Do NOT Buy A Karambit Until You Watch This!!! Part 2

[@vyrUS79]

I love the karambit. its a cool knife. To my knowledge, the knife wasn't designed to be a self defense weapon but more of a stealth and max damage weapon. Most people, myself included have never experienced a knife fight, and those are the people who rant the most about what is effective and whats not. Not to sound like an asshole, but for the most part the primary weapon of choice for those people are their keyboards.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Yep. And that is why Part 1 got so many people flustered....because my experience doesn't fit their narrative.

[@grayblackhelm8196]

Aadil Mohammed And it wasn't a self defense weapon. This is a weapon used in what you could call "dirty boxing". Hand strikes and grappling can also be used effectively with the karambit.

[@gearrodclements7531]

Aadil Mohammed ,Im not an expert but I do have a general interest in the karambit, I was under the impression that the karambit was originally a farming tool , which silat practitioners recognized could be a formidable weapon. Clearly not perfect but under the right training and system could be very effective

[@gearrodclements7531]

Obviously I could be totally wrong but thats just what my original impression of the blade was

[@shaunsdu]

The karambit started out as a farming tool, as many martial weapons have (nunchaku or taboo-toyok, sai, Kama, etc.) and then became a tool to fight oppressors. In the case of the karambit, to help the people of Indonesia fight back against the Dutch invaders. I carry a karambit sometimes, but generally carry a straight fixed blade, and a back up straight folder for the exact reasons mentioned in the videos. Under stress and adrenaline dump the fine motor skills required to use the karambit aren't there without 1000s of hours of training. I train with the karambit, but not nearly as much as I do with a straight blade.

[@strick1473]

Forgive me if I missed this but as far as what I've seen when people talk about using a Karambit there is a very very simple way of explaining how to deploy a Karambit which I have not seen anyone talk about. 1st of all I agree with you 100% that you can not use a Karambit like a straight blade and that is a mistake I've seen more often then not. 2nd and only real point I'm trying to make is that a Karambit should only be used as an extension of your hand when striking like a boxer. If you get the "its a knife" process out of your head when using it, you're not going to use it like a knife, and the motion is more like throwing a punch while adding small angles to the strike.

[@zinknot]

I agree. Karambit is not a thrusting weapon. If you already have boxing skills a karambit may be much more effective than learning a new art.

[@carlosvillanueva1210]

Nice video sir, I personally carry a karambit as my EDC, here in the philippines. Thanks for the insights i learned a lot from this video.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Car los Villanueva Thanks my friend. Be safe!

[@jheckdeleon4244]

Car los Villanueva is it legal here in our country to carry a karambit.?

[@carlosvillanueva1210]

its not legal, but i rather carry my karambit and slash the hell of those who dare to harm me. its your choice ive experience almost getting stab so i would never take chances.

[@zerodyne5333]

Yeah... the area I used to live in was pretty much lawless (squatter area). Cops are corrupt anyway so it's not like they're there to help you out even if you were to follow the law. Nobody but the kids really worried about following the law in that area I lived in... hell the only time I saw cops was when they had assault rifles and came in to get someone.

[@jusette8692]

nice video can you do one which fighting style is better kali or silat plz

[@j_valentin13]

"That's just not how shit works!" You sir are correct. 😂

[@suckmypipes1342]

3:15 your left thumb is clearly at your right hand wrist lol... That reach hypnosis is completely false lol... On with the show.

[@harrymerridan6435]

Ikr

[@bryantherocker]

LOL, lots of stupid people on youtube, look at his body, where is the camera shooting, stupid people will think they don't align, in fact, his thumbs align. The camera just have a diffent perspective at where its positioned

[@Fardawg]

@@bryantherocker You could use a long karambit against a shorter straight blade and claim karambits are always longer. It is an astoundingly idiotic claim that curved blades are always shorter. Karambits come in many sizes just as straight blades do. I am dumbfounded by how many people have bought this BS (I assume it is because they vaguely remember being told in school that a straight line is the shortest distance between two points compared to a curved line, but I don't know of anyone who walks or rides on knife blades...) And he clearly doesn't know enough about that trainer he is using to understand that it is based on a design meant for multiple deploy options, including a moveable clip (or you can use two clips if you want so you can change on the fly). You can absolutely use it in a forward grip and use the wave feature to open the blade on the pocket the same as in reverse, you just pull it backwards rather than forward.

[@jamesc2545]

Great videos; for many of these folks here is my take. One; almost no one will ever get into a situation where they will need a blade. Two, most will crumble under the pressure, you see this in battle, in the dojo, in the gym. Some guys have great technique but when it comes time to perform and/or their ass is on the line they cant handle the pressure. Three, if you do find yourself in a situation where you need it and you can perform under high stress and the other person doesnt have a gun, then I dont think it matters rather you have a karabit or a straight edge blade... which I think is the point he is trying to make, you just need to train with what you have and will use.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

James C. B I N G O!!! Training is the key.

[@hugostiglitz9864]

I carry a knife all the time and I have martial training. Under stress, the stabbing or thrusting movement would be the easiest way of doing serious damage to internal organs in my opinion. I guess the exception would be if you train in a martial art that emphasizes the karambit.

[@4thLevelConciousness]

100% agree. for an edc carry for self defense you must consider your ability to use that weapon. it looks pretty to use fancy techniques but knife fights are down and dirty ugly fighting. for the minimally trained you want to use simple, natural movements. if you want to use more advanced weapons you must train and practice with them.

[@blakebarber5750]

So I’m not a soldier nor am I a Asian islands martial stylist...I am a martial artist who over the twenty years I’ve trained and as the kind of knucklehead that once took every opportunity to test and hone what I had learned by finding every single chance I could to get into street fights (I’m a little older now and have realized I’m neither bullet proof nor immortal)I have discarded more techniques than I could probably remember learning to embody this same philosophy...take what works and feels right and natural for you and use in ways to make it max effective...I have in fact been in fights where knives were involved and it fucking sucks....both ways ...but I keep reading about reach and extension and slashes and thrusts ...and this is somewhat enigmatic to me that this type of openly revealing your weapon isn’t seen by lore as folly...posturing with a weapon such as a knife serves no other purpose but to make it look like a mere prop you have no intentions of using or to get your skull split from behind when someone (possibly meaning well )sees a “knife wielding maniac “attacking this other poor guy ...and not realizing until it’s too late that you weren’t the bad guy...what I mean is nothing good usually comes from brandishing a weapon this way....your concealed weapon stays concealed until the moment of critical threat and when it’s in your hand you are using it to directly oppose the threat by removing a fair portion of the blood of said threat...the ONLY reason I made it out of the one fight I’ve had where I faced a knife with nothing more than a few scratches (none of them co big from the knife)was because the guy pulled the knife held it in plain sight and arced and whirled it through the air in front of him and I used the environment to keep objects between us until I found the right timing and opening (.and bottom section of pool cue)to make my reach greater than his and neutralize the knife by breaking the hand that was holding it more ....however had he at anytime rushed me without tables and chairs or room(lots of room to retreat I would have been in trouble and as we all know most fights still end up on the ground or close in-style grappling on your feet which will almost always still lead to the ground ...having a knife in your hand doesn’t change that ...we also know that while training is always a good thing it’s one of the primary ways we grow in anything...but the vast majority of knife type attacks are not open reveal scenarios and find the defender (or victim)usually stabbed or cut multiple times before they realize the bad guy even has a knife in his hand because its totally concealed until the very moment of the first strike...all that pretty ass twirling ,swirling kata type movement you are these guys doing will be not show up in an actual knife attack or defensive scenario if it’s not over before you have the chance to spin your Karambit around your fingers you’re probably dead or dying ...this guys dies great videos and seems to be a competent of not highly skilled practitioner but guys if you let anybody yeah you knife defense techniques that don’t involve running like hell until you can retreat no further the. You are letting someone train to get seriously injured or killed because the majority of empty handed weapon defenses fail ...not because the theory behind them isn’t sound but because they represent situations that will not be present in the reality of a knife attack conversely routines of kata movement with weapons is great for learning angles and just plain becoming comfortable with your weapon...and if it’s a a knife and the use of it isn’t taught be deployed and executed from concealment to and as a deceptive unknown quantity that will be most effective if used not as a standoff or siege weapon,but as a hidden way out when your in critical trouble and are forced to use potentially lethal force to survive...if you use it in any other way your likely gonna to find its usage was in fact criminal in the eyes of the law ...this reality is why I prefer he Karambit....because it can easily be deployed from seriously disadvantaged positions and is Taylor made for this close type usage whereas a straight blades knife depending of the size could be a liability you have to have the space to remove it straight out of the sheath and this can be the seconds that determine your life or death...just my opinions but it’s based on real life experience the only time I’ve used a knife against another human being was done in this way and only when retreat was no longer an option and I found myself (I weigh around 160 pounds being pummeled into oblivion (which felt like dying at the time ..so yes I was in fear for my life)by a 220 pound dude ... had to retrieve a folding tactical style straight blade from my pocket where it was clipped ,open it and stab upwards about from under took way too long ....curved Karambit would’ve slid right out went to its bloody work had I have had one in way less time

