Does Waterproof Makeup ACTUALLY Work? | Style Theory

[@florenceherson9252]

Matpat coming back to dump buckets of water on his employees is iconic

[@NA-Per]

😂

[@AstrologyRenee]

Yes I wish he made little appearances in more videos tho

[@spacerangeredits]

lol

[@MarineTeen]

@@AstrologyRenee yes, I would also like it as well since he still feels like part of the theory company as a whole and not someone who just does GTL.

[@ItisJasmine27]

😅

[@igorlopes8463]

1)New idea for Film Theroy: why do ppl watch sad movies? 2)MatPat coming back to dunk water on Amy was hilarious

[@maironamakesstuff]

I like that idea!

[@turtle1658]

because it's fun to be sad. it's not that deep

[@__Obscure__]

Welcome back to Film "Theroy" with our host Leroy

[@rachie._mi8998]

​@@turtle1658 I feel like no. My mum works in palliative and refuses to watch most things sad. She has to know the genre and if it's bittersweet or sad, she's not watching it

[@kitcat8308]

Or to get tears going when you're already feeling down but can't seem to cry😅

[@ramsessiereveld2824]

Ash forcing Amy to watch the dog die while laughing about the whole situation is just **chef's kiss**

[@maironamakesstuff]

Watching Amy cry over that sweet pupper almost made me cry! 😭

[@ItisJasmine27]

It also made me cry 😅

[@Ace-me7rq]

​@@maironamakesstuff it was the kind of stuff that one could apply the following sentence to: "When something sad enough happens, even the devil may cry" - Trish, I think

[@Valorian6167]

I was balling

[@charleslee8313]

It could have been UP, or the last 5 minutes of Coco, but Marley & Me... wow.

[@srslyawkward3095]

I love how y'all are, like, "MatPat came back," like this wasn't in his literal back yard. 😂😂😂

[@witchy90210]

Its not often you see the CEO of a company doing actual work.

[@vaderkid]

@@witchy90210 But this is MatPat

[@srslyawkward3095]

@@vaderkid for real. MatPat cares too much about the Theorist Universe to be a hands-off boss, even in retirement.

[@DdaengEli]

I know right! 😂😂😂

[@asinglesliceofbread8198]

Realizing MatPat remained in GT Not Live ™️ negated any sort of sadness

[@Defektyd]

Matpat's retired and he's not letting anyone forget that with that throw. That throw was as cold as Amy most likely was afterwards.

[@icyflame716]

Ash bonking Amy with the bucket had my crying from laughter on the floor.

[@ResaChiic]

Falling in afterwards was the cherry on top xD

[@saozinha2000]

I was at that moment in the video, and immediately went to check the comments. I needed someone to laugh about this as well xD

[@leahluostarinen]

Who's Ash?

[@icyflame716]

@@leahluostarinen the person normally behind the camera on GT live but now assisting in throwing buckets of water at Amy. They introduced Ash at the start of the video.

[@RajikaAjit]

😂

[@avelynn.li.2]

Love the fact the matpat came back to aggressively throw water onto his employees

[@JeanMckitrick]

Fr

[@RajikaAjit]

Frr

[@Igel.3]

Frrr

[@How-Do-I-Nezzy]

More than that, he invited them over to his house from the West Coast to aggressively throw water on them.

[@raratigris]

Ash hitting Amy with the bucket had my dying of laughter 😂😂😂

[@ttaIIer]

I know that was VIOLENT

[@denikalocke5414]

Thank god I’m home alone, I screamed at midnight😂

[@TheDwagons]

SAME!!!!

[@RajikaAjit]

😂

[@kimberlieroseberry]

Saaaaame! Had me testing the makeup vs tears theory right here at home! 😂

[@misoki3514]

14:13 "OMG ARE YOU SORRY- I'M SORRY" killed me 😭😭

[@litjell]

might be the classic "are you okay?" and "I'm sorry" mix up, and the fall in the pool is just a cherry on top, it's so hilarious🤣

[@slepingmahicapet3919]

The way Amy cried to Marley and me instead of going the easy way and putting fake tears is so funny💀all for the results

[@KaitLynnHt]

I won't call it funny for personal reasons, but I definitely would have been using my eye drops instead.

