Game of Thrones | The Lion & The Rose | Episode Revisited (Sn4Ep2)

[@post-leftluddite]

"There is a savage beast in every man, and when you hand that man a sword or spear and send him forth to war, the beast stirs. The scent of blood is all it takes to wake him." Ser Jorah Mormont - A Storm of Swords - Daenerys II

[@arghunqon3774]

whatever

[@SwitcherooU]

@@arghunqon3774 They try to remember the quote at 12:30 or so. OP was just giving the correct version for those who are curious.

[@dc3189]

Really

[@tjjordan4207]

Didn’t Barristan Selmy say it in the show?

[@ZOD4]

@@tjjordan4207 No, it was Jorah.

[@calebwinfield1403]

Joffrey is the prince that was promised and now all of Westeros is doomed.

[@johnnyskinwalker4095]

maybe that's true. who else who would be vicious enough to stop the NK

[@herbertschulz4904]

Caleb Winfield no, that is hot pie

[@Brandonhayhew]

There are three like: The Faceless man, Melisadra or Tyrion lannister?

[@rokkfel4999]

@@johnnyskinwalker4095 idk ramsey makes joffery look tane

[@hijo1998]

Flesh Weasel he'd also be the only one to shove a sword in his wife

[@Vanillastump]

The reason that Ramsey has Theon/Reek shave him is pretty much Ramsey just saying, "Look daddy, I trained him real good! So good he'll do whatever I say! Please love me!" It shows that he OWNS Theon.

[@johann242]

From Sponge Bob to Lil Pump, your references are the sprinkles on this Game of Thrones donut

[@babyray5643]

Last time i was this early Joffrey was still alive. R.i.p. my sweet prince

[@blandersummer]

Larry Jones so um define sweet

[@wisdommanari6701]

Long live the king

[@thatbaratheongirl7726]

@@wisdommanari6701 I have some bad news for you...

[@wisdommanari6701]

@@thatbaratheongirl7726 lol not mad at it

[@modnarer]

You gonna blow out those candles? I was sleeping, it was midnight! LMAO great stuff!

[@iloveyourunclebob]

I've been watching a lot of KZbin clips about the fashion of Game of Thrones. I really love this episode because of what they do with her wedding dress. Especially when you compare it to her wedding dress with Tommen. There are a lot of subtle meanings behind all of the intricate details of her wedding dress. "Time flies when it takes two weeks for each video" I love when people are self-aware and make fun of themselves.

[@prof.cecilycogsworth3204]

Have you seen Costume CO's videos?

[@iloveyourunclebob]

@@prof.cecilycogsworth3204 yep that's who I'm talking about. I couldn't remember the name and I'm lazy and didn't want to look it up. I remember it used to be a longer name and that's why I really didn't want to look it up, but I knew she shortened it, still didn't want to look it up. Lol

[@SawGoodMan]

Despite Shae being one of my least favorite characters, the scene where Tyrion sends her away and treating her like less of a person always hurts me to watch, for Tyrion to direct that much false pain and insults to her as a person must have been heartbreaking for him after everything he suffered through until now.

[@babyray5643]

That's actually not the girl from last season. The girl from last season was named violet, in season 5 miranda tells sansa that violet got prego, and this new girl tansy talked too much

[@johnnyskinwalker4095]

How the Hell do you remember that?

[@FadzaiSimango]

@@johnnyskinwalker4095 Focus😂

[@alexjjgreen]

put the sword naming to a vote and itll be called "swordy macswordface"

[@dzo...]

I miss boaty macboatface...

[@dzo...]

@Ragnar Skarpsvärd unhggg I FUCKING LOVE IT

[@christianvennemann9008]

DING-DONG, THE WITCH IS DEAD! The first time I saw this episode, I couldn't wipe the smile off my face for a good 20 minutes afterwards.

[@thatbaratheongirl7726]

Wasn't sure what satisfied me more, him dying or Cersei's reaction after her bullshit when Bran was pushed from a window.

[@davidlinville1518]

Be quiet, you understand me?

[@thatbaratheongirl7726]

@@davidlinville1518 ummm nope.

[@lilboogie9812]

“There’s a beast in every man and it stirs when you put a sword in his hand.” Is the quote from the show. Its worded slightly differently in the books but its the same idea

[@ThePerks2010]

Wilko Johnson(Ilyn Payne) is still alive!!! Stop saying he's dead haha

[@H2Mass]

I'm sure Nerd Soup knows this but this KZbin thing is a grind and if you've never done it, it's hard to understand the difficulty and pain of wanting to grow and knowing you're getting better but seeing little to no results.

