From The River To The Sea

Language is a tool that humans developed to communicate with one another, but when we misdefine or misunderstand words & concepts, it leads to people speaking passed each other rather than to each other.
Those that are against Israel & the Jewish People will have a sure future, since history has proven that ALL nations who attack Am Israel are later only remembered in history books, but those who ultimately only seek for their People to be free and families given equality, it's time that we hear, understand, and take them into full consideration.
Support on Patreon
patreon.com/rudyrochman
🎥: @kavanafilms

[@jonathanl107]

I used to be encouraged by your videos of you having discussions with young Israelis and Palestinians about peace and coexistence. Now after 10/7 and watching interviews with Palestinians who oppose living side by side with Jews and supporting Hamas attacks, I don’t think there are any people chanting that who don’t mean it, unless they honestly don’t know what it means.

[@leoraac]

True, I think this video is a bit optimistic. I would like to know if anyone has a video or link to an interview with someone who meant the chant as "we want to be free to live with or next to Israelis" as opposed to "we want Israel gone and Israelis gone," because I haven't seen a single example.

[@annaan8232]

I agree. I think Rudy is fantastic, smart and brave, but very naive. This is my recent experience. I was naive too, but not now. I'm watching this situation from the sidelines and I see that it's just wishful thinking. What they mean and say: "It is our land, they (Jews) must go away from our place where ever they came from. They don't belong here." So I think he should turn to Matthew 7:6

[@brian9731]

​@@HDracer- sadly, I fear, that's far too accurate an analogy.

[@NoamTheGOAT50]

You're all full of crap.

[@stefan4159]

Exactly. I've also heard that what Arabs are chanting in Arabic as a "translation" is "Palestine will be _Arab_ ". Classic. Talk about freedom in English, and explicitly about ethnic cleansing in Arabic. Just like Yasser Arafuck who preached international peace in English and jihad in Arabic.

[@Rajaz117]

I'm Palestinian rudy and I hope you're safe out there. People like you are key for a lasting peace between our people

[@avtaras]

Palestinian from where?

[@Rajaz117]

@@avtaras village near tulkarm

[@koachyisrael]

@@avtaras Britain

[@ofekash13]

Shalom alyha habibi, from Israel 🤝

[@Rajaz117]

@@ofekash13 shalom habibi from balaa

[@twayapeh]

Oh dear so idealistic..., admire your wishful thinking...but imo a little detached from the reality on the ground..... and with availability of non speaking denunciation trees to hide behind....

[@Peaceforall1234]

I used to think about 2 state solution and I thought it might work but after 7 October I know clearly it is not an option!

[@leemiller1837]

Funny, I'm feeling the it's the one state solution that has lost the most credibility... Maybe it's both 😥

[@totozviara]

The idea of 2 state solution is popular only in the West. People should open their eyes. If they watch Palwatch and Ask project, they will realise how indoctrinated "Palestinians" are. Evil forces invented this identity to make them repeat like in a trance: "it's ALL our land".

[@NetanelWorthy]

As an Israeli, I think that the biggest problem with their claim to right of return is they don’t have a right of return. We have to keep in mind, that most modern day Palestinians are not from Israel. They’ve only been in this land for the last 100 years. Most of them came from Lebanon and Syria and Egypt. The land that is, Israel had Arabs to the establishment of the state, but it was a very small number. This is why all contemporary sources that document document the time at the turn of the century, described it as a barren land with few people. A land that was desolate and mismanaged. And that’s not one or two people. That’s across the board. You can find numerous accounts. Unconnected to each other. So there are some that have been here for hundreds and hundreds of years, we are talking about a very small number. Most of them only came to Israel because, after Jews started purchasing the land, and making it a place to be, Arab started immigrating from surrounding countries that were undergoing hardships. But that doesn’t give them the right of return. They literally have more of a right to return to someplace like Lebanon or Syria or Egypt. They keep advocating for this concept, because, they know that if they cannot win a war, or they cannot win a battle, they will win by children. If they can get enough people into the land, they could have more and more children, and soon they will be the majority, and Jews will be the minority. And they will take control of the land that way. This is something that we cannot allow to happen. This is why there are biblical prohibitions in place for things like this.

[@stefan4159]

Exactly. People go on and on about the vast Jewish immigration to Palestine in the early 20th, but no one wants to talk about the vast _Arab_ immigration to Palestine. Because that would destroy the narrative of "evil Zionist colonialist Jews displacing the poor indigenous Palestinian Arabs".

[@IA67676]

Palestinians were the originally indigenous land as they are canaanite descendants according to DNA study. The jews and the 12 tribes of israel invaded according to the Bible. And you may ask why 2 state solution wasn't excepted in which I ask why they couldn't live in peace in one country called palestine. You can't not be big in number and expect to be the majority in certain countries. Maybe if palestine accepted israels 2 state solution in 2008 we would've seen israel try to invade palestine and actually expose itself. But what I'm saying is that the zionist narrative is for jews to have their own state where they are the majority but why would that be possible in palestine if people are already there. They were let in because the arabs don't mind living with jews their issue was them trying to claim their own state effectively claiming half of the palestinian land. Imagine Russia who invaded ukraune opted for 2 state solution where the country of Ukraine loses 50 percent of its land. That wouldn't be fair so its the same for palestine israel. And you can talk about jews being indigenous but again they were let in for a reason the issue wasn't specifically because of jews it was specifically because they wanted their own state. Watch mohammed hijabs video on the whole history of this its quite informative

[@JDAfrica]

@@IA67676utter nonsense … it’s pure speculation that Canaanite’s are Palestinians. There is absolutely no evidence beyond wishful thinking. How are Lebanese different from Palestinians? Where basically a French / British border was created on paper - making one side Palestinian and the other side lebenon? When every one of those people are Egyptian - who’s parents came up to the land for British oil and shipping trade a few decades before.

[@tomavalon1938]

Wow! That’s a really interesting perspective, that makes sense to me!

[@HusseinRizkana]

This is actually untrue. Historically the majority of populations were peasants(farmers) this makes up the majority of the palestinians as well. In historic palestine the population was mostly that of farmers with their olive groves and orange trees. Farmers that were there for 100's if not thousands of years, as can be seen from the 200+ year old olive groves that israel continuously burns. The fact is jews accepted converts and are genetically only 30-60% are the historical hebrews before jews were seen as a nation and it was a religion. With the palestinians there were traders that came through the area and stayed as with any other area however approx 60ish percent of palestinians are 'true' palestinians of (canaanite/ converted hebrew) descent. The levantines that left claim complete rule over the levantines that stayed. I am with rudy on this one, right of return for all those of levantine descent palestinian and jewish. Even though there were palestinian jews as palestine was an area and people not a religion. Perhaps it can be something such as the united states, one democratic country with different states under slightly different laws.

