Disney's Dinosaur (2000) Accuracy Review

Dinosaur came out 24 years ago and has maintained a following since then with its memorable CGI depictions of dinosaurs new and old. How well does this animation hold up scientifically 24 years later? #paleontology #dinosaurs #dinosaur
Facebook: / redraptorwrites
Patreon: www.patreon.com/redraptorwrit...
Instagram: / redraptorwrites
Twitter: RedRaptorWrites?t...
Movie Review: • Looking Back at Disney...
Sources
Carno Arms: web.archive.org/web/201709220...
Carno Scales: blog.everythingdinosaur.com/b...
Lemur Origins: today.duke.edu/2018/08/fossil...
Nostril Position: web.archive.org/web/201309060...
YDAW Iguanodon: • Iguanodon: Your Dinosa...
YDAW Carnotaurus: • Carnotaurus: Your Dino...

[@redraptorwrites6778]

Oops I confused Microceratus with Leptoceratops. Oh well. Hope you enjoy guys. Sorry for the delay. Those Disney copyright bots are working overtime trying to claim anything they can. Bro, just make a good Marvel movie. Stop trying to steal my money.

[@angelinetchouawa1399]

Oh😅.

[@johntodd3910]

That’s okay Can you rant the ice age movies and accuracies of those movies

[@ducestat06savage99]

If you look at the deleted scenes and concept art it tells you alot of what they wanted to go with but disney of corse ruined we were supposed to see them go threw jungles to mountains to finally hit the desert predators from deinosuces( or Sarcosuchus) to t rex allosaurus spinosaurus and even mosa raptors were originally supposed to be feathered but at the time was to hard to animate

[@ducestat06savage99]

And carnotarus was going to be accurate size but dangerously agile and even scarier pick you off at your weakest they would have been following the herd constantly and killed off aladars grandparents and bruton who was originally his brother

[@davidspencer8373]

Like video

[@yissibiiyte]

The designs may not be accurate, but the CGI was incredible. Still better than many modern movies

[@Mong00ze-Muzik]

It's actually amazing how well its held up. It does have its moments but it still makes me feel the same awe it did when I was 5 years old

[@rockettbennett]

Um no? I like the movie because of its incredible score, great voice acting and the real life backgrounds but the cgi is literally the worst part. I don’t think the movie is bad or anything but Jurassic Park came out almost a decade earlier and it looks miles better. (But I can offer the excuse that Jurassic Park only used its cgi a little bit while Dinosaur used it for the whole movie)

[@Dracovenatrix]

The iguanadons look hideous

[@rockettbennett]

@@Dracovenatrix You are very brave. I have learned from experience that Disney Dinosaur fans will often get angry whenever someone doesn’t like their movie. But of course plenty simply just state their own opinion and offer constructive criticism of yours without getting angry or frustrated in any way like everyone should. You shouldn’t whine like a baby and call another reviewer’s opinion bulls**t because you don’t agree with it.

[@Dracovenatrix]

@@rockettbennetti literally just said the iguanodons look hideous. Do you know what whining is? Do you know what anger is? I merely just commented how horrid the iguanodons look and i don’t think i have to explain why

[@chadgorosaurus4898]

This movie was goated. Love how they chose the Carnotaurus to be the villain instead of being generic and choosing a Tyrannosaurus.

[@coolbilly3605]

Or even spino

[@calebbusing6171]

They originally were going to use Tyrannosaurus but they decided to use something that was not as famous or well known as Tyrannosaurus

[@coolbilly3605]

@@calebbusing6171 perfect, as much as I love the T. rex, I want other dinosaurs to shine as well.

[@mikewazowski8368]

@@calebbusing6171 Explains why the size was as large as it was, they'd probably already modelled the T-Rex and just made a few alterations.

[@calebbusing6171]

I feel the same

[@clobertina8176]

7:29 As a kid I always assumed by her "being the last of her kind" meaning that the asteroid from the beginning of the movie is what wiped out most of her species due to them being so large and slow lol

[@ExtremeMadnessX]

That should be obvious?

[@alexfraser8352]

Yeah I thought that was obvious. Raptor is overthinking it lol

[@calebbusing6171]

Most likely

[@sobekapep8320]

Baylene is supposed to be the last of her kind because of the "Fire Ball." I suppose the sauropods were just too big and slow to evade the falling debris and take shelter in time, Baylene was just lucky.

