism because research into Hindu philosophy was not the topic of discussion in their circles.

[@starlordgg]

😂😂😂😂

[@devrajff1396]

​@@starlordgg What happened

[@f8103]

you can ask science journey

[@shatzco]

Is Allah Upanishad part of philosophy too?

[@thunderred5263]

There are already too psychological books today

[@manofscience69]

Waiting for those "This is not a science Channel just anti Hindu propaganda" Yeah cuz you didn't watch those hours long science education podcasts he had been doing.

[@iykyk857]

lol tru every uneducated hindu goons daily life

[@GiteshRishi]

Actually people in India started knowing they were Hindus from 2014 and more in 2019,some filthies are so insecure that they put up stickers of hindu on their cars or bikes just so that they could be proud of something on which they have no control on(their birth).

[@nafees_ur_rehman]

No religion is compatible with Science and you're watching this video on a Ed-Science channel. So please don't bring religion here the channel is based on pure science and some criticism of hinduism, islam and Christian beliefs.

[@Sasuke-d8l]

he don't have balls to talk about abrahamic religion and he haven't studied upanishads lmao

[@Sasuke-d8l]

@@goodguy26 because abrahamic religion is demonic even the middle east don't follow it anymore, but some indians are still brainwashed, sadly even in time of krishna there was Duryadhan, demons will always exist , the problem is when people don't recognise it, like this Guy.

[@readnseek]

Hey, Pranav I was waiting for you to say this. These scientists did read Hindu scriptures especially the Upanishads from the Vedas and the Bhagavad Gita to know about Indian philosophy, but not for Scientific discoveries or Science. I wanted you to tell the audience that there's a huge difference between these two things - Philosophy and Science. Many discoveries in Quantum Physics like the dual nature of the particle or the presence of an electron at two points at the same time were difficult to digest for many at a time when anything that defied Classical Physics was considered incorrect. So these scientists found solace in the Upanishads, a philosophical part of the Vedas devoid of any religious practices. In Upanishads, they found echoes of their theories and a philosophical foundation to ensure they would no longer be cast adrift by the implications of Quantum Physics. No one actually tells you that these scientists were also critical of other parts of the Vedas which are full of outdated, unscientific or superstitious practices of deity appeasement. These scientists were interested in just philosophy and not religion. Basically, they were hardcore scientists at heart and believed in the scientific method of evidence-based understanding of things. But as every man needs a philosophical foundation to his life, they too wanted the best of every philosophy out there whether from East or West. So they looked at these things out of interest and curiosity for their philosophical pursuits. This has nothing to do with science or their scientific discoveries. An outstanding article on this topic of Upanishads and Scientists is on Science The Wire. Go check out that for more information on this topic.

[@akashraghuvanshi-gp3xb]

Yes they studied it for philosophical purpose

[@PraveenAkash-ik7bb]

wish many hindus understood about this topic as you have.

[@santoshkarela8433]

This is the best description for this video ❤

[@piyushpatnayak4951]

he does not know shit about these things and you go ahead to ask about intellectualism from someone who couldn't even land a job or work in any science related field and landed on yt to earn easy bucks

[@AmlanPritamParida-b1l]

First of all u haven't actually read the vedas , the vedas u read were simply misinterpretation of the actual meaning of things mentioned there , everything written in vedas is actually moreover on spirituality which is the upper stage of science, science is only based on this dimension that is just a simulation or Maya , but spirituality is the science of higher dimensions , u simply speak these things without researching and yes the scientists did read the vedas for philosophical meanings but simply couldn't understand the scientific things there that are written in a much metaphorical way which not even u and me can understand

[@beactivebehappy9894]

5:44 a lot of documentaries mentioned that phrase “ we don’t have evidence for it” and when I was a theist, I always took it as “ it probably happened but we can’t prove it”

[@arjyachatterjee6874]

I guess that it's the argument of gnostic thiests.

[@CuriousINDIA101]

Watch 'A Brief History of Vedas' Heard of that 1600-year-old iron pillar that hasn't rusted, We had metallurgy, maths, physics, geometry, architecture, literature, medical science, astronomy, art, music, dance, more than 19500 languages and dialects, etc. Bakhshali manuscript found near Takhshila, And the Bharat was big part of trades and travellers. Is it all my wishful thinking or your believe, are you follower of science or believer of science? Are you really skeptic and a explorer and seeker of truth or just a believer like a religious person.

[@ayudhdasroy7090]

​@@CuriousINDIA101and it has nothing to do with religion. i don't see your point here.

[@CuriousINDIA101]

@@ayudhdasroy7090 yeah about the religious aspect.... We didn't had any so called religion here...(Dharma and religion are different things) What we had was 'Panth'(which means path), Shavism, Shaktism, Jainism, Buddhism, Shikhism, Smartism and Istdevta etc. These were Spritual means(Kind of like a song for our Psychological and mental betterment and evolution) on the well established foundation of Yoga, Bhakti Yoga Karma Yoga Janana Yoga Raj Yoga, This culture was more scientific than anyone could think of.

[@CuriousINDIA101]

@@ayudhdasroy7090 and in all That Charvaka was also a Panth, This culture took care of every kind of mind

[@iu9130]

Religion and science can never go hand in hand because it doesn't matter how rational your religion is as religion doesn't change it's rule or evolve or develop unlike science

[@N0Xa880iUL]

Not true. Religion always evolves, but simply to survive. It absorbs the new discoveries by claiming that they were already mentioned in their religious texts. And the con continues.

[@indiarocks5731]

most of the famous scientist were jews

[@Agnosticcc-x3m]

By this logic, ISRO scientists couldn't have done space programmes.

[@afishekkrishnar4415]

​​@@Agnosticcc-x3mreligion can exist along science but when religious thought increase scientific temper decrease and that's the problem...... believing in a god or religion is personal....but I think believing and wasting ur money,time etc. for something which has no evidence of existence is dumb

[@indiarocks5731]

@@afishekkrishnar4415 everyones has a right have faith …like you have of no god…

[@abhishekdubey6033]

I love the fact that Everyone I see in comments is Hindu on paper😊 You have liberty to talk trash about faith of a Certain Belief without getting threats of Sar Tan Se Juda

[@abhishekdubey6033]

We should at least respect the Vedas and ancestors for this liberty😊

[@tgducsfdifxdt4533]

Lol a man was killed by an Hindu mob because there was an rumour he ate beef, journalist gets death threats for critizing scams by dongi babas there are genodical threats by hindu politician wow so much liberty shown by hindus

[@tgducsfdifxdt4533]

Religion oppresses people

[@tgducsfdifxdt4533]

Some old guy takes drugs and comes and tells us this is how universe is, I met God bla bla bla are we suppose to believe this stories with no skepticism

[@abhishekdubey6033]

@@tgducsfdifxdt4533 I am not saying you have to follow it. You can be a Nastik and a Hindu. Just because you don't believe in things that doesn't mean you can openly abuse the reason why people are not Committing suicide, Openly taking drugs and drinking alcohol and Rap3ing and killing people around.

[@celestialsatheist1535]

Funny enough some Hindus are very upset for a particular scene in Oppenheimer

[@vanessahargreaves528]

That's just immaturity by some politically motivated f00ls tbh

[@karthik951]

Some hindus before - ahh geeta inspired Oppenheimer nolan will give tribute to geeta world will know the power of geeta Meanwhile nolan in Oppenheimer with Geeta -

[@celestialsatheist1535]

​@@karthik951their was something to behold

[@anchitbose4151]

@@celestialsatheist1535 I'm not upset just that the scene was not factual. And how the physicists where represented as sex maniacs.