[@JosesRants]

Rudy usually you are spot on, but don’t ask them when you are in your activist role send someone who isn’t Jewish or is a Muslim and ask the question. You will get a very different answer than the one you get. I am a Juban and I know because I come at them as a Cuban not as a Jew and they know exactly what from the river to the sea means. I’m going to say it Kahana was 1000% right. If you all want to understand this read just one of his books “Listen world listen Jew.”

[@MarioPeeps]

kahane was right? wtf are you talking about? israeli arabs didn't do 10/7 you absolute fool

[@jannalam6861]

You ARE Wrong. They just want to be free

[@JosesRants]

@jannalam6861 they are free. They crossed a closed border and kidnapped citizens and Tourists to their country. They acted like ancient vikings violating, stealing, and erasing whole families. That's not wanting to be free.

[@JosesRants]

@@jannalam6861 so why do they keep doing terror attaks

[@erandro]

Hi Rudy. While usually I agree with your message, I have to disagree on this one. It doesn't really matter that some people mean different things when they say that slogan. This slogan has a meaning which comes out of the context that you mentioned. Explain it as anything else is, in my opinion, "westsplaining" (or being delusional). When you chant something, a call for action, you should know what you are saying. You can't chant "gas the jews" and then say that by gas you meant fart. If a Palestinian/pro-Palestinian is open to the idea of coexistence they shouldn't use this chant.

[@onthusitsentshwarelang6149]

From the river to the sea means cleaning all the Jews and owning the land,its a face value definition which seals all.Palestines could be enjoying moving from Gaza to West Bank via Israel but they have chosen to follow Hamas/Iran's hate for Jews.Someone must ask himself which they burnt all the fruits/vegetables and gardens that they were left by Jews when they forced from Gaza to Israel.Its just hate that wont help them.

[@tali605]

Rudy, i think you are being naive this time...

[@abrahaml5641]

We know what the majority of them mean when they say it and it’s not good.

[@alexgroysman6044]

Well, it looks a little bit naive. I believe most of those who use this chant understand what it means. Because the chant has an interesting ending "Palestine will be free". Try to dig into from who they want it to be free? As they call the whole piece of land Palestine they definitely don't mean free Palestinian state next to Israel, right? If someone want to promote the idea of right for traveling through Israel he definitely should use some other words.

[@lucabriatore7891]

It seems you did'nt watch the video...

[@FennecFoxxx]

They know what they are saying by chanting that particular slogan. If they would want to distinguish their aspiration for freedom from the historical meaning of that chant, they would come up with a different slogan.

[@RoseReadings]

Show me one Palestinian who chants this phrase with good intention in his mind. Don't be politically correct Rudy.

[@JonathanOvnat]

It only means one thing... If you'd wanna say something else you wouldn't use that slogan.

[@joshui1131]

Thank you, Rudy, for your videos the last few months. As an American Jew applying to colleges, you are my source of hope. If only everyone watched and truly listened to what you preach in your videos, our world would be an infinitely better place.

[@vicegripp]

Stay strong, brother. We are not our ancestors, we will not be moved out of where we feel we have a right to exist & we will not go quietly in the face of hatred & ignorance. #NeverAgain #AmYisraelChai #ToughJews

[@mabhodlelajj1195]

Most American jews are radical leftists who are anti Israel, you probably believe what Judi is saying here that genocide chant doesn't actually mean what it means

[@alejandromarquez3526]

Of course no mention here of from the river to the sea, Israeli sovereignty is all you’ll see. But I guess ignorance is the name of the game here

[@stormtrain11]

As an Israeli, in my opinion, the safest thing now is two states for two peoples. After that, it will be possible to talk about whether to stay like this, or make one country, or something like the European Union, in terms of borders. Personally, I have no problem with Palestinians living in Israel, but in my opinion, the best option is two states with two democratic governments, which are related to each other and meet every X amount of time to discuss what is best for the residents.

[@missruzl14]

Educate me please I thought Palestine rejected the two state solution?

[@stormtrain11]

⁠@@missruzl14 It did. Multiple times. But to really stop this mess, is to get strong leaders who can stop this mess for the people

[@missruzl14]

@@stormtrain11 but it’s obvious that the Muslims are the issues here. They have sworn not to live in peace with the Jews. Generally they actually don’t like the Israeli that’s why you see many uprise against Israeli. Yemen is going through worst , but because that attack is from another Muslims country there’s no uprise

[@raedvalenzuela5085]

@@missruzl14WE NEVER rejected a two state solution. Read about Netanyahu statements. He does not want peace.

[@raedvalenzuela5085]

@@stormtrain11not true. We want a two state suiting but it’s the Likid party’s racism and rejection to make a peace agreement. Do listen to Israeli or US propaganda. There’s actual sources of this

[@Geej9519]

Hey India and Pakistan too got partitioned and no Hindu is allowed back in Pakistan or Pakistani to India just because they want it … neither California allows the Mexicans to move back willi nilli … why ONLY the Palestinians are allowed such pipe dreams after three generations ?

[@SimSimon87]

As German, I stand with Israel ✡ However, the rise of antisemitism is extremely worrying. When I talk to friends and confront them, I usually find out that they know very little about Israel or the history of the conflict. It's scary to see that some falsehoods are being repeated over and over again. For example, when I just point out that Gaza is neither occupied by Israel since 1948, nor has it been occupied by Israel after 2005, then I'm usually met with disbelief. The same person has sent me a link to a 45min youtube documentary about Israel by Al Jazeera that same evening... I deeply respect your strength for continuously standing up for the dignity of the Jewish people and the people of Israel. I admire the Jews for their ability to heal themselves from so much pain and suffering over the centuries. As for a religion I find this not only heart-warming and commendable, but truly inspiring. Cheers for the upload and take care, buddy!

[@Crysalis-bd9so]

Thank you for your shining light 🌟

[@freeborn204]

Wish I could copy this .

[@cjamo65able]

You have a very narrow definition of 'occupation', one that is out of step with the rest of the world. The occupation most definitely did not end in 2005. The jailers merely stepped outside of the barbed wire fence & locked the gates behind them.

[@SimSimon87]

@@cjamo65able You have a very loose definition of occupation, then. You literally say there are no foreign soldiers and no foreign citizens in that country, but for some reason it's occupied? By whom?! If there are no more Russian soldiers in Ukraine, then Ukraine is still occupied by Russia according to your definition, which is nonsense. Gaza people can do in Gaza whatever they want, but due to the history of many wars and several intifadas with terrorist attacks, they are no longer welcome in Israel. Can you blame Israel? I certainly can't. Why not blame Egypt? They don't have a history of violence with Gaza, why don't you blame them for not opening the border and letting Palestinians in? Why the double standard? Btw. there were attacks against Israeli citizens by Palestinian Arabs from Gaza before the occupation by Israel in 1967 and after the occupation in 2005 (land for peace), so it's safe to say that for the terrorists it's not about the land.

