FNAF: Unsolved Mystery of Midnight Motorist (Five Nights at Freddy's Unsolved Mysteries - Theory)

[@HyperDroid]

I don't know how I didn't notice, but yes the Intro will be turned down in Episodes 4+! No I don't know why it went so loud and how I didn't realize after 3 episodes haha. Do you have any FNAF: Unsolved Mysteries that you'd wanna know more about? EPISODE 2: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aIjIoGmqg5tmnKc ALSO CORRECTION: Grave CANNOT be Elizabeth's, she dies after Charlie's already dead, not before, so my bad for that error, I confused my original dumb timeline with the one with a load of research and stuff, my bad! It would be either Mrs. Afton's or where William hid Charlie's body, nothing else really makes too much sense Timeline-wise SUBSCRIBE! :)

[@gela-sj7uk]

idk

[@FebbyFaber]

Potato

[@thehunter9248]

Why are there kids in security puppet minigame? Also, why is LEFTY an animatronic that you can buy?

[@evenlynrose]

The wooden animatronics why are they there and how where they made

[@duckmangameing]

I love your videos

[@ethanforan7050]

Finally someone who can just state the obvious that Juniors is a bar it sounds like a bar name. And it really doesn’t make sense for a kids arcade restaurant to be open at midnight if the name of the game is true or for it to have a bouncer outside. And if a kid was just murdered outside of another location the company would immediately close all the others.

[@JDMMaster26]

I kind of feel like the footprints belong to the crying child instead and he broke out to visit a loved one buried in that pile of dirt

[@HyperDroid]

yes I do agree with it being Crying Child's! that's what I meant by 2:57, I meant the unsolved mystery of just the RABBIT footprints :) him visiting the mound/grave itself is also a good theory!

[@Dumbo-zx7oc]

@@HyperDroid here’s the thing spring Bonnie wouldn’t work well because it was raining and it couldn’t of happened earlier in the day before the rain because the dirt wouldn’t be wet enough to create footprints which just makes this more confusing because it can be literally any animatronic

[@codyryan9789]

@@Dumbo-zx7oc maybe it was one of the 2 friends we see with Michael in the fnaf4 mini games.

[@Dumbo-zx7oc]

@@codyryan9789 but it’s a animatronic foot we we can tell this because it has 3 toes which a lot of animatronics have it’s honestly can only be a fnaf 1 animatronic but that wouldn’t make sense since MCI victims aren’t dead yet

[@ender01o66]

@@Dumbo-zx7oc what if spring bonnie is haunted, and it slowly corrupts william, which is why he kills people

[@Darkstar574]

I feel like the proof of you driving on the wrong side of the road in the mini game can kinda prove that this is a normal thing for william to do

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

I thought it was cause he’s British

[@Ms.FortuneTeller]

@@unicornbarfingrainbows7599 But he lived in the US.

[@unicornbarfingrainbows7599]

@@Ms.FortuneTeller that was a joke. He lives in the US but has a British accent and so does his kids.

[@radcanadian7365]

I actually like this theory that all the killings happened because Afton was drunk and reckless one night. It's a sad but realistic idea to how and why he started killing those kids, and that it all could have been avoided if Afton had just not been drunk that night.

[@agua246]

This is quite a good theory. Sometimes its always the simplest of answers and not a stretched out lore of why killers kill

[@dannyboidee]

Honestly yeah. Instead of him just being some evil incarnate who is evil and villainous for his whole life for the hell of it, making him a tragic character at first who transitions into a villain feels better.

[@radcanadian7365]

@@agua246 That was my thought of it

[@radcanadian7365]

@@dannyboidee It definitely makes more sense than him just being evil for the sake of being evil. He just went deeper and deeper into a rabbit hole that he accidentally started

[@jerekaneplaysthings7755]

One headcanon I like is he started drinking heavily because of either Mrs. Afton fighting/leaving him/dying, and he was jealous of Henry's happy family.

[@dominicfox101]

I'm thankful someone else who made a video on the lore agrees that Jr's was just a hint to William's reasoning to kill, and that Green Guy isn't super important. I think the timeline is really weird in a lot of ways and anything could make sense from any angle but anymore, as long as it makes sense, that' good.