[@adityask277]

There was nothing offensive in that scene. I think Nolan was trying some complicated storytelling in that scene that we all missed

[@mithunbalaji8199]

Schrodinger's quote on vedanta, I think is more affiliated with philosophy of mind/consciousness and its metaphysics than empirical science

[@Mlecchakshaydixit]

Even if it's about philosophy and discovery of these scientists were not connected to hinduism then also how you will have to agree that hindu philosophy and its texts gave a very deep description into nature of reality and metaphysics to these scientists

[@mithunbalaji8199]

​it is quite possible that they could have given them a good description on consciousness Schopenhauer especially was suprised to find numerous similarities between the Upanishads and his own The world as will and representation. He was also interested in Buddhism. It think pranav included such quotes which entails idealism and consciousness centred solution and interpretation of wave function collapse in quantum mechanics

[@mithunbalaji8199]

There are many interpretations of wave function collapse. People without any conclusive evidence favour some interpretations like the one centred around consciousness and affiliatied with Vedanta over others They claim the interests of scientists into such philosophies and their beliefs As some sort of evidence/support. Apart from it,when it comes to philosophy in west there are plato, Kant, Berkeley we have philosophers like adi Shankaracharya, Nagarjuna etc... Philosophers like Schopenhauer even tried to interpret the Upanishads on the light of his own philosophy (which he came to conclusion seperately)

[@Mlecchakshaydixit]

@@mithunbalaji8199 what we fail to understand that science is for the discovery of material universe the one perceived by our senses while the purpose of philosophy and spirituality are concerned with our inner world thier goal is to find cause of suffering and several solutions to it it is like a science of exploration into conciousness and human mind they are not concerned with maths rather with mind I think both should not be intermixed and both should be given importance into our lives one helped us to explore outer world other helps to explore our inner self

[@mithunbalaji8199]

Yes. Science by its very definition studies the natural world . Your post reminds me of the first noble truth. Indeed, the nature of consciousness (don't now whether possible to study Using science) is a central thing in spirituality and philosophy. Moreover it has huge implications in ethics

[@karthik7486]

This is the problem with extremists. The Hindu extreme think Oppenheimer was actually uppala Narasimha coz he read and liked Gita. Atheists think religion is useless and played no role in their lives coz they didn’t make thesis and research papers on it. It’s spirituality and science. Ramanujan said the Devi leaves the equations on his tongue. Is that rational? Is there any evidence of a goddess coming and somehow putting ideas into Ramanujan brain like in inception…or if going by your logic, since he said tongue, LITERALLY on his tongue? No. We all know it was ramanujan’s genius. Muhammed Ali says all his strength has come from allah….do we have evidence that allah was connected to Ali through a artery and sending him his powerful blood? No. He was doing it all by his hardwork and talent all the years. But these ppl mentally derive their strength from being spiritual. The thing is, spirituality makes humans do extraordinary things. Thats why great minds use religion for self introspection and mental health, whereas lesser men take every word literally and debate around if the words meant one thing or another.

[@mayankanimates6460]

Correct that's why I don't like pranav too, he is just average guy as any other, just trying to debate debunking people. He had done shit for humanity or invented shit. Zero.

[@mtk3755]

The answer lies within experiencing a spiritual state and replicating that experience through your actions and works. Also being grateful to get the opportunity to experience it.

[@lightyear5732]

what make you think we delight in seeing foreigners talking about our religion. That is the mindset of the so called peaceful religion

[@gauravdas6741]

What did tamil jihadis think?

[@laudenaththetoiletcleaner]

lindu ling pujari

[@akkrishna]

Much needed. Thanks!!

[@scienceisdope]

Thank you!

[@AA12434]

Krishna Said in Gita *Thus, I have explained to you this knowledge that is more secret than all secrets. Ponder over it deeply, and then do as you wish.* Krishna clearly gives choice to Arjun to gain knowledge and then perform what he thinks and wishes. As human being, we should also take knowledge from all sources, ponder over it, then do what we think is best. Even if its direct words of God Himself. Stay curious, Hare Krishna !!!!

[@manofscience69]

Should have kept it a secret only.

[@svanimation8969]

​@@manofscience69 *Aano bhadra krtavo yantu vishwatah* they were motivated to believe that one must acquire knowledge from whatever source it may come from. Let the knowledge to me from all directions its up to ur own u have to decide what's wrong what's right u have to use ur brain ur creater given u brain use it and find the answer of life's difficult questions which Hinduism allow Debate and discussion ! And reforms ! Which I like ! I don't like the fake name Hinduism Hindu word was derogatory term from Persians to we people's of jambudweep or u can say bharatha official name ! Anyways I see as our scriptures as philosophical work and some are like that ancient eras science journals (for e.g shushrut sahita) and patanjli book of yoga ! Like no other faith have this much shit its a contribution like Wikipedia organization sometimes it can be right some times it can be stupidity some times it can be a propaganda ! So yeah this thing teach us always do ur own research ! Take references like those scientists took cuz knowledge is everywhere nothing is absolute correct nothing is absolute wrong ! Even science can't answer many questions of life many mystery's we can only use our imagination as first step so yeah both needed !

[@theodiscusgaming3909]

@@svanimation8969 'Hindu' is not a derogatory term, it comes from the Persian word for India which comes from the word Sindhu

[@svanimation8969]

@@theodiscusgaming3909 it is bro it is ! Say any afgan afgani (its also a derogatory term peddle since ages by outsiders) like how people's from white country's say americans Yankees 😂 its just like that ! Just imagine if america fall down and there education system (no printing technology ) no other technology to save info ! If u say a lie again and again it become sometimes reality ! After literacy fall down after burning of India universities like nalanda takshashila and 15 others reputed ancient educational hub its so easy to fool peoples who didn't GEt any education for long ! Even bramins who we used think they also not have much knowledge actually ! Only so so rare to find someone knew about why when brahmin mantra for ceremony include word jambudweepa they just read !

[@v-rex3206]

SANATANI​@@theodiscusgaming3909

[@bananaverse]

I've never clicked so fast. Your topics are always intriguing, This is the type of content KZbin needs more of.

[@frankiestein8482]

hes a just a typical gungadin

[@bharathikb8116]

I don't y this guy is hating on Hinduism but realise that u were born in this religion so ur able to talk so rationally that u claim. Realise u are lucky to be born in Bharat Sanatana Dharma where u were not discriminated or deprived u off ur education

[@jeswinchowdary]

😂

[@jeswinchowdary]

Bro caste system was an integral part of Hinduism. And you are talking about equality 😂

[@YasHraJ_1203]

​@@jeswinchowdaryit depends on your work

[@ashwinarora7561]

Great one Pranav!

[@harsh2day]

Another well explained video!

[@Kokani-boka]

I am hindu, i believe in God but i also against blind faith and superstition, fake godmans who are actually culprits. Edit -(Some toxic atheist attacking me in comment section )

[@Abhay-vk9uq]

how do you know if a faith is blind or not? and if you can answer that how is ur faith not blind?

[@vishalkaleeswaran7039]

How is belief in God not blind faith?

[@NidzShah-ps6kr]

​@@Abhay-vk9uqreligions that slap blasphemy laws for raising questions about God or subjecting criticism to accounts of his "greatness", who believe that you will burn in hell for all eternity if you don't follow the word of god, or invoke a culture of honor and shame to marginalize skeptics are definitely trying to instill blind faith bcz they're saying you should believe them no questions asked and if you dare to inquire then doom and torture will be struck on you either by god or by his followers.

[@Kokani-boka]

Ok do you people believe in love & humanity, he is every person heart, who are kind and innocent, Love is God 🙏

[@vishalkaleeswaran7039]

@@Kokani-boka People who are good at heart and kind, are "people". Why do you have to invoke an imaginary entity and call them God? Genuinely curious.

[@madeinandhra12-rk5mw]

Hinduism and certain amount of thought process in it may definitely have some intellectual and philosophical aspect in it (most religions do) - but giving this scientific claim is mostly due to superiority complex from our inferiority complex. We have to come out of it and as you stated in your previous videos - let’s realize our right strengths.

[@namah4399]

Name those 'most of the religions'

[@madeinandhra12-rk5mw]

@@namah4399 if you asked this question in these days of the internet - you wouldn't even understand the answer to it. Move on bud.

