Producer Reacts to GWSN "Puzzle Moon"

[@Mogajaee]

"I feel like we're gonna get a rap break from the adrogynous one" Kiwi Pop: SIKE

[@wujusonyeo8106]

5 months later Kiwi pop: we were just joking last time Miya started rapping Everyone died bcause no one expected that

[@yuikoo0613]

@@wujusonyeo8106 too bad it was only 2 lines which equals one normal length

[@seong9333]

Makaroni funny because soso probably got the same amount of lines as Miya but y’all don’t give two shits for her

[@yuikoo0613]

noir I didnt even know who soso was

[@newbiechu7024]

@@seong9333 I wanna full moon.

[@25AGrace]

They gave her the least to work with and she's already the most popular. I'd like to see what she can really do in the next comeback hopefully. The song is great i hope they explore this concept more

[@totally5694]

ikr they drew all of the lesbians in with Miya and then gave her nothing to do, top 10 anime betrayals svdjkddhjd

[@babykay7929]

25AGrace it helps when you had a hair that short tbh, the same way people go gaga over amber but they are just average and their co-members are definitely better

[@tajah1356]

@@babykay7929 I guess but Amber is actually cute af tho soz

[@LunaDarkFall]

Peek a boo Well miya and them are only famous bcuz of miya have a more boyish concept

[@vxlnxtine438]

@@babykay7929 thats pretty offensive when you say her members are better-

[@user-fg6zp8ym5i]

Both foreign members Miya and soso didn’t get any line here, so I’m guessing it’s the language problem

[@zoey2771]

actually they didz just veryyyy few

[@tamiahchanelle]

9:49 the background music omg, i miss f(x)!! and gwsn's debut song reminds me of 4 walls

[@marisolmartinez7332]

minho bundles it’s the main bass/hook which is why it sounds alike so much and same I love 4 walls

[@beatlejuice3times859]

minho bundles omg finally someone who thought the same xD

[@jetdelossantos2595]

it's deep house music, aka the best, superior genre (imo) ever explored in K-pop, SHINee also has "View", Puzzle Moon is house, EXID's Jeonghwa's "Alice", Seventeen's "Moonwalker", I think there's a couple more

[@sunstrine]

ah the classic deep house, god deep house in kpop is genuinely so amazing

[@momooneit7100]

Ikrr

[@arthurartchive]

it's a shame that everyone only talks about miya but forgets that soso also barely has lines too :( I guess miya stands out for her looks, but soso also barely has lines for (I suppose) the sane reason, which is being foreign. none of them are my bias but it's a bit sad to see people being so vocal about miya but forgetting about soso. ...anyway peace, stan future kpop queens, stan gwsn ✌

[@onceyouwheeinyoucantwheeout]

Bel-kun yeah Miya stands out for obvious reasons and soso looks don’t. 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@TomsMusicCorner]

People have different taste. I agree with Bel-kun. It's a shame that no one talks about SoSo who has the same "problem". But I don't care about line-distribution. To be honest, i hate these discussions, there are obvious reasons why some have fewer lines than others. I mean in general, not in this particular case. Obviously you can tell me these obvious reasons, why she stands out 😬😏😂. Personally, I find the other girls interesting as well (Vlive is your friend).

[@dirrty9387]

miya aint special cause she got short hair :D

[@onceyouwheeinyoucantwheeout]

Tom's Music Corner it’s all about personal preference. Her looks are different and she’s the only one who wears pants while the other wears skirts and dresses. It’s why people call her the amber of the group 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@lorenafrancesca6918]

She’s the only one that stand out to me too. The rest of them look the same in a way that most idols kpop girl groups look. Super girly super cute etc. So obviously when you see a girl that has short hair and wears pants almost looking like a guy you’re obviously going to look more at her. I don’t even know the names of the other members and honestly don’t even care. But I’m stanning Miya because she’s different lmao

[@soyapann]

this is indeed an impressive debut, even their b sides on the mini album has great quality!

[@marozasulaiman379]

You should listen to their b sides, particularly shy shy and Melting Point, Miya has few lines. Miya's voice has somewhat similar voice range as Amber.

[@nuf412]

I thought her voice was a bit higher than Amber, actually her voice doesn't really fit her androgynous style

[@TehPolarBearr]

Funny enough, she says her inspiration is Amber!

[@yokonamigaara]

Oh no don't tell me that... I've been trying not to stan her just b/c she's masc (that's wouldn't be fair to her), but Amber is my ult..... guess I'll have to listen to the b sides now

[@aorieedx2096]

miya also sing chorus at YOLOWA

[@staciii]

"possesses a unique." unique what.. 😂

[@FinlayEvans]

Staci-Ann Lawson It works idk what you mean

[@Ace_Aceee]

Miya aka androgynous looking girl sings 3 very short lines. In your video she sings at 1:48, same part on the second chorus and finally she says “I like it” in the rap break. Its unfortunate but she’s japanese. Maybe she’s not confident enough in her korean but she should at least have one decent line. I feel like she’s just there to be like Amber or Ren. To get attention for her androgynous look but it worked. We’re all talking about her.

