FIRST TIME HEARING Bee Gees - I Started A Joke (Live in Las Vegas, 1997) (Emotional)| REACTION!!!

[@carolbeck3645]

Goosebump city !!! Loved Robin's voice !!!!

[@susannolan9662]

You're a sensitive soul. I love your appreciation for the Bee Gees.

[@beeharbour]

Robin, Robin, ROBIN!!!!

[@lauriebarnes2999]

Robin (the lead on this song) did many leads before the disco era, probably more than big brother Barry from the late 60's to the early 70's. This became Robin's signature song and he loved it so much that he requested that it be played at his funeral in 2012. Please react to more of his leads from the early days. I might suggest "Massachusetts", "I Can't See Nobody" and "And the Sun Will Shine", all of which can be reacted to using their wonderful 1974 Melbourne concert. Great reaction to "Joke"!

[@juliefox1743]

If you want to hear more robin check out "I can't see nobody" on the Midnight special... Or Massachusetts or For Whom the Bell Tolls. Robin was always my favorite

[@xzeroevil]

Massachusetts made me change my mind about them 100% i liked a few of their songs before but Massachusetts made me respect them

[@saphirzafiro7777]

he also did most leads in the 90 es. Check out ´rings around the moonˋ, ˋfor whom the bell tollsˋ and all the Still Waters album

[@sylviategroen1583]

They have been songwriters n singing for 5 decades...

[@bobbyboko6317]

Robin was a special talent

[@ConnieKWONG-lw4zl]

This song was released first in the year 1967 .The front man was Robin with the amazing harmony of the other two brothers....Its a very sad emotional song with the influence of our Robin 's unique vocal but it's incredible.....❤❤

[@bpaq9349]

Love this one-also “Massachusetts” and “I Just Got to Get a Message to You”

[@pattiehernandez769]

early bee gees were the best to me. my favorite is Massachusetts. late bee gees would be " subway ".

[@angelone1839]

Please listen to BeeGees- Massachusetts. Robin sings on it too. Beautiful song

[@irmarocha7809]

Love that song; they were in my opinion; up there with the Beatles!

[@peggypennington3270]

Yes yes yes

[@michellejackson6679]

Robin did lead back in the 60's.. I love this song.. my Uncle/Godfather.. can sing this so perfect.. My uncle loved the Bee Gee's b4 DISCO era. I wasn't born yet when my Uncle loved the Bee Gees.

[@Sunshine123x]

" for whom the bell tolls "❤

[@gingeroo5765]

Andy was the 4th youngest one who sang independently on his own from the BeeGees. Also, Andy died first, at a young age from heart complications caused by years of drug abuse and depression.

[@jtaylor2563]

Didn't Andy also date Victoria Principal

[@gingeroo5765]

@@jtaylor2563 yes. and one could easily also argue he died of a broken heart from their breakup as well.. one he never in the least recovered from

[@jgilbertify]

Humility is beautiful and powerful...

[@lynneg8874]

Maurice once said about Robin singing this song - "That's the voice that touches your heart." How very true.

[@JC-es5un]

This entire concert is pure 🔥, strongly recommend checking it out

[@garfield122010]

My personal favourite is a later hit " for whom the bell tolls " Robin sings a lot on this song too, I like Robins voice the best ❤️

[@carolyncoppola974]

YES! ❤️

[@cindyknudson2715]

Alone is wonderful too.

[@ardentynekent2099]

Absolutely!

[@neojc128]

That's a song that Robin wrote when he was 18 and it was played at his funeral. Brings tears to my eyes everytime. I hear it was meant to be about contrition, when you hurt someone by saying something wrong. Both candid and deep

[@ruthmeow4262]

To me it sounds like someone always on the outside, who never fit in.

[@cyndi.K9090]

Or maybe just misunderstood

[@Shasha-yg1mm]

I never understood why Robin stopped being the lead or why he and Barry didn't switch off. I felt more feelings with the songs Robin sang than Barry's. This song and Massachusetts always make me tear up.