[@namah4399]

@@madeinandhra12-rk5mw don't try to act cool Just admit it You do not know the names of the 'most religions'

[@madeinandhra12-rk5mw]

@@namah4399 Okay Admitted sir, Sleep happy and proud. Nice meeting you here.

[@AnimeIsCrap]

​@@madeinandhra12-rk5mwNo other religion (known and popular ones) alive today are even one bit closer to Hindu philosophy lol🤣🙃 Go and read your seven deadly sins and what not fanatical bullshit in Abrahamic shit🤣

[@adrenokr]

Pranav gonna get so many hates from chintus and tunnis

[@AmeyVikram16]

Chintus and tunnis? What is that? I'm sorry but I'm not aware.

[@anamelessmonster]

Chintus and tunnis 😂😂😂

[@adrenokr]

@@AmeyVikram16 extremists religious people who just spread hate for others and have very low IQ.

[@MF_DOOM99]

@GOD_SHINIGAMI.07 chintus = 'nafrati chintus'. Tunnis(short for sanatunnis) = people who are so tunn/high on religion that they can't even see the truth. 😂

[@Zardy123]

​@@MF_DOOM99sir tun se juda

[@QWRTYPSDFGHJKLZXCVBNM]

Antoher amazing video @ScienceIsDope. As someone pursuing PhD in physics who also has a keen interest in literature, philosophy & psychology; I'd like to share my two cents on this: 1. Our goal is to understand the nature, the universe, through scientific means & hence, all the ancient texts don't stand a chance in this endeavour. 2. Having said that, these texts have their own place in the society. I completely agree with what Pranav said that they surely are piece of art worth cherishing, and at times give very profound insights. 3. These texts are surely marvelous and worth exploring, simply because of the ideas and topics they discuss. As Socrates said, it's a mark of an educated mind to entertain an idea without accepting it. 4. The problem arises when one starts reading way too much between the lines or begins mis-representing/mis-associating them in sciences.

[@praveen25]

This is pretty much all that needs to be said on the topic. If everyone understood this, we would all be better off.

[@Agnostic7773]

Well said

[@skpaanda]

Wonderfully put!

[@krox477]

That's your opinion

[@amritanshuupadhyay8269]

@surajrawat6802 Language games is said in context of logic as a teleological tool for describing reality not exactly intermixing there is cognitive pareidolia for that stephen jay gould's idea of non overlapping magesteria would be more appropriate for your assesment.

[@sujayshah13]

"For the past twenty years, I have searched through all the Hindu scriptures like Vedas, Upanishads, Puranas and other ancient books related to Hindu Astrology and other sciences, but I have not been able to discover anywhere that the basic principles of modern science are contained in these books." - Scientist (Astrophysicist) Meghnad Saha

[@HimanshuKumar-uh5um]

check quantum physics

[@traderdox]

Well that’s incorrect. I will give few examples; 1. Pi 2. Pythagerous theorem mentioned centuries before. 3. Heliocentric theory (that sun is in the center), ever heard of Navagrahas? 9 planets. 4. Distance between Earth and Sun 5. Earth being 4.32 billion years. Wtf was she reading?

[@sujayshah13]

@@HimanshuKumar-uh5um I'm starting PhD in Physics this year, studied Quantum Mechanics in bachelor's and master's. Didn't find anything remotely similar to quantum physics. Physicist Meghanad Saha studied and researched Vedas for 20 years, along with his physics researches, he didn't find anything similar too. A few western scientists said those, but they never researched on Veda, Heisenberg for example, travelled in India, met Rabindranath Tagore, and Tagore told him about Veda philosophy. Heisenberg himself said this in the whole quote. So he didn't read Vedas either, he just heard a few stories from Tagore when he was in tour.

[@sujayshah13]

@@traderdox Meghnad Saha is a ‘he’, btw, 1. Where does it mention? Which Veda, which shloka? 2. Where? 3. Navagraha (9 planets) in hinduism includes Sun and Moon and it doesn't include Earth. According to hinduism, Sun and Moon are planets, and Earth isn't a planet. Rahu and Ketu are in those 9 planet list too, which causes solar and lunar eclipses according to hinduism. But in reality, other planets can't cause lunar eclipses on Earth. Btw, there are 8 planets, if you include Pluto, you have to include other dwarf planets too, which will cause the number go up. So even the number 9 isn't correct according to modern science. So it's scientifically inaccurate. 4. Where? 5. In my Gita, it is mentioned that Krishna comes to this Earth every 8.6 billion years, but Earth's age is between 4 to 5 billion years, so it's again another scientific inaccuracy in Veda. I read Vedas, Mahabharata, and Ramayana, starting my research in astrophysics in 2024, I've never found anything scientific in those books. Instead I've found many many scientific inaccuracies and wrong information about the universe in those books. This doesn't only apply to hinduism either, Bible starts with wrong information about the universe from the very first page, Quran has tons of wrong information. Anyone with an unbiased open mind and genuine intention can see those, blind believers can't.

[@theodiscusgaming3909]

@@traderdox there is a video on this very channel about how the Earth-Sun distance claim is fake.

[@Amiittk]

Ramanujan was greatly inspired by mythology and we all know how great he was... Probably the most influential mathematician of all time.

[@kafka1343]

Even Newton was a great believer of Christian God. And even Einstein believes in the idea of spinoza So what will you call there religion and believes leads these extra ordinary works

[@Hatak_ekakashi15]

​@rjejrjejyes but

[@abi3751]

Definitely not, can be called one of the.

[@For_watching_yt]

​@@kafka1343so that means just don't shit Do whatever you want and don't disturb others

[@BruceWayne-qe7bs]

@gamepirate4998 It's something more than that. Many of his colleges didn't understood how he got the conclusion out of thin air. When they ask him, he always said God said this equation in his sleep.

[@prabkunvar10]

Bro trust me, ever since the Radicalisation of indian population I have switched my youtube from india to the USA and Deleted insta (the most toxic social media rn) YOU are one of the only few indian channels i am following right now! You are a logical and a rational person bro! And i am happy, i got a chance to follow ur page!

[@inUSA072]

How to switch your youtube from India to USA ?

[@prabkunvar10]

@@inUSA072 youtube app>settings>general>Location Then change it to any country you want......... And see for yourself how much better the youtube of usa is than our india's toxic youtube 😃

[@inUSA072]

@@prabkunvar10 I thought ussey sirf Explore page badalta hai, recommendations nahj

[@inUSA072]

@@prabkunvar10 mujhey thumhari kahani nahi sunni. The thing is youtube Algorithm. If you watch these things, you will get recommendations like that only. These things like switching Country on youtube won't work like you mention. Just start watching American content and you will be recommended the same. You are just philosophically wrong, and I want to correct that.

[@iamyourmom65]

Broo I did the same😂😂😂

[@neet6804]

Video Summary Introduction: In this video, the creator discusses the claims made by some individuals that Hinduism is greatly compatible with science. They specifically focus on the statements made by four scientists: Julius Robert Oppenheimer, Carl Sagan, Erwin Schrödinger, and Werner Heisenberg. The video aims to debunk these claims and highlight the misinterpretations and exaggerations made by those who associate Hinduism with science. Retelling of the Video: 1. Julius Robert Oppenheimer: Oppenheimer, known as the father of the atomic bomb, famously quoted a line from the Bhagavad Gita when witnessing the testing of the first atomic bomb. Some people interpret this quote as evidence of Hinduism's compatibility with science. However, the creator argues that Oppenheimer was simply using a religious metaphor to describe the awe he felt during the explosion. The claim that ancient Hindu texts mention nuclear weapons is baseless, as there is no scientific evidence to support it. 2. Carl Sagan: Carl Sagan, a renowned science communicator, is often quoted by those claiming that he regarded Hinduism as the greatest among religions. However, this claim is taken out of context. In a video discussing how ancient civilizations viewed the universe, Sagan mentions that Hindu myths have time scales comparable to modern scientific cosmology. He states that this correspondence is likely a coincidence, and there is no scientific evidence to confirm the claims made in Hindu mythology. 3. Erwin Schrödinger: Schrödinger, a Nobel Prize-winning physicist, is also cited by Hindu nationalist blogs to support their claims. However, the creator couldn't find any scientific significance in the quote attributed to Schrödinger. It appears that these blogs are more interested in finding famous scientists who mention Hinduism rather than seeking genuine scientific evidence. 4. Werner Heisenberg: The creator mentions a quote by Werner Heisenberg, but no elaboration or context could be found. It seems that this quote is also being used to associate Hinduism with science without any scientific basis. Conclusion: The video concludes that these claims of Hinduism's compatibility with science are often exaggerated and misinterpreted. Quoting individual scientists or cherry-picking quotes does not provide scientific evidence or consensus. It is important to critically examine the context and consensus within the scientific community before making any claims about the compatibility of religion and science.

