Five Nights at Freddy's: Plus - ALL Jumpscares VS Original FNAF (Comparison Showcase)

🍕Join the FoxPlay's Army: youtube.com/@FoxPlayYT/join
Timecodes:
0:00 - Bonnie
1:11 - Chica
2:30 - Freddy
5:12 - Foxy
6:35 - Golden Freddy
7:23 - Missing Child
#fnafplus #comparison #showcase

[@FoxPlayYT]

🍕Join the FoxPlay's Army: youtube.com/@FoxPlayYT/join

[@luna24kitty]

I didn’t know

[@bubbshalub]

i think the original designs are better because they are more in the uncanny valley, while the fnaf plus animatronics are clearly designed to look scary, completely overriding their initial function of making children happy

[@TheNorfAndOnly]

I don’t know, I think they instead look much more realistic, and a lot more in-line with the unsettling looks that, say, Chuck E. Cheese animatronics have. Edit: Apparently I have different memories of Charles Entertainment Cheese compared to everyone else. Chuckie in particular had pretty much the exact same kind of dead-eyed stare that Bonnie and *especially* Freddy have in this fan game.

[@Wizardjones69]

The chuck cheese animatronics are scarier than the ones from fnaf plus lol

[@ErickGameplaysN64]

I think Chica specially looks indeed too forced.

[@atupeleisaac3953]

Wrong

[@geovanecarvalho8489]

​@@ErickGameplaysN64nem me fale. Aquele periquito parece que saio do manicômio, o carente parece um noia, enquanto fredoncio parece um bandido.

[@Foxxive]

The way Bonnie actually lunges at the cameras and disrupts them, they way both him and Chica also bang at your windows while they stand outside your office, and the way Bonnie stands inside your office for a while when he gets inside adds so much more horror, genuine dread. If this is just a fangame I can't imagine what the full game must've been like had it not been cancelled

[@geovanecarvalho8489]

É realmente impressionante uma fan game consegui recriar o fnaf original só que de um jeito como se fosse outro jogo.

[@geovanecarvalho8489]

Vou ter que ralar peito pra fazer algo a nível desse.

[@AlemaoATxWR]

Furry 🤮🤮🤮

[@Tomi20007]

​@@geovanecarvalho8489vamos tu puedes 😊

[@geovanecarvalho8489]

​@@Tomi20007eu tiver um PC eu consigo fazer do que jeito que pretendo. Eu queria que tivesse a piscina de bolinhas pra viajar pulando a fase da faculdade já tendo emprego.

[@7xo7xo72]

The game over screen in fnaf plus, it looks like foxy is dragging the suit you were stuffed in and drops it in front of everyone

[@CursedSFMS]

Like "Arrgg look what i did lads"

[@spinylizardz]

​@@CursedSFMSArgghhh mateys we plundered sum mighty fine booty tonight

[@killer_queen4062]

FNAF MOVIE SPOILER just like he did with william when he got springlocked

[@KamwiJunior]

Oh hell nah bra I'm out man

[@purpseatpeeps8641]

I do like the fact that they actually move on camera now, always was my biggest gripe with the original. Though I’ll admit that it does lower the shock value of Foxy, in the first game it shocked you that he was running on camera, seeing as none of the other ones did. The animation still looks great, but just less impactful.

[@repentofyoursinsandbelieve629]

Freaky

[@tidela4714]

I always thought they didn’t move because they didn’t want to be seen until they were killing you

[@kayla9839]

imo i feel like them not moving is scarier, just for me. the fact that they just stand there and you have no idea of where they’re going next or how they even got there just freaks me out

[@greatestgianni]

I actually kinda disagree. I was way more shocked seeing Foxy run in here than the og. I think it’s personally more scarier to me to see them fully move before your eyes, the little things.

[@CapLikesIceCream]

Ok I gotta be real, the image after golden Freddy’s jumpscare was actually creepy ngl, even if that’s the old version of plus

[@parkjimin7925]

true😢

[@JottoMasaki]

After the jumpsacre? You mean windows?

