Doctor Who (1963-1989) and An Adventure in Space and Time (2013) - scene comparisons

[@kaijohnson3730]

I love how Sacha Dhawan plays Doctor Who's Director in this, then becomes the Master in series 12. It's almost like the Master orchestrated the whole thing

[@ThornOfSociety]

Still love that the lady yelling for the kids to come home as their dinner was getting cold, was actually Carol Anne Ford who played Susan in the show

[@HarriRobins]

And how Nicholas Briggs is playing Peter Hawkins.

[@Kryojenix]

There were lots of cameos - I didn't pick a single one until I read an article listing them all!

[@ssp6186]

Carole ann ford had to write an E on the end of "carol"

[@amyclarke41]

Susan seemed the 60s version of Sarah Jane Smith 😆

[@monkeyjb1988]

Thank you. I've been trying to find her in the movie with no luck :D

[@timrob12]

3:54 - Current Dalek voice Nicholas Briggs playing original Dalek voice Peter Hawkins. A nice easer egg for New Who fans and Nick's chance to pay homage to the man who got him his dream job.

[@anewgroove]

David Bradley nailed the First Doctor performance he was brilliant...he is perfect as the First Doctor!!!!

[@christofferoff]

Better than Richard Hurndall.

[@VictorIV0310]

Green Whovian I agree. Not perfect but fair enough.

[@andrewgilbertson5672]

The inflections are all off. The farewell speech to Susan was subdued and sad, missing the way Hartnell played it. I mean, it wasn't horiffic, but... it wasn't that close, either.

[@Elricwulf]

Sorry, all I hear is his unwelcoming portrayal of his bitter old curmudgeon Game of Thrones character Walder Frey. I don't hear any trace of William Hartnell's Doctor in there. Maybe he was the closest facsimile they could find and he probably did the best job considering, but to say he nailed it or that he was perfect is exaggerating quite a bit. William Hartnell played it somewhat aloof and condescending at times, but he never came off as bitter and mean spirited the way David Bradley does.

[@Lumibear.]

Mister Groove - I think he has way less exaggerated inflections, Hartnell was rather intense, they spent a lot of time trying to soften him though so in some ways Bradley’s performance is more how he wanted to be.

[@jwg5774]

Love the scene of Nick Briggs doing his Peter Hawkins Dalek voice impression.

[@gohanmoreno7]

He was doing that after all, just pretending he is acting, but no acting really. He is a very good actor, maybe with a new script written specifically for him, he will put all together.

[@LibraGamesUnlimited]

Maybe they should use the cast of the movie to recreate the classic lost episodes of the original series. They seem really good at it.

[@timrob12]

THAT'S WHAT I HAVE BEEN SAYING FOR A WHILE NOW! I know Marco Polo uses the original TARDIS team and that's one serial EVERYONE wants to see back.

[@LibraGamesUnlimited]

@@timrob12 I mean they used the guy who played William Hartnell in the movie to play the actual First Doctor so it could work. I would say, if they did it, they should use the same budget and techniques to do the effects to try and duplicate the original as much as possible.

[@timrob12]

@@LibraGamesUnlimited Agreed.

[@marianojrivera8101]

@@LibraGamesUnlimited with an adjustment to inflation of course

[@LibraGamesUnlimited]

@@marianojrivera8101 Of course.

[@thoranzalarvhazen4250]

WE'RE RUNNING OUT OF TIME! CHECK THE FORNICATOR!

[@SofiaFox]

*FAULT LOCATOR

[@jgmfuentes]

@@SofiaFox Thanks for saying what's the actual sentence

[@JRRLewis]

I like Bradley and am glad he's returning to the part, but where's the First Doctor's little half grin while speaking, all the theatrical facial expressions, the business he does with his hands and fidgety fingers, his greater mobility and physicality, his periodic imperiousness and arrogance, his silly giggling, his frequent "hmm?", and foremost the charm and whimsy of the character? I appreciate that Bradley for the most part more or less looks and sounds similar to Bill Hartnell, but he seems to still be missing a lot of the heart of his character. There was something magical and likeable behind the character's gruffness that Bradley still needs to fully find and I hope he does.