[@avisharma4576]

What you are doing is important, Sid. Thank you for existing...

[@ex.hindu.now.atheist]

@avisharma4576 “What you are doing is important, Sid. Thank you for existing...” ================= Who is ‘Sid’ ?

[@saisankark90]

Who's Sid ?

[@ex.hindu.now.atheist]

@@saisankark90 "Who's Sid ?" ================== I think 'sid' is a fat-fingered typo, where the intention was to say 'sir' .

[@amitkolhe4155]

@@ex.hindu.now.atheist- Sid = Science Is Dope = S...i...d

[@prakashkalluri64]

​@@ex.hindu.now.atheist it's short for "Science is dope"

[@nik.overkill]

Appreciate your work brother, i personally am a hindu and got nothing against religious people but its very important to think rational so we do not get fooled by these people like sadguru, i think hinduism is beautiful as it is and does not need any validation from any scientist, its very unlikely that our mythological stories like mahabharat and ramayan are real, but they teach us alot of moral values about how we should live our lives which makes it lovely as it is.

[@justforfunlol2258]

I was genuinely shocked to learn that many people actually take myths literally- like growing up hindu, I never got that impression. Everyone just treated them as romanticised stories around me and often replied in an agnostic way when asked about death and stuff. And I'm talking people like my mum and grandma, who are serial temple goers. Maybe it's a South Indian thing

[@nik.overkill]

@@justforfunlol2258 I also feel blessed that i was never forced to have a mandatory passion towards religious beliefs or rituals.

[@justforfunlol2258]

@@nik.overkill I was definitely forced to go to temples tho lmao, but their beliefs weren't as defined and staunch as you find it online now I guess

[@nik.overkill]

@@justforfunlol2258 true

[@prakharrai5359]

​@@justforfunlol2258like today's rational people don't want to save their culture they just want to force their culture

[@lmaoidgaf]

Science is Dope!!!! Love your content!!!

[@abhishekbhattacharjee6584]

When it comes to Hinduism and the admiration of Hindu philosophy by famous scientists, these secular progressive scientist youtubers suddenly become Close Minded. They won't want to dig deeper.

[@Nobodylihshdheuhdhd]

He is not even a scientist. He is a failed podcaster

[@dev_peace_soul]

8:28 dude is a bozo in science... you gotta study more 🤡💀

[@arshkr17]

Whats your thoughts on book " why i am an atheist by Bhagat Singh" Can u suggest some books which challenge our old beliefs and help to think more rationally.

[@gurnoorsingh2214]

God delusion by dawkins and god is not great by hitchens are the best ones. For more rational ones, go for sapiens by yuval harari

[@VijayThakurMD]

advait vedant is a good read.

[@RJ-vk5kh]

Read veer seventh book

[@vidhroh1538]

Annihilation of Caste by BR Ambedkar

[@namah4399]

Carl Segan , Neils Bohr , J. Robert Oppenhiemer , and more scientists found Hinduism and its teachings interesting and deep and if Hindus are proud of that they should be ! Appreciate your ancestors . Be proud of them. Not because scientists admired their religion but because someone who was not born in their religion did it which makes it exceptional

[@ni8fury101]

yeah but they don't , they get delusional about that makes their religion true or something like that. scientists like the philosophy and we should too but only till there. and appreciate your ancestor thing i don't know what you mean by that but taken religion as a concept then no. majority of practices done previous generation are mostly bad and in today's world most of them are considered as crimes so NO.

[@RandomIndianUsingYT]

10:14 There is no science there. But there is philosophy. And erwin Schrodinger subscribed to the same core philosophical idea as Advaitis. He thought this kind of metaphysics would fit in with his ideas

[@vishwmehta1813]

The scientists that were mentioned in the video actually took inspiration from Vedanta, i.e., Bhagwad Gita, Upanishads and Brahmasutras, by grasping its philosophical aspects and stay motivated into their pursuit. But the problem is when people especially hindus start saying things like "See that XYZ Nobel Prize Winner scientist quoted our religious texts, so he/she discovered their findings from our scriptures. Hence, our ancients were great scientists and we were the first ones to teach the World." So this kind of argument shows how naive and stupid you are. In fact most hindus, themselves have not read Vedanta (as mentioned above) so they don't understand the fact that the scriptures are more of philosophical in nature than that of outer physical science. Thanks Pranav for pointing things out loud without hesitating. Keep going brother 💪

[@ozarks2345]

lol no its not called motivation its called biasness towrds you relgion and yes science motivated them way more than vedanta and geeta or anything else these scientist did discoveries even before knowing any relgious bullshot

[@PrashanthKuppa]

The video is not about that though, if some scientists did praise something about Hinduism. Vedanta is a part of Hinduism, do you think Islam, Christianity have equal claim on it or something?

[@ozarks2345]

@@PrashanthKuppa vedanta is bullshit it literally says jagat mithya lol

[@PrashanthKuppa]

@@ozarks2345 brother that is irrelevant to my comment

[@mitchjames9350]

@@ozarks2345 in what way is the Vedanta bullshit?

[@Mahato-r7z]

Pain is clear in his words 😂

[@siddharthn5007]

Science is nothing infront of Religious Textbooks ~ According to Bhakts commenting on KZbin using phone made my science 😂😂😂

[@prakharrai5359]

Well not gonna say but hinduism is better than organised religion like in terms of moral much better you believe or not your choice but it's reality

[@gurnoorsingh2214]

​@@prakharrai5359no, the reality is caste is an integral part of hinduism, it has mentions in gita, vedas and puranas. And since hindu texts advocate casteist behaviour, it is the same as organised religion. Just a few days ago, a hindu woman was killed because she was a lower caste and entered the temple during peak hours. Such cases happen evry week and day and that is the rezlity

[@prakharrai5359]

@@gurnoorsingh2214 casteism was mention but not by blood but by work, can show your proof that any text said casteism doesn't allow people to enter in temples or they are lower also dear i am not gonna say it's not present but if people taking it in wrong way it's not book's fault like like imagine did Hindu scriptures mentioned that every widow commit shati i guess not but people create this inhuman way

[@iiTzKaran_YT]

​@@gurnoorsingh2214casteism was distorted generation by generation, British ruined them even more, there is no evidence in scriptures that we didn't allow anyone because of their caste before the invasions

[@gukananand6647]

​@@prakharrai5359but hindu scriptures say that people should be punished based on castes...In manusmriti there are different punishments for shudras and a brahmin... shudras can be killed but no one should kill a brahmin even though he/she commits a huge mistake....

[@jaysnehpandey7089]

Wake up babe, science is dope uploaded

[@mithunbalaji8199]

When it comes to Upanishads its interpretation of the nature of consciousness was a great achievement in philosophy. When it comes to its implications on science, by the very nature of their studies are limited to the domain of neurophilosophy and possible little neuroscience. I think we have to see such texts more as a philosophical one than as a religious thing, just like how we see the works of Kant, Schopenhauer, Spinoza etc.. It is also possible that they could influence various positions within the philosophy of science especially the philosophical interpretation of fundamental laws in quantum mechanics.