[@kindaremix5149]

I bought a karambit just to watch this vid after doing it 😎 Am i cool now?

[@EseSlicc_Diablo]

Yes my son yes you are

[@teamtreklip7527]

“Thats not the way shit works” haha .. all said 😄

[@vikingbluesbreaker729]

Iv been carrying my karambit for years, and training/teaching with it for years. it has even saved my life in Afghanistan. to me the first platform was great when the punch came down the line because my stand up is muay Thai and its just right there hitting his arms and hands with very little movement, the second platform took years of training and a lot of hard work but it comes down to the clinch (in this case, undertook, low wrist using head control) and the karambit excels. with the third platform the hardest thing was to control the gap until I was ready to close it, to be fair it was also hard with the straight blade, but once I was in and clinched again the karambit excels. however, I agree with literally everything you said lol. my training is in muay Thai, judo, wrestling, and jiu-jitsu, it took a lot of trial and error to make the karambit work for me because it's very hard to find proper instruction. to be honest, it would have been better for me to use the straight blade when I first started training, then added the karambit. People need to understand, the trap and roll flow drills are not going to happen. the only thing that is going to happen is violence. I think more people need to take your advice and not be emotional about the tools they use.

[@jeremyknop5378]

There are 2 kinds of knife fights, the kind done in anger followed by immediate remorse/regret resulting in the stabber knowing they just fucked up their life, and the kind with malice where the guy literally wants to kill you. For the latter, which if your going to get into one will likely be the one you encounter I recommend to anyone watching prison shanking videos because that's about the extent of it when it goes down in most assault and murder cases where knives are deployed. Its an explosive repetition of short quick stabs all over the torso and where ever else they can get to. I focused on boxing and Greco-Roman for ground work but my best friend has done bjj and Thai boxing for several years and both styles have more in common with each other than they do with other styles like Kung fu, karate, Tae Kwon do ect. Most of the traditional eastern martial arts have two major draw backs, no full contact sparring, and they are mired in centuries old tradition and aren't meant for modern self defense. Because I don't have time to practice another* fighting art I've done similar like you and incorporated a blade into my existing strike work only in my case its a punch dagger instead of a karambit.

[@MybeautifulandamazingPrincess]

It’s all about one’s proficiency and familiarity with a type of blade. A Samurai and an European knight with a Long sword both will be effective if trained and skilled in their respective arts

[@thomaspounds9031]

Brady Hartsfield 😂

[@user-pq4by2rq9y]

Not really, a spear would rule the battlefield even in the hands of a untrained farmer, that’s how Rome was built.

[@JexroShadark]

True, but i think in the video he is talking about beginners who have no training. The straight edge knife would be a better choice.

[@watchdog7033]

@@fuckoff81747 - Hey Jeff...why don’t you tell us what you really think? 😋.....but honestly some true words there my friend 👍 ....I have to concur.

[@yannik246]

my main problems with the karambit are: - reverse grip is bad for slashing - can't stab - shorter reach - catches onto certain clothing - no EDC use - hard to justify carrying it in case you have to use it

[@aubertbethencourt3241]

Depends what karambit you have, there are many karambit's that double edge to be able to slash just fine whatever grip you chose, You can stab perfectly fine. It actually can extend alot further if you flip it forward. I deploy mine just great and never catches if anything it deploys alot faster and more discrete then a straight blade.

[@imaginehydreigons5377]

Dude, buy a delica 4 with emerson wave, install a signet ring. You have a karambit/edc knife.

[@silkroad1201]

They're made for slashing and you can stab.

[@ATD909]

There are foldable karambits to allow for easier concealed carry

[@sayvorE88]

My friend said the way I like to hold one is called Pikal, I'm making them and other blades in traditional forging methods of high grade high carbon steel now. He said take a few classes so I can understand more and figure out why the tools are designed this way to at least make them correctly for their application

[@petergreen1354]

The Karambit and the straight blade are as different as cars are to motorbikes, you don’t drive/ride them the same way. Adjust your method to the tool in hand. You don’t fight using a curved blade style with a straight knife and vice versa.

[@TheTruthseeker1231]

Exactly, each weapon has advantages & disadvantages. Strategy and tactics should vary accordingly. Karambit is a CQ weapon the idea that it is not the best sparring weapon at range should be obvious, but how many times does knife sparring actually occur? Most of the time it is used CQ where the karambit shines. Also, the karambit folder is one of the most limited of the karambits available. This video is sort of biased against the karambit.

[@SageShadow096]

@@TheTruthseeker1231 especially using a short one to compare to a straight blade and standing the same distance lol. I mean grab a same size kambit then that comparison goes away.

[@themaninthesuit772]

Nobody tell this guy that I bought a karambit before I saw this

[@jonathansaavedra7863]

Thats tru, but rember that de streigth blade is longer, thas wy u dont have the same reach

[@SageShadow096]

excatly lol, using a short karambit for example with a straight knife ,there are bigger and longer karambits. shrug

[@BudgetStudios]

Yes Yes, I agree! I personally have trained using a Karambit and I can tell you that it is only effective with training. The Karambit was designed like an Eagle's talent or a Tiger's claw. Its primary objective is to hook or slice skin (Not very deep ones). It is extremely deadly especially in close-quarter combat (With an experienced wielder). I've seen a fight in my Indonesian town before, where a man literally got his forearm sliced open (You can see the damn bone!) But a Karambit. He was unable to run away because his Achilles was also sliced into 2 parts. In conclusion, the Karambit is not a weapon for someone who just wants to defend themselves without any training. It is, however, a good choice for trained military personnel, martial artists, and bouncers. It can really do damage as the blade's hook is meant to hook eyeballs, ligaments, and nerves on the neck (Sometimes genitals but let's not think of that). Its curved edge is used for slicing or redirecting other blades. Some professionals even use the hook to catch long blades like katanas. But the hook is generally more well used. The karambit is better with 2, as it is a style of martial arts that always blocks then attack. Hook a person's arm, redirect it away, slice his neck. It's something like that. I've never killed anyone but I've sliced dummies and pig bones, along with hand-to-hand combat in real scenarios and not those fancy stuff (More MMA-like). So if you wish to devote the time and effort, go get a Karambit! If not, get something easier to use. Great video btw! I think some people are just too biased towards the karambit.