[@JasonBorn89]

Is it possible Susan may be in the Christmas Special though

[@SceneComparisons]

nobody would be perfect bradley is the next best thing if you accept the premise that the first doctor is back, you have to accept the new actor for what it is and just enjoy the nod to the first doctor and be happy ;)

[@Kryojenix]

I doubt Susan would be in it. Ben and Polly are a chance, but I dunno if they could even do that. I do wish Michael Craze hadn't fallen down those stairs though. Would've been great for him to see all these new episodes. ='-(

[@andrewgilbertson5672]

Well said! I think the difference is more evident to those of us that were pre-existing Hartnell fans, and pick up on the mannerisms and inflections that he infuses the part with.

[@alfredjohnson2647]

Of the four, I think the most identical resemblance is Jemma Powell as Jacqueline Hill (especially in black and white), right down to the voice. David Bradley looks like Hartnell, but the real Hartnell was much shorter and played the First Doctor with a distinctly soupy-sounding Edwardian public school voice.

[@reydaniel75]

I really like your scenes comparisons videos,keep up the good work.

[@SceneComparisons]

thanks :)

[@MADAMEARIES]

It is extremely confusing to have both audio playing together, for a true comparison alternating the scenes would have been far more productive

[@SceneComparisons]

it helps if you use a stereo sound there's no purpose in alternate the scenes since anyone can do this with any player on the computer

[@christopheralthouse6378]

Dimitri Bitu There IS a point! Not all of us are skilled at video editing, you know. Besides which, why go through the extra bother when the video could've been properly edited from the get-go when you uploaded it!

[@granadosvm]

I actually liked all playing together simultaneously. It gives you a sense of how similar or different the rhythm was on each scene.

[@scaper8]

Having the episode and the reconstruction scenes from 'An Adventure in Space and Time' going together works, but I would have separated the pilot and pilot reconstruction into there own set. Two going at once is fine, four was a bit trickier. Still, excellent video.

[@metalmugen]

I know, its bringing me nuts

[@gromusodus1949]

I realize they added the Doctor dropping his scarf and the extra door openings in order to make the production seem bad, but I would have preferred they be more accurate. But overall they did a very good job!

[@WilliamZeebub]

amazing talent you have dimitreze, must have taken a lot of time to make this clip. actually David Bradley plays the role with all his heart and soul.

[@SceneComparisons]

+WilliamZeebub thanks! yes, it did take a lot of time make. ☺

[@AubreySciFi]

Well, he plays the part of William Hartnell with all his heart and soul in this docudrama. When it comes to his performance as the 1st Doctor however he is very flat and doesn't give it any of the wonderful subtleties that Hartnell did. He did a much better job in the Twice Upon a Time, unfortunately they had him playing it very sexist there, so it still wasn't a true seeming version of the 1st Doctor. Oh well. At least he stepped up his game playing the 1st Doctor 2nd time out.

[@josephchambers2000]

I loved all the performances in this. I hope they use these actors to re-create lost episodes.

[@PeterHamiltonz]

Thanks for putting this together.

[@SceneComparisons]

you welcome :)

[@Jack-pr3si]

i do think bradley is almost perfect as william hartnell but I think he plays him a little too hard, there's a certain whimsey to hartnell that bradley didn't quite get

[@timrob12]

You could actually do a comparison of the final Hartnell story "The Tenth Planet" with the scenes from Twice Upon a Time.

[@PoissonVisageStudios]

I made one when it came out if you wanna check it out: kzbin.info/www/bejne/q6SzgIyYgsRmhdU

[@feeno1188]

You actually did it o_o I'm impressed by your work and the care and attention you give to it :D

[@SceneComparisons]

I did the whole first scene again from scratch. Hahahaha.

[@gabrielzanotti0612]

I loved the focus on Susan when she said tardis for the first time on the show on pilot

[@jonathandoyle513]

There is a slight error, The reason Susan is wearing a different top is she wears a different top between the original Doctor Who Pilot and the The actual Second Pilot which was Broadcast.

