Former director of Israel’s Mossad on civilian deaths in Gaza | UpFront

In this week's episode, Marc Lamont Hill challenges Mossad's former director, Efraim Halevy, on Israel's war on Gaza.
As Israel’s war on Gaza enters its fifth month, over 27,500 people have been killed and 85 percent of the total population has been internally displaced. The war has also spurred regional tensions and threatened stability across the Middle East.
Efforts to halt the war have been in vain, with Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who recently rejected a truce offer, saying there will be no end to the war until Israel wins.
So, when will the attacks and killings stop? And what is the Netanyahu government’s long-term strategy?
This week on UpFront, Marc Lamont Hill challenges Efraim Halevy, the former director of Mossad, Israel’s national intelligence agency.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
@AljazeeraEnglish
#Aljazeeraenglish
#News

[@bradjekadetje9890]

These ppl r never tired of playing the victim card!! EVIL🤢

[@SmellMyKKPP]

It's second nature that's why they don't get tired.

[@spinnach2896]

Which people are you referring to?

[@angieshujana3398]

Israel is a victim of its own evils.

[@mynews4272]

Indeed. Look at the way this Blacky guy is phrasing his loaded questions. Of course Israeli children are more important than Pali useless people.

[@angieshujana3398]

Palestine is also a victim of Israel's evils.

[@davidnagi5099]

Doesn't matter how much you press, you will NEVER get one of them to tell the truth, ever.

[@jameswoodend6029]

AMEN

[@chrisculhane3777]

Don't believe your lying eyes and ears

[@Ili_chilli]

its forbidden for them

[@rainbowbridge11]

Exactly, always either playing dumb and or lying never the truth

[@CowneloAlvaroid]

The truth is the greatest insult to an Israeli

[@staticcouch135]

Marc Lamont Hill is a journalistic genius.

[@Thinking858]

No he's a journalistic prophet like Mohammed

[@staticcouch135]

This man has committed assassinations in the past and is allowed to sit and speak while free.

[@ranapour]

This soulless war criminal should not be given air time to justify Israeli crimes. This evil soulless Zionist must be in ICJ answering for his crimes 😢😢.

[@kevindonaghey8483]

So does anyone in the American government including trump

[@staticcouch135]

@@kevindonaghey8483 Very true. 👹🤮

[@Tanakatricks]

This man needs to be locked up.

[@stillwatersnightsky6533]

You cannot talk with Israelis and not be blatantly lied to.

[@CharodyParody]

Sorry, don't agree with you.... A lying community will never progress and Israel is one of the top most countries in the world....

[@didi9017]

It’s in their culture mate. Rightly, wrongly, save your skin first no matter what the consequences are for others. Next, use the victim card and then the blame game. It worked all these 75 years of occupation so be relentless in the fabrications.

[@rak6223]

If you don't agree with Israelis, you become their enemy automatically, it feels like talking to a wall. Israelis have NPD (Narcissistic personality disorder) and it’s impossible to co-live with that narcissistic attitude. Gaslighting, arguing facts, narcissistic anger, playing victim when cornered. Faults projection on victim. Isolating victim. etc. etc.

[@yon4209]

How nice that you're using the same rhetoric *these* Israelis would use about Palestinians.

[@CharodyParody]

No country can lie and continue to prosper.... Palestinians have lost gor constantly lying and playing victim-card... they have lost all credibility.... therefore the world is silent and allowing Israel to have its way.....

[@doosenco]

Mr. Halevy just proved my made up saying: once a psychopath, always a psychopath.

[@mominulhaque2243]

None can be Mossad unless becomes psychopath!

[@stevehughes2731]

​@@mominulhaque2243and a bigger liar than trump, but that's the fascist way, and don't you see how white the Semite is ?

[@mogamadgreyson143]

​@@mominulhaque2243you can't become a psychopath,one is always a Psychopath,,you then become mossad.

[@TonyNaber]

mossad and psychopathy are one in the same. God knows how many strings these devilspawns are pulling

[@graceyenne4497]

And he does it in such a posh British accent.

[@mohdnorudin]

That is the face of an EVIL that will not tell the truth till the demise.

[@annamric6597]

Good grief, now he is senile. Everything he accused Palestinians of doing, Israel has done in the past weeks, months, years. No, I can't watch that evil man.

[@sho-na]

It’s called gaslighting.

[@dennissalisbury496]

Too painful to watch Genocide being justified by a psychopath.

[@wiFkyq-besmaf-3medwy-mz7cc]

TAKE ADVIL

[@halukkilic3171]

"It's hard to separate civilians from.." Pure evilness. Pure psycho.