[@faizahmohammedaruwa]

Ash accidentally assaulting Amy with that bucket bonk has me legit gasping for air 😆😂🤣

[@ghostmistwho]

I would love for there to be a follow up episode where Amy gets to interview professional mermaids for their favorite waterproof brands and products

[@Nam3l3ssAnami]

That would be iconic 😩👌

[@SouthernArtist-gi8gr]

Seriously we need that!

[@BlueAnalogGaming]

Its nice too see Mat Pat around in some videos!

[@NA-Per]

Same😊

[@leahluostarinen]

Yes he is

[@mandalynfeesh]

Definitely why i clicked on this one

[@SingingSealRiana]

Given they are technically around him as in his back yard...

[@pradeepmalar327]

Ash: "How excited are you?" Amy: The most intense breathe in to talk I've ever listened to😂

[@Pretzelfriend]

“It’s waterproof” famous last words

[@Heartrose7]

*Titanic grumbles in agreement*

[@NA-Per]

@@Heartrose7😂

[@Azerinth]

"it's ____proof" more generalized last words.

[@Pretzelfriend]

@@Azerinthyeah that’s really true

[@CarlyanimationsYT]

Fr

[@Gryffindor_girly23]

AMAZING that Matpat came around to dump water on his employees. What a very theorist thing to do.

[@EmpressCirce]

NYX waterproof eyeliner - I've literally gone to shower, washed my hair, rubbed it hard and it wasn't even smudged when I got out.

[@TheGrossDemon]

✍️🏾✍️🏾✍️🏾 right gotta pick some of that up

[@hollyschmidt9316]

I second this. I was on the swim team in high school and it didn’t even come off during practice

[@No1WasHere7]

I wrote a note on my arm with it as a test, lasted for several days with a few showers.

[@Caranig]

I discovered the hard way that it only comes off with makeup remover. That stuff is amazing.

[@cs1261]

Which one of them?🤞🏼🤞🏼

[@nataliag6885]

I would love to see this replicated but with water resistant makeup, like, what makes it water resistant and not waterproof? How does it hold up in comparison? It would also be fun to see if setting powders or setting sprays make a difference

[@mia_maggie6844]

Matt coming back just to dump water on Amy is just the best😂

[@leahluostarinen]

And it was funny to 🤣

[@mia_maggie6844]

@@leahluostarinen Fr 🤣

[@Rammbob]

The Ash & Amy footage is just ultimately funny. :D I expected it to be educational only, but this makes it so much better - nice bucket technique Ash, no one saw that one coming.

[@catl1v3r]

THAT THROW MATPAT😭

[@StaryIris]

WILL WOOD TSHIRT!!!!! IT SPOOKED ME, I DIDNT EXPECT IT!!

[@luminous_spores]

WW jumpscare

[@vsnowball4745]

i knew they had one just hadn't seen it yet!

[@epicminipekka251]

SOMEONE ELSE NOTICED IT TOO!! 🐁🌕

[@limediamond4595]

WILL WOOD FANS SPOTTED RAAAHHHH

[@chxrillz]

I CAME FOR THIS TOP YAYYY🐁🌕

[@uhkuh1]

MATPAT İS A SAVAGE FOR THAT WATER THROW

[@VenomVenomX]

Exactly 💯

[@NA-Per]

Definitely 💯

[@Ztime_Live]

FR 💯

[@serpent_tail]

FRRR🤣

[@espeon030]

Yeah💯

[@regurgitationsample]

"I think you need to cry a little bit more" -Ash, while giggling at Amy crying about a dying dog

[@Hayatonyaaa]

I have to wonder if sweat will affect the makeup differently than regular water. That's the real moisture I experience most in the summer.

[@mackenziej8980]

Mat had no mercy with the water.

