Ep18: Indian Music v/s Western Music

[@deepikachoudhary1156]

This is the only video i found on KZbin which explain important difference of indian & western music.... Thank you so much Anuja.😊👌

[@rashidrashi7628]

Exactly

[@chrisofmelbourne87]

100%! Same

[@chintalashanthi6319]

Mam can you plz reply me...I want learnt Western music but in my hometown western music not available... That's why I want to Go Sangeetam clases(classical music)...is this classes are help to me to learn Western music or not???Plzzzzz reply me mam 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@carbonc6065]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qYi5mpighbF_qqc There's more out there ...

[@vasanthaiyengar273]

Please look for the book by V.S. Narasimhan titled Carnatic and Western music on youTube. Released recently; has all the explanations with music to listen to as well.

[@codered81]

everytime anuja says melody. 90’s kid in me “ melody khao khud jaan jao”

[@viveksingh-rb1fz]

they dont know about indian music...im not talk about bollywood

[@thesis33811]

Wow. So clearly explained.

[@Gyani_Baljinder_singh]

😂😂😂😂

[@viveksharma9564]

😄😄

[@rs-tarxvfz]

Accha hua tujhe "Harmony" se harmony condoms yaad nahi aaya 😂😂😂😂

[@sun4502]

You've put a lot of effort into this video. Even managed to create two different personalities. Top effort.

[@jaijaikrishan921]

नमस्ते एक प्रस्तावित भजन कान्हा.......... एक बढ़िया संगीत मय प्रस्तुति kzbin.info/www/bejne/aYDTfKuBgtlnjpY सही कहा एक सुकूनभरी आवाज़ राग यमन का एक अच्छा उदाहरण

[@amyaustin4858]

I've been looking for ways to teach my middle school singers about world music. This is fantastic! Thank you

[@narayanmahale296]

If I had not read comments below, it would have been impossible for me to believe that you both are not twins and it's YOU ALONE in the episode. The dress, hair style, way of talking and smiling, winking and looking at each other everything nicely picturised. It's wonderfully organised and picturised too. You are great. You do the things which others don't do and also can't do. Enjoyed the video. Please keep up such experiments and give happiness and satisfaction to music lovers. God bless you Anuja and Tanuja. Lastly, Thanks for sharing such a UNIQUE and WONDERFUL VIDEO to viewers.

[@tester24243]

Narayan Mahale can you please stop posting spoilers dear!

[@tripathishivam342]

Same here bro💓😍

[@jayeshmahale6177]

Mahale saheb namaskar

[@ericchin739]

Right?!?!?!?! Like just THAT small aspect required so much attention and skill. This girl is amazing!!!!

[@WhiteMetal_]

Lol same infact i have to use Google to double check 😂

[@ghazaltaghvaee]

Hi Anuja. I'm writing to you from Iran. I love Indian classical music and I really enjoy the way you teach it. Thank you so so much for this effort of yours. Love your vibe🥰

[@rudraiahrajasekhar9352]

I have lived in western countries for over forty years without understanding western musical concept. I love Karnatak music and through your videos I start to enjoy Hindustani music. For the first time I understand the main difference between Indian and Western classical music thanks for a very succinct and informative video. It was also an added bonus that this particular video has been presented by two lovely ladies. It is very meaningful that twin sisters has presented the two major musical concepts. I hope to see Tanuja more often in future.

[@AnujaK20]

Thanks for your wishes :) Tanuja is a photographic trick

[@rudraiahrajasekhar9352]

I was totally fooled. Well done.

[@sulatakundu5698]

@@rudraiahrajasekhar9352 me also

[@armeshram]

@@AnujaK20 Thanks for clarifications. Aata paryant watal ki tumhi doghihi twins ahat. Doghinhi surprise kelay barr ka saglyanna. Parat ekda Dhanyawad tumchya hya Video baddal ani tumchya Surekh awajasathi suddha.

