Firearms Expert Reacts To Battlefield 2042’s Guns PART 3

[@jonathanferguson1211]

If I may clarify my comment on the 'K' marking on the G36C - it's a C model i.e. 'Compact', so we would not expect it to have a K ('Kurz')-marked receiver. The obvious explanation is that it was built on a K receiver with a semi-auto only trigger group and C barrel, handguard and carrying handle - but UK police do not use the K so it's a bit odd. (NB - edited from my original comment as I made an actual mistake in that one!)

[@derekp2674]

Hi Jonathan, I'm not sure what the difference is between C and K versions. However I know the UK Civil Nuclear Constabulary like to use the short versions of the G36. I've just found a FOI request response that lists the types of firearms in their inventory - including both C and K models. Let me know if you'd like me to email you the link.

[@TheName123456789]

@@derekp2674 The C variant has his use for close Engagement situations where you want the length of an Machine pistol/ Personal Defence Weapon but need the Fire Power of a Full Rifle. The down side is the G36C hase its wweaknesses on long range entgaments. Compared to the Stamdart G36 and G36K. G36K sitz between the G36 and the G36C, so for the BF 2042 game it would make more sence to include the G36K. I personaly think a Police Unit would rather take the G36C for hig risk Arrests. Since normaly Police would not have to engage on ranges above 100m. The G36K is a "bether" version of the G36. Forgot to mention that the G36K Variant is slightly sorter then the G36 but not as short as the G36C. But on the side of HK you can see the difrence clearly. I hope im not to wrong.

[@jehoiakimelidoronila5450]

The K variant is the carbine version of the full size G36. Meanwhile the C variant is the much shorter version & further development of the K variant

[@ntb_cheerios2316]

Hello Jonathan, you're exactly right in your analysis. The only thing i would like to add is it appears to have a K stock. The full length g36 and the K have the same length stock while the C had a slightly shorter one. Little hard to tell from video but its also possible it was originally a fully built K that had the barrel, hand guard, and trigger pack swapped out. Hope this helps!

[@peterclarke7006]

@@jehoiakimelidoronila5450 I suspect the issue isn't to do with the length of the barrel, but the marking on the receiver. Jonathan knows what the G36 varients are (he's the Keeper of Firearms at the Royal Armouries in Leeds, etc, in case you weren't aware). His point is the receiver and the barrel are off different models, but not for the usual reasons of changing the trigger group from select-fire (Military) to semi-auto (Law Enforcement).

[@patrikhjorth3291]

Considering how often the Desert Eagle comes up in this context, do you think the Royal Armouries could justify having one permanently signed out to Jonathan? For demonstration purposes, of course.

[@derekp2674]

I'm sure they would but Jonathan might not want to be lumbered with having to carry it around everywhere.

[@peterclarke7006]

Preferably so every episode there's a brief video of Jonathan daintily dropping it into a wastepaper basket and then patiently explaining why a 9mm is better in any situation that doesn't involve an extremely unimpressed bear.

[@HomicideJack187]

@@derekp2674 Owning the L5 lightweight variant myself, I can confirm this. It's a brick.

[@patrikhjorth3291]

Well, maybe some kind of carrying contraption could be devised, that would allow him to carry it more easily. A kind of pouch hung from his belt, or strapped to the side of the torso perhaps. I'm sure somebody at the Armouries could come up with such a thing.

[@derekp2674]

@@patrikhjorth3291 Isn't that called a holster?

[@scarecrow443]

Gunther is a running joke from the german face in Battlefield 5. Gunther kinda just became a meme in the community and he showed back up in the portal mode as the default face for a german player model

[@endymionselene165]

The wrestler?

[@scarecrow443]

@@endymionselene165 no, a character model in the game from Battlefield 5.

[@SquibbeyJenkins]

I was happy to see him back in 2042 🫡

[@Nugcon]

Gunther my beloved

[@burr6303]

I absolutely love that Jonathan referred to himself as a connoisseur of bull pups. Complete unintended giga Chad this man is.