[@macarunes2325]

at the time of debut she'd only been living in korea for four months, so she struggles w korean a lot, but she's a skilled dancer who's been performing since 2012, possibly before that. her dancing was always highlighted during predebut promotions and buskings. she's not just there for looks.

[@cieloz7574]

I hope u are not saying they are using her unique look to be like someone else because she's been like that before joining the group or the auditions...and she's natural born to slay ^0^

[@Ace_Aceee]

Ciel Oz Its not about her looking like someone else which I assume youre talking about Amber. Its about her looking very androgynous. Having an androgynous member will get people talking, it worked for Amber and Ren so so it will work on Miya as well. Amber is debatably the most popular internationally while Ren was the most popular overall before PD101 s2.

[@_tachan_]

Miya might have gotten very little lines in this song, but she's an incredible dancer! They've done quite a few covers of other songs and she blows me away with how precise she is. I read she was in a Vixx dance cover group which explains everything LOL On top of that she's just plain gorgeous/handsome and all of the above???

[@EnzeruYoshida]

PD literally went through every international fans struggle through the MV. LOL But I just wanna say, I'm pleasantly shocked how well this song and group is being received. I accidentally clicked on a teaser and instantly fell in love, but when the MV came out, I become just plain obsessed (I literally have to play the song at least once a day to survive), but I thought that it was gonna be one of those hidden gems among the thousands of groups that's debuting, but the video is accumulating quite alot of views and the group's fan base is growing very rapidly. I'm glad that you reviewed this PD and hope to see more quality reviews (also maybe a GWSN album listen lol they have a few side b bops)

[@timothyford1103]

Yep. Very slick debut. Anticipating more. They also seemed vocally strong and stable in show appearances. I get the impression that they quickly established a credible mysterious concept.

[@Imyourcherryybomb]

Their debut was top notch 💯The mv was shot really well and the song is super catchy and the members are so cute :3 and the vocals and rap is pretty good ♡♡♡

[@shellycarter1691]

I am glad you reviewed this one, I find the choreo, and the mv, and the song really interesting makes me excited to see what they will do in the future.

[@kananislove2014]

everyone talking about miya but throughout the whole video the solos are tossed around four girls -- the redhead girl, the short haired girl, the prechorus girl and the black haired girl who starts the song. 3 members got very insignificant lines, yet all the attention is on miya alone.

[@noodlehead9183]

im so glad you reacted to this. Loona, Fromis_9, GWSN, and G-idle for the win, rookies are going hard this year!!

[@Kiana_S_Y]

Please also check out A.C.E's collaboration with a French Dj and producer ^^ the song is called I feel so lucky 😊

[@SuperUkeChan]

PD is all Miya stans after she didn't get any lines 😭 but I think it's because she's Japanese and her Korean isn't that good yet, same with Soso who is Taiwanese... Hopefully they'll get more lines in the future! But this debut is so amazing, the whole album is incredible! I'm so happy they're doing so well already, I've been waiting for their debut ever since I've seen their teaser pics and just 💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖

[@sewerrat8096]

Soso is Taiwanese!

[@SuperUkeChan]

@@sewerrat8096 so I was right aaa I just wasn't sure lol. I'll edit ^^

[@asurafire5386]

Miya, Soso, and Seokyung are already very popular so they wanted to give the rest of the members more screen time and lines to push their popularity and also Miya and Soso aren’t confident in their Korean

[@snore9154]

I just come back here every time PD does a video on their comebacks.

[@XENODENO]

8:50 that *What the fuck* made me laugh so hard it's such a mood 😂 Edit: also I heard that (f)X soundtrack😏

[@kristinwashburne6662]

I stan GWSN so much

[@lvehaerin]

I love this song so much I can't even express

[@guido6006]

I absolutely LOVED the album. One of my fave 2018 releases, one of my fave debuts in a while and also a rare album where I like all of the tracks. And about Miya, I think even though they couldn't do anything about it at the time, giving more screentime and lines to the other girls was crucial in sort of attempting to even out the popularity between the members since Miya automatically grabs attention and even now she's still by far the most popular member, but their debut song gave the other members exposure so it wouldn't just be Miya + the others. I have no doubts Miya and Soso will get more lines once they get more experience and get better at Korean though

[@mirandachen8189]

Anyone else gay for Miya? She caught my eye instantly and I swear she stole my heart omg 💘

[@sickatae_9257]

i saw them live at the korean festival in my town! i fell in love with them 🥰

[@ddvjbh]

Yay i'm glad you agree that the song was awesome. I loved it the first time I saw it and also the choreo is so good. Miya is so pretty and she's an awesome dancer, I also wish she had some line in the song. Like anything so we can hear her voice. Their leader is cute AF. I really have high hopes for this group.