[@wolfsavage7647]

I heard they try to add feather on the velociraptors in the movie, but it was hard to animated so that’s why the velociraptors don’t have feather and it’s been a lot of stuff that they cut out in the movie

[@alielsakkout7415]

hard to animate but above all super expensive and therefore not profitable

[@Genubath1]

Dinosaur was the very first 3d animated movie by Walt Disney Feature Animation (Pixar had already done a few by then). The technology to animate hair and other stuff like that was cutting edge and very expensive at the time. It would take months to compute the final render of a movie at the time. Pixar created a tool called Fizt for Monsters Inc to automate the animation of hair instead of having to arrange every single hair. They still use it today for hair and cloth animation.

[@adamthespinygiant]

Dinosaur is the most under appreciated Disney movie.

[@apathy2454]

True as a matter of fact i see a lot of people hating on it

[@chubibi06]

@@apathy2454 no song, no disney prince/princess (well, aside for furries and scallies) and no magical BS Of course they hate it, it's DIFFERENT !

[@keizervanenerc5180]

I still can't believe Shaffrillas ranked it as the worst disney movie ever.....

[@adamthespinygiant]

@@keizervanenerc5180 something tells me he has no appreciation for extinct animals. To me, Chicken Little is the real worst Disney movie.

[@wingedhussar1453]

It sucks tho .it could have ben a fun Disney movie instead it turned into a depressing boring one .the fiest 10 minutes in the jungle intro was amazing and then it turns into 2 hours of bore

[@revol2933]

In defense of Kron's & Bruton's unique physical features: there're are animal species in which males have certain characteristics that can be either developed or not. The best example are orangutans with their big, meaty cheeks. When males mature they can "choose" to grow these cheeks to show that they're dominant males - or not grow them, and then they look pretty much like females. Maybe here it's a similar thing - since Kron and Bruton are dominant males with high levels of testosterone, it might be the reason why they developed nose crests, larger frame, humps and back spikes - while Aladar lived his entire life with lemurs, so he never had the need to develop these features of a dominant male (no interspecies combat, no need to fight for females etc). That's just how I see it. (Ps. Sorry for grammar. English is not my first language - but paleontology is my first love. Haha)

[@calebbusing6171]

That’s a good theory

[@katyungodly]

Your English typing is better than most native speakers' typing, good job

[@Wandervenn]

This was my theory as well

[@Cryptic-Cryo]

Some notes about some of the dinosaur designs. Earl the anky is actually a Euplocepholus, as confirmed by the lead dinosaur designer in the special features. That said, he still doesn’t look like one that much. The mini ceratopsians are called microcerotops in tie in books and the special features. If you’re a nerd of palaeontology, know it’s now call microceratus. This goes the same to the pteranodon where this particular species is now called Geosternbergia. Of course, that’s still debated if it should be a unique genus. While not scientifically plausible, it’s possible Kron and Brutons nasal designs are based on the first depictions of iguanodon.

[@chubibi06]

"younger depiction are too frail and hornless ! They'll never make it" Bruton, to Kron

[@mitchellulrich930]

Url wasn't the only ankylosaur in the film. There were 2 Talarurus in the beginning as the egg was passing by.

[@oshkeet]

Thinking about it this makes a lot more sense. Its like you if took the Crystal Palace depiction directly and tried to "modernize it" to be more dinosaur-like without actually knowing what Iguanodon should look like.

[@eduardusk5808]

​@chubibi06 I like this, is a more meta interpretation. Kron and Bruton have older designs that would be easier to intimidate other iguanodons and make them leaders.

[@NolanDraconis]

The two Carnotaurus’ are male and female, with the bigger surviving one (till the end) being named Brutus in the script, he also appears at the beginning of the story.

[@Greenthero]

Oh really? This actually answers the question I’ve had for years on why they looked different. Also does the female have a name?

[@NolanDraconis]

@@Greenthero unfortunately no

[@blueguy2128]

​@@Greentherowhy wouldn't two Individuals of the same species look different? Literally every single individual living thing even the ones with no distinct differences like humans are unique.

[@Greenthero]

@@blueguy2128 wait I thought it was only specific species that had individual variation, like humans or tigers?