[@SuryaJinping]

Why do you think they have to be superimposed on parameter of science?

[@sujayshah13]

By their own logic, Christianity or Judaism must be true because most scientists believed in it, one of the greatest contributor of science, Issac Newton very very strongly believed in Bible, he studied and researched years on Christianity, and believed that murti puja is a sin, he was even against most Christians because they make statues of Jesus.

[@sarveshtanavade506]

Issac Newton read bible only for alchemy related purposes and not because not because he was a staunch Christian 😅😅😅

[@kafka1343]

@@sarveshtanavade506lol 😂there is zero alchemy in bible lol he believed in bible god. And even the alchemy words comes from al kimia have arabic in origin mostly from jabir ibn al hayyan work.and even darwin he believed in bible God, until near his death he called himself as atheist the reason behind was the human pain and suffering and war lol even at that time when he gave his Darwinian evolution theory he was a theist who believes in bible lol So stop reading headline and whatsapp text read the full content 😅

[@sarveshtanavade506]

@@kafka1343 When did I say that there is alchemy in Bible but he believed so and tried to create his own magic portions for immortality

[@leonhardeuler7647]

Well to be fair maybe that's why they think that Newton stole it all from Hindus ..

[@godlessparticle]

It's the unemployed youth that want to feel special by believing in these things.

[@yenaremadun7184]

Not just them, my friends who are in high paying jobs also think Hinduism is special.

[@aizen9057]

​@@yenaremadun7184it is

[@CuriousINDIA101]

Watch 'A Brief History of Vedas' Heard of that 1600-year-old iron pillar that hasn't rusted, We had metallurgy, maths, physics, geometry, architecture, literature, medical science, astronomy, art, music, dance, more than 19500 languages and dialects, etc. Bakhshali manuscript found near Takhshila, And the Bharat was big part of trades and travellers. Is it all my wishful thinking or your believe, are you follower of science or believer of science? Are you really skeptic and a explorer and seeker of truth or just a believer like a religious person.

[@himanshugurjar9002]

​@@yenaremadun7184It is special. A human without an identity is just a puny individual. Hinduism provides a sense of belonging to india to some. For others, it addresses different aspects of their psychology.

[@N28-h9m]

​@@yenaremadun7184do they all also fanatically support a particular party? Not judging , just trying to find a pattern

[@Mukesh-oq8dx]

@13:10 agree with everything in the video except the last part. imo, indeed it does make Hinduism special in terms of its rich philosophy. Probably they are some of the first ones who put effort into thinking and hypothesizing creation of the universe.

[@yash1829]

For me Indian philosophy is nastika philosophy ( charvaka, Buddhism, Jainism, ...)

[@AryanKohli-hkscx]

philosophers were born around the world. many of them had different deep thought

[@Mlecchakshaydixit]

​@@yash1829why

[@yash1829]

@@Mlecchakshaydixit what?

[@dnyaneshlakhmal7735]

Bro comes at everyone who talks about positive about Hinduism 😂😂

[@AnimeIsCrap]

He's blunt. He doesn't realize it but he's blunt. He doesn't know how to explain the general public properly. That is in my opinion lol😂 And the other part that he's just doing it for attention on KZbin cuz he's most likely jobless😂 Bro goes onto smash on philosophical texts and never considers the positive part of it and always looks for holes that suit with his reality🤣

[@v-rex3206]

Still I'm figuring out that he's encountering Scientists

[@frankiestein8482]

hes a gungadin that if gora sahib told him to eat his poo as its more superior than Dosa he would proudly.

[@mayursawant111]

And I'm 100% sure in coming future ( I'm saying in scale of few 100 years ) someone will come and say our ancestors already knew everything about moon and that there's also a place called shiva shakti on it. Their counter argument will be, how can there be a place called shiv shkati on moon. Because our ancestors were very scientific and they discovered mentions of it on the moon in one of many books we religion people blindly believe in.

[@afishekkrishnar4415]

😂 damn bro❤

[@N0Xa880iUL]

Inception

[@NolanGraysonNowl]

Mercury was named after the Roman god of travel. Venus was named after the Roman goddess of love and beauty. Mars was the Roman god of War. Jupiter was the king of the Roman gods, and Saturn was the Roman god of agriculture. Say something about it, 🥺

[@pikachue602]

Yes our ancestors where mathematicians and scientists

[@Bhakt-TheDevotee]

@@NolanGraysonNowl "Oh sheet! Ab kya bolu ab toh meri hawa nikal gyi!"

[@RohanItis]

Everytime there's some new invention it has it's routes somewhere in the Hindu Text 😂

[@anamelessmonster]

It funny tho

[@thimbaiah9005]

Lmao fr

[@mistydash]

Most scientific religion 😂😂

[@SussyBaka-uq6nf]

And they claim that it is stolen from there

[@aniketverma8774]

There is one person you missed, Ramanujan. Please explain how he came up with all his equations without scientific way of approaching the problem. Well he didn't came up totally unscientifically at the same time, but I can't but agree that his intuition was divine. I'm not a criticiser , just curious.

[@frankiestein8482]

he cant because his inferoity complex wouldn't be able to

[@brahmendrabachi9016]

I have these three basic questions, If anyone knows please comment the answer When did modern science declared earth is a sphere? Is it already there in Indian Scriptures? When did the idea of time dilation starts in modern science? or the concept of time dilation already said in Indian Scriptures When did modern science found the distance between earth and the sun? Is it already mentioned in the Indian Scriptures? Please answer these three questions

[@DJISBEST]

Earth being a sphere was not proved by modern science, even the ancient Greeks and Romans knew it and even calculated circumference of the earth Concept of time dilation is not mentioned in Indian scriptures Distance between the sun and the earth is not mentioned in Indian scriptures

[@sandeepnautiyal3070]

@@DJISBEST Concept of time dilation does exist in the scriptures. It is said that bhrama's one day who is living far away in the cosmic ocean (which is believed to be over the edge of the observable universe per some schools of hinduism) is equal to our 4.32 something billion years

[@--joker]

​@@DJISBESTsee, west will never accept the ancient richness of Bharat, you have already seen how they reacted when bharat landed it's chandrayan on South pole of moon, you are talking about Greek Romans, even there it reached from bharat, Greek roman mythologies are talked by west but they will never talk about history of Bharat, because they themselves are thief they will get exposed if they started talking about bharat history

[@Dawg.12]

​@@DJISBESTdistance of earth from sun is mentioned in hanuman chalisa

[@DJISBEST]

@@Dawg.12 no it's not, it's been debunked years ago lol

[@tgkthebawse]

Oppenheimer did actually learn Sanskrit and read the Bhagwat Gita. He is a philosophy nut and has read variety of literature for philosophical and political interests. Him reading the Bhagwat Gita is a part of Oppenheimer's philosophical journey.

[@sukumarkrishnadasa6708]

9:58 Propaganda again - who is saying that there is science. You please answer, by these quotes do you feel that they have an appreciation towards vedanta and upanishads? Looking forward gor your answer.

