Etrata vs Daretti vs Mistform vs Akiri | Tymna EDH / CMDR game play for Magic: The Gathering

►Like what you see? Why not subscribe: bit.ly/1MhSmfN
►You can now support me through Patreon: bit.ly/2k6NJtf
►New videos every Monday / Thursday at 11AM EST (Eastern Standard Time)
►Watch me play EDH / CMDR on Twitch: bit.ly/2puY8BD
►You can now buy MTG Muddstah playmats: bit.ly/2omrWBl
►Here's my referral link for OMA: originalmagicar...
Longest game ever?
Mistform: tappedout.net/m...
Daretti: tappedout.net/m...
Etrata: tappedout.net/m...
Akiri | Tymna: tappedout.net/m...
►Use the promotional code: MTGMUDDSTAH at Flipside Gaming (www.flipsidega..., ORIGINAL MAGIC ART (www.originalma..., and MULTIZONE (mtg.multizone.ca) to get 10% off orders of $10 or more!
(some exclusions may apply)
►This game was filmed at Wizard's Tower in Ottawa, ON
Tweet me at: @MTGMuddstah
Music from filmmusic.io:
"Danse Macabre" by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licence: CC BY (creativecommons...)

[@stevoyah]

woah almost 30 mins! Nice to see you on last weeks episode of Commander Clash from mtggoldfish!

[@DarkEinherjar]

Muddstah went to a hidden monastery in the mountains, where he honed his Magic skills under the watchful eyes of his master, the legendary elder goblin monk, Mistform Ultimus. For months, he trained hard every day, even meditating under a waterfall to sharpen his mind (insert Naruto's training theme here)... and after a long time, he finally mastered the art of remembering to draw from Rhystic Study... for the most part, at least.

[@jaded2269420]

Holy hell you remembered your studies trigger haha Very Good game

[@MTGMuddstah]

I'm giving all of the credit to Peter. I was basically just drawing when he did.

[@spicysalmon8590]

Two Rystic Studys and a Smothering Tithe is absurd to watch

[@robertbolea2308]

Adam didn't have many cards to spend the treasures on in the end

[@G3M333]

Since Mistform is now an Army, something like Commence the Endgame could be sweet for voltron damage

[@namename8004]

Kinky

[@DarkEinherjar]

When Master of Waves died, you still had Grand Architect, so the elemental tokens should've lived.

[@MTGMuddstah]

Dang it!

[@loganl8440]

@@MTGMuddstah I can't imagine trying to keep track of that many tribal/color interactions.

[@littlegamingmoments2923]

But he DID remember a majority of his study triggers!

[@AffinityForCommander]

Mistform strikes again! I absolutely love that deck! :D

[@tomobarker]

I reckon he should make a morophon deck if he hasn't, would open up a lot for him and make the deck really good.

[@typoholic]

That’s a “next level” game right stuff there. Pretty sure that all players piloted their decks extremely well.

[@orimsamitehealer1579]

The Duke of Dumpsters. I just found the new nickname of my Daretti deck.

[@namename8004]

This is my favorite kind of EDH game. Long, grindy, interactive, everyone gets to do stuff. I know Akiri had a slow start, but it's not like they didn't do anything all game.

[@bengoodman7400]

21:30 or so, Scott did have an infinite - by targeting spine with itself, getting infinite paradox triggers. Loved seeing a great, grindy game. Thanks again.

[@twidgetron328]

There were so many downright bizarre choices made in this game, especially by Peter and Adam. Still great content as usual.

[@testmand123]

That Batman playmat is pretty cool

[@oom-3262]

15:02 this is the ultimate "yes, but actually no" card.

[@Anaki99DK]

Yay mondays means Muddstah vids... Greetings from Denmark

[@inthestateofdelirium]

So proud of you muddstah! You nearly got all your rhystic study triggers!

[@ProdigalMadness]

The overwhelming victory Mistform deserves. That was a great game of commander. I love long games of actual gameplay. And yes, I completely did expect you to miss that first Mystic trigger. Super well done on your triggers. With only two uses of the dice of shame, that is some great improvement on your end, and well done for that.

[@mugiwaralee9592]

GodDAMN Rite of Replication putting in work these last few games. Also Andrew I've got about 3/4 of my own slightly budget version of your Mistform deck completed, cannot wait to play this deck. Always happy to see it's amorphous, bizarre face in the thumbnail.

[@DarkEinherjar]

15:48 Wait... did Peter tap the Metalworker he had just blinked for mana?

[@oplex]

Same happened earlier, around 8:34. When he displaced his Gonti then attacked with it.

