GAME SINS | Everything Wrong With The Evil Within In Twelve Minutes

Subscribe on Patreon for CLASSIC SINS & DLC SINS: / dartigan
The Evil Within is about as scary as a trip to a blood drive accident. Also, Shinji Mikami is apparently a renowned genius according to the press. here's GAME SINS Everything Wrong With The Evil Within.
Follow Me On Twitch: / dartigan
Join My Discord: / discord
Like If You Did.
Subscribe For More.
Vote For The Next Game.
Inspired by Cinema Sins.

[@JudgeBane]

I believe the reason that Sebastian can't run for shit is because he smokes. You know, like every other fictional police officer in a trench coat ever.

[@NWO41508]

That’s actually.. surprising accurate. Didn’t think of that

[@creatureslim]

I smoke and can run longer than 3 secs

[@JudgeBane]

@@creatureslim Fair. Do you smoke lots, or just occasionally? That may have some impact on it.

[@creatureslim]

@@JudgeBane I don't smoke tobacco anymore just the green. But I smoked 2.5 packs a day for like 6 or so years then would smoke 2 or 3 packs a week for another 5 or 6 years.

[@JudgeBane]

@@creatureslim Fair enough. I think tbh they just added the crappy stamina for gameplay purposes, it is pretty unlikely that anyone could have such bad stamina unless they literally had emphysema.

[@stewartviera4774]

The siren, the rain, the radio, no people... All that is because the whole first intro is not real. They are already connected to the machine and ruviks brain from the first second of game play. They think they're in real life but they're not.

[@leoncoben6983]

But...how did they get there then in the first place? And why was Seb and Jo there too? They seem pretty irrelevant unless they were just more test subjects.

[@Butchimus]

Been forever since I played but if I remember correctly, Sebastian was investigating his daughters death and wife's disappearance, which are both linked to Mobius. Mobius discover that Seb is close on the trail and notice that he is a capable detective, so they kidnap him and put him in STEM to kill Ruvik so that they can freely use STEM without it being a horror shit show. Joseph is Seb's partner so they probably put him in STEM also to assist and make the "dream" more believable for Seb. The DLC's later reveal that Seb's wife is a member of Mobius and it may have been her that picked Sebastian to be the one to kill Ruvik and organised his kidnapping.

[@rotkappchenlp7032]

they are all in there because Dr.Jemenze was building a wireless version of the STEM in Beacon that, by connecting to other wireless transmiters such as a radio in a police car, can affect people in limited radios around the main terminal (the one you wake up in Beacon at the end of the game)

[@Alexandra.AI.]

You also find a "missing person" poster of Joseph, near the end of the game, which says that at the time of his disappearance he was looking for someone (which most likely meant Seb).

[@axellorinser8322]

just play The Evil Within 2 and u will see everything a cristal clear

[@soidus]

You forgot that when Sebastian's calf muscle was sliced, then he jumped into a pool of blood, INFECTIONS!!!

[@Bloodhurl67]

true. AIDS

[@jojolafrite90]

Yeah, but since all this is not in reality. But in the collective mind of all the people connected to the STEM thing. There is no aids in a big blood pool if it is a make believe giant blood pool made with generic blood, not actual individual DNA that is mixed together . XD I'm overthinking it. But still.

[@Bloodhurl67]

jojolafrite90 No that is indeed right, dx

[@ethanedwards3357]

ITSAVAIDEOGAHME

[@Engmatic]

The same thing my brother and me thought when I first started Playing the game

[@carlosvelasquez8710]

In Markiplier's playthrough of this game, he actually goes "IS THAT ME?" when Joseph first comes up. Lel.

[@Fiery_Latina_Goatchan_GF_681]

who?

[@princessbeexxxx]

Misty Graves Markiplier, a KZbinr, played this game and when Mark saw Detective Joseph, he says, "Is that me?". Its funny because the guy that's sinning this game, said that Joseph was a discount Markiplier.

[@Fiery_Latina_Goatchan_GF_681]

pfft I see nothing, joseph looks more like ofdensen from metalocalypse

[@DLatrice325]

tbh that's prob why he said it, bc markiplier said it himself

[@mewmew34]

Marina The Octoling I love you. Metalocalypse is the greatest thing ever.

[@nerevar117]

To be fair it makes sense that Ruvik would be wearing a hoodie. He's a burn victim after all.

[@captaincuck6239]

+Indoril Nerevar There's always a possibility that Two-Face decided to guest star this sins video.

[@Smiley_Face0]

AcidicReaver :'D

[@StormyRaven]

It *also* hides his weird glass dome thing over his brain.

[@serenitydiehl1441]

Indoril Nerevar honestly he’s a rip off of the antagonist from the movie “Deliver us from Evil”. No shade love this game soooo much, #2 was a let down compared to the first in my opinion. The detective is similar to Sab as well. Not sure if they’re related because the game came out 1 month after the movie but if you watch it the resemblance is nuts, never looked that deep tho.

[@cartooncritique6625]

If we're just going off THAT logic he should really be wearing a fedora and a Christmas sweater. XD

[@yinyang3681]

Sin for you calling JOSEPH JOHNATHAN.

[@sakutaazusagawa6012]

JoJo xD That's why i wondering about...

[@josesierra198]

Yin Yang I swear that was bothering me so much

[@Peachelliver]

thought I was the only one xD

[@leonjoey9919]

jojo

[@LukeDude759]

"Throwing away a chainsaw in a zombie survival scenario" should have earned at least 20-40 sins.

[@ethanedwards3357]

LukeDude759 The chainsaw cut into metal. It likely broke.

[@ethanedwards3357]

@@ryguy3696 Are you fast?

[@ethanedwards3357]

@@ryguy3696 I was being snarky.

[@ryanyont9953]

Your first like 6 sins fail to realize that in the opening scenes the 4 characters in the car are already in the STEM which is why there is no one there except for them. Everything seems out of place because they're all ready hooked up to the STEM and are being controlled.

[@ryanyont9953]

I just. Ugh. You don't know the story at all.

[@joeyq4970]

+Ryan Yonr ikr

[@matthewsullivan9087]

Yes I agree they were plugged in right off the bat by kidmans doing

[@itzrepeerc5564]

Yeah the loud ringing means your plugged into stem

[@aaronl5388]

As someone else in another video pointed out, EVERYTHING from the start of the game is in your head, which actually makes the city being empty kind of a cool thing as once you learn the truth it becomes kind of creepy. It also kind of sorts out a few time inconsistencies. It actually makes me think that the only reason you survive anything is because your just stubborn and are literally imagining ways out of a situation. So...it's like inception...

[@ChronicNOTAG]

Discount Markiplier gets me every time.

[@julesroy3469]

ChronicNOTAG Even Mark noted it!

[@Fiery_Latina_Goatchan_GF_681]

who?

[@queenbeemoon10]

Mood

[@kuwakaney2443]

Marina The Octoling imagine watching a gaming video on a quite obscure game and not knowing who Markiplier is

[@dill6688]

half of these sins can be explained through the story

[@dill6688]

XxDarkDragonxX in my opinion the dlc is way more fun too

[@Collector731]

Dylan Ecclestone For example ''sexism'', troughout the game you find document of Sebastians diary in which he suspects Kidman being there not as a rookie, but as someone who(how it's written) watches their every step.

[@mayaemogrl]

I know right! I was shouting that at the voice over guy though most of this video lol

[@freezerounds]

theduckmenace The DLC is ultimately better than the main game itself.

[@matthewsