Here’s how a ONE-STATE solution is possible - Rudy Rochman | Clip from Ami's House Ep 17

📺 Full Episodes / @amishousepod
🙏🏼 Support on Patreon patreon/com/amishouse
🟢 Spotify Podcasts open.spotify.c...
🎙️ Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple...
📷 Instagram / amishousepod
🎶 TikTok / amishouse_podcast
🐦 Twitter / amishousepod
Ami’s House is a weekly podcast hosted by comedian and musician @aj-comedy with co-host Michael Weber. We schmooze with our favorite artists and thinkers about comedy, politics, and all things Jewish.
‪@RudyRochman‬ tells ‪@aj-comedy‬ and Mike about how a peaceful coexistence between #israel and #palestine could be implemented.
#israelpalestineconflict #jewishpodcast #idf

[@ChrisRubeo]

Rudy's incredible. It a privilege to support his effort on Patreon.

[@hilleyify]

I like Rudy but this is la la land talk

[@aminahmad2595]

Yes and stop that we will re-educate the Muslims after complete victory over hamas lol. You really think Muslims are going to listen to any jew?

[@snizami]

Thats his shtick. He has no real solutions, especially not ones requiring the power holding occupier to change course. Its just flowery peace and love language but if you scrutinize what he's saying, its in defense of whatever Israel is nominally doing as it is.

[@1729krish]

@@snizami maybe. But ive not seen anyone else offer a solution either. Its all radical bs mostly hate for the other side.

[@snizami]

@@1729krish Rochman offers no real solutions if one examines the policy upshots of his rhetoric: there are none. The framework for a solution has long existed in international law and it requires enforcement in the form of consequences for the power holder in the relationship (Israel) which the US has so far refused to permit. Nearly the entire world is united on what needs to happen, a two state solution along 67 borders.

[@GreenCanvasInteriorscape]

🚫🤡

[@3cosmo]

I'll tell you in a single word why this plan can't work: Islam

[@choyayahyah]

I don't agree with Rudy here. He's trying too hard to fit a square in a round hole. But kol akavod to Rudy

[@joanneburke9901]

No two state solution

[@NP1066]

Lol this is some crackpot shit

[@atholseptember8937]

What kind of legal/judicial system would be enforced under this system? Rabbinic or Biblical? Where would the palestinians go, and how do you claim back the temple mount and bring back temple worship without bloodshed?

[@Roumi89]

belgium example is possible. and jerusalem would have the same statuts of brussel

[@yanivcahoua9325]

very interesting opinion, not realistic at all

[@shainazion4073]

Rudy says some very valid points, other points not very true.

[@thevillageyid]

I agree.

[@ajl8198]

he is an idealist which has a place

[@Dekeljokearound]

i like Rudy trying to bring in new fresh ideas into the mix thats exactly what we need

[@GreenCanvasInteriorscape]

If anything welcoming Noah hides would do wonders for the strength and ability for Israel to define itself as a Jewish state, Rudy's approach to mean people from the street is remarkable, I commend him for that, don't think there's any aspect of what he's talking about that would work out with anything but Doom and gloom for the Jews, once outnumbered, that's how it works out until the time, yishai Fleischer talks about being an armed ethnic minority, Zionism is plausible for all people's as long as strong well-armed Jews are in charge, going forward zero consequences for any abrogations of treaties, or ceasefires with full prosecution for the complacent IDF that allowed all of this crap, times of Israel had an article today with even more proof that warnings had been boiling up for a year. Ami made a big funny lol in the middle which I already forgot so I'm relistening again

[@noahcytrynbaum4751]

But if it’s our indigenous land why do we get the south of Israel? We never controlled it apart from David’s kingdom. And we only controlled a small part of modern day Jordan…

[@GreenCanvasInteriorscape]

I'd be listening if you did a rebuttal, but no content on your Channel regarding your knowledge on actual portions of actual countries, I like Rudy's approach but it seems obtuse or naive or La La Land

[@GreenCanvasInteriorscape]

I follow the topic closely but I'm not as sharp as I could be on borders demarcations, I meant no dismissal towards you and welcome learning more, hence Rudy today

[@NaProbablyNot]

🇺🇸🇮🇱🇺🇸🇮🇱

[@Updualusain]

Jews

[@shainazion4073]

No, Jews are not only 2½ tribes. The Lost Tribes theory is a Christian ideology. Africans are Not Israelites. They have proven this by DNA. Rudy believes this kumbayah ideology. The Lemba have NO Jewish or Israelite DNA, the Igbo have no Israelite or Jewish ancestry.

[@deans5086]

The Lemba do.