[@henriettemcpartlin8640]

Why? Hamas is committing war crimes by not having army uniforms on. They can’t tell the difference between a mass person and a civilian.

[@thunderation]

He means, "it's hard for us to care enough to separate civilians from militants. It's hard for us to acknowledge civilians as humans equal to us."

[@Crazy5exycurvy]

If you can't separate, shouldn't they then retreat - not kill anyway?

[@halukkilic3171]

@@thunderation I know. They made a jen o cide house/techno song and video of them blo-wing buildings. *Sick*

[@ajaygup]

Israel know how to deal.

[@gillps5130]

Well done the interviewer for preventing further disingenuity over the nature of the case at the ICJ.

[@frenchfree]

His denial of the Hannibal directive exposes him as irrelevant.

[@savhass3956]

I cant listen to him anymore. He wants to go back to Oct 7, lets go back to 1917

[@henriettemcpartlin8640]

The history is older than that… try a few thousand

[@user-eg8fg3ik4y]

​@henriettemcpartlin8640 can't use bible or whatever entitlement from thousands of yrs ago to genocide n expell people from land so squatters can squatt.

[@ravenblack7052]

@@henriettemcpartlin8640 Ah yes, the era of the fairytales! Easter is coming... waiting for the Easter Bunny 🐰. Yay!

[@becobiberovic415]

​@henriettemcpartlin8640 are you talking about dinosaur 🦕 time?

[@Redcrossdwarf]

@@becobiberovic415 The snake in the Garden of eden🤔

[@hgfku-tn6hb]

Attack on palestine has got nothing to do with Hamas. Israel has been wishing to attack palestine all along

[@user-kc9uw9ij7j]

So take the murders and Isis to your home stupid

[@marksernes139]

400 dead in the West Bank provides proof of your statement

[@TheVuduYuDu]

It does have to do with Hamas in as much as it gives them the excuse to do what you describe and what the rest of the planet is beginning to believe.

[@YoramAizenberg]

This is so unfair. Hamas promised them in the elections to kill the Jews. Hamas kept the election promise and they were so happy after Hamas killed and raped 1200 Jews and Jewish women as well as children. But now Hamas is using the people who elected him as human protectors. Hamas robbed them of their food and humanitarian aid. Hamas shoots those who flee to the safe areas. Hamas fires rockets from their hospitals into Israel and forces thousands of people to stay in the hospitals so that they will be harmed when Israel returns fire to the sources of the fire. Hamas sends their children to the Israeli army to identify the sources of the gunfire. This is so unfair. If Hamas had told them that this is what would happen, they would not have chosen Hamas and would not have educated their children to kill Jews.

[@zen5419-so8kp]

You are projecting.

[@user-us3qw6ed4k]

Funny how the "victim" is always holding the knife and standing over the body.

[@mebdoc]

Imagine how many people died under this man's orders.

[@ReportingLiveFromNewYorkCity]

This isn’t a man. This is a pig at most

[@vaclavkubicek2970]

This old man is sick and has been for more than 75 years when the Israeli occupation began.

[@WahibaDaniels-qz2jm]

Remember how Ariel Sharon struggled to die. 8 years , suffering

[@annychest718]

collective hypnoses there is no truth within them

[@kirklandday]

And who knows, he could be the son of an SS, or maybe SS himself.

[@Thinking858]

It always hard to accept the real situation...

[@smubarik70]

He keeps calling it a war...there are no two states engaged in combat here, the reality on the ground is that there is a state with one of the most advanced army in the world destroying a people with no tanks, airplanes, armed carriers, no navy etc...how can this be a war?

[@creativestudios3d]

It's their delusion. Like saying an arson that is burning an entire building full of people 'A bit of a fire'.

[@justinharper6909]

Since when is a definition of war that both sides have to be equally equipped? War is a conflict where weapons are used to enforce a certain goal. Let´s go Israel.

[@MA-sk4fg]

So well said!!!

[@user-wl6zn5zg9u]

This is a genocide of Palestiniens in Gaza and in west bank with the American VITO they do what ever they want the 7th of October was a response to 75 years of occupation and ethnics kleinsin

[@MohamedIbnAbdouBa]

He said he's never seen or heard of the hannibal directive🤔. They'd rather lie and seem incomprehensibly incompetent of their positions, it's crazy.

[@bradbesco6595]

Listening to monsters may be fascinating but is ultimately pointless.

[@user-ug5dx9zr7r]

Why even bother trying to talk to an Israeli Mossad......

[@habsom1406]

...I hear what you're saying, but at least it exposes these conscience-less criminals and their total detachment from reality!

[@Nobody-zv5lp]

@@habsom1406 I totally agree. This is evidence. Their hubris does not allow them to see that this is self-incriminating.