[@mrudulaization]

@@AnujaK20 But for this comment, you totally had me onboard.

[@v6in6ie6t]

Trolling level over 9000 with the twin trick...

[@giriraj-ej6im]

It's over 9000000000

[@TheOyeHoy]

I didn't even realize there wasn't a twin until you pointed it out! :O

[@seemagaurrow21]

I think the tanpura creates a harmonious backdrop. I think indian vocal classical is so beautiful.

[@sameerburdy2960]

One of the most worthwhile videos on youtube which deserves your time .. simple and yet a detailed explanation .. superb .

[@leonarddavid199]

Even you laugh or may be admire your own concoction of your twin sister. But you have done a great job in providing a sisterly connection between the concepts. Your "that" is very cute!

[@oziosmans]

Awesomely excellent narrative presentation Well-done 🎵💟 Be blessed 🙏

[@skkwatra]

Can't thank God enough to have discovered this channel of yours, Anuja! You are supremely talented, and so full of confidence of your capability... Be blessed 🙂🙏

[@Dobbyisafreeelf595]

I love the way Indian people sing. It’s so beautiful 😍

[@rakeshkumar-mo4ev]

Wonderful - i am short of words , actually you are doing great service to Indian classical music, god bless both of you , i am 70 yr.old still ĺearnìng

[@AmanExplorerBoy]

rakesh kumar respect for you sir

[@zubisstar508]

Sir she hasn't got a twin, it's camera trick

[@mili12367]

I listen to all kind of music which is GOD for me for so many years but never thought and realized the way you explained (Chapati n Burger). GOD bless You Beta, always.

[@laurabohlander5985]

Love your videos :) I'm a western classical singer specializing in opera and early music and I'm currently learning carnatic vocal as well and I have so much to add to this that I can't write it all out. What I wouldn't give for a chance to collaborate on a video like this 😊

[@vishalkrishnaag2860]

Indian music always stands for peace not rock ie each raga represent personality's to the song such that it goes like a drama when the lyrics narrate the song raga and the tune will give a the emotion in which the song should me sung and whom the song refereed so it is an abstract combination of notes and micro notes which adds flavor to the song just like harmony .such that as in carnatic music the harmony exist but the way is actually the way to see it is also different .we carnatic musicians representing the real life so that we always care about the structure at which a tone occurs (in ascending or descending) and its beauty(not at all) thank you i will think my comment will be help full for you.

[@user-hv7jw3ji2g]

I like Anuja ‘s smile,talking&hair styling

[@AzonicMagar]

Good concept.... Viewers would get confused if you explained alone!! Thanks once again :)

[@darshangowda9347]

You almost had me there! From the dressing to the voice... Ever considered theatres as a career option Ma'm?😜

[@tigristube]

I am throughly enjoying your videos. Keep it up! Simple to understand and one of the only resources to get a understanding of the complexities of music in a very simple manner!

[@debamohapatra5403]

Two beautiful gifted sisters

[@shillongsquirrel958]

thank you so much, I am studding India Classical Music and being a foreigner sometimes I would wonder whats is the difference! Thank you for giving the food for my brain and answering my inside question!

[@ArshadNiaziArshad]

After a year I watched this video again and watched it full. Thank you for your time and efforts. Stay blessed.

[@eastersonramchiary9886]

I work as music teacher and your youtube channel help me lots for vocal lesson.

[@sparteranglong6632]

This is the explanation and definition I have been searching from 3 years ago...+++. Finally I found it in 2021 4th November

[@rasamasala]

I literally laughed out loud when you related melodies and harmonies to a chapati and a burger haha

[@NagarajBellary]

Anuja, You are so talented. It is a pleasure listening to your music.

[@jaijaikrishan921]

kzbin.info/door/nLAOTamuU2Ios_kiVz8bnQ

[@abooswalehmosafeer173]

No doubt You are angels on Earth. Thanks your explanations are more than crystal clear.

[@kumarvs3486]

Anujaji, this is the best yet from your repertoire. What amazes me is your sharp focus on just one thing: Simplifying. And you do it without making it simplistic. Bahut khoob, young lady. God bless you. Waiting for more.

[@astrobookwormsinger]

I find this very interesting and useful because I'm an Indian girl who wants to learn Western music, and I already know a great deal of Indian Carnatic music. Good job. You've earned a new subscriber.

[@29117600]

Thanks you Anuja and Tanuja...very nicely put...simply put Indian music is day ..multiple sounds background noises..Indian music is like night..single sound no background noise..

[@vishalzparadize]

I think the acting here is pretty solid..It really felt like you have a twin sister.

[@imthepassionate]

11/10. One extra point for your double role work. Very creative.

[@anindya19Cal]

Am left speechless! This is the second video featuring you and it would be a lie saying I didn't like the concept. It is so enlightening. I know nothing about music. But my parents were both singers. Naturally I always had this attachment towards music. Apart from the enlightening aspect I was left stunned by the way it was presented! And I must admit it took me some time to realize, but am still in a daze, that it was a photographic trick! Like your amazing musical talent this was a proof of some presentation talent too! Really good. It was sort of an April Fool kind! :-)

[@reikitube]

Great teachers. What a beautiful explanation by these two beautiful and educated ladies. Love their style and pleasant delivery of each word. There’s no one like them anywhere!!❤❤❤❤

[@shubha2308]

I read all the beautiful comments. Nothing is left to be said. I will just say: God bless you, Creative Innovative Anuja!

[@addypaul5551]

I have no words for you just always i love you and your teaching accent ❤

[@super8pgh]

Superb job, I have been singing all my life without the real knowledge, Understanding music & singing makes a world of difference. I think you should start teaching in USA. God bless you.DostUSA

[@leelakanoi7991]

Very beautifully expressed by twin like sisters. Thanks a lot dear

[@albertjacobs8155]

Very well articulated by this wonderful twins on the concept of both Western and Indian music. Really educational .

[@aqibali760]

Last moments of this tune was very beautiful😍😍 2:15

[@sharvarijahagirdar1088]

Woow! You both explain everything so perfectly + You both have got an amazing voice!!!!! :)

[@zubisstar508]

She hasn't got a twin, it's a camera trick

[@nagarajsingh5362]

Super! Very well organised video and the subject matter is taught in an interesting way ! Kudos to both sisters! GOD bless you!

[@vigneshrk]

wow you really upped the editing in this video! what camera magic makes you twice?!?!?

[@saurabhgupta1402]

A1. Fantastic. I can't heap enough accolades on your effort.

[@anujmuzik]

Set of smiles made me subscribe 😂. Good teacher too.😁

[@saamegan2985]

Thank you very much. Very informative and I thought your Falsetto was sooo beautiful!

[@kartikshivam3987]

Both of you are cute... Doing well..Gifted..I always show your video to my daughter tanuja!! Inspired by your work!! Great dear..

[@kalyanraman8566]

Super explanation.good explanation and demonstration.Thank you.

[@ashokohal5340]

Good morning it beautiful morning.mam i see your video always in the morning. And I get lot of information from this video. Thank you.

[@pankajjaiswal6498]

Epic ! TANUJA AND ANUJA ! EAST & WEST ! can't get better.

[@pallavisreetambraparni6995]

Hi anuja. in western music, there are normally four singing parts. soprano, thr highest female singing voice, alto, the lowest female singing voice, tenor the highest singing voice and bass the lowest singing voice. sometimes there is a part called baritone that come between tenor and bass. baritone voice is for male voice. the soprano voice is usually sung in the head voice. the alto voice is sung with a mixture of the head voice and the chest voice. the tenor voice is sung with chest voice and mixture of falsetto voice. the baritone voice is dung eith chest voice and falsetto voice. the bass voice is sung with full chest voice.

[@susanchacko3067]

Very informative subjects in musics... Both girls are surprising

[@abdulrahimghaus4545]

Very encouraging to see both sisters explaining music of different continents. I truly appreciate the depth in your content of knowledge. God bless you both. I also perform in Singapore and music is my passion. God bless

[@shivapriyabk9053]

There is only one person. It is double acting like in movies.

[@abdulrahimghaus4545]

@@shivapriyabk9053 really bro, thanks for the info.

[@satyajitmukhopadya6159]

what an excellent way of describing the difference between two. Very happy to see young stars are researching about music . Thanks to you both

[@weinhold0204]

Interesting to hear your perspectives of this. As a professional Western classical performer, I always find it interesting to compare the differences and similarities. This video focused a lot on vocal performance, but it must be said that outside of Opera vocal music isn't as predominant in Western classical as it is in ICM. If you look at a symphony orchestra's programs, you will notice that most of the soloists will be instrumentalists. Additionally there is a greater variety of different ensemble types in Western music. While indian music primarily consists of a Soloist or a duo of soloists with rhythmic accompaniment and a drone, in western music you can find anything from Piano accompanied Singers, to fully fledged Violin piano duos, to string quartets and various other chamber music ensembles to complete symphony orchestras, each providing their own tonal and harmonic possibilities. A lot is made in these comparisons about the differences between melody and harmony, and it is true that some western music is highly polyphonic, but it is likewise true that there is a lot of Western music where the melody is dominant with the harmonies serving as accompaniment. For example the Baroque era's Figured bass. For another example, look no further than Mozart, who often makes use of only very simple harmonies, and is mostly known for his incredible talent with melodies. Anyways, nice video as always, and I'm looking forward to the continuation!

[@AnujaK20]

That's some lovely information from your end :) Thank you

[@Divadellecurve]

weinhold0204 As a Western ICM student I would say it is true Western Classical music can have a more melody predominance in some cases (some say Mozart is the 'less Western' composer in the Western classical tradition) but the thing is that in Indian music you cannot have any harmonization of two performers. Only jugalbandi (duet) is possible where the performers alternate. In Western music we need to determine a vocal range otherwise harmonization would be impossible. In ICM you don't need it as the SA pitch is fixed according to the soloist's vocal range.

[@weinhold0204]

Yes, I just felt like pointing out that saying western music is exclusively harmonic is a little misleading. Also, I've never heard of Mozart described as being "less western". :D

[@fishbonegaga]

weinhold0204 I agree 100% , not to mention that classical vocalists of chorus , opera vocalists , and "pop" vocalists are completly different.

[@fishbonegaga]

Anuja Kamat There is not only big orchestra in western classical and they use lot of instruments cause back in the days , there were no amplification and there were a large audience. Unlike the trio or quartet who were performed in front of small audience , mostly in the King's court , just like hindustani classical who was performed inside palace or small places , in front of Maharaj. It isn't a matter of harmony , you can create harmony with only one guitar , or piano , organ , or else. They start to make big orchestra quite late in western music history.

[@user-hd2bz3km8l]

आश्चर्य हैं आप दोनों।समझाने का प्रारूप और तथ्य दुर्लभ है।

[@scientia736]

One correction: In western classical music, the vibrato is added to the sustained note from the beginning. The end vibrato is more of a pop music thing. Also western classical music prohibits the use of falsetto. They use what is called as head voice. Head voice and falsetto are different.

[@sydsmrn]

Scientia -right duh

[@yoverale]

Thats right good point

[@jeffersonbyrd9925]

These two sisters are lovely and helpful.

[@rahuljha4629]

mai samajh gya Indian music me logon ke Baal khule hote h, aur Western me Choti bandhi hoti h....