[@eden3685]

That is interesting! Do you believe they really think jews don’t belong or they are not native to this land of Israel or do you think they just have hate for Israel?

[@shainazion4073]

*From the Sea to the River, The God of Israel will deliver!*

[@amjadqureshi4622]

The God of Abraham will unite us.

[@Isabella_MRP]

Damn, that’s powerful.

[@user-Jenn82]

Amen!! I’m a Christian and I stand with you! Many remnant Christians in the US have committed to opening their homes should any Jew need to flee evil antisemitic people. I will bless Israel and the Jewish people forever ✡️🇮🇱❤️🙏✝️

[@amjadqureshi4622]

@@user-Jenn82 Muslims and Christians both accept the Jewish rules under Saul, David and Solomon. So our religion sees Jews to be part of our family. Fighting anti semitism is definitely our duty.

[@avtaras]

Or the version of woke leftists lol: “From the River to the Sea, everything is a projection of ME!”

[@S.h.i.s.h.K.e.b.a.b]

They know very well what they mean by that.

[@OhadLutzky]

How does one guarantee, without a clear demographic majority, a land that is a safe haven for Jews, where they cannot be persecuted on the basis of their ethnicity? This is the circle to square - representative democracy, guaranteed safe haven for jews, rightful citizenship for all who have Palestinian heritage. It doesn't seem possible to have all three in one country. (not that the alternatives are great...)

[@mitchellfolbe8729]

Not sure how the right of return would allow for continuation of israel as a Jewish state.

[@israeliguybjc]

It would not

[@alexjohnson9630]

You are rationalizing. All arabs/muslims know what "from river to the sea" and they agree with it. All "palestinians" know what it means. You are seeing what you want to see. Its not there. Sorry.

[@leemiller1837]

Oct 7 showed that it only takes 3000 people with murderous intent to kill 1200 and terrorize an entire country. So, even if we are very optimistic about Arab Palestinian sentiment overall, the idea of having an an open border with the Palestinians should give us pause. I see Rudy's vision as messianic, and i dont mean than pejoratively: Judaism has a steong messianic tradition, and thats a beautiful thing that gives us inspiration and broadens our sense of the possible. And who knows -- after all, the idea of the EU would have seemed messianic in 1918 or 1944. Keep bringing positivity 💙🧿

[@wallybonejengles5595]

Knowing the work you have done to foster a peaceful future, it hurts to know you have to be out there fighting among the people you have shown so much love. I can only imagine how this must all be tearing your heart apart 💔 Much love Rudy. Voices like yours are worth more than gold. Stay the righteous soul brother you are.

[@NaProbablyNot]

I’d LOVE to see Palestinians who accept living side by side with Jews. Have yet to see any share this sentiment!

[@eden3685]

Exactly! And if some arab would say that they will be considered a traitor in the best cause in the worst cause they will be killed😳

[@arishillermusic]

Thank you for laying this out. We need more people who chant it to explain what exactly they mean.

[@jannalam6861]

Everyone Ive ever spoken too says it means they want the Palestinians to be free in the land. Stop twisting it.

[@captainmichael787]

Hey man just wanted to say what your doing is really putting a mark in the world I see many people just like you at protests now making comparisons between eachother and bringing us together to make peace and not kicking one side out thank you a lot🙏🏼

[@HillyPlays]

Amen

[@shachuvmeod-hb2wr]

One of the problem of this chant is that in English they yell “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be FREE” but in Arabic “من المياه للمياه فلسطين عربية” as in Palestine will be ARAB

[@marinafrish8434]

I like when a man with the gun discusses peaceful things. It is really meaningful and convincing 😊

[@EddieLancelot]

Ironically, yes.

[@DemonDog444]

Peace through strength

[@pavelbavtra]

Why holding a gun? This is weird and u didn’t have to

[@meitalt3301]

I cant imagine the burdern of being a public voice of reason when everyones hearts are so hardened. Keep it up youre doing great

[@MrBoazhorribilis]

Too complicated explanations, too many suppositions. "From the river to the sea" never means taking in millions of Arabs who are well meaning and want to make Israel their country along with the Jews . .... "From the river to the sea", every time is uttered or screamed, means no Jews, no Israel but only Muslims in a state they will probably name Palestine . You figure out the details of how that will be accomplished.

[@yasminachou]

if you were really calling for peace you wouldn't talk with an arm in your hands

[@aaronfarkas6890]

Hey Rudy - I also used to be one of your admirers for the way you calmly, patiently, and persuasively dealt with hostile Jew haters. In this video however, I strongly do not agree with allowing a ‘Right of Return’ for Palestinian Arabs, even under the conditions you specify, which are highly unrealistic. In fact - unless I completely misunderstood what you’re communicating - I’m quite shocked that you support a ‘Right of Return’ for Palestinian Arabs. . As has been pointed out by every Prime Minister on the political Right or political Left, it would be suicidal to do so, as the Palestinian Muslim majority would replace democracy in favor of Sharia law. Your solution to that problem - if I understood you correctly - is to import the “millions of lost tribes of Israel that are out there”, which would theoretically balance out the demographic issue. Rudy, have you lost your your mind! As you know, the millions of “lost tribes” of Israel have been lost forever following the Assyrian conquest of the Kingdom of Israel, and would mitigate favoring a ‘Law of Return” In conclusion, I’m rather shocked that more people in the comments section haven’t opposed your theoretical solution for a ‘Right of Return’

[@yaakovcohen2830]

Israeli - Palestinian conflict will resolve only when Palestinians will get the Westbank and east Jerusalem from Israel, large portion of the eastbank from Jordan and half of the Sini peninsula from Egypt. Only then with help of Arab world and the rest of the world they can rehabilitate the war refugees and build a Palestinian country. Middle East countries were drawn by england and France artificially at end of first world war and need to be adjusted to accommodate Palestinian state. The other solution is Palestinian country from the rever to the sea only leads to endless casualties of wars.

[@abzy3k1]

I'm a Muslim and all my mates we use the slogan for one simple thing. Freedom from oppression. We want to Palestinians to able to have the same rights as israelis.. from the river to the sea.. no checkpoints.. no walls.. freedom to live anywhere.. from the river to the sea.

[@pillowproject]

My pray for this man and everyone who support him. Israel for the better future 💙🇮🇱

[@jhjghkjoo]

I disagree with the peacenik stance you've been taking .....

