Trump Backs H-1B Visa Again Amid MAGA Civil War | Vantage With Palki Sharma

[@pulkitthehbkable]

an american president is fighting for indians against his voters. just imagine how big of an issue this is. now imagine what such minds can do for our own country? just use our tax money to pay these brilliant minds rather than giving freebies to people!

[@vigneshk8413]

60000 limited period visas a year and just a fraction of it actually ending up getting permanent residency - if you are scared of this against 300 million, then it is a perfect definition of paranoia.

[@maheshverma6148]

So true brother, but what can we do the Indian companies pay so less salary and no work life balance also, obviously talented people will run where they get good facilities.

[@rashmip-dl9gj]

Do not victimize yourself, we know USA is so cruel to Indian intellectuals.

[@BestatWowraids]

If I was India 🇮🇳 I would want to keep all my smart people to help build my nation just as good as the Nation they want to go to.

[@D_402S]

But Tai is busy taxing popcorn

[@stop_lying_to_me]

Weird. Billionaires exploit the working class? Who knew?

[@augurcybernaut4785]

🎭

[@Madame702]

H-1B visas is new neo-colonialism.

[@giangnguyen-kv5ki]

That's one reason they get richer!

[@ryanwalters6184]

That's why they are getting killed 😂

[@one4allall4one56]

@@Madame702 Yes, nowadays slaves have to compete with other slaves for the privilige to be enslaved.

[@michaelvikhman7926]

India needs to get its shit together and reform. There is nothing stopping it from become a first world country. Then there will not be a need for so much H1-B visa's. Start by building sanitation and infrastructure. Create greater laws and regulations. Clear out corruption. No one needs to be poor.

[@Jppvv492]

Yes. That's what Indians should learn. L

[@reshmaangela8584]

So true😢

[@GB-np9eq]

you need to get your act together and study and grow the 3rd brain cell. Maybe then your country will not have to depend on bright people from other countries. you dont have to steal other people's lands or resources or riches.

[@dhruvthechamp7085]

bruh what is wrong with you guys more than 98% of people have toilets and don't shi-t on streets like your drug addicts do. get your fact right bruh before telling others look at your own problems. your north american continent got more street shit-ters and net only shows extreme cases of india promoted algorithm

[@shripadbhagwat6566]

Yes sir🎉 but unfortunately no one cares😢

[@Ak-uj5jr]

The good fight ? Stay in India and make India great again

[@giangnguyen-kv5ki]

Spot on. They know they are exploited by corporations but they are still begging to come.

[@AdmiralAckbarr]

​@giangnguyen-kv5ki A guy named Nguyen talking abt "coming to America" is ironic 😅

[@zainzoala1083]

Don’t think there are jobs in there country. And ‘ They are not like China.

[@janvanpelt5572]

MIGA !!! YOUR FUTURE IS HERE !!!

[@AS-if5jg]

You know the shit hole it is, right?

[@monirasultana4083]

India needs smart people… why all these IIT students are working in the US? They should try to make their country prosperous by working in a big tech companies in India.

[@kevinanderson7128]

As an American, I can agree with that. India should keep those people there or try to keep people there that way they can make it better for the people living there.I don’t understand how that racist according to Palki.

[@Pain-zd5uo]

​​@@kevinanderson7128 calling Indians as third world parasitic invaders on twitter isn't racist? You gotta agree that there are MAGA supporters who seriously hate indians.

[@neelanj6375]

Do you think people doing the same job in India would earn the same amount as they do in the US? We can't compete with the employee benefits offered there. In fact, we can't even compete with China and several other Asian countries in this case.

[@kevinanderson7128]

@@neelanj6375 not now but who knows it In thirty years .One thing is for certain you will never find out unless your country provides opportunities to stay .

[@anandandyiyer]

COGNITIVE DISSONANCE. MOST ARE WORKING IN INDIA. IF YOU COULD READ YOU WOULD KNOW THAT INDIA IS THE 4TH LARGEST GDP ON ITS WAY TO BE THE 3RD. STFU

[@PramodTan]

Indians must come out of the dream that H1B is for their benefit. It is for the US to decide, considering their benefits.

[@god563616]

why wont the India government provide for its people!!

[@Djockzone]

​@@god563616well, India has billions of people and it isn't easy to create opportunities for such huge base

[@Djockzone]

H1B is indeed for their benefit. Why do you think none of them want to come back?

[@ashishbhambore8506]

Both will benefit

[@PramodTan]

I see many people creating opportunities in India. After spending 18 years in the West, I have returned to India, where I believe the potential for growth is greater than in the USA.

[@Xccelerate25]

India should use of the IITians and top talents by hiring them in ISRO and top research institutes and government should fund them to create startups in India rather than going to US.

[@darshanpotdar7654]

There are nearly 60000+ graduates each year just from the exclusive institutes only in engineering how many jobs can be given to them and all those graduates want money which is not available in research jobs and also isro and the!n the problem with IT ( for those students who graduate from avg / mediocre collages) jobs here is that most of them pay very less and make you overwork.

[@RoseGautam-sw6ly]

They should increase salaries in ISRO first

[@D_402S]

Just because someone is from an iit it doesn't mean they are super talented. Most students get into IIT just to get a good salary, not because they are interested in research and development. India should focus on everyone, iitians, non-iitians, dropouts, etc as long as they are smart

[@VinayashaPaswan-nn9vd]

@@D_402S first we need to fix our primary education

[@Iceblock4]

@@D_402S "Just because someone is from an iit it doesn't mean they are super talented'? approximately 12 lakh students attempt JEE every year and from that ~20000 are selected into IITs, that's the top 0.016%

[@KSA-k5t]

This is their country, they do whatever they want

[@kevinanderson7128]

Exactly

[@Rishabh_Rudra]

This lady only knows to speak english except that she is totally illogical and meaningless

[@Activethinker6378]

@@KSA-k5t ALBINOS don't get to give orders. Your kind is almost finished in America . You have zero say in it. 😭

[@KomalJogi-d8o]

So, we can kick all the minority out as well?