[@CertMediocre]

He literally wrote a book on bullpups.

[@Fadaar]

@@CertMediocre hahaha yeah no kidding, him and Ian are two of my absolute favorite people on youtube

[@waygyanba2195]

Considering how much the weapon designer loves his bullpups.... That's something they both will have to fight over.

[@Cheesepuff8]

@@CertMediocreI think maybe THE book on Bullpups

[@ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz]

@@CertMediocre Specifically on British Bullpups, even more specifically from the Thornycroft to the SA-80, even more more specifically with a beautiful red cover as an option :)

[@MrGrimsmith]

Just an FYI regarding the General Dynamics RM277R - it used a different cartridge from the MCX Spear that was much lower chamber pressure and polymer cased. One of the big selling points was how much lighter a standard ammo load would be (30% IIRC) and that they didn't need the same chamber pressure as others to reach the required range. I was rooting for the bullpup myself as they just make so much sense :)

[@usernamunavailiable]

Yep, it was True Velocity's 6.8TVCM.

[@hawkeye7527]

It's a travesty that Sig won the contract. Another AR platform, only even heavier now!

[@ittapupu7406]

@@hawkeye7527 I know, isn't it odd that an established company with not only the means of production, but also a track record of producing high quality products won the contract? On the battle tested and proven AR platform no less! What a travesty, indeed.

[@ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz]

@@hawkeye7527 Different AR.

[@hailexiao2770]

@@ittapupu7406 Because General Dynamics is clearly just two guys in a shed who started bashing out bicycle parts 3 years ago.

[@huunhanle3809]

I'm glad to hear Dave's voice again, when the world needed him most, he came.

[@Workaround224]

He comes a lot. It’s actually quite impressive.

[@wondertownfunk6858]

"He came" 🤨

[@ShadowFox37]

so did i ;)

[@chrisyoung1576]

He came?? 😳😳

[@R-SXX]

He came!

[@jonathancandra8190]

The RPL-20 (RPT-31 in game) is actually firing the 5.45x39 mm cartridge. It's designed as the new SAW to replace the RPK-74M.

[@knrz2562]

Replace?!.😢😮

[@invictusangelica]

@@knrz2562 Yes, because belt fed = more ammo = longer continuous fire.

[@invictusangelica]

So far this thing and the Kord 5.45mm were in testing and the Russian military haven't shown much interest about it considering that they have the PKP already.

[@jackhandsome1160]

@@invictusangelica 'cause it's not for the army, but for the Police

[@invictusangelica]

@@jackhandsome1160 Usually I would ask why cops or even the FSB need a belt fed MG but since it's Russia, I guess it's just that

[@vonvard]

Say this on every video and not going to stop any time soon. Jonathan needs some recognition on the honours list soon. National treasure

[@destrega3316]

The what list?

[@vonvard]

@destrega3316 it's the annual British honours from the King. You get them for services to society. OBE's, Sir, Dame etc

[@officegossip]

He’s the only expert that actually plays video games which makes him a lot more interesting to listen to because he acknowledges the liberties that a game has to take to make the weaponry balanced in a fictional digital environment.

[@patrickbo2045]

Jonathan, the "K" in G36K means "kurz" or short. It's just the german designation for the short carbine model. Also as a german, I don't mind american guns being attributed to us! =)

[@TotallyNotAFox]

The K and C are different models though, with the K having a longer barrel and doesn't come with a picatinny rail by default

[@knrz2562]

Aw nice3

[@forzikt]

i thought it is Karabiner or Carbine, meaning assault carbine

[@littlemouseboi5965]

@@forzikt No, the C was used to mean Carbine in G36c, since they had made the G36k prior to it, which used Kurz instead of Karabiner because, and I can only assume, it wasn't short enough to call a carbine.

[@darthcerebus]

All I need is a breakdown of Killzone's weapons just to see how much sense he can make of it, and to see some Killzone representation on the internet again.

[@Mazorzarch]

Have a bump for the Killzone algorithm. I miss that series.