[@justice8718]

Nah. William Afton buried himself in the Yellow Guy's backyard till Susie's dog was ran over.

[@ranma8834]

i don't have anything to add to the theories, but simply wanted to say how cool the idea for this series is. mixing the old buzzfeed unsolved with fnaf (arguably the indie franchise with the most mysteries) was genius - it was like a double nostalgia hit. can't wait for more episodes :D

[@SmoughTown]

As someone who played all the games only recently absent the research of the community - that was my initial thought; JR's is just a bar and they are turning Afton away because he is drunk/and a mess.

[@ashykins]

I think the drunkenness and William just being a psychopath makes sense. I think that this along with what the squimpus tapes said I know non canon but taking his anger out of Michael by killing other kids because it would be too obvious to kill his remaining kid after the crying child was crushed. In essence his motive is him being drunk and a psychopath where murder is a way for him to get his anger out. But also murder allows him to kill people like Michael so he has the relief of killing people like his son but not killing him directly

[@frenchiesottises8193]

The minigame feels so out of place that, yeah, this could literally be the game that gives us William's motive behind all the murders. The biggest question that people ask when stuff like this happens is why, and William is no exception to that rule. People just play along with it now cause we never had a clear answer. William being drunk and finding a new way to vent his anger actually makes a lot of sense. Also, something, something, it's not the first time Scott's implemented weird clues in order to tell us something we either didn't get or got wrong and they've felt out of place. Makes sense this game is just another example of that.

[@konaqua122]

There's something bugging me about this and I realized this now. We never saw the inside of that room with the broken window, right? There was a footprint outside, it was raining and the present one in the house is watching tv. Then the only possibility is there was someone from the outside breaking in the inside. This debunks the Crying child theory going outside. Why? There are no glasses outside the broken window. This is a normal clue on detective shows like Detective conan. If the force for breaking the glass came from the inside, (Crying child going out to escape theory), then there should be shattered glass outside. There was none so it's possible that someone broke from outside to inside and the shattered glasses are in that room. No one noticed because of the sound of rain and TV.

[@WalterWhite69]

Maybe orange guy was the purple guy before he got insane

[@badbatboy]

Yes

[@Fallenvalkyriealyss]

I'm so glad you made this video. I've always assumed that jrs was a bar, and green guy was a bouncer. You did fill in some blanks for me tho. Because I was under the impression that the dirt pile and the footsteps had to do with the animatronics burying themselves like they do in the novels. And coming to life at night and kidnapping the crying child. But then I always wondered, how did he get back home? But your theory makes much more sense timeline wise.

[@giantsalamander8139]

I always thought the mini game was trying to say the following: William, struck with grief over either his wife or Elizabeth, turns to alcohol to try and ease his problems. When the bar Jr’s cuts him off, saying he’s had too much to drink, William goes out driving. His driving is reckless and dangerous, exactly like how you drive in the mini-game itself. That night when Charlie gets locked out, she does what all children do, run out into the street, where she’s hit and killed by drunk driver William. William panics, hides her body in the alley, and speeds off. However, it’s this encounter that activated his dormant desire to kill. William, who was looking for an escape from the loss he’d suffered, first tried alcohol, but by accident found that he could get a better high from murder. He drives home, behavior erratic from what’d he’d just done, yells at his kids and then goes to find where the crying child went. Canonically I don’t think he went back to Jr’s, I just think the dialogue option there is supposed to tell the viewer William had been there earlier. PLUS, it makes no sense for Jr’s to be a pizzeria, what children’s pizzeria is open at midnight?

[@StickBoi2743]

I think the pile of dirt was an Easter egg for the Twisted Ones, as that book came out not too long before FFPS

[@mattsadveyt]

Good theory! But wouldn’t that mean that the twisted animatronics are THE NIGHTMARE ANIMATRONICS? And That They Come from the ground to kill the crying child?

[@duckman9327]

@@mattsadveyt which can’t really work considering fnaf 4 is a test area, meaning it wasn’t just some random attack

[@Takejiro24]

@@duckman9327 So, if FNAF 4 was a test area, then William was really willing to have the animatronics kill his kid(s)......just to test them out?