[@techevar]

This is an easy fix. Pay both the H1bs and the Amerians the same prevailing wage! This will force the companies to pick the best candidate and stop my Indian friends from the exploit.

[@stevemargolies1187]

@@techevar H1b hurt mostly older Americans. Older Asian Americans included.

[@Madame702]

No, it the new "neo-colonialism" Elon Musk won't go to India to exploit you, he will get you to come to America and exploit you. Just when you think you seen it all.

[@pixpusha]

Why would they pay H1Bs the same when they would take less. Have you ever sold anything? You sell to the person that would pay more.

[@ryanwalters6184]

People literally will walk through a jungle to come to America. They can pay these people nothing and they would still come here. 😂

[@stevemargolies1187]

@@ryanwalters6184 so true

[@LordDementus1987]

We have smart people. What we don't have are smart people that are willing to work for poverty wages.

[@lilydog1000]

Very very true. Well said.

[@gangasflo9445]

Average H1b Salary is above 150k. You are delusional

[@LordDementus1987]

@@gangasflo9445 musk doesn’t pay his engineers that much

[@CoolGuyz-c8r]

Smart people, not fraudulent ones.

[@Moeheyn]

Smart, cheap, obedient and willingness to work in any condition under the fear of visa restrictions of sponsorship

[@KomalJogi-d8o]

Far less than US steals from the world.

[@shivendrasingh4631]

The guy responsible for Tesla's autopilot goes by the name Ashok Elluswamy who is an Indian studied from Carnegie Mellon. With AI boom America needs talent to compete with China. The argument presented did not have any substance it was pure hatred and they think it a zero sum game.

[@Rastamonk101]

There is no smartvindians... these are just cheap indentured slaves... only bring down our standards

[@abcatos]

Kuch bhi mat fake bhai. 🤦😂😂😂

[@RohitJha-e3x]

😂😂 bro looks like you are some kind of Albert Einstein. We indians have already exported so many dumb techies to the USA. People go to the USA through a lottery system. I have worked with many. The majority of them especially those who are from the southern part are fake resources. They are good for nothing 😂. They won't even get a job in India if he exports. They are now packing their bags 😂.

[@prashantbhosle3524]

India should make compulsory for IIT graduates to work at least for 5 yrs there after allow them to migrate. It's like our lamp post giving light to neighbour's house.

[@RavinaPatil6558]

There are no jobs which is why they leave

[@z_eke]

Why do you think they'll leave India in the first place because we cant provide like the foreign countries and thats disappointing

[@NisargaNagaraj-q1z]

So you want to take away democracy now just cause someone studied at IIT? lol 😅

[@Madame702]

H-1B visa is the new "neo-colonialism". Elon Musk is not going to come to India and colonize you he going get you come to America and exploit you there.

[@dark_knight439]

There is something called quality of life which is not valued in India, so it's better to leave, I regret staying here every single day.

[@lennyp6669]

My company shut down an entire wing and moved it to India as after Covid they realized if a job can be done from home., let it as well be done from their home country. Now what are these fools taking about raising minimum wages and fees.

[@siddave549]

But that is not an H1B problem my friend. That is outsourcing which is completely different.

[@lennyp6669]

@ yes. But post Covid I feel it’s totally relatable. These jobs are given to H1b because there’s no local talent to do these jobs. if these guys are not addressing that problem but making it tough to hire H1B, then it’s gonna destroy the economy. A multi billion dollar businessman should not be in charge of laws in a working class economy.

[@siddave549]

@@lennyp6669 as a former h1b, i understand your concern. i can say h1b is good for us as long as it is not used as a cheap labor program. US companies which hire international students pay really well or even higher for h1b. It is the indian consulting firms which used to pay lower wages to bring people on projects and that should certainly not happen. They should make 130k per year minimum salary for those who are not US graduates. H1B is very expensive for companies. Most US based companies do not use it as cheap labor program/

[@AnoNymous-i1o]

@@siddave549 nfw you are former H1B. $130k ? it depends on state and job role. for example an entry level in Texas would make $60k vs an entry level in Bay Area making $90k. if you dont even know this, you are probably operating from a bot farm. No Indian consulting firm is violating the law. They are following the guidelines given to them. H1B workers have to file taxes. No way they are cheating.

[@jaibabaki8754]

0:00

[@darkshadow2443]

As an Indian i understand the american sentiment but it doesnt give you the right to be racist towards indians, instead you should blame the government and force them to rectify it. Calling indians weird names wont help your cause.

[@Tamaxa-z6o]

Vivek started it by calling them stupid. And Indians were online insulting Americans as well. It's wrong on both sides. It's not your own fellow Indians that help exploit Indians.

[@Mr.Coffee576]

@@Tamaxa-z6o I don’t think Vivek insulted them. He said American culture promotes mediocrity. Whether it’s true or not, the fact is people wouldn’t have been angry if Vivek was white. Because I’ve seen so many white conservatives complain about American culture over the years and everyone was ok with it.

[@REDACTED45-r8g]

​@@Tamaxa-z6oboo hoo the world is hard

[@user-je7pc2mp5e]

@@Tamaxa-z6o "And Indians were online insulting Americans as well." This true, Even now you can see indians are trying to ratio ur reply make you feel hostility. This proves it.

