ENTERPRISE vs STAR DESTROYER! - Space Engineers EPIC BATTLE!

[@pigpig252]

Damn, that saucer separation was beautiful

[@beemy.6923]

Yee

[@mythicthefox1246]

“Feel the power of the dark side, harry” - Gandalf The Grey

[@Syndikris]

Kirk: WARP SPEED AHEAD MR. SULU! Sulu: I'm trying but it's not working. Scotty: SIR, THERE'S A GIANT HOLE IN THE NACELLES AND ONE JUST FELL OFF!

[@gabeking9444]

Admiral ozzle: open fire Random officer: sir! their starting to break apart. Admiral Piet: intensify forward fire power I don't want them escaping Another random officer: SIR! THEY HAVE TAKEN OUT OUR MAIN THRUSTERS admiral Piet: *looks in anger General veers: PIET, WHATS GOING ON! Random officer: SIR INCOMING TORPEDOS Admiral ozzle: HIT THE DECK

[@axolotlgaming3987]

Star trek beyond moment

[@Beamer490]

How the SD crew opened fire: hey just selected “Enterprise” and clicked “delete” on their keyboard

[@jonathonmyles172]

the enterprise got one shot on the sd but without the shields hte enterprise will be mowed down because of the pure power of the turbo lasers

[@leaftail4853]

Fun fact: The only Enterprise that can detach the saucer section was the NCC-1701-D. Under Picard's command. Not being mean, I love your space battles jack and I also love how you spice battles up every now and then. Thank you!

[@CaptainJack]

Well, the Constellation could :)

[@leaftail4853]

Well, yes. Happy new year too!

[@crashkelvinsrandomtrash2012]

+Kuha Cola Judging on the looks of the enterprise it's the JJ Abrams one which shown in ST beyond could seperate their saucers and I saw art of one in the ships if the line book which was based off of original ST.

[@darknyeh553]

Kuha Cola technically other ships could with explosive bolts, but it would require a star base to repair. Whereas the galaxy class could do it alone

[@fenrisvermundr2516]

The Enterprise-E was actually capable of Saucer Separation. It was never utilized though.

[@GavinTheFifer]

Maximize forward fire power! MAXIMUM FIRE POWER!!!!

[@CaptainJack]

Intensify Forward fire power! I SAID INTENSIFY FORWARD FIRE POWER! Too Late * Explosions *

[@superslayer0986]

SIR were making a waffle iron it should destroy them

[@Charahuman213]

@@superslayer0986 XD

[@Bentadeo]

The empire : shoot that piece of junk out of the sky!

[@Syndikris]

Kirk: DAMMIT, AGAIN FOR THE 6TH DAMN TIME MY SHIP GOT REKT!

[@minecat1839]

Is this logical?

[@robinsunbird]

@@minecat1839 ya I think Im not vulcan

[@fernandomarques5166]

**Saucer comes drifting in to collision course** TAKE EVASIVE ACTION! **Star Destroyer klaxon on the background**

[@Syndikris]

Why didn't jack heart this?

[@CaptainJack]

It’s hard for me to see every single comment mate, I do better than most at replying / liking comments.

[@cam_nc3312]

Captain Jack true, you've already replied to 3-4 of my comments.

[@hawkz1271]

Brace For impact!

[@atomicrc5189]

Fernando Marques ***waffle iron has entered the chat***

[@hailstormrising1634]

"Separate the engines from their pylons then disable that saucer!" I believe the admiral of a destroyer would take that plan of action or something along those lines lol

[@xSuperFryx]

Man that's such a good looking Star Destroyer model. The creator really did a good job. From a distance it looks good enough to be in the movie.

[@GusMcGuire]

The problem with any battle involving an ISD is that - in a head-on confrontation - the opposing vessel's AI always seem to target the very tip of the ISD's bow, when the bridge is the more obvious tactical target.

[@minecat1839]

AI is not as logical as Spock or as tactical as Thrawn.

[@P3x310]

Somehow that was one of the most elegant scenes of destruction I have seen in Space Engineers to date. That Swiss-cheeseified saucer section... It also clearly demonstrates how Star Trek ships are one massive structural weakness after another (even though not many sci-fi ships do much better in this regard, see Star Destroyers and their vulnerable bridge).

[@inceptional]

And that's about right. If this were real the Enterprise-D (and that's the one I'd personally go with) would actually target the Star Destroyer's shield generators and take them out in seconds and then it would basically be over.