[@duckman9327]

@@Takejiro24 Yeah, actually lol. William has been shown to have no care or feelings towards anyone, in the fourth closet he outright treats Elizabeth as a slave rather than his child, which is saying something because she’s the only of his children that he seems to like. William will do whatever to anyone in order to get what he wants.

[@JDMMaster26]

Now future ideas -shadow animatronic mystery (who are they and what's their purpose in the lore) -fnaf 3 minigame lore -why is it possible to buy lefty which isn't supposed to be a stage character as it has to soothe and transport the puppet -why all animatronics in fnaf sb are aggressive towards Gregory except Freddy and Sun Like if you agree so he'll see how many people want those videos

[@garrettclemens6612]

William started a bar fight man i need a game about that

[@mageofshadow]

I really like this interpretation of midnight motorist, though I'd say it is more trying to show why William decided to target Charlie in specific rather than giving us a motivation for him becoming a killer. Considering the funtimes were created for the sole purpose of kidnapping children in order to harvest remnant he'd probably already been fine with murdering kids by this point.

[@cashbrady4074]

AT 6:36 I Dont think it was a bar since alot of people explaining timelines they say that henry said you cant enter in here for fnaf 2 location and i dont think he was drunk and tried to take his anger out he wanted revenge

[@dingleberrysauce]

the green man is henry,the orange man is afton,afton went to "Jrs" to claim the co-founder position at the new restaurant/pizzeria henry started,but henry didnt want him to be part of the new restaurant.

[@jokernoob9905]

I remember RyeToast made a theory that Midnight Motorist took place AFTER the bite of 83, and the animal footprint was Golden Freddy's (appearing out of nowhere as per usual). The one who snuck out was Michael, he broke a window to follow the machine that had killed his brother, and "that place" is the grave, the Bite Victims grave.

[@cheerios2548]

I saw that theory and I really like it!

[@duckman9327]

eh, doesn’t really make sense as to who the person on the chair could be. (plus, golden freddy didn’t do the bite)

[@thisisasupersayin376]

I've also accepted that theory, but the last part of this video is helpful for fleshing things out since William being drunk when he kills Charlie is a detail that can just be slotted in without disrupting Ryetoast's interpretation

[@deadshotop6876]

@@duckman9327 isnt fredbear and golden freddy the same animatronic?

[@duckman9327]

@@deadshotop6876 no, they are not. Design wise, they are different, not to mention that golden Freddy has black/brown highlights while fredbear has purple. They’re the same type of robot(and same character, golden Freddy is a fredbear, but not THE fredbear from fnaf 4), but different suits

[@aishisufuyu5961]

I've read so many theories about this minigame and I've never once seen anyone mention that other room with the mound. That's pretty crazy. I've seen some people specualte the footprints could have been related to Shadow Bonnie. I don't think anything is impossible, but I guess that'd probably be unlikely. I do think you may have ignored why CC's footprints weren't there.

[@rwqfsfasxc4668]

Actually the fazbear's fright books heavily imply that the footprints belong to Shadow Freddy but obviously nothing is confirmed.

[@aishisufuyu5961]

@@rwqfsfasxc4668 It's... YOU!!!

[@rwqfsfasxc4668]

@@aishisufuyu5961 It's Me

[@sockjems2558]

Mat Pat over on the game theorists channel suggested the mound is one of the "twisted ones" from the book trilogy which was quite interesting

[@ender01o66]

@@rwqfsfasxc4668 wait, really?

[@espsiongold2espy655]

(Unsolved mysteries the traffic light lore) Unfortunately springlocks and rain don't mix. I'd focus more on why the guy at Jr's is the colour green. and the person on the seat gets two colours. If we find red guy then we have the full set of traffic light guys green amber and red and the lore of the game is we need more traffic lights to stop speeding traffic going 500mph on the road .... 😂

[@Username-pz1te]

I heard a similar theory to yours with the only difference being that instead of the footprints being Springbonnie's, they were actually Shadow Freddy's, who went to BV's room and lured him to see Charlotte's body. Due to the "what is seen in shadows is easily misunderstood in the mind of a child", BV thought that Shadow Freddy was Fredbear in the shadows and when he saw Charlotte's body, he became scared of the animatronics, hence why he's so terrified in fnaf 4.