[@richardchurchward4413]

To expose their lies, intent, blindness and evil.

[@mikejames8296]

These people are sick

[@rikailayabbir]

😔

[@Realone1000]

Facts

[@wiFkyq-besmaf-3medwy-mz7cc]

SHABBAT SHALOM 🇮🇱✡️🕎💙🤍💙🤍

[@Thinking858]

No,,, just you

[@giuliabudny6223]

I’m so dead with the amount of lies they spew smh

[@junebrilly5302]

KUDOS to Marc Lamont Hill. He has unquestionable Integrity and the Intellect to go with it! BRAVO!!!

[@PaulHallelujahMaranatha]

Genocide is evil

[@user-isra-hell-is-terr-or-rist]

So are Jews

[@Not-a-GSD]

So are the Zionist…

[@winifredobalbago2363]

Like hamas rapist regime

[@monamak8271]

God bless late Ohio congressman James Traficant for warning us about Zionist Israelis and USA support of Israel. He was killed.........

[@Thinking858]

Tell that to hamas

[@Ladygrind83]

Thank you Marc Lamont for calling out the racism and Calluseness of the Israeli government

[@andrewhigdon8346]

Our fearless news anchor held this guy to task and I commend him for this. Well done.

[@sagewalsh9702]

The Israeli man is lying about the Hannibal directive.

[@ek7390]

He is not Israeli he is a British man who forced Palestinian people off their land for his colonial project.

[@sagewalsh9702]

Oh okay. I misunderstood

[@amypowell6495]

His laughable denial about the Hannibal Directive should invalidate everything that came out of this man's mouth. Such obvious lies.

[@georgestavri4474]

ABSOLUTELY CORRECT!!!!

[@michaelyudovin3887]

Only in Hollywood would a government call that kind of operation Hannibal.

[@Peter-hs7zn]

Lie lie lies Hannable not real who he trying to kid just shows how far they go with lies .. The interview presenter was terrific. Showed the world what we needed to know of their character. Vile.

[@Hannestv4607]

*what a mistake in the Qur'an!* Allah himself testifies that he has a son and he is the son as Christians understand it! Only the Koran writer was too ignorant to know what Son of God means! Allah's word which created everything is Allah himself too! *The Word Allahs which created everything is the Son of God according to Christianity!*

[@Hannestv4607]

Son of God does not mean that God has a child in Christianity! *what a mistake in the Qur'an!* Son of God are 2 titles one referring to the Word of God = God himself and one referring to creation (humans, angels, demons)

[@TheBascotie]

Not familiar with the Hannibal directive? Tons of people OUTSIDE of Israel know what it is and the former director of the mossad claims he is not familiar with it..

[@wakingup1458]

Holy Fack , talking to these people is like beating your head against a wall. I give you credit Marc for your professionalism

[@Thinking858]

Yes,,, try speaking to Hamas leaders that's even worst

[@Britishrailwaystories]

Chilling to listen to. 1930s European tones here, absolutely frightening. Great journalism.

[@YoramAizenberg]

This is so unfair. Hamas promised them in the elections to kill the Jews. Hamas kept the election promise and they were so happy after Hamas killed and raped 1200 Jews and Jewish women as well as children. But now Hamas is using the people who elected him as human protectors. Hamas robbed them of their food and humanitarian aid. Hamas shoots those who flee to the safe areas. Hamas fires rockets from their hospitals into Israel and forces thousands of people to stay in the hospitals so that they will be harmed when Israel returns fire to the sources of the fire. Hamas sends their children to the Israeli army to identify the sources of the gunfire. This is so unfair. If Hamas had told them that this is what would happen, they would not have chosen Hamas and would not have educated their children to kill Jews.

[@renkylo2179]

i wouldve shake too. He was a Visionary leader. hey xew, gazprom chamerz calling ya. wanna go with all your fam?@@IsraelMilitaryChannel

[@user-gu1ti9me6i]

Why is it chilling? Are you non binary?

[@user-gu1ti9me6i]

​@@IsraelMilitaryChannelSo he was based?

[@haimarazy]

@@IsraelMilitaryChannel In case you didn't know, leaders of the Yeshuv did business with the Nazis in the 1930s and 1940s - it's all very well documented. What does shaking Hitler's hand have anything to do with holding 6 million Palestinians in concentration camps for 57 years?

[@ChrisAlbertH47]

This old man gives me all kinds of SS vibes. I've seen his other interviews in European channels and it was just filled with the same justifications and arguments that no one should take seriously.

[@henriettemcpartlin8640]

Get a grip

[@halukkilic3171]

True - "We only followed orders" were also typical SS answer.