[@ornithrop.mp3]

@@JottoMasakii think they mean the disfigured face

[@CapLikesIceCream]

@@ornithrop.mp3 yea that’s exactly it, gave me chills, I think it’s a kid in the suit

[@tsurokai]

I love how you can hear Foxy's footsteps running through the chambers and hallways.

[@Loofwoof]

I disagree with people when they say the designs of the animatronics in this game are trying too hard to be scary. Have you guys seen actual animatronics from the 80’s? Some are genuinely this level of creepy.

[@keckingrabbit354]

I saw 80s chuck e cheese and I was traumatized

[@merryglowround]

That doesn’t really justify it, if something is made specifically for kids it shouldn’t be scary, yet it is in this case, sure for a horror game the designs are nice but lore wise it wouldn’t make that much sense to be super horror-ey

[@mechamedegeorge6786]

​@@merryglowroundhow it doesnt justify it? You mean that those real animatronics dont make sense either? Real life is not realistic? Wtf

[@keckingrabbit354]

@@merryglowround chuck e cheese is a canon event, you can't deny this

[@Kill0trocity]

When I was a kid in the early 2000’s, I went to Chuck E. Cheese’s nearly every year for my birthday. It never really occurred to me how creepy he was compared to what he is now. I know based on the pictures of my relatives who had parties there in the 80’s, chuck E. was SO much creepier.

[@Mart1n192]

While I prefer the og models, i gotta admit the way FNAF Plus executes the horror and jumpscares is impecable, i dont quite understand how the system truly works (since i havent played the games) but seeing bonnie tempering with the camera while you look at him is terrifying

[@PACKGODSBIGGESTFAN]

Agreed 👍

[@El_Tovis_237]

True.

[@TurtleButter]

Completely agree also nice sunny pfp

[@ThatGuyErazo]

Had the actual game not been canceled, I can imagine just how utterly terrifying it would’ve been. For a fan game, this is really well done.

[@rogueassassin7117]

You can find the game on game jolt, other people posted it

[@benjaminvillacorta4103]

if you don't mind me asking, why was the game cancelled?

[@milksalmon]

​@@benjaminvillacorta4103 Basically the developer said Fnaf Ruin was boring during his stream. A 16 year old called out and said, "Fnaf Plus should be boring then" (Something along the lines). After that, the dev's fans sent death threats and gore vids to the guy, and the dev treated it as a joke. That's when he gets "cancelled", and decided to not publish the game.

[@TotalWannabe]

​​​​@@milksalmondo everybody in the fandom have brain damage or smth? Although I probably shouldn't expect much from a person, who describes himself as "pansexual"

[@benjaminvillacorta4103]

@@milksalmon well that escalated quickly...

[@chef4025]

I think Freddy’s old way of staring up at the camera was the scariest

[@OreoSmithOfficial]

the chica jumpscare caught me off-guard, i thought it was going to be the same as the bonnie one

[@cloudherebb]

same shit, my soul left my body for a sec

[@d3athstrok317]

I think the designs are all fine except for Chica. It just seems a bit too forced to be the weird one out of the bunch.

[@ColoreFaied]

Looks like battingtons chica

[@steeledcelestial2958]

Yeah I don’t like hers, the rest are good

[@kredka139]

Chica looks like average 1980 real life animatronic. I don't know what is forced about her.

[@whact]

@@kredka139 she looks broken, which doesn't make sense since why would they put a broken animatronic to perform

[@kredka139]

@@whact Only her eye is broken. Everything breaks after a while.

[@JanusHoW]

The Plus versions of the animatronics look much, much scarier than their original counterparts, just from a pure design standpoint. -Their eyes look more sunken. Sunken eyes are naturally terrifying. -They're all extremely twitchy, giving the impression that they're machines truly gone haywire. -Their grins look like genuine Slasher Smiles. -Chica got that drooping right eye and the second set of teeth that we saw in FNAF 2. -Freddy's Toreador song when the power goes is accompanied by that Joker-esque grin...and the jumpscare mid-song even startled me! -Foxy actually going for the kill rather than just popping into the room and screeching was a plus. Kudos to the creator of this game.

[@WembeyNoodl]

Trying way to hard to make them look scary while the uncanny look of the first one accompanied by the atmosphere is what made the game work.