[@blueguy2128]

@@Greenthero I'll use Komodo Dragons and Crocodiles as examples. They all "look the same" right? Having minimal sexual dimorphism between the two sexes and all sharing distinct crocodile or komodo dragon characteristics. But no individual croc or dragon is an exact copy of the other. They still have individuals with their own personality preferences and variations in physical size and features.

[@tyrannotherium7873]

The filmmakers did mention that brachiosaurids were around during the Cretaceous for a little while such a sauroposeidon since it is in the family, that’s why they were doing a reference at the time

[@chubibi06]

Baylene is what, 50 million year old ? Still looking great for her age

[@toonrex2806]

My theory is that Url the Ankylosaur is disabled.

[@9656311]

They did have ridiculously small brains, so that might be why he is basically a dog compared to others

[@AnimeRyker2001]

As for Baylene, I think there was a strange thing going on in the 1990's and early 2000's where its believed that Brachiosaurus (or a creature that was similar to brachiosaurus) lived for a few million years into the Creataceous, but not very long. As for the extinction of Baylenes species, most likely Baylene hasnt found any other Brachiosaurs, so without any way to find out its probably likely she believes she is truely the last of her kind. Another possibility is that the Carnotaurs have practically hunted them down. Baylene seems very afraid of the Carnotaurs, specifically pairs as she points out in the movie how 2 Carnotaurs would be significantly worse than 1, which, while true, she freaks out the most after saying it. This wouldnt make much sense, even with the oversized carnos, but it must be the case, why else would Baylene (while old, shes still huge and strong as we see in the cave scene) be afraid of creatures that much less than half her size. Most Likely Carnotaurs around the continent eventually became more confident, or found a near foolproof strategy to bring down Brachiosaurs.

[@sizzybubbles]

I have the old special edition multi-disc dvd with all the bonus features as well as the large making-of book… it has A LOT of insight on the designs. I know the iguanadon character designs were made so you could tell them apart easily. The trick if they were all shadowed, you could still tell who’s who. In the art book Zondag says: “We’d add a little bit of a bump on the nose or change the shape of the beak a little. We’d find what we could an exaggerate it.” It specifies that Kron’s was meant to look intimidating with this thick neck and big chin… Bruton was also very robust and rhino-like. So in the end… just character design :D

[@calebbusing6171]

Interesting

[@GreebleClown]

15:04 It could be that the size and additional adornments are like what happens with silverbacks and orangoutangs and many other primates where only the dominant males grow bigger and have display features while the males who haven’t bred/haven’t won leadership do not develop the dominant features until they can win a fight and breeding rights. You kinda also see it with anoles and iguanas, though I’m not sure to what extent it is age vs dominance in those species.

[@ExtremeMadnessX]

That's how I see it as well.

[@rileyohrt7256]

Once again, you got Url wrong. Dinosaurs character designer David Krentz confirmed Url is a Euoplocephalus

[@captainstroon1555]

I just realized the lemurs were included as implied human ancestors. They chose lemurs despite the temporal displacement to make that connection more visible. That, or they just needed the mammalian sidekicks to be able to climb on Aladar's back

[@SmashBrosAssemble]

My stance is, when something is made for entertainment, I don’t care about palae-accuracy, when I watch things like Disney’s Dinosaur, Jurassic Park, King Kong, Primeval, Dinosaur King etc all I want are cool visually appealing distinct designs with verisimilitude. I’ll criticise a bad design for being either ugly, messy, not really resembling the animal it’s meant to be etc but accuracy isn’t a factor, if I want that, I’ll watch a documentary.

[@Random_Nobody_Official]

_"Innacurate does not mean bad,_ _this video was made purely for entertainment_ _and was highly requested by_ _the amazing people from this community"_ - The Mythology Guy Completely different context, but I think it perfectly applies here!

[@insectilluminatigetshrekt5574]

I mean, there should be a baseline minimum accuracy so you can at least tell what the animal is supposed to be

[@SmashBrosAssemble]

@@insectilluminatigetshrekt5574 Yeah, you gotta get the general look of the animal down, that’s required, but you don’t need to be 100% accurate, just make a cool looking design.

[@insectilluminatigetshrekt5574]

@SmashBrosAssemble it depends on what kind of movie/show it is. I think there are some fictional plots that would require accurate dinosaurs. Like if it's supposed to be a realistic fiction kind of thing of what would dinosaurs in captivity actually be like. By the way, almost all dinosaur movies up to and including the first jurassic park tried making their dinosaurs as accurate as they could for the time.