[@CaptainForsyth]

three ventors vs One star destroyer. SD took out one Ventor. only fair to add more.

[@badproductions769]

Captain Forsyth only 2 venaters

[@CaptainForsyth]

no.

[@ThatOneGuyWhoLostHisHandle]

Epic Troll, he said add “more” not add “1 more.” Did you skip English?

[@ThatOneGuyWhoLostHisHandle]

Epic Troll, Math*

[@bazooka422]

You just want two vaporized venator class star destroyer

[@jasperrey1767]

Wow that's a nice saucer separation

[@awesomemarksyt2659]

Nobody: Jack: *SEPARATES THE ENETERPRISE’S SAUCER.*

[@afonsoamaro247]

Star Wars fan: *sees a star trek drone* Also Star Wars fan: Shoot that piece of junk *out* *of* *the* *sky!*

[@andrewaftontheandroidhedge2780]

i love the smell of blown up trash *sips coffee as the enterprise blows up*

[@minecat1839]

Star Destroyers should not be able to shoot behind themselves.

[@AsrielDreemurYT653]

@@minecat1839 is that a star trek nerd i hear boys?!?!

[@minecat1839]

@@AsrielDreemurYT653 No, just a loyal Imperial who knows the Star Destroyer schematics.

[@connorgolden4]

Could we get another battle in atmosphere? Maybe an imperial class star destroyer vs 2 providence class star destroyer?

[@user-ft3jq5vi2l]

*Providence class dreadnaught (no hate)

[@indycole396]

Weyland Yutani!

[@nephihenry4328]

Wow that distroyer firing full power is a awesome sight

[@JohnSmith-un9fy]

I thought that the final round was a bit more accurate. Enterprise has hellish photon torpedoes.

[@beckonerseven9517]

Yeah Starfleet is overpowered. Photon torpedoes and phasers would eat SDs. SDs don't even have real shields, they have deflectors. The deflectors on the Enterprise are from the navigational dish and are fodder to the full shields they have on top of that. Though I admit that an SD could beat an NX, and the Enterprise refit might lose to a fleet of SDs with Tie Bomber squadrons. 1 on 1, if we're talking TNG or after, it's a wash.

[@juliebradwell7435]

Fitting how the Enterprise slices through the IDS's bridge, seeing how it's basically the universe's largest pizza cutter

[@minecat1839]

And the Star Destroyer is the pizza

[@DarkEva096]

BEST KZbinR FOR SPACE INGENEERS...like if u agree..he even plays halo soundtrack in halo mods

[@xxponyo7332]

“Ingeneers”

[@townrat8283]

Best youtuber for 'space ingeneers' indeed.

[@joshwoznicki2844]

I want to see a Super Star Destroyer in this, that would be AWESOME!!!

[@wadesmalling83]

Firstly, that Enterprise looks fantastic! All that aside, let's give this battle to Photon Torpedos. Lol!

[@ApollosKnights]

First Order Dreadnought Vs Resistance Fleet

[@alexiel4406]

Apollo's Knights that would kill his computer

[@RavenousMemic]

Alexiel Black True

[@meteozek3760]

but still a good idea

[@GavinTheFifer]

The Empire Shall always triumph!

[@VictoryFireStudios]

The torpedoes are just to overpowered!

[@gawdziller1640]

can't wait to see dark helmet in action!

[@juliebradwell7435]

Apparently that Star Destroyer had a shortage of crew members so they let the Stormtroopers take the turrets!

[@OzziBozzi]

*GLORY TO THE EMPIRE*

[@carlosjohnson6121]

I am glad that you guys can be able to do the Starship Enterprise against the Republic Cruiser

[@lexluthorrulerofaustrailia2882]

The Enterprise needed to use more Photon Torpedoes.... **PEW** "PHOTONS AWAY!"

[@jacobflasko33]

Who wants the last Jedi space battle!?!? By the way love ur vids Jack keep it up!

[@not-kate2639]

4:22 thats a little bit of the ol' Beyond right there

[@zackzeed]

Imperial Star Destroyer Wins 8/10 times i would say and i'm even being generous here ^^

[@jtob2831]

Fuck that he didn’t even use his primary weapons he totally nursed his own ship to make it Star Wars friendly I love Star Wars but the enterprise would fuck up the entire Star Wars universe including the death star by it self

[@ghostclawthewarriorcat4877]

@@jtob2831 that was...bullshit. The Enterprise is a lot smaller than the video did show.