[@toriku_]

My god all of those Study triggers that weren't missed, also wow long game and it was fun to see all the way through

[@pauljimerson8218]

I just wanted to say that you are a true soldier for owning up to all your foibles with Rhystic study and any mistakes you make during the game.

[@hafusan]

_"And he keeps (...) and a mean boy changeling."_ (Amoeboid Changeling) that made me so happy. I should watch youtube more often while munching loudly if it grants me such blessings.

[@biyasiz]

So this was the long game you tweeted about. Honestly I didn't even notice the game lasted 30 minutes until you mentioned that it was a long video. Good game!

[@Scott.not.Scotty]

I’m so proud of you for remembering your triggers

[@erickbailey4753]

How did Gonti attack at 8:50? It was blinked and should have summoning sickness?

[@Y0SIN]

Was thinking the same thing lol

[@darylchiu9030]

Aww, I was hoping for Feather. Someday maybe. ^_^

[@crovax1375]

@21:45 There is a missplay with the Spine of Ish Sah. The card ruling states that it can't be sacrificed to trigger the return to hand portion of the text

[@MTGMuddstah]

The ruling has caused a great deal of confusion unfortunately. If you follow the thread found here: (www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/magic-fundamentals/magic-rulings/magic-rulings-archives/312724-spine-of-ish-sah) you'll see that the ruling does not stop you from using the ability when sacrificing the Spine to other cards.

[@DarkEinherjar]

What that rule means is that you have to use another effect to make the Spine go to the graveyard; the last ability, by itself, doesn't allow you to sacrifice it at will.

[@crovax1375]

@@MTGMuddstah ok the wording on the ruling could be more clear

[@iamkevinash]

can't wait for the mistform conquering your commander vid. absolutely love that deck.

[@GaucheEtVeule]

GO MUDDSTAH GO MUDDSTAH GO MUDDSTAH This game was amazingly fun

[@Googleflax]

Unless I missed it, when Peter cast Cyclonic Rift, you missed a card draw from Rhystic when he played Swan Song to counter the Mortify.

[@DarkEinherjar]

This weekend, I had Smothering Tithe on my board throughout the game and almost made it to 30 treasure tokens... I'm practing for the day I run Rhystic Study in my decks. :D

[@puzzleybearded3977]

I love your content. I have just put together my own Mistform deck. It is based on your deck but I don't have or could not afford some cards. I all so put the new Ugin in it to help remove enchantments.

[@thyronebennett1170]

Will you ever do more deck techs. Like the conquering your commander series. I'd love to see it

[@sage4rage]

The hate on Etrata and Daretti let you steal the win to be fair. They should've seen this coming from miles away.

[@pauljimerson8218]

I think you should of mulled with Rhystic Study in the opening hand, that's a dead card. I keed, you did a great job!

[@padowiczJ464]

Whoa long game! Great work!

[@vsDenchal]

Is there any chance we'll your Trostani List sometime again? I only discovered your channel recently so there's lots of older content to explore, but with Ulvenwald Hydra and Bramble Sovereign, I fell in love.

[@julianhugen8760]

Even too long was a great video. The camera was perfect too. Your mistform deck has improves alot. Even if you has a huge boost with rhystic study your deck seems more consistent. Peter seems a really good player. Is not easy control 3 player at once. All perform very well, even Adam that don't has a chance. But he deserve a crown of pacience. How long this game was? 3h?

[@kylemarrow92]

I love Scott's playmat

[@Kazz1187]

Holy moly, almost made the 1/2 mark! This game must have been going on for a while

[@lorenzozanello6812]

Very nice game, but if I'm not wrong the elemental tokens at minute 22 shouldn't have died thanks to the grand architect +1/+1 since they are blue as well

[@rorylastname7635]

15:52 With the Closet blinking Metalworker, it now has Summoning Sickness. It cant tap for mana until his next turn.

[@noriaas]

Mistform looks so fun, I'm more and more tempted to build one.

[@MrWhatsyourflavour]

Such a great episode!

[@robertbolea4341]

if there is anything like a hullbreacher that can deny any extra card draw, then u do not need to draw if the opponent does not pay the 1 for rhystic study. same goes for anyone that want to draw extra cards.

[@luigi2.021]

Wow almost 30 Minutes! I like it

[@Cole444Train]

I think the Etrada deck could benefit from a different commander

[@PlotwistInc]

Damn, what a game! Mistform is really turning into a powerhouse.

[@thefourhorsemen4839]

That’s awesome I live super close to wizards tower I’d love to get some games in!