[@Random_Nobody_Official]

@@insectilluminatigetshrekt5574 *_H O W T H O U G H ? ? ? ! ! !_* What the heck are those "velociraptors" ?

[@KingSpades]

One thing i did notice about the Carnos is that the smaller one not only was smaller, it was also faster and FAR more reckless and aggressive. Im guessing it was a father/child situation where the "fireball" drove them out of their home and they stuck together to survive, then they found the scent of the herd and followed it for food and the rest is history.

[@calebbusing6171]

Probably

[@NoobsofFredo]

Another theory that I've heard is that they were a mated pair, though I agree that the 'fireball' drove them out of their typical range and were following the herd in search of their next meal.

[@cristhianmlr]

I remember from a tie-in magazine from Dinosaur that Bruton and Kron where based on Muttaburrasaurus since they were believed to be Iguanodontids back when the movie was in development, they also called Ur Euoplocephalus.

[@AnimeRyker2001]

Also as a minor point, Bruton and Kron are not Iguanodon, they are Altirhinus. I know the question is "well if thats the case how is he Neera's Brother". Well that leads to one of two things. Either they are trying to say that Iguanodon and Altirhinus are so close that they can interbreed (probably not), or Kron was adopted, I doubt Neera was adopted since Iguanodon seem to be so much more populous than Altirhinus, who might be going extinct due to competition with their close cousins.

[@nateperez7768]

Actually, leptoceratops was not in the movie. The small ceraptopsians are Microceratus( known at the time as Microceratops) Also, the velociraptors were indeed originally planned to be feathered but the feathers got left out

[@LucasCaminha]

So apparently, the whole "cretaceous brachiosaur" conundrum was a common misconception from the late 90s to the early 2000s, as some sauropod fossils from early cretaceous Tunisia were once assigned specifically to Brachiosaurus, and as such a lot of dinosaur books from that time mentioned its temporal range as going from the jurassic to the cretaceous. Needless to say, those fossils are no longer believed to belong to Brachiosaurus, and I'm pretty sure they're currently nameless, though I don't remember if it's classified as a brachiosaurid still or if that changed. Weirdly, Iguanodon and Hypsilophodon were also often mentioned to range from the jurassic to the cretaceous back then, likely due to wastebin taxonomy.

[@calebbusing6171]

The scene when the meteors destroyed the island and killed most of the lemurs is one of the saddest scenes in a Disney movie

[@jacobcuevas5609]

I always thought the reason Burton and Kron had a horn like thing on their nose was a reference to paleontologist thinking iguanadons thumb spike was a nasal horn

[@DinoMike2986]

Actually if you look really closely at the pteranodon wean it drops the egg and the babies in the nest they do have some fluff something I just now noticed

[@stevenelbert8989]

Yeah and if you look closely the adult does have pycnofibors you just have to pause and look

[@calebbusing6171]

I have noticed that

[@kevinnorwood8782]

As iconic as this film's version of Carnotaurus is, they really focused on making him seem like a powerhouse-type predator like T-Rex, when in reality it was a speed demon-style predator (a Cretaceous cheetah, as it has often been described). So in that respect, the Terra Nova Carnotaurus is actually MUCH closer to the real Carnotaurus, except its arms are WAY too big. If you took the Terra Nova Carnotaurus, and gave it the arms of the Disney Carnotaurus, you'd probably have a design that's nearly exactly up to modern scientific standards.

[@chubibi06]

I have Disney's Dinosaur to thanks for my now unconditional love for Pachyrhinosaurus. Loved the model, loved mattel's mini figure i got in an egg back then. True masterpiece of a Dinosaur, change my mind !

[@tm43977]

Alright The Disney Dinosaur Accuracy Portait

[@dont-hurt-me2519]

