REBUTTAL WITNESS: Fremont Co. Sheriff Det. Bruce Mattingly testifies in Chad Daybell trial

#eastidahonews #daybell #truecrime
Fremont Co. Sheriff Det. Bruce Mattingly was called as a rebuttal witness and testified in the Chad Daybell trial. Here is his testimony from May 23, 2024.
Watch in the video player above.
► Support East Idaho News: www.eastidahon...
► Subscribe to East Idaho News: www.youtube.co...
► Get East Idaho News merch: www.eastidahon...
► Download our free app: marketplace-red...
► Like us on Facebook: / eastidahonews
► Follow us on X: / eastidnews
► Follow us on Instagram: / eastidahonews
► Subscribe to our free newsletter: www.eastidahon...

[@gabitrindade4607]

How sad a daughter sides with her murderer dad…

[@gulliver7419]

Maybe it was too traumatic for her to believe that her own father could do such a heinous thing.

[@aimeefriedman822]

It blows me away that she showed NO emotion towards the horrendous murders of children, that she's living in a home where murdered people were found and not even a tear about her mom. I hope she reads the tens of thousands of comments about her disgraceful behavior and gets thrown out of her church and community.

[@christiemoore232]

It's textbook response. Deny, defend, repeat.

[@horsehaircreationsbykaren]

​@@gulliver7419my children were raised with the wherewithal to completely abhor the murder of innocent children under any circumstances, as most normal people are. I might, might sympathize if a parent murders another parent, but when murders of children are involved, ALL BETS ARE OFF!!!

[@aimeefriedman822]

@@comparedtowhat2719 oh I'm agreeing with you for sure

[@bobbicatt]

Of course Emma didn’t want anyone to see her fake reaction when she learned her mother was murdered and didn’t die of natural causes. The amount of lies Emma told under oath is staggering, She made Tami out to be a woman who was so sickly she barely made it through each day.i know know why all the Daybell Kids turned a cold shoulder to all of Tami’s family .

[@Ronin4614]

John Prior: “ Judge, I’m going to object ….(stupid reason)….. Judge: “Overruled”. 🤣🤣

[@GirlLearningTheWorld]

Wow, Does Attorney Pryor not realize we can see right through his questioning he is providing to the detective and the jury?

[@geniemememe5936]

I would not want Emma to be anywhere near my child. Especially after watching her on the witness stand. A "religious woman" swore an oath, and absolutely misrepresented facts and situations ( lied in front of America and her God). Also, her dad "sees dead people" and murders his mistresses' kids and buries them in his back yard, while he lies to his eventually murdered wife. Too many icky things happen around this family.

[@LindaD-s1b]

SHE committed perjury

[@LindaD-s1b]

EMMILY had said she did not want her mother's results it is sus to me imo

[@annettelacey7913]

​@user-qz6xk4ro8o It's suss to me Emma didn't want to know too,What if it was genetic, does she care if she can just die for no reason in her late 40s, she is a mother,I'm so angry the way Emma,Garth & Joe lied on the stand, it shouldn't be allowed to slip just because there relationship to the defendant, It's disgusting, Poor Tammy,

[@giorgismama8024]

Liar, liar, pants on fire, Emma! What a horrible Mormon you are! Everything you have said in trial is LIES!

[@HeidiSue60]

I wonder if charges of perjury will be brought.

[@WolvesinFrance]

​@@HeidiSue60Let's hope so 🙏💕

[@iveliserojas612]

Who don’t want to see how mom died she so evil

[@susanna8612]

Just like her father. They are totally emotionless and seperated themselves from reality

[@patgal2359]

So what if they didnt tell her or when. If theres a suspicion of murder, why would you notify the suspects family in advance

[@CWRTalentPassitOn]

These are not CHILDREN! These are adults. Emma is a married WOMAN with children of her own. She is not a little girl, as much as sticking her tongue out at people implies that. When he handed Emma the victim’s help numbers, she seemed to be surprised. She knows she’s not a victim here. Something is wrong.

[@merandaingram4295]

Emma also made all those faces at that reporter while she was trying to do her segment on the case.

[@bobbicatt]

I never saw that, Do you know if there is video of that now ?

[@merandaingram4295]

@@bobbicatt a murderous heart put it out about 9 days ago

[@bobbicatt]

@@merandaingram4295 Thanks 🙏! I haven't seen it yet but sounds very immature.