[@antonchesnokov638]

I was about to write that yarok would be a so much better as a commander instead of etrata if Peter wanted to play etb-deck, but remebered that yarok is from core 2020 XD

[@DarkEinherjar]

I'm amused by the fact that Peter is taking more advantage of ETB triggers and artifacts than actual combat... maybe he should've swapped Etrata for Rona. :P

[@Cole444Train]

I definitely think there are better commanders for that deck. Especially in dimir

[@TheOGLionQueen]

How was Scott untapping his artifacts so often? I missed that play that allowed him to do so

[@basicswamp]

clock of omens

[@EvGamerBETA]

Does Scott use voltaic key to net extra 1 colorless from Sol Ring? It could be shortcut, but doesn't look like it Also I would love to have Paradox Engine in my decks, but I'm glad it's banned

[@Devin-oh7gr]

What gave the metal worker haste he bounced it with the closet then tapped it on your turn?

[@EduardoBritoSan]

Also the closet should return the metalworker to its owners field right?

[@Devin-oh7gr]

Eduardo Brito no its under your control

[@DarkEinherjar]

This is one rare case where the card returns under the same controller, not the owner.

[@EduardoBritoSan]

@@DarkEinherjar Interesting, makes sense, thank you

[@ivernedit]

Yay a long Episode,thanks dad

[@DummyUrD]

Good job on the Rhystic!

[@uiop60]

Thoughts on just going “island, pass” turn 1 and then island-sol ring-study turn 2? Not only does it have pretty much the same result, but would undo some of the stigma of a turn 1 ring.

[@Y0kAiS]

"sword of the anime" lol love to see it

[@hafusan]

Fantastic video!

[@ModelHX]

Maaaaaaaan, Scott missed out on so much mana by not using Voltaic Key before each Paradox Engine trigger.

[@namename8004]

I saw that, too. He could have gone off much harder.

[@ModelHX]

@@namename8004 Totally. It wasn't infinite but it was at least 2 more Spines or spells cast per turn.

[@MTGMuddstah]

It was his first time playing the deck, so a lot of the interactions were newish to him. I'm impressed with how well he did!

[@overmind5556]

Ever thought about putting ugins nexus in your deretti if your deretti and mirrors works out it is a red time stretch

[@marcd2726]

If I'm not mistaken, couldn't Scott have infinitely sacced the Spine of Ish Sah to Trading Post to draw a card and recast it to blow up everything on board?

[@marcd2726]

Ah, you still had Relic. FOrgot about that!

[@kennythereaver1]

okay i need to know where scott got that playmat cus i need it

[@scottcampbell4642]

Found the playmat here, and have been getting it signed by various batman artists at comic cons for a few years :) www.amazon.ca/Batman-Superhero-Stylish-Playmat-Mousepad/dp/B07DL18MHW/ref=sr_1_3?keywords=batman+playmat&qid=1557282372&s=gateway&sr=8-3

[@condrecomics]

Killing the Hostage Taker token should have brought Tymna back in play from the Command Zone. That kind of exile effect does keep track of the card if it goes to a public zone different from exile (unless it later changes zone again - for example if it was recast)

[@MTGMuddstah]

Good to know, thanks! I'll try and keep that in mind moving forward.

[@imaginarymatter]

Are you sure that was you piloting the Mistform Ultimus? There was far too few missed Rhystic Study triggers.

[@thenemosix6835]

Great game!! Thank you for the content.

[@ivernedit]

We love your mistform deck

[@joshuaheckelsmiller5694]

8:50 how did gonti attack after being flickered? Also love the channel! keep cranking!

[@DarkEinherjar]

Peter apparently doesn't realize creatures regain summoning sickness when they're blinked... he also tapped Metalworker for mana after he blinked it.

[@Quelfas]

How does Peter tap the Metal Worker for 4 mana to sac the Hedron Archive to draw 2 at 16:00 ? He flickered it with Conjurer's Closet, so it should have summoning sickness.

[@DarkEinherjar]

By forgetting that flickering causes summoning sickness. He also attacked with Gonti after flickering him.

[@adams333]

What could be worst than Forgeting Rhystic trigger? Not paying for your opponent's Rhystic trigger. It is not easy to lose when you draw 5 + cards per turn.

[@expertionis794]

Damn what a game

[@IntegratorNivramgrate]

Someone has certainly been inspired by a certain other person who used Mistform recently... did you take (Rhystic) Study lessons from him?

[@Wolffy.]

The tokens should remained alive when Master of Waves leaves the battlefield since Grand Architect was still in the board and provided the +1/+1 needed for their survival.

[@parkerstockett7609]

Awesome game! So many. Cards off of rhystic study!

