Everything Wrong With Atlantis: The Lost Empire in 21 Minutes or Less

[@dday906]

This movie deserves so much more love than what it got.

[@Dadum-bass]

Disney making all their old movies real life. . . . Insert Will Smith *THIS* meme

[@KakashiHatake-ge8ve]

this movie has a loyal fanbase

[@Draconightfury]

This and Treasure Planet

[@KakashiHatake-ge8ve]

@@Draconightfury you know they were actually planning to make a sequel to Treasure Planet

[@Nikto10k]

I’ve deadass never heard of this movie prior to this video.

[@vastotales4431]

The only true Sin is that this movie, as well as Treasure Planet, is Disney most forgettable and unrated movie of all time and doesn't get the recognition it deserves

[@techpriest99]

Glad it wasn't just me who enjoyed those movies 😅

[@dr.traplord1227]

Straight facts.

[@bufordhighwater9872]

If a movie is forgettable, that usually means the movie was underwhelming and not deserving of recognition.

[@AttemptedVoices]

Had me in the first half.

[@doomthedemonhedgehog]

both movies where destroyed but disneys greed especially Treasure planet which literally had the Twist in the trailer for the movie

[@LCCWPresents]

For sin 122, if a cave system is big enough with the right conditions, a cave system can have its own weather patterns. A couple of massive caves near the Himalayas have enough perseveration to have clouds inside of them at times.

[@elibedard6373]

Truly? That's incredible.

[@HearMeShout789]

Go geologize something!

[@G4m3rKoneko_Keori]

Heard the sin and straight away checked the comments to see if someone provided an answer. Thank you muchly!

[@tonyf.9806]

During WWII, Boeing's Washington factory was so big, it has it's own indoor weather climate, including clouds. I do agree it'd be strange, but theoretically possible. But bigger question would be, where is all that breathable air coming from.

[@skyetranqille9534]

@@tonyf.9806 that was my main question, would air trapped in a unwater bowl be toxic to humans? I assumed it meant the Atlantean God was somehow making it breathable lol

[@educasantos_]

the fact that you didnt mention they discovered the same fish that was extinct and in the dudes aquarium a few year latter as not being extinct is mind bogling

[@mr.smiley597]

Thank you! My fishy paleo-nerd self had to pause the video just to check that those fish were what I thought they were!!! It shows the makers of the film had an extra attention to detail I never noticed till now! Such a great movie!

[@garg4531]

I always wondered about those coelacanths

[@ikarosuasutoreaAKB48]

Actually the Coelacanth was rediscovered before the movie in 1938

[@benjaminaskren9075]

@@ikarosuasutoreaAKB48 I think they are confusing the year the movie was released (2001) and the year the movie is set (1914)

[@Pellimori]

Can I add that Cookie called one of the spices "cilantro" when it was still called coriander and would continue to be such for several more years?

[@Steven-xt3sn]

Atlantis the lost empire is my favourite underrated Disney movie. It should have gotten a lot more love back in the day. Kida deserves to be recognized as an official Disney Princess.

[@ganema9]

Especially considering that most Disney Princesses aren't even remotely princesses.

[@celestialstar6450]

Kida is a Queen, not a Princess

[@lilashj14]

@@celestialstar6450so is Elsa but she’s still considered a “Disney princess”

[@audreyglass3125]

@@lilashj14 Actually neither Elsa or Anna are Disney Princesses and it's not even because they both become queens, it's because Frozen was so financially successful that it became its own franchise separate from the Disney Princess franchise. The only reason the Disney Princess label exists is for marketing. And it's why Kida wasn't included, because Atlantis wasn't profitable enough so they don't consider her a marketable character.

[@pkmnan00bis]

*More You Know* - Kida was not only part of the Disney Princess line but the first character made specifically for it. Disney wanted an original character to be the face of the franchise. So Kida was in and they released some Disney Princess merch with her throughout the 2000s. Disney even wanted to keep Kida in the 2010s revamp which removed the less popular characters. They made a modern redesign, but dropped her from the line because she was not a popular with their test audiences. That people weren't even aware that this happened suggests they were onto something.