[@Username-pz1te]

@Sally Trip not necessarily. Something of note is that the Orange Guy ignores the footprints. If he’s able to see his sons footprints from that far away, why wouldn’t he notice the animal footprints closer? What this suggests IMO is that the footprints weren’t actually left there, rather they are just there to represent that Shadow Freddy was standing there. Granted, I don’t really believe the theory but it’s something I’ve heard.

[@Wattson19]

How would this be Shadow Freddy if he's made out of agony, pain and suffering from the MCI, that happens in 1985?

[@Username-pz1te]

@@Wattson19 that’s not confirmed. The person who made the theory believes that he was created before then. Though I don’t believe this theory for that reason

[@Wattson19]

@@Username-pz1te Who made this theory and what's his explanation for Shadow Freddy?

[@Username-pz1te]

@@Wattson19 a KZbinr named ImpulseEvan_37. He believes a more unpopular theory that Elizabeth died first and that Circus Baby wasn’t designed to kill, rather the killing features were added on later. The reason Baby killed Elizabeth was similar to the Novels where it was powered by Williams rage after Mrs. Afton divorced him. This rage created Shadow Freddy. Not 100% sure what the evidence for this is, I just know that one of the pieces of evidence that he brought up in a separate video was based on the theory that Eleanor is in the games and that in the games Eleanor is a version of Elizabeth. He then noted that in FF Eleanor was an entity called The Shadow similar to Shadow Freddy and used that as evidence that they were connected. There might be other pieces of evidence that I’m forgetting. I think the first video where he mentioned it is on his video about who died first. I disagree with quite a few of these concepts, though. Edit: I guess another way for this to work is if you believe that Shadow Freddy was created by Charlottes murder.

[@nightdog4183]

I never thought about this, but William killing Charlie because he was drunk is an interesting interpritation of how it happened ngl.

[@andrew_the_artist]

Maybe the mound is a grave for Mrs. Afton. I doubt it, but it's possible.

[@ckvr]

I feel that the next fnaf game should take place in JR’s taking place at the same time as fnaf 2 and showing that they opened another restaurant with the monetary gain from the first two. They could attempt to show early prototypes of gregbot (if they choose to go down that route) and show depth to the restaurants and the daytime of the haunted pizza restaurant.

[@TheBlackChaos]

Is Junior's Five Nights At JR's??? Im just joking

[@TheBlackChaos]

But it's just a theory. A game theory!

[@MeemahSN]

This is probably a stretch, but I think JR’s is a parallel to Jeff’s Pizza in Into The Pit. Jeff’s Pizza used to be a Freddy’s location but was rebranded and taken over, years after the original establishment was shut down. I’d imagine JR’s is in a similar vein in that it was once a Freddy’s location but was bought out, downsized, and rebranded under a new name and owner. Since Afton no longer owns the place, and if it is a bar, then it would make sense for the new owner to turn him down if he’s always getting drunk there.

[@Jesse-zl8sf]

What’s strange is, how could there be footprints from William dressing up in a spring lock suit when he was too busy getting drunk and murdering Charlie. Also if he used the suit the only way footprints could show up, is if it was raining, and everyone knows springlock suits DON’T do moisture. While I definitely think ur right on most of everything, there is still puzzle pieces that don’t fit.

[@Stream.DailyClips]

Hmm is Scott going to tell us the history someday?

[@berniebare371]

I’ve been holding out hope that one day, he’ll release a “Big Book of FNaF” where he just straight up tells us the lore. But now that he’s retired, I don’t think it’ll happen unfortunately.

[@mr.ugabye]

@@berniebare371 he still makes the books and is in charge of the lore he just doesn’t make the games anymore

[@Angermations]

@@berniebare371 he's not retired, he still writes books and helps Steel Wool make the games, heck I wouldn't be surprised if he released a game made by only him again.

