Everything Wrong With CinemaSins: The Star Wars Interquel Duology: Solo and Rogue One

[@Th3Birdman]

Everything Wrong With The Sequel Trilogy: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pZ6uZIN9YtZ3jpo Patreon: www.patreon.com/Th3Birdman Twitter: twitter.com/Th3birdman15 Instagram: instagram.com/Th3Birdman15/ Discord Invite Code: nQZRn5m Subreddit: reddit.com/r/Th3Birdman Facebook: facebook.com/Th3Birdman15

[@jono3175]

What’s the intro song

[@Darth-vade123]

Jeremy is painful to watch

[@latorasmith]

Nice touch at 11:11 (based on the sin timer the KZbin timer reads 11:51) referencing to one of cinema sin's first and most recognizable sins

[@tonyacosta4574]

Lol u think that guy Jeremy knows where a gym is

[@Th3Birdman]

@@erikbihari3625 Are you so easily swayed that you believe that? Hahaha. Hang tight.

[@JohnGenericName]

The wildest part of the exhaust port being called an "obvious, stupid weak spot" is that an entire moon-sized space station only has one exhaust port that poses a security threat. That is an incredible feat of engineering, especially when it's a space station that fires a massive laser with enough energy to destroy a planet. Gaming PCs even have trouble with managing heat sometimes and they're not energy weapons.

[@Phoenix2312]

Canonically, There are MUTIPLE Exhausts... Not just one, There was only ONE that would be Vulnerable though! The REAL Irony of the "Obvious, Stupid Weak Spot" is that - And funnily you are on the right track mentioning Gaming PC's... NOTHING IS EVER PERFECT! The Titanic was a master of engineering design, But it still sank! The German Tiger Tank was DEVESTATING, but weak as shit on it's rear! F-14 Tomcats are AWESOME but drink fuel like a bitch! And ONE EXHAUST PORT leading to the reactor... On a Space Station as large as a Small Moon... With BILLIONS of Canons, TIE Fighters, Missiles, and numerous other defences... Much like all the above, The Empire did NOT CONSIDER something so small to be a significant risk! The Tiger Tank as I said was DEVESTATING! A Truly remarkable piece of 2nd World War Hardware that Allies were deeply afraid of! Had the Titanic been crewed better - It might never have sank! and F-14's are still used by the US Air Force as despite the fuel consumption, They are amazing machines!!! One Small Negatable Flaw does not mean you should tear everything apart and start all over again! Hell, the amount of Weapons on the Death Star - The fact the Rebels even managed to get CLOSE to that Exhaust port at all is a BLOODY MIRACLE! It was Guerrilla War tactics, Had Luke not had the Force - Yavin 4 would have been DESTROYED and the Empire would have WON! The Rebel force LOST MOST OF ITS PILOTS just getting to the damn thing! Hence whenever I hear someone say "RoUgE oNe fIxEd ThAt PlOt HoLe FrOm A NeW HoPe" - I WANT TO BEAT THEIR F**KING HEADS IN! IT WAS NEVER A PLOT HOLE... IT WAS A PLOT CONTRIVENCE!!! The one time where Jeremy Scott could have said DEUS EX MACHINA and it would have been CORRECT!!! (and Yeah, I love Star Wars.. I love it WAY TOO MUCH that I actually studied that scene to determine if it was a Plot hoe or not... I studied History to make sure I was right... I studied Military Tactics I NEED TO GET A LIFE!!!)

[@ultrabigfella]

@@Phoenix2312 bruh

[@francisoffilth7953]

@@ultrabigfella hey the man definitely has some knowledge

[@takayamuramoto4490]

It isn´t even a weak spot, because it makes a 90° turn after a few kilometres so that the shot could only be done by a sufficiently strong force user, the only ones out in the open being on the imperial side.

[@Vikt0rian]

Even more impressive considering that the real science behind the Death Star would turn all the people inside of it into paste. So somehow they overcame this insane engineering feat as well.

[@thelaughingrouge]

"There is literally no reason for the death star to cause an eclipse before blowing up the planet." My guy, literally EVERYTHING the empire does is about creating FEAR and a sudden eclipse for no reason is scary AF!