Here's a list of animals I'd choose if I were to make a more "scientifically accurate" update of Disney's Dinosaur. The time for my setting is ~68 MYA; due to this, many animals from ~2 million years prior or later appear in this update. ~2 million years isn't that big of a stretch, so it's possible there could've been some overlap; with some creatures starting to become extinct & others just starting to appear. The setting of my update is Laramidia (the Western Half of North America - no specific subsection). Due to the natural disaster (either a smaller asteroid impact event or a volcanic eruption), species from both the Northern & Souther sections of Laramidia are present here. The natural disaster caused many species to become displaced & they're now able to meet/interact with each other: Kritosaurus navajouvius - Replacement for the Iguanodon. Struthiomimus sedens - Same as the original but now with feathers. Avisaurus archibaldi - Replacement fro the Ichthyornis. Hypacrosaurus altispinus - Replacement for the Parasaurolophus. Pachyrhinosaurus canadensis - Same genus as the original but a different species for the update. Alamosaurus sanjuanensis - Replacement for the Brachiosaurus. Palaeosaniwa canadensis - Replacement for the Longisquama. Albertosaurus sarcophagus - Replacement for the Carnotaurus. I didn't want to go with either Tyrannosaurus or Nanuqsaurus, Tyrannosaurus is overused & Nanuqsaurus is too far North, so I decided to go with a this tyrannosaur for the update. Albertosaurus is, in some ways, the tyrannosaur equivalent of a Carnotaurus. I was considering a trio (instead of a duo) pack of Albertosaurus, with one being an exceptionally large individual (hip height of ~3.5 meters & length of ~10 meters) & the other two being average size (hip height of ~3 meters & length of ~9 meters). Leptorhynchos gaddisi - Replacement for the Oviraptor. Champsosaurus annectens - Replacement for the Koolasuchus. Glyptodontopelta mimus - Replacement for the Talarurus. Tethydraco regalis - Replacement for the Geosternbergia. While its' fossils have been found in North Africa, it could've had a larger distribution due to it possibly being analogous to Sea Birds. Mosasaurus hoffmanni - A creature that had a fully rendered model but was cut from the final; so I decided to include it in the update. Being an marine animal, it likely could've had a global distribution. Purgatorius sp. - Replacement for the Lemurs. Dineobellator notoheseprus - Replacement for the Velociraptors. Regaliceratops peterhewsi - Replacement for the Styracosaurus. Leptoceratops gracilis - Replacement for the Microceratus. Anodontosaurus lambei - Replacement for the Ankylosaurus/Euoplocephalus. Sphaerotholus buchholtzae, edmontonensis or triregnum - Replacement for the Stygimoloch. I couldn't decide on which species, seeing as all three fit the temporal & geographical setting of the update, so any of the three could work.

[@joshuaW5621]

Welcome back Tim. I forgot this accuracy review series was even a thing for a while.

[@thehuntersguide]

Perhaps the carno was suffering from gigantism?

[@calebbusing6171]

Maybe

[@pedrord19]

I love the fact that some of the scenes were shoot in real locations. Geostenbergia is actually feathered/fuzzy and I love the model and colors. Still, my personal favorite ones are Velociraptor, Struthiomimmus and Oviraptor. They are so funny and unique. An awesome review of a trully spectacular movie !!!

[@christianbontempo8859]

7:04 Two of my favorite dinosaur related pieces of media combined into one. You sir are a man of quality. This makes me want to see what how you’d do an accuracy review on the Dinosaur episode of Zoboomafo would be like. The dinosaurs in that episode being Brontosaurus, Tyrannosaurus, Ankylosaurus, Triceratops, Stegosaurus and Edmontosaurus (called a Duckbill, but the model is very obviously based on Edmontosaurus.) Also at 5:40 the small ceratopsian seen in the herd is actually Microceratus (known as Microceratops at the time the film came out.)

[@jeremybickham2842]

I think the Brachiosaurus featured in the movie might be a reference to a time when these long necked Dinosaurs were thought to have lived right into the Early Cretaceous.

[@ExtremeMadnessX]

Sauropods lived during Cretaceous, just not Brachiosaurus and related species.

[@aladar488]

I always found it interesting how kron and aladar fought. And the use of the thump spike

[@Left_Shoulder]

Been watching your videos for the past few months now keep up the good work

[@CJTheTokay]

The Disney carno is actually 7m tall and the iguanodons are 5m tall everything in the movie is oversized

[@mattrodriguez476]

The CGI STILL SURPASSES JURASSIC WORLD. THIS MOVIE IS TOP TIER AND FOR THEM NOT TO HAVE MADE A SEQUEL IS ILLEGAL

[@Greenthero]

With Disney’s track record of stuff like Wish and She-Hulk, do you really want to risk this amazing movie for a possible failure of a sequel?