[@shubhamkunkerkar5787]

yes, there is appreciation for mythological stories and philosophies not for science

[@HeySpecified]

Here to save students some time. the entire video is just "no evidence,no scientific method followed,not true" so dont waste your time watching this Neither disagreeing with him nor agreeing but rest of the video is just that what i said above :)

[@sahasananth987]

That’s all you need to know religion is bs

[@Whatyelooking]

You talked about Sagan's video clip but not his own published book How arrogant You didn't talk about Schrödinger (who initially was a Sanskrit scholar but later got nobel in Physics) Why didn't you talk about Heisenberg? Why not Einstein's small yet influential mention? Why actually not highlight the verses from the Hindu texts taught so I guarantee you neither studied Physics Neither did you study Hindu scriptures We agree Hinduism isn't as accurate as modern science But whatever was said was logical and most of them are proved correct except that too many personifications and metaphors confuse us simple brains But other religions do not even talk about such topics They are still stuck in spreading love and kindness which people obviously do by default In Physics we study: Electron interacts with the world in 3 ways As wave (superposition and interference of ß-rays), As particle (bond formation), As energy (photoelectric effect and energy level changing) So similarly Hinduism says a single God can exist in several forms (Polymorphism) and reside at different places (like Superposition) And Hinduism also says that there is Only One God (Eka Brahma Dvitiya Nasti) So Hinduism isn't Polytheism, it is Polymorphic Monotheism (This is a very complex thing and gets easier if you study Carl Sagan's book on superposition ) And Shri Krishna also told Arjun that _any object is made of energy and every such energy belongs to Shri Krishna_ And this thing is taught in higher education Physics. That is, all matter in the universe is energy (E=mc² for converting) And also Thermodynamics teaches that the energy of the whole universe is conserved and also of same origin and are unified. Scientists like Heisenberg, Schrödinger, Sagan, Oppenheimer, Einstein acknowledged Hinduism Einstein just acknowledged but wasn't much into it Oppenheimer read Bhagvat Gita and followed Shri Krishna's principles in his daily life and the above mentioned word of Shri Krishna inspired him a lot (the death and destruction quote) Sagan later on converted to Hinduism Heisenberg after making his theory came to India and after his interaction with Rabindranath Tagore about the Vedas and Upanishads he said "The theories of modern science would be Easier for those to understand who read the Upanishads or Vedas" Schrödinger in one of his articles had some Physics theory and where he used Upanishads for reference (I don't understand the part too cuz it's very complex... 🐱) Now coming to Biological sciences, If we see the Avatars of Lord Vishnu, they appeared exactly in order of Phylogenetic progression

[@riasharma3927]

The point at which the rover landed shouldn't be named Shivshakti . It's a mockery of science and hardwork of scientists. Instead it could be named with any of the scientist who played a key role in establishing ISRO.

[@whimsicalvagabond6906]

Exactly, the location where the Apollo mission landed was called “Sea of tranquility” a very neutral name. They didn’t call it, “Miracle of Jesus” or home of Jesus” or Jesus is real” or “Christ is great and the only real god”. Even their missions didn’t bear any religious names. But here we have “Mr.Sewer Gas” and “Elephant head plastic surgery” calling the site “Shiv Shakti”. Absolute utter rubbish.

[@AmeyVikram16]

Exactly . It could have been given a secular name, like the name of a scientist, freedom fighter, or any philosophical concept. Religious names are not optimum here.

[@Cray-wilder]

Scientist who worked on the project named it Apollo mission not because they believed in the greek god Apollo. Rather they thought that it was the only name that could justify the scale of mission. Pm modi has done the same by giving it a context, men and women together made it possible. We fail to see bigger picture. Every one names after their great scientists there is no originality in it.

[@theodiscusgaming3909]

@@whimsicalvagabond6906 well _technically_ the Apollo missions were named after the Greek god Apollo but no one believes in ancient Greek religion it doesn't count

[@alpha-vs1fx]

​@@theodiscusgaming3909it does count. Its western culture. India needs to name points on indian culture. Idk what's the problem.

[@kashinathmaharana7422]

This guy is like why the hell these scientists found similarities in Hinduism.. Then goes on saying " this means nothing" 😂😂😂 Keep crying

[@frankiestein8482]

he needs to stop using 'hindu' numerals as they are so backward and unscientific.

[@Raja_Vasireddy]

Another Great Video !!!! 👏👏

[@henilchhipani]

Why every religion want to become so scientific do they love science that much.... Or just validate the point and sell their ideas because they knew people trust science more than their religion 😅

[@sounavapandit7888]

its that sanatan and science is inter connected , sure u haven't even heard the names of the vedas

[@no1factsspeaker321]

​@@sounavapandit7888it's definitely not LMAOO

[@harishpujari5779]

Thanks

[@rudrakshsharma7726]

I have heard many of them say that their work was inspired by some hindu text but all of them were christians Knowledge is knowledge one doesnt need to be hindu to gain knowledge

[@robinroy3436]

Right 👍❤❤❤

[@Hindu_Flat_Earther]

Actually Oppenheimer was a Jew. Carl Sagan was a convert to Buddhism.

[@ashukumar7755]

Not true everyone wasn't Christian, Carl Sagan was atheist

[@rudrakshsharma7726]

That's not what I am trying to imply

[@arjyachatterjee6874]

​@@ashukumar7755 Carl Sagan was not an atheist, he was an agnostic.

[@towardstruth2125]

How Rishi's knew about science? Example: science says we are made up of cells. Single cell cannot be seen through naked eyes, we are visible because trillions of cells made us multicellurar & we became physical. But a bird's egg is not a muticellular, according to scientists it's a single cell but we can see through naked eyes & it has a physical presence. Nature is abundant with such examples to grant you science & develope your scientific temprament.

[@akshayk6421]

Happy Onam bro

[@jaybhavani8416]

❤ We expect discussion on Literature of Pandit Gopi Krishna Unbelievable mysterious spiritual experiences & Unexpected Physical -mental-spiritual state of sadhak . Towards the Truth . -------------------------------------------------

[@aakashatheist9161]

Keep going bro we are with you 👍👍 great video you doing a great job plz keep going don't think about those people just keep us educated

[@chesswithsagar]

10:07 that quote is for philosophical purpose to reduce ahamkar (self) of humans, It talks about randomness of universe, how out of billions of galaxies, out of billions of stars and their billion of planets, we got a planet on which some atoms managed to think and ponder about life and universe. We should remember that we are a part of this consciousness (brahm) only, not something divine or mystic. It is to make us understand that universe does not revolve around us. If you want to know about philosophy in detail, I suggest you videos of Acharya Prashant (Ex-IIT, IIM, Civil servant) who roasts such people who connect any scripture with science.

[@harbinger_1984]

"I have become death the distroyed of words" I heard this first time from the mouth of oppenheimer... Its clearly a Bhagwat Gita phrase but it also gained popularity coz of he said it.

[@v-rex3206]

Becoz he read it

[@harbinger_1984]

@@v-rex3206 he read many other shlokas... But he said this one.

[@celestialsatheist1535]

Hey SID i am surprised you are not covering the moon landing. Come in man as a science communicator this is prime material

[@thegodssin]

what is there to cover? Its awesome but there's nothing to discuss

[@Chalshanaban007]

​@@thegodssinwhy? And how is this helping more than not talking about chandrayan-3.

[@thegodssin]

@Ritesh-pv4yi i guess that's true on which I agree with you

[@thegodssin]

@@Chalshanaban007 well this is definitely helping clear misconceptions about scientists

[@celestialsatheist1535]

@Ritesh-pv4yi now that's a great idea

[@TheNeo349]

Great video as always pranav! a minor quibble, at 6:00 you mention that Sagan was an Atheist, which is incorrect. He called himself an agnostic throughout his life. He agreed with Einstein's support for Spinoza's god. A quote from him on atheism (source-wiki article on Carl Sagan) "An atheist is someone who is certain that God does not exist, someone who has compelling evidence against the existence of God. I know of no such compelling evidence. Because God can be relegated to remote times and places and to ultimate causes, we would have to know a great deal more about the universe than we do now to be sure that no such God exists. To be certain of the existence of God and to be certain of the nonexistence of God seem to me to be the confident extremes in a subject so riddled with doubt and uncertainty as to inspire very little confidence indeed" I am an atheist and consider Sagan to be a personal hero, so had to make sure his views were represented accurately. Thanks for your work in popularising the message of this legend.

[@scienceisdope]

The definition that you gave is that of a hard atheist. I'd say Carl was a soft atheist. An agnostic atheist. So am I. The hard atheist position seems irrational to me. No one can be certain that God does not exist. The general definition of God is unfalsifiable

[@arjyachatterjee6874]

​​​@@scienceisdope He used to call himself as agnostic though.