[@madhukathel3029]

RAHUL JHA haha ur sense of humor ,,😂

[@deepikachoudhary1156]

hahaha....😃 i like this joke..... but she is really a good representer of this kind of stuff... 👍

[@amankhandelwal7497]

RAHUL JHA epic bhai

[@shalludeora8267]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@rockinggirl2020]

Waah :D

[@jordanscott8854]

Great introductory video! An interesting historical fact that goes along with what you were talking about is that Western Classical music used to have a system for improvising harmony called Basso Continuo, but it stoped being used in performance a few hundred years ago because the harmonies became too complex

[@aashishanand1423]

Fach system actually has 6 types of voices: Bass Baritone Tenor Alto Mezzo-soprano Soprano

[@jaijaikrishan921]

kzbin.info/door/nLAOTamuU2Ios_kiVz8bnQ

[@prasadmalladi6174]

Well explained for the people who do not know the difference between Indian and western music.thank you very much.

[@gathapota9376]

really great job anuja😘 but tanuja is yourself only right??

[@syedhasan404]

Finally a video where the explaination is bang on point.. Really awesome work. Keep. It up..

[@renumalasi4715]

Teacher you have a very sweet voice 😍

[@prabhakarmathurapantula8365]

Great . the sisters are teaching like experienced professors in a simple language and clear examples. Though I am very old compared to them I salute them the way in which they explained. God bless you to continue this teaching to us

[@aubreylunn2558]

Wonderful indeed! I liked every bit of your video and both have an in-depth knowledge of music. I have learnt a lot!!! I have commented on some singers and have received Highlighted replies! I do have some knowledge of Tal, Sur, and harmony. I know the beats system,. Four beats to a bar, 6 beats (jive), 8 beats to a bar, but not 16. Singers of today are using fusion into their singing, by using a Raag notation based on se re ga ma pa notation, while the musicians add a lot of Rhythm, specifically Jazz. Boring you both!!

[@vimalsoneji4078]

Wow it’s a nice surprise to c u twin sisters my love n blessings to anuja Tanuja n keep up the music Thanks for this as I was curious for such a lesson

[@handycamlady]

Lovely video Anuja. Thanks for posting. I have question- does a harmony have to be composed of the same melody in different octaves or can it be different melodies in harmony? TIA

[@user-oy4ov2rr5d]

जय श्रीराम, अतिशय महत्त्वाची माहिती मोजकी व कमी शब्दात दोघी भगीनींनी दिलीत, आपल्या पुढील वाटचालीसाठी भरपूर शुभेच्छा जयहिंद

[@djwaynenoel7413]

chapati vs sandwich :) Thank you!

[@chinmaychandraunshuh]

Chapati vs bread.

[@skankhunt-zw6gg]

I like Sandwich most of the time

[@pradipchaughule3464]

Very Good explanation Way u have given is very nice...

[@ashokbo]

Western Classical music has melody and harmony, not just harmony.

[@ambhat3953]

She clearly said it's "based" on melody vs harmony. In the picture (1:44) also it was shown that harmony has multiple melodies, anyone with common sense can understand what it means by "based" on.

[@hayekianman]

ok concern troll

[@tristanbruns5968]

This video is excellent and very interesting. Thank you very much!

[@musical_priyaghosh]

i dont think u both are twins as u both have mole mark in chin in same place ..... nice editing ......

[@dr.aishwaryasrinivas7654]

Ma'am my opinion is that you should concentrate more on the concept being taught rather than on the fact that they are twins or not:)

[@sheshpandey8170]

Aishwarya Srinivas you are right

[@UzairKhan-qd3xu]

@@dr.aishwaryasrinivas7654 the fact is she is a better learner as she is a better observer ! what makes you think she didn't learnt the concept being taught judgemental fool

[@Prakala_Studio]

This is the only informative video i got... i am not from music background.. i was unable to pinpoint what is exact difference... thanks to you i at least understood

[@DipayanPyne94]

Actually, the video above is quite misleading. She did not explain Harmony properly. Harmony is EXTREMELY important in Western Music. In fact, without Harmony, Music can never be Universal. Harmony gives us Polyphony, Modulation, Enormous Diversity, Sudden change of Mood from Major to Minor etc etc etc. Indian Music is Linear. There is no Vertical Component. The Raag and Taal System makes it Extremely Interesting and Sophisticated, but it lacks the Ambience that Harmony provides. Long story ...