[@Bentadeo]

@@jtob2831 bull fuckin shit even the falcon would blow the enterprise up and as the famous kylo said SHOOT THAT PIECE OF JUNK OUT OF THE SKY!

[@Oceanic2409]

Star Trek Samo studios music in the background... I LOVE IT

[@thexsoar]

Ever think of revisiting these battles with the updated game, to see how far it's progressed, or to see if the outcome would be the same?

[@legendary6790]

Star Destroyer, also me thinks that shields in this game are really not powerful enough to accurately display capital ship engagements they just fizzle out and die

[@mikea2363]

That's because a) its a mod b) is designed for being balanced with vanilla weapons, not lasers that go through armor as if it was wet paper.

[@IDPerson-]

As A Star Wars fan I will always say that the SD would win in a fight, but to be fair they are two very different ships that have completely different purposes, and each is better than the other at what it is made for.

[@WhiteWeaseI]

It's a shame the phaser mod is no longer on the workshop. No idea why the author took it down.

[@United-Federation-of-Planets]

MORE STAR TREK VS STAR WARS PLEASE! :D

[@GamesforCykits]

Wow just like in the movie XD love it whoever put that feature on the ship just great job

[@bleach-chan3199]

I know this ship isn't well known ( as well as the series) But the ship Destiny from stargate universe vs the star destroyer (the destiny ship has insane shields and fire power)

[@franknfurterfan666]

Those proton torpedoes are the most busted thing I've ever seen, I kinda want a demolition derby kind of video now of those being fired at various ships and letting them pull them apart!

[@tylerchristensen7434]

Star Destroyer won this one.... although if the Enterprise had used all the weapons available both in film and Space Engineers the Star Destroyer would get destroyed. As we saw in round 3... I think that not using all the weapons available made the fight unfair because the Enterprise is a much more sleek ship and as such is thinner and not as dense, once the shield's go down she's like paper. By design this fight was unfair in my opinion... but oh well great video, Enterprise won this one for me personally but technically Star Destroyer won if we count the weapon limitation on the Enterprise.

[@2vex715]

When I saw the thumbnail of the video I already knew the Star Destroyer would win. Please nerf it, its too OP.

[@BelgianDneprGuy2003]

More fleet and ship vs ship battles!the series is awesome

[@thelordz33]

Yes! You finally did it! Yay!!

[@xxkeemxx9608]

The Enterprise Is like a giant space frisbe connected to giant boosters

[@aghostlyhat]

perhaps 3 Venators or 3 Munificent frigates against one Star Destroyer, no modifications. wonder how it would work out, seeing how much firepower a Star Destroyer can carry

[@pancernywiatrak6368]

this inspires me so much

[@lucasclark1669]

Do one with a later model of the enterprise I love the fact you can separate the saucer, it’s one of my favourite feature of the later models just cause it looks so cool when it separates

[@redshirt0479]

Actually every _Enterprise_ is capable of saucer separation. It's actually one of the major reasons that there is a saucer section (Roddenberry was a massive fan of _Forbidden Planet_ and initially wanted the saucer to regularly land on planets). If you want to see a TOS _Constitution_ class starship saucer separate then I recommend the fan film _Of Gods and Men_ or the two part finale of the fan series _Star Trek Continues_ "To Boldy Go". On a related note, there were cut saucer separation scenes in both _The Motion Picture_ and _Search For Spock_ 68.media.tumblr.com/8a8d4a031cdc9117e24bd86685f2dcc5/tumblr_p0616d4hVg1rzu2xzo1_1280.jpg

[@scytheseven9173]

The NX-01 Enterprise couldn't Separate it's saucer section because it didn't have a secondary hull.

[@redshirt0479]

Actually Doug Drexler indicated that she can saucer separate, but it'd only be used if they needed to detach the nacelles and pontoons.

[@Jay-mq2ng]

Cpt Jack: FIRE ALL WEAPONS ON THAT STAR DESTROYER Spock: Captain we are not equipped for this matter of engagement! Star Trek Beyond reference

[@HeLLFiREGM]

Thanks 4 this epic battle

[@thomasharrog8845]

Jack, you should pilot the USS Defiant against the Star Destroyer. It's like a bigass fighter with guns that fire concentrated badass.