[@bobbicatt]

@therealz360z7 I’m still wrapping my head around the fact she’s a school teacher. I did see that video and WTF? Who does that knowing it’s going to be national news. She’s a strange cookie so is her husband. Now we know they are both liars.

[@Marilynn-minoux]

I saw that video.. omg, I was appalled. What a toddler 🙄

[@LoriArmstrong-l1i]

I think after all this is done. Many will always remember Tylee,JJ,Tammy,and CV. Those family and those who gave hours of service to justice. I pray

[@muthaship2992]

Chad shouldn’t of wasted his home to John Pryor for his defense, he was right when he told Emma he wasn’t ever coming back to it

[@Lifewithpersians]

Prior asking the detective or trying to blast him for making light of Tammys passing but yet no-one has made more light of it than Emma. So disgusting! It's also not their job to chase the family for autopsy results. The police said they had reached out several times.

[@JudiT55]

I hope that these people who swore to tell the truth, and have been proven to have committed perjury will be held accountable for their decisions. If the police had paid attention to CHARLES VALLOW, and held Lori Daybell accountable for her actions, none of this would have happened. I hope the prosecutors and judge will learn from these mistakes and not ignore these adult children lying. Who knows what they could be capable of in the future.

[@TorisGotAStory]

This is a murder investigation- why does it matter if the families informed or not? I’m not saying it was right or wrong. I’m saying - what does it prove? Other than he’s trying to make the jury feel bad for the family.

[@sim-b]

He clutching at straws - that’s all he got

[@TorisGotAStory]

@@sim-b very true! I just can’t comprehend what he thinks he’s trying to do. When this is all done, his career is over bc who would hire him w his tactics?

[@annettelacey7913]

Emma does not care,She knows how her mother died they all do, Who acts like this to police that are trying to solve the murder of children & the investergation of what happened to her mother,Poor tammy would be heart broken if she knew how her own 5 kids turned on her after her death,There is something very wrong with chads kuds & given all there beliefs shouldnt be school teachers,i think they shouldnt even be around there own kids,There dangerous,They admit to believe in what there father believes in,Shes running around looking like a mini lori since her mum died, That is very strange youd try look like your fathers lover,wife all the samething with lori,hohn prior is so rude

[@happycamper4ever873]

I think the kids turned on Tammy before her death. Chad devalued her, and so did they.

[@catherineseiler7407]

Emma is just going to have to face the facts, it is proven Tammy was murdered by her very own father, asphyxiated

[@margiemarion9437]

Chad is a bad father encouraging his grown daughter to commit perjury. Cold-hearted!

[@billyje4726]

That is called narcissism, grandiosity and sociopathy at its best!

[@PaulaWoerner-ck6gr]

Ms Blake Excellent Job!!! Proves Emma lied….

[@susancoy3096]

Why is it a big deal if family not told about exhumation? Especially with the circumstances. And what is the big deal about the police trying to inform family of autopsy findings? The police tried and family didn't appear to want the info. That wasn't the PD's fault. Prior keeps bringing it up.

[@sherryjenkins5129]

It's frightening that these kids probably believe in their father's cult mission

[@aimeefriedman822]

Gotta say, I wouldn't have let ANYONE off Subpoena protocols in this case. That's one thing I've been questioning about the Prosecution from the beginning of this case. How were they to predict who would be important to call back, ESPECIALLY law enforcement.

[@MsCicie1408]

Chode has been “hugging” himself for comfort. Nervous much?

[@beckylynn209]

SOOO WEIRD, RIGHT?? Why us she practically running from the reason their mom died?! It must have looked stange to LE.. 🤔

[@OnlySpoilers]

The hardest day of this trial so far, was to hear the robotic, rehearsed and monotone answers of Emma. The only emotion was the contempt and bitterness towards prosecution and law enforcement! Emma even had contempt for her dead MOTHER! All in a pathetic and futile attempt to defend her dad. Wonder if she will one day see what her dad has done, and she and her husband will be haunted by their words and actions throughout the proceedings!

[@PaulaWoerner-ck6gr]

Mr Prior please find a new interrupting line, you’ve worn that one out😂😂😂….

[@nrussell7625]

The body language of Pryor and Chad has been so interesting the last few days

[@susanna8612]

I havent seen any difference about Chad's body language. He allways just sit there totally motionless and emotionless and listens like he would be just some kind of outsider in audience.

[@cglenn1457]

@@susanna8612 he holds his nose and chin up in defiance, is what I have noticed.

[@904daniela]

I have (had) a best friend who died unexpectedly. I'm going crazy not knowing what happened - nothing released by the M.E. yet. ... and this is my friend - not my MOTHER. Smh.