[@angelinapetersen7422]

There are so many hilarious moments before they even get to Atlantis in this movie that I forgot about until I re-watched it recently. Sweets holding up two giant beakers and telling Milo I'm going to need you to fill these up and Milo spits out the thermometer and replies "WITH WHAT" before the scene just moves on

[@Flt.Hawkeye]

Oh my 4o' clock appointent.

[@brettbarnard4501]

6:13, needed to sin the fact that Mole's dirt collection includes flags for Pakistan (1947), post-Mussolini Italy (1946), and post-1945 era Germany when the movie is explicitly set in 1914.

[@DrTannin9155]

He did say "spanning the centuries!" So... maybe?

[@Shane-hx4xp]

@@DrTannin9155Mole is a time traveler. Or at least the dirt is.

[@DH-xw6jp]

What, you actually expect a channel started so they can point out inconsistencies in movies to actually be able to do their job instead of being sarcastic knobs?

[@hannahbanana7723]

You should've been on Sheldon Cooper's show about flags. This is impressive!

[@MeNoOther]

The real 4 basic food groups of Beans, Bacon, Whiskey, and Lard We cannot live without them

[@trinaq]

I adored this movie growing up, and always found it underrated. Casting Michael J. Fox, one of the most likable actors of all time, as Milo, is also a huge bonus.

[@LazzyVamples]

I suggest rewatching it as an adult if you haven't. For me it was even better as an adult.

[@ceeb420]

​@@LazzyVamplesWatched it in college with some friends under the infleunce of some greenery, and the whole time, someone would randomly chime in "this movie rocks" lmao

[@JoannaMcCullough-n9n]

"Boring" animation of the submerging submarine? You ok Cinemasins?

[@kimi7396]

They haven't been good for a while! Go watch Cinemawins instead - at least they care and don't have to make up lies to try proving their own point. :P

[@samuelmeasa9283]

Every Cinemasins employ has to fill out a "10 movies I want to see ripped" list. Those files are then put on file to be pulled from when they need to fill out a slow season. Someone was bound to have listed every Disney movie from 90's threw 00's. I know I would have done that as a way to spite my sisters who had to watch those again and again till the tape died. Then they moved on to the next movie.

[@alvaroperez2349]

It saddens me that this movie didn’t get the recognition it deserves.

[@DeathsAvarice]

Same, loved this and the sequel when I was younger

[@catfishhunter9642]

It's getting the best recognition it can get right here! 😅😅😂😂

[@guilhermehank4938]

Maybe its for the better, far less likely to get "modernized"

[@alvaroperez2349]

@@guilhermehank4938 you know what? Fair point.

[@jakushkadarkstalker6278]

@@DeathsAvarice The "sequel" is actually the start of a tv show but all the episodes got put together for a "movie"

[@lordoberon22]

0:45 I think the reason Kida's mother wasn't released was bc it likely took way more energy/life force to power the shields during the cataclysm + sinking of the city, ultimately taking too much of a toll and killing her. Alternatively, when Kida was used, she just had to raise the city, which likely consumed much less energy. My head canon lol

[@CIoudStriker]

Also, it's confirmed that the Heart is sentient, so it very well could have been a conscious punishment for the then-rulers of Atlantis. Kida, acting out of a will to protect, would not warrant that.

[@alexaltenberger7324]

@@CIoudStriker i kinda headcanon that, with that mentioned sentience, kida's mom played a part in releasing her daughter from the heart, with only the returned bracelet as evidence of her being still alive in there..

[@TheQue5tion]

Nah you gotta remove a sin for creating an entire fictional language. That's dedication to story and to consistency. Also a clear sign that this movie was made for nerds, instead of the usual target audience of those who want fart jokes and one dimensional characters.

[@josh113866]

Nah, this channel isn't like that any more. Even if they do actually remove one, they just add another one back on for the same thing.

[@LordSvzklx]

Eh, conlangs are two a penny these days. Even back then, not that uncommon

[@MrDARKJAK]

And speaking of fart jokes, that one with the beans is the cleverest one i’ve ever heard, I had no clue that was the joke lol

[@OkayYaraman]

Except this movie does have a bunch of fart jokes and one-dimensional characters. But I agree on the sin.