[@timrob12]

I think there is a reason for that. I have a feeling it's adressed somewhere, but I can't remember where.

[@Durwood71]

David Bradley played a good William Hartnell, but he wasn't very good as the First Doctor. His delivery and performance were flat, like he was just reciting the lines instead of actually playing the character.

[@Kryojenix]

I think that was deliberate. Hopefully he'll be better at Christmas - but it's a massive call to ask one actor to represent a character in the same style that a previous actor did. That's why Doctor Who has mostly avoided it.

[@UltimateHammerBro]

I thought it was intentional. They made the in-character delivery flatter to better distinguish it from the actor's delivery.

[@UltimateHammerBro]

Have you ever seen any comic book where the characters read a comic book? Don't the pictures in the "comic book-within-comic book" tend to be cruder or more cartoonish than the art in the actual story? It's a way of telling apart what's supposed to be a drawing in-universe and what isn't. This could be a similar case. As a way of telling apart what's acting in-universe (i.e. Bradley playing Hartnell playing The Doctor) and what isn't (i.e. Bradley playing Hartnell), the in-universe acting is made flatter than it actually was. Otherwise, there may not be much difference between Bradley's Hartnell and Bradley's Hartnell's Doctor.

[@tardiselliottrailers]

100% agree

[@mrhello7611]

I believe that was very much intentional, I view this as David Bradley playing William Hartnell playing The Doctor, instead of David Bradley playing The Doctor And in my opinion this was a good decision, and this immerses me more to the idea that that is William Hartnell playing The Doctor, and not David Bradley, because, and I apologise for redundancy, what we are seeing is David Bradley portraying William Hartnell portraying The Doctor, and not David Bradley's portrayal of The 1st Doctor

[@jayceboy]

the BBC need to redo the 1st doctor story line that had the missing episodes with David Bradley playing the 1st

[@MichaelM28]

FUCK NO!!!

[@anonymystical4413]

Michael McGrath why?

[@helmsly2010]

Nice work, very interesting to see

[@SceneComparisons]

thanks! :)

[@bradleynathaniel-thomas]

Great work👍

[@SceneComparisons]

thanks :)

[@Darren79]

The scene is finished in the original and the AAISAT reconstruction is half way through - they're so laboured and don't do justice to the original performers! (But it was fun in context of the docudrama)

[@AndrewChapman]

I'm taking in the "An Unearthly Child" bits as they've now been edited/removed from the 60th anniversary re-release cuz of this whole copyright issue with Stef Coburn. Like when they're rehearsing scenes, uttering dialogue while recording the first episode and Sydney Newman viewing the serial.

[@fsfx1239]

This video is like that Rick and Morty scene where there are multiple time streams playing at the same time! Trippy AF

[@Grelipe]

Why does this keep being reposted? I don't get it.

[@SceneComparisons]

Filipe Freitas sorry but I found 2 new footages after I uploaded the videos so I updated. the video is now more complete and better 😉

[@Grelipe]

Dimitri Bitu Alright makes sense I guess

[@ProjectFlashlight612]

Unbelievably confusing to have audio streams running at once like this (a cacophonous babble) and thus completely counter-productive to the aim in mind.

[@SceneComparisons]

the idea is to compare at the same time, so it's the only way to have the audios playing at the same time

[@clormp2375]

My headphones sound came out of one ear I could only hear the classics when both come out I can hear both

[@blick847]

This feels like A Rickle In Time

[@SceneComparisons]

this one looks more kzbin.info/www/bejne/p56se2mDmbCkl6c :)

[@finnsempire5671]

dimitreze I'm the very first real life incarnation of the world famous doctor who

[@blastfromthepast8344]

Fascinating stuff. But it messes with your head a bit after a while...

[@LauraSeabrook]

This is so weird to watch, but brilliant!

[@doctorwhoproductions834]

I wish in an adventure in space and time they showed how they did the regeneration I would of love to of seen that

[@stormyjlb]

David Bradley was MEANT for this role!

