Pies to snag 'dream' trade target thanks to potential new AFL rule? I Midweek Tackle I Fox Footy

[@roryo2040]

On what planet would a pick 3 key forward thats 4 years into his development and about to hit his prime be worth pick 15...? How would the swans ever think thats a good deal 😂😂

[@Comatosedpeanut]

McDonald holds the keys. He’s out of contract and only kicked 21 for the season. Plus as they said swans will have a cap squeeze soon.

[@roryo2040]

@@Comatosedpeanut all the swans players have been very open with the fact they have taken pay cuts in order to keep the group together. Fox footy saying there is a cap squeeze, doesn't mean there is one. I'd be surprised if he left Sydney

[@tb7667]

@@Comatosedpeanut The question was what is he 'worth'? Not what could Collingwood steal him for? He is clearly worth a lot more than one pick in the teens.

[@mattspencer-mumme-sc8ty]

Zurhaar from Roos, who Pies should be the targeting if he is on the market.

[@foleyyy6220]

if you listened properly it was pick 10 to 15 range and a second round as well. likely a future pick as well

[@tb7667]

1:45 Gullan thinking Sydney would be the one trading picks sums up the quality of this discussion. Hypothetical speculative nonsense.

[@TheMissiIe]

And talked about by people who don't understand how trades work

[@cmadelaide56]

This nuffy saying ‘I think…’ now somehow justifies the banner ‘Pies to zero in on McDonald’. What a terrible state sports journalism has become these days. Speculative nonsense, with no effort to contact either club. Total BS. They even state the name of the Swans list manager and make no effort to hide the fact that they couldn’t be arsed getting a comment from him. It’s laughable.

[@perthonabudget]

Melbourne based journos need to stop running these segments where they spout their wish lists, raiding non Melbourne clubs of their high draft picks once developed. This competition continues to be disgracefully biased toward Melbourne based clubs, led by these journos.

[@Panttz12]

What a load of crap. No wonder this muppets are on during the middle of the week.

[@kokmuncher6702]

You watched it

[@VeronicaWaugh]

Dream on why would anyone leave Swans to play for anyone else

[@richard1221]

Lol collingwood a much better club unlike Sydney which relies on handouts from the afl to survive. On top, he was a collingwood fan.

[@innoctem5656]

@@richard1221 handouts like being trade banned for 2 years for not breaking any rules? some lovechild. you guys get grand finals on your home deck lol, no one will ever respect that

[@neckweak7907]

@@richard1221​​⁠​⁠hahahahah sorry we don’t rely on umpires and ex afl players to fix games and make ya win !! Ahhahha what a disgusting team to be part of 🤢🤢🤢

[@mick5610]

Melbourne media are actually out of control pick in the teens for a ready made key forward 😂 anyone else trading for him they would say he must be worth 3 firsts

[@PeterM1-qx1tz]

Bingo!!

[@Comatosedpeanut]

@@mick5610 could luck getting three firsts for a bloke who’s not top 5 in his own clubs goal kickers for the season.

[@TopFix]

Collingwood has absolutely NOTHING to work with. Any trade talks regarding picks with the Pies is a literal delusional pipedream. Pies fans need to have a bloody reality check. The most out of touch supporters in the entire league.

[@richard1221]

Lol sydney fans are the delusional ones supporting a team that relies on afl handouts

[@billmccarthy5920]

And we are the reigning premiers as well as being delusional.

[@neckweak7907]

Facts

[@kokmuncher6702]

Only port fans can be given that title

[@WINKERS76]

Bunch of absolute dribblers this lot. Verbal diarrhoea is all they speak. 😉🇦🇺👊

[@waynemurphy2825]

Your forgetting the Dunsbough factor, Amiss is from their id say their is a connection right their without mentioning the surf and lifestyle

[@JustinSteele-gd5nu]

He doesn't fit in to freo anymore. Who are you dropping for him, jye, JT or Jackson, then we have Sturt banfield & Voss. McDonald don't fit into freo forward line @ all

[@thesecretwombat056]

Pies need a player to get the ball to ground and let our smalls work at ground level, logan McDonald isn't that at all. A perfect fit would be a tough tall that doesn't necessarily kick that many goals so we can get them on the cheap.

