ER - John Carter Lucy Knight Stabbing

A tribute to the events that caused and followed the tragic stabbing on the show ER on Valentine's day, 2000. In Memory of Lucy Knight.

[@melaniej.roberts206]

I forgot Peter got on the flight with Carter to go to rehab. Wonderful. Such wonderful writing.

[@michele21auntiem]

I just rewatched the 15 yr series. The writing was so good. The acting superb.

[@beaglejenny]

I used to watch this show all the time. It was great and I especially loved Lucy. It was so sad when she died and what Carter went through after. This video is great, the way it shows that all.

[@bcptbcpt]

when youtubers actually think they can improve on a great TV show by editing what people actually want to see and adding an annoying music on top.

[@SciTrekMan]

bcptbcpt I thought I was the only one who felt this way. I hate it when people throw music, especially music that doesn’t even fit, over great scenes.

[@Liz-vd4lj]

Preach!!!

[@sarcasticallyrearranged]

It distracts from the acting, dialogue, you can't hear anything and it's always a cheesy song. Ruins it every time!

[@mike4619]

Wow. What a tough crowd. Of assholes, that is.

[@Loreleii03]

The music doesn't work with this video at all. Could have just played the same music that was going on during the episode originally. The music and video don't match and it ruins everything

[@VMars221]

Aww! I love it! I especially like the Benton/Carter scenes. Benton always cared more about Carter than he let on.

[@kimberlyjeanne9456]

Honestly the music in the episode made it eerie, it didn’t need this music

[@sarcasticallyrearranged]

The music during the stabbing is the same as when the stabber runs into Carter bringing everything back to the moment. The music over it ruins it.

[@tiggerbait]

ah.. I am crying... this is absolutly amazing. Great work. This episode made me cry when I watched it. I love the song. Goes great with the clips.

[@judyl5260]

Why does Italian always make you feel the emotion so strongly? I miss ER, so well done.perfect television

[@sheilapotter3274]

I loved all of ER but these two episodes were so heartbreaking. Well done to all the cast and crew, past and present

[@larryanddeb]

I watched every ER episode and have them all on video tape. You did great here.You captured it all in a few minutes where if I wanted to revisit these scenes it would take me hours. Excelent choice of music by the way.

[@coewee]

one of the most beautiful you tube video yet every time i watch i nearly cry a full grown man well done

[@Bendito2006]

Wow! I can't believe the amazing quality of this video! Thank you for doing such a good job! The music fit perfectly!

[@DaysWatcher]

Wonderful job, you captured all the integral parts of the story. Great music as well.

[@klaudiagrob]

What else was Carter supposed to say to the grieving mother. She was in enough pain as it was.

[@you.hadme.athello]

This is one of the most well done and brilliant tributes I have ever seen!! I love Lucy and I think this video honors her character and is truly an inspiration! Thank you for posting this!❤

[@MichaelBrown-js1ti]

ER PG VIDEOS PG DVD PG KZbinPG

[@margothsegovia9792]

Thanks for this video , 22 years later still hurt this

[@Yanks4Life23519]

ah you made me cry!!!! :( such a great video...well done!! I haven't watched ER in a LONG time but I remember when I saw this episode...Noah Wyle was amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!...thanks for posting!!!!!!

[@scm0717]

Okay, so I'm bawling right now. So tragic,sad and the song is perfect. That show was one of the best.

[@azmamazmam727]

The part when Benton pulled Carter, hugged and kissed him was so poignant.

[@maryliz98]

So tragic and yet so beautiful at the same time. This actually made me cry - and that rarely happens to me on You Tube! 5 stars.

[@austinsmith1505]

Noah should gotten a Emmy nomination for the bathroom sence

[@susanaaguayo9442]

And for every single episode in seasons 6 and 7.

[@lindadegraaf9297]

@@susanaaguayo9442 & Austin Smith- AGREE, 100%

[@laurieheartsdcx]

very sad, but shows what a good actor noah wyle is. this is good. saw the episodes today. thanks.

[@alilinzee]

Excellent...thank you! xxxx

[@you.hadme.athello]

This is amazing! You did an awesome job with the music and everything! This is truly empowering!🙌👏🏻

[@ForestTekkenVideos]

I used to watch ER way, way back. Until Luck Knight was killed off. To me, the show ER died with her. To think that ER lasted so long without her is baffling to me. It was so sad. I can not watch any ER type of shows like Grey's Anatomy.

[@AppleEarring]

This was beautiful! You did a very good job. Wow. Not only the great Lucy and Carter stuff, but the great Carter and Deb stuff, and even more so, the absolutely amazing Carter and Benton footage! Oh and the Mark and Carter stuff was awesome too.

[@lucyknight9]

wondefull video, I miss lucy so bad. thaks for share this.