[@APICSKH]

And Vivek thinks he is American. People will never accept him as an American, he will always be IINDIAN AMERICAN for racist far right groups.

[@satience]

Indian govt should be ashamed that their people settle in America and become billionaires and trillionaires. Govt should evaluate why this is so and create an environment in india that is attractive

[@KomalJogi-d8o]

Musk was from SA

[@HaroldBouchard]

I'm forever Glad!!! Hit 3500k today. Thank you for all the knowledge and nuggets you had thrown my way over the last months. Started with 14k last year 2024, God bless America

[@DonnaPayn]

Excuse me for real?, how is that possible I have struggling financially, how was that possible?

[@HaroldBouchard]

Thanks to my co-worker whom God used to give a great opportunity of crossing paths with 'Lori Watson ​@@DonnaPayn

[@HaroldBouchard]

She's a licensed broker in the United states and finance advisor.

[@verakleinberg2475]

YES!!! That's exactly her name (Lori Watson ) so many people have recommended highly about her and am just starting with her lori Watson 🇺🇸 ​@@HaroldBouchard

[@SeanAguilay]

I have heard a lot of wonderful things about Lori Watson on the news but didn't believe it until now. I'm definitely trying her out

[@brownhunk007]

Need visa cap per country. Otherwise look at Canada.

[@kovanpillai8840]

To complete globally, US firms have to recruit the best workers they can find, otherwise they risk losing the AI race to China.

[@sammmy2023]

Yes , Canada is now a third world country big thanks to Indian migrants.

[@dem0n595]

Lol , canada harboured separatist/terrorists.... It was bound to happen.

[@joeymikaelson9845]

visa caps ❌ background checks ✅ Canada's democratically elected govt. managed to selectively bring in people from shady and terrorist backgrounds for their votebank politics, many of them are fugitives wanted by India for seperatism and treason. These kinda people make India look bad on a global scale but the thing is they don't represent India in the first place, they are wanted for crimes.

[@gangasflo9445]

Bro we have one?

[@one4allall4one56]

Why talented people need to beg for a visa, instead of working for the benefit of their own country? Do the US employers really have something special to offer?

[@vitmartobby5644]

Yes, be grateful you were born in one of the greatest nation in the world, rather than in a culture-less corpse of a country Speaking as a south america

[@deathlordgamer3749]

Yes, atleast they do have jobs to offer . What Indian employers have to offer? Nothing.

[@Joebiiden]

Yes , money, facilities,live big

[@vitmartobby5644]

@@one4allall4one56 Yes, aside from the capital and facilities as both gentleman above said, underdeveloped nations lack something critical, trust... Nobody has the obligation to work for a society that will never value your work and skills, and where being rewarded for putting in the work is not a guaranteed thing.

[@froodtube]

The average salary in the US is $63000 USD per year. The average salary in India is $4500 USD per year. Obviously these highly skilled workers would make more than $4500/yr in India, but the same highly skilled US workers make more then $63000 USD/yr as well. Even earning far less than American workers in America, they make more than they would in India and send much of that home to India. The right answer for India is to remove all their kickbacks and nepotism from business and create a robust environment for them to thrive in but that is no easy task on many many fronts. Additionally if India tries to "leapfrog" their industries into these highly skilled highly paid ones they end up with a very "in your face" wealth disparity of the "haves" and "have nots" India needs to grow up the food chain and develop a middle class before catering just to the high end. It is a long and difficult road.

[@Moira_Gloucestershire]

Similar to USA with H1B visa, in the UK a significant number of HSMP applicants were from India, leading to perceptions of overrepresentation. This was one of the factors that prompted the UK government to reform the immigration system.

[@APICSKH]

And look where UK is compared to USA now😂

[@ppen8359]

Don't worry. The US is not foolish like the UK to hate immigrants and run for anything similar to Brexit. Immigrants run the USA. H1B is just one thing. From agriculture to hospitality and restaurants, the USA needs immigrants because they are the ones who put in hard work. Americans have inheritances, etc., to count on, which immigrants cannot, so they have to work hard. The result is that America is the most productive and developed country.

[@suseeln]

@@ppen8359 Developed? I doubt.

[@ryanwalters6184]

Look at Canada 😮

[@Jiuhyysys-pt2pk]

​@@ryanwalters6184lol it imported truckers and criminals from India who r on interpol notices,better check ur own govt before blaming 51st stater

[@douglasstrother6584]

H-1B visas have been a hot-button issue since the late 80's when I was a member of the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) and the American Physical Society (APS). Trump is starting-out with his shoelaces tied together. This is a bad start to his 2nd term!

[@RushikeshTade]

I doubt he cares though because anyway he can't run for 3rd term

[@douglasstrother6584]

@@RushikeshTade President Trump should weigh the consequences of his words and actions.

[@milindd8309]

I definitely like what Elon has suggested, Indian IT companies are capitalizing on cheap labor from India. but in return Americans loose jobs and have to work on low wages, and they have to support their families in USA not in India. I am an Indian but I am totally against this policy. Infosys, Tata , Mahindra teck, vipro are amassing wealth and hard working Americans are suffering.

[@lilydog1000]

Don't believe anything Musk says. He is only interested in more money.

[@rishabkhuba2663]

Wtf is happening… Why can’t politicians and Musk stick to one narrative regarding the policy

[@judewarner1536]

There is only one narrative: maximum work and/or abilities for minimum cost = maximum profit. Political policies are driven by these metrics.

[@Madame702]

He is a double Gemini, he going spin and lie. You have to watch out and he also bi-polar so lookout.