[@Hobbyrepubliken]

Had the Enterprise used its photons torpedoes full potential (not stop firing for the benefit of getting a nice spectator view) it would have won

[@SpheroJr3289]

Fleet battle: 6 venators vs 7 imperal star destoryers vs 3 enterprises

[@meteozek3760]

it will kill his computer

[@juliebradwell7435]

The part where the Enterprise loses the nacelles and separates the saucer reminds me of Star Trek Beyond, only thing missing is some Beastie Boys!

[@OrgyMeyer]

Would love to see what you guys do with Rdav's Fleet Command MKII mod! imagine being able to launch tie fighters and have them all be AI controlled!

[@juliebradwell7435]

The Ultimate Nerd War!

[@Commander_Wolf32]

Star destroyers are much bigger the the enterprise

[@Greystonedelta]

When in doubt, Saucer Separate!!!

[@zahkrosis5133]

This is one of two: 1) a reupload 2) a video very very very similar to a video I saw this summer

[@CaptainJack]

I mean it's not a reupload considering we made it the same day.....

[@Allegheny500]

Need to get the phaser mod working for a good battle, also the Miranda class would be a nasty opponent with the megaphasers on the rollbar

[@CaptainM792]

Evacuate everyone to the engineering section, full impulse power once the separation sequence is complete.

[@CaptainJack]

You would evacuate everyone to Saucer Section lol.

[@Lisanalgaib2]

Can you do more ramming I know it slows way down but it’s still really cool

[@CaptainJack]

It's a hard one because we get quite a few complaints about it.

[@British_Alien]

Captain Jack what if you did battles the way you do now and at the end do a ram just to see what happens?

[@plingket]

Man these battles are fucking awesome

[@captainiona8632]

Enterprise vs. The venator would be a cool battle

[@spencerwhite8730]

stardestroyer

[@user-roninwolf1981]

The Enterprise is rather large in scale compared to the Star Destroyer. I take it you were using the Kelvin Timeline/Abramsverse Enterprise's specs?

[@Rex227c1]

I wish there was a mod like the weapon on the molevolence (from star wars the clone wars) where it disables all power and short sircuts the weapons ,gyros,and thrusters for a certain duration and the longer the duration the more charge it needs

[@lexluthorrulerofaustrailia2882]

Either do full impulse where you can go from earth to moon in 5 seconds in real life, you need to place the ship a lot closer together, or both if you want a collision course to be successful.

[@dragoneverde4793]

Enterprise, those torpedoes shredded that destroyer.

[@abdussami9538]

Do more fleet battle

[@CaptainJack]

Working on some more soon mate, stay tuned!

[@abdussami9538]

One question dose the malevolence ion pulse work

[@zuelzkeclan797]

i watched his review I don't think it had it or a mod

[@obsidian53-B]

Could you do 2 Klingon D7 vs a Star Destroy. Could you do more STAR WARS VS STAR TREK.

[@RoboFloyd]

Captain John Archer: Mayweather move us in at half impulse. Shields at maximum. T’pol: Sir, they’re charging weapons. Captain John Archer: Wait until we’re in range. *Shots from the Star Destroyer hit Enterprise* T’pol: Hull plating at 80%. Captain John Archer: Target their shield generators! *Though intercom* Trip: Sir, we’re taking a lot of fire down here! T’pol: Sir, I suggest we try and get behind the ships main weapons. Malcolm: Or get blown to bits trying! Captain John Archer: Take us in Mayweather. *Shots continue to hit Enterprise* T’pol: Hull plating at 50% and decks 4 and 7 are venting atmosphere. Mayweather: Sir, I don’t know how much more Enterprise can take. *Enterprise approaches the rear of the Star Destroyer* Malcolm: We almost have a shot on their warp drives. *Through intercom* Trip: Captain we’re losing power! Captain John Archer: Just a little bit further. *Enterprise is behind the Star Destroyer* Captain John Archer: Fire! *Shots from the Enterprise hit the Star Destroyers engines disabling it* T’pol: Their warp drive is offline and weapons are down. Captain John Archer: Get us the hell out of here, Mayweather. *Enterprise turns to the stars* Mayweather: On it Sir. *Enterprise leaves the battlefield*

[@Kyeaeaea]

So true thats what would actually happen lol 😂 and the shields are much better in star treck

[@RoboFloyd]

War planes Gameplay remember the Star Destroyers were used to destroy the surfaces of planets

[@CRocketSlim]

NX classes don't quite have that armament, but Constitution classes had the same capability (granted Starfleet didn't use their ships to wreck worlds as a rule)

[@RoboFloyd]

CRocketSlim I’m referring to the Star Destroyer

[@redshirt0479]

If you have a canon source that indicates that a Star Destroyer is capable of destroying a planet's surface, please provide it. So far the only bombardment I've seen was in Rebels and the turbolasers were hitting the ground with the force of a 40mm cannons.