[@stephencollins9062]

One of my favourite games

[@wildwavesairsoft]

Regarding the grenade launcher I’m pretty sure the games excuse is that the shell is like split in half so it houses two projectiles… even though the firing pin would have to modified for that to work.

[@44R0Ndin]

Probably something similar to the 3GL that came from the Metal Storm program, which is a 3 shot 40mm grenade launcher that uses the superposed load principle and electric priming in combination to produce a grenade launcher where you can fire 3 times before you need to replace the WHOLE barrel assembly.

[@codmanout9861]

@@44R0Ndin That's what I was going to say. If you look at the shell when it is loaded, the front looks like it is split in two, so I am guessing that the in-game explanation is that it is an electronically fired cartridge that fires half of the shell per shot.

[@enderborn017]

Apparently there were a few blackpowder revolvers that worked like that. I was hoping he'd see the description and comment on that

[@wildwavesairsoft]

update in the game it now only fires one shot per loaded cartridge....

[@reubenritchie6254]

There is a very experimental coilgun in the commercial market. Ian from Forgotton Weapons did a video on it. Would be interesting to see Jonathan react to it

[@InsaneCarverUpqik]

theres also a different one that matt had on demoranch that shot steel discs

[@ChenAnPin]

4:44 The RM68 appears to have two kinds of reload animation/sequence. The one Jonathan noted using the right hand to replace the magazine is for a partial reload for when the gun isn't completely empty. The "correct" with using the left hand to reload is for when the gun has emptied its entire magazine and thus using the left hand after putting in a fresh magazine then follows up with pulling the charging handle.

[@jareddegraw8719]

Noticed the same.

[@HappyMan0203]

Yeah I noticed that as well. I think it's to add some visual variety to the reloads.

[@MrTeddy12397]

which makes it even more dumb than usual, taking your hand off the trigger in the exact situation where you would need it there in case you have to use the single round left in the chamber.

[@cheesecake4lyfe196]

it might have also be done to elongate the partial reload to keep all the timings the same, which is a weird decision from a gameplay perspective but would make animation variation implementation easier. From an artistic perspective the animations in the more recent BF games are super clean and weighty, they've done a great job in that department.

[@sourlemon3337]

@@dickizzinya9085 the rm277 in mw2 has that as well. For some reason they turned the magazine release buttons near the trigger into the bolt release, despite the gun having a unique bolt release on the right side. The rm277 in mw2 only has the rear magazine release button. A really silly design decision tbh.

[@NinjahDuk]

As a G36C fan, I am very glad to see one anywhere I go. Also as a side note on the PF51 (P50), the game actually mentions it is originally a semi automatic weapon that's been modified for automatic fire. Which is nice. I also did not know the XCE Bar was a real gun, very cool.

[@dangluan92]

Its real name is XCEED from Tec-Target-Schneider

[@ExecutorArtaris]

I'd absolutle want to see Johnatan talk about the Deus Ex HR and MD weapons, since he mentioned again, and he mentioned like years ago that he played it and would be amazing to hear his opinion about it

[@maximtkachow]

There IS a two-barreled grenade launcher. It's soviet-made ДП-64 «Непрядва» or DP-64 Nepryadva. It was made for sea use (surfaced submarines, ports, military ships and so on) against combat swimmers or other special forces. It is not 37 mm, though, the caliber is 45 mm, but that's okay, I guess :D

[@SuitsTheRedcoat]

I wonder if Johnathan hasn't seen the ArcFlash coil gun that Ian covered on Forgotten weapons 10 months ago

[@atlashugged2591]

I came here to wonder the same thing. He says that handheld coil and rainguns existing in the next 20 years is absurd. Meanwhile I'm like...both already exist. They're prototypes, sure, but they're surprisingly capable for prototypes. I fully believe that railguns and coilguns will see major strides in the next 20 years.

[@daviddavidson2357]

I was wondering the same thing. Maybe it's because the EMG-02 is extremely underpowered for it's size? It is a start though. I could see a coilgun like that in 20 years time. Better supercapacitors and batteries. Maybe superconducting coils too.