[@OreoSmithOfficial]

i also found that the animatronics breathing on camera was unsettling

[@asimplepie2279]

I personally like the originals better but fnaf plus still looks great

[@sizzlergamer5800]

​@@WembeyNoodlreal life animatronics are scarier. Try again

[@WiseMysticalTree81]

​​@@sizzlergamer5800Real life chuck e cheese characters from the 80s dont have a second set of teeth either.

[@blinxboi1632]

No one can convince me that that design of Chica was EVER designed to make kids happy

[@kredka139]

This is how animatronics used to look like in 1980. You can google Chuck e cheese and see

[@gOat_GrandMa]

Then you gotta go to a chuck e cheese or some animatronic place to get the vibe

[@evehellod9776]

I don’t think anything can beat the original, not the biggest fan of the fan-made designs or any of the changes. But I have to give credit to what they did with Foxy, him being seen/heard across multiple cameras, and the jumpscare not being him just peeking into the room is pretty good

[@elzorrodorito]

I disagree, foxy’s jump-scare is just a lot worse know, while the OG foxy jump-scare wasn’t all that scary the plus foxy jump-scare fells unatural

[@someguy-hc8gi]

@@elzorrodorito wym "unnatural" lol the entire game is unnatural, you got a squad of robot opps tryna jump u

[@RowdyOnPatrol]

I REALLY like foxys animations in fanmade plus. The way he rounds the corner from pirates cove, and THUNDERS down the hallway shaking the camera as his eyes where lit up caught me off guard but it gave it more weight then just watching him blandly run it felt like he was something heavy and him running full tilt sprint down the hall shaking the camera gave it the sense of he’s a machine made of metal where him running has weight to it which I really loved,og is still good but I love the details, played this for my friends in call we all had only one nitpick was that during the investigation stage nothing really happened. We thought the animatronics would show but no. I hope phis or the fan made creator pass it down to someone who will put their soul into it and finally have a fully complete experience

[@gyropizzamozzarella1012]

If the design of animatronics in Fnaf + were real, probably no kids will be wanting to come to pizzeria ever again lol

[@kritikill7779]

have you ever seen 80s animatronics? they were even more unnerving than the plus ones

[@bytelaw1711]

Obvious things are obvious

[@gyropizzamozzarella1012]

@@kritikill7779 Do kid love them tho?

[@kritikill7779]

@@gyropizzamozzarella1012 They did and alot still do, so yes

[@gyropizzamozzarella1012]

@@kritikill7779 welp it must be a really cool and futuristic to see some talking robot at the time

[@Jervis-JehanYvesLaurent]

7:21 golden freddy in plus taking a dump and realize there's s no toilet paper

[@iiPolaris]

7:35 dont ever take no weed from the gas station bro

[@smokestack534]

Kind of a missed opportunity for 1987 to be its own separate gamemode where golden freddy is the only animatronic kind of like night 5 of fnaf 4

[@luftwaffle4156]

Not really, they were trying to emulate fnaf 1 here, so putting in a random mechanic from fnaf 4 would be pretty out of place

[@smokestack534]

@@luftwaffle4156 doesnt mean they cant add new additions to their fan game. If people really just wanted fnaf 1 they would just ignore the mode.

[@OsmarBros]

The damn jumpscare in the middle of the jukebox really scared me.

[@unevraiegrenouille6390]

Pathetic

[@CopperLoveAndKisses]

I like when they still have remnants of the original fnaf jumpscare sound, it’s cool.

[@yesseru]

The original sound is from a horror movie where a woman gives birth to an alien (this is also where the scream is taken from). Yeah.

[@scp049leplaguedocter3]

@@yesseru WHAT?!?!?!

[@Von_Haast]

Bro new Gold Freddy just made me laugh, sounds like he's letting out a fat burp in your face.

[@drewholmes7356]

3:50 This will never not be terrifying to me. From the guard’s POV, he’s screwed.