[@susanhoh1414]

Beautiful sing he wrote at 18...it was played at his funeral. Only one left, im sure Barry feels lost eithput his brothers.❤❤❤❤

[@teeken8850]

Listen to the tremolo with vibrato in Robins voice, one of a kind!

[@anncain2432]

Thanks for sharing the sadness that welled up because it is sad ..... Barry has been devastated and it's sad he's the only voice left. I'm sure it's like loosing a leg for him. Music is supposed to bring out these emotions.

[@lclark6854]

Robin's voice is very emotional. As others have said, outside of the disco period, he had a lead or prominent role in many songs such as Massachusetts, I've Gotta get a message to you, Holiday, Run to Me, New York Mining Disaster, For Whom the Bell Tolls and many more.

[@Tessiefaye]

These are all some of my favorite Bee Gee songs. I the disco was what they are best known for but by NO MEANS their greatest songs in my opinion.

[@kimberlytuten8262]

You know Barry. This is the Bee Gees voice. Stellar.

[@teday86]

YES!! You get it. Robin's voice has always killed me but I can't hear him sing " 'till I finally died" without losing it. Watch clips of Barry doing his anthology tour alone. He starts this song and then brings in footage of Robin finishing the song. Everytime that line comes up, the screen goes away from Robin. It kills me

[@debbiefannan5357]

It’s just such a sense of loss. Since they all brought us joy…..we are sad

[@sylviategroen1583]

Andy is the baby he's awesome..they all have songs..Robin sang this song when he was younger, this amazing song..

[@ronni5467]

This song has Always made me cry, Every Time

[@ronni5467]

Andy was a solo act, one of the brothers yes, the youngest

[@dorieann64]

Andy was their baby brother who had a solo career. You should check out his offerings too. All the brothers have an inherited family talent.

[@michelebriere9569]

Check out their album called Still Waters. Dim the lights, turn your phone off, put headphones on, and relax. Very R&B album.

[@NickiSixx1]

Barry the oldest, Robin & Mo the twins and Andy is the youngest brother. Barry, Robin & Mo are BeeGees and Andy had his own carrier and the brothers wrote a lot of music together. Both for themself and for other artists like Barbara Streisand, Diana Ross, Dolly Parton & Kenny Rogers and Celine Dion just to mention a few. They also have a older sister Lesley, that lives in Australia. Barry, Robin & Mo started singing as very young kids, Barry was 9 and the twins was 6 when they first started to preform for a public.

[@Erica-jv7ze]

This song is so beautiful

[@sandraborchart6910]

Andy is the youngest of Gibb brothers. Who had a solo career. Who periodically went on stage with his brothers. Andy passed away at the age of 30. Due to heart failure.

[@michelebriere9569]

About 3 days after Maurice died, Robin had to do and interview and solo song in the Netherlands. He seemed to be running on shock. When he started to sing about a love affair gone wrong, begging his loved one to come back, you could literally see reality hitting him. Brother Mo was his twin. Can't get closer than twins. It was heartbreaking to watch.

[@kathieovercash8414]

Robin has such a beautiful and unique voice. Songs Robin sings almost all of. Massachusetts. Juliet. I Can't See Nobody. Bodyguard. I've Got To Get A Message To You. Saved By The Bell. I Saw A New Morning. My World. and songs he sang parts of, For Whom The Bell Tolls. How Do You Mend A Broken Heart. Mr Natural. You Win Again.

[@carolyncoppola974]

Thank you so much for this reaction! I’m so glad you appreciated it! I truly respect you reacting to songs/artists that hold a special place in my heart! ❤️. Andy was their younger brother - another great talent! Would love to see your reaction to him! Great guessing on their names! Careful - pretty soon you’ll be able to name them all without cheating!!! 🤣Thanks for sharing! God bless you!

[@s.sh.4442]

what an angelic voice...they were are gone to soon

[@rellisclements6875]

He sing lead on Massachusetts another good song is For. Whom the bell tolls live

[@popgaj1573]

yeah this song was my dads favorite song (imagine a big strong Marine grunt here), It is actually dark and deep to actually read the lyrics.. Robin alone is amazing he actually is my favorite of the brothers Gibb. This song makes me get emotional also Twon, not just because this is my favorite group but also it floods back the memories of my father. Thanks for this I know it may not get the same likes that other video may get but the memories are precious.