[@SimonLandmine]

Glad someone(s) else was going to ask this, too. :-)

[@theVlKlNGR]

The point Johnathan makes about coil guns being rather unlikely is this: Carrying the power supply alone is an unreasonable burden for soldiers or military personnel (and will certainly be so in 20 years' time), considering the weight of regular equipment, which is seldom less than 30 kg. Batteries and electrical components in general are usually heavy and carry a certain potential danger for the user. Especially with the current doctrine of using unmanned equipment, such as drones, to keep the casualty rate as low as possible. A soldier who dies only brings something to the enemy side. I think it is more likely that we will move from projectile weapons directly to "energy beam weapons" than produce energy-loaded projectile weapons. But even that is still in an unpredictable future. Edit: Above all, a new weapon system must bring with it incredibly many more advantages than the existing ones. So here's the question: what does a modern M4 currently weigh with a loaded 30-round magazine plus the spare magazines in the vest carrier? Can the energy weapon undercut this weight and what other advantages does it bring me? We have all heard and read about burnt-out e-bikes and e-cars of all kinds and know how difficult these fires are to put out. I wouldn't want to carry a battery like that around in a combat situation. The projectiles that could potentially hit me are more than enough for me.

[@derekp2674]

I'm sure Jonathan is aware of the ArcFlash coil guns but I think he was referring to EM guns capable of actually outperforming conventional "powder guns". As he hinted, a viable candidate threshold for that would require meeting or exceeding the performance of DMRs or anti-materiel rifles. The 10mm square bore railgun that I used to manage could accelerate 1 gram projectiles to around 3000 m/s but was powered by a room full of 8000 V capacitors. Our best ever firing rate was about 1 shot per week, but we were an aerospace research project, not a military technology development programme. Not least from current interests in electric vehicle developments, power supplies should be becoming more effective with regard to power per unit volume or per unit mass. But our experience was that power supply work was the least favourite part of the EM gun research, as seen by military funding agencies. That's why I really applaud the work that ArcFlash are doing.

[@AhegaoComics]

One thing to note, is that handheld portable coil guns already exist. They may not be particularly useful or effective right now but Ian from Forgotten Weapons has done 2 videos on 2 coil guns. kzbin.info/www/bejne/m3KrfIZmo7ufgpY - GR-1 Anvil kzbin.info/www/bejne/e6irg52di7x5pNE - EMG-02

[@liufi69]

Had exact same thought.

[@livingcorpse5664]

I was bummed the RM277 Amicus didn't win the Next Generation Squad Weapon program. Glad it is in video games though. The other companies you couldn't remember who worked on it was LoneStar Future Weapons. Which is now owned by True Velocity, who made the polymer cased rounds for it.

[@s0meRand0m129]

the gun is laser beam in BF2042 due to slow firing rate

[@r2crowseye]

But Jonathon, we have handheld coil guns now! The huge prototype and smaller prototype Ian showcased earlier this year or last year.

[@LordAnubisGaming]

Jonathon mentions Deus Ex Human Revolution, but I can’t seem to find a video of him reviewing the weapons. Possible idea in the future? 👀

[@compaqdeskpro5770]

Happy I found this series, always a good watch. I would like to see FEAR's weapons covered, its a good mix of real life but slightly off weapons and totally bizarre energy weapons.

[@xpendabull]

You can never wave around enough deagles, Jonathan.

[@jaxmarumaru]

I don't think the Rosch MK4 would be too futuristic. The weapon is surprisingly similar to ArcFlash Labs EMG-02 CoilGun that you can buy and use today in usa. However from Forgotten weapons videos about the coilgun and its predecessors EMG-01 & GR-1 Anvil leads me to believe that their accuracy and power aren't there yet. If I remember correctly.

[@Arsanthania]

Not yet, but with the advances in battery technology it may be a thing sooner that people think it will. Or maybe in 2042?