[@nathanmckenzie904]

I'm sure they do, but with 166k subscribers they have overcome the challenges

[@sarikatimmi]

Agrees but for sure theyve seen the results. Already they've gotten a sponsor and almost 200k followers for doing something you love to do anyhow

[@slobiden.2593]

He’s 100 percent right, I subbed to H2mass and I completely forgot I had because youtube never tells me when he uploads and I complete forgot about the channel.

[@noneofyourbeeswax01]

You don't get notified of updates just because you subscribe to a channel; for new content uploaded yu need to _also_ click on "notifications" (the little bell icon next to the "subscribed" bar).

[@christophertracy4377]

This is the reason Tyrion made a terrible Hand 2 Dany! He IS trying 2 protect his family!!

[@CalSippin]

I was so happy when Joffrey died. Like so much I was taken back with my self. Granted, he deserved a much worse death. Thanks for the upload folks🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾

[@bobbythebrainii2118]

These Game of Thrones revisits are amazing. I watch them as quickly as I possibly can whenever it comes out. It’s really the perfect recap. It’s not just because they have a great show to discuss either. These guys made me watch through Season 2 of west world. Season 1 was amazing, season 2 wasn’t nearly as good as season 1, but Kiksuya was the best episode of both seasons. I would have missed that if it weren’t for these guys. Thank you for the work you guys do. I hope HBO has an amazing show coming up for you. Or maybe you guys could do something awesome like Ozark or Black Mirror.

[@gholamdapantaloonsniffer8218]

Now they'll have house of the dragon to do 🙏

[@blackjag121]

I love how Olenna says to Sansa I am sorry about your mother and brother, at a wedding!!!!!

[@angie-tq4ew]

15:52 LOL! "The look he gives everybody...24/7!" So good! 😊❤️

[@joshmiller6260]

These re-visits have been so good with the long wait for season 8. Thank you

[@thatbaratheongirl7726]

How many people replayed his death several times out of satisfaction, but justified it by saying you were 'trying to figure out who done it'? ☠☻ Awesome series guys. I'd love the videos more often because they are good but jeez you guys have lives and it probably takes a while to put together.

[@dc3189]

Apparently 9 people

[@flobarrerav7374]

That little "C'mon" after Tyrion tells Jaime he's the commander of the Kingsguard, makes me really feel the brotherly love he has for him Edit: Just now realizing he says "Command." .-.

[@TK-kn2kx]

"Get fffk outta the way, I gotta do nothin!" 😂😂

[@user-vz4hj8oh2z]

I’m glad you guys never shilled for the BetterHelp scam.

[@batshine8]

I can understand Bran losing more of himself as opposed to Bloodraven still remembering more of himself because he had much longer to live life and have a sense of who he was where Bran is a young child at a critical age. He's seen such tragedies and been through so much, moments like running around free again, seeing his family without being able to interact with them via visions, I would imagine it would make him more robotic as we saw last season.

[@blackbird_entropy]

Batshine Exactly. Bloodraven had a character that was developed over decades, experienced good and bad events and got to really grow up. Bran never got the chance to which is part of the tragedy of his character, and most of the Stark children really.

[@PeaceOfMind8190]

Thank you...for an ASMR commentary an a nice brisk walk

[@factotums]

I love the shaving scene because it's such a subtle but powerful thing to show Theon's submission and loyalty to a man that tortured him so incomprehensibly. Especially when he finds out that Robb was killed, the person he thought of as a brother and who he might have considered his best chance of getting released (even by death) from Ramsey. He learns that Robb was killed just as he has the razor at Ramsey's main artery. It's such a small thing to let someone shave your face but it really does show control in great visual storytelling.

[@lydiaquinn2892]

I can listen to your GOT videos over and over. So spot on, so entertaining, they never get old.

[@lesgoodrich1446]

Aaron about Stanis's look:"What look, his face?" That was awesome. I love Nerd Soup!

[@jordylyons4648]

The binge continues better late than never.... thanks guys excellent content.

[@movieloverfan18]

When Tyrion tells Jaime that he can command troops as their father does, he asks when was the last time you saw father use a sword. However, Tyrion saw his father in battle swinging a sword in season 2 at Battle of Blackwater.

[@beesonbandit6639]

“Get tf outta the way I gotta do nothing!” That got me

[@rushabhbhakta7181]

That’s not actually Tansy, she got pregnant - both in real life and they work it into Miranda’s dialogue about her on the show later. This new girl is just another victim of Ramsay’s.

[@nordette]

Really I don't remember that? Do you remember exactly what she said about her being pregnant?