[@sadaasdafa8635]

I feel Cinemasins was a little harsh. Sure, it’s satirical and we shouldn’t take it seriously but I felt he had some genuine dislike for it in his comments. This movie got me into Jules Verne as a child - a steampunk/dieselpunk adventure with beautifully designed but plausible vehicles, unusually diverse array of characters for it’s time, a lovely art style and even an entire language and script invented by the guy who used to do Star Trek languages. This was Disney trying something different other than another musical story based of a story or novel someone else came up with. A lot of effort went into crafting this world, even if elements of the story didn’t quite fit in place. It’ll always be one of my formative childhood movies.

[@theenchantedceiling]

Yeah, there were more than a few sins where I was not loving this. It’s like dude refused to like any part of the awesomeness of this movie. The animation was beautiful and the details are great to look at and yet the sins piled on

[@joyholmes254]

@@theenchantedceilingthe fact that he sinned the guy for making his own language for this movie when JRR Tolkien did the same for The Lord of the Rings book series. That should not have been a sin because it takes a lot of work to be able to create your own language

[@MrIsleNFair]

2:50 This resolves your critics. He definitely poured out his subjectivity

[@stargirl7646]

To be fair, I watched this movie for the first time as an adult and was disappointed. The premise was cool but I felt like they really messed up a lot of the execution. The pacing felt rushed, tons of characters with only minimal backstory (I had the same reaction to the sudden fireside backstory-sposition as CS did), and plot holes galore. It was okay, but I had really wanted it to be great. I dunno if it would have been different if I’d grown up with it as a kid or not

[@volichristo]

@@stargirl7646 To be Fair. The movie was cut short in many places due to Disney leadership at the time saying the movie went on for too long. So in their effort to make it shorter Many other scenes were cut out. I have to agree with some of the things above. Felt like CS was way too harsh on this one.

[@quadcannon]

7:04 sinning them for a shot from a movie made 9 years later? That seems pretty sinful to me.

[@shawnpayne4383]

So glad someone else caught that too!

[@galaxyeyes1457]

t h a t ‘ s t h e j o k e

[@thebarbaryghostsf]

Did it for Avatar and Inception lol

[@hiddendesire3076]

10:52 One of the writers posted Mole’s backstory online some years back. Essentially comes down to him being an heir of some noble family who suffered from light sensitivity and something else. As his behavior in front of guests was detrimental to the family’s reputation, he was restricted to the lower cellar of the estate during the daytime. He eventually became infatuated with some moles that had burrowed into his room in the cellar, as they were like him and he gained an interest in tunneling. One day his father awakes to the gardener panicking about a large beast being spotted on the grounds at night and leaving large holes which leads him to investigate with several others, all armed. What they encounter, however, was his dirt covered son having just burrowed up into one of the flowerbeds. So it is pretty much a story of a boy with light sensitive skin that can develop a rash and flake off like dandruff, became the black sheep of his noble family and was treated like an animal stuck in the cellar away from everyone, becoming obsessed with moles and tunneling.

[@PanSpaceman]

his tragic and disturbing backstory is actually that he's french 👍

[@TheQue5tion]

​@@PanSpaceman I can guarantee that this will get a lot of likes from the English.

[@arilumani6194]

Geesh, no wonder Sweet said "Trust me on this one. You don't wanna know." when Milo asked about Mole's story and warned Audrey not to tell him. As a kid I always wondered what Mole's backstory was and why Sweet didn't want Milo to know it. Now I know why.

[@hiddendesire3076]

@@arilumani6194 I forget the name of the condition, but I think it had the nickname of “butterfly skin” because of how it flakes off. Might’ve been a different condition though. Did see a picture of some kid who had it before. Their skin was pale and where it was rash-like and blotchy, you could see the skin peeling. It was nasty and I felt sorry for them.

[@stargirl7646]

Okay is it sad that this is nowhere near as messed up as I expected lol??? Like this is sad but they acted like it was some super nightmarish story

[@zacharymccoy7091]

I do love the relationship between Milo and Kida. They don't even kiss, and you know they care so much for each other as a couple after everything they went through.

[@TheAllSeeingEye2468]

This movie and treasure planet deserves more love then and now

[@chazfreakshow]

I would also add Titan A.E. to that list.