[@marioncarroll8994]

Yes. There is a lot of genocidal terminology in Israel. Seeing people as animals, etc. all reminiscent of the SS @@halukkilic3171

[@ChrisAlbertH47]

@@henriettemcpartlin8640 You're projecting.

[@rikailayabbir]

@@ChrisAlbertH47I think you’re right.

[@nfahel]

I think if you talk to a brick wall, you may have more honesty, at least the wall can’t talk BS

[@Thinking858]

You obviously tried many times speaking to walls... You seem to have a good understanding what the conversation is going to be like....

[@lilianehuddleston9363]

This guy should not be given a platform. Tired of the poor us Israelis we had no option….

[@johnpullen3729]

LETS GO BACK TO THE "BEGINNING"... History of Israeli war crimes towards Palestinian civilians and other nations since 1948: 1) * Tantura Massacre, 200 deaths (1948). 2) * Operation Dani (1948). 3) * Operation Hiram (1948). 4) * Operation Yoav (1948). 5) * The Naqba - In 1948, over 1,000 Palestinians were killed, with 530 villages destroyed and 750,000 Palestinians displaced. 6) * Saliha Massacre, 70 deaths (1948). 7) * Deir Yassin Massacre, 112 deaths (1948). 8) * The Lyda Massacre, 250 deaths (1948). 9) * Abu Shusha Massacre, 70 deaths (1948). 10) * Al Dawayima Massacre, 100 deaths, and 455 missing (1948). 11) * Khan Younis Executions (1956). 12) * Rafah Executions (1956). 13) * Kafr Kassim Massacre (1956). 14) * Al Arish Executions, 60 deaths of surrendered Egypitian soldiers (1967). 15) * Ras Sedr Executions 52 deaths of surrendered Egypitian soldiers (1967). 16) * USS Liberty, 34 deaths (1967). 17) * Shatila Refugee Camp Massacre, 3500 deaths (1982). 18) * 1st Intifada, 1,932 deaths, 53 were children (1987). 19) * Temple Mount Killings, 21 deaths (1990). 20) * 2nd Intifada, Jenin Refugee Camp, 500 deaths (2002). 22) * 2nd Intifada Nablus (2002). 22) * 2006 Lebanon War, 3,334 deaths, mostly Lebanese, Amnesty International, UN Officials, and Foreign Civilians (2006). 23) * Gaza War (Opeartion cast lead) 2008 - 2009, 926 deaths. 24) * Gaza War (operation protective edge), 2,310 civilian deaths, 2,251 UN HRC deaths (2014). 25) * Israel Palestine Crisis, 256 deaths, 128 UN OHCHR deaths (2021). 26) * Israel Hamas War, over 28,000 deaths and still counting (2023/24). 27) * Israelis bombings in Lebanon (2023/24). Listed above are only a few major crimes and do not include any remote incidents or assassinations of high profile figures since 1950 to 2020s. Israelis/Zionists have been committing, horryfying crimes, oppression, atrocities, and genocides since 1948 and have killed thousands of innocent civilians/Palestinians, including children, babies, women, and elderly, with the support of USA, Britain, and EU. Israel is the only country in the world that systematically prosecutes minors (Palestinian children) in military courts and accepts confessions obtained by coercion. Also, hundreds of Palestinian children remain detained, suffering in Israeli jails. Hundreds of Palestinian women and men were kidnapped and detained in Israeli jails, who are suffering from torture and inhumane treatment by Israelis/Zionists. Illegal occupation by Israelis/Zionists is the root cause of the problem.

[@halukkilic3171]

Horrible numbers 😥

[@henriettemcpartlin8640]

Hamas prisoners are getting an education in those jails

[@henriettemcpartlin8640]

The beginnings is thousands of years ago

[@habsom1406]

A truly staggering litany of atrocities perpetrated by Israel. Wow!

[@marioncarroll8994]

Henrietta, you use same hollow sound bites as Israeli propaganda. You’re obviously not very educated on the subject as you only repeat a couple of short soundbites again & again all over the comments@@henriettemcpartlin8640

[@rachidhaboub2064]

What can u expect from a retired professional hitman ?

[@jaysonturner-williams8490]

How does the former director of the Mossad not know what the Hannibal Directive is?!

[@DynamicLearning4u]

He said, 'Let's start at the beginning 3:06...' But the beginning was 75 years ago! Not on Oct 7th 2023!

[@Thinking858]

The beginning was 3000 years ago when Israel Palestine was Judaea

[@DynamicLearning4u]

So they can kill people and drive them out? @@Thinking858

[@Roblox-ev7ry]

This man most likely committed lots if war crimes in 1948.

[@ChrisAlbertH47]

I think he may have been too young, but he very likely committed plenty during his career.