[@trb2021]

Robin has always been my favorite too ❤️❤️

[@deannastands5141]

Robin's unique voice touched my heart. Rest in peace, and I know you're singing with the angels.

[@dawndeleon3765]

Barry, Robin and Maurice were the Bee Gees. Robin sings lead on this one. He sang lead on many of their older tunes, and after Living Eyes, but didn't sing a lot of lead from 1976-1980. His voice is pretty unmistakable. Andy was their little brother. He was about 12 years younger than Barry, and about 10 years younger than the twins (Robin and Maurice were fraternal twins). Andy was never an official member of the Bee Gees, he had a very successful recording career of his own in the mid-late 1970s (I Just Want to Be Your Everything, Shadow Dancing, An Everlasting Love, Words and Music, etc.). Andy was the first to die, five days after his 30th birthday of a virus of the heart that caused his heart to enlarge.

[@mogolurch]

Robin was lead in quite a few of their songs.

[@nancyhawkes3531]

Listen to Massachusetts. It’s beautiful

[@chrisf.7980]

The Bee Gees had hit songs back in the 60's to the 70's BEFORE they skyrocketed to worldwide superstardom during the disco period with "Saturday Night Fever" fame. Many terrific TV performances from those earlier years to be found on KZbin, just saying! All three were equally talented, even though Barry was highlighted as lead, but Robin had a singularly unique voice quality that was showcased in several of their early songs.

[@negf22]

This was Robin, this song was from 1967. They all sing solo at on time or another. Robin used to sing lead a lot on the songs back in the 60's. No one has a voice like Robin. The youngest Brother was Andy, he was a solo artist, he was going ti join the group in 1989, but he died in 1988.

[@susanhoh1414]

Check out kid brother Andy Gibbs Shadow dancing, he was about to join the 3 brothers Bee Gees but died at 30. What a talented family.

[@garycox3205]

This is pure voice, no auto tune hear

[@tammybiddle7115]

Robin sang lead in many of their earlier songs.

[@Newfie-zc7ug]

Historical fact...........Robin was the Star of this group before Barry took control. Not complaining ...just sayin'...LOL

[@tammybiddle7115]

@@Newfie-zc7ug exactly

[@ThePhilly501]

Fact. Robin was the lead vocalist

[@kthor]

@@Newfie-zc7ug Not close to being true…..considering Barry wrote all of their earliest songs (seldom with Robin), & Barry usually sang lead.

[@jerickson725]

@@kthor Robin was very involved in writing early on, as was Maurice. I heard Barry say in an interview that Robin, age 17 at the time, had written 95% of this song when he brought it to them (and same for many others). However, usually all 3 are credited for writing the lyrics on all of their songs.

[@theresapillar2093]

Robin is actually my favorite bee gee. Love them all though. Check out MR. Natural. Keep in mind many times Robin and Barry sang together to create one voice, but since the camera loved Barry it often looks like Barry is singing alone.

[@jettechdonatkins]

I love how much you enjoyed this song.I grew up with these guys and love their music a lot.I read that when Robin died in the hospital,that his son played this song on his cell phone and layed the phone on Robin's chest while it played.What a tear jerker that had to be.Thank you my friend for this video.

[@caroltaylor7351]

Yes Andy. They wrote their own music. Lov love lov

[@lydiabugner6437]

Robin sings this and it was played at his funeral in 2012. He had an amazing voice that harmonized with his brothers so well. He is missed.

[@kathieovercash8414]

Andy died in 88. He was 30. He and Barry were very close. Maurice (pronounced Morris, black hat) died suddenly in 2003 I believe. Then Robin in 2012. I cry every time I hear certain songs of theirs like Alone. I Wish You Were Here. (Our Love) Don't Throw It All Away. For Whom The Bell Tolls. I loved the late 60's, 70's, 80's and 90's. I got to sit in front of the TV watching my favorite basketball player Larry Bird and cruise around blasting the Bee Gees.