[@GDJoppa]

the video was well put together. very sad :(

[@jennifermartinez5616]

I forgot how much I loved this show

[@dramagal19]

the scene with Benson gets me everytime

[@juliemcarthur3004]

Lucy was one of my favorites

[@izzyanddennyfan]

GREAT video it shows the turmoil that carter went through after lucy's death

[@annebarnes9687]

The sad part is that they made the perfect couple. And to end it in such a tragic way.

[@drewzuhosky6826]

They were supposed to have paired off, but Noah Wyle objected to it because it would have been unethical for Carter to do.

[@toddsmitts]

I actually met Gwynyth Walsh, who played Lucy's mom, at a convention and asked her about that scene. She talked about how hard it was to shoot that.

[@elizabethcunicelli7023]

Can the music....the video speaks for itself

[@burnningbridges]

God how this whole thing just wrecked me for days. I mean it’s just a show but to have seen Lucy be stabbed and then to die… just had me in tears and so damn sad.

[@saramarie18]

the episodes are "Be Still My Heart" and "All in the family"

[@AIartBonaza]

well done,Loved it !

[@Oyasumi12]

You did a great job! This video is amazing! I really like how you mix the music and the important sentences that are spoken! loooove it! Is it season 6 by the way?

[@Bernie61dee]

So brilliant so powerful 👏

[@patriciavincent9832]

How wonderful to use such a beautiful song, sung by a true artist Josh Groban! Thank you for sharing this.

[@joannemadden7449]

NEVER UNDERESTIMATE THE POWER of the MIND. Unfortunately in many, many EDs around the world things like this happen. And sometimes as doctor's look for the WOW factors, the saying of ," it's the quiet ones you have to worry about" is very true. God bless all those out on the front line.

[@MerriToon]

This episode is still so upsetting and horrifying 💔💔💔💔

[@msproject5775]

What's with the over-the-top melodramatic music. I just wanted to watch this episode geez. Thanks for the posting but someone has too much time on their hands scoring this episode

[@Oyasumi12]

It's Italian! Beautiful song, great video!!! =)

[@54spiritedwill54]

this is great!

[@melanierouze1964]

I've seen episodes of housing and Lucy are stabbed and when I cry because it is painful when you love a series that people dying is sad .... and its very touching !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! see you soon

[@sarahtubb7955]

Oh my....that was soo moving.

[@ernestinemurphy9519]

Wish you can stream ER love this show

[@PlumbPitiful]

It's on Hulu

[@Strider30]

I remember this episode as a kid.

[@juliemcarthur3004]

Love this video

[@Oyasumi12]

I have to buy it NOW!!! :DD Thanks a lot for the information! *bows* ^-^

[@capncrunch479]

Someone should make a video of the many times Carter telling or screaming “sweet Jesus”.... add the Wilhelm scream

[@izzyanddennyfan]

such a great song :) i love it. who sang this version? it sounds like josh groban

[@ventilator98]

I love ER MORE THAN WORDS DESCRIBE. I WISH THAT THERE WAS IN EXISTANCE A WAY I COULD GET A DOWNLOAD ANY EPISODE FREE. SUCH AS THE EPISODE IN SEASON 3 called (FEAR OF FLYING). I cannot pay. I would loooove this. Your videos are beyond wonderful. Beyond any means of description AMAZING!!!!!!!

[@amigiles4130]

Peter Foster if u have an android box or anything you can get exodus and the every season of er that is made is on that

[@Oyasumi12]

Oh my God! That's such a sad reason!! =(

[@melanierouze1964]

housing and lucy it's a shame that was the episode where it's made ​​me cry a lot to me for this sad episode I'm serious

[@medsubway]

Awesome!

[@nicolettabellina2738]

FANTASTICOOOOO❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@coewee]

terrible i cryed as a full grow man so sad top episode

[@xxleilaxxnumba1fanxx]

that was really good! it was so sad!

[@Dotveoh]

carter was an ass to her in this ep. but i love him and it was her idea to leave ER. lucy left the show after her sister's death, as she could not bear to spend so much time in even a fake hospital after being in real ones so much during her sister's illness. I LOVE Corday GOD she A GRAT WOMAN! i LOVE YOU CORDAY

[@madirishgirl76]

Dotveo not true she left er coz she got into college she told er from the v start that she had applied to college if she got in she would leave the show so thats excatly what happened she didnt leave coz she coukdnt bear to be in a hospital after her sisters death. Ut was also written into her contract that if she didnt get into college she could remain on the show if she wanted. Get it right

[@Dotveoh]

@@madirishgirl76 wow, I posted this 13 years ago, and you had the nerve to reply to my comment that is 13 years old. Jesus!

[@madirishgirl76]

@@Dotveoh so tough if uve a problem with that get the f over yourself you're nobody special u were wrong in why she left the show you were corrected deal with it. Maybe you'll check your facts next time before you post wrong information gobshite

[@sharitorrance2656]

This was so sad.