[@MarieAvora]

The Rorsch does like 2500 m/s of muzzle velocity, the real coilguns are like 60 :D

[@zbyszanna]

I think the proper nomenclature is "less lethal" as opposed to "less than lethal" now to underscore that those rounds can actually be lethal. Also, that Beretta/True Velocity bullpup is not canceled, it's being offered on the civilian market, so you have still a chance to shoot it! The idea and execution of the cartidge seems to be great so you should try it out if you have a chance.

[@Taintedmini]

The railgun looks extremely similar to the GM 6 Lynx, the bullpup .50 BMG rifle. I immediately saw the similarity in the mag well and rear end, but upon comparing them, aside from the screen and battery assembly, it's a Lynx.

[@Vundabamazing]

You've probably seen this 50 times, but for the railgun? The battery swaps depending on what fire mode you're in. I don't know if that would really change anything though.

[@NorthyPark]

One thing I was hoping to see brought up here is that for some strange reason the G36 has a 20 round capacity even tho its clearly the standard 30rnd one. And if you get the extended mag it still only goes up to 30, but first of all the mag itself looks weird, but it also looks like a 60rnd mag

[@TheMusicftw1]

Bf2042 is horrible when it comes to having correct magazine models and round count in them. It's been like that since it came out. Really weird thing to do

[@titaniumwo1f390]

​@@TheMusicftw1it has high power round as a default mag (less damage drop at longer range), and for sake of balance it default mag can hold 20 rounds, but the standard round with 30 rounds mag can be unlocked later.

[@JayJay-gh7or]

I am always down for a Deagle waving session. Great content as always.

[@latewizard301]

seeing the Rorsch return as a MK4 is really cool, even though i don't think i will play 2042, i really like that detail!

[@Tom_-]

We already have hand held rail/coil guns. Ian fired one on Forgotten Weapons. It of course isn't very powerful and the pieces of steel rod it fired tended to tumble, but it's at least the beginnings of this firearms technology being a real thing.

[@savagedog157]

Interesting how the character actually reloads the rm68 with his left hand when the mag is completely empty. Too bad Johnathan didn’t notice that haha

[@antiluckermd1956]

G36 C (Carbine): 9inch barrel, 228mm, designed for police G36 K (Kurz): 12,5inch barrel, 318mm, designed for paratroopers, KSK, KSM

[@TotallyNotAFox]

How to quickly identify them: The K version has 4 holes while the C only has 2 above the barrel

[@NaritTeg]

Could we get another Hunt Showdown ep? There's a bunch of interesting/niche weapons including one he specifically mentioned wanting the devs to add last time.

[@shortinos]

Hope he does 6 Days In Fallujah soon

[@MrTJPAS]

I think True Velocity might have been planning to bring a civilian version of the General Dynamics NGSW (what 2042 calls the RM68) to the market and calling it the Amicus, but I don't know if that ever really came to fruition. They just have 1 video of it on KZbin from what I can see. Otherwise, that could be Jonathan's way of obtaining one and adding it to his collection of bullpups.

[@sourlemon3337]

The civilian version is called the Genesis

[@ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz]

If it's using the weird polycase ammo I dont see an appreciable market for it, but using 308/6.5Creed/.277 Fury and SR 25 magazines there will be some market. Probably the same people buying FDE SCAR17s a few years ago.

[@gregbarnes4083]

With the SPH Explosive Launcher the reason given for 2 shots in game is that its actually 2 shots that are stacked and fired electronically (similar to how metal storm worked) with a standard rear case so it can be shot out of normal grenade launchers with no modification needed.

[@Virgiliusz]

The railgun battery does change depending on the battery the gun either fires a super powerful armor-piercing shot with it being single charge up for a long time round, a second battery that has a slight charge up 3 burst fire mode, and a fully automatic mode with no charge up.

[@niklasw.1297]

How cool would it be if you had a crazy strong futuristic weapon (Railgun) but it has a quirk (You need to reload/manage both the magazine and power supply) *(cough Metros Tikhar and Railgun cough)*

[@juusolatva]

to be fair ArcFlash Labs EMG-02 actually uses same kind of batteries as power drills

[@HIT14MAN2]

Do SAO Fatal Bullet and COD Advanced Warfare

[@swayingGrass]

PKM can actually use disintegrating links as it pulls the cartridge. Ukraine actually made one out of plastic, Armourer's Bench did a video on it. The one that "shoves rim and all" is the VZ.