[@rushabhbhakta7181]

nordette when Miranda is giving Sansa a bath.

[@darth856]

Tansy is the girl from this episode. Violet was the one from season 3 who got pregnant.

[@Ivbo]

Rip to the finest and most noble king to be put on this good earth, King Jof

[@slade-joseph-wilson1822]

"there is a beast in every man and it stirs when you put a sword in his hand". One of my favorite qoutes of the show. And even tho the words are out dated the deeper point is still treu.

[@shellymariejang3467]

Beaus moment of “what” when Aaron says sommelier 😂

[@nyleahjones9619]

Damn, this one came out really fast! I love this series so much! Notification squad! Great videos, Nerd Soup! ❤

[@emilyescobedo9917]

YAY !!!! Morning coffee and Nerd Soup !!!! Happy Saturday : )

[@RizztrainingOrder]

I love y'alls reviews. Articulate, comical, in depth and thorough. I absolutely enjoy revisiting the best seasons of the series 1-4! Keep up the great work you got a fan in me. Contimplating being a stalker fan but don't know if I have the energy. Anyway thanks guys!

[@Shakdnugz2024]

29:46 - Cersei wanted to know if Pycel was still loyal to her. The food was just the medium.

[@JMarston1984]

"Go drink, until it feels like you did the right thing" My House Words

[@Georgedelacy]

I look forward to these every week! You guys are great

[@emilymcdonough1298]

Wilko Johnson, the actor who plays IIyn Payne isn't dead! He was diagnosed with cancer in 2013 and had to leave the show but he recovered and is now touring around the U.K. With his band!!

[@Brandonhayhew]

This is what Joffery needs this humiliation death because of vicious and selfish actions as a king.

[@tjjordan4207]

This is the episode that showed the fans that not even the villains are safe

[@Alfie871]

It took me a while to get into game of thrones, so is started when Season 5 began. And after a while i took a break around season 4, and i thought i was on episode 3, but i was on 2. And the spoiler of the century happened. Joffrey had died, and i missed it.

[@cullysloy2705]

I LMAO everytime Roose looks over Theon and goes... "what did you do to him"?

[@ShepardOfficial]

I've always loved that at 21:40. Snows on the throne. Or maybe even Snow's on the throne

[@tekakiuluy3221]

But he's not a Snow

[@cgonzo]

I never thought about the candle lighting scene between Melisandre and Shereen. That was hilarious!

[@KaladinVegapunk]

the cool thing about the family words, all of them are boasts or threats, and do have two meanings ours is the fury/baratheons, we do not sow/greyjoy, hear us roar/lannister, tyrells growing strong is a play on the flower theme, but also how they yoinked the high lord status during aegons conquest from the previous rulers after they got melted but starks winter is coming, its just a warning.. unless like the saying of lannisters pay their debts, its implying they ARE the winter, and not just an omen about actual winter and the Others, especially if they have some connection to them

[@shreddman8704]

The Stark men were formally known as Kings of Winter before they united the North and became the King in the North.

[@oniebrown8319]

Crazy how he joked about the actor who played Ilyn Payne died years ago. I looked it up today he died a few days before thanksgiving on Nov. 21, 2022. He died 6 days ago

[@stephenleininger2997]

Oh snaps they dropped this one early! Also, NerdSoup “liked” my comment last time, but didn’t comment or agree with it, so I’ll say it again for a third time ;). These revisits are so much more in depth and amazing than ever before. With that in mind, you all HAVE to continue these revisits through seasons 6 and 7 again! WHAT DO YOU THINK NERDSOUP?!? We love y’all.

[@thatbaratheongirl7726]

They have already done those as they aired? They've gone back to the beginning to fill gaps.

[@stephenleininger2997]

Beautiful Dirt oh for sure! I’ve seen those. I’m just saying they should continue though, even after finishing season 5 to re-review seasons 6 and 7 with this new perspective.

[@nathanfisk4054]

Doesn’t liking the comment seem to suggest they agree?

[@stephenleininger2997]

Nathan Fisk oh it’s certainly implicit, but I’m looking for that (non) binding verbal agreement lol.

[@nathanfisk4054]

Stephen Leininger lol ah fair enough, you will get there one day my friend

[@Titanic_401]

I fucking loved the A Star Is Born meme!

[@ChrisHeston]

God damn, this episode was fire. 10 out of 10 commentary you guys were on point with your humor and your little throw in with the SpongeBob and A Star is Born made me laugh so hard

[@reynedefazio6283]

Even watching your review of the wedding scene is tense!!

[@GC-hy3to]

The actor who played Illyn Payne didn't die. He survived pancreatic cancer. Wilko Johnson.