[@johnyesjustjohn]

It’s like I can still hear Matpat’s voice… and feel him dump buckets of water on his employees…

[@Irreverent_Radiation]

Mat: "I'm not dead!" Theorists: "Ah... it's like he's still here with us..."

[@piemseml6206]

not Ash cassualy wearing a Will Wood t-shirt and thought I wouldn't notice. I wish I had one too

[@vaeschwartz2482]

Part two! Testing diffrent water proof brands expensive vs drugstore

[@julietaromero6082]

Omg yessss!!!!!

[@DustyRed7]

This!!!

[@xipler]

I literally just thought "huh haven't seen style theory in a while" and then they uploaded a video! Lovely timing!

[@serpent_tail]

Bro really hit you with the you though wrong lol

[@Blahydra]

The muffled OH N- when mat expertly throws water, priceless.

[@darkcloak100]

Can we talk about trends and what style each decade has and why?

[@mxrsbxrs]

YES PLEASE ❤

[@alysonespina2748]

LOVE THIS IDEA 💡‼️

[@someonenotsomeone8450]

This would take way more than just one theory. It would have to be an ongoing series It's also been done by a lot of other historical style KZbinrs, and I highly recommend checking them out!!

[@agirlcalledlaila]

thissss

[@natalieching7930]

PLEASE i need this type of testing but with setting spray

[@stellanovaluna]

I love that Ash is being featured so much more often they’re so cool Also YAY MATPAT CAMEO but tbh Amy is a fantastic replacement. She’s more than just a replacement, actually. She’s carved out her own identity while still channeling a lil bit of that Mathew Pathew energy and I LOVE it

[@GravityDontMeanTooMuchTooMe]

Her being a fan of my fav band makes her so much better!!! I 💙 Gerard Way! And MCR in general. I was barely even alive when Black Parade album released 😭😭😭😭

[@dragonli1y]

I love that you call the ocean “fish water”

[@teatea123]

You showed the Marley and Me scene and now I'm crying at work. That movie is the bane of my existence.

[@Ztime_Live]

love how matpat came back to drown his employees, welcome back matthew 😭

[@LadyLocket]

Tears and rain, they are the two ‘waters’ most likely to break down my waterproof makeup fastest. Also as a very oily-skinned person, I know that nothing waterproof works as my oil breaks it down quickly. I've switched to bobby brown gel eyeliner and Kevin Aucoin tubing mascara which seems to work better for me.

[@shannonbalthazor8712]

I am also very oily skinned - my face oils melt make-up off my face. But- I will say if I use the Nars eyeshadow primer it holds beautifully - even swimming and sweating all day.

[@Bardic_Knowledge]

I was already crying before watching this because of a video wherein a beloved character from a game dies, and then you show a movie I've never seen but still punched me in the already bruised feels.

[@Tubradi8tions]

MATPAT IN STYLE THEORY?!

[@digbyanderson5556]

LETS GOOO WILL WOOD FAN SPOTTED

[@crimsonmoonrise9785]

The dog dies alternatives,allergies,onions,pepper spray,or watch a movie so funny to shed tears of joy.

[@monstersociety3360]

I feel like pepper spray would be wet enough to make the mascara run regardless of tears

[@silvermoon6175]

How is pepper spray supposed to be a better experience than sad movies???? That stuff lingers.

[@noramorad560]

Ngl Amy explained osmosis better than most and potentially all of my science teachers.

[@macsnafu]

She gets it, she really gets it. Rarely have I seen anyone who throws themselves so thoroughly into testing their ideas like this!

[@MUSASHIINUNU]

Amy's dedication is truly wonderful

[@M1KK1101]

“I love a learning experience” So do I:3

[@serpent_tail]

I too love learning experience 😂

[@Retro_Creations]

“This is a channel where you learn a lot things” -Ash 2024

[@serpent_tail]

@@Retro_Creations ash is so bases

[@lillukoita]

Ash has a Will Wood shirt!?:OO

[@Ph1syc]

william is everywhere

[@Asteroids.are.edible]

I NOTICED TOO 🔥🔥

[@alexisrich7285]

THE WILL WOOD SHIRT ILY

[@JynxieTheMermaid]

You need Ben Nye setting spray. That makes makeup stay so we'll I went scuba diving and nothing moved. The secret all mermaid performers have.