[@robotstar3876]

But another question. Is that, Where is Michael? Maybe he's the one watching television. But right now I said that that one watching TV isn't Michael. But the purple car says that the yellow guy is William(in his normal form) and the boy who could have ran off was Michael. Maybe. But it is so difficult to say because the damn purple car. Bro why the heck is it purple???? Maybe the guy was an employee of the. Fredbear diner so that's why his car is purple. But how if it was actually William then how to spring bonnie came towards William house? Maybe those footprints were Michael's footprints

[@FTZPLTC]

So... way back when, Mat Pat put out a theory about Orange Guy not being William Afton, but being Henry... which would completely upend a lot of stuff that has been assumed about the other characters... but which I think can actually still work. Unless there's some definitive evidence that I've not seen, I don't think anything in the games directly contradicts the possibility of Orange Guy being Henry, and Mike and Crying Child being Henry's sons. I know people point to the cut scene at the end of Sister Location as proof that Springtrap is the "Father" that Mike is addressing... but that's only an inference. I dunno, to me, including Midnight Motorist makes a lot more sense if it's supposed to tell us something. And what really bothers me about the idea of Orange Guy being William Afton is that that *wouldn't* really tell us anything. We don't really gain new information from it. Whereas if the intent was to say "No! You've got it wrong! Crying Child ISN'T Purple Guy's son!", then it would make more sense as an inclusion. Showing his father as the *opposite* colour of Purple Guy would make a lot more sense too, if it was supposed to signal that he's a different character. Whereas showing the same character in a different way only creates more confusion.

[@blueberryelf1150]

This is a great theory! Puts a new perspective on things

[@robotstar3876]

Well Jr's is actually just a restaurant where William wanted to go but was blocked by the guard and became very angry and came home. When he came home he saw that Evan and gone to the freedy's. Now Evan was actually scared of going there so how can he go there at night in fear of it Well according to me that yellow guy isn't William. He is someone else. The yellow footprints that we see is actually maybe spring bonnie foot prints. Maybe William came towards the boy and tried to bring the boy to the Fredbear diner. And then elimated the him and Put the body in the Fredbear suit(one at parts and services)

[@msiio]

source: trust me bro

[@maryleethefox8642]

I 100% believe the Scott himself doesn't know what is going on, he's just leave bits of lore here and there that he just decided on without a bigger picture in mind. The man has just been winging it for years and will never admit it.

[@tastyboi2163]

Maybe his wife left him after Elizabeth got killed, and Elizabeth is in the dirt mound. This is why he's getting so drunk and full of anger and why he'd take it out on his ex-partners daughter etc

[@duckman9327]

but Elizabeth is kinda like, in baby’s stomach?

[@tastyboi2163]

@@duckman9327 this is true lmfao how could i forget the horror

[@duckman9327]

@@tastyboi2163 baby is also in the mound, clearly.

[@King-CosmoAlpha1]

I kinda like the theory on Jr’s and the green guy, maybe jr’s is just a bar that William would go to get drunk probably because of the guilt he felt for what happened to Elizabeth, he probably caused a commotion inside the bar and was kicked out so in his drunken state he got angry and drove back to Fredbear’s diner where he saw Charlie ( Henry’s daughter) alone outside and so in his anger decided to kill her, probably because he was jealous at Henry since Henry had a good life with his wife and daughter while William had no wife probably cause she left him or passed away, so William decided to take something from Henry so he would feel the same pain he felt. After killing Charlie he drove back home only to find out his son ran off to Fredbear’s family diner Now that I think of it William is a straight up Psychopath

[@flaremations2693]

Even if he was sad cause of Elizabeth's death, it's still his fault cause she died from circus baby which William made specifically to kill children.

[@samuelsmith1412]

I LOVE this theory, your so underrated!

[@charlierashi100]

The problem with this theory is that the grave doesn’t add up. We know that Elizabeth Afton dies because Baby was programmed by William (Purple Guy) to kill children. We also know that Charlie, Henry’s daughter, died before any of the others. So if this is based the same day as Charlie’s death (William’s first murder), why would Baby already be programmed to kill children? It only really makes sense that William got a taste for killing after his first victim (Charlie), so he programmed Baby to kill for him, which means Elizabeth must die after Charlie, so therefore she can’t be in that grave. So we suppose that it’s Mrs Afton in the grave. Why would William be trying to scare Crying Child away from Fredbear’s if none of his children have died due to the animatronics yet? Also, it’s heavily implied that Mrs Afton posses Ballora, so she couldn’t be in that grave if she does.