[@Shasgirl]

"He's a sick fuck, he likes a quick fuck." has my daughter and I rolling 🤣🤣🤣

[@Spongebrain97]

If tywin never died and the lannisters still had firm control over the 7 kingdoms, would the iron bank have used the golden company to collect their debts

[@goldfishprime]

They probably would have used other methods. Sending the Golden Company against Westeros would likely not yield results. Instead they would play economics. Making it seem the Lannisters were incompetent and having the Tyrells bail them out, diminishing the respect of the Lannisters until their family name meant nothing.

[@herbertschulz4904]

goldfishprime and of cours, supporting Stannis

[@michaelventura1309]

Need soup videos are one of my favorite forms of entertainment

[@ethanhawkins3391]

The longer these videos get, the easier it is to wait until 2019 for Season 8!

[@dickonmanwoody7599]

😥

[@SayaCeline]

I loved Tywin and Olenna's scenes together. I would watch a show that was just them as some snippy old married couple.

[@jamesdeanlove]

I am obsessed with these videos!

[@ericrogers8632]

I cannot tell how hard I laughed at the meme with Bradley Cooper! Love the content

[@laceyleighlovell2967]

Harry and the Hendersons. And also Encino Man.

[@0okamino]

Setting a deadline and then ignoring the hell out of it was also the Douglas Adams way.

[@robtintelnot9107]

Ramsey was badass. One of my favorite characters. Evil and funny.

[@rhyslloyd3200]

Theon shaving Ramsey is a scene I've rewatched many of times

[@twinblade6]

New Nerd Soup upload? LET'S GOOOOOO!

[@leftovercrass5210]

The kennel masters daughter

[@TheAztecGamer123]

Insanity Excursion Fpv That's probably why Jamie was so legendary he only trained with soley one hand and focused all his skill on one hand

[@leftovercrass5210]

@@TheAztecGamer123 jaime was only legendary because his family told everyone he was, he has fought no decent swordsman nor killed anyone worthy in battle, Nedd Stark tells him that to his face . Fact

[@TheAztecGamer123]

Insanity Excursion Fpv I've never thought of it like that. Thanks for the new perspective my guy

[@leftovercrass5210]

@@TheAztecGamer123 first thing a swordsman learns is to use both hands. Usually Because they are holding a shield or spear in the other. Imagine if Jaime was just chilling out on his horse and someone charged him from behind and attacked on the left? Even with 2 hands he would be screwed. Nedd basically laughs at Jaimes skills to his face when they first see each other season 1 haha. A fighter is graded on his ability to fight in battle. Nothing more

[@xZZNSx]

Can't wait till the Ge to season 7 again

[@remmoze]

Wow, i haven't noticed that Lock and Ramsay were bros, but it makes sense!

[@alphariusomegon3965]

The mist novel child put in that planet taken away from us also imagine if he had to deal with the sparrow movement and how quick it would been felt with

[@kunkashi8208]

At the end of the day, the wedding still went exactly as planned.

[@BigRob1994]

Bran was warned not to stay inside summer too long or he'll lose himself, who he was.. it was probably the same with the weirwood net. He had to stay in the weirwood net longer because of his encounter with the night king while in the weirwood net

[@bridgetcooper6331]

He’s a great actor. To get us all to hate him as we did.

[@post-leftluddite]

In the books, Mel burns Uncle Flurent to gain favorable winds for their sea voyage to the Wall, and in the books, while Stannis' hand of the king, he wrote a letter to Tywin saying that Stannis will surrender and that Shareen will be married to Tommen so that when Stannis dies, the Lannister's would basically get Storm's End and he did this without Stannis' knowledge, so that's treason so he deserved to die. The show makes Mel way more evil than she actually is in the books.

[@darth856]

But the interesting part is that GRRM wrote the script for this episode. I wonder if they cut anything out while filming it, or if George changed it himself.

[@demJem09]

Paused at 15:22 to say that (imo of course) Tyrion couldn't explain things to Shay because she, as a person, has a very strong-headed & stubbourn personality. As in, she believes strongly that everyone has a choice and freedom to follow that choice if they really want it. Tyrion would say that it isn't that simple in his situation, but Shay always argued otherwise when the topic was brought up. So Tryion did what I think was his only choice besides forcing her away against her will. Just my thoughts on it, really enjoying the video so far.