[@koopon3900]

‏אתה בחור טוב אבל ‏אתה חי בסרט

[@shlomi546]

I would fear living under an Arab government. I'm gay, and up until now I haven't seen any arab government treating the LGBTQ+ in any good way. I do wish for us to live in freedom, but the fear is too big for something bad to change this dream to last long.

[@gregorymichael6182]

Rudy it is you who is willing to talk … not them …

[@s0064019]

Rudy, the problem is no matter how logically you display the reality/history to ''them'', they will not accept the truth which has been deluded in such a long time...sadly...

[@diandenmark]

Whoa, Rudy! How many millions of people can Eretz Yisroel absorb without ecological catastrophe? And can Israel be a democratic, Jewish state without a Jewish minority?

[@a.m204]

FROM THE RIVER TO THE SEA HASHEM will deliver US

[@millerbiz]

The right of return is suicidal

[@LAlonely]

Disappointing. You have to take the phrase within the context of other actions and statements. Right after making excuses for Hamas, accusing Israel of Ethnic Cleansing and Genocide and other clearly anti-semitic acts and language, its clear what they mean.

[@anonymousperson5831]

let me tell u why your government does not agree with you. say you allowed palestinians back and even gave them citizenship, from there on it will be a numbers game and fertility race, because if they outnumber you (the same throughout all zionism movement), then they will have a representation in your government and may even have one of their own running for presidency (assuming Israel is a democracy). so ...

[@erniestrother3545]

These college kids know exactly what it means and they need to be called out for it.

[@joannemendiola2406]

Dear Palestinians Stay with Israel and make peace there is no Palestinian land..instead be a province of Israel be in their system because it brings progress to yourselves and to your next generation enjoy living in a world without hate like the Emirates and Saudi it is a shame that after 75 years you still wage war with the Jews..learn to have Peace and love..it better.

[@ais2871]

The more i watch your videos, the more i believe that you are one of the true believers of Sons of isreal, that Allah have mentioned in Quran. "And We did certainly give the Children of Israel the Scripture and judgement and prophethood, and We provided them with good things and preferred them over the worlds." Ch 45, verse 16. Love you brother and much respect

[@LeonGustaveStuart1899]

Assalamualaikum @adhams2817 from NZ ..I am part jewish and we need peace with Muslim brothers and sisters ..Hamas not want peace and many leaders in these parts of world also not want ..Israeli government also needs to push for peace and they also geed change ways they do things. What a threat to world if Israelis and Palestinians join together and live peacefully ..true good hearted Muslims who can teach their kids to love and respect and same with other side. ..that is my wish ..not to kick out anyone as it's enough of this ..enough now I say. Hamas has to go bcos they just want pain and conflict and they have brought absolutely no happiness to the people of Gaza ..I don't like Fatah but at least they not as bad like Hamas ..Israel Bibi and lakud I'm sorry but they need change ..anyway I will never move to Israel EVER until their is true attempt and true peace made ..not kick out of harm Israeli and not kick out or harm Palestinians ..it is not my country to go until this happens ..Salam brother .. love you like a brother and no hate ..to much hate and people that want to divide us 🙏🙏

[@MichaelWander]

Nuanced conversation is important, and even critical!

[@michalperi22]

רודי אתה משהו מיוחד. עלה והצלח. הצלחתך הצלחתנו. אמן ~

[@Samet-c3u]

Movie name: predestination !!!!!!! Like this comment because everbody see

[@raphaeljasi5517]

Impractical 🤦🏾‍♂️🤦🏾‍♂️

[@AnotherJoe]

Rudy, you are my #1 source for sanity on these matters. You should be given a much bigger platform because I do believe on both sides you will be heard. Your reasoning on matters are the ONLY ones that could pave a way for Jews and Palestinians living together. I’m well aware that many call you naive, but you truly are not. They are not listening to reason.

[@yosisergant6916]

Thank you Rudy. I really appreciate your continued willingness to take on these complex and difficult topics with honesty and rigor. These topics deserve the kind of rich discourse you are willing to engage in... even if others aren't there yet... you are modeling what is possible. Yasher Koach.

[@raymondaloni2309]

From the river to the sea our cousins cannot pronounce "P"😂😂😂😂

[@es8945]

Very naive young man

[@jordanpwatson1]

You really need to be in the public sphere more. I've been following you for years now and you bring such good discussion to this never ending conflict. Right now Piers Morgan has the world's views on this conflict so please try to get on the segment because It would honestly help the cause immensely.

[@netaji-thebritishslayer]

Piers morgan is getting destroyed by leftists😅

[@America_1st_the.rest.r_last]

I agree with you as a Palestinian. The only reason Palestinians and arabs dislike Israel is literally only because of the conflict. The disliking or hate of Israel would disappear the next day once what you're suggesting happens. I can put myself in jews shoes and see where the fear comes from, but to achieve this goal both peoples need to think this way and sit down and talk. We both I'm sure have concerns to go over with each other. Which both peoples would need to figure out a way to reassure each other. Hypothetically this is simple and straightforward. What is stopping us? Ive concluded that not one government official in the world cares about or listens or even has their people's (constitutes) best interests in mind. Our world leaders seem to all have an agenda and money (for selfish personal gains) is the common denominator for all of them

[@geerenmo]

Incorrect. They have disliked Jews even before this conflict. But I'd agree with you if you'd say that this conflict needs to permanently end. It's been going on for too long. Both leaderships need to be replaced by people who want to work towards a permanent solution to this conflict.

[@tombuddy100]

Perhaps the three NOs contributed to the situation.

[@sgmovies7864]