[@kevinwaller657]

I bet you felt like a real pro while typing this comment out. lol.

[@Nanashi_Kenshin]

You can see by your wrists that when you measure the thrust forward, your wrists are not in the same position. So your poking out the straight blade and holding back on the karambit. That's my only concern. Everything else is good.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

I'd recommend everyone to hold an equal overall length curved blade and straight blade with the blade tip to a wall and see if basic geometry holds true. Straight line vs curved line will always have a greater reach.

[@MansMan42069]

These 2 videos pretty much apply to any weapon system, melee or ranged. Don't go out and buy a .500 S&W just because it's "cool" and "badass". Great vids

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Sylas Grayson Thank you!

[@springbloom5940]

+Vampire Lord Vladimir In the Army, we called it the 'CDI Factor' - 'Chicks Dig It'

[@holgerdanske8935]

Ha ! Sylas ! You Nailed it ! A near miss with a .500 S & W, is not as good as 2 x .22 to the heart or skull !

[@Morgetty]

So about karambits I use one I have a longer blade it’s about as big as your standard knife maybe bigger and I use mine going up then down :edit: karambits are very good if you take training

[@joeyseal9189]

On a personal note I love the karambit it forces you to become more familiar with your body movement/angles and gives you an advantage (making space)

[@nancyoffenhiser4916]

I should say also that after carrying knives for over 40 years, I always thought of them as my friends and helpful tools. Having to explore knives now for self defense because as I get older I may become a target is very disappointing for me. But it is better to practice and be ready and hope I never have to use those skills than not be ready and possibly be killed.

[@mr.bussyoface5278]

"That's just stupid!" Favorite line in this vid. Lol. Not sure why anyone would argue straight lines vs curved especially for distance..it should be common sense🤦🏽‍♂️

[@Fardawg]

It should be "common sense" to see that he has a straight blade that happens to be longer than the reach of the specific karambit trainer he is using. Let's see that with a Swiss Army knife blade against a Schrade "Shasta" karambit and see how that works. It would be just as ridiculous as his claim here. Karambits are not all one size just as not all straight blades are the same size. And I'm not even a big karambit fan. I usually prefer a long straight blade, though I see potential in shorter karambits for more close up grappling situations where you don't have the room to pull and maneuver a larger knife.

[@lowendlover5804]

I have my Guro in Arnis De Mano, as well as many years training in silat. The point I would like to make is simple: a folder and a karambit are two different weapons. It is a fallacy (as you noted yourself) to equate them. They are only "equal" in the sense that they both cut. I do think it's pointless (no pun intended) to talk about which weapon has the greater reach as a criteria for choosing one over the other. Some karambits are huge, and likewise some knives are very short. Any serious student of the blade should concern themselves with the various ways to carry and utilize their weapon. I do not own a karambit and usually carry a folder that deploys in "earth" grip. I've done enough training that when I'm in "heaven" grip my brain is in slash/thrust mode. If I'm in "earth" position, I am thinking CQC - punching, manipulation, and tearing, more akin to the tools of silat. Bottom line: anyone who carries a blade for self-defense needs to spend time exploring the possibilities of their weapon. Not everybody needs a bicycle, but having one is pointless if you can't ride it.

[@tomservo3401]

I used a crkt bearclaw for 15 years almost every day. The design is almost identical except the finger hole is at the top of the handle by the blade. The design made a very secure, manuverable knife. One thing that struck me is what a devistating stabbing weapon it could be even with such a small blade. If you were to stab into the neck, collar bone or any soft tissue then violently pull back it would do tremendous damage.

[@ndhikaatube]

that my friend is knowledge of the tool. greetings from indonesia 🤙

[@NickkaDUB]

Use a straight blade Karambit with a tip that points back. Mine is double sided. I think the best karambit is the the lil tiger 🐅 claw with the 90* angle. People don’t know it’s coming which is the biggest upside to saving your life.

[@mang058]

Hey I’m just looking to use it as a survival tool

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Surviving against what exactly? They aren't great for hunting, they aren't great for carving, they aren't great in the bush, they aren't great for cutting rope, etc. So what are your standards for "survival knife"

[@mang058]

Nevermind I found a better one

[@archangel9727]

hmm.. just a thought here but looking at the movements required to effectively use a kerambit, it reminds me of traditional muay thai with the elbow blows and sharp slicing movements. maybe I'm just seeing things.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

That is a great observation, and pretty correct. The empty handed movements of Kali and SIlat are heavily based off the movement of the blade. So we use elbow strikes the same way we use our blade, and vice versa. So the correlation that you see of the blade movements in relation to empty handed striking is correct.

[@MF-XYLYL]

@@S2StrategicDefense interesting, I've started training at my local mui thai gym (I'm lucky to have one, apparently not many people do) and have a karambit lying around in my knife collection. Might look into fighting techniques with the karambit.

[@miciahchamberlain8370]

Look at it this way why are animals such as a wolf, bear, lion, tiger.. there claws aren't straight there curved like the karambit it's for grabbing easier and tearing through flesh... Anything can be used as a weapon it's just the matter of what you want the weapon to do to the victim..

[@Gangst3r4ever]

Is the karambit better suited for short people?

[@S2StrategicDefense]

I don't think it is for short or tall people exclusively, I think that the karambit is designed for a specific use and has specific tactics/techniques and training associated with it. It is a VERY powerful tool in the right hands, and VERY poor choice in the wrong hands.

[@mcornielle]

how come there are no recorded street fights with a karambit on it? you can find machete, knife stick empty hand and gun on a single google search but nothing on a karambit, maybe it is that lethal? or maybe no one has use it on an actual fight

[@S2StrategicDefense]

I've spoken to literally one person who used a karambit to save his life, and barely stayed out of jail... and by the circumstances.. any blade would've been a good tool for him in there.

[@mcornielle]

​@@S2StrategicDefense thank you for reading. Yes, like you said its the ''cool'' thing to do and this ''cool '' tecniques are messed up and you will absolutely have a hard time explaining why you have some mortal kombat looking knife with you. judge: how do you explain having this knife? me: I was going from my ricefields to my to climb a tree and get me a coconut...thanks for reading and for your reply.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

@@mcornielle be safe my friend. Careful on those trees. :)

[@hotpopcorncake]

I think karambit is a good weapon for anti grappling and striking attacks.

[@JamesSmith-hy6ke]

Most karambits are only single edged, but what about a double edged karambit? Thoughts?

[@S2StrategicDefense]

James, double edged has it's own set of problems: 1) Can't do a folder in a double edge. And fixed blade is illegal in many places. Heck, double edged is illegal in many places as well. 2) Double Edged also means that all given points of time, a sharp edge is always facing you as well as the other person. So in essence, you may be putting yourself in harms way 3) The blade articulations and manipulations do not really change between single and double edge. Actually has to be more precision because you need to keep the back of the knife off of your body. 4) Double edge doesn't gain any reach or distance. Still the same size and shape...with an additional edge. Does that help?