[@LukeAImp]

13:01 To be fair, most cars actually do have little labels on the starters showing where to turn the key to start the engine, turn on the power, etc. And the push button ones typically say what to do on them as well

[@meliodasgloom1818]

With these being Military or at least Paramilitary vehicles they used for the expedition they do indeed have Dummy-proofed instructions to turn them on, standards for maintenance, and so on.

[@DH-xw6jp]

As do most industrial machines

[@antilatte235]

Mad there was no reverse slurp of the ding for the fish tank behind Prof. Whitmore containing Coelacanths, described as a living fossil, the movie is set in 1914 the coelacanth was still considered extinct, as a live one wouldn't be found until 1938 and it says SO MUCH about Whitmore being shady and having worldwide connections at least as far away, and as remote as small fishing communities in India

[@CurtisWhitehead-wn5bs]

I thought that's what they were.

[@joyholmes254]

India? Why India? They were found off the coast of South Africa

[@KettenSyndicate]

Did I somehow misunderstood, was it meant as a joke - or did he actually sin Atlantis for copying both Avatar and Inception, movies that came out years and years later?

[@Czigot]

It might have been a joke but it's hard to say, since that's their standard response to criticism.

[@thatman8562]

That was definitely a joke (see: the extended bit after mentioning Avatar); I should also note that I consider this whole channel a joke so I’m probably biased.

[@LordSvzklx]

A joke. CinemaSins are not legit criticism, they’d be the first to tell you that, so a lot of the sins they give are just supposed to be humorous jabs rather than actual critique

[@Mocita]

0:42 If she had looked, then she would've been blind like her father. The reason he's blind is because he didn't look away, and the last thing he saw was the Light.

[@TheQue5tion]

It's sad that some of the best animated films of the last 30 years flopped simply because there were no marketable character songs.

[@jsimon]

Sorry, Jeremy, but you get two sins for attributing "voulez-vous" to Patti Labelle when the artist is known just as "LaBelle" and when we all know the correct answer is ABBA because it's the title of the damn song. (ding-ding).

[@AtheistOrphan]

A-HA!

[@lord.greymoon]

Never forget about the Atlantis: The Lost Empire promotional chocolate cereal that had the Atlantian alphabet on them when they got wet.

[@onethousandroses]

Oh wow. This comment unlocked a memory of that cereal for me!

[@lord.greymoon]

@onethousandroses I miss them about as much as the cap'n crunch chocodonuts limited time cereal (and you're welcome for any time with helping you unlock long-forgotten memories 😊)

[@NerdFromColorado]

18:53 Correction: Helga did not survive that, nor at least it’s heavily implied that she didn’t. Its implied that she survived the initial fall but died from her injuries soon after.

[@kevinr.9733]

That and a giant balloon falling on her.

[@ananegg]

You ignored how this is just StarGate and Milo is Daniel Jackson

[@bemasaberwyn55]

THANK you

[@captjc]

Atlantis rips off StarGate so Stargate makes an entire series taking place in Atlantis. It all comes full circle.

[@ananegg]

@jdla2000 is that dem Japanese Cartoons?

[@AdmiralBlackstar]

Ya, but that was ancient Egypt, not Atlantis so...totally different.

[@ananegg]

@AdmiralBlackstar ahh ok, I thought all ancient cultures were the same. I guess they didn't invent chopsticks either?

[@kitsunekage12]

Did... did you mean 'everything great about Atlantis' with this video title? I'm just kind of having a hard time processing the idea of it being anything less than an animated masterpiece.

[@ithinkihadeight]

Make Kida A Real Disney Princess!

[@eclipsehorse8693]

According to Disney only humans can be princesses- she clearly is not, this is why Nala was never inducted as a princess either

[@thomasbyrne3569]

​@@eclipsehorse8693 Is she not human?

[@dontcare803]

@@eclipsehorse8693 how is kida not human? she is just from the city of atlantis, a city of you know, humans

[@eclipsehorse8693]

@@dontcare803 Spitballing here, but Im gonna guess- from Disney's standpoint, she's an alien race, not like humans.