[@user-zb4dp4vr8l]

honestly they both so scary thanks FoxPlay

[@extraterrestrialgoose8738]

I do like the way the new designs look, but as others said, they're trying way too hard to be scary. People say to look up old chuck e cheese animatronics and I did, they have ugly, awkward looking faces, but overall still look cuddly enough, nor do any of them have the segmented bodyparts like FNAF. FNAF+ is way too creepy to he for kids, OG FNAF is the perfect blend in the uncanny valley. As a side note, its way harder to spot the animatronics in the cameras of OG FNAF, which adds to the creepiness. FNAF+ makes them easy af to see

[@srthebox4946]

I agree, the chuck e cheese animatronics were horrifying because they perfectly fit in the uncanny valley, Fnaf plus just tries too hard to look scary with the character designs and movement, the animatronics move too much in fnaf plus that it loses its creepiness, one thing that made the og fnaf so effective was that you rarely saw animatronics move, when you looked at the camera they were just completely still staring at you which made then all the more creepy and terrifying , in fnaf plus the animatronics leap around, lunge at the camera and violent shake constantly which completely ruins that unnerving atmosphere, this is a perfect example where less is more

[@uselesspoyo7726]

7:29 never buy weed from a gas station bro

[@KiiBon]

I am SO glad they improved the jumpscares. The previous remakes ones were honestly terrible

[@notcrabb]

i mean, those are from 2015 but yeah u right

[@cheese0827]

​@@notcrabbi think they mean fnaf 2 os cuz fnaf 1 has great jumpscares

[@KiiBon]

​@@cheese0827No, I mean the previous version of Fnaf Plus. There was another one before this that wasn't nearly as impressive

[@yoyoy9546]

@@KiiBon Yeah that was V0.5 which is made by the same guy who made this one, LostPawPlay

[@Passw0rdYT]

Poor bonnie had a run in with a swarm of angry bees from the looks of it

[@laabgbbs1]

The original fnaf 1 jumpscares are just so good and simple but the fnaf plus designs are definitely scarier

[@jurassic190]

I like how the scream sounds more static-like kinda like a radio

[@BenGamingX]

Fnaf rtx off:😐 Fnaf Rtx on:😱

[@BigJDawg4523]

In FNAF Plus, they added a firework sound with the jumpscares. How fun! 🎉

[@bigboahtony7759]

7:35 "I fear no man, but that thing. It scares me."

[@hoxiipoxii56]

These are great and all but I think the fadeout and death screen really break the immersion. This was my gripe with JR's as well.

[@hoxiipoxii56]

They're too swift, y' know? Don't let you process the genuine horror of what happened to that poor unfortunate soul in favour for a "cooler" transition. I just don't think it works

[@garrtoons4303]

Ngl, Plus really does go above and beyond in terms of delivery and effort. It is a great fan game.

[@chromelambo3938]

Foxy’s jumpscare is a whole lot better in plus than the original

[@tuukkamatikainen3389]

I'm sorry, but I can't take the new jumpscare sounds seriously, they genuinely sound like meme sfx 😭

[@dollarnattar2]

The first thing that came in my mind after seeing this moment 7:26 was a video about a guy who bought himself some weed at a gas station.

[@carvode7428]

I feel that the biggest difference is in the cut. Animations and animatronics are good but the white noise shortly after the screamer just adds some uncanny element of sorts, when fnaf+ instantly puts this weird musiv and weird animation that is imo much less scary than the white noise interrupting an intence screamer. Foxy is a huge glow up tho

[@Nemo________]

The power outage Freddy is 10 times scarier, You just see his teeth and his eyes flashing and there’s no music 😭

[@Stukleak]

I was prepared for the fnaf plus jumpscares yet i still jumped from my seat

[@ThexTraveler]

One thing that I like about Bonnie in FNAF plus I that he has the ability to disable cameras like Tjoc Office where Bonnie does the same thing

[@spinningpeanut]

Good lord the toreador march is haunting thats exactly what the worst of the irl animatronics looked like. The eyes man. The eyes.

[@abc.animal5143]

The original designs are scarier because of their uncanny style. The new ones are clearly designed to look scary, but the old ones, being made to NOT look scary and make kids laugh, makes it feel all the more creepy. But the new games executes the jump scares well.