[@JamesSmith-hy6ke]

thank you for the concise response! I like karambits for their look and feel but I carry a straight blade for the reasons you state! Thanks again!

[@S2StrategicDefense]

No problem!

[@robertdale7001]

i have trained most of my life in edged weapons ,father was the teacher and i can appreciate everything this man has put forth..Now for me when i picked up a Karambit i was much older and was out on my own when i picked it up it felt great in my hand and i was able to use the blade almost like breathing so im a huge fan of both..i carry the karambit most of the time..i also of course have my ccw one thing dad got me to believe in never bring a knife to a gun fight...lol...shalom

[@sumanngon]

the second part I agree more with, provided you have the small, single edged Karambit. yep for a newbie in such a case without much of body mechanics involved, a straight blade would be better choice. But then all blade fight really require many hours of training and attitude. one can train but if the attitude isn't there...you are just holding a stick in your knife that can be used against you. the best feature of karambit I like, is its retention capabilities due to the ring, and yes you are right reverse grip is the traditional and primary grip for karambit.

[@sumanngon]

wrist bending is really minimum when you have a traditional double edged Karambit. What I find in a straight edge is that blade itself acts like a lever to dislodge it from your hand, and also in a straight blade the handle material and design matters a lot. That is one big handicap! I use straight blade as my EDC or survival knife. when it's self defense I trust all forms of karambit ONLY! however many who are proficient in karambit like Doug marcaida, they handle most knives with equal elan...but I ain't Doug I am good with the karambit only.

[@lancefisher8358]

In my opinion the karambit is more effective as a deterrent. When people see this blade type they fear it. For good reason because it is devastating. Also Karambits are generally deployed faster being unfolded as soon as it leaves the pocket if it's a folder. However I do agree it requires some level of training. Similar to a butterfly knife

[@S2StrategicDefense]

I wouldn't say that Lance. Although...they can be super intimidating to look at but definitely not any more devastating than any other blade. As far as deployment, Karambits with the wave feature open very quickly but a straight blade with spring assist or a pocket catch open just as fast. That is something I've been using a shot timer to test and see if one is faster than the other and the time difference has been marginal and can go either way. On avg, they are the same. Thanks for commenting my friend!

[@rayward9265]

I agree more with Lance here than with S2's reply. S2's point that a karambit is not any more devastating than any other blade is correct, insofar as it goes. However, my take is that Lance's point about a karambit being more effective as a deterrent is also correct, and is the main thrust of his argument. My experiences with people's reactions to knives is that a blade that is "wicked" in appearance is more intimidating, and there is a primal reaction to curved blades, particularly those shaped like a claw or a fang, such as the karambit. A straight blade, while having IMHO superior characteristics in an actual fight, does not have the same intimidation factor. If you can intimidate your way out of having to employ the blade, by displaying it only, you come out ahead. The same way that more than a million Americans a year use firearms for defensive purposes without firing a shot. My analysis of my situation is that my principal threat currently is from opportunistic predators in and around commuter trains. Their main weapon is a knife, such as a box cutter. Pulling out a large karambit with a shiny blade would most likely deter an attack. (He's an old white guy, but that KNIFE!) I just bought an inexpensive, double-edged fixed-blade Schrade SCH112 for everyday commute carry. (Yes, I need to move to a free state where I can carry my preferred .45 instead of kitchen tools and drive to work...)

[@Psysso]

Karambit isn't even meant to be flashed as a fear factor (as most knives aren't) vs the opponent. It is a stealth weapon used in extreme situations solely as an element of surprise and max damage into an escape type of scenario. No sane person will flash a karambit to intimidate a thug and especially not vs one with a larger knife, gun or even a baseball bat. That would be dumb.

[@MybeautifulandamazingPrincess]

Karambit are made for and with a purpose, and are place historically in a context. If you have Silat training and proficiency with Karambit, an opponent with a knife will never touch you. You will know where to strike and end a fight instantly, if you know where to strike you can paralyze someone momentarily, or even permanently. I have experience with martial arts and to me the Karambit is the most brutal and deadly design of blade, that’s my opinion but I have experience to back it up

[@Monquie2000]

“Similar to a *butterfly knife*” (balisong users: triggered)

[@dmp762]

I think that where the Karambit really shines is its speed of deployment and usefulness at punching and grappling ranges. By practicing indexing on the ring and using the wave opener, it can be nearly as fast as drawing fixed blade from a sheath. Also, violence tends to take place at close ranges. Violence may not always take place at very close range, but if you look at recordings of violence caught on camera, people tend not to keep their distance.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

dmp762 Karambit is definitely designed for close quarters. As far as deployment, with the WAVE feature its fast but not appx the same as any other with spring assisted opening.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Thanks for jumping in. You are correct! But don't say that publicly, the masses who DON'T train with their blade will flurry to show their expertise.

[@dmp762]

Don't mess with Texas You know I can't find any videos of blade vs blade that take place in the America, or Europe for that matter. This matters because people in different countries tend fight differently. Attackers in America tend to rush in regardless if they have a knife, impact weapon, or are unarmed. That's based off videos of attacks. Sparring is an important and all too neglected part of knife training, but, just like unarmed sparring, there are significant differences between it and defending your self in real life. Like scrambling to get your weapon out before your attacker reaches you.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Don't look for actual blade vs blade videos in the US....not a common place here unless you are looking at prison riot footage where you can find shankings. You can study that like I did for 20 months under a Corrections Dep't contract in the early 2000's. As far as sparring, you have to introduce the elements into it progressively. So we change the environment, lighting conditions, then scenarios. I use my Force On Force/Simunititions Firearms against the blade, 2 on 1 vs the blade, unarmed vs blade, blade on the ground, blade in a grapple, blade vs ambush attack, etc etc. Guaranteed that not many people have put that kind of pain and time into this thing. Also, keep in mind that the Blade vs Blade sparring/training is also very helpful in everything else. Weapons training whether it is impact or edged or improvised is a great way to develop functional attributes such as timing, distancing, line familiarization, defensive footwork, offensive footwork, etc etc....attributes that apply to even basic unarmed self defense. So although it is unrealistic to have a "knife fight" in reality....the valuable lessons that come from training that way are excellent.

[@sebastiancoolidge2401]

The karambit to me feels far more natural than a straight blade, but the reverse grip makes it so it fits naturally into many martial arts. I also EDC a fixed blade double edged karambit

[@Brian-wm7pd]

Man those are some good points. I was watching a video recently on martial arts distances compared to actual non arena based combat. The difference between a ring and actually fighting for your life is a dramatic and alot of people don't seem to get that cheap shots, weapon usage, and overall techniques differ so greatly from class to combat that it very quickly changes you being alive or dead. that the "cool" weapon, flashy techniques, and expensive gear are garbage without hours behind them. Looks like I really have to step up my weapon and weapon defense game.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Brian buettner Training for the lifestyle is key

[@OGDamnnation]

I carry a straight blade because I'm 5'6. I need that extra reach. A Karambit only makes me smaller and forces me to close the distance.

[@raptorjackson6397]

I may not be right but I think that may benefit you get in their face and start stabbing In to them with the karambit and get under their rib cage.