[@shaheedaessack6142]

Definitely.

[@EG-gq1fn]

War crimes just like the ones the arab states that started the war leading up to the missdeeds in 1948. No one is clean in this conflict. There is no good side or bad side and both sides try to promote their narrative. Personally I think the arabs are more skillful when it comes to that. They have gotten a big part of the world to belive the history started in 1948.

[@Lottieaire]

💯

[@del7724]

I wonder if his relatives were members of the terrorist Haganagh or Stern Gang

[@CowneloAlvaroid]

The name of this show is up front but your guest was anything but Up Front 😂

[@michaelsmith-re2ge]

Mossad through and through. He even denied the Hannibal Directive without a flicker of guilt or shame. Couldn't lie straight in bed.

[@zainzoala1083]

Who has invaded who . This guy using words like ‘ We were invaded and invasion is just unbelievable.

[@creativestudios3d]

Exactly. He wasn't even born in Israel: He was born in London.

[@MuhammadnizamuddinbinAbdullahn]

twisted minded people they're, they said Israel gain it independent in 1948 when in fact they're the invaders colonialist

[@wiFkyq-besmaf-3medwy-mz7cc]

SHABBAT SHALOM 🇮🇱✡️🕎💙🤍💙🤍

[@WillYouVid]

Mr. Hill stays professional in front of a genocide apologist (that did a lot of bad homicidal stuff during his whole career)

[@noecadavona1862]

He try to manipulate the old man but fell short of his expectation. We journalists are a bit like vultures, feasting on war, scandal and disaster. Turn on the news, and you see Syrian refugees, Volkswagen corruption, dysfunctional government. Yet that reflects a selection bias in how we report the news: We cover planes that crash, not planes that take off. Nicholas Kristof🤣

[@sssssinead]

Well said Willyidol

[@frankcrozier2592]

What do you expect a man like this to say no surprise at all.

[@MA-sk4fg]

@@frankcrozier2592Evil in their genes.

[@user-tl7rj4wc8m]

The current civilian casualty ratio in Gaza is just 1.6 (16K civilians and 10K combatants). The usual ratio is at least 3. So actually, the number of casualties is very low compared to other wars. Is Marc Lamont really a journalist? Doesn't he know that? Actually, he is just a cheap propagandist of Al-Jazeera.

[@jaa89623]

Marc, you're a true professional. I couldnt keep my cool with this sort of monster.

[@Thinking858]

That's why you are you.... Made from the in print of your parents...

[@djpaulcfunkeddub3951]

Oh they lost civilians, Palestinians lost over 200 that year alone before October 7th, & thousands since 1948 but do continue with what the world knows as lies...

[@crusinx1234]

These are not human. That's not how humans talk.

[@tethergobrrr]

I’m going to be honest. I couldn’t care less about what happed to people on October 7 anymore. Israelis have completely lost my sympathy. First time I’ve felt this way about a group of people.

[@numaanmohamood4712]

Israeli Chosen Nation are digging their own graves.

[@MissinginMiami]

Agreed 💯

[@montenegr1954o]

Exactly 👍

[@sagewalsh9702]

Me too.

[@billjohns9488]

I agree.

[@oldmanriverpip1003]

I forced myself to listen to this interview & it was sickening to hear.

[@Roblox-ev7ry]

So what about Palestinians who got invaded in 1948. What should they have done?

[@chukwuemeka888]

Who invaded Palestinians in 1948

[@gratefulwoman8848]

Palestine was invaded by Jewish immigrants in 1917. Irgun, Lehi and Haganah started terrorizing the Palestenians from the jump. Irgun is known as the founder of modernn day terrorism BTW and that terrorist group became Likud.

[@kirstyduncan408]

​@@chukwuemeka888The Israeli state dummy. Before that it was Palestine.

[@rahmaabdijama7844]

Savage Grandpa is beyond Repair. What a wasted Life, you must pity his Offsprings. Israel Savagery Exposed, no more Status quo.

[@coleengoodell7523]

I couldn't agree more.

[@stewartlowe6703]

I saw a banner on an old chimney while driving through Hobart Tasmania Australia this morning concerning the horror in Gaza ie. GENOCIDE HAS NO PRIDE. Has this man no moral compass? Great interview. Well done.

[@zenaabdullahi8119]

Notice how he is effectively saying this started on oct 7?

[@Thinking858]

Yes, you noticed that too... It actually started 3000 years ago... After Romans renamed Judaea to Palestine... Fake name fake Empire

[@happygucci5094]

Marc Lamont Hill - top 🔝 tier 🫡💯💪🏽🖤✊🏽🇵🇸🇭🇹🇸🇩🇾🇪🇸🇾🍉‼️

[@michaelkiernan4315]

What about all the Palestinians that have been arrested and detained for years with no charges Isreal always the victim

[@FoxSullivan]

Or the thousands that have been killed whenever an Israeli sniper got bored? Or the amount of UN and other agencies employees murdered by the IDF?