[@dontcare803]

@@eclipsehorse8693 what, thats stupid. But disney gonna be disney

[@ThePhengophobe]

Man, these are starting to get abit lazy. The lever thing at 7:27 shouldn't HAVE to select line 4, Wilhelmina is a switchboard operator, much like how phones in the 1910s operate, she routed the transmission to his horn. And bitching about Milo's research being saved at 8:17 shows that the sin is lazy. This is an experienced exploration crew, when the whole thing hinges on one scholar's ability to find what you're looking for, you're gonna want to make sure you protect that guy and his notes so you can FIND the thing you're looking for. Especially when you then sin someone for mocking him for reading the book not 2 minutes later.

[@kimi7396]

They've been extremely lazy for a while. Sins has been literally fabricating 'sins' because they lost the plot and need to keep up the near contentfarm levels of uploads. Go give Cinemawins some love instead!

[@PrinceIsot]

This movie and Treasure Planet are Disney's most underrated animated films. Along with Lion King: Simba's Pride and Aladdin King of Thieves. Very underrated movies

[@theenchantedceiling]

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@theenchantedceiling]

Those four were some of my most watched as a kid. I was obsessed with Atlantis and Aladdin and the King of thieves.

[@galaxyeyes1457]

are you seriously comparing two theatrically-released original films with cheap direct-to-dvd sequels

[@Sean-eo8ns]

This channel deserves infinite sin for covering this wonderful gem

[@jordanbravo047]

Stop this is a fkn masterpiece

[@jordanbravo047]

Actually I haven’t seen it since I was a kid so it could be trash😭😂

[@anakelly76512]

​@@jordanbravo047 It's definitely not trash. It's loads better than the woke trash Disney is coming out with nowadays. Like "Snow White". I think that movie is going to flop badly.

[@jordanbravo047]

@ definitely Disney been going downhill I can see that too and I gotta go back and rewatch it, I remember one with like 2 dudes in Egypt that was good too but I think that’s dreamworks

[@Lukeharperdeadlmao]

@@anakelly76512🫵🏾🤓

[@eclipsehorse8693]

@@jordanbravo047 'Prince of Egypt' and 'Road to El Dorado' were both Dreamworks pics...

[@chickenman-kf5qs]

Atlantis and Treasure Island are underrated honestly. The fact they never got their own franchise made me lose trust in critics, they not always right, but the audience does.

[@samrichens2962]

5:52 shut up cinema man

[@TheWarmachine375]

0:23 It's scary to imagine that there was an army of Leviathans and one of them easily took out many ships before destroying the submarine carrier that transported Milo and the expeditionary force to Atlantis.

[@thomaswillard6267]

1:30 it isn't a cryptograph for English, it is runes translated to English. So the "c" in iceland making an /s/ sound wouldn't use the same character is the "c" in coast making the /k/ sound

[@Finchspielberg]

Ikeland

[@Xicxwingless]

I let out an audible gasp of shock when I saw this... I have loved your content and I applaud your services and insight... You have fired a blast across my bow with this one... This movie is near and dear to my heart. You have one shot to get this right. I am pausing my whole day to watch and appreciate this video, now. May you have more respect than history did for this movie. I will reply with my thoughts below after.

[@AlexisVandom]

"He will not." *ding*

[@SigurTibbs]

This is one of the best animated movies of that era. Absolutely loved it as a kid, still love it as an adult.

[@hazeltifiaeh6196]

11:19 Atlantis came out before Avatar so really Avatar copied Atlantis.

[@Gsxrchick79]

Didn't Inception come out later than this too?

[@galaxyeyes1457]

r/whoosh

[@Flt.Hawkeye]

This movie deserved so much better. The dialogues are just so packed with love for the characters and are all so well written.

[@WarpChaos]

This movie is so underrated and one of the few Disney films that actually deserves a live action remake.

[@LostGeburah]

facts! right along with treasure planet.

[@WarpChaos]

@LostGeburah And The Black Cauldron.

[@01134man]

100

[@Zyk0th]

But they actually need to be respectful with their live-action remake. Disney has made many exceptional movies but the live-action remakes of their classics are more often than not, lazy, low-effort cash grabs that kinda rely on you having seen the original to understand half the plot.