[@alyxlocke1284]

I always thought that JR’s was the FNAF 2 location and that green guy was phone guy, but honestly this makes more sense. FNAF 6 was all about tying up loose ends, so this could work

[@huan_karamehmedovic]

that toast fnaf channel said that the one escaping and breaking their window is michael seeing the spirit of his brother as golden freddy, explaining why the animatronic footprints suddenly appear. The pile of dirt could be crying childs grave and michael could be going to "that place" after seeing a ghostly aparition of the animatronic that got his brother killed

[@jerekaneplaysthings7755]

* In regards to the footprints: I feel like would have to be a Shadow Animatronic. Those footprints are still fresh visible in pouring rain and we know for a fact that Animatronics, especially springlock suits like Spring Bonnie, do not do well while wet, so it couldn't have been anyone but those 2. It couldn't have been William since he just got home from killing Charlotte, and there's only one set of footprints where the rest just vanished. * One theory I saw on reddit that seems really simple to explain William being orange: If he just killed Charlottle, his suit would be messy and he had to change clothes. It's such a simple answer but I had never thought of it that way * To me, the grave belonging to Mrs. Afton makes the most sense. Look at it this way: if that was Elizabeth's grave, that would mean William made child remnant funtime kidnappers before everything else started. He would have to know possession existed at that point. * As far as an Unsolved mysteries episode., I'd like to see one about 'Immortal And The Restless'. There could be a lot people could grab from that series!

[@mattsadveyt]

I believe JR’s was fredbear’s I mean think about it, the kid (aka most likely the crying child) ran away to “that place” he can’t really go anywhere since they are surrounded by the woods, so he could only go to JR’s and we know most likely that the crying child loves Fredbear’s and it’s animatronics and William wants him NOT to go there because of what happened to Elizebeth, so multiple nightmare nights later: he’s scared of fredbear’s ALSO we see in the fnaf 4 mini game that fredbear’s is pretty close to the Afton house, so it wouldn’t be a stretch to assume the location is fredbear’s

[@TheBlackChaos]

HyperDroid Did you hear about Cube Escape? I would really like if you did Timeline of Cube Escape it's a game where you have to solve to get out of a room I can't explain how it works :D I think you won't see this

[@NobodyUndefined]

I like the idea of jr's being a bar and the guy at the door being a bouncer, that's really accurate and honestly I think that's what Scott was going for. But I don't think William just started killing kids after getting drunk one night and killing Charlie. As we don't see Elizabeth in midnight motorist and we see a mound of dirt, it's possible that Elizabeth has already died and Afton buried her remains. And as the funtimes were programmed to kill kids, which is how Elizabeth died, this means at this point Afton was already killing kids/planning to kill them and probably just killed Charlie out of spite for Elizabeth dying. I think like MatPat theorized, William was always just an awful person who just killed for the fun of it like lots of serial killers do.

[@deejaepjs]

I really like this theory!!! This is basically what I thought, but everyone else wants to take it a step further.....

[@FosterBaba]

Idk, tv guy kinda sounds more like a mom vs an older brother. “Leave him alone. He had a rough day today” doesn’t really sound like something a bully of an older brother would say, especially to their murderer dad. Idk about all game theory said on this, but that definitely sounds like a mom to me

[@Uggabugga07]

"Toy animatronics are possesed" is something i thought we all agreed on wasn't the case

[@Angermations]

Ayy a new series! But also, is the Fazbear Frights timeline series gonna continue? I really liked it.

[@duckman9327]

The footprints are almost certainly Shadow Freddy’s instead of Springbonnie’s, as he’s been shown to lure people to places in follow me minigames and frights

[@cisnt9244]

I think maybe Henry is orange guy, checking on aftons kids or on his own. And afton has taken one away.

[@eternallylearning2811]

Before I watch this I made a youtube video under the possibility of the midnight motorist being Mrs afton ages ago just based on the logic that for alot of people the only person they would let use their car is the one they are married to.

[@ShadyPod]

İ was just thinking this . Even game theory cant solve this minigame

[@SCP-469]

That is dark as hell.

[@sarahni]

I remember thinking it was just a bar that he was being kicked out of when the game first came out, I think that if it was a previously known location Scott wouldn't have called it Jr's, a generic name for a bar/restaurant type establishment

[@L.R.R.H413]

The color connection for Afton being orange guy isnt really a strong starting point more of a stretch for evidence. The opposite color to orange on the wheel is blue not purple. For purple it would be yellow. These are known as their complementary colors. Even with this wheel used as an example the arrow starts at yellow/lime not orange. JR's defiantly is a bar though. Bars typically have flashing signs and someone standing guard outside. I mean have yall ever seen security for a kids restaurant standing outside? Not only that but I always got the vibe that this game was taking place at night.