[@sleezyimpalass]

Miya is BOSS! I can’t wait to see more from her as she learns. Check out out the live stages, she’s an awesome dancer. She’s so fucking fierce and beautiful 😍😍 Awesome debut, the whole album is great.

[@animefean1]

the short hair girl is not Korean so she gets only a few ad-libs (along with another member who only has ad-libs i think) but from what ive gathered as info shes EXTREMELY popular (even before debute) so her role for now is to get the group attention, idk why shes popular but shes also a lot older then all the other girls so she might have been a media person even before she joined the group idk

[@formoftherapy]

Androgynous girls tend to always be really popular!

[@jadend9757]

Thank you for reacting to GWSN and giving them attention

[@cakredi4132]

This is the best debut by a girl group in my book.

[@estradarhydeljand.3356]

Love is 4 waaaaaaaaallsss

[@elise1739]

YES GWSN STANNNNNN ❤️🌕❤️

[@Sandy33569]

This really is an absolutely beautiful MV and song and choreo combined! I've been hooked on them since this great debut!

[@ahlamatiny6245]

react to gwsn pinky star!! mia have lines there

[@clau5174]

this is one of the best debut of this year, and ALL the songs of the album are really good

[@slylover123]

Had the same impression of the debut Silver hair won me over

[@valk1257]

GWSN is having a comeback (so like park in the night part 2) on 13th of March! Hope you watch it 🌱♡ (Miya (androgenous girl) is Japanese and didn't have much lines besides some ad-libs. In other songs on this album she does sing a bit. Also you pronounce GWSN as "gong-won-son-yeo" 😂)

[@luvi4091]

YESS MY GIRLS GWSN!

[@goraniiii555]

Now Miya got lines in Pinky Star⭐⭐⭐

[@leandrooliveira3070]

I instantaneously stanned them after listening to the mini album, simply too good!

[@bbelluv]

Omg yessss I love GWSN STAN LEGENDSSS!!!😍😍😍❤️❤️

[@KB42moomoo]

Miya really is eye catching, definitely the kind of member that people look back on as "Oh, I guess they were the reason I got interested/became a fan/ started to stan!" ... for me at least. But I'm gay and weak for those handsome girls, so maybe that's just me! I really love the song, and I'm so excited for more from the whole group! I know people don't like it when you compare groups, but it sort of feels like if gfriend did a dreamcatcher style song!

[@SiennaClaire98]

everyone's already commented about miya so i'd just like to say that it is SO worth it to give their mini a listen. every song is different from the other AND they're so good ahhh i really love yolowa!! i love this reaction skjdgkdjs

[@HyeShogun]

I laughed when you played 4Walls at the end because first Puzzle Moon does remind me of 4Walls and second, Miya reminds me of Amber 😂

[@emr4314]

Here where it all started 😌

[@Haiii_itsnanda]

yeah yeah Miya, even though she didn't sang alot, she was one of the girls that i gave alot of attention too XD

[@rodrickheffley8414]

PD THEY’RE COMING BACK SOON I CAN’T WAIT TO SEE YOUR REACTION TO RED SUN

[@hinatasharem3259]

Miya is DEFINITELY an anime prince 😍😍😍

[@farrahwho]

i never kept up with them before this but god this is such a solid debut, i can't get over this song and choreo. the b-sides on the album are even better particularly shy shy and melting point

[@Haiii_itsnanda]

i just realized they formed a star in the begining of the mv....NICE :3

[@leo-ou7hw]

watching this after his reaction to pinky star ahah you can see him falling in love it's amazing

[@n.4139]

I WAS WAITING FOR THIS

[@hunhoon6283]

Literally the best debut for me this year.

[@4700cat]

I deadass screamed when I saw this was uploaded djdbjfbf

[@larissanogueira4758]

YAAAAAS! I was waiting for this reaction for so long hahahahaha i knew that you gonna love it!

[@aniele48]

From what I've seen people say Miya, the one you talked about, can't really speak Korean well and that's why she didn't get lines in neither singing nor rapping. Hopefully once she's good enough she'll get them! She has amazing stage presence and charisma (watch their street performances) and visuals too. She's already the most popular one and that's also an advantage for her ^^

[@Kata_Rin]

I like the short haired one since long ago!!! I also wish she got to sing on camera

[@chuunafish]

Is it just me, or is the backing music they used when they talked 4WALLS BY F(X)??????????