Muslims do not hate the Jews or Children of Israel. The fact that Jews or Children of Israel are addressed directly so often in the Qur'an should tell us something. Allah wants to address Jews, to give them dawah [the message], to give them the Qur'an, instead of having stereotypes about them. Islam doesn’t allow stereotypes. Everyone is equal in the eyes of Allah, and the only thing that makes some people better than others is Taqwa [faith/belief]. In the Bible, Joshua 21:43-44 states: “So the Lord gave to Israel all the land of which He had sworn to give to their fathers, and they took possession of it and dwelt in it. The Lord gave them rest all around, according to all that He had sworn to their fathers. And not a man of all their enemies stood against them; the Lord delivered all their enemies into their hand. Not a word failed of any good thing which the Lord had spoken to the house of Israel. All came to pass”. This passage suggests that the Israelites had already taken possession of all the land that God had promised to their forefathers even before the creation of modern State of Israel. The promise of land belonging to the Children of Israel is never permanent. It comes with conditions: “Surely, following the ˹heavenly˺ Record, We decreed in the Scriptures: “My righteous servants shall inherit the land.” (Qur'an 21:105) Psalm 37:29 states that “The righteous shall inherit the land, and dwell therein for ever”. This passage is often interpreted as a promise of God’s blessing for those who live righteously. It is believed that the righteous will be rewarded with a place in the land of Israel, which is often referred to as the “promised land”. Similarly, G-d is sovereign over the nations and history. He raises up and brings down kings and empires according to His will. He uses human agents, even pagan ones, to accomplish His purposes. He is the Lord of hosts, who controls the armies of heaven and earth (Jeremiah 1:15; 25:9; 27:5-7; 32:17) If Zionists claim that G-d had given the land of Palestine to the Jews is true, then why Abraham had to negotiate with the Hittites to purchase a burial plot for his wife, Sarah [Genesis 23]? Why didn't Abraham just take the land like the Zionists did? The so-called "promised land" was given to descendant of Abraham - Isaac only. Likewise, descendants of Ishmael never lay claim to land of Arabia! In addition, Moses and his followers did not enter the "promised" land due to their disobedience. Qur'an 7:128 states: Said Moses to his people, “Seek help through Allah and be patient. Indeed, the earth belongs to Allah. He causes to inherit it whom He wills of His servants. And the [best] outcome is for the righteous.” Jews are no longer G-d chosen people. The Israelites did not keep their part of the covenant. Here is the evidence: Jeremiah 31:31-34: “Behold, the days are coming, declares the Lord, when I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel and the house of Judah, not like the covenant that I made with their fathers on the day when I took them by the hand to bring them out of the land of Egypt, my covenant that they broke, though I was their husband, declares the Lord. For this is the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel after those days, declares the Lord: I will put my law within them, and I will write it on their hearts. And I will be their God, and they shall be my people. And no longer shall each one teach his neighbor and each his brother, saying, ‘Know the Lord,’ for they shall all know me, from the least of them to the greatest, declares the Lord. For I will forgive their iniquity, and I will remember their sin no more.” It had already been prophesized in the Bible that the descendants of Ishmael/Arabs shall administer the Temple Mount/Jerusalem. Isaiah 60:7 "All the flocks of Kedar shall be gathered together unto thee, the rams of Nebaioth shall minister unto thee: they shall come up with acceptance on mine altar, and I will glorify the house of my glory." All the flocks of Kedar - On the word 'Kedar,' see the notes at Isaiah 21:16. The Kedarenians were a wandering tribe that frequently changed their residence, though it is probable they usually dwelt in the south part of Arabia Desert, or the north of Arabia Petraea. They are mentioned as dwelling in beautiful tents Sol 1:5 : 'I am black, but comely as the tents of Kedar,' see Psalm 120:5; compare Isaiah 21:16-17; Isaiah 42:11. The language here also means that that which constituted their principal wealth would come and enrich Jerusalem. The rams of Nebaioth - Nebaioth was also a son of Ishmael Genesis 25:13; 1 Chronicles 1:29, and was the father of the Nabatheans. They were a people of Arabia Petraea, and lived principally by plunder, trade, and the keeping of flocks. The country of Nabathea extended, it is supposed, from the Euphrates to the Red Sea, and embraced Petra, the capital of Arabia Deserts, and also Medaba. It is not possible, however, to fix the exact boundaries of the various tribes of Arabians. The general idea is, that their most valuable possessions would be devoted to God. The second Temple had been completely destroyed as predicted by Jesus in Luke 21:5-38. For 500 years or more, it had been left in ruins by the Jews. When Umar Ibn al-Khattab, the second caliph of Islam, captured Jerusalem in 638 CE, there was not a single Jew in Jerusalem. Now, as prophesized by Isaiah, Jerusalem is administered by descendants of Ishmael/Arabs. Dome of the Rock is the Third Temple. There are some interpretations of the Bible that suggest that the construction of the Dome of the Rock is prophesied in the Book of Daniel. Specifically, some people believe that Daniel 12:11 is a prophecy about the building of the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem. "And from the time that the daily sacrifice shall be taken away, and the abomination that maketh desolate set up, there shall be a thousand two hundred and ninety days." [Daniel 12:11] Rabbi Isser Weisberg of Machon Mishne Torah in Lakewood, explained that the “appalling abomination” spoken about in the Book of Daniel is the Dome of the Rock on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem, which was completed in the year 692. Counting 1290 (a thousand two hundred and ninety) years from the completion of the Dome of the Rock “you get 1982 and the 1335 (one thousand three hundred and thirty-five) ends in 2027. So that’s the window (1982-2027) when the Moshiach has to come.” This may confirmed the Qur'anic message. In Qur'an 17:104 says "And We said to the Children of Israel after Pharaoh, “Reside in the land, but when the promise of the Hereafter comes to pass, We will bring you all together.” The modern state of Israel was promised by British and its allies and not by G-d. In ancient Israel, G-d had prepared Moses for 80 years to lead His people Israel. 1948+80= 2028 may be the complete systematic dismantling of the modern state of Israel by God All-mighty. It is a heresy/unholy to think that Jews shall administer Temple Mount/Jerusalem as it had been clear in the Holy scripture that descendants of Ishmael/Arabs had been ordained by G-d to administer Jerusalem/Temple Mount. In Hebrew Bible, Devarim 32:17 reads as follows: "They sacrificed to demons, not God, to gods they had not known, new gods that had come recently, whom your ancestors had not feared". The medieval commentator Ibn Ezra suggested that the “new gods” mentioned in this verse were actually the gods of foreign nations that the Israelites had come into contact with. "new gods" is today's Zionism. Zionism is a nationalist movement that emerged in the 19th century to enable the establishment of a homeland for the Jewish people in Palestine. The movement initially emerged in Central and Eastern Europe as a national revival movement in the late 19th century, both in reaction to newer waves of antisemitism and as a consequence of Haskalah, or Jewish Enlightenment. Since the establishment of Israel, Zionism became an ideology that supports “the development and protection of the State of Israel”. One cannot deny that the conflicts in the middle-east is caused by the Zionism movement and the violations of the 3 Oaths made by the Jews found in the Talmud (Song of Songs 2:7, 3:5, 8:4): The Oaths: First Oath: Israel should not ascend to the land in a wall (i.e., en masse or forcefully). Second Oath: The Holy One adjured Israel not to rebel against the nations of the world. Third Oath: The Holy One adjured the nations not to oppress Israel excessively. Jews worldwide are now paying the price for the violations of the 3 Oaths Zionism ("new gods") is only around 100 years old. It is the transformation from religion to nationalism, to materialism created by non-religious Jews who hated their religion. The reason why they use the name Israel, the Star of David, hijacking, stealing the identity of Judaism and the Jewish people is in order to gain a legitimacy for their existence that should lead people to say, 'oh, it is God given to them' and that they should use fear and intimidate people from speaking out against their actions because they will call those that do anti Semitic; it couldn't be anything further from the Truth. Leviticus 26:18 “And if ye will not yet for all this hearken unto me, then I will punish you seven times more for your sins.” Qur'an 62:5 "The example of those who were entrusted with the Torah and then did not take it on is like that of a donkey who carries volumes [of books]. Wretched is the example of the people who deny the signs of Allah. And Allah does not guide the wrongdoing people."