[@카시로스]

As a female, I carry my straight blade folding knife AND karambit every day. I carry my revolver every day provided I am legally able. The reason I carry all of those options is because 1) it is pretty much par for the course to carry a straight blade for everyone where I live 2) I feel infinitely more comfortable using my karambit if I were to need it and 3) sometimes you are just gonna need a firearm. Concealing blades is a lot easier than conceal carrying my firearm, but if it ever comes down to it, having multiple options to get to if need be is always going to be preferable for me. My father is a LEO and trained myself and my siblings and his advice was always to have more options than you think you will need. Just my own two cents. Carry and hope you never have to use it, but if you do, be ready to do what must be done. Be safe out there, everyone.

[@friendlyheavy4297]

May i ask what state you live in and what the laws regarding knifes (specifically the karambit) are? I've been wanting to carry a karambit but my state law makes it EXTREMELY confusing what's legal and non-legal to carry even going as far to say "Everything else has not been specifically allowed/banned" meaning they don't even have laws for some knifes (Including the karambit). Mostly i'm worried about what to say if a cop ever sees it and asks about it, apparently "self-defense" isn't a good enough reason and you'd get arrested on the spot and the knife will get confiscated and you might even get charges.

[@카시로스]

friendly heavy Louisiana. We are one of the friendliest carry states. I can pull the laws for you, but essentially you are looking at the law as such- if the blade length is less than four inches, and it is fixed, you are good to go. Switchblade are illegal unless you are law enforcement or fire....otherwise, the laws pretty much cover you for everything open carry short of an actual sword and even then I don't think that would be a real issue tbh 😂

[@johnwukong6763]

Some good points, interesting video, thank you. The serious benefit to the karambit that I think you missed in this video is the flip to increase range. The extra range, and simularity to a right hook when using it, mean I expect to put a hole in someones skull if they annoy me.

[@zinknot]

Also there is definitely an advantage as a slashing weapon. The claw like curve causes it to really grip into whatever it cuts. I think it's perfect for defending against someone attacking with a straight blade if you target the hands and wrists of the person attacking.

[@zinknot]

I am curious to experiment with the flailing motion, it seems like it wouldn't generate enough force to be very affective but I haven't practiced with it yet.

[@-R.E.D.A.C.T.E.D-]

Feel free to correct me. Ive never been into a knife fight and never want to be. I know many knife attackers rush in with strength and adrenaline with no technique, stabbing repeatedly. Can the karambit be used in the same way except instead of stabbing, its all rapid punching motions where the blade is there for additional lethal impact and making counter grappling a lot dangerous to counter? For me its not what of type of knife you use but how ferociously you use it in the spur of the moment

[@S2StrategicDefense]

You've brought up a few points that all kind of relate. 1) Rushing in isn't just a knife tactic, we see that with almost every kind of fight. However, we shouldn't look at aggression as a replacement for skill. It will only get you so far. Also, you have to think about what to do when someone rushes in at you...are you going to rush them back? Probably not a great idea. 2) Karambit can be used in the same punching method that you describe. They can also be used to open beer bottles or to pry something open or as a screw driver....doesn't mean that is the way they are intended to be used. They can also be used for hooking, scooping and locking with some training and skill development. 3) Ferociously implies that you are swinging wildly and without any tact....again, don't confuse aggression with skill. Ultimately as I said in the video, the Karambit is an awesome knife design but we have to quit being "fan-boys" of it and understand what they are good for and what they are not. Recently, GN from Funker Tactical even made a post on his FB page about how he has been trying to use the Karambitin live sparring sessions and ultimately finding out that it isn't half as useful as people think it is.

[@friendlyheavy4297]

Hey could you help me out? I've been wanting to carry a karambit but my state law makes it EXTREMELY confusing what's legal and non-legal to carry even going as far to list a bunch of rules and knives and then saying "Everything else has not been specifically allowed/banned" meaning they don't even have laws for some knifes (Including the karambit). Mostly i'm worried about what to say if a cop ever sees it and asks about it, apparently "self-defense" isn't a good enough reason and you'd get arrested on the spot and the knife will get confiscated and you might even get charges.

[@nicholasdouglas2275]

Just pertaining to reach, yes in forgrip the straight blade is better for reach, however when the karambit is in extended grip it reaches farther than the straight blade and that switch in grips can happen in less than a second.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Nicholas Douglas define "extended" grip. If you're referring to a forward grip it still doesn't compare in reach. And to say the "grips change in a second" would also be untrue. Sure it can be done fairly quickly...but not under the stress of someone trying to harm/kill you where even fractions of a second and fractions of an inch can mean the difference between life and death.

[@hoax4312]

3:04 bruh his shoulders were not squared with the bag

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Bruh, it's camera angle. But if you don't believe that a curve line will cover less distance than a straight line, please go get your hands on a straight/curve blade and try for yourself. Then come back, and forward to the closing one minute of this video, which is where all of the substance is. Make sure you place your video link in the response of your training with a Karambit vs a Straight blade.

[@hoax4312]

@@S2StrategicDefense ah ok my bad i thought the karambit blad was the same length

[@tigerfang7471]

i have a question..?? originally karambit is a single edge or double edge knife..???

[@S2StrategicDefense]

tiger fang The double edge doesn't influence the reach or articulations of the blade.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Original Indonesian version had both single and double versions.

[@omegafoxxtrot7248]

So one question, I have relatively little experience in martial arts having only a year of training in Judo. I have been looking for somewhere to train in an edge weapon self defense and own a straight blade knife which I carry for work and a Karambit which I was a gift. Is there any martial art that specifically incorporates the Karambit into its training without being exclusively for the use of the the weapon? If so where can I train/learn? I would rather not learn straight blade defense because I can't carry something to work that is technically a weapon and if I register as trained then I wouldn't be able to carry my knife but I live in a very rough neighborhood and need something better than a basic carrying throw to defend myself.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Omega, you can look into Kali, Silat, JKD, among a few. And if you have limitations on carrying a straight blade, you definitely will not be able to carry a karambit. BUT, you can find and replicate the characteristics of a straight blade in day-to-day items....but that is not true with the Karambit. If anything, you should learn the straight blade, as it is easily found. As far as "registering as trained," that is a myth. I don't know anywhere in the globe that tells you to do that.

[@omegafoxxtrot7248]

I work for a self employed man who is against violence for religious reasons, so he doesn't like the idea of me carrying something that is used for harm, he's fine with a tool but I would rather not risk my job over a knife and he is a good friend of mine. As for carrying it, I wouldn't carry it to work, the problem comes from receiving training then carrying a straight blade to work, that's why I don't want a martial art that is exclusively focused on the use of a weapon such as the Karambit. I know I feasibly could receive training and still carry the knife to work, I'm just the kind of person who really doesn't like doing anything that I would see as betraying my friends trust since he hired me when no other people would even look at my resume. I'm not the best at English so "registering as trained" is the best way I have to express it. Thank you for the information and your time.

[@Knight_of_the_Old_Code]

While I train with the karambit as much and whenever I can, my main use would be for a last resort weapon along with primary weapon (pistol) retention at which point after using the karambit, I'd create distance and go to my firearm.

[@jennyyy505]

How would I get a training karambit, would should I try carving one out of wood or buy a professional training karambit

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Gam3r11 The Kraken. There are many training Karambits online. Go to Amazon and find one you like.

[@jennyyy505]

S2 Strategic Defense mkay

[@Navoii.]

The forward thrusting with the Karambit would be similar to that of the Jambiya, which I've heard is curved to make stabbing easier on your wrist

[@S2StrategicDefense]

@@Navoii. Jambiya is a Yemenese knife and has a reverse curve and the curve is only in the tip area. Not the same at all.