[@addambarcelos]

sick game. mistform rocking as always and daretti putting pressure with paradox

[@Iann525]

Now we can finally have an adam v adam v adam v adam game

[@mythiccmouse6214]

I'm just sad there is no new commander gameplay with the new set i.e niv-reborn or tolsimir

[@MTGMuddstah]

I've got a game with Mowu dropping hopefully next week.

[@mythiccmouse6214]

@@MTGMuddstah mowuwuwu woohoo! *inserts generic goblin cheer*

[@MordeenDK]

Hey muddstah. Are you planning on doing more themed episodes? Like the all mono-blue episode you uploaded. Love your vids!

[@MTGMuddstah]

I'm always open to theme ideas, but they have to be something I want to do.

[@MordeenDK]

@@MTGMuddstah have you considered doing more mono-colored themes? Mono-red for example has great diversity in subthemes (artifact decks, chaos, goblin etc.). I think you did an all partner commanders episode? Otherwise I think it would be amazing to watch! The spellshaper legendary creatures? That would be a blast from the past!

[@MrEliakimRAS]

@@MordeenDK There is a double video with 3 pairs of partners.

[@MordeenDK]

@@MrEliakimRAS I also mentioned that I thought Muddstah already had uploaded such a video. I was just brainstorming ideas. :)

[@gabriellecureux5528]

Nice describe of the decks

[@lazaruscomplexofficial]

This was one of my favorite games that etrata deck was RUUUUUDE

[@nielsweijts7488]

Great game muddstah

[@lucashoman9351]

Good serie

[@septred3]

Hey Andrew do you plan on doing any Oathbreaker format videos?

[@MTGMuddstah]

Not currently.

[@Hubert1246]

Since you’re in Canada again, now are you going to be visiting NJ often still? Or is it not worth the drive/flight?

[@MTGMuddstah]

My wife is still hoping to do some stuff with Princeton, so we'll probably be back every now and then.

[@stevenbuck4090]

Why was everyone picking on my boy Peter suddenly? It was obvious you and Daretti were the targets.

[@jonathanvaldez7523]

As a rustic studies player, I started sweating when smothering tithe hits the field like....shoot xD

[@amethystwyvern]

Great game

[@mattky6361]

How long was this game? :o

[@goodknight88]

great game! such fun!

[@humanname1458]

You should put a token in a different colour sleeve in your hand whenever you play study.. And the token just say "Trigger" 😂

[@ErikTheRedd1]

I have literally force of willed a rhystic study because I hate it so much

[@sage4rage]

Yeah, the card does too much for 3 mana in a multiplayer format.

[@Battleguild]

I like to counter it with Smothering Tithe.

[@TheQueerLeaf99]

Wouldn’t your elementals stay because of the grand architect?

[@MTGMuddstah]

You're correct! After two hours in one game though, my brain went to mush.

[@DarkEinherjar]

That brain death cost me a game last saturday... I passed the turn without noticing my opponent had Dark Depths and Thespian's Stage, so he made a Marit Lage during my end step and killed me. :/

[@Sakharee]

Whoa a such along game

[@lucassloan1960]

I mean paradox engine is banned still if I remember correctly granted y'all could have been rule zero this

[@nicholasberry8456]

I bet you’re excited to build new Krenko Muddstah :)

[@MTGMuddstah]

I'm actually not all that keen on him =( Sorry!

[@nicholasberry8456]

MTG Muddstah Thought so too myself but after playing him I was actually impressed, my biggest complaint is the art though

[@frigglegiggles]

Dude I love your content, you are clear and you have character but varying your cadence would go a long way in making this series more engaging. I'm glad you have music but I think workshopping your voiceover would be much more effective.

[@DarkEinherjar]

I really don't like Etrata as a commander... the fact that she needs to connect three times per opponent (and they need to have targetable creatures every time) and you need to focus a big chunk of your deck into finding ways around the shuffling effect is so... ugh. Thankfully, Peter's stealing and copying effects did such a good job in this game, he was able to be a powerful threat without ever bringing out Etrata. I'm definitely getting inspirations here for my future Dimir deck (I'm planning to use Rona).

[@thelunchlady8276]

Lord Lazav is disappointed in your lack of faith.

[@DarkEinherjar]

Lord Lazav lost hexproof, and my respect with it.

[@thelunchlady8276]

@@DarkEinherjar Blasphemy! I do like Mastermind better though. The hexproof does help.

[@orsettomorbido]

Horray!

[@pkphantom]

I miss Paradox Engine 😞

[@samb123078]

Muddstah should play solemnity so he doesn’t get shame counters.

[@DarkEinherjar]

No one can escape the dice of shame and Rhystic Failure... :P