[@williamhickey3903]

amazing

[@SceneComparisons]

thanks :)

[@williamhickey3903]

your welcome and enjoy scene comparison

[@jgdeleon1983]

Will you do The Room vs. The Disaster Artist?

[@SceneComparisons]

there you go kzbin.info/www/bejne/bIvHk5hmhrNlh8k

[@DravenGal]

Why is this making me tear up?

[@WilliamZeebub]

Charley, I never knew that, only that Ian was the car park attendant

[@johnlarro6872]

My thoughts on Bradley playing Hartnell were, and remain, that he is a great Hartnell, but a lousy First Doctor. The "recreation" scenes show this well - there's none of Hartnell's spark in them at all.

[@tomattah_]

Quite astonishing.

[@gohanmoreno7]

Wait wait wait, my DVD copy didn't have the regeneration scene, WTH?!

[@SceneComparisons]

they released some things on the BBC youtube channel ;)

[@LaurenceReeves]

No one else tripped out by how alike they all are? I got confused on what was what st some points!

[@SuperSymbiote1]

He said "we have no drugs". haha

[@MrPaulmorris7777]

Bradley didn't do the "one day" speech very well.

[@Silverwind87]

GAH! TOO MUCH DAVID BRADLEY AND WILLIAM HARTNELL TALKING OVER EACH OTHER!

[@mahfuzurchowdhury2765]

I was on your Charlie Chaplin video, and noticed someone asked you to make this, even though you'd never watched the show. After making this, have you?

[@SceneComparisons]

No. I have a thing that if start any franchise, I have to watch and know everything (like I know everything about Star Wars, Lord of the Rings, etc). And Doctor Who is too much for me. Same reason I never watched any Star Trek. Maybe in the future. :)

[@mahfuzurchowdhury2765]

dimitreze, the thing with Doctor Who is, that you can start Doctor Who with Series 1 back in 2005. It introduces you to everything you need to know. I've never needed to watch anything before.

[@SceneComparisons]

I get it but I could never do that. Hahaha. 😃😃😃

[@nakyer]

Never realized the movie got Susan's clothes wrong.

[@vdesatch6273]

nakyer They didn't, he isn't showing the right episode. He's showing the unaired pilot, where Susan wore different, more alien clothes. If you compare the reconstruction with the pilot, it's spot on.

[@AndrewChapman]

Love it.

[@karentaylor8006]

dead on!

[@justinthibault1101]

Why don’t they make a special edition colorize the black and white would look very cool❤

[@AndrewChapman]

They colourised "The Daleks" and aired it for the 60th anniversary. Though they also condensed it down to 75 mins.

[@katie2940]

Quick! Check the fornicator!

[@2rrkd]

I just can't help thinking the guy who's playing William Russell has got a huge forehead.

[@josephmay6377]

the original is still the best

[@vdesatch6273]

Joseph May That would imply that Time and Space is a remake or re-enactment, when it's actually a docudrama.

[@LY2030.]

my left ear

[@SceneComparisons]

the movie on the left channel and doctor who is on the right channel

[@tesstickle7267]

so the 1st doctor will be the 13th? not the same actor of course just the one playing the 1st

[@RaphaelWiggum]

Nah, Bradley is just playing the first Doctor. For real this time.

[@ilovedoctorwho8357]

He never came back for Susan

[@jwg5774]

Sure he did. His Eighth incarnation interacts with Susan three times in Big Finish audios - An Earthly Child, Relative Dimensions, and the two part Lucie Miller/To the Death.

[@HPGamingReal]

aw man im confused o-O

[@musterhere]

That‘s where I get Sasha Dhawan as the Master

[@therestorationofdrwho1865]

Are they out of sync?

[@AndrewChapman]

Recreating moments from the 60s and trying to get them exactly in sync with the original footage is merely impossible.

[@thefabledknight]

wait sacha dhawan now plays the master david bradley plays the 1st doctor now, if that isn't timey wimey....