[@formoftherapy]

It is😈

[@virginluvr]

thank you for reacting to this mv!! i loved it

[@viniciussantana289]

FINALLY!!!!!!!!!!

[@Sleepgarden]

also Miya sings the oh 비춰주네 (oh bichweojune) line

[@ladeeda9]

First time i saw PD give 10/10 right there with yaaaaaaa Im in love Full stanning

[@abigailc9185]

they remind me of f(x) and wjsn😭😭

[@silv3rd0se]

4 Wallllssss

[@bonepeonies]

Thanks for a great reaction! While I guess I kind of understand why the English name isn’t park girls (?) or something like that, having an acronym name that isn’t pronounceable is a little too bad, when the Korean is so nice.

[@formoftherapy]

What do you mean? GUHWUHSUHNUH just rolls off the tongue

[@isalesme015]

I think their actual English name is Girls in the park

[@sewerrat8096]

their English name is "girls in the park" they use it on their twitter and their youtube channel but it wasn't in the title of their mv for some reason

[@britling9101]

Personally I think GWSN sounds cooler and edgy lol

[@zandyzain6241]

Pure Visual and Dancer

[@lipsouloliviahee5996]

You know what else is confusing? The fact that one of their teasers for this song hAVE tHAT dROP and it is nowhere to be found in the MV. Not saying it’s a bad song without the drop though. It’s actually one of my moods for debut songs in 2018! And setting aside the obvious reasons for the foreign liners. It can also be part of their concept story-wise as well.

[@slylover123]

Agreed

[@abigailc9185]

literally i was laughing at PD this whole time omg his reactions and his frustration makes me laugh😭😭😭😭

[@geccd_out_guntai]

I just noticed that PD used f(x)'s 4walls when he was giving his opinion at the end.

[@doe7878]

its thought that miya (short haired girl) has few lines because korean isnt her native language, and she was still getting better at it after moving from japan!

[@zanaholiday9335]

Lets not forget Seokyoung from PD101 💓💓 Fighting GWSN!

[@donatoraimondi895]

This clean bandit vibes

[@MaEun1]

8:34 vibin' with the song I see 👀 Thank uuu so much for reacting to this! You should check out their album cause the b-sides carry the same vibe as the title song, and are surprisingly good for a debut. I'm sure you'd enjoy them ~

[@starlordnachos296]

FINALLY

[@aaronclariz6452]

Please react to GWSN's first comeback "Pinky Star" !!! I know you'll get satisfied with Miya's parts this time. :--)

[@hdhdidbdjsksisj]

YES RED HAIRED GIRL IS REALLY PRETTY

[@peachsoup3695]

*I really liked this omg*

[@milkisspop]

SAMEEEE I WAS LIKE UNIQUE WHAT 😂

[@maiheartx]

miya has one line in this song lol (she's amazing btw, really great dancer) i had the same problem like "when is her moment?" even if she said one word it didn't happen and i was wondering how is her voice sound. i loved the mv tho, lighting and colors were too beautiful ♥

[@kumalala4447]

Please react to Amber- White noise :D

[@gzilla_00]

YES FINALLY

[@alicegcnd2254]

aaaah finally 💕💕💕

[@rodrickheffley8414]

pleaseeee react to their comeback pinky star ! the song is amazing and MIYA HAS LINES

[@stuffytrucky]

Has anyone noticed that the puzzle is a finger heart ♥ 😁🤔

[@meltingmxxn]

omg finally! i was waiting for this video so bad T_T missed u pd

[@michaelrumawas]

YASS

[@speckqlaas8714]

While I was watching the video, I kept thinking that this might actually be in the same best and key as View and 4 Walls so I was really surprised when you used 4 Walls in the background!

[@telur_dadar]

OH MY you are using f(x)'s 4 walls instrumental :00000000 it's so good

[@tahliagonzalez4442]

"Oh man that was some naruto level shit" I WHEEZED.

[@MISA-vj9uf]

MIYAaaaaaa😍

[@Takaneenomoto07]

Mmiiyyaaa 😍😍

[@WaterLillyxo]

that sneaky 4 walls instrumental when you were giving your thoughts tho

[@deuwdrop]

8:51 "what the fuucckk" is a mood

[@fmaha1781]

Giving wjsn vibes esp with the constellations

[@wujusonyeo8106]

Pinky star run by gwsn is out when will you react i would love to see you react with miya rapping

[@sailorb_]

9:58 4 Walls in the background I'm dead

[@ebiUsher]

SOMEONE NOTICING MIYA UUUUUGH

[@valk1257]

Bitch everyone is talking about Miya, it's not weird, she stands out but still. Don't act like she's SOO underrated cuz she's by far the most talked about member.

[@reliusmoonemusic8642]

I’m Addicted To Anne’s “I Wanna Full Moon” (2:34)