[@zacharyfrierson6972]

Exactly. Remember the giant walkers they used for Hoth? As Birdman said: "Seeing a giant, lumbering mechanical monster walking towards you is supposed to break your will and make you want to give up. That's the point."

[@Chuck_EL]

@@zacharyfrierson6972 Remember Jeremy "sinned" Grand Moff Tarkin blowing up alderran as "overkill" As birdman said "That's the point !!!" He did it because he knew it was Leia's home planet and her parents were still on that planet Then, her "Royal monarch" demeanour changed once he threatened to blow it up, so he pulled her emotional strings and broke her will... Something the empire and Darth Vader were KNOWN for doing to get the point across not to mess with them (even Mon monthra points this out in a new hope and return of the Jedi )

[@willer3399]

Not to mention they’ll be able to see the beam coming at them with the sun eclipsed.

[@eclipse7393]

also it just looks cool as fuck why WOULDN'T you want to do that in a movie

[@dallonpainter2674]

That's like asking why Vader and Palpatine wear all black, it's to look menacing

[@LilRedDog]

I know you are "just poking fun" but you are what I look forward to see every time CS posts an EWW video.

[@SpikeC91]

Same

[@DIESEL0725]

Real talk lol!

[@AnansiTheLibra]

💯

[@Dgjserffft]

Fr

[@HobbitOfChaos]

I’m excited for the morbis one

[@therealwilldalbey]

I think the whole "12 parsecs" thing is because the Kessel Run is curved. And the minimum safe curve is twenty parsecs. However, Han decided to beeline and cut the curve, shaving off at least 6 parsecs.

[@ingvarkarlson5982]

as far as I'm aware the kessel run is close to a black hole. so the 12 parsec thing from a new hope isn't han saying "look how fast I can go!" but more like "look how to closer to danger I can get without dying!"

[@Xpwnxage]

@@williamshelton4318 I'm fairly certain the I read before that in the original 77 script, Han made his usual 12 parsec comment and Obiwan rolled his eyes to imply that Han was bullshiting and Obi knew that.

[@lexark]

@@williamshelton4318 because lucas was just using sciency sounding words (like he did with insults ("laser brain")).

[@ptassa270]

I want to believe that Jeremy in real life is different from how he acts in his videos, but it gets harder to do so with how these videos are.

[@BrickedUpp]

Maybe at one point he was. But this persona took over and now he’s just this everywhere. He believes he’s smarter than everyone because he was the first to “sin” movies

[@matthewodle]

@@BrickedUpp and here I thought Eve was the original sinner

[@SpringDavid]

@@matthewodle Eve is cringe, Adam was too innocent. Actually no, both of them were too innocent

[@jlev1028]

I mean, he does write books which I heard are pretty good. But his CinemaSins persona is indeed obnoxious.

[@WandererEris]

@@jlev1028 The Ables is an absolute disaster.

[@andymac4883]

29:45 I'm pretty sure I said it in the original video, but I'll say it here too; in her recorded message in ANH, Leia says "my ship has come under attack, and I fear my mission TO BRING YOU TO ALDERAAN has failed." It's there in the very first Star Wars film, that she was on the way to Alderaan via Tatooine so that she could pick up Obi-Wan.

[@timcirulis5273]

Yes CinemaSins never change because you allow birdman to make superior content.

[@whunt5533]

Holy shoot you just made me realize why the exhaust port was a vulnerable point for the dethstar its not obvious to people who don't know how kyber crystals work. They wouldn't be able to shield an exhaust port and all galan would need to do is make sure that the exhaust port leads to part of the crystal.

[@mjf69]

I love that he complains about her costume having "double swords" having seen no implication she knows how to use them. A. It's literally a costume. B. As you pointed out they weren't swords. C. He then complains that she doesn't use them.............................You JUST complained you've seen no reason she could use double swords, now you're asking for her to use double swords??!?!?!?!?

[@lobaandrade7172]

Am I the only one who actually really liked Solo? It felt like a western movie but set in the SW universe

[@Cameron19]

I actually enjoyed Solo as well. It was definitely a tone of fun

[@ogrimzyz8643]

Yeah I’ve seen it’s got mixed reviews but I really enjoyed it

[@LightingbladeShen]

Each time Jeremy posts a video i just picture Birdman sitting there, grabbing his streetfighter and going: "how many times must I teach you this lesson you hypocrite!" and I'm all for it!