[@froodtube]

Musk is pretty consistent on his stance. He says they are a good thing. Musk was accused of being a 'greedy CEO' and just wanting to use the cheaper labor. He pointed out the fix would be to make companies pay for the visas so the Indian labor costs about the same as the US labor. Indians are not forced to come here, they come because even the lower wage than that offered to American workers is substantially higher than they can earn in India. India receives $120billion in remittences a year from these workers so it benefits India as well.

[@lilydog1000]

Their narrative is less jobs and money for Americans, and cheaper labor for immigrant labor. All Trump and Musk care about is MONEY.

[@2084j]

The visa should remain, but companies that hire foreign workers should pay tuition for Americans to compete for those jobs in the future.

[@tomhite3510]

I've talked to literally 80,000 of these "highly skilled immigrants" on work visas over the past 20 years as part of my job in the medical industry. There is unlimited work visas given to organizations in medical research. Unlimited. 10% of the immigrants can't communicate in English. Another 10% communicate poorly. Another 20% have some issues. Many of the jobs are just pushing buttons on machines in a certain pattern and that's about it. Most of the workers do NOT need to have unusual talent and do not have unusual talent. Most Americans could be trained to do these jobs in a couple of weeks. What the Americans CANNOT do is work for poverty wages. That is the appeal for the ownership class in America. I do remember one American fellow working for UCSF and lived in San Francisco. He worked in one of UC San Francisco's labs making $24,000 per year. I asked him how he could afford rent. He said, no problem, he had rented a walk-in closet. That's all he could afford.

[@chrisreddy6808]

Everyone has issues..Americans aren't immune to issues

[@GK-se7vk]

Not true at all. When employers hire H-1B visa holders, they HAVE to advertise competitive wages and PROVE that they have done enough search for qualified Americans before they open up the H-1B pool. A lot of people in medical industry as the poster is saying, come on J-1 not H-1B visas.Truth is, people like tomhite don't produce smart people and so America needs to import smart ones from overseas. People like these could not stand the thought of people coming from India and china while they were okay with europeans coming in the same way in years past and so start this non-stop whining about cheap labor. Even with all the stupidity in their gene pool, the racist pseudo superiority is the only thing left in these people. This carnival barking is the death throes of racism in America. Ignore!!

[@REDACTED45-r8g]

Do better then

[@siddave549]

That is cap exempt H1B and I don't think many Indians take those jobs. Indians are mostly in the cap H1B jobs.

[@BestatWowraids]

India 🇮🇳 would do good if there was a ban on the H1B India 🇮🇳 should keep there smart people to build up India 🇮🇳 just like the Nations.

[@RameshReddy-m6e]

In this situation we should take an opportunity to seriously show how it affects their white supremacy

[@judewarner1536]

Donald Trump cannot force corporate America to pay American salaries when H-1B visas can source equally competent workers for cheaper salaries = higher profits.

[@MetroBoom-psalm23]

If they do what Australia does and make the job first posted for a set period to citizens first and then can hire outside if no reasonable candidates applied at the same posted pay; that may be a check and balance.

[@pixpusha]

Exactly. You get it. Most people argue that they should pay equal salaries. But this is hypocritical because we all do such things in our personal lives. Why wouldn't the country?

[@kovanpillai8840]

But they don't have lower salaries.

[@fakeu2122]

H1B is not for cheaper salary, outsourcing is. Learn the difference.

[@riteshsgh]

The other flip side is if the H1B is made more tougher, then companies end up shipping jobs offshore. Catch 22 situation.

[@stevemargolies1187]

H1B in 99% of cases is about saving money. Maybe 1% its about bringing in top talent that cant be replaced easily. It hurts especially older Americans. That is including older asian Americans.

[@VoyagerIsHere]

Indians are under the impression they're being given the H1B because they're smart. They don't understand they're being given H1B because no one else will accept wages as less as they're being given for their jobs. This is also taking away jobs from American people - which is very wrong.

[@seuconrado3365]

Ofcourse! It's a huge lie, but I will tell you what fascinates me. He bought Twitter, gutted it (everyother company follows his idea), influences the election, the wants to get cheaper workers here. The real question is will he succeed?!

[@Madame702]

No, sorry H-1B are not about saving money. This is about attacking American workers and workers in general. It about exploitation of the workers. It about getting around workers "rights and pay". There will be more fights like this to come.

[@gangasflo9445]

You've never hired or worked in IT and it shows

[@stevemargolies1187]

@gangasflo9445 yes I did over 30 years. And .have seen many layoffs of older Asian American layoffs to save money. Have seen been having to train their replacements. This was done for one reason. Cheaper. How many IT layoffs in 2024 alone? 150k. Last 5 years there were 500k IT and you tell me we need more H1b visas? Why?

[@harivikas718]

The other side of the "How is this good for India" argument is that this improves the Hindu soft power in US. Israel is where is it is today coz of the strong Jewish lobby in US politics. On the other hand, Jews are very united... Unity is something the Hindus need to work on.

[@user-je7pc2mp5e]

I thought H-1B visas are for smart people like Elon Musk who will create jobs with multiple innovative companies. Elon was also a H-1B. But now I am realizing that H-1B is actually for cheap laborers.

[@judewarner1536]

Well, you thought wrong! H-1B visas are for moderately intelligent techies who can follow orders for less money than moderately intelligent Americans. India doesn't have the technical infrastructure to adequately compensate moderately intelligent folk and corporate America can maximise profit / minimise social costs by importing Indians with skills, but no prospects in India, and no great expectations beyond short-term pay and potential opportunities in USA.