[@pross6525]

I would be honored to train under your guidance. I enjoy a straight blade and a fixed blade. I am looking forward to learning the Karmabit

[@jeremyknop5378]

I used to do HEMA for a few years and messed around with Rondel dagger sparring, got decent at german longsword but dagger fighting I never grasped. That being said I've boxed for about 12 years. Havnt in the last couple but I still do bag work at my home gym every weekend. Between work, working out and training in marksmanship and team firearms drills and trying to work in time with my family and friends I don't have time to pick up another martial art style lol hence why I carry a push knife. I can literally use my already competitive level boxing skills but with the addition of a 3 1/2" blade extending from my hand. Of course I carry it off hand as my primary is my side arm and if a situation deteriorates to the point of me having to pull a weapon in self defense I'm pulling my sidearm first however sparring practice and training drills have proven to me having a up close and personal off hand weapon is an invaluable asset to carry.

[@KiiDxLegacy]

Very informative video. But when you compared the reach of both knives you didn't put the karambit in the same hand as the straight blade. The heavy bag is a cylinder, so when you tested the reach of the straight blade in your right hand you were technically closer to the bag. Compared to holding the karambit in the left hand, the bag was farther away because the left side of your body was not in line with the closest part of the bag; like your right side is. You can clearly see in the video that because of the circular dimensions of the bag, the karambit was aimed at a further part of the bag. I'm not sure, but it seems to me like the left side of your body is further away. I do believe the karambit has shorter reach, but not by that amount as was showed. I would appreciate a reply on what you think of this.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

KiiDxLegacy There's a seam on the side of the bag that I reached for...so we had the same target with both hands. Also, camera is set at an angle from me so it may look like one is extended further...but they are not. If you do the same "test" to flat wall...you'll get the same result. Try it. And the reach isn't the only argument..how about trying the three testing platforms I explained at the end...that is where the real results will come thru for you.

[@tylermoore7320]

Just purchased a double edged karambit, and two training blades. Any tips for Affordable practice gear I want to have my own an not some gyms handme- downs

[@tylermoore7320]

And I just subscribed so hopefully a buddy and me can get you that video of the hour sparring, edited for time of course 🤙

[@tronstudios5848]

Were can I get a custom painted karambit?

[@Ka0ziun]

What would be your opinion on a knife such as the DART that displays a tanto blade ? Seems like it fixes a lot of the drawbacks your are highlighting in this video as it is fantastic for stabbing strikes and keeps a lot of karambit principles in the way you operate it.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

The DART is straight blade design, just has a retention ring on it. I discuss that in another video. That being said, the point of the video isn't the karambit, it's the training. Buy whatever ya like... train with it.

[@Ka0ziun]

@@S2StrategicDefense In which video please ? Im hesitating to purchase that knife and learning how to operate it but the only persons the does reviews on this knife are using it as EDC/Box opener ... would be interested to have your full opinion on this knife through the video you mentioned, thanks !

[@nayibalgarin4338]

💪karambit 💪🔥 depend what you looking for. the model of karambit and wau 💪 is your arm like a rock or something depend. For my the karambit 💪🔥💪.

[@74Mikep]

I don't know if it was discussed already. I didn't go through all the comments. But, the karambet you are using is a folder. And you say that it only deploys in reverse fighting. I carry my fixed blade EDC in cross back, It can be deployed in either reverse or front style.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Michae' Pence I'm using a folder because fixed blades are illegal in my area.

[@jianpai4020]

Thas it have age limit? I want to use it for self defence karambit

[@TheLifeofJP0724]

why not buy both?

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Onebadegg Buy both. Train with em both

[@TheLifeofJP0724]

S2 Strategic Defense what if i train first then buy then untrain?????

[@xXDDKJefferyXx]

you assume that all karambits are single edge

[@S2StrategicDefense]

No.. no I don't. I explained very clearly at I'm using a single edge because many states do not allow a fixed blade or a double edge.

[@mastiffmythslegendsandlore]

I carry a Schrade Shasta McNasty has my edc I like the benefits of the double edge also the length is pretty decent California living boy

[@RAMZCK]

An open question to anyone from someone who has very sweaty hands. I have tried alot of handle materials but i find them difficult to get a grood grip of whenever my hands start sweating. In my case, am i better of with a karambit since it has a retention ring?

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Retention ring is not a replacement for proper grip. All you end up with it slippery knife moving around in your hands with a ring on it.

[@jimg741]

about the whole reverse grip thing. you can deploy it in either forward grip or reverse. it just depends what way you have it in your pocket. after you switch the pocket clip you can deploy with your pinky through the ring

[@S2StrategicDefense]

If you switch the pocket clip...and draw it backwards...yes you can deploy it in the forward grip. Now go try to do that with someone in boxing gloves trying to rip your face off and place the video of it below. Also note, right now on Facebook I am involved in a post where people who literally thought the retention ring was going to help them....BUT lost their finger or skinned the meat off their finger from tip to knuckle are posting up their pics. Kinda gruesome, but something to think about. Most common cause....they didn't have the correct manipulations of the karambit (they thought they did) and struck a bone/hard subject that resulted in the blade getting angled off and inertia pushing/dragging their finger thru the retention ring....and skinning them literally down to the bone. Think about that one.

[@jimg741]

im not arguing safety nor technique here. just mentioning alternative ways of drawing the weapon.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

I am very well familiar with the forward and reverse deployment methods. And wanted to give you some additional stuff to think about.

[@whiskey6964]

correct me if im wrong but what ive had read that the karambit is supposed to be a slash weapon like a claw, but when i can get a knife i want a ka-bar for the practical and defensive/offensive purpose Edit: www.evike.com/shop/30/201/1165/ you can find some training knifes and swords

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Unfortunately that is incorrect. The Karambit is and always has been primarily utilized in a reverse grip ever since it was used as a weapon. Although it's origins come from farming tools...and the blade is shaped like a claw, it's uses have never been to replicate an actual claw.

[@whiskey6964]

okay i wasnt entirely sure but think you for correcting me

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Whiskey No problem.

[@gearrodclements7531]

Now dont get me wrong you very clearly know more about this than most people but if the karambit was double edged wouldnt the aldivase / figure eight (im not sure how exactly to spell that) motion be just as simple as a straight blade?

[@thm_dusk2503]

There are such thing as double sided blade on krambits so u can have the same mobility has a straight blade if used correctly but I'm not a professional so correct me if I'm wrong

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Problem is that you can't put a double edge on a folder knife, and many states in the US make fixed blades illegal to carry. Plus, the double edge doesn't make it any more or less effective, the ability of the person using it does.. and that's my entire point.

[@thm_dusk2503]

@@S2StrategicDefense ok I apologize I wasn't trying to criticize or anything I just kinda put my thought out there since I live in a state where non-folding krambits are legal as long as the blade isn't to long. Thanks for correcting my statement keep doing what your doing.

[@abnergaldos8695]

They took down your part 1 vid

[@Nova-ne1il]

I fully agree in many places the one place it does shine is the minute you get locked up you're assuming fixed blade will get the kill shot once you get locked up with somebody that's when the curved blade shines

[@Michael-mg9fr]

like when you thrust with the karambit and the spine hits the target first the blade lock can fail and you lose your fingers as it closes on them

[@S2StrategicDefense]

The part people don't talk about is the dismembering or de-gloving caused by the retention ring of a karambit.