[@Chuck_EL]

OF COURSE!!!

[@optillian4182]

I'm still of the opinion that Solo is highly underrated.

[@maxschaeffer7228]

W Opinion

[@whunt5533]

It would've been except they use it to turn han into a joke and a shit pilot. Watch the film theroy episode on it

[@lexark]

@@whunt5533 shit pilot? id like to see 90% of the pilots in star wars do what he did in that movie. besides, he was still relatively new at it. not quite as experience as we see him in the OT

[@RongusCongus]

i never bothered watching it until like 2 months ago, bro it's so good. The only thing I didn't like was the goofy droid romance plot with Lando

[@Xpwnxage]

I'm with ya

[@123RADIOactive]

I swear, many of the people who still likes Cinemasins and still think Jeremy is right are likely the same demographic who ate tide pods……..

[@joehung1552]

I know someone who thought Cascade pods were Sushi.

[@capitancoolness942]

Hey that's my generation!!

[@luigiboi4244]

*Gooooood... The series is complete. You have done well, Darth Penguin.*

[@butcherpete2286]

Mad props to the Birdman for churning out the quality content lately. I'm 100% here for it

[@RowdyBrian17]

They've all been reuploads except for Batman

[@butcherpete2286]

@@RowdyBrian17 still quality content

[@KyloRenmcgoo]

31:04 may be among the dumbest things Jeremy has ever said, glad you called out how ridiculous that sin was

[@MsWillowbayOrelse]

OMG Obi-Wan poppin up to say "Hello There" after you said "Ever hear of Disney+" Killed it!!

[@destructo-pizzatv2263]

Day 108 of telling th3birdman I appreciate his content

[@markusafri2343]

So you're like typing a comment every day even tho he's not uploading? You should follow him on Twitter that seems much easier

[@destructo-pizzatv2263]

@@markusafri2343 no not every day that would be way too difficult it's only when he uploads

[@whatthefilmwtf7171]

In the original movie they said it was an exhaust port and said that there were multiple but that one was the biggest so it wasn't a flaw it was necessary for it

[@Phoenix2312]

Ummmmmmm... Nah, You could say it was a flaw, and it is never stated in A New Hope that its the biggest - Only that it is the least well defended! But even then, The Rebels lost almost every pilot... Had it not been for Luke, Han and of course the Force - Yavin 4 would have been DUST! There were so many Anti-Aircraft weapons across the Death Star the Rebel Fleet was Decimated! They engaged in the only option they had - Guerrilla warfare tactics, Do or Die! The Rebel fleet had no choice! Without Luke, The story would have ended in DEATH! One of the only times Jeremey Scott could have shouted DEUS EX MACHINA and it would for once have been CORRECT! The Death Star Exhaust Port has NEVER been a Plot hole and never needed to be explained, It was a Plot CONTRIVENCE!

[@cedbanani]

I used to watch CinemaSins a lot. But as time went by, I started to notice that their sins were not making sense. I am glad this channel is here to point that out.

[@JadeAislin]

To this day I still find it funny that my dad didn't realize Rogue One was a prequel to chapter 4. We were watching it at the movie theater and it took him between half and 3/4ths of the movie for him to realize this fact. I spent the first half of the movie trying not to giggle. "What's Darth Vader doing in this movie? I thought he was dead? Are they building a new death star?"

[@reallybadgamer2602]

Making a movie and cinemasins reviewing is like eating moldy bread. Either you throw up or you get food poisoning there is no winning. You're the immune system that doesn't make you sick so good job

[@dinglebloopynoop5053]

Honestly BP, I would love to have the crunching for “padding the sin count” sins, made them 10x funnier

[@ForemostCrab7]

Watching a Star Wars related video while playing SWTOR, perfection.

[@worstwordmonger]

Interesting point you made about the common “I already know what will happen” argument for prequels. I recently heard that when talking to someone about Kenobi, and the direction I went with is that most shows you pretty much know the hero and villain are going to stay alive. Sure other shows that prove they have the guts to prove the characters are not safe tend to be much better but those are a rare gem

[@TheCynicalCommentator]

32:32 I probably would’ve said “sinning this scene” Probably one of the most badass scenes in Star Wars.