[@bangupzzz2403]

I’ve finally found my middle ground with you. ✊🏽

[@kalel333]

Thank for still harbouring a glimmer of Hope for Peace between the two people that are One with a divide that has been ongoing for longer than we care to remember. “An eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind”

[@pamelaleibowitz3019]

Rudy Transjordan was greater Palestine. In 1949 It became the Hashsmite Kingdom of Jordan. The majority of people in Jordan are Palestinians.

[@avtaras]

2:40 That’s completely bullocks and you know it. The entire presupposition that Nigerian tribes would have to be imported here to defeat the “demographic issue” is preposterous. Only Palestinian refugees have a clear right of return rooted in relevant events (and Jews should generally be allowed to make Aliyah if they are persecuted in their home country). The difficulty is that the Arab world is responsible for a lot of the panic that caused them to migrate, and the same Arab countries can’t even provide for their own people let alone refugees. I don’t think we live in a good society if people constantly talk about a demographic issue. Israeli Arabs are mostly integrated and this is actually catalysed by the war but they need to be fully Israelised. Just like in Germany, Catholics don’t talk about a demographic issues with Protestants.

[@saszablaze1]

Most ppl i speak to in britain who chant that in solidarity mean what the most part of the Palestinians you talk to say they mean; You are so right, my government and american government, but specifically in 1948 the british foisted a forceful invasive diaspora upon the area, upon the ppl, in order to destabilize & reap the benefits over the next few hundred years. The new silk road was however talked about by the elders of zion council allegedly. Netanyahu ( or whatever his real -sztein name is) is fully complicit.

[@ISlandyute11]

Hello Rudy, I'm a newcomer to your channel after discovering you recently. I appreciate your perspective and you seem like someone who is trying to engage in good faith and with nuancd (including in this video) as I look for Pro-Israel voices to balance the perspectives ive been receiving. However, I think it is disingenous to say Israel was attacked in 1967. I've heard many pro-Israel voices do this. I understand you will probably say that Israel striking first was defensive or pre-emptive; however, that isnt the same as saying Israel was attacked. Blocking off a port or Sabre-rattling as others say, is not the same as attacking an enemy. I think itll turn-off open minded listeners to your channel when you claim something that can so easily be disproved.

[@cjamo65able]

What do Likud mean when they have it in their charter?

[@Matithyahu]

It doesn’t matter what anybody means by the chant. Explain to me how Jews can accept the right of return by non-Jews into a Jewish Democracy that doesn’t risk Jews becoming a persecuted minority in their own country, like has happened in every country they have ever lived in except the US (so far). Israel won’t be the homeland of the Jewish people if it is forced to play according to non-Jewish rules. Having said that, it also won’t be if it chooses to as well.

[@user-Jenn82]

God Bless Israel and God Bless the Jews, God’s chosen people. ✡️🇮🇱🙏 Many bible believing Christians stand with you and are helping to fight antisemitism. I’ve had so many people come against me for standing for the Jews. I don’t care because I chose God and His word over what people think of me. ✝️🙏

[@tictoc5443]

Imo ur on the wrong track Rudy based on the historical experience under muslim rule There are about 14 million arabs with palestinian heritage which potentially give them a 2:1 majority in the country resulting in an exodus of jews fearing further massacres Imo the problem of palestinian arabs is economic not political and always has been...properly address that and things will improve jmo

[@YeshuaIsTheSonOfGod]

King Yeshua is the messiah who has died for our sins so that we can be reconnected to God and be forgiven for our sins. Repent, trust and believe in your heart and proclaim with your mouth that Jesus is the Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. Jesus is truthful, faithful and He loves you✝🙏❤

[@jaekamei]

That right of return would just be for Egyptians, Syrians, Lebanese and Jordanians. Why would Israel want that?

[@tomavalon1938]

I agree with You, Rudy! The leaders of Israel should make clear what You said, that there should be a right of return and full freedoms, in exchange for an end to all the violence created by the Palestinians, against the Jewish people in Israel!

[@eden3685]

Haha that sounds nice😅 But how will it work in reality ? Inviting masses of people that vast majority of them full of hate and and contempt and dream of destruction of Israel 🤔? Just for example do a quick Google search ”black september” about what they did in Jordan 😂

[@betsonthebackroads5435]

Praying for you Rudy

[@MrInkotime]

Rudy you're coming towards the center more, what has changed? What have you seen of late for the different views? Kudos to you btw

[@jstones9872]

and when Rudy isn't there on camera and they talk privately they mean exactly what they chant. Sorry Rudy, but when they tell you over and over what they want , believe them.

[@presidentresident]

Imagine this guy was prime minister of Israel. Even without a one state solution I guarantee the war would end.

[@sabratouiri6523]

Jewes people and moslims people have many things a same in religion. Islam is coming for all mind kind islam is not just for arabs. Islam has come with arabic culture. Why jewes hate prophet jesus and mohammed???? And mohammed name means the blessing one. Prophet jesus was a jewish why people hate jesus and prophet ismaill. Prophet abraham love all of he's childeren. Abraham is the big papa with love. And moslims believe in all prophets. Peace and love!!!!❤❤❤ we are one big family with big problem in the world. I HOPE ENDING COMING SOON AND LIFE IN PEACE WITH EACH OTHER.

[@mungus633]

Sorry, buddy. We don’t believe the sequels are canon. 🤷‍♂️

[@tobiklaus722]

2:04 Its the same as if putin would not want ukrainians who fleed krim or were expelled by rusians to return so he doesnt loose power over time.

[@lapicciano]

Amen #NeveragainisNow From the River to the Sea, #Israel will remain, Free🇮🇱💯

[@erwinalbaestrecho6607]

River to the Sea is the Exact land God Gives to his Chosen people IsraelJewish identity

[@RhubarbEnjoyer]

Ok ok ok ok I have this one question that I just can't figure out. Why didn't the Jews become Christian before the diaspora? If Jesus was ressurected on 33 AD and Jerusalm was destroyed in 70 AD, which marked the second diaspora, that would give Jews plenty of time to become Christian, so why didn't they end up converting?