[@user-je7pc2mp5e]

@@judewarner1536 Techies like coders, web developers, etc are also called labor jobs. These are labor intensive jobs which is mostly done with the help of A.I. now.

[@anonymous-ui7il]

please look up O1, that is for smart people

[@AngieWaltersTorus]

It is for smart people, out of the country, to be in the US. Elons Spacex uses H1B. It's a global search for brains. Trump and maga wanted to kick everybody out, but Elon shone a light on it. Only maga hates Indians. If India can send a rocket to the moon for only $74 million, Elon Musk would want them at Spacex. Musk spends money on his companies and would sleep on a floor if he has to. Trump is old school and needs luxury, gold and mansions. Trump has always used H2B workers.

[@lilydog1000]

Musk is not smart. His money comes from blood diamonds. It is a fallacy to call people with a lot of money, smart. Which they are not.

[@sreddy914]

Perfect conclusion

[@kelg-ti7xb]

If they want smart people fix the public school system 😂😂😂

[@RoRZoro]

That's now how smart people are created. First thing is to change family and priorities. A

[@colberthunter12]

Elon just fired thousand of tech workers and the Oligarchs have fired thousands of tech guys around the world, there is no shortage, what they want to do is secure that Free agent world talent looking for work over our American talent looking for work and we are saying hell no because you can't have a shortage if they are firing tech workers.

[@seuconrado3365]

😂😂😂 it's easier to shut down the department of education and import people 🤔 just a big lie! The smart people they want can get in! They just Want to fill the tech sector and get rid of the Americans working in it! I have never seen such ridiculousness. Elon buys Twitter, buys the election, amd will now become richer by importing the workers 👎🏾

[@Carlbooze]

And, the Indians can go back and use their smarts to fix their toilets and water system!

[@longtalljay]

@@RoRZoro That's now how a genius is created either.

[@balajis4788]

Who said tech companies are paying less? Only Indian outsourcing companies and shady desi consultancy companies are paying less.

[@k1_1m4r2]

How is this positive for Indians? It is called BrainDrain. Give the Indian tech sparks the right conditions and wages and keep them home. Look at the rise of sectors like IoT, AI and Space in India - a lot of brain power is needed

[@sampatkalyan3103]

Why don't you advocate for removal of reservations first

[@ashwinvk4124]

​@@sampatkalyan3103why don't you advocate against cast discrimination

[@sampatkalyan3103]

@ashwinvk4124 I am doing it. Reservations are caste discrimination.

[@ashwinvk4124]

@@sampatkalyan3103 reservations are the result of cast discrimination

[@sampatkalyan3103]

@@ashwinvk4124 but my point still stands. You are using legally discriminating against a group of people. Reservations are legal discrimination. So we should remove reservations first. Not your imaginary thing which has no legal backing. Reservations perpetuate the very thing you are against. So you are a hypocrite.

[@KomalJogi-d8o]

In America: everything under the sky is opportunity to exploit.

[@cutemomr]

Meta is getting rich. Because of Indians. Why can’t Indians develope their own meta

[@Watch24.7]

Because of Taxes are waiting

[@Demirak]

By the way meta was not discovered by an American, it was discovered by an european jew immigrant whose parents had come to US for safety from germans..

[@Watch24.7]

@@Demirak Whoever Discovered and Whoever invented. Meta Founders Mark Zuckerberg Eduardo Saverin Andrew McCollum Dustin Moskovitz Chris Hughes It's not one man show If you have talent but you don't have enough resources then your talent becomes India's got Latent

[@froodtube]

First India would have to decide which politician is going to own the company. Then the Indian government would have to appoint substantial regulations to monitor the company and make sure a good chunk of profits go to the government as well as endless fines for "discrepancies" The politician picked to own it would then hire all his children, brothers, sisters into upper management and cousins & more distant relatives would then make up the work force, but these would be made offers so low it makes H1B look like a gold mine. Once all that is in place, they would need to find some actual skilled workers that might actually be able to build something and give those people offers even lower than the 'distant cousin' workers are making and everyone in the company must understand and accept the strict hierarchy within the company. India has a long road ahead to get where it wants to be.

[@freecoder522]

Indians are good workers not good innovators . META was made rich by Indians by working at low wages for Mark and company .

[@abhi2511768]

Just one thing needs to be done, and most of these issues will be resolved on merit. A world reserve currency that no one can manipulate or control.

[@spat6922]

Had the H1b for low paying jobs like agriculture or any blue collar job this wouldn't be an issue.. some ppl are a lil jealous without skills.

[@anilprasanna]

H1B visa system has been monopolized by only one state in India. There is no prejudice here but just a straight fact. Even some of my Telugu friends from Dallaspuram want more diversity than make USA = United states of Andhra.

[@sushilapatel2127]

Don’t use apple, google, facebook or any technology if you don’t like H1B visa 😂

[@lovegalore681]

This lady is a great reporter, she broke this down well and what the future issue can be.

[@bijojoe4810]

Trump is going give h1 visa to Modi , so modi can run the government

[@HornetCucumber]

If you talk to a Indian immigrant/expatriate in America. You will know they love usa. They are humble and want the American dream. Ready to hard work. Which else nationality person deserve more of these visas then. Americans with their racism are shooting their own leg.

[@costilla1212]

Still don't want them 🤢

[@khanh8524]

I guess all the hate is from all the outsourcing and layoffs. Americans being replace because of cheaper labor, it’s not a skill issue. I seen it happen and I do believe in Americans first. Corporate greed and the government embedded with big tech since they fund their election. You have to be put yourself in there situation if you lost your job to someone else overseas with the same or lower skill set because of cost.