[@sallytheuselessbird]

I dont see it, the originals just arent scary

[@mrscruffles801]

The subtly of Fnaf 1 was what made it stick out. Making them look "scary" would ruin the believability that kids would grow attached to these characters. The point of Fnaf was to show how unsettling something normally cute and marketable can be under different circumstances.

[@mjasterix1667]

0:30 why is bonnie genuinely tweakin

[@Creative_YT]

when they said “AAAAAAAAA” i liked that part

[@driftarmy8414]

fnaf plus jumpscare are in another level

[@alexjackyperson101]

The sound when he's just got in the room is just something else

[@RyanElliott2005]

They’re typical tbh, nothing special. Good game tho

[@dexter2898]

​@@RyanElliott2005I don't think anybody is ever gonna top the jumpscares from tjoc:sm. The only person who could do that is probably nikson himself in his ignited collection

[@KimvyKinsley]

Yeah, another level of mediocre

[@Tam3603]

7:28 this is music from chapter 3 that the devs posted on their discord

[@linkroyal3703]

What is that? A ghost or something?

[@Nessie7205]

The jumpscares in FNaF plus look a lot better (minus Freddy's power out because it's the exact same as his regular one) but the rest of it just seems like it's not trying to be an upgraded FNaF 1, but instead a 3d version that is trying too hard to be scary that it forgets what it's actually supposed to be

[@TylerWallace69420]

The lights out Freddy in fnaf plus is absolutely terrifying

[@madycartoonlover3383]

I like the Og models better but the remade jump scares are scarier.❤

[@annistar9693]

Actually watching them move on camera is something I didn't know I was afraid of til now

[@beeninn8307]

4:58 man whyd this actually get me

[@MediaMen22]

On the thumbnail, the remastered version of Bonnie looks like the rabbit from Hoodwinked

[@ItsDave07]

I love how you can hear the sound of foxy running and getting closer the detail is amzing

[@Ne_Ne_Vova_UA]

Ah, such a nice video to watch before going to bed

[@SunnyMitten]

I hope to see the phone calls from fnaf plus uploaded as were the OG

[@Parkdum]

it takes alot of effort to get jumpscared by plus chica

[@MaximumChannel]

Freddy is not ready for this

[@divinity898]

7:30 dont ever buy no weed from the gas station bro

[@bucketman5386]

God that death screen bro 😮‍💨

[@SourHillTony5983]

agree

[@CursedSFMS]

7:31 Thats just scout tf2 💀💀💀

[@bleh9314]

Scout, victim of the bite of '87

[@Mono-so1cl]

0:50 i hate how bonnie is he ONLY one to do this

[@Brent751]

Really live the detail when the endoskeleton jaw actually moves

[@bluenevla7874]

Why did u feel the need to leave in so much static screen after the original jump scares? Im glad I had ad block turned on for this vid

[@callmezeldaonemoartime]

4:44 nah, that’s trying a bit too hard ngl

[@chucklesmcgee5693]

I don’t love the new jumpscares in fnaf plus, I think most of them look silly or stupid. But I love the new power outage jumpscare! So creepy how part of his face lights up, and that the jumpscare happens DURING the song instead of after.

[@daniloramdom9861]

The one that scared me was Freddy from fnaf plus when the power went out because I expected the song to go away so that if he would attack and attack at once then I got scared because I didn't expect it AHAHAHAHA

[@nelsonic84nelson25]

That fnaf plus golden Freddy actually got me because I didn’t think it was gonna happen

[@Lepro2526]

It looks like jrs gameplay, so cool

[@Tooneric5252]

1:00 2:22 3:33 5:01 6:25 7:21

[@Alpha-b487]

0:45 bonnie moving fast. Like real rabbit, and also the fact that Bonnie, like, runs faster than Foxy

[@user-nv4nj7oh4c]

In this fan fnaf plus, the streamers are too fast. I just don't have time to be scared, in the original fnaf, the screamers are longer and better.