[@mungus633]

Lol it’s cause the resurrection never happened, bucko! Jesus (whoever he may have been in reality) died the same as any unremarkable man

[@millerbiz]

Rudy I love your work but I am not sure why we need to interpret words that are clear and unambiguous

[@JM-yn8mb]

Rudy has aged 10 years in 60 days... Wow.

[@C.I366]

People like him can bring peace and after all my readings, i cam see good and bad on both sides

[@D0nRidah]

From the river to the sea, the israeli flag is all you’ll see ;-) 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇮🇱

[@malikhaji2764]

Rudy! Have you considered becoming a politician?

[@stephen6851]

From the river to the sea, Palestinians shall be freed…. from Hamas

[@advance512]

When you say "Right of Return", do you mean to Israel or to Palestine? What do you truly mean by that?

[@avtaras]

1:32 That’s actually very nice of you to say.

[@funkydrops]

Your patience is infinite, Rudy. Thanks for the work you put in

[@sgmovies7864]

Muslims do not hate the Jews or Children of Israel. The fact that Jews or Children of Israel are addressed directly so often in the Qur'an should tell us something. Allah wants to address Jews, to give them dawah [the message], to give them the Qur'an, instead of having stereotypes about them. Islam doesn’t allow stereotypes. Everyone is equal in the eyes of Allah, and the only thing that makes some people better than others is Taqwa [faith/belief]. In the Bible, Joshua 21:43-44 states: “So the Lord gave to Israel all the land of which He had sworn to give to their fathers, and they took possession of it and dwelt in it. The Lord gave them rest all around, according to all that He had sworn to their fathers. And not a man of all their enemies stood against them; the Lord delivered all their enemies into their hand. Not a word failed of any good thing which the Lord had spoken to the house of Israel. All came to pass”. This passage suggests that the Israelites had already taken possession of all the land that God had promised to their forefathers even before the creation of modern State of Israel. The promise of land belonging to the Children of Israel is never permanent. It comes with conditions: “Surely, following the ˹heavenly˺ Record, We decreed in the Scriptures: “My righteous servants shall inherit the land.” (Qur'an 21:105) Psalm 37:29 states that “The righteous shall inherit the land, and dwell therein for ever”. This passage is often interpreted as a promise of God’s blessing for those who live righteously. It is believed that the righteous will be rewarded with a place in the land of Israel, which is often referred to as the “promised land”. Similarly, G-d is sovereign over the nations and history. He raises up and brings down kings and empires according to His will. He uses human agents, even pagan ones, to accomplish His purposes. He is the Lord of hosts, who controls the armies of heaven and earth (Jeremiah 1:15; 25:9; 27:5-7; 32:17) If Zionists claim that G-d had given the land of Palestine to the Jews is true, then why Abraham had to negotiate with the Hittites to purchase a burial plot for his wife, Sarah [Genesis 23]? Why didn't Abraham just take the land like the Zionists did? The so-called "promised land" was given to descendant of Abraham - Isaac only. Likewise, descendants of Ishmael never lay claim to land of Arabia! In addition, Moses and his followers did not enter the "promised" land due to their disobedience. Qur'an 7:128 states: Said Moses to his people, “Seek help through Allah and be patient. Indeed, the earth belongs to Allah. He causes to inherit it whom He wills of His servants. And the [best] outcome is for the righteous.” Jews are no longer G-d chosen people. The Israelites did not keep their part of the covenant. Here is the evidence: Jeremiah 31:31-34: “Behold, the days are coming, declares the Lord, when I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel and the house of Judah, not like the covenant that I made with their fathers on the day when I took them by the hand to bring them out of the land of Egypt, my covenant that they broke, though I was their husband, declares the Lord. For this is the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel after those days, declares the Lord: I will put my law within them, and I will write it on their hearts. And I will be their God, and they shall be my people. And no longer shall each one teach his neighbor and each his brother, saying, ‘Know the Lord,’ for they shall all know me, from the least of them to the greatest, declares the Lord. For I will forgive their iniquity, and I will remember their sin no more.” It had already been prophesized in the Bible that the descendants of Ishmael/Arabs shall administer the Temple Mount/Jerusalem. Isaiah 60:7 "All the flocks of Kedar shall be gathered together unto thee, the rams of Nebaioth shall minister unto thee: they shall come up with acceptance on mine altar, and I will glorify the house of my glory." All the flocks of Kedar - On the word 'Kedar,' see the notes at Isaiah 21:16. The Kedarenians were a wandering tribe that frequently changed their residence, though it is probable they usually dwelt in the south part of Arabia Desert, or the north of Arabia Petraea. They are mentioned as dwelling in beautiful tents Sol 1:5 : 'I am black, but comely as the tents of Kedar,' see Psalm 120:5; compare Isaiah 21:16-17; Isaiah 42:11. The language here also means that that which constituted their principal wealth would come and enrich Jerusalem. The rams of Nebaioth - Nebaioth was also a son of Ishmael Genesis 25:13; 1 Chronicles 1:29, and was the father of the Nabatheans. They were a people of Arabia Petraea, and lived principally by plunder, trade, and the keeping of flocks. The country of Nabathea extended, it is supposed, from the Euphrates to the Red Sea, and embraced Petra, the capital of Arabia Deserts, and also Medaba. It is not possible, however, to fix the exact boundaries of the various tribes of Arabians. The general idea is, that their most valuable possessions would be devoted to God. The second Temple had been completely destroyed as predicted by Jesus in Luke 21:5-38. For 500 years or more, it had been left in ruins by the Jews. When Umar Ibn al-Khattab, the second caliph of Islam, captured Jerusalem in 638 CE, there was not a single Jew in Jerusalem. Now, as prophesized by Isaiah, Jerusalem is administered by descendants of Ishmael/Arabs. Dome of the Rock is the Third Temple. There are some interpretations of the Bible that suggest that the construction of the Dome of the Rock is prophesied in the Book of Daniel. Specifically, some people believe that Daniel 12:11 is a prophecy about the building of the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem. "And from the time that the daily sacrifice shall be taken away, and the abomination that maketh desolate set up, there shall be a thousand two hundred and ninety days." [Daniel 12:11] Rabbi Isser Weisberg of Machon Mishne Torah in Lakewood, explained that the “appalling abomination” spoken about in the Book of Daniel is the Dome of the Rock on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem, which was completed in the year 692. Counting 1290 (a thousand two hundred and ninety) years from the completion of the Dome of the Rock “you get 1982 and the 1335 (one thousand three hundred and thirty-five) ends in 2027. So that’s the window (1982-2027) when the Moshiach has to come.” This may confirmed the Qur'anic message. In Qur'an 17:104 says "And We said to the Children of Israel after Pharaoh, “Reside in the land, but when the promise of the Hereafter comes to pass, We will bring you all together.” The modern state of Israel was promised by British and its allies and not by G-d. In ancient Israel, G-d had prepared Moses for 80 years to lead His people Israel. 1948+80= 2028 may be the complete systematic dismantling of the modern state of Israel by God All-mighty. It is a heresy/unholy to think that Jews shall administer Temple Mount/Jerusalem as it had been clear in the Holy scripture that descendants of Ishmael/Arabs had been ordained by G-d to administer Jerusalem/Temple Mount. In Hebrew Bible, Devarim 32:17 reads as follows: "They sacrificed to demons, not God, to gods they had not known, new gods that had come recently, whom your ancestors had not feared". The medieval commentator Ibn Ezra suggested that the “new gods” mentioned in this verse were actually the gods of foreign nations that the Israelites had come into contact with. "new gods" is today's Zionism. Zionism is a nationalist movement that emerged in the 19th century to enable the establishment of a homeland for the Jewish people in Palestine. The movement initially emerged in Central and Eastern Europe as a national revival movement in the late 19th century, both in reaction to newer waves of antisemitism and as a consequence of Haskalah, or Jewish Enlightenment. Since the establishment of Israel, Zionism became an ideology that supports “the development and protection of the State of Israel”. One cannot deny that the conflicts in the middle-east is caused by the Zionism movement and the violations of the 3 Oaths made by the Jews found in the Talmud (Song of Songs 2:7, 3:5, 8:4): The Oaths: First Oath: Israel should not ascend to the land in a wall (i.e., en masse or forcefully). Second Oath: The Holy One adjured Israel not to rebel against the nations of the world. Third Oath: The Holy One adjured the nations not to oppress Israel excessively. Jews worldwide are now paying the price for the violations of the 3 Oaths Zionism ("new gods") is only around 100 years old. It is the transformation from religion to nationalism, to materialism created by non-religious Jews who hated their religion. The reason why they use the name Israel, the Star of David, hijacking, stealing the identity of Judaism and the Jewish people is in order to gain a legitimacy for their existence that should lead people to say, 'oh, it is God given to them' and that they should use fear and intimidate people from speaking out against their actions because they will call those that do anti Semitic; it couldn't be anything further from the Truth. Leviticus 26:18 “And if ye will not yet for all this hearken unto me, then I will punish you seven times more for your sins.” Qur'an 62:5 "The example of those who were entrusted with the Torah and then did not take it on is like that of a donkey who carries volumes [of books]. Wretched is the example of the people who deny the signs of Allah. And Allah does not guide the wrongdoing people."