[@EnbyGaemer2005]

Ben Nye makes the best stuff for your face.

[@emilsmadvlogs5879]

The slay✨ brother of Bill Nye the science guy

[@Giselle.829]

Tell me why I read that as BILL Nye 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@-.aluvre]

@@Giselle.829 same

[@downside8204]

ASH‘S WILL WOOD SHIRT, OH MY GOD

[@sammy_slammy]

The adorable little deep inhale when asked how excited Amy is about water slides. It's a magical experience we all can relate to, I think. Our inner child being reborn.

[@afimoons]

OMGGG i love the Will Wood shirt that Ash is wearing!!!!

[@-bee-2187]

Loving Ash's Will Wood shirt.

[@BTS_ot7_Potterhead_ARMY]

MATPAT?? 0:12

[@SingingSealRiana]

You know he did not die right?!

[@tom-on]

No way, Ash has a Will Wood T-Shirt???? (14:23)

[@krisgomez3997]

ASH!!!! LMFAO. From the first whiff I knew in my CORE that Amy was gonna get nailed in the face with that bucket. God the memories of my friends and I being stupid on summer break all came flooding (pun intended) back. I'm still laughing XD

[@ForestRaptor]

Loving Amy using the channel's resource to go back to waterslides :3

[@Shadowreaper5]

ok I'm pausing around 15:19 to put in my guess. I expect that the issue is that the salt water dries out your skin and since the water is what's lifting up and carrying the makeup away, it is sticking better(and later the chlorinated water will do this too). Locking in my guess now.

[@Shadowreaper5]

ok I was sorta kinda right

[@aditigunjal4231]

1:23 Ok but that is the most symmetric eyeliner I've ever seen. We need the tutorial Amy!

[@secretman796]

Inside out 1 is my equivalent to Amy's Marley and Me. I can't watch inside out 1 without bursting into tears 😢

[@Giselle.829]

Mine is the Bluey Special, The Sign. That ending kills me! 😭

[@AshyBoi1705]

me but with the fallout- i can't watch it without crying at some point

[@trustindean5164]

my favorite type of style theory video is ones with actual scientific experimentation and this really proves exactly why. Like thats an actually fascinating conclusion to come from this and on top of that the whole process was very fun to watch

[@justineberlein5916]

Sometimes I can still hear MatPat's voice...

[@sniper441]

This video was amazing and Amy is such an incredible host, she keeps me coming back to this channel each week.

[@rosettesionne9139]

If I was in Amy's place, I would have never watched a sad movie (I would have cried for days) I would have cut a bunch of onions, it would have given me the same effect minus the emotional trauma

[@Spamtonontheinternet]

Matpat coming back just to throw water at his employees is literally reminding us why he’s so iconic. I was not expecting his voice.

[@jackson_terrance]

I got SO excited when I saw Ash in a Will Wood shirt ❤

[@wv1seahawks]

I think something Steve Mould mentioned in his latest video might be at play too. Water dissolves water-based products because they are both polar. But when you introduce salt with chloride ions with high electronegativity, the polar water is very attracted to them. So the polar water molecules are too strongly pulled on by the chloride to be able to interact with the polar makeup in this case.

[@Naiadryade]

The way that just watching a video about someone watching a movie where the dog dies, almost makes ME cry...

[@Lili-lovejoy28]

Matpat coming back just to throw water on amy was so perfect

[@sodathejunker]

Ash hitting Amy with the entire bucket and literally no water was crazy That said, always love when trying to prove a theory leads into learning a brand new theory. Great episode

[@HaydenTheQueer]

I will absolutely, 100%, never in my life be over ash wearing a Will Wood shirt. My fav liking my other fav enough to have his merch? I’m crying

[@kayleelombardi1930]

I love watching style theory

[@The_AroAce_Therian_36912]

I love that Ash had a Will Wood shirt 14:28

[@Navillea]

And when the world needed him most, MatPat came back to dunk water on his employees

[@redjules1215]

I don't wear makeup and still found this very interesting. The explanation at the end was great and well done. Amy's killing it.