[@KaladinVegapunk]

Martin said there's not going to be any new POVs besides the one-off prologue/epilogues So no Meera POV We got a lot of his visions in his dance chapters, ned from ch 1, earlier ned post war talking about Jon and Robb growing as brothers, the King who Knelts brother making weirwood arrows to take on Aegons dragons, and a first men ritual It's definitely obscure, Bloodraven teaches him a lot and feeds him the jojen paste haha But I'm sure it'll be a bit restrictive as far as what we see of his visions for the big stuff

[@kingmatthias5441]

Dear NerdSoup. I am a newbie in your channel and i have to say that i havent felt such a relief. You became one of my favourite videomakers and i like both of your opinions about the show. And did you noticed that the only character who stands better than season 1 is Bronn :D

[@teksdead9780]

Ramsay was more likeable than Joffrey. Equally sadistic but Ramsay had a more upbeat personality that you could almost enjoy.

[@Sp1rit19]

After Joffrey death the show became kinda boring. Dont get me wrong there are other great villians like Ramsey but I just loved hating Joffrey

[@modnarer]

I disagree, Joffrey was easy to hate, but man Ramsey is way way worse. Joffrey is powermad, Ramsey is just mad!

[@The810kid]

@@modnarer Ramsay loses point for having writers favoritism until it was time for him not to have plot carry him

[@goldfishprime]

+The810kid Agreed, Joffrey at least had some explanation to his cruelty... Poor upbringing, Cersei, inbred. Ramsay was cruel because... his father didn't love him?

[@thatbaratheongirl7726]

I disagree. Tywin was the great loss this season. Charles Dance just takes over the room, such a dominant presence.

[@The810kid]

@@thatbaratheongirl7726 agreed his death was bigger for the plot Cersei said it herself that arrow made them open

[@cuppycake0rainbow]

OMG yey I've been waiting for this for a while

[@gabriellawless2202]

I love you guys, don't ever change!

[@King_Mac80]

I think the difference with Bran and the original 3 eyed Raven is that Rivers lived a long life before he became the 3 eyed Raven, while Bran wasn't even a teenager. There wasn't much for Bran to hold onto I think that's why he lost so much of himself.

[@blackjag121]

I am happy!!! A real treat!!!!

[@justinvidal3572]

For now on I’ll refer to Tyrion getting rid of Shae as pulling an Air-Bud

[@gabrielle6415]

Coffee Justin “Get outta here! Can’t you see I don’t want you anymore!”

[@tkbruisekc2077]

Love these Revists! Slightly off topic but could you do a review of the Movie the mid 90s?

[@davidwoodward9528]

Franz Kafka once inspired Peter Jackson to make a proof-of-concept for a Giant Roach & King Kong Jr as web-based culture critics. This is the result.

[@Alexander-xh7zm]

Always been my favourite episode!

[@McKay2]

I think the trope in fiction mentioned at 13:48 is sometimes referred to as "White Fang"-ing

[@deshawnmichaelson4161]

Max Von Sidow is a master thespian... he can draw upon a lifetime of complex emotions, memories and characters for a nuanced three eyed raven. Isaac H. Wright is literally a child actor, chosen because he came across quite naturally as a simple playful child. There is ZERO indication that his acting abilities are above average at all... let alone in the range of Max Von Sidow

[@alldayagain]

With this episode in particular, i'm suprised Joffrey didn't kill the guy who suggested the sword name Seems like something he'd do

[@catsrule6231]

My favorite character is the Nights King thank you. I love him very much. Such a Strong lean cold man with peirceing blue eyes and never speak a word , how could you not fall in love with him ?

[@lashisrad]

Nerd Soup of Thrones Revisited Season 4 Episode 2-The most likes I ever got on a post was saying "You're all about to see my favorite thing trending possible.:

[@jamiecaldwell35]

I have no clue why but I could never find myself really hating Joffrey all that much. Like, I hate the things he did but I didn't have a hatred for him. I honestly find him quite interesting.

[@goldfishprime]

He's well written villain. One that riles you up, but you don't want to see gone.

[@lsaaiahh]

You guys should do a breaking bad revisited

[@TheMorganVEVO]

Y'all are so funny. I really love this channel. XD

[@MrSteelx79]

i have nothing to say i think this is one of the best written episodes games has to offer it has bro v bro bro v sis and bro v dad all in the same family their is a choice to be made here and very big one which caused more of a bigger storm for there feature . by the way this comment was written 1:42 in the video.

[@nickrosetti9224]

When you guys gonna show Joel Embid, Ben Simmons, and my man Jimmy Butler some love?!?!?!?!?!

[@rochenmanta838]

If you shave somebody you need such sharp knives, and you aren't allowed to miss otherwise you could kill him. And Ramsay proves he broke theon that utterly he doesn't even try to kill the man who castrated him