[@mattrodriguez476]

@@Greenthero no

[@Spiritprime91]

Reckon the duo carnotaurus were supposed to be a mated pair, or a parent with a child. The large one that survived the cave in (from what I remember reading in the junior novel of the movie) had gone on a revenge rampage. It basically snapped and made a suicidal charge at the herd when normally a more cautious carnivore would not really attack a huge herd of herbivores at all.

[@calebbusing6171]

Both theories are possible

[@galamran2251]

I have waited for this one for so long

[@mcjohngd3583]

Just in time, yesterday I reminded myself of this movie, and today red raptor posts it, heck yeah

[@wilberator9608]

Oh my god I had this on video as a child and I had completely forgotten about it for more than 15 years until now

[@BohrokKiller]

I remember when I was a kid, I thought Kron and Bruton was supposed to be Muttaburrasaurus.

[@alphakraut]

Finally! I waited way to long for this

[@oliverking7227]

You should have a look at the Minecraft mod “prehistoric nature” it has over 800 prehistoric animals from the pre-cambrian all the way to the Jurassic at the moment the Jurassic is still being worked on so yea but they are going until the present day the creatures are as accurate as they can be within the restrictions of Minecraft and they will update animals and there models if new research comes out on them with noticeable differences

[@VanessaScrillions]

This video is truly fantastic. I thoroughly enjoyed watching! Thank you!!!

[@shainewhite2781]

Paul Verhoeven, director of ROBOCOP and Total Recall, was goung to direct the movie using stop motion animation by Oscar Winning VFX artist Phil Tippet, who did VFX for Jurassic Park. The story was going to involve a Styracosaurus named Root protecting his family from a Tyrannosaurus named Gronzi harassing them for far too long. Root tracks down and kills Gronzi, and Root reunites with his family, until the 6 mile wide asteroid slams into the Earth, wiping out the dinosaurs. The film would show that lemurs survived and that it wasn't the end, but the beginning of the human race.

[@araucanoraptorargentinus3973]

Woot, not Root. Also, other dinosaurs that were supposed to be in the film included Iguanodon (ironic, isn't it), Pachycephalosaurus, Thescelosaurus, Parksosaurus, Rhamphorhnychus, Dorygnathus, and Pteranodon.

[@masonfriel9882]

I always loved this movie. Scared me so much when I was a kid

[@calebbusing6171]

One of my coworkers said that she watched it for the first time when she was a little kid and the Carnotaurus gave her nightmares

[@LilRick96]

22:46 😂😂😂 What did he saaaaayyyyyy???

[@keizervanenerc5180]

I always, even as a kid, thought Kron and Bruton were supposed to be "Austrialian Iguanodons" = Muttaburrasaurus like seen in the 5th episode of Walking with Dinosaurs. I thought so because their noses look somewhat simular.

[@calebbusing6171]

They do look similar

[@theangrysuchomimus5163]

15:04 Some social animals have dominant males which are bigger and have more exaggerated features than their subordinates. I'm not an expert on this topic, but from what I can remember, the lower ranking males' features are inhibited by the presence of the dominant males. So it could explain why the other Iguanodonts are smaller than Crone and Bruton, both of which are at the top of the social hierarchy. However, this doesn't take into account why Aladar doesn't grow such features after he becomes the leader. I'll excuse it as the producers not wanting to confuse the audience, which wouldn't understand the change.

[@mannyfernandez1713]

I once heard the bruton was suposed to be a mutaburrasaurus, not an iguanodon, but atill

[@Lycan3303]

memba going to my cousin's house to watch this on VHS

[@creakingskull7008]

The baby Pteranodon/Geosternergia have fuzz, this blew my mind when i noticed it in my last rewatch

[@sosa2mars]

I always thought the big boss on Bruton and Kron’s noses were meant to be sort of references to the much earlier description of Iguanodon where the thumb spike was thought to be a horn on its nose.

[@theterribleclaw4285]

I hate it when people compare these Dinosaurs to how people see them today they should compare these Dinosaurs to what they looked like at the time.