[@ad9478]

the karambit works well with Jeet kune do due to the intercepting aspect of the style. Training is paramount due to this principle because you have to get in close fast, faster than your opponent can actively execute his attack and cut it short. this is a very short range weapon make no mistake. To use this properly you must get right next to your target. If you're willing to do that then this is the blade for you. It's a high risk, high reward weapon to be sure.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

The knife will only work as good as the person using it. It's not a magic knife.. the point of the video is that everything requires training, and the karambit requires EXTRA training.

[@ad9478]

@@S2StrategicDefense exactly.

[@gosoku2771]

Where is the part one video?

[@manuska1999]

I edc an karambit my self because I have tried an straight edge blade and it dose not fit my fighting "technique" wich is boxing based where the karambit is easier to utilise in dodges and side steps

[@S2StrategicDefense]

If you feel comfortable with a Karambit, then by all means...carry it. Like I said in the video, doesn't matter much to me....BUT.....use the 3 Testing Platforms I provided at the end of the video first and make a decision after that.

[@lerinarazafy7826]

1. As this video says, the Reverse grip is the usual way to use it. Its a "Disrupt, Destroy, Disengage" weapon. 2. The farming tool fable is a myth. Probably a ploy to mimic Okinawan weapon stories. a) No serious farmer will spend time and effort with such blade. b) A Weapon is sacred. Its a vector of life or destruction. Its not a toy to be flash flipped in combat. It is meant to disarticulate, gouge, and slash. Only occasionally stab or puncture.

[@bluehornet197]

I'm sorry but I have trained in Silat and Kali and if 2 trained fighters are using knives and they both have the same training equivalent training (not talking about styles) the guy with the Karambit will win because there are a lot more defensive moves one can do to avoid being killed where as the forward grip does not the knife can mainly be used offensively and its MUCH easier to disarm someone using the normal grip compared to the reverse grip do you actually know anything about fighting with a knife?

[@S2StrategicDefense]

James, thanks for the comment. But you're absolutely incorrect. First, you mention that you've studied Kali and Silat.. under who, how long, how consistently? Because it's still people such as Guru Inosanto, Tujon Gaje, Tujon Taboda, and pretty much any of these great pioneers in Kali that ALL say that Karambit has far too many restrictions. And historically speaking, the karambit was considered a tertiary knife... the long blade, the straight fixed dagger, then the karambit for when the other two weren't available. So again, who and what is it that you "studied"? Now to your next fallacy of "all skill being equal, Karambit person will win". What science is that based on? Because the one thing that we know by studying any real world violent encounters is that "equal skill" doesn't exist when attacks are done in ambush matter. Equal skill doesn't exist when one side is highly aggressive and the other side is unprepared. We can even look at combat sports such as MMA and see that equal skill doesn't exist. Who is more effective at the moment matters much more. Furthermore, how much sparring have you done with the blade match up? For those of us who have done A LOT of it, we all realize the perils of the same thing. We've also taken 2 people "of the same skill" when they're brand new to edged weapons and had them spar with the mismatch to find the person with the karambit struggles much more. So when EVERY single indication or possible measurement of efficacy is applied, the karambit proves subpar in knifr based tactics.. your reasoning is "I've studied some Kali?"

[@eddiewitchcraft6574]

what's your opinion on the dart knife by Doug Marcaida?

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Eddie, I haven't had the chance to get one yet so I can't say. Looks like he used a straight blade with the addition of the retention ring of the karambit. Essentially it's a straight blade, and looks pretty nice.

[@pyshpoak]

Its a wonderful knife.The reverse tanto point is great for thrusting,and it can be use for EDC,which traditional karambits cant.Sadly,i have small hands,and it simply doesnt fit.

[@Kobudokaiju]

this is more of a engagement thing like how close do you think you will be if attacked

[@noelchristianromero425]

great video.. I've been carrying a karambit with a short blade (about 1.5 inches) since i got mugged almost 2 years no. i prefer it since i can easily conceal it and in case i need to attack first, enemy won't be as prepared compared to seeing you attacking with a knife and they would think that you're only throwing a punch. but this video made me think about carrying a straight blade knife. thanks for the great tips.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

mc noodle You're veey welcome. BTW...no reason it can't be a 2nd blade.

[@noelchristianromero425]

it might be questionable now with the authorities here in the Philippines if i have 2 blades with me but thanks for the idea. :)

[@spikechang556]

What specific knife is that straight one? Also is that Fox Karambit the medium version or the xl version?

[@anthonysmith3442]

This was very eye opening. I have been trying to learn the Mike Janich systems here on youtube using a spyderco yojimbo. Its been a long time and I dont feel I am making good progress. Just purchased a karambit trainer to try and add that skill set but again looks like it.might be an uphill battle.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Mike Janich is a very skilled practitioner and bases much of his basic training drills on pangamut and palisut. Problem with that is that for someone brand new to the blade, the foundations are missing. That being added to the lack of concepts from the Filipino arts (Kali); and the fact that theres little to no attribute training such as timing, distancing, footwork etc. That's not a slam on him or his Modern Blades Combatives program.. it's just honest feedback on the training itself. Can't just "comma cut" the way it is presented.

[@muhammaddigoadhyaksaparaka621]

hello dude so the original karambit before modern as now it has two sharp blade sides, not like you hold only the sharp inner side so in my opinion karambit can hurt the enemy more than the straight blade

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Medical and Forensic study have proven that 3 factors relate to lethality as it relates to an open cavity wound. 1. Wound Cavity Placement 2. Wound Cavity Depth 3. Wound Cavity Width A double edge does not have any added benefit in any of those 3. Secondly, watch Part 1 to get history on the karambit. I go thru the evolution. Next, try to have a double edge folder knife.. doesn't work. Sure it's still an option in a fixed blades but many states in the US do not allow a fixed blade carry. Finally, if your argument is that "double edge original design is more lethal than the single edge as I'm using," then by default you're saying that the modern style is then less effective, and a then we would compare double edge karambit to double edge straight.. and by the rules of woumd channels, the straight blade gets deeper wound cavity every time. Lastly, the debate that a whatever blade is more lethal than the other is kinda weak. If fighting attributes and body mechanics are more natural with a straight knife rather than a karambit, a person would be more effective with the straight knife combatively speaking. The brush doesn't paint the art, the fork doesn't eat the food, and the blade doesn't fight the fight.

[@gmichaloski3367]

thanks for the review, I think it helped me make a more informed decision

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Team Black Very welcome. Best of Luck!

[@brianrosoman570]

the karambit is meant more for deeply ripping youre opponent from crotch to chin than for stabbing though you can use it fir that if you wish, it more a ripping tool, its derived from "the claw of Hanuman" -a character from the Ramayana pictured to the right), the magical claw, which protrudes from between the center of the hands of Bima and Hanuman - has become recognized as a symbol of the martial arts of the Indonesian archipelago, namely Pencak Silat and is often attributed as one of the roots of the overall Karambit design. The graceful and efficient curvature of the tiger's claw (designed by mother nature) in combination with the mystical hand weapons of the ancient characters of the Mahabharata and the Ramayana - the Kuku Macan, Kuku Bima or Kuku Hanuman - where forged together with steel and bone by early village-dwellers to create the ancient Karambit. In modern times as the Karambit (now much smaller in size than its battlefield-sized ancestor) is now recognized internationally as a traditional weapon of Indonesian Pencak Silat.

[@IlokanoWarrior]

Brian Rosoman - I like to think of it a as rip from balls to throat kind of weapon.