[@falseego99]

Look at the comment above you. Its not a visa or skill issue.. its just hatred 🤷‍♂️

[@varun2250]

​@@costilla1212we know

[@costilla1212]

@@falseego99 ah yes The country with the largest population on Earth has to be allowed in

[@ErVikashMehta]

If not US then I will go Europe but not India. I don't want my upcoming generation to be a part of endless struggle and mediocrity.

[@Engllishworld]

Why be racist just make american people smarter.I just can't understand that these people go there legally do the job, pay taxes and face racism in return.

[@OptimusPrime-x9x]

I remember Trump saying he loved the uneducated

[@lilydog1000]

Trump will say anything to get a vote.

[@pawanjain8264]

bravo trump you said the smartest word, doesn't matter where smart people live,

[@Pain-zd5uo]

These dumb extreme trump supporters think they can do whatever they want 🤦 There is a reason why China is a manufacturing powerhouse. Companies would just rather shut and shift their business from america to China, India etc than paying high wages to the Americans.

[@tiz6549]

Well, he doesn't need to look much futher than right in our backyard!! If these ppl were really smart, they would stay in their own country and rebuild it to compete with our country!!!

[@colberthunter12]

You are not smarter than Americans stop the lies, just because you are allowed to go to school in America doesn't naturally make you smarter, if so tell me why isn't any of those countries better than America and we would be sending our students to their schools. And they have as many wealthy people as America and their economies are large enough to make their countries like America, so how come their countries are not as good as America that they are all fighting like hell to get into, so they want to move to a country with a bad culture of mediocre people? I have never heard of a superior culture people wanting to move and be accepted by people from an inferior culture, explain that part.

[@petergijsbrechts5154]

Apparently not in the US.

[@tiz6549]

@petergijsbrechts5154 - Don't be fooled this is about cheap labor nothing more and nothing less!

[@MD-fr4xt]

Yes, US need smart people from all around the world, H1B should not be allowed to be monopolized by one group and one country only. US was built by smart people from all around the globe, not people from one country trying to block entry for everyone else. US should prioritize people from all across the globe and put a strict restriction on disproportionately represented countries.

[@kevinanderson7128]

It the United state and us owned companies they do whatever they want to .

[@kovanpillai8840]

India isn't forcing the US to take workers only from India. US corporations are looking for the the best workers they can find for a given salary.

[@Djockzone]

You're entitled to your limited knowledge but I suggest you do some digging. US has a limit in place for H1B applications from each country. Now it is not wise to have the same limit for every country considering the facts that all countries don't have the same number of people, the same composition of skillset etc. No matter how many people apply,the number cannot exceed the limit they have set up for the respective country. Next time you use phrases like "monopolized by one group", "one country only", "one set of people block entry for everyone else", think again 🙂

[@MD-fr4xt]

@ yes, they have a limit but the lobbying group wants to eliminate that list, they already breach that limit multiple times to compensate people from one country of origin. Almost all countries produce IT graduates and engineers, but IT firms in USA bulk hire from one specific country because of lobbying. Go check the stats for H1B visa issued by country of origin and how disproportionate it is.

[@MD-fr4xt]

@@kovanpillai8840 go check the list of companies that hired people on H1B visa the most, most are Indian origin companies or led by Indians, showing clear biases in hiring.

[@sanjeevjangra84]

You missed the point. Companies usually don’t find the locals to fill the position. So even if they have to pay high, they still have to hire h1b. So it’s not just about cost for companies.

[@ManuelaJäger-k8u]

That is not true.

[@sanjeevjangra84]

@@ManuelaJäger-k8uThen you’re misinformed. I get paid much higher, and same is true for many people that I know of. That’s simply because they couldn’t fill the position with local.

[@VivekKumar-wf4db]

False.

[@dangyho]

We couldn't hire a decent data engineer. We interviewed for 5 months and ended up sponsoring h-1b. The skill gap is real and everyone in tech knows this.

[@VivekKumar-wf4db]

@dangyho Pure lie which benefits Indian companies, South Indians and those who want cheap labor.

[@user-gp9mk7wm1s]

75% H1B visa for Indians, only 15% for Chinese. Palki, that means the Indians are smarter. You are right to celebrate Palki

[@Cai1900-f8e]

75 percent to indians means organizations are not filing for other nationalities end of the story

[@ag4eng]

Chinese are smarter to not leave their own country and build it up. Indians should do same, need jet engine, build it.

[@user-je7pc2mp5e]

Nope. It means indians apply in large numbers than chinese.

[@APICSKH]

@@Cai1900-f8eMay be Indians are just best employees

[@ManuelaJäger-k8u]

That means, the boss is indian too. 😁

[@kimliebal8031]

You are backing off America first!!! We elected you on MAGA!! WHAT A DISAPPOINTING ANSWER MR PRESIDENT!!

[@nazzicutter-yf2df]

wowwww its almost like .. the left has been saying this… before the election. you voted for another 4 years of his bs policies. live with it.

[@Badrith1234]

U r WRONG Palki..... As US does NOT have enough Talent pool that's why they r getting professionals on H1B....and the next due to cheap labour as well.... 👆👆👆👆👆

[@Article39A]

Indians Be proud of yourself,at Last come back and contribute to your mother land

[@princevegeta2715]

Nobody wants to live in shit tier per capita

[@dark_knight439]

Our motherland is sold to greedy politicians, babus and dehati people. Don't come back if you got out.

[@Pain-zd5uo]

First India should be able to offer better opportunities like the US. Even the Chinese used to immigrate a lot but now their govt have improved their country and less Chinese immigrate and permanently stay in foreign countries.