[@mattrobson3603]

Yeah, the rim keeps a 'push through' belt from being a good idea (since the rim would get hung up on the belt link as it's being pushed) but the way disintegrating links work is perfectly compatible with rimmed cartridges. It just needs to have links that will be pinned together when a round is pushed into them when being belted up.

[@johnoneil9188]

What Jonathan is not aware of is that there actually already exists a prototype for a handheld coilgun. Ian from Forgotten Weapons has put out two videos about the very first iteration and an already improved version of it. It is still rather low power for a projectile weapon but it works.

[@thatdudeinasuit5422]

I reckon the Cyberpunk depiction of rail guns is more realistic (not in size but in battlefield role) in that they are not there as the main service weapons but are there in situations that require heavy penetrative power for instance when shooting through walls or thick body armour. I will say I think the Tech Shotguns make little sense without a destructive environment as I think the role they would play IRL would be as breaching weapons where rather than shooting at specifically the hinges on a door you could shoot out a section of the wall

[@JayStrun]

I would very much love to see Jonathan react to Fallout 4 weapon mods, specifically the vast array of MP5 mods to rate the accuracy or believability of them

[@noobguy9973]

I would love to him react to more weird weapon designs that are really unconventional like weapons from Serious sam with the semi auto rocket launcher, the brutal chainsaw launcher, the bomb carrying parrot etc.

[@44R0Ndin]

Seconded the idea for Johnathan to go over the weapons of the Serious Sam series. Even the dual revolvers you start with are pretty dang interesting, what with their "explanation" for the unlimited ammunition for them.

[@neonhvit]

Do more of Fallout New Vegas, alot of the unique weapons are so cool

[@raptorcell6633]

As if the Germans would ever develop a firearm using P90 magazines. After a little searching I found two double barrel grenade launchers. The Russian DP-64 and the relatively new American Sage Deuce. Interestingly, the DP is a 45mm grenade launcher.

[@hamishsewell5990]

Amazing work as always! Star Wars Republic Commando perhaps? Or the 007: Everything or Nothing game?

[@walkerwhited]

EON! Yes!

[@kanrakucheese]

Everything or Nothing has the weird situation where nearly everything has the capacity made wrong at the last minute (the demo had correct capacity), and the models all being very crude even for the era.

[@hamishsewell5990]

@@kanrakucheese yeah, definitely in need of a remake.

[@GrumpyMann]

In regards to the SPH 37mm launcher, I like to think it is just a less-lethal launcher that was repurposed by the no-pats with some kind of custom-tooled lethal round. It doesn't explain the fact that multiple operatives on opposing sides made the exact same thing but, hey, its a video game.

[@simulacra7885]

The grenade launcher doing 2 shots is likely based off of the metal storm system of having 1 cartridge containing 2 shots and an electronic primer setting each shot off with one barrel

[@toshineon]

I wonder if Nordvik is a reference to, or at least inspired by, Sandvik, which is an actual real swedish industrial company.

[@phucletran2860]

The railgun reminded of Guns in Boundary (basically COD-Counter Strike, but in space). Hey, let Jonathan breakdown on that game.

[@under-chonker]

I want to see Jonathan reacting to the weapons of Warframe

[@joey193650]

@jonathanferguson Does the GR-1 "Anvil" not count as a handheld coil gun? I know it is not powerful and is gimmicky, but it functions none the less. Just your thoughts on it would be interesting. I know Forgotten Weapons did a video on it as well.