[@billynomates9661]

Why are these people allowed to spew their lies and evil, in a parallel universe it’s like watching ISIS being given the platforms and backing to speak and represent themselves in institutions that are meant to prevent such evil.

[@kavemanjosh]

Feeling hurt that AJ has someone on that isn’t parroting their twisted narrative you want to so desperately believe?

[@gratefulwoman8848]

Speaking of US/Israeli backed ISIS that is exactly what this is.

[@billynomates9661]

@kavemanjosh as ur name states go back to yourself little hole and educate yourself

[@kirstyduncan408]

Top 8SIS commander was Israeli Mossad. It was long known that isis was shoer for Israeli secret intelligence service. Why hou think ISIS NEVER attacked Israel??

[@veenacriddle1207]

War is nasty, don't start it then cry. How do you fight hamas buried amongst their civillians.

[@CookaSoupNieceEH]

Liar liar liar hannibal directive exists

[@choicemed2423]

He lied for a living

[@rl4899]

Genocide is wicked and evil

[@henriettemcpartlin8640]

Oct 7

[@marioncarroll8994]

1948 actually but hey anyone can be out a day or 2! White man arrived in 1948 & pillaged, plundered, k i l l e d all around him & hasn’t stopped since@@henriettemcpartlin8640

[@IsraelMilitaryChannel]

7 Oct

[@I.Davids786]

Palestinians 24-7

[@marioncarroll8994]

Israelis hated all around the world thanks to Israeli military. Worldwide increase in attacks on Jews thanks to Satanyahu & Israeli immorality. I feel sorry for peaceful Jewish people being attacked every day. God help you all when you go on holidays! @@IsraelMilitaryChannel

[@JohnFelinn]

In the future, people will ask in horror how the world allowed this genocide to happen as it was being recorded in broad daylight.

[@N_Harkin]

When they SHOULD ask: How did the powerful states of the west support and encourage this genocide? (The rest of the world, I think, is walking on eggshells trying to do what they can while avoiding WWIII and probably the end of all life on Earth.)

[@onedos23]

Special intrest.

[@Fnpro221]

The court did not see genoside. Otherwise they would state it happened.

[@ENT756]

@@Fnpro221 Excuse me, where do you live? There's an ongoing case in the International Court of Justice whether or not the State of Israel is committing genocide. And it will take the court years to make a decision about it and until they will be able to issue a final ruling. And, there's also an ongoing case in the International Criminal Court whether or not the State of Israel did/does commit other war crimes against the Palestinian people.

[@kirstyduncan408]

​@@Fnpro221If they didn't see genocide case was potentially made it woud have been throwb out and Israel wouldn't have had rules put on it which it isn't following and they wouldn't he having to go back to the court to show how they are complying with the rulings.

[@ramblingrootscamp]

Mr. Hill is the hardest hitting interveiwers i have ever seen You sir are a hammer.

[@user-kp8ed4dq7y]

It’s useless to invite these monsters to any show! They would just lie and lie and lie!

[@numaanmohamood4712]

He definitely knows about the Hannibal directive😂

[@johnwebster5005]

Of course he does!!!

[@khalidaser1430]

😂😂 he was squirming, the pathetic liar

[@HYTELES]

I could easily tell he was lying as he kept getting annoyed and clearing his throat while trying to control his anger.

[@o.z.p.]

He turned angry to hear that hanibal directive ?

[@Bavafa1]

unless if his head is up in his @$$

[@roncarlin3209]

The sad thing about this old man is that he thinks he's helping Israel's case.

[@nellyson5552]

He know by the time ICJ is done he ll be dead that's why is confident n comfortable with his views

[@annikamyren3026]

Nothing can help Israel !

[@halukkilic3171]

@@annikamyren3026 Åkesson försöker förgäves.

[@Nobody-zv5lp]

I think this interview should be submitted to South Africa to be sent to ICJ. This man is complicit. Israel's report of their compliance with the provisional measures is due around Feb 26th. Of course Israeli's themselves are providing evidence everyday of their psychopathic mentality. This guy has not heard of the Hannibal directive and he was an high official in the Mossad? He is either ignorant (his own admission) or quite pernicious.

[@annychest718]

​@@nellyson5552 the swines will cut his pension if he told the truth

[@thehal991]

There’s not many journalists out there that consistently push these Jazis on the hard questions, Marc makes them squeal! So much respect for this man - Professor Marc Lamont Hill, people!