[@NancyDrew1]

That’s a natural reaction when you love someone. Hope you find out soon and everything is ok!

[@904daniela]

@@NancyDrew1 Well, nothing will be ok at this point, but I can't understand why some people don't want to know.

[@waywardangel6356]

I know exactly how you feel! I'm in the same boat. We are still waiting for the release of her autopsy. All I know it was "sudden" death.

[@PaulaWoerner-ck6gr]

Mr Prior the officer’s don’t have the time to chase people down!!!! It’s up to the family Mr Prior…. And look at who your talking to…. It just shows your intelligence…

[@WolvesinFrance]

I'm wondering why they dropped Josh Garner, anyone know why?

[@marycaine8623]

Prior just acted like a total jerk in that performance

[@maxhill5197]

Is the Emma Murray @ Kershaw Intermediate School Chad's daughter? Surely she is not still teaching???

[@sim-b]

I believe she is 😮

[@sim-b]

She lacks empathy and thinks like chad light & dark - she should be no where near children - they will get rid of her now I’m certain

[@tammarrafoote5917]

Thank God he got caught before he turned into Charles Manson. Then

[@shannonricci2785]

How freaking weird Emma’s acting on that recording! Holy Mother of God I lack any understanding

[@skyleawood2649]

Complicit. 😈

[@PaulaWoerner-ck6gr]

Ms Blake got it in didn’t she Mr Prior 😂😂….

[@jamesmckay9966]

IT IS PROBABLY TOO LATE NOW BUT SOME OF THE SOUND IS UN BELIEVEABLY BAD.

[@christiemoore232]

Ok, who else thinks Chad has a larger cult than we've witnessed.? Beginning to think that it began within his immediate family...Tammy and kids...bet they all know about light/dark tomfoolery. Also thinking now that Chad may have a dark history like Lori.

[@tammarrafoote5917]

This is 100% RABBIT HOLE...

[@rundogrun297]

Not sidin with Emma however she told the police what they had decided to do and he should have quit bothering them at that. NO WONDER she did not want to talk with him as he does not know when to stop talking to her.

[@catherineseiler7407]

The police reached out to her several times, Emma ignored them. He went to meet her at the school once, how were they bothering her? Who wouldn’t want to know how their mother died? He told her no questions, weird family

[@Diggs4Dogs]

I don’t believe Emma was in on this. She has major trauma going on here. She didn’t trust the police. For good reason. She trusts her dad….when experiencing trauma you feel like chaos is in your brain. You forget things; you distrust people. Especially if her father is manipulating her. It’s got to be a horrible experience she’s going through.

[@iveliserojas612]

Really she don’t trust police beyond dad and husband u dum if that mom I would like how she died u sound dum if it my mom I live to how she died her and her are believed Chad that he’s being set up dummy

[@tigerseye99p]

That does not justify her dishonesty on the stand!!!!!!

[@lilg2300]

For good reason? Which good reason??

[@gulliver7419]

@@tigerseye99p Maybe she NEEDS to believe her father is innocent,. She has lost her mother and there is a good chance her father is going to be put to death, have some compassion for these children, they have been through hell.

[@rosierosie62]

She did not trust the police for good reason? Because they has the audacity to dig up her Dad´s back yard and drove by the property during day light hours? Or that the officer was very kind when he approached her to explain the autopsy results? Emma got a lot of issues, the police did not cause that, she can thank her criminal delusional father for that. My guess is that her issues go even deeper, again, Chad might be the cause ´. As he clearly stated " My kids can keep secrets" Draw your own conclusions.

[@justkiddin84]

Hey folks! Some True Crime folks are suggesting we all go get a burger for Tammy the day this monster is convicted. Maybe one of the stores in Boise would host it there. I tried corporate, but they only take ideas from within. But a local restaurant might participate. Just an idea. But we can at least do the thing! ♥️✌️🩷🩵💜

[@NancyDrew1]

I don’t live close but I’ll be getting a burger here in Bellingham Wa! Great idea!

[@Ronin4614]

John Prior: “ Judge, I’m going to object ….(stupid reason)….. Judge: “Overruled”. 🤣🤣

[@ChaiChai1965]

He often forgets to state the grounds he is objecting on and is also commonly untimely. 😅

[@kaybrown4010]

I would hate to be John Prior right now. He’s rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic and he knows it.

[@kaybrown4010]

I would hate to be John Prior right now. He’s rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic and he knows it.