[@Spiny_21]

Never thought I’d see this but I really enjoyed it

[@mariedufore8795]

You inspired me to watch it and I love it

[@calebbusing6171]

The Carnotaurus in Jurassic World seems to be the size that the real life Carnotaurus was

[@BugattiONE666]

Im sorry but the way the creatures move, for example the Carnotaurus charging at the hard....the mas, the weight, the tail curling to the right as it drags the prey over....brilliantr

[@WOLFY_THUNDER-vh7hl]

australia wrights a big "DO NOT COME HER, WE DON'T WANT YOU" with it's animals

[@Greenthero]

Idc if this movie isn’t exactly completely accurate, this is still my favorite movie

[@patricklee5239]

16:11 At the time the film was being produced, Altirhiuns was still considered part of the now dubious species Iguanodon orientalis. So, it's possible that they used the big nosed "Iguanodon" design and then applied some "Hollywood magic" to make them look more intimidating. Funnily enough, by the time the film came out, Altirhinus had been assigned to it's own genus.

[@brodenwood895]

8:49 did you call strutiomimus a maniraptoran? Btw I love your videos and I'm glad you're back!

[@tyrannotherium7873]

I heard that it’s actually implied that Bruton and kron are based on muttaburrasaurus

[@drewmccoy756]

The velociraptor design makes me so happy given there realistic proportions of there body’s and its the highlight for me seeing as it’s not common to see in media anyway only issue which is not that big of a issue seeing as the feathers and it’s ok for me because it was hotly debated at the time & not excepted at the time.

[@wroggisaurusmarshalli2440]

Wasn't URL based on Euoplocephalus tutus? The making of team on the special feature turnboard Says this

[@DarkTitan1954]

Will you ever review the first land before time

[@blueguy2128]

Seeing 23:07 when i was a little kid always unnerved me. Just getting eaten is scary, especially when you're ripped apart. Watching Brutus devour flesh makes my stomach turn upside down

[@hopegallows1392]

I had the Carnotaurus happy meal toy as a kid, it was a rubber hand puppet and that thing terrified me.

[@mcfreker1487]

it would be cool if you reviewd animal armaggedon next is a 8 part series covering diferent mass extincions from the past some of wich havent been covered by any other docu series you reviewd in your tier list sry bad english

[@calebbusing6171]

I had noticed that there were different types of dinosaurs in this movie from several different parts of the world that would have never met each other. Carnotaurus lived in South America and Oviraptor and Velociraptor lived in Asia. The others lived in North America

[@AdamWingard_Official]

Make a heisei Godzilla accuracy review as he was originally a dinosaur

[@shardgunner4815]

That family feud clip took me out 😂

[@calebbusing6171]

The main character originally was to be a Styracosaurus. He may have ended up being an Iguanodon but there still are some Styracosaurus in the movie

[@lindavanwyk8268]

I remember having the DVD of it but the backside of the DVD called the Iguanodon, Edmontosaurus instead

[@Oaglor]

Nothing about Iguanodon running on all fours? Or is facultative bipedal running more of a hadrosaur thing due to the different body shapes?

[@thylascene]

heya! :), could you do an accuracy review on "triceratops: the final battle" someday? it's a short film by ABC terra, it talks about the last day of the cretaceous period, and would be nice to see you cover the in/accuracies of it on the channel when you can

[@tyrannotherium7873]

I hope they do a sequel, prequel, or a medical, or matter of fact, a series of this movie I’m actually shocked you’re not a fan of the movie because a lot of fans love it but the only problem I have with it is that the pacing was very fast, but it is what it is but other than that it’s still one of the best movies ever and it’s hard to say, which is my second favorite dinosaur movie either Disney dinosaur or the land before Time because they both have very good stories and yeah, even though it’s not accurate, you can still enjoy the story and story is the most important thing

[@0iqgremlin414]

With Kron and Bruton's designs, my only personal interpretation (which might be accidental) is that they represent how we used to see dinosaurs, big and aggressive with a 'you are on your own' mentality. They also had a bump on their noses like how Iguanodon used to be portrayed with before it was found out to be a thumb spike. Meanwhile Neera and Aladar are representing the newer ways to see dinosaurs, caring, herd/pack animals that watch out for the weaker members, more like animals than monsters

[@GLeviathan]

I find the misconception of old paleoart depictions dragging their tails funny. Many famous pieces from the time simply depicted them in a resting position.