[@Pacifist_MRM]

In this regard, I prefer Neil deGrasse Tyson's opinion over Richard Dawkin's. As an atheist and considering the fact that religion is a deep rooted system unlike political ideologies, I do not have issues on what religion people follow as long as they do not "pass it off as true in a science classroom".

[@AaryanK]

Since you have been debunking the myths around Hinduism, It is also your responsibility to acknowledge and bring limelight on "empirical" contributions that the so-called Hindus gave to Mathematics and Sciences. Some of them are: "Infinite Series Proportion" was first developed by a mathematician named "Madhava" in Kerala and was transported to Europe through Jesuits in the Malabar coast "Modern base 10 numbers" were first used by hindus and was translated to Arabia and Europe "The Pascal's triangle" 's concept was first discovered by a Hindu named "Pingala" in around 200 BC (consensus date but it can be stretched further back) , despite this he is not given the credit that he deserves. Wikipedia does not even mention his name in the article related to pascal's triangle. These are some, if you dive deep, you will find plenty of contributions by our scientists/mathematicians. You talked about Aryabhata which I really appreciate for. Hope that you will make furthermore videos acknowledging our Scientific History. Much Support for you 👊👊

[@sommyamishra8204]

I literally like your series, I am also a Hindu believer but i don't like how some people spread misinformation regardless they don't really have any evidence for that.

[@manasuniyal2897]

Actually you should revisit the statement of ISRO'S current chairman on VEDAS and SCIENCE . I think you are not as intellgent as ISRO's chairman .

[@blahblahanything]

@@manasuniyal2897 again logical fallacy

[@luserguy4732]

​@manasuniyal2897 That's appeal to authority. A scientist is good in science that doesn't make him competent in other domains such as Philosophy & Religion. Stop treating imcumbents words as gospel.

[@narutoff08]

Ok .. but you dont have any problem in believing the fairy tale stories like some apple fell on someone and he woke up to discover gravity .. lol .. 🤣🤣,

[@trevorstatham4451]

This video is incorrectly titled. They ofc loved the texts and read them. But to attribute their discoveries to the texts would be a fallacy. But then this channel has a viewpoint which is more than science

[@hsk5234]

That was a different era, science was taking over the world and at the same time Scientists at the time just used to quote religions from around the world to stay relevant and show how well versed they're. Does not certify anything. And lol Oppenheimer mentions Vishnu instead of Krishna, that should be enough to know how much he actually knew about it. Oppenheimer also found inspiration in alcohol and sex lol let's celebrate that.

[@AhSjdv]

Referring krishna as vishnu itself tells he knew a lot because everybody says krishna told bhagwad Gita and referring krishna as Vishnu means he knew he was an avatar. Also not all humans are perfect, so no need to learn everything from a person who has excelled in one field

[@hsk5234]

@@AhSjdv lol again a false assumption just like every religious person, no one in their right mind would indirectly quote a literal sentence for some other character.

[@AhSjdv]

@@hsk5234 I was trying to say that he knew krishna is Vishnu that is why he said Vishnu. It means he studied hinduism enough. Why did these genius minds even were interested in hinduism. Maybe because they found those ideas interesting for the times they where written and also might find the philosophical aspect interesting. I never attacked you, just asked you questions and you were offended and called me religious and not even understood what I wanted to say, you are as ignorant as a religious person. I am neither athiest nor religious, I have not got answers to everything and I like to ask questions and stick to it till I get satisfactory answers

[@BruceWayne-qe7bs]

@@hsk5234 Your claim is not true. Scientists were quoting Hinduism and India was still British colony and at that time whites belived they were superior. No one would quote inferior people's religion.

[@Happinessquare]

​@@hsk5234😂😂😂libergandu

[@AnuChaudhary-w5c]

Listen to the full audio not a small part. Atheist be like how can i oppose any religion, oh just cut small part "by accident" Viola scientists disagreed. 😂😂😂 i genuinely feel sad for you people. Watch the full video.

[@Not_Even_One]

Again brother you are misinterpreting things completely. Complete misunderstanding of philosophy and historical facts. Science indeed great tool( also only tool) to analyze external world but these scientists are also driven by philosophy of life and ethics , in which you don't seems any speciality(means background of reading philosophy). You are just quoting facts and studies to validate your arguments but brother how can you use these tools to understand philosophy? I agree these claims of nuclear weapons in history are bullshit but don't mix it with what scientists have to say about Hinduism as philosophy, and not orthodox religion. Vedant and upnishad are huge source of moral and philosophical base for scientists as you mentioned their quotes. Just don't bring your hate of right wing to timeless wisdom of sanatan dharma. Hope you will take this as constructive criticism.

[@tathagatquandaliusganesh1082]

Exactly. The criticism we needed. He is confusing metaphysics with scientific interpretations. Our ancient scriptures don't have anything scientific to claim but they made philosophical interpretations to scientific questions of the natural world.

[@Not_Even_One]

@tathagatquandaliusganesh1082 exactly. And just see where he puts like on comment, where crowd talks against Hinduism. His personal bias do influence his views and so do visible in video. He said in video at 10:45 (I don't find anything...) bro seriously, where did you tried ? I hope u know that this will not mentioned in research papers. Honestly PRANAV read about "hermeneutics" .

[@thesheldoncooper]

Adding something to Sagan clip, in that episode he was discussing how human mind is curious, how the primitive humans tried to answer the question with whatever tools they have, and most of time resoted to common sense and mystical powers. He at NO POINT in that episode claim any religion is superior or got the science right. It's very heart breaking for to witness such nonsense around Dr Sagan. He's my Hero. I've always looked up to him and I still do...❤❤❤

[@basantprasadsgarden8365]

Saffronization of Science will not be allowed

[@anishthomas1]

Good stuff as always Pranav. Keep it rolling

[@sampatkumar3286]

Dope video as always. A request, Could you please stop calling that baffoon Sadguru and refer him with his actul name i.e Jaggi? Thanks in advance!

[@scienceisdope]

I did. Towards the end it would have become repetitive so I just said sadhguru. Trust me I dont mean any respect to that fraud when I say that

[@neet6804]

Key Insights 💣 Oppenheimer described the awe he felt while witnessing the first atomic bomb blast by quoting lines from the Bhagavad-Gita, suggesting a connection between science and Hinduism. 📚 Fiction has often predicted technologies that did not exist at the time, raising the question of whether these authors should be credited for envisioning future advancements. 🌌 The speaker highlights that the Big Bang Theory, which suggests a clear beginning of space and time, was first proposed by Catholic priests, challenging the idea that it makes Christianity special. 🤔 "Instead of answering the question of how the universe was created with God or cultural myths, just say 'I don't know' when you don't have enough evidence to conclude something." 🧠 Knowledge doesn't come magically, as Carl Sagan points out that understanding reality requires more than just meditation and basic science is necessary. 🌌 Our understanding of reality and the age of the universe is based on empirical evidence, not wishful thinking. 🤔 "These people who want you to believe these ideas are going out of their way to find rationalizations to associate Hinduism with science."

[@nikhileshsatani]

Yet another risk by Pranav 😅 Kudos to your work , Great Job🎉 👍👏

[@Bhakt-TheDevotee]

Risk? This video is not about Islam. His head is safe, don't worry.

[@riyazshaikh1665]

​@@Bhakt-TheDevoteeyes we all know what happens to journalists etc who raises questions against you lol😂

[@Bhakt-TheDevotee]

@@riyazshaikh1665 Lol yes. We all know Sir Jamal Khashoggi ji

[@riyazshaikh1665]

@@Bhakt-TheDevotee we all support jamal kashogi.. he was killed by saudi monarchs,and I am not bhakt like you..