[@namwob77]

Most of Robin's singles was done when he was the lead. After Barry found his high falsetto, he became the lead singer. Next react to Maurice and the little brother Andy!!!

[@debitaylor8361]

When they started to make it Robin sang most lead, then as their style changed Barry took most of the lead. In fact at one point Robin left the group, but their love for each other mended the fences. Andy looked so much like Barry but had blonde hair. Can really see it when Barry was clean shaven. This is the group I grew up on. My cousin had a band and they sang the Bee Gee. Couldn't wait to go and see rehearsals every weekend 1970.

[@andreaclarke161]

Lovely reactions your facial expressions are a delight to watch and you dress very well! The Bee Gees are exceptional singers! Andy was the youngest brother who passed away early

[@kazshaw3945]

Andy wasn't in the Bee Gee's he was a solo artist ,Barry ,Mourice and Robin were the Bee Gee's ,only 3 of them !

[@goatedbross9975]

Hi Good Morning Day Everybody and Good Afternoon.

[@lloydgilbert2182]

Bodyguard by The Bee Gees.

[@Zlata1313]

Yes!

[@LadyGator1983]

The documentary that Barry is doing or has done is sad because he is the last Bee Gee alive. And like you said, we all die. But what breaks my heart is that the Bee Gees were very talented songwriters and singers. And we won’t have that anymore. The talent that these brothers had was God-given and we won’t see that same kind of talent ever again.

[@ZebraDazzle66]

The documentary was released last year “The Bee Gees: How Can You Mend a Broken Heart”. It was phenomenal!!! It has been nominated for 6 Emmys. You can watch it on HBO or Hulu. I highly recommend it!

[@LadyGator1983]

@@ZebraDazzle66 Thank you!!!

[@toniencheff4046]

You must have an artistic soul, Twan for such a reaction.

[@maryblum8365]

You have got to listen to man in the middle with maurice singing. Nights on broadway and Fanny be tender with my love. It's a must

[@LadyGator1983]

One of my favorites!

[@clintwood1083]

If you get a chance, watch the entire Las Vegas Concert (1997)-One Night Only. They pay a tribute to their youngest brother Andy.

[@carolking1502]

Twon, just for amazing fun, look at "Bee Gees First Television Appearance". Seeing Robin with SO much personality tickled me!

[@maryawaterbury1305]

Robin had the real voice. Barry has the falcetto.😎

[@xina7066]

Nice reaction bro. Bee Gees is amazing! Closer Than closer - bee gees (maurice lead vocals). Greetz from Brazil.

[@KarinStrong-k4j]

This is Robyn singing. There was another one, Andy. He was younger and passed away from a drug overdose at 27 years old.

[@timsiemer7331]

Andy was a brother but not a Bee Gee

[@Newfie-zc7ug]

Man , this is a great track but you should listen to the original from their 1st Greatest Hits album...Classic BeeGees.

[@dahuffy]

Bee Gees Gold is their best album, in my opinion

[@ericbrownfield7291]

You will really enjoy "I've gotta get a message to you". Or Massachusetts

[@oompa_loompa_piano]

My bee gees fav. An all time classic. I even published a piano cover 🎹

[@suedyment511]

Barry the twins Robin and Maurice and the younger was Andy , Robin sings alot of their songs as well as Barry

[@sisuboy]

Have you heard Nights On Broadway, by them? It's a banger, for sure.

[@valeriewilliams3041]

Andy Gibb had his own career.

[@lindataggart2087]

This is Robin singing.. Maurice and Barry.. Andy is the younger brother that went out on his own..but did sing with the BeeGees on occasion...

[@dianawhite637]

You are such a sweet soul!

[@rogersprague563]

They have a little brother named Andy I believe he was a singer also but sung by himself !