[@theshield2004]

“Our lives are remembered by the gifts we leave our children.”

[@Alphasnowbordergirl]

I actually love this movie, especially as I got older. Kida should be a princess. And if Mulan gets to be one, so should Esmerelda. These women were amazing, strong willed, and could take care of themselves without Disney shoving it down your throat about female empowerment. Kida was a warrior, a queen, could rock climb, and carries a knide on her. Esmerelda, stood up for justice, protected her people, and dealt with unwanted advances while being kind and still very feminine. They were actually fun to watch.

[@tjsMAR]

How dare you sin this movie! It is a work of art and a staple of every 30 year olds childhood!

[@VaciliNikoMavich]

This movie is my absolute favorite ❤ One of the only times Disney grew up, and didn’t do a lame sing-along. Also Dieselpunk-Steampunk hybrid worlds rule!

[@Phaota]

Why do you keep saying the movie is stealing from Avatar when it is the other way around?

[@Sera666]

Exactly, Avatar released 8 years later, came directly to the comments to see if someone mentioned that

[@galaxyeyes1457]

r/whoosh

[@Sera666]

@@galaxyeyes1457 It's not a woosh, the joke was stupid

[@TheWarmachine375]

1:01 Wakanda: "Look what they needed to mimic a fraction of our power!"

[@Zahok1]

This and Treasure Planet are goats of awesomeness that were killed in the battle of 3D bullcrap. Still watch these two all the time.

[@Doomrider47]

The irony in this statement is that the animation that this and Treasure Planet used was a mesh between 3d modeling and animation. Tarzan also used the same techniques, was also why production was VERY expensive and may have fed into why Disney wanted the first two to fail so the animators didn't have the leverage to insist on more widespread adoption

[@firefighter5559]

I don't know whether to dislike the video because you said this movie is boring, or Like it because you actually did Atlantis.... guess I'll like it.

[@cameroncritendon9967]

You say this movie ripped off those movies, but this movie was released before those movies. If anything, those movies took inspiration from this one.

[@Xicxwingless]

1:47 Sooooo Milo likes preserving history and he winces when someone destroys a bit of ancient history. Look at what happened to all the Mummies around the 19th century and you may get an idea as to why Milo was "hiding" the mummy in the corner of his office.... Especially when all the museum administration was there...

[@LCCWPresents]

Actual sin 183, the planes and weaponry brought by Milo and company are between 5 to 40 years too advanced for 1910 technology (the submarine is definitely a nuclear submarine if not a giant gas/desiel submarine, the airplanes in the fight scene are at least 1915 aircraft that shouldn’t be able to string together that quickly, and the gas masks are definitely later ww1 design after a few unsuccessful models went through trail and error on the western front.).

[@jessegorman8265]

Audrey actually mentions the submarine having boilers, which should have suffocated everyone by using up all the oxygen on board.

[@balrighty3523]

5:55 Incorrect! Those forty seconds deserve a sin off! I like this movie, especially on an aesthetic basis, but one of its biggest weaknesses is how fast-paced the dialogue is. Every minute up to this point is crammed with as much speaking as possible when they really needed to take a moment a few times, have everyone shut up for just a second, and be in the moment. This shot of the sub descending was a breath of fresh air! The movie could easily have stood being five to ten minutes longer, adding absolutely no additional dialogue anywhere, and just using that time to let us get to know the characters without it being forcibly crammed down our throats.

[@benderrodriguez7372]

As a jaded kid who was easily bored by musical pieces this is one of my favorite Disney movies.

[@LCCWPresents]

Actually sin 176 should be that because this film takes place in 1910, the Kaiser wouldn’t be viewed as an evil boogeyman by the international community and Milo should’ve thought of a historical figure more horrifying for the time like the king of Belgium, or if he was British he would’ve more likely said the tsar of Russia.