[@Bhakt-TheDevotee]

@@riyazshaikh1665 Good

[@ShivamSingh-zx6fg]

Leave Pranav Alone, He is doing this to make a living (Pet k liye karna pdta h)

[@prince.8022]

Our definition of religion is primarily constructed by Abrahamic- Western understanding of God and Religion. So you will never be able to see Hinduism from Indic lens. The concept of God in Hinduism is different from Western Abrahamic faiths. Hindu view of God is the inner one, of pure consciousness, of the state of mind where fear evaporates, where you control your sense and you achieve the peace, equality within. You realise a that Atman (pure consciousness) is indeed Brahman (the infinite, eternal consciousness).. And Who developed Yoga? Today Yoga is world wide recognised, if you think Hinduism is false and superstitious, therefore yoga is automatically a superstitious too

[@mr.gamerkabir8142]

True Sat-chit-ananda is the mahat tattva

[@TheCosmopolitanHefty]

legit my bruh!

[@debjyotisarkar2492]

That's the thing i was looking in the comment section. Yes I'm saying god is not real its a abrahamic philosophy. In Hinduism its parmatma, self consciousness, vagban.

[@pratyxx3169]

This guy: professor dhoomketu🗿 Sadhu guru: Dhuni baba 🗿

[@shubmahajan]

Religion is personal thing. It gives inner peace and enlightenment of oneself to achieve outer things and success. So people who are saying it doesn't matter what religion he/she follows doesn't link to his/her achievement *is wrong*. If such great scientist feel it that one religion helps them directly or indirectly it matters. For being scientist you don't have to be Atheist. Just have faith in your religion without following wrong things.

[@RealCherry8085]

"Gather most of your knowledge from books, not from Internet"

[@llawlient10]

Hey pranav keep it up. You have balls which others dont have!

[@Chalshanaban007]

He doesn't actually..How many videos he has made on Islam? I have seen just one or two.. that too nothing substantial..he could have touched so many topics helping the ignorant Muslim youth but he loves his head on his shoulders

[@souravdebnath5339]

​@@Chalshanaban007aa gaya mu uthake apna stupidity ko represent karne

[@crossfadekent]

Whataboutery much?@@Chalshanaban007

[@gopime5885]

@@souravdebnath5339 How come it is a stupidity to ask question..? Stupids are those who do not mature to give valid or dare answers to the questions asked and blindly says.. Stupidity..... Hinduism is the only religion against which anyone can give bad comments or narratives or critics.. since they know nothing will happen.. but surely not with particular religion... Pranav knows the consequences clearly if he expose or make critics about particular religion.. you may call my comments also a stupidity by proving you are stu...d.. All religions having blind beliefs.. but some Stupids are interested only with Hinduism beliefs.. Never minds.. inspite of million stupid's comments and critics.. Hinduism survived more than 10 thousand years.. and still...

[@dobbysurfs]

​@@Chalshanaban007India is Hindu majority country,so ofc he will debunk stupid beliefs from there first. Same goes for any other KZbinr from other countries.And also Pranav was a ex-hindu ,so he has some experience about the customs first hand and hence ,more comfortable about talking it

[@subhendugiri5018]

Perhaps people are misunderstanding Oppenheimer's opinion here. What I understand is that Oppenheimer is expecting to be excused for his role(or justifying his role) for atomic bomb like the way diplomat Krishna has advised Arjun why he must take weapon on his hand to fight against his brothers.

[@pythonsnake9076]

Please make video on Quran saying about big bang , black hole , relativity theory etc .My friends are so indulge that they think science is nothing but Quran .So please make a video on that so that they can be rationalized .Thank you.

[@soul2197]

@scienceisdope you made a video with Narendra Nayak about reservation. Why did you delete it ? Can we expect it back

[@parzivalwade5664]

Ricebag😂.

[@Truth_Jc007]

Oppenheimer was nerdy guy , he used to read lots of philosophical books along with science. So its nothing special that he read Gita & got knowledge from it to make atom bomb. He quoted that statement as a metaphor

[@mitchjames9350]

He did go out of his way to learn Sanskrit and recited the Gita multiple times.

[@NabiKaCartoonBanao]

Iode, he didn't read rep maker book Qu'raan.😂

[@Namish-yv9mz]

Lord Krishna was not teaching Arjun on the battleground how to make an atom bomb. lol. Oppenheimer read the Geeta and at that time when he saw the atom bomb explode in front of his eyes he remembered the shloka from the Bhagwad Geeta when Lord Krishna appeared as Bhagwan Parambrhma AdiNarayan MahaVishnu in front of Arjun. His aura was equivalent to the combined light of a thousand suns as described in the Geeta itself. That particular shlok came to his mind when he witnessed the bomb explode in front of his eyes

[@Truth_Jc007]

​@@mitchjames9350source : trust me bro

[@Truth_Jc007]

​​@@NabiKaCartoonBanao I'm not Muslim. I'm an atheist you dumb. Your comment clearly shows how dumb a$$ u are...just blindly hating other in name of religion 😂

[@vijayshukla109]

They are quoting hindu religion. That makes us proud. That can quote other religion too if they find any accidental truth there.

[@anuragkumar5472]

why is this guy so obsessed with sadhguru you are making video on debunking hindu religion that you are uable to but again and again remebering your daddy Sadhguru

[@AdityaSingh-us7eu]

drawing parallels is different from claiming evidence. maybe those scientists found Hinduism to be of good philosophical value.

[@godson200]

Yes they found philosophical value I think. But brain dead sanatani is awake hindu channel are making videos claiming Hinduism scriptures have everything and also recipe for atomic bomb, lost in translation. Because nobody fricking knows sanskrit

[@anantverma3428]

I'll pin it in my clipboard to throw at any blind believer's face whenever they mention things like these🤣

[@sorenutpal6091]

Religious Tunnis-Science is false our Religion is the greatest and correct Also Religious Tunnis-Our Religion has made these discoveries science has proved this

[@markjitu]

I love jaggis cameo in science in dope video

[@jaysnehpandey7089]

Loved the mention of the expanse, goated show

[@binujoseph8094]

You’re doing “God’s” work dude. Keep it up 😂

[@praveenmallar]

Nice video. Carl Sagan quotes almost all religions and civilisations in his books.

[@ApoorvSaurabh]

Philosophy many a times leads or shows the way for science, critical thinking and theoretical hypothesis. Hindu Philosophy is one such thing. That’s it.

[@chiranantansharmamondal9870]

Waiting for the video ❤️

[@romibengali]

That's why I always say keep science and religion (dharm) separate because they ARE separate! (Say whatever you will satguru is a dongi) Plus these people (Hindu nationalists) will get so butthurt if you ever talk about becoming atheist

[@godson200]

Bro i hate one thing. Please spread my word to all religious people. Hindus are tolerant right? In bhagwat geeta also it is written about free thinking and all na? We should think on our own this is kind of covered in vedas and all stuff. But why is atheism considered a fault? According to Hindu scriptures, atheism is accepted. Even if you go to punjab, in langar everyone is given food to eat, doesn't matter if he is atheist or theist. Why don't Hindus learn something from them sometimes? Hinduism accepts atheism is my point. But people have forgot that because they haven't even read their own books. They are just misled by propaganda online.

[@purptube678]

​@@godson200people put their religion as a mask to seem superior morally but what they do at all times is putting other people down, now this is not against most people but definitely a case with extremists

[@adyasingh2459]

​@@godson200Nobody asks your religion at a hindu bhandara either. Looks like you've never attended one lol

[@godson200]

@@adyasingh2459 I know. But people are changing nowadays. They have forgot their true roots.

[@adyasingh2459]

@@godson200 nope! Go to any Hindu bhandar, no matter how small or big, they'll never ask your religion

[@AKTUImportantquestions]

Verse 11.32 of the Gita says: kālo’asmi, lokakśayakṛt pravṛddhaḥ lokān samāhartum iha pravṛttaḥ. The conventional translation of “kālaḥ” is “time”, and via this interpretation, here is the literal prose translation: “I am time, the cause of world-destruction, mighty; come here to annihilate the worlds.” Oppenheimer had read and studied the translation of Gita by Arthur W Ryder, in which we find: Death, am I, and my present task Destruction.

[@AnalystSarvesh]

I am sorry, but all I could see was feynman 1 and 3 absent...😒