[@musical_priyaghosh]

but ur voice is just waooooooo

[@yorubamexico]

I have seen some of your videos and its great to understand how Indian classical music works, i ve been a lover of classical Indian since i was a teenager, im latinamerican from México so here its very difficult to find info, thanks again and much love Anjuna Saludos hasta india gracias

[@ShubhenduSarkarRhythm]

Wow.. dodo aap

[@AmanExplorerBoy]

Shubhendu Sarkar Rhythm 😂

[@MastMastBoy]

Didn't know you had a cute twin sister! You two are truly blessed. I have been enjoying your videos. Please keep posting. Best wishes.

[@ta-ya-music]

Twin sister I thought it was a clone done in Adobe

[@debashisdas889]

Thank you so much,, very beautifully explained.. Love from Bangladesh!

[@gamelover420]

Nice try, but your twin seems to not be able to locate where you are. As always you are best and very talented.

[@vinodcuckemane5665]

Superb. Many Thanks for explaining the otherwise, complex music making in a very simple way. I have seen your few other videos as well on ragas, taal and lay. They were simply great. Please continue, giving us the insights on the world if music.

[@manikroy7768]

I know - not twin but you are in double roles!

[@AAG007]

They both are so cute to listen to

[@varunnrao3276]

is she really your twin is is it you double playing??

[@charumehta3634]

VARUN.N RAO i

[@Arwin329]

You both sisters are superb

[@culritesh]

Is she for real? She even sounds so similar to you.

[@vk274]

Wow! So you are an actress too? What a double role! As always your voice and knowledge of music are superb.

[@crazypumpkin738]

wait! do you actually have a twin sister? 😱

[@AnujaK20]

photographic trick :)

[@crazypumpkin738]

Anuja Kamat OMG😅! because twice the amount of cuteness and smartness would have been too much to handle!

[@jagadhriwalapreet2774]

Anuja Kamat awaz bhi alag lag ri thi apki

[@nayeemnm]

Good question 😀

[@ManishKalauni]

Anuja Kamat I thought you have a twin sister

[@ramniwasbhukel]

No words for their talent. In depth understanding of music earns natural appreciation by millions.

[@DeepikaSingh-sw9rw]

is she really ur twin ?

[@AnujaK20]

photographic trick :)

[@AzonicMagar]

Good job

[@spykeebrar6973]

Deepika Singh no

[@priyans1020]

good acting too

[@ankitjaiswalmusical5605]

@@AnujaK20 great explanations mam. But initially I was searching for Tanuja kamat on fb and suddenly saw your reply.

[@sudheer4198]

Really informative.. The way of presentation👌👌Thanks

[@abcdancd736]

ur sister is photocopie of u

[@praveenawesome2182]

abcd ancd its photographic trick bro

[@anoopviswanadh3413]

5 വർഷം മുൻപ് ഇറങ്ങിയ ഈ വീഡിയോ ഇന്ന് അതായത് 16/നവംബർ /2022 ഇൽ ആണല്ലോ കാണാൻ സാധിച്ചത് എന്ന് ഓർക്കുമ്പോൾ വിഷമിക്കുന്നു എന്ന് ഓർത്ത് ഞാൻ ദുഃഖിക്കുന്നു thank you. You both are so good

[@shivaaniupadhyay7416]

I don't know why people dislike the knowledgeable video if they are really want to learn something about music they have to listen first

[@Aviator.Sam.Thomas]

So lovely sisters... Thanks for the updates 💕🎉