[@maryemclea6436]

what a hard video to do great job

[@paigematthews06]

I totally agree with you!

[@chatty2164]

This was insane

[@Vic-xw1ok]

I love carter my mum has the box set I am in the middle of watching it

[@kaitlynoreilly3777]

I almost cried...

[@eugeniadistefano4158]

Agradezco por los comentarios. Pero me gustaría saber que dicen porque sino no puedo contestar

[@paulinauribes]

What cap is?

[@giordanotirelli6028]

Happy birthday dr lucy alias kellie martin from italian boy live in rome and I m fan of er

[@KingFofo666]

@ForestTekkenVideos i'm with you man, i can't stand it that they kept on going without her :(

[@hothotheat3000]

Could you make the music any fucking LOUDER?!

[@johnnyn1111]

What is that song?

[@AppleEarring]

Some of this is the next episode, All in the Family. But I believe :34 is still Be Still My Heart, or the one before it... Abby Road.

[@juliemcarthur3004]

Love this one

[@volleyballmylifee_]

Miss you Lucy😔🖤🕊️

[@jessicacosentino1772]

too bad the music drowned out the emotion and the words

[@giordanotirelli6028]

Happy birthday at carter from italian boy live in rome and I m fan of er

[@rottencat240]

hey, what episode was 4:00 from? and 4:51?

[@giordanotirelli6028]

Happy birthday john alias noah from italian boy live in rome and I m fan of er

[@brookss0505]

one of the best of er

[@xxhenrike]

great job! I like the voice of Josh Groban and I like ER.. but this is so sad...

[@Livibox]

best/saddest er episode to date

[@toddsmitts]

I think she meant emotionally. Noah Wyle didn't really come up but I'm sure he's a nice guy. I also asked her about the few episodes she did on "NYPD Blue" (she was in a few episode as Theo's doctor when he got sick). She had nice things to say about Dennis Franz and said she could tell how much he appreciated having that role.

[@madirishgirl76]

Toddsmitts Noah has admitted in interviews he was horrible to her from the v start he didnt like she was getting more snow time than him he felt disrespected by her coz he felt she wasnt on the show long eoungh to get more show time than him. It wasnt untilnoah was threatened to be fired for his attitude toward her he copped onto himself. He shouldn't have been like that at all. I saw an interview she did after leaving the show she hung Noah out to dry said she would never work with Noah ever again that his attitude how he treated her was disgusting to her. So no he maybe a great actor but his attitude how he treats ppl leaves a lot to be desired u dont treat ppl like that ever

[@CC-si3cr]

WHY THE MUSIC???? This was not a tribute. What did Lucy ever do to you?

[@riosattic]

well done

[@alejandrainclan812]

Doesn’t show Lucy’s stabbing Carter’s pain killer addiction is heart breaking 😢💔

[@PlumbPitiful]

They never showed Lucy being attacked. After Carter was stabbed and he fell to the floor she was already laying there

[@srosie10]

@butpleasedontcatchme yeah i think its called Romeo and Juliet Theme or something like that but its by Andre Rieu

[@giordanotirelli6028]

Happy birthday dr abby from italian boy live in rome and I m fan of er

[@marikobrandon]

it's episode 21 from Season 6- the one where Nurse Hathaway leaves to reunite with Doug Ross. (her last episode and Clooney's surprise cameo.) Carter gave a woman something she clearly stated she was allergic to, and almost killed her.

[@MaryJimenezUniversalProfile]

She died or of her own stupidity. The patient WAS combative, psych and aggressive. IT remains in restraints

[@KasiaB13]

I miss for Lucy, for ER... Why Lucy and Carter were not a couple ???? why....

[@michele21auntiem]

Kelly Martin wanted to leave show. She played Lucy.

[@Notawesomeatall7]

Hard as in "emotional" or hard as in "getting it right"?? What did she say about Noah Wyle?

[@Notawesomeatall7]

I like the song you used. It wasn't some tacky song or anything.

[@natalicious13]

what happened to the one with warning sign? :S

[@juliemcarthur3004]

Loved lucy all in the family is my favorite

[@briannaheath6923]

This episode was very hard to watch this show was amazing great acting loved it but I hated these episodes at the same time cause Lucy dying carter wishing he died instead and what he went though I hated it I just had a very hard time and the rehab ones also got me cause no one should have to go though what he did and I don’t blame him for sticking himself with that needle cause he just wanted the pain gone and that’s the only way he thought he would get rid of the guilt 😢

[@nickandersonecw9551]

Lost to my family

[@pork123100]

I listened to music more than watched video

[@Proud2BASootGremlin]

Theres no sound ):

[@annapoggi2588]

Happy birthday at kellie martin from italian girl live in rome