[@princerb4450]

Man don't compare karmabit with the way you use a straight blade

[@funny963funny9]

Where is the part 1?

[@Michael-mg9fr]

if you brace your forearm on someone's collar bone and have a karambit the stabbing method wouldn't even be an option so wouldn't disembowelment be better than repeated stabs? so a horizontal slash at about the belly button. same effect in essence but done with less repetition. so like 1 slash vs. multiple thrusts

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Very unnatural in movement....the point of the collar stop is retain someone and apply forward pressure while you cycle the knife. If you go horizontal you have the knife going left and right, arm going front to back, and all of it across your own body. Can it be done? Yeah, just not well.

[@dkwolfe1]

Thanks for providing some great advice. The one point I would make is that the karambit does make a lot of sense for those with empty hands training. My training is in Tomiki-ru Aikido, and my krambit is an infinite force multiplier, because I'm going to get in close in the first place. It's not a distance weapon, and you rightly point that out. Great video.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Again, depends on the hand to hand training, and previous edged weapons training. The Karambit as we know it was used as a concealed weapon to augment the hand to hand combatives of Silat, a very fluid and dynamic art with close quarters and grappling. For them it made sense...you give a karambit to a Tae Kwon Do person and they won't do well with it.

[@crazynutreviews2647]

@@S2StrategicDefense Speaking as a taekwondo practitioner I can completely agree

[@williama1029]

In your end remarks concerning sparring in karambit/vs, I'll just say that its clear you understand that the human hand is the best blade or club. Always accessible. It would be cool if you did a vid on "Pikal" techniques.

[@peter-radiantpipes2800]

Part 1 removed?

[@dominicknepper2082]

As my old sensei used to say, "If you get in a knife fight, you've already lost. You WILL get cut. They only way you can walk away safe is if they have nothing and you have a knife. Then you go to jail."

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Sensei is incorrect on all counts.

[@michide72]

@@S2StrategicDefense oh no. What old sensei really said was: If you don't want to get hurt - stay out of trouble! No more and no less.

[@stjohn241]

..as my choice of carry blade all day karambit works perfectly for me..i work at night-grave yard shift so i cant afford to lose what ive got and it was proven and tested twice that this blade saved me..

[@todd8086]

Good info. I'm not sure why so many people seem to have only one EDC setup. I like the DART karambit style knife as my weak hand front backup blade with either a large folder or fixed blade as my primary but that could be due to my constant learning of new techniques. The DART knife designed by Doug M. helps to eliminate the problem of stabbing in either grip.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Thanks for commenting Todd! I used to do the same set up as you, but between a firearm and magazine, I only keep one blade on me unless I am away from my gun. A few other people commented about the new DART knife, I haven't gotten one yet but I think it is a very well thought out design.

[@fin_jan]

3:14 Now YOU'RE fudging it. If you held both knives in the same hand, there is

[@BSt0ic]

I agree with what you said. I have karambit and a trainer and I am still working on the motions. It's one if the coolest blades I have ever seen.

[@S2StrategicDefense]

It's a great blade! Be safe while you're working with it!

[@strwf]

How can a knife with a four inch blade, straight or not, give you three or four inches more reach than a knife with a 3.2 inch blade thats a little curved, thats total bullshit, not to mention i have both of these knives and the cold steel gives you maybe an inch at most, i understand his point, but hes a total exaggerating

[@LVLouisCyphre]

If you're passionate about your weapon system and train with it, you will excel with it. There's no right or wrong way of (self) defense, it's finding a system that works for you. I see both sides of the argument of karambit v. straight blade. Both are deadly in the hands of the accomplished practitioner. Karambit and straight blade techniques are different. I view karambit technique as a blade extension of your fist while boxing and probably could work well with an accomplished PR-24 baton practitioner. My apologies if this offends any Kali practitioners. It's just what it appears to be to me. Do I see it as a viable fighting technique, absolutely. Having a blade extension of your fist is something quite deadly. There are pros and cons to everything. Find the system that has the pros for you and be safe.

[@jsanljohn7925]

the beauty of the Karambit is it ability to be "less than Lethal" ...but you are 100% correct.. it takes a Lot more training and favors quick of hands and the "hand trapping" style.

[@jsanljohn7925]

it is a Defensive Weapon with the Ability to Kill. Made to be fast with varied modes of attack. The Karambit is more versatile. Yes it gives up reach and Attacking motions, ...but in favor of Defensive/Grappling/Close Quarters... do you expect to fence with your EDC Edge Weapon?

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Jsan Ljohn All weapons are offensive and defensive...depends on the use. And to understand the use you need to understand the fundamentals such as: Distancing Range Angles Footwork Bridging and Reverse Bridging Targeting Entering Amongst Others. These are fundamental in combat. So if you don't know those things intimately...you get comments like "you expect to fence with a knife?"

[@jsanljohn7925]

these things should be elemental in CQC.. edged warfare. ...in a combat zone I MAY want my Kbar.. in a civ situation.. ill take my folding karambit tyvm.

[@jsanljohn7925]

its funny that you would try to belittle with your statement, fair enough... a straight blade was made for and thereby counters. (Punching and Kicking) very straight line attacks yes? (like fencing) ... the Karambit..turns the close quarter combat scene into very deadly control battle....

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Not trying to belittle....losing translation in text...especially replies given at stoplights while driving. Don't take it as belittle....just getting to the point

[@babbonatale6342]

But I already bought one! Oh no! It's too late! Joking though I only wanted as a display/colection purposes. However great video.

[@demonx_xu4329]

As someone who is proficient in many styles of martial arts. Modifications of knifes, swords, exc and an expert handler and twiriling, flipping and knowledge of mass X Volume X speed and weight distribution I know he is right the straight FIXed blade will beat a fold up traditional one sided karambit yes but you will not beat a fixed double edged sawtooth karambit with any knife machete, or hatchet, ONLY If you have knowledge of the martial arts and body mechanics. My phrase is simple Twirl and kill tricks plus fast movements and good move execution you will always win because you don't engage with one single karambit they always recommend one male and female pair one is held reverse grip while one is held regular think of this method as fighting like a windmill a fan or a planes proportion system would you really throw yourself into a whirlwind of talon shaped blade edges I think not...... Also is recommend a pair of brass knuckles a sharkskin coat for slash resistance just saying... Lighter the weapon the quicker man or women wins bigger isn't always better in the street. Maybe in your pants but not here

[@Tacticalcatninja]

The karambit was designed in the Philippines for close range combat because people kept on getting jacked every time they went anywhere and Guns really weren’t available at a time Filipino martial arts have roots in Karambit fighting stick fighting and so on

[@S2StrategicDefense]

Karambit comes from Indonesia, as a farm tool. It didnt even make it into Kali /Phillipines til the 1970s and 1980s for the most part.

[@Tacticalcatninja]

S2 Strategic Defense OK I didn’t know that I will admit I’m wrong overall good video the karambit blade is one of the blades I carry on my utility belt when I’m on patrol

[@S2StrategicDefense]

@@Tacticalcatninja I got no issue with em.. they just require a specific training designed around the karambit. Not as intuitive.

[@watertiger33]

nice video. I have carried knives all my life and practiced MA for a few of those years. I have an interest n the karambit currently. you did a nice job bringing out a lot of differences. the distance difference meh. thrusting any blade and impacting something solid would not be my primary movement. the video does a good job though bringing out many differences I really hadn't even considered yet. thanks

[@S2StrategicDefense]

watertiger33 Thank you!