[@LordSvzklx]

Eh, while we might see Leopold II’s atrocities in Belgium as worse than anything Kaiser Wilhelm had done up to that point, all the European powers were up to similar shady colonial stuff so couldn’t really criticise. Leopold was also fairly sane, authoritarian but sane, while Wilhelm was a mercurial imperialist who so demonstrably could not be trusted that Russia and Britain ended their feud purely so they could both focus on curtailing German expansion. Was Wilhelm -the- bogeyman du jour in 1910? Maybe not, but not did he exactly have the best rep so it’s not unrealistic for Milo to use him

[@Cakebraincat]

Time to watch the Sins of one of my favorite movies of all time

[@ScientistCat]

The biggest sin about this movie is how underrated it was.

[@yodelingllamas1145]

I wholeheartedly believe that Whitmore was a secret villain in the movie. He knew what Rork and the rest of the team did on the other missions, and he obviously profited greatly from it. He was totally willing to expend Milo for the chance to sell limitless power to the highest bidder.

[@robertcowley8512]

This, Treasure Planet and even some of Don Bluth's flicks like Titan A.E. deserve live action remakes.

[@whatduck943]

I would love a live action Titian AE!!

[@galaxyeyes1457]

please no

[@martinschnelle3077]

I loved this movie from the first time I saw it. Atlantis combined with steampunk - I got it on DVD the day it was released. Only thing to criticize IMHO is that they took indeed quite a lot of equipment with them when fleeing the Nautilus in only some minutes.

[@Drews2923]

Subscribed to you back in 2014. Glad you’re still going strong✊🏾

[@starbrand3726]

Ah you missed a sin. This movie is supposed to take place in 1914, but...bubble gum wasn't invented until 1928. Also, also, Avatar came out in 2009, while Atlantis came out in 2001, so... Avatar copied off of Atlantis not the other way around. And Avatar basically stole its plot from Dances with Wolves (but that's another story.)

[@NZBigfoot]

Not to mention copies to hell and back the sci-fi story 'Call me Joe'... hell its got blue cat people being piloted with a neural link by a guy in a wheel chair for crying out loud, how 'you copied this' can you get...

[@caroltawil]

Love when Cinemasins show that they’re a bunch of Trekkies 🖖🏻 7:37 7:53 12:06

[@sane_scientist]

given that this is quite possibly the best disney movie ever made im sinning you for every sin you gave the movie cinema sins sins: 197

[@jennaheiser625]

This movie deserves many more sins off, sir.

[@bertcarroll1243]

You finally did this movie it’s been 25 years. I’ve been waiting.😅

[@Gamer3427]

Remember when CinemaSins bothered with actually critiquing cliches instead of just being spiteful about every little thing and making up excuses to slap "sins" everywhere? Me neither, but I feel they've become addicted to to the sound of the ding so much Pavlov wonders why he bothered experimenting on dogs.

[@jameshill4589]

His job is to be the movie snob who constantly points out stupid and meaningless inconsistencies to the point of annoyance. So in short he did his job

[@Gamer3427]

@@jameshill4589 The thing is though, they've started doing a lot more "this isn't even an inconsistency, I just wasn't paying attention to something that was said two seconds ago" sins, and a lot of times they just go off on a tangent or complain about something that has nothing to do with the movie. They've always done that to a degree, but as time has gone on, it's become a lot more frequent.

[@jameshill4589]

@Gamer3427 fair point

[@ShadowsightSolos]

I’m so glad you’re FINALLY reviewing this film!

[@craftynerdybookish]

…THAT WAS A FART JOKE?!?! I’ve had this movie in VHS since it released and have watched it an innumerable number of times and I didn’t notice until 2025!

[@Zangetsuv2]

One more sin; Milo never went back for his pet cat.

[@FrancistheBrave]

I remembered seeing this movie in the theater back in the day. I fell in love with it. Instant classic along with Disney's tarzan and Treasure Planet. 😊

[@cpljimmyneutron]

Your comment on pastel ink... You are so spot on, that Sherlock Holmes (yes fictional but still) once identified exactly where a person had been based solely on light pink tattoo ink. To bring it more modern day... black paint, like the kind you can get at Lowes, Home Depot, or Walmart... only came out 30 years ago.

[@noranishikawa7271]

I remember being so obsessed with this movie as a kid. I still love it to this day. My favorite underrated Disney gem 💎. Treasure Planet is too.

[@AngrierGuy]

How are people commenting hours ago when this was released a minute before

[@KillerKitty317]

Do they have a membership system with early access?