[@JustAngellol]

And the reason he was angry could be because his wife died!!!

[@skycreeper0173]

Super awesome video. Your theory makes a lot of sense for me.

[@brunobucciaratiswife]

My only question is why the FNAF 4 house layout is different from the Midnight Motorist house layout, if they’re meant to be the same? They aren’t even similar I don’t think

[@pr.depper4819]

I don't feel like Charlie gets killed before Evan, "Later that Night" could be reffering to that and it's sort of an obvious guess but Nightmarionne isn't canon in fnaf 4 meaning possibly that the puppet hasn't been made yet and The Puppet is a security device so why would Henry build a Security Robot if no tragedies had happened at the location yet.

[@Doktor_Etti]

What about the fnaf boots in it its toll that Henry commited suicide with a animatronic

[@queenwannabee2600]

FNAF and a buzzfeed unsolved reference?? Never clicked faster.

[@lof1l769]

William can't be wearing the suit himself because it's raining, otherwise we would have gotten springtrap way sooner

[@gaminganimators7000]

I agree with most of it except the footprints. How do we know they're rabbit foot prints because most of the animatronics have very similar feet so for all we know it could be Fredbear.

[@grimace9670]

The jr’s detail along with William’s attitude could just be confirmation that William is a scumbag and there fore was not the one who promised to put the crying child back together again as it’s trying to paint him as an abusive father, idk

[@Mr.W.H]

You know in ruin at the end there are 3 old costumes? Well what if those costumes are from Jr's

[@SheriffZock]

‘Five Nights at Freddie’s: Midnight Motorist’ sounds like a Fnaf Mario kart rip off

[@darkangelboy7440]

What if the thing that the crying child saw wasn't someone putting on a spring lock suit but he saw the death of Charlotte and the reason that William didn't realize that his son was there is cause he thought both of his kids were at home as well as him being under the influence. Also does each 8 bit gameplay section in fnaf 4 take place one after the other or could they be swapped around

[@thegreatestwarnow2838]

This makes so much sense

[@Mr.Caelus]

Fnaf JR's is a fan game but there more from it, its more like a Deep Lore

[@spaceman3613]

4:48 “wife”

[@creeperboom9813]

I think that IF Jr's is supposed to be a Freddy's location, then Green Guy could be Phone Guy

[@trapbear48]

I think we should stay with your theory Because it make sense,William waz drunk and angry and thas why he killed Henry's daughter

[@Marco_1505]

Cool, never thought of it

[@VideoGameMasters09]

JRs could have been the FNAF 2 location and Green Guy coulda been Phone Guy.

[@adammartinez8061]

0:15 I believe that this maybe either the sister location of Fredbear’s or Freddy’s or its Fredbear’s family diner. In Security Breach there’s a gift box with a Fredbear’s family diner poster inside…..when you look at the poster, instead of Fredbear…..it’s Freddy…..Where do we also see This???? Oh wait…in that MiniGame from Fnaf 2…….A Animatronic is busy keeping Kids happy…..It wears a hat……Holding Carl the cupcake for some reason…..Yes…..The Animatronic is Freddy…..Not Fredbear…..Freddy.

[@WakoDoodle]

I had this crazy idea but Monty and Roxanne are new to fnaf: sb. But what if they weren't? What if they're from another pizza place or sister location and their likeness and/or their names were reused for familiarity? As if the fazbear company used them after aquiring the company through a buyout or maybe that company instead bought out fazbear after the fire? Because one thing I never understood is the pizzaplex itself. Who built the pizzaplex? It can't be vanny/vanessa as she wouldn't need to be hired if she already owned the place. But the chilling thing is, monty gator has appeared in fnaf in the past games. In the "happiest day ever" minigame there is a kid with a green mask that looks like monty and a purple mask that looks like the foxy one but with a shorter snout; like a wolf. It can't be mr hippo or happy frog as both masks clearly have some kind of muzzle (comparing to the foxy mask) and the purple one also shows teeth on the top, not the bottom. Could it be that monty and roxanne were around a lot longer than we knew? Could they be from JR's? It would explain why chika is also there with them along with freddy, instead of foxy and bonnie.