[@juliebradwell7435]

2:15 All gunners, fire in every other direction, maybe, just MAYBE we might actually do some damage!

[@nokommie8055]

Oviously the Empire won

[@JJ-zb9kk]

in the second round I would have got on a impact course like you did the saucier separate and pull away

[@JC-ze2et]

next time you build a warship, try mounting weapons on guntowers (think of the tower on the back of the droid cruiser, but with each side[left and right, not fore and aft] having turrets mounted along it's length) not only would this increase the number of weapons able to fire on a target, as well as greatly increasing the firing arc, ex. allowing top mounted weapons to fire below the ship (depending on it's length) but you could use the added space to mount extra thrusters, reactors, etc, increasing power, speed, and maneuverability, without having to increase the size of the whole ship. this should work on any ship (if you don't care about looks, or want to experiment) but would work best on a x- or star- shaped ship (viewed from the front). for another visual, imagine a x-wing with turrets on the top and bottom of each wing. p.s. please do a fighter battle with the starfury from Babylon 5. not only do they look awesome, but they are actually one of the most realistic space fighters in sci fi. Spacedock did a video on them if you want to know more.

[@juliebradwell7435]

Now do an Intrepid-class vessel vs an imperial heavy cruiser

[@themc.kennyshow6585]

Damn if only you still did these Jack, I have ideas,but I don't know if it's possible: UNSC Pillar of Autumn vs.Battle Star Galactica. And the UNSC Infinity vs Resurgent battlecruiser. (Also I'm now subscribing to you!)

[@toasteroven6761]

Star Destroyer wins at short to medium range. Enterprise wins at long range because of the warp capable torpedoes. Lesson learned: THE POWER OF PURE ANTIMATTER!!!!! Einstein's butt kicking E=mc^2 of glory!

[@kol_ceridwen]

Moral of the story: Keep using the torpedoes

[@inaki7884]

Do a fleet battle the rebelion vs the empire

[@CaptainJack]

Will see what i can do mate :D

[@inaki7884]

👍👍

[@zetta6656]

It was destroyed just as quickly as the real one! :D

[@queencarmilla5625]

I would love to see a romulan warbird vs the enterprise.

[@carterh8431]

Really liked this video.

[@TheLaurasmith1977]

At the beginning did you hear his constant breathing after every sentence

[@StaticYonder]

Definitely the Star Destroyer, it's a planet subjugating Warship

[@firebird_5282]

Where can I find this awesome Photon torpedoe mod?

[@CaptainJack]

Star Trek Weapons Pack

[@SSSSSSSuuvvvv]

what are the music?

[@md7556]

The thing is, the Enterprise is a research ship and not a Battle ship, while the star destroyer is a battleship

[@CaptainJack]

This is also a game, so ya know.

[@petepalone5013]

Can you pls make a Tutorial about these Mods i dont know how i place and use These Mods in the Game

[@nicholasrachal383]

now can we see star wars vs star trek vs warhammer

[@nicolebeck5730]

I would love to see how this battle would turn out in an accurate simulation with proper weaponry and shielding, is there some kind of simulation capable of that? #TeamEnterprise

[@DJSpike-ft9yw]

No. They are both fictional and in separate universes with different physics rules so there really is no way to “accurately” test anything. Anyone that says “This can beat that” is foolish.

[@10054]

@@DJSpike-ft9yw Your logic is not sound. Just because there's different physics rules doesn't negate the fact that we can statistically calculate who'd win. The technology on a starship in star trek is orders of magnitude more advanced than star wars including extremely superior sensory, superior agility, superior warp capabilities, and superior range. Startrek has nanomachines and starwars fails to make a proper AI robot.

[@deborahbowers5220]

The flying space dorrito VS a flying saucer. Seems legit

[@TheRedSpy43]

This fight is about as fair as the one at the beginning of episode 4 of Star Wars.

[@talonrichardson7521]

if it had the enterprise 72 tubes of tornados it would have been smoke. and I think the enterprise vs the Jedi cruiser

[@easyredbeard9799]

Liked just for the idea xD