[@shainazion4073]

@@deans5086 The Lemba have No High Priests DNA, that is incorrect! They have been shown to have Arab Muslim DNA from Arab traders. They have no Jewish or Israelite DNA. The Lemba have no Cohen genetics. There were 5 studies done on Cohen genetics. The original CMH (Cohen Modal Haplotype) was tested in 1996, and 2000 when DNA testing was in its infancy. Dr.Karl Skorecki tested Ashkenazi and Sephardi Jews that self-identified as Cohanim. From these "White" Jews, they came up with 6 gene sequences that most had, they labeled this as the CMH. The problem was that the control group which was mostly Arabs that had no known tie to Jews, let alone the High Priests over 30% of these people also showed positive for these gene sequences. In later testing they tightened the parameters of the DNA testing and used more gene sequences to create the *_Extended CMH,_* when the Arabs and the Lemba were tested against the Extended CMH, neither group had these genes, while 95% of the Cohen Jews showed positive. The Lemba was tested again in 2013, by the South African Medical Journal, the study called, *_"Lemba origins revisited: tracing the ancestry of Y chromosomes in South African and Zimbabwean Lemba"_* the study concluded; *_"While it was not possible to trace unequivocally the origins of the non-African Y chromosomes in the Lemba and Remba, this study does not support the earlier claims of their Jewish genetic heritage"_* Any questions? I work with DNA and have read all the studies the Lemba were tested in. They have no Israelite DNA, they have no High Priests DNA.

[@shainazion4073]

@@deans5086 The Lemba have No High Priests DNA, that is incorrect! They have been shown to have Arab Muslim DNA from Arab traders. They have no Jewish or Israelite DNA. The Lemba have no Cohen genetics. There were 5 studies done on Cohen genetics. The original CMH (Cohen Modal Haplotype) was tested in 1996, and 2000 when DNA testing was in its infancy. Dr.Karl Skorecki tested Ashkenazi and Sephardi Jews that self-identified as Cohanim. From these "White" Jews, they came up with 6 gene sequences that most had, they labeled this as the CMH. The problem was that the control group which was mostly Arabs that had no known tie to Jews, let alone the High Priests over 30% of these people also showed positive for these gene sequences. In later testing they tightened the parameters of the DNA testing and used more gene sequences to create the *_Extended CMH,_* when the Arabs and the Lemba were tested against the Extended CMH, neither group had these genes, while 95% of the Cohen Jews showed positive. The Lemba was tested again in 2013, by the South African Medical Journal, the study called, *_"Lemba origins revisited: tracing the ancestry of Y chromosomes in South African and Zimbabwean Lemba"_* the study concluded; *_"While it was not possible to trace unequivocally the origins of the non-African Y chromosomes in the Lemba and Remba, this study does not support the earlier claims of their Jewish genetic heritage"_* Any questions? I work with DNA and have read all the studies the Lemba were tested in. They have no Israelite DNA, they have no High Priests DNA.

[@mikeg2306]

Doesn’t matter. Anyone who wants to be a Jew should be accepted. There are too few of us.

[@AmandaAdames-kt3ww]

DNA isn’t “proof”. You can use DNA to identify a parent or a sibling but when it comes to ancestry, DNA results are merely estimates based on genetic markers and incomplete databases, thus they do not provide a comprehensive picture of your ancestry.

[@shainazion4073]

There should be No "Right of Return".

[@snizami]

The irony of saying that when some joe shmo white passing, fully assimilated, atheist from california whos never stepped foot in a synagogue or celebrated a jewish tradition can make ot back to israel but a Palestinian born there cannot.

[@shainazion4073]

@@snizami "Palestinian" that was born there, mortgage Palestinians were not born in Israel, and those Arabs that stayed are full citizens of Israel. Over 2.1 million of them.

[@snizami]

@@shainazion4073 bro, you guys are so heavily propagandized and also completely ignorant of the conflict's basic history. Makes you feel validated amongst your in group but to outside observers it's just sad. Palestinians were kicked out of what is today Israel-proper. They have no right of return despite a very clear, direct, officially recognized connection to that land. It's a double insult to grant emphatic right of return to any Jew (with an odd, idiosyncratic, wide sweeping, hyper-nationalistic, settler colonial criteria for who qualifies) across the world. If they have a right, expelled Palestinians and their children and grandchildren have even more right at the very least.

[@kallytem9652]

@@snizamiit’s upto israel to decide who can immigrate to Israel. The idea that Palestinians can demand to immigrate into another foreign territory is funny. Like who are you? That can take in all the Palestinians in their future state in West Bank and gaza

[@snizami]

@@kallytem9652 yea, and it's our right to deem it a hypocritical, increasingly fascistic, settler colonial, hyper-nationalistic, deeply problematic ethnostate.

[@Alex-vk9rx]

WTF is this dude talking about?