[@chester896]

I LOVED this movie when I was a kid. It was always in the VCR at my grandma’s house lol

[@JohnM-cd4ou]

Misspelled my name guy

[@pursuedsubset5915]

For bruton and krohn the artbook says the idea for them was a mix of modern(at the time) and old images of iguanadon, the bone crest on the nose is the giveaway for krohn since old iguanadon had the thumb as a nose spike and bruton is a giant thats pretty evened out not arched like the old paleoart. So yeah they just used old art😅

[@calebbusing6171]

The filmmakers originally planned to use Tyrannosaurus as the main antagonist but they changed their minds because they decided that since Tyrannosaurus always seemed to be used as the main antagonist in dinosaur movies, they would use something else. They decided to use a carnivorous dinosaur that wasn’t as famous and well known as Tyrannosaurus and had never been in a movie before. They chose Carnotaurus since it wasn’t well known and familiar at the time and hadn’t been in a movie before

[@JurassicReptile]

I’m a little confused on why the UK animal isn’t Iguanodon. Wasn’t it first found there?

[@redraptorwrites6778]

Good question! The UK animal is no longer considered Iguanodon because the type species of which the genus is based on was changed from UK material to more complete finds from Belgium. That made the Belgian Iguanodontian species the basis for Iguanodon. But over the past 20ish years, many dinosaurs formerly lumped into that name have been split into their own distinct genera. This includes the UK stuff that used to be called Iguanodon. Because it's different enough from the Belgian species, that material is now called Barilium and Mantellisaurus.

[@guillaumebabey4484]

For me the main issue with the Struthiomimus is that the skull seems to be closer in shape to Gallimimus! I do wonder if that's a case of misnaming in that regard.

[@cro-magnoncarol4017]

Accurate Disney's Dinosaur cast - (Takes place in the Ojo Alamo/Javelina Formations) Herbivores - Iguanodon --> Gryposaurus alsatei Parasaurolophus --> Augustynolophus morrisi Brachiosaurus --> Alamosaurus sanjuanensis Pachyrhinosaurus --> Ojoceratops fowleri Styracosaurus --> Torosaurus utahensis Talalurus --> Glyptodontopelta mimus Ankylosaurus/Euoplocephalus --> Indeterminate Ojo Alamo Ankylosaurid Struthiomimus --> Indeterminate Ojo Alamo Ornithomimid Stygimoloch --> Sphaerotholus sp Microceratus --> Indeterminate Leptoceratopsid Carnivores - Carnotaurus --> Tyrannosaurus sp Velociraptor --> Dineobellator notohesperus Oviraptor --> Ojoraptorsaurus boerei Pteranodon --> Indeterminate Hell's Creek Pteranodontian Other - Lemur --> Indeterminate Proto-Primate Koolasuchus --> Brachychampsa sp Ichthyornis --> Avisaurus sp Edit: Url as an Euoplocephalus because that's apparently what his character designers said on the DVD.

[@cyanide7270]

Honestly, the Carno may not have been 100% accurate, but you gotta admit, much like the Velociraptors and Rex from Jurassic Park, they just look so freaking cool!

[@zilla2004]

Early on one of your videos! How cool is that?

[@gavinsiville9969]

I do have my own headcanon that the giant monstrous Carnotaurs in the movie are not actually the species Carnotaurus Sastrei but are instead a speculative much larger and more bulkier species that evolved from them to fill the niche that tyrannosaurs have

[@meatball2304]

I will stand by the fact that Stygimoloch is a valid genus for my entire life

[@AnimeRyker2001]

Actually, if you look closely the Geosternbergia does have pycnofibers on its back. I agree it needs more, but considering when this movie came out, its impressive any way included. As for feathers, originally the Velociraptors, Oviraptors, and Struthis were gonna have them, but they turned out to be wayyyy to complicated to animate at the time, which is fair. How many shows or movies back then had CGI birds that looked good

[@Elliotlorenzo-vs6pc]

it's not the only thing you confused. kron and bruton(i know I butchered their names) are altharhinus's(am I spelling it correctly?)

[@JLRules]

The best thing about this film was obviously the incredibly creative title.

[@sophiekrueger4719]

Something that I really like about the movie now looking back is the 'mobbing' behaviour on the part of the iguanodon towards the carnotaurus'. It's very much like today's cape buffalo towards lions and other predators. I think it's a neat bit of speculative behaviour.

[@Lauresaurus96]

I always think about the Dino Nerds from JP: Operation Genesis when I watch these videos lol

[@Fablevill]

This was my FAVORITE movie for many years! But, I was a dinosaur kid and also 2.

[@oshkeet]

Its says a lot about how ubiquitous it is in the modern day I almost never notice there shouldn't be grass in a dinosaur movie.