[@mrdntgetshot2759]

Been waiting in the new 2042 video. Was not disappointed 👍

[@billyjoejimbob9573]

I would have to re find the name, but there is a .22 caliber rail/coil rifle available for purchase in the U.S right now, it's $3,000 for a .22 cal, but it does exist

[@hamzterhero]

Absolutely love the series and the tradition of breaking Jonathan mentally through cursed guns. Would be awesome to see Jonathan reacts to weapons of F.E.A.R. and Max Payne series. The guns from those old school timers deserve some attention from this chad

[@lucca.machado_]

The rpl 20 actually uses 545, it's made to fulfill the same role as the MINIMI

[@livingcorpse5664]

I mean we do have a handheld coilgun, your friend Ian did a video on it, but currently it's like an electronic musket, its great great "grandkids" will be like the ones we see in sci-fi movies. kzbin.info/www/bejne/m3KrfIZmo7ufgpY

[@daniellambert1217]

Jonathan , just a thought about the sph explosive launcher`s dual shot single barrel issue ..... could it be an innovation along the lines of how rounds would be fired from the metal storm ? sequentially mounted rounds ? ie 1 in front of the other ? otherwise yeah strange choice with that one

[@somdudewillson]

I mean that is literally just what the lore text that was on-screen said, I think.

[@getreal3209]

Game is so unbalanced, the assault riffles are ridiculously accurate at long distances which makes snipping irrelevant.

[@boisq97]

19:55 handheld coilguns are already a thing, not very powerful tho and i think not technically guns, DemolitionRanch did a video on them a year or so ago

[@marcellosilva9286]

15th week pushing for a Resistance, Darkwatch or E.Y.E. Divine Cybermancy episode.

[@Boyahda]

Oh yeah I forgot this game existed. It was pure dogshit when it released so hopefully it's better now.

[@RevanAlaire]

The K suffix for the G36 probably stands for Kurz since it has a short barrel.

[@daviddavidson2357]

You saying we won't have handheld coulguns by 2042 is a bit odd, considering we have handheld coulguns *now* The EMG-01 and EMG-02 are both handheld, man portable coilguns. They have less power than a .22, but they're also pretty homemade. I could see an experimental coilgun by 2040 if we can get better supercapacitors and more energy dense batteries. That seems to be the limiting factor.

[@derekp2674]

I agree that power supply technology is one of the main limiting factors. Perhaps progress in electric vehicles (and other tech like industrial laser cutters) will generate useful spin off for for EM guns.

[@RyanYouTubs93]

Great video! You should play the game Jonathan it’s quite good. 👍🏻😊

[@GenomeSoldierDK]

"So it's nice that it has had an afterlife in this game" - oh believe me Jonathan, it has. >:D

[@MrDrboomstick]

there already IS a handheld coil gun. It's been on forgottenweapons.

[@reapershadow1656]

Can't wait to See him Reviewing "Black" PS2 Game Weapons 😂

[@usernamunavailiable]

That G36K is a thing of beauty. I keep telling myself I don't need another gun, and a G36 is unobtainium, but there is Tommybuilt.. and I have a homeless Aimpoint pro.

[@ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz]

I though a $700 red dot on a $600 handgun felt bad, a $3500 gun on a $500 red dot feels worse 😂 I couldnt care less about HK weapons but Tommybuilt is definitely a cool company. If you got the money, do it.

[@RawRamenBoyo]

So I looked it up, the difference between the G36K and G36C is that the K version is a shortened version of the original G36 (k meaning “kurz” in this) and the C is an even shortened version where the K has a 12.5 inch barrel and the C has a 9.0 inch barrel

[@CAP198462]

I’m reasonably certain Ian from Forgotten Weapons fired a handheld coil gun. So I’m not so sure in twenty years there won’t be one on the market or in use somewhere.

[@yucon_man]

Does playing video games count as research at the Royal Armories?

[@Great_Cthulhu]

The G36C (C="Compact") is a compact variant and a further development of the G36K. It has a shorter barrel than the G36K, and a four-prong open-type flash hider or a birdcage type flash hider.

[@TastyMackerel]

The mag slap reload animations have always irked me in games I'm glad Jonathan points it out in this episode.