[@Mo_loves_aisha-6yoBTW]

The issue is that Zionism is More s secular movement then a religious one.

[@sgmovies7864]

@@Mo_loves_aisha-6yoBTW Zionism is anti-Judaism. What is the punishment for defiance and lies against G-d? Torah will tell you.

[@Tamar-sz8ox]

Shield of Light & Protection to you Rudy ❤

[@MarioPeeps]

love ur optimism

[@gman6176]

Again you have to have trust. So far ive seen none.

[@soenggamlu]

but isn't Israel itself already a practice of (domination) from" the river to the sea"? When a palestinian says (domination)" from the river to the sea",it became a crime?

[@777lara]

Your voice is very much needed during these times. Thank you and please stay safe. God bless

[@aoteren]

Rudy, I agree with the idea you propose. However, from the opinions of Palestinians that I heard from the limited sources I have, most of them agree on one idea: their right to the land is exclusive. Meaning, only they get to decide who can and who can't live there. Only a small minority recognizes that Jews actually have rights to this land, let alone more then themselves. While most of them are not violent, most will also not accept any authority that is not Palestinian - again, because of their belief in the exclusivity of their rights. Therefore, when they claim they just want to live freely in that land, that usually comes with the caveat of not being subject to any government that is not theirs. And that can only happen with the dismantling of the state of Israel. I do want peace between the two peoples. If the Arabs did not attack Israel in 1948 upon its creation, and instead sought a solution with negotiation, I believe there would be an option to create two states in the following manner: by bisecting the land into North and South with a line roughly from northern Ashdod on the coast of the Mediterranean Sea, and to a gap between the two parts of the Dead Sea, with Israel being in the north, and a state of Palestine being in the soth. That will leave Israel with Jerusalem, Bethlehem and parts of the Dead Sea, as well as cities like Nablus/Shchem and Jericho, while Palestine will get Ashdod, Ashqelon, Gaza (all of which used to part of city-states of the Philistines, the Palestinians' namesakes), as well as the coasts on three seas, Mediterranean, Dead and Red (where currently the Israeli city Eilat stands), leaving cities like Hebron, Be'er-Sheba and Gaza to be their capital. The ancient kingdom of Judah actually did not go far beyound Be'er-Sheba, and the indigenous people of the Southern Negev desert were actually Bedouins, who are Arabs, making it even more appropriate. Muslim (and Christian) Palestinians, in this case, should of course be allowed an easy access into Jerusalem and to all their holy sites there. I believe that the entire Jerusalem should be the capital of Israel, becasue a) it already was a capital of a Jewish kingdom and b) it has the single holiest site of the Jewish faith, while it is only the third holiest site of Islam. Unfortunately, all that seems more like a fantasy about what could have been if only. I am against any notion that Israel would be giving up any of the land in currently controls. And I honestly have no idea as to a solution that would require the least sacrifices from everyone involved. Still, I wish you luck, and hope you will find a way to realize the idea of the peaceful coexistence.

[@leemiller1837]

There is also an in-between in which Jews are permitted to stay in a Muslim Palestinian state and are never fully safe or equal, but also not expelled. Jews of sufficient means will leave, and poorer Jews will stay and suffer, or perhaps migrate illegally to Europe, where they may be unwelcome and resented. This sounds a lot like Jewish history over the last 2000 years, and what Zionism is meant to remedy.

[@netaji-thebritishslayer]

​@@leemiller1837werent jews tht stayed in west bank and gaza killed on the orders of arab leaders😅

[@leemiller1837]

@@netaji-thebritishslayer That also seems reasonably likely. Both outcomes -- oppression as second-class citizens and expulsion/death -- seem plausible. What seems less likely is Jews actually living in an Arab-Muslim Palestinian state as a minority with equal rights and personal safety :(

[@yasminachou]

from the river to the sea Palestine will be free

[@ViviCoderGirl]

Your words are important for the few non radicals that participate. I think that is an important group to speak to as well as others, and I hope they will watch this video. Kodus on you being calmed and composed doing all this hasbara 👏🏻