[@AngrierGuy]

@@KillerKitty317 maybe

[@Klishar122]

KZbin memberships.

[@JoeyP946]

don't buy youtube membership. Yt sucks lol

[@TerriMorganDishife]

This movie and My Fair Lady are the reason I became a linguist. It's still my favorite Disney film today because a linguist is the hero. ^~^

[@heatherlowry754]

A unique, imaginative movie with a distinct animation style. All sins removed I love this movie, and along with Spirited Away, sparked my love of animation

[@wolfey1579]

This movie never got the credit truly deserved. This was such a good movie in my opinion

[@VanchaMarch2]

Also, when Milo speaks Latin to Kida (which makes no sense at all obviously) it’s grammatically incorrect. In the context of the conversation, Milo uses the vocative case when he should have used the nominative, and Kida uses the future tense instead of the present

[@Stonecrow99]

this was an incredible film to watch as a kid, good visuals, good story, good characters and good va

[@dillonbuford]

I'm just now realizing how much this takes from Stargate and The Mummy.

[@rainestar82]

My entire life loving this movie and I genuinely didnt know they worked hard with the Atlantean writing

[@SimpleGunner]

i love this movie SO much, and so i agree with these sins. this movie deserves so much more love. and kida should be a disney princess, or queen.

[@robertmorris8997]

Rhode Island COULD be a city in Texas. It's so dinky.

[@prenticeandrew11]

Aww man, it's a sin just to sin this one. Best Disney movie ever made.

[@LittleBlueReviews400]

FINALLY! Tell Me I’m not the only one who’s been waiting for them to Cover/Sin on this.

[@svilenvasilev3819]

Jeremy, sin “Maximum Overdrive !🤟🏻🤣

[@MidwesternDiva]

If this movie had come out 10 years later when steampunk was becoming trendy, it would’ve gotten the love it deserved.

[@Thaylien]

Sinning Cinema Sins: Concentrates on the switch that goes between 'speaking and listening' and ignores the other lines that are hanging in the background behind this one, which are lines 1 through 3. "Helga survives this." She does not. "Standing this close to a fire." Is not nearly hot enough to make you scream or think your flesh is melting.

[@amanyhossam5437]

An awesome underrated movie uploaded 1 min ago while I am trying to find something to watch while eating?! Niceee

[@themischiefman]

FINALLLYYYYY IVE BEEN WANTING THIS FOR SO LONG!!!!!!

[@BVictoria_]

Just put this movie on to feel nostalgic, then this pops up 😅This movie had me obsessed with gems, stones and marbles growing up. Such a beautiful gem that deserves more recognition, especially Kida as a Disney's princess. I wish they took a different route for the sequel (I liked it, just feel the tone was too different)

[@joyholmes254]

That’s because it was the pilot of the TV series they had planned.

[@iAmRaaP]

11:19 Atlantis: The Lost Empire 2001 Avatar 2009 Technically Avatar copied Atlantis.

[@galaxyeyes1457]

gee whiz it’s almost as if that was an intentional joke

[@iAmRaaP]

@ went over my head 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@Douglas_Props]

This movie is perfection

[@deantasaeran8883]

Rourke stood on that particular spot in the pool because he figured out the riddle in the journal, "The Heart of Atlantis lies in the eyes of her king" When Rourke sat on the throne (where the king would normally sit) he realized the phrase was meant literally. The entrance to the crystal chamber was directly in his sight, "lies in the eyes of her king" = is directly in front of a person seated on the throne.

[@Saternalia]

7:40 actually the sin here is for that being a crevasse not a crevice

[@samuelmeasa9283]

This movie takes bits from Star Gate, 20,000 Leagues, Star Wars, Voyage to the Center of the Earth, Dances with Wolves, Riders in the Sky, Nadia: the secrete of Blue Water, He-man... I may have had to watch this to often when working retail and made so many connections to other series.

[@Spooky_Spookerson]

This movie is great and I am tired of pretending that it isn't!

[@Margot_est_douce.]

This content is amazing! I'm hooked!

[@maksimvolkov5233]

3:25 My personal sin is that, in my opinion, Michael J. Fox delivered that line about claiming everything too calmly.