[@billyjoejimbob9573]

"We've waived enough Deagles around on this channel before" Me who wants him to show the real world gun every time he looks at an in game one: 😢😢

[@CertMediocre]

11:00 What Jonathan is being too diplomatic to say is that Kel-Tec makes designs with the application of Columbian Marching Powder.

[@derekp2674]

That Keltec P50 looks awesome - but didn't they just copy the configuration of the FAS 604 and 6004 air pistols? For its day, and for club use, I think the FAS 604 was (or still is?) the best precision target air pistol out there.

[@ShadowHybrid92]

we do have that coilgun Ian was playing with a few months back

[@Dudeman9339]

Any railgun that a person could fire from the shoulder, prone or not, wouldnt have anywhere near enough energy to do anything beyond a couple hundred meters at best.

[@derekp2674]

That will be true if they also have to carry all of the power supply, assuming that it is based on current technology.

[@kaiserbrotmesser3892]

The K stands maybe for "kurz" with mean short in german

[@rayman2084]

If I know it right the "k" is for "kurz" what means short in german

[@newburger]

BLACK from Playstation 2, please?

[@b44rb44r]

I saw a hand held rail shotgun that fired metal disks on Kentucky ballistic videos🤔

[@derekp2674]

Actually I'm sure it was (in electromagnetic terms) a coilgun not a railgun.

[@daniel-san836]

real question is, would we still be using all the same guns in 2042 that we do today?

[@derekp2674]

Well I'm sure AKs, 1911s and Glocks would still be around then....

[@TicklesTheElf]

There already exists handheld coil guns.

[@DjDolHaus86]

In theory (assuming you had the power source to run it) a rail/coil gun would have higher magazine capacity (with the same physical sized magazine) because it's only a projectile rather than a cartridge

[@derekp2674]

True but then yo'd have to carry the much greater mass and volume of the power supply as well. There might also be a greater need to have some kind of sabot around the projectile, for example to provide the railgun armature and, depending on the application, the sabot mass may count as a parasitic mass, as does the propellant mass in a powder gun.

[@AntiSilence]

Nice to hear someone else say the rail gun reminds them of a drill, I call it the Bosch 🤣

[@Personal43546hf]

I think hes gonna eat his words on railguns.

[@jessediego4096]

Please do killzone 3 or Shadowfall next

[@nolanlemmon8180]

Could you potentially get him to cover Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days? That game has loads of Chinese weapons you don't see in media a lot, which I think he'd be fascinated by!

[@N0I5EMAK3R]

That G36K has to be an armorer's special if it's a British SWAT piece. The KEs and KVs are export versions of the K, so it's a mystery where that one came from.

[@derekp2674]

Don't forget that British Aerospace used to own H&K and would have been happy to produce batches of bespoke models to satisfy orders from individual police forces.

[@omsharma2049]

Can you do the weapons of "enlisted" next

[@Thisandthat8908]

That scope is obviously a Tiktok scope!

[@Sableagle]

At 4:15, you say "six-eight is the metric designation for that cartridge." For _what_ cartridge? Something in .268", or maybe .275" if measured before it's fired, but you didn't specify.

[@frenchouiaboo816]

The French Riot Police uses a break open dual barrel 44mm launcher called the "Flash-Ball Super Pro" made by Verny Carron it's meant to be less than lethal

[@roninsghost108]

The K I think means compact. As in German compact is spelled with a k instead of a c. And on the mp5k, the compact version. The k desiganes compact

[@Whiteknight-xg2pq]

My understanding is the K means Compact, of course this is conjecture but my reasoning is because G-36 C meaning Carbine and "K" being the German version for English's "C". My only supporting "evidence" is In R6S Mute has access to the H&K MP5-K which is configured in a more compact design like the folding stock and 8" barrel. Once again just conjecture but it makes sense to me. Edit: On the SPH Launcher that has bugged me so bad since it appeared but I've come to terms with it because of a small idea. That being it has ben electronically modified to fire a weird "smart" munition. Instead of the shell being one single shot it behaves like a over-under shotgun but only in its casing, not the launcher itself, so a duel chambered shell with a 2 strike electronic primer and two shots.