[@milkshakebananaz]

I appreciate the Jenna shout out. This whole video gives elevated Jenna

[@erikaflowers6055]

This is my favorite Amy style theory episode. Loved it Amy!

[@kysostudios7624]

14:23 will wood t-shirt 🗣️☝️

[@malpracticeoffices3622]

This makes me think we're gonna see MattPatt in Style Theory more often then the other series. Throwing his cut out into Game or Film theory is one thing, but having him 'on set' for Food and Style Theory means he'd be trying food/recipes and splashing Amy and maybe doing some other style stuff since he took such a big passion on his own style before leaving Style Theory

[@miriamchmiel]

SLAY MATPAT JUST DUMPING BUCKETS OF WATER

[@jimnicholls5215]

Ash wearing a Will Wood shirt is pretty friggin dope

[@Iatrites]

Loved this episode :D I learned about water potential in AP Bio this year so it was cool to see how it's applicable in reall life. seeing Ash's Will wood shirt was also really cool.

[@-LiterallyEverything-]

matpat coming back for this simple reason is wonderful

[@SpeedDemonStar]

You should do a sequel testing different brands of waterproof makeup vs waterproof setting spray over regular makeup!

[@epicminipekka251]

I did not expect to ever see Will Wood in a style theory episode, yet Ash surprised me 🥲

[@ellishotomani1462]

Way to go, Amy! I appreciate your dedication to the cause!

[@mxrsbxrs]

THE FACT AMY IS THE ONLY GIRL I KNOW THAT WOULD CRY IN FRONT OF A CAMERA (u are so brave we love you amy) ❤❤❤

[@roxannology]

This has quickly become my favorite episode of Style Theory ever!! MatPat's water dumps and poor poor Amy getting hit in the head by Ash made my day!!!😭😭

[@ThomasBarrettMusic]

Ash is a being of chaos in this episode 😂😂 making Amy watch the whole movie, hitting Amy with the bucket 😂 poor Amy

[@addie8720]

WE LOVE HOW ASH IS WEARING A WILL WOOD SHIRT

[@huniebunny]

Reminds me of that post where historians and architects couldn't figure out why ancient roman and greek bricks wouldn't corrode against sea water. turns out the recipe to make those bricks included sea water.

[@lonely-lee]

can we talk about amy's eyeliner? it's always ALWAYS on fleek.

[@-.aluvre]

Haven’t heard “on fleek” in ages

[@GoldieDrawsStuff]

i really love ash wearing the will wood in case i make it shirt

[@LaurelChastain]

My answer to the title of the video: Yes, yes it does, at least my mascara does, it works great, and I ain't no gatekeeper so it's called: "Liquid eyelash extensions mascara, ibcccnda mascara" Looks great, it's a bit hard to get off though, but a decent makeup remover will do the trick. The brush that comes with it kinda sucks though so I use the disposable ones

[@julietaromero6082]

Does it work when u go underwater and swim around for a while?

[@tuesi]

THE WILL WOOD SHIRT OMG

[@creedhaymond1939]

Amy, you’re doing awesome on this channel! All the theory channels are still so amazing and their new hosts are doing so well! Keep it up folks 🤘🏽

[@justaenderman985]

ASH IS A WILL WOOD FAN??? I JUST SAW THE SHIRT OMG

[@yoXneo]

"You're sorry but you're laughing!!!" 😭😂

[@ari.sacchies]

ASH WITH THE WILL WOOD SHIRT ! !

[@tonka4201]

This was one of the funniest episodes ever, i think i ruined my makeup laughing, I shouldve worn water-proof makeup! (btw, very happy about ahses will wood shirt)