[@Joebiiden]

Then who will pay those people?? They don't want our country's minimum wage

[@SS-uo3uf]

A lot Indians now go abroad to study, get some work experience, and return home after having spent 5-10 years abroad. It's a good thing in the sense that they bring their learnings to India. Things in India are not as bleak as a lot of folks here are making it sound. American folks should also stop worrying to this extent because not every Indian on the H1B visa is looking to make the US their permanent home. Some are just there for the experience.

[@ppen8359]

A better approach would be to give green cards so that H1Bs do not work on lower wages.

[@Madame702]

The H-1B visa as been abused by the American companies to exploit Indian workers. It is the new "neo-colonialism". Why come to India and colonize you when we can get you come to us and then colonize you in America. It just another way of getting around workers rights and pay.

[@Sri-se8iw]

H1B pay is higher than many other jobs like teaching, police, non auto or Aero companies. Raising it heigher is nothing but dont hire H1B. Usa is nothing but companies siphoning talent and resource from other poor countries. When the depolarization becomes effective, the reverse will happen.

[@goondugoondu]

H1b guys should stop treating desi food delivery guys like a thrash and should pay tips.

[@Madame702]

Indian, H-1B is the new "neo-colonialism". Why come to India to exploit Indians, have them come to you the exploit them.

[@Swatkats-jx7cw]

Nobody owes you tips.If you need to survive on tips then get a better job.

[@sylviathomas1061]

India and their caste system. 😢

[@karlweaver2597]

I have a lot to say about this topic. First, India will become a technology powerhouse one day, perhaps 10 years from now. The key is Semiconductors, which India lacks in manufacturing but not chip design. They are leading in AI algorithm development; however, Indian laborers performing these tasks are doing that work in the USA. I have been to India many times, and they will improve just as China is the biggest competitor to the USA, India will also become a major competitor one day to the USA, but hopefully with friendly competition overtones. India can not expect the USA to continuously be a crutch for Indian employment when it's much simpler and easier for Indian labor to work in SE Asia and even China for technical jobs. I predicted India's rise in 2008 with a Smartphone revolution presentation, and I also predicted the outsourcing of Smartphone production from China to India in 2015. Actually, Indian outsourcing companies are really the ones exploiting Indian Nationals more than Western firms. These are the facts. Indian people, for at least 500 years, like Chinese people, will travel abroad to work, they are resilient in that aspect. I admire this. India has brilliant minds, and so I say toss down negativism in your country. Don't depend 100% on the USA for your employment, many countries are accepting of Indian technology labor. Happy 2025 to India! Karl Weaver

[@aneeshsasi5589]

Exactly Indian government should force companies in India to pay this techies better and better work culture like in US. Then automatically, nobody will move to US.

[@rakhiraveendran6790]

@@aneeshsasi5589not possible. The only reason IT is outsourced to India is because of cheap labour and the moment we demand same pay, the outsourcing will continue to countries like philippenes. Its a sad reality. If not india, there are other cheap labour options available and thats where tech companies will go. Unless Indians themselves become tech giants and generate employment. But thats a long road. And dollar revenue is huge for india and to generate that amount of wealth from Indian companies alone, thats a long road. And the major problem? Nobody cares, policy makers and politicians are too busy in creating divide amongst people and have no time for actual issues.

[@subrayhegde264]

Palki complains that 24% rejection for a couple of years is the world's end! What about those 76% who obtained the visa? If there were no loopholes in the program, why is it that year's quota is filled within days after it begins?

[@tipoomaster]

"Nooo we thought the vp married to an Indian was more racist noooo"

[@JackT1961]

There are Smart People already in the United States. You just aren't willing to pay them the United States wages they deserve.

[@darshanpotdar7654]

See the first sentence is just wrong. Maybe now the students are smart but the ones who graduated 5-15 years ago are not top calibre for jobs just look at any US based webseries / movies I literally can't find a normal child either they are one of the best students in the country or literally opposite, there is never a guy who works hard in schools to learn a skill which he can use in real life

[@dharan5314]

America please ban H1B visa 🙏 - Indian

[@AJSingh-j9c]

The only problem is this, most companies give preference to foreign engineers, then American engineers. Some rules must be set to save Americans' jobs for American engineers

[@kharoubhachemi9630]

CANCEL DV LOTTERY IMMEDIATELY

[@arunjose7585]

H1b need reform for sure. And locals should be given preference over foreigners. Isn’t that true for every country? What’s so wrong with that?

[@chandra_has]

Nothing wrong, work will just get offshored

[@aJones-hv5ny]

Since when does our nation of 1/3 BILLION need ANY more immigrants??

[@bobbyeapen6049]

Someone is lost in a field. It's been since 1960s. It was the Immigration and Nationality Act. Since then, the population of the USA has more than doubled. Its growth was literally the immigrants.

[@aJones-hv5ny]

@@marmosetman - Are you a comedian? Only half of our 800k STEM graduates deserve to graduate? Who says? You completely MADE THAT UP. But even if it was true, 400,000 US STEM graduates need jobs every year. We need ZERO immigrants.

[@lilydog1000]

It doesn't, but the corporations don't like paying decent money. Immigrants are cheaper.

[@benji-t7v]

Impressed by your balanced and well researched point of view Palki

[@Resilient__19]

This is good news for india lot of talent will come back to India

[@anirbanchatterjee2682]

The problem is that there are less number of jobs in India.

[@kiritheepanthangarasa2383]

Don’t go to USA

[@ArjunArya05]

Is this good for India? I don't think so.