[@shahfaisal3502]

4 figure civilians were military reservists in the kibbutzs which surround Gaza

[@goblinkind123]

You can't argue against such reckless hate!

[@henriettemcpartlin8640]

Yes Hamas’ hate

[@marioncarroll8994]

Boy have you been brainwashed Henrietta! Are you American by any chance & listening to US biased media & easily proven Israeli propaganda? Maybe try listening to Greenday’s “Don’t wanna be an American idiot” instead @@henriettemcpartlin8640

[@I.Davids786]

And denial structured in the same propaganda used by all of them,it's like listening to a recording. Then playing victim to have an excuse for committing the worst otrocities in front of the whole universe.....and still continues mercilessly, with no shame, and with no end in site

[@Redcrossdwarf]

and reckless stupidity, they are losing sympathy globally and only hardline, narrow minded, ignorant bigots remain in support. The US is suddenly trying to rid itself of the faecal impaction since several countries have recognised US genocidal complicity.🍉🍉🍉🍉

[@ENT756]

@@henriettemcpartlin8640 Are you talking about your own hatred?

[@nigeljoseph5472]

Brilliant interview by Marc Lamont Hill. Halevy sounded old, tired, and completely insincere.

[@shellydistaola2834]

This guy is frustrating i can tell the host is getting frustrated too

[@pietrosseel6258]

Talking about the 7 October and ignoring all the rest that precedes that event is nothing more than rewrite history.......as usual off course???

[@shafikgeorgeskhouzam5810]

Where you expecting empathy from a former Mossad director? They have been treating the Palestinians as animals or the last 70+ years with the blessings of western nations.

[@louiscarter-adams4226]

Exactly- you hit the nail on the head. Zionists are evil.

[@margaretbrown9478]

They are ALL evil

[@chambermuses7802]

So much power, so little understanding: this man has no idea what "proportionality" means. And 12,000 dead children were "not necessarily civilians." The perfect poster child for evil.

[@ronanwarrior2113]

So this is what pure evil looks like

[@Thinking858]

No,,, lve seen pure Evil on the 7th October... Thats exactly how it looks like...

[@husseindiba2169]

These old man is not ashamed of lying in front of millions watching

[@imbalancedstatus8824]

I end my conversation with anyone that starts history on October the 7th.

[@lajolaj4901]

former director looks like he has no heart, no emotions, he don't care

[@kahinaaicha7471]

Every interview with an Israeli official looks like a chess game, you have to be very very tactical and push them to the corner to make them show a little little little discomfort facing the truth 🙁 It's exhausting 😢

[@henriettemcpartlin8640]

😢 yup

[@burnbeetlejuice9232]

Every Israel rep interviewed only follows their standard scripts and full of evil accusations and nonsense horseshits

[@marioncarroll8994]

Ya, Israelis prefer lies, sound bites & propaganda. They’re very uncomfortable with the truth

[@BertGraef]

no, its like playing a chess game with a pigeon. Pigeon shits all over the board and claims a victory.

[@aslamiqbal8444]

supremacist ideology Their life is more valuable then others

[@JohnFelinn]

The problem is the artificial colonial settler state of Isreal having no regard to international law and human life. What Israel is doing is not self-defense, because it has no right to it as the occupier. Israel has proven to be an outlaw state. What is the international community going to do about that?

[@kavemanjosh]

Israel is surrounded by hostile states with no regard for international laws. It’s the Middle East not Europe, open your eyes.

[@Stevef2022]

What of the artificial colonizer Arab states all throughout the Muddle East? Jerusalem is 1500 miles away from Mecca.

[@MOR44455]

@@Stevef2022 What a stupid answer and what poor arguments. Do you have anything better to contribute? don't answer me, ... I don't think so.

[@EG-gq1fn]

You are absolutely right. The history is complicated. It seems like most people belive that the arabs was the first people in the area and not the conqueres of the people who lived there before. They belive Saladin was a defender when he was just as much a qonquerer as Richard. However it doesn’t help anybody to look back in history. That is a big problem in the middle east just as it is a problem when the Serbs can’t loose the grip from that battle in 1361. One has to look forward if one wants a better future for everybody. And killings on either side does not help that. One coul wish Hamas would have understood that.

[@EG-gq1fn]

That answere shows your respect for democracy and your thoughts of other peoples right to have another opinion. Democracy is that you allow other people to have other opinions than your own without being rude to them.

[@reneb5408]

I gave up watching to this interview, the fact that the guy is okay with killing innocent people is disgusting

[@henriettemcpartlin8640]

If you had watched the whole thing, you probably would have a different opinion

[@ENT756]

@@henriettemcpartlin8640 The same applies to you...