[@alexmartin628]

Big Kinnear Beatson fan here 🤷‍♂

[@ma3stro681]

Kinnear Beatson has made lots of dud early round picks in recent years, the worst being Dylan Stephens ahead of Caleb Serong and Hayden Young. Jacob Konstanty and Cooper Vickery also haven’t played senior footy, and Gus Sheldrick is always injured …

[@kenny-gee]

This show is so amateur. These vic media types are an embarrassment for the AFL

[@MrRocco1974]

Warner with syd till the end of 25. If they make the GF and win no one is going anywhere.

[@GuyFisher-ff1gr]

As a swans fan , he’s massively overrated and would be happy for him to get traded. Can’t take contested marks and has not developed as much as we’d hoped

[@UbuteyAustralia]

Your dpot on im still waiting for him emerge but alas he wont as its not there😮👎😏

[@papleylivesrentfreeinurhead]

playing a different role as of now. moves up the ground regularly and gets the ball deep when we need an option out the back. can still kick long goals too. give him time the boys love him

[@TheMjb85]

This is going to be funny when he signs in a week

[@catto66]

This is Clickbait, they make a statement and highlighted as news

[@PeterM1-qx1tz]

Why is it the non Melbourne clubs are supposed to just cough up quality talent for nothing in return and the media talk about it being a win for them?? Salary cap will be going up soon... and the only thing that will satisfy the Swans to let this guy go (I would imagine) are draft picks (with an ''s''), one in the top 5, and another one in the top 15.. and that would only be if the kid WANTED to leave the Swans!!. The idea that Sydney are going to let a quality proven forward walk for sweet FA is laughable. Pies have not got the ammunition, powder, clout, pull, call it what you want , to get this deal done.

[@papleylivesrentfreeinurhead]

how badly do fox want a swans player to leave? speculative bs about trading a pick 4 forward for a late first rounder. good try mate, dont think collingwood appreciates u talking about their trade strategies like this

[@UbuteyAustralia]

This is all pie in the sky stuff and ill say thiscsydney doesnt let any one go that they want to keep😏👎

[@ericcartman8694]

Prolly go to norf

[@michaelobrien1779]

You fink??

[@finigan7834]

Sydney didn't match Adelaide's offer of 10 years for Gulden. He signed for 4. Embarrasing when they can't even get basic facts straight.

[@Comatosedpeanut]

@@finigan7834 why would they need too? Adelaide are crap and guldens from nsw

[@finigan7834]

@@Comatosedpeanut They wouldn't, but that ddn't stop the melbourne media speculating about all the places he would go lke they've done with all the Sydney free agents this year.

[@kokmuncher6702]

The afl will just give Sydney extra salary cap space again, you watch most favoured team in the comp

[@papleylivesrentfreeinurhead]

they’re increasing everyone’s salary cap actually. pretty well looked after when we got banned from the draft for 2 years when we did nothing wrong. get over yourself mate

[@Robrulz666icloud]

McDonald is absolutely overrated… And stats back it up.

[@papleylivesrentfreeinurhead]

u could do much better ay robbie?

[@Comatosedpeanut]

McDonald to Collingwood would be sweet 😂

[@johndoe5061]

Joel Armarty would look better in a pies jumper

[@aok43]

Sure, we would love Logan. But these stories have no substance. Just picking names out of a hat to fill a segment. Rubbish.

[@dougtheslug3793]

Good call. I also reckon sydney could get nick daicos for pick 65 and a bag of twisties

[@darylcumming7119]

Speculation.

[@stevesalkas9128]

Waste of money pies stay away

[@kayethomas7863]

Victorian mentality. Not a GWS or Gold Coast supporter but now they want to move finals from their home grounds. Next thing they will be asking is all finals played in Melbourne