[@Healing.Tortruer]

We do need smart people coming in. The system shouldn’t be broken to the point where employers are incentivized to hire foreigners over citizens.

[@peterkiburio8323]

Thank you Donald

[@eashwarsriram1217]

There are a lot of inconsistencies here. An application for H1B needs to prove that the candidate getting hired is paid the prevailing wage for it to be approved. Hence, companies don’t use H1B because they can pay them lower than Americans but it’s to fill the gap in skill demand.

[@kelg-ti7xb]

H1B is just a way to get lower pay

[@kovanpillai8840]

H-1B salary information is publicly available. The average H-1B salary is $167,000/year. This is not cheap labor. If you work in any of the affected industries and compare your salary with that of the H-1B worker, you will see that the numbers are comparable. Too many people believe this is cheap labor - it isn't. Labor is cheap when it is offshored.

[@ShudraRising]

India needs to create a business friendly environment. The current business environment is a legacy of the congress party. India needs to stop being a barrier it the entrepreneurial spirit of its citizens. Get out of the citizens' way and they will uplift India!

[@suseeln]

Why should an Indian channel be so worried about H1B as if Indias economy is dependent on it.

[@hiransarkar1236]

Because this has led to rampant racism against Indians

[@giangnguyen-kv5ki]

It does somewhat.. Look at all the billions dollars remittances they send home every year

[@sadhanabhagour7308]

@@giangnguyen-kv5ki so what everyone knows the fact that usa is getting more profited from those Indians.

[@suseeln]

@@giangnguyen-kv5ki They claim India is Super power but.

[@neelanj6375]

Does it seem like a "worry"? I would say it is simply reporting.

[@johnnyflores8116]

Mega you are smart buy rice and beans is very cheap to eat🤣🤣🤣

[@winiphoo8802]

Palki you summarized it very very well.

[@Boulder-t7p]

As a black American, I love Palki boldness

[@augurcybernaut4785]

You are neither black nor American 🤥

[@mg9854]

Something weird is happening, Taiwan too wanted Indians out of their country 2-3 years back and started out with racist attacks on them online and now u see them demanding Indian engineers back in Taiwan!

[@davidmedick5530]

Trump said he wants smart people. Not people depending on the US for everything.

[@soultravel8742]

It’s important for skilled labour to come into USA but at the same time there are no IT jobs in USA. Record layoffs experienced people , graduates, US citizens are struggling to find jobs. Already overflow of candidates. Indians have voted for Trump in large numbers eventhough he did not support H1B last time.

[@mightypaws2645]

This media has no credibility

[@oaoun5836]

Trump is like a wave in the sea which goes wherever the wind blows. He says no exceptions till it begins to counter his donation base in other words no integrity.

[@MariaPereira-n5y]

Basically trump is calling Americans dumb 😂😂 😂

[@kevinanderson7128]

The people that founded those companies that you wanna work for are all Americans. america gonna be your your daddy regardless of what you do.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@sanidhyakumar5816]

@@kevinanderson7128 vietnam is real daddy

[@adrianrice6396]

Not to be rude but they're also calling these migrants cheap labor. This isn't good.

[@kevinanderson7128]

@@adrianrice6396 sad to say they are .

[@lilydog1000]

@@adrianrice6396 Because all Trump and Musk care about is paying LESS money.

[@Jay57T]

From my experience, Indians make up about 75% of IT personnel in large US corporations.

[@mathew42able]

America first, not Americans first. That was Trump to said. Poor US people thought they were going to be first.😂😂😂

[@lilydog1000]

Then they need to think again US society needs to change.

[@PatamaGomutbutra]

To be honest. It need to build infrastructure such as affordable housing first. Otherwise it will have problems to both local people and immigrants as Canada. US need president fighting inflation first.

[@shinjik4797]

Indians, come to the US and make America great again!

[@pleongv1]

Just like great India

[@anikaitgalla8901]

Lol they are not the only whose making America great🤣

[@AmitkumarVerma-d1t]

H1B visa is not good for india .. what is good in ?

[@darshanpotdar7654]

The people who work through h1b visa send back a lot of money in india

[@redskies10]

It is not about race, it is about jobs for Americans!

[@JenniferSamuel-h8k]

Cheap labour no wonder Elon Musk is in all the way super expensive cars on cheap labour.

[@StevenMyers_796]

Amazing post & information. I took advantage of the 200% deposit.

[@craigwells7114]

We need a smart president?

[@siddave549]

I am on an H1B and I make 400k a year. Indians who graduate from US schools get paid higher than Americans so cheap labor argument does not work for US graduates. They get paid very well on par or in most cases than American citizens. However, those who come from TCS, Infosys were paid less and that needs to be reformed so that they are paid as much as an American citizen.

[@krajpathak]

Can someone please explain to me how H1B workers are paid less? I work in big tech and we get paid wrt to our performance and not what VISA we are on. There are some on T1, some on L1, some green cards and some H1Bs and plenty of US citizens. I get paid the same as all of them so I do not see an incentive other than talent for these companies to file for H1Bs or any other immigrant VISA. To me the picture is very simple, there arent enough US Citizens qualified for the jobs so immigrants come and fill those so how is that a problem?

[@AyushSingh-d3w]

People may be understand why our own country is the best place despite other problems

[@KK798-hi7ct]

Palki does have any other news to cover??

[@Rastamonk101]

Racist love racist stories

[@darshanpotdar7654]

​@@Rastamonk101 look at other channels of her

[@johnnyjohVnprice]

Do it. XAI767 already in my bags. I had a XAI767 after ( your should I buy ) and I agreed and bought. I'm looking to stack more, too.