[@wiFkyq-besmaf-3medwy-mz7cc]

SHABBAT SHALOM 🇮🇱✡️🕎💙🤍💙🤍

[@Ass_of_Amalek]

"hannibal? never heard of him" - former mossad director 😂

[@johncox2589]

He is like the chancellor in "V For Vendetta", this is the only thing that he knows how to do.

[@Inst19ct]

Mark has got something with this Hanabal directive angle. This could be key to exposing what truely happened on Oct7 .

[@xlifexwithxlithiumx]

its already been exposed by many israeli newspaper like haretz and YNET

[@valeriewedel2775]

There are other channels talking about this. A very surprising percentage of Israelis killed on 10/7 were in fact murdered by the IDF, using tank shells and other weapons only the Israelis have. This is now documented. Search, it will one up.

[@valeriewedel2775]

The IDF has also admitted using the Hannibal Directive in statements made in the last month or so. So this misguided sociopath we are not listening g to anymore is clearly either misinformed or lying through his teeth.

[@o.z.p.]

One reason this guy said he knows no such thing about. The families of the fallen should wrap their life around getting to the truth of Oct 07. They are the ones who can push this, and from exile need be.

[@del7724]

Most educated people who care to look know the Hannibal Directive was used and the iof killed many of their own. It's beyond belief that a mossad agent pretends he hasn't heard this

[@samuelallen8945]

You literally did start this war - how many Palestinians were killed before "October 7"?

[@ucheuchema1081]

Efraim Halevy, former Mossad Head, has never heard of the Hannibal Directive... Talk about lying as a fundamental element of one's constitution.

[@carsi7282]

He stated 'I cannot imagine another strategy'. That in itself is the issue and states the truth. They are not intelligent enough to counter innovative, driven focused indigenous populations who want their land back and are willing to fight for it against those with better weaponry. They are spoilt, entitled and believe they 'deserve the land they are not from. He was clearly northern European.

[@Thinking858]

We are all European... We can't imagine another strategy... Back to Allah for those poor innocent people

[@reneebarclay8816]

Netanyahu’s goal are unmeasurable and therefore unachievable. His aim is to remain in power.

[@marioncarroll8994]

& postpone going to jail

[@shaheedaessack6142]

@@marioncarroll8994 Thugs like him succeed in the end.

[@marioncarroll8994]

Hopefully not! He’s evaded jail for long enough @@shaheedaessack6142

[@user-li7dz5zw5j]

Bravo to this journalist👏👏👏

[@liammorris4655]

"I've never heard of the Hannibal Directive." lol

[@dilajastettler6652]

Settlers are not civilians under international law

[@izmi2938]

What he actually said is "all of them are hamas because they are fighting back our occupation"

[@farronstrob]

Marc you did a great job, I wouldn’t be able to do this how you perfectly pressured him and worked through the lies in his voice and his soul.

[@barondebarrou]

Marc Lamont Hill Thanks brother for being so excellent

[@Harris665]

3:08 ‘start at the beginning’ please do.. Oct 7.. 😂😂😂

[@toradoalice2573]

Let's ask him if hamas was hiding in Tel Aviv would he destroy the city to the ground ?

[@josephdebri8941]

He tried to ask that in roundabout way and got nowhere.

[@wiFkyq-besmaf-3medwy-mz7cc]

SHABBAT SHALOM 🇮🇱✡️🕎💙🤍💙🤍

[@wiFkyq-besmaf-3medwy-mz7cc]

YOUR ANALOGY IS WRONG

[@wiFkyq-besmaf-3medwy-mz7cc]

AND THE ANCHOR ANALOGY IS ALSO WRONG. INTENTIONALLY SO

[@abdul_thegreat7642]

6:30 he was ready to admit the IDF killed Israeli civilians but Marc Lamont interrupted him

[@sagewalsh9702]

Good job Marc Lamont Hill. This man is awful.

[@poeticgangsta6616]

NOTICE that when u corner a liar they always get upset and fall apart.

[@kristenwilson6767]

Mossad monster. He was mossad no surprises with his view. Oh yeah it all started on oct 7th. What a professional interviewer. Well done.

[@elenileoussi9174]

Full of admiration for the interviewer for managing to keep calm and to the point, interviewing this lying monster.

[@mullahosk585]

Yes, he's opening the path for other journalists who are still too afraid to take on the Zionists

[@evangelistgina274]

Yes bcos he refused to say what u expected!

[@nooralimanjee9102]

One thing was definite, MOSSAD chief was not in CNN, FOX, OR CNBC STUDIOS.

[@HYTELES]

Which makes me wonder why he was okay with going on this platform.