[@imbatrossthescrub2096]

That Freddy jumpscare ALWAYS gets me

[@MASTER56555]

In fnaf plus ... No freddy song? :(

[@mnstrforce4023]

Um, question. Who is that? 7:30

[@RyanElliott2005]

Bro never saw vhs tapes

[@CrazyManhog]

Jack Walten

[@exaltedarchvile4357]

Scout from Team Fortress 2

[@dolomitilino9015]

Having more animation really helps, and I think making the faces smaller/heads chunkier makes them creepier

[@djjk5457]

It's like a children's pizza place we can't make it creepy

[@dolomitilino9015]

@@djjk5457 but it’s a game…

[@djjk5457]

@@dolomitilino9015 it's not a game it's real life

[@dolomitilino9015]

@@djjk5457 it’s a video game, and video games don’t have to be realistic

[@djjk5457]

@@dolomitilino9015 it's real life not a video game

[@thenelsonbruhs722]

7:24 ah heck naw he got the gas station weed 💀

[@twillacatron7596]

Even though I like the Plus game over, Og always wins

[@anarchy_9841]

Avarage Scott sucker

[@VERT1220]

That literally means you’re blinded by nostalgia

[@flamingcat1101]

​@@VERT1220No it doesn't

[@sallytheuselessbird]

​@@flamingcat1101Yes it does. Saying the old one is better no matter what is literally the definition of nostalgia blindness.

[@dangng7079]

​@@sallytheuselessbirdno lmao😂 + L ratio

[@ryoach1999]

What’s the soundtrack name at the missing child part?

[@tuftyterror983]

Bonnie in Fnaf+ looks like the villain from hoodwinked

[@twillacatron7596]

You’ve been hoodwinked baby

[@Flame_and_fortune]

TY UP DA GIL BABY

[@Jayboi77]

If u look closely at the stacit inf fanf one u can kinda see something

[@nicolerogameplays3454]

1:01 J0DER

[@noice6421]

Would be interesting if there was blood flowing out of freddy head in fnaf plus.

[@oseiascalebe]

Crazy jumpscared

[@Bluefire397]

fnaf plus trying way too hard to be scary

[@firestar6]

Ok the 1987 golden freddy one for fnaf plus doesn't just seem like an Easter egg it straight up just looks like something you should have never looked up or else you end up cursed. Like a challenge where someone triple dog dares you to do it.

[@wiktorniewiem3442]

bro had easter egg with head bonnie in parts and services

[@bignick2k215]

Both are great in their own ways

[@vroygan1551]

Bonnie just looks like that Bunny villain from Hoodwinked now.

[@vortexgaming7800]

What version of FNAF Plus did you play?

[@RyanElliott2005]

Latest one the dev of it made.

[@helpy336]

Foxy running down the hallway is actually terrifying. The only problem with it is that the footsteps sound like human footsteps and not metallic animatronics

[@repwashere]

Mike looks like he has seen better days at 7:25

[@ConeKatOhio_]

8:00 bro had his mouth all the way up

[@hydrasalesman9629]

The golden freddy one is the only improvement. Being able to see the animatronics slide from the side before they scare you removes all surprises.

[@ShadowWolffi]

Nothing will ever even come close to being half as good as the originals.. Ever

[@fourseasons4105]

Sometimes less is more...

[@katekiler]

yeah exactly. there is got to be something subtle, obscure and unspoken. something that needs to be poorly made and skewed on purpose, not that perfectly polished style with a tons of unnecessary animations, pointless changes with only purpose of the change itself, and that frivolous too "scary" design. i mean yeah, without a doubt this is the game that got its appreciation from the fans, but this is definitely not the game dozens of millions of people would have played for decades anyways. og fnaf is like telling you nothing, only showing its malicious intent while remaining silent and obscure and that you are not belong, while fnaf plus is like heeey look at me im so well made, modern and casual. oh no, you lost? would you like to play again? everything is alright buddy. but anyways it’s just my perception of it

[@Chee6]

​@@katekilerWell it's called "Plus" for something, isn't it? Extra animations, polished graphics, re-designs, etc. You don't find it as scary as the original? That's okay but I don't understand this argument of "It tries too hard to be scary" yeah, THAT'S the point, it can't be as "less" as the original because it's meant to be "plus"

[@Muzzled_Monster]

The Plus designs are so overtly scary that they’re not scary at all to me. They just look silly.