[@wyattcastle7225]

I want to see the alternate universe where Han Solo in Solo: A Star Wars Story is played by Danny Pudi.

[@M0b1us_118]

I’d say the same for Leonardo DiCaprio.

[@tomsenior7405]

Cheers Th3Birdman. Excellent job, as ever. Cinema Sins failed to tear "Solo - A Some What Movie" a new one. Such ineptitude deserves at least a Dozen Wilhelm Screams. I can't wait to hear Jeremy's take on 'Uncanny Valley Leah' next... I have A New Hope that Jeremy will mess that up as well. I have a Very Bad feeling about Jeremy's abilities. Help me Th3Birdman, you're my only...

[@shrezii843]

the music in the intro is the perfect type of music for this movie, retro and sci fi but it still has that underground beat. its like an alien drill beat

[@TheDudeWhoWalks]

Love how Jeremy worries about clothing hangars even though there are ships and floating speeders, wtf? Like they can just be using stuff like for speeders

[@jameslambert5198]

By the way, due to Star Wars the Force Unleashed, initially released in 2008 that (which is to be considered somewhat canon due to the start of the Alliance and killing of most of the remaining Jedi) Kyber Crystals are a thing. Maybe they were introduced earlier but they did get featured in that game. And we're called that by name. It's like how in Jurassic Park the Game, it was the first time the volcano was mentioned or named. That would be then used in the sequel trilogy. Some parts of games are to be considered canon. However that does imply a few other weird stuff is canon.

[@kaigen999]

I actually like how Vader sounds in rogue one better than the original trilogy. Sounds deeper and more intimidating

[@pyronuke4768]

Jeremy hates fanservice, in spite of how much he uses it in his own videos

[@morganyoung3557]

Did CinemaSins think it was impossible for the Death Star to cause a solar eclipse when a solar eclipse is caused by the moon blocking out a star like the sun and it has been established that in the very first Star Wars movie that the Death Star is about the size of a moon? Somebody should have pointed out about how stupid he was going to sound if he left that sin it.

[@supersaiyanbino]

17:55 When you go back to a beginner dungeon and you have endgame gear

[@christ-abel8774]

"Everything Wrong With Solo, ladies and gentlemen... “Okay, so check this out: there are vehicles in this movie... and there are vehicles in another movies! Isn't that outrageous??”" I don't know why this line makes me laugh so hard 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@pivotguydc1149]

That's the official name of these movies now. The "Interquel Duology". ID for short.

[@camiloiribarren1450]

Time to save the Galaxy and fly the Millennium Falcon all Solo Sentence: Thats great, Kid! Don’t get cocky!

[@mattway18]

Director C. Sins: “So, I’m still in command?” Darth Penguin: “Careful not to choke on your aspirations, Director.”

[@dimitribottjen2495]

6:10 Already 2 of my favorite moments on this channel, good job

[@derekedwards5390]

Love this channel so much!! Thanks future birdman for all the great videos!!

[@FreemanWelterweight]

Birdman's work schedule still unmatched

[@JHymestudios-zd8ct]

I'M just going to say that my whole family felt in suspense from watching rogue one not because we didn't want them to all die at the end, but they do die.

[@amysargent4237]

4:18 I see what you did there. Because Han Solo (The Titular Character) ran less than 12 parsecs in The Kessel Run, Sin #12 had to be a good pun.

[@uncharted_bread]

Cool! Will there be a video about The clone wars movie?

[@lilboicoen]

I’m just waiting for the day the disclaimer in the beginning just says “I fucking hate cinemasins”

[@lukeperry33]

I love hearing you call Jeremy out on his hypocrisy. I would love to see a future where cinemasins loses almost all of its Fanbase or they start to make videos that actually have cinema SINS… I don’t watch his channel anymore because the jokes that he make are so corny and cringe that it is unbearable

[@aaroncarroll2417]

Call me a Normie but I also did not realize the difference in the text crawl colors. That's actually interesting

[@damienhouse7706]

Kinda wish he had sinned the Clone Wars animated movie, so all these could have been 3 parters.

[@Marcibee05]

23:10 "This is a disobedient fucking droid..." Woah Jeremy it's kinda wack to call something that is intelligent and sentient 'disobedient' when expressing discomfort about a near death- ohhh yeah he's from Tennessee...