[@richtensail]

bgs r music legends

[@miltonslocum8957]

Thanks for being real with your reactions. That's a great quality. If you haven't reacted to The Spinners, check out Could It Be I'm Falling In Love, One Of A Kind, Mighty Love and Love Don't Love Nobody just to name a few. They have a great catalog of songs. Take care Twon!

[@vincentcole6398]

We know how you feel bro, you expressed it better than you think.

[@ralphwatts8993]

You’re a good man Twon.❤️🤘🏻

[@jimmypadgett1106]

Andy youngest brother

[@garfield122010]

You would love " love you inside and out " it's got a real vibe to it ❤️

[@thequieterubcomethemoreuhe1198]

It is so great to see you reacting to The Bee Gees. Robin has always been my favorite. His voice was so profound & you just experienced his vocal ability to capture your emotional soul and feel everything that he just sang! You watched him do one solo, here, & felt the impact of his death, as well as the sorrowful grief, experienced by everyone who has his voice sewn into the fabric of their hearts! Iconic and legendary are small words to describe these brothers, their music & their legacies! I hope that you will do a full dive into their library of music. You cannot find a 'bad' Bee Gees song! For Whom The Bell Tolls will make you check to see if your heart lies bleeding on the floor! Alone, Spics & Specs, Massachusetts, One, Nights on Broadway, Tragedy.....too many to name! This concert, One Night Only, is worth a full view & listen! They cover many of their hits that they recorded, as well as some that they wrote for other artists, (and they wrote many). Celine Dion comes onstage here to sing Immortality and they back her on it. They wrote it for her, I think? I hope to see you react to all of these and more. You have a real appreciation for music and song if you are drawn to these legends! What's in the heart defines the measure of a man and you measure up, no problem! Every time I watch you, I think to myself, "What a fabulous son he must be. I bet his mom just beams when she is with him'! And I think, "Those waves! Beautiful curl"! LOL. Does every mom in the neighborhood want to adopt you? I would! Thank you for the smiles!

[@suebauer1515]

Have you reacted to their song"for whom the bell tolls".it's a great one!! One of their best ones

[@wuwei128]

It's profound for sure..."Nights on Broadway" is really good too with Robin showcasing as well.

[@lindataggart2087]

They all sing it just depends on which song sings the most..

[@mariapricola781]

Yes babe Andy was the youngest. Maurice Robin and Barry were the Bee Gees❤

[@cathybrookeburt2616]

Andy Gibb is the younger 4th brother, who was not in the group. He was a solo performer. Rpbin is singing this.

[@saras.6641]

You were right. Andy was there youngest brother that passed away .

[@Zlata1313]

Andy wasn't a member of the group although they'd planned on it but he died before it could happen. Robin and Maurice ( pronounced Morris) were fraternal twins . Robin was 35 minutes older.

[@laurelcarter1573]

Andy died young. Robin sang lead quite a bit too. A totally different sound to Barry. Maurice also sang lead with a different sound again but all amazing. Listen to For Whom the bell tolls and Man in the middle. Andy was filmed doing you should be dancing with them I think it was 1976.

[@MrBluegrouse]

You’re awesome, man. Really love watching your real, authentic reactions. Breath of fresh air in this crazy world and in these crazy times.

[@Mary-gq9wf]

It’s Robin singing and when he passed away his son took his phone and put it on his dad’s chest and played this song and then broke down.

[@kimberlygarrett4251]

Your reaction was spot on!

[@pammcleod3228]

The other brother Maurice sings man in the middle and closer than close I think you would enjoy

[@barnowl5774]

Perhaps these lyrics are paradoxical. In esoteric spirituality our death is the doorway to the true life in Spirit. And life in the earthly realm is a kind of death to that life in Spirit. This involves reincarnating. We are spirit , through the mediator of our Soul, having physical experience. Robin had this song played at his funeral.

[@michelebriere9569]

Barry usually took lead, Robin 2nd lead, and once in a while, Maurice had lead. Check him out on Closer Than Close.

[@sherylhenley1931]

You should see Robin's 1968 version-It's much more personal and emotional.

[@Isleofskye]

As is the official video Sheryl :)