[@TheToolBox99]

I think it was a kid being lured by spring Bonnie to a location like Fredbears so the kid wanted to get away from his abusive dad

[@duckmangameing]

I love your videos

[@HyperDroid]

thank you so much! :)

[@sillygoofygoofball]

I'm still convinced orange guy is Henry.. but I get that it's unpopular at this point

[@JacobLovesDogs]

Bruh how do u do this ur good

[@jeremiahthornton7938]

Concerning the way Scott wrote the story, we may never know, not unless he tells us. That's good, but also very bad. I say this because he makes things too complicated. The story is like a jigsaw puzzle with pieces that don't fit to each other. It's clunky and disorganized, mostly because there is no clear order. Sorry for the rambling. I'll get to the point right away. I think Take Cake To The Children or Midnight Motorist did not happen after the Bite of '83, but before. The wildflowers and lush grass suggest the FNaF4 minigames take place in spring. Charlie died on Halloween. It could be the Halloween of that year, but I doubt it. The animatronics were acting up before the Crying Child died. And if Will already murdered Charlotte, it would explain why the "numerous and simultaneous springlock failures" happened. It also explains why Fredbear was able chomp the Crying Child's head, which no normal animatronic jaws can do. Will was behind it all. He may have started killing way before this, but who knows?

[@EvyDevy]

Tales from the Pizzaplex might solve this minigame

[@stickybear2557]

Could the crying child have just jumped into the suit? Similar to what goes on in Security Breach?

[@BasementDweller_]

The mini game that tore me apart.

[@blacknoircomicbook6495]

In my opinion, the footprint outside are Of Shadow Freddy,

[@xxmichael-aftonxx1426]

You are what made me the fnaf fan i am

[@Blake0118]

Great video 👍

[@garryoak]

Spring Bonnie would lock up bc the lock springs won't work in the rain.

[@OfficialGoldenLeaf]

Person watching TV is definetly not a child, they are the size of an adult as you can see from the legs reaching to the floor and the head reaching the head rest Also the person in the chair is probably not Michael as he was not an adult while the crying child was alive. And as a teen he did not care about his brother so he wouldn't have said "leave him alone he's had a rough day" I belive the person in the chair could be Ms.Afton and the kid could be a very young Michael. The problem with my theory is if it's the same night he killed charlie it could be much later in the timeline instead of when Michael was young. But if it's the crying child then we would know that Charlie died WAY before the missing childrens incident (we already knew it happend before but this places it ATLEAST 2 years prior) since the crying child died in 1983 and the missing childrens incident happend in 1985

[@cashbrady4074]

jrs is a run down carls jrs

[@Totallyoffical-lego_broly]

… Henry maybe

[@ginsingchamomile7648]

I don’t necessarily think that he killed her on purpose. I think she was in the wrong place at the wrong time. I think he pulled a hit and run and was too drunk to take responsibility for his actions so he left.

[@wackinghour]

I don't understand why people think the footprints are that of a rabbit.. Literally bear and rabbit animatronics have the same feet, and maybe (not broken) foxes as well.. Also if it was spring Bonnie, wouldn't it cause a spring lock? Causing the robot to limp to the ground?

[@RogerioSanto1]

I honestly don't think that orange guy is William. I'm sorry, I know there are theories about the purple car, but that doesn't seem enough to support that this purple car belongs to William itself. I mean... Why he would've been dressing and spring Bonnie or possibly sending a Bonnie animatronic to haunt his own house and his own children

[@kai7108]

I think that the person in front of tv is ms.Afton and the kid is foxy bro and the footprints are of golden freddy(crying child)

[@spencerdunn866]

What if orange guy wasn’t a guy at all. What if orange guy was orange girl? The mother? Mrs Afton? If so why is she upset. Maybe this is lore for the purple guy the escaped child is william afton. And jrs was the only place he felt safe. Away from the abuse.

[@Mediocre_Comments]

It was raining so can’t be springtrap that night.

[@GJMinions]

The footprints couldn’t be William cause then the spring locks would activate