[@artsof_tm]

I used to watch Cinema Sins when I was younger.... and I find myself still trying to figure out why

[@studiousorb9132]

Another banger by the Th3Birdman

[@dyloosutherland3075]

You know what great video but damn right the rock over Steve Austin

[@chillinsquirtle]

In my opinion the best star wars Droid is bd-1 from Jedi: fallen order

[@2littv330]

There needs to be a Wilhelm scream every sin he sings from now on

[@dignelberrt]

the ambush on Jedha is actually pretty good at showing you where everyone is at all times

[@squatch1565]

Did... did I read that Sentence right? One of the best actors in Hollywood wants to return to play one of the coolest characters in Star Wars? Consider me on board!

[@Trickbot7000]

Jeremy’s laugh changed in his Morbius video… I have to think that *something* influenced that

[@BornofFire117]

Dude that boondocks clip of stinkmeaner was sooooo good 😂😂😂

[@DiktatorFluffki]

No fucking way he sinned the Darth Vader hallway scene, I think I’m going to explode

[@Se7enthWard]

As much as I love Birdman content Ive binged too much, too quickly and now listening to that CinemaSins bozo Jeremy even here makes me want to run into traffic

[@JLeppert]

I would like to thank you for correctly saying, "you cannot eat your cake and have it too."

[@karencove7197]

Agree that James Earl Jones's voice of Darth Vader is still superb. His voice transcends age.

[@Jrock3891]

I just watched this on DVD again last night.

[@rccraig7580]

That Boondock/Tom DuBois reference really got me LOL! and I'm still laughing while I'm typing this!!! Way to go Birdman don't let Cinema Sins get away with anything !

[@supersaiyanbino]

There's no way Chewy is only 250 lbs, lol

[@kelgreen99]

I left the video to watch the original Wilheim scream while making the Kessel Run for spice in less than 10 parsecs. So there's that. 😂😂😂😂

[@cheezemonkeyeater]

I feel like if they had just called the series "Dumbass Commentary," they'd get a lot less shit for this stuff.

[@melanatednoir4923]

Always gonna show luv🥰🤗🤗🤗

[@weik-2936]

If I might add, "sacrificing one's self for the people you love" is a common theme in SW

[@the1lostronin]

Also since the death star is only used at a fraction of it power it was not yet "unleashed"

[@MrLolx2u]

What Jeremy failed to realize that Star Wars also mimmicks real life in some extent which in the case of Lando betting his ship against Han's ship, that's entirely possible in high-stakes poker. That's what we called a side bet that each person bets upon which is on top of the general bets on the table which we called "pot" whereas sidebets have their own pots called "side pot". Gamblers can even bet anything that's being certified be it a simple Rolex Perpetual watch to a title to a fucking building in downtown LA. That's how crazy side pot betting can be and with Lando risking his wealth against Han where Lando's often known to be lucky in the series, I don't see why he can't see himself walking off with the bet and Han's ship even. Also, I don't get why he was talking about "Lando shouldn't talk fractions before the deal is done and price is discussed yet". Lando is a fucking smuggler himself thus he could already estimate how much it is beforehand and hearing Crimson Dawn's name being tagged to the job coupled with the route taken, he knew the math would come out huge and even if he takes 50% of Han's 50% share, both would still profit massively no matter what thus he decided to gamble on Han again as, mentioned, Lando is always lucky. Besides, that's how business are often dealt with. Even before profit numbers could be given, percentages are often asked or negotiated so I don't see why Lando openly asking Han for 50% of the profit even the raw numbers could be given would be wrong or a sin. Jeremy poor at finances cliche.

[@Xekzelstriker]

Why is he sinning fuel? I find it hard to believe that a si-fi civilization wouldn't use some form of fuel to power there advance vehicles.

[@KeybladeMasterAndy]

Chewie is 7'3" in large part because Peter Mayhew, the original actor, was 7'3".

[@lethalwolf7455]

I love you dude! You’re so much fun. I lost all respect for CS ever since they had that guy from clerks ruin what could’ve been their best video

[@GRasputin91]

I'm sinning you, Birdman, for failing to use the Wilhelm scream instead of the ding for every sin as you promised.

[@Swedeinaboonie]

Righto my man. Hot on the KZbin drops! Sköl

[@AdamWieczorek-Swain]

These are one of the best movies of the new generation of Star Wars.

[@Miikasae]

please let mace windu randomly be in Andor or something. that would be so sick

[@kemp6510]

dude is a MACHINE with this upload schedule

[@DoGDarkBurner2736]

To be fair though the Star Wars ones were combined into certain sections hence the faster uploads

[@grex951]

The time has come... execute Cinema Sins!

[@marquesbowden0130]

These movies were the only ones I didn't want to watch in the star wars lore. That being said, it's amazing that cinemasins continues to critique these movies without having the basic knowledge of characterization, deciphering a plot, or story telling...

[@thatguy_5240]

This isn't about the video, but about these two movies in general. I can understand the hate Solo got, it wasn't an overly incredible movie, but I still had fun watching it. On the other hand, I think Rogue One is one of the best star wars films. It's not perfect, for sure, but I don't understand how people were disappointed with Rogue One.

[@BluePhoenix_1600]

Correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't Chewbacca also in RotS cause I feel like I heard Yoda talk to him been a while since I have seen it

[@nobodyshome6792]

He is. (He is the one that helps Yoda into a shuttle right after Order 66 is issued.) He is in 2 of the Senate Scenes of the Clone Wars movie. He is in the original trilogy, 2 of the Prequels, Solo and all 3 of the sequel trilogy. Wookies have lifespans of around 400 years. Chewbacca gets around. Especially as he is part of the clan that finds and creates Hyperspace travel routes. And he carries a list of all hyperspace routes.... Chewie is the Hyperspace *KING*

[@magnatcleo2043]

@@nobodyshome6792 One thing I have to wonder about hyperspace travel routes: are they like safe pathways for lightspeed travel, or are they just more efficient paths?

[@nobodyshome6792]

@@magnatcleo2043 from what I can understand it is hyperspace routes around fluctuating gravity wells. (Planets, stars, asteroid fields, black holes, nebula and other major space phenomena.) They are constantly in flux, and are prone to change.

[@nobodyshome6792]

@@magnatcleo2043 and these are "safe" routes mind you. Safe being only applicable to not encountering gravity wells or being ripped apart by gravity fluctuations.

[@charcuterie3641]

13:37 another point: Lando isn't saying that L3 is the literal best navigator in the galaxy, he's exaggerating. When you say "my dad makes the best chili in the world" you don't mean that he's the literal best in the entire world

[@709mash]

I know I'm in the minority, but I enjoyed solo. That and rogue one were the best modern star wars films imo.

[@lelandanderson8319]

Love it!!!

[@aidansalole194]

I’m kind of mad at you because Cinema Sins used to be one of my favourite channels to pass the time with, but now I spend my time watching them looking for flaws

[@187btokes]

Bro been calling him fake SJW woke sellout for like 2 years now. NEVER CHANGE BIRDMAN YOU ALWAYS KEEP IT 1 HUNNIT HUNNIT

[@pauhy5601]

@Th3Birdman,the vehicles in the Solo movie moving through the scenes reminds me of ,"F-Zero" the Nintendo game,haha?.

[@dontprayforme]

Bruh how can they be so wrong about the “Deadpool style double sword droid bounty Hunter costume” it’s literally a imperial trooper with some traffic batons and it SHOWS it when they are landing. Dude didn’t watch the movie at all. 🙃😂😂😂😂. CinemaSins the type to say “Oh I wAs JuSt BeInG sArCaStIc AbOuT tHaT”

[@nixonjones9543]

More of these compilations if you don't mind♥️

[@idontevencarewhathtissays]

You do not use your Yoda impression enough, my dude.

[@zaczane]

Okay…. That Vader Scene edit was Dope as Shit Bman.

[@assimilation9]

Hey are you planning to do the clone wars?

[@sethylich6395]

another banger I say

[@geneallen8176]

R.I.P Darth Vader

[@felipeborquez6370]

Will you ever sin Cinemasins' Clone Wars video in order to finish the movie canon?

[@patriotofthewest6420]

Been watching you for a while and seen you grow, let me offer you a hand in brotherhood (without preaching religion or politics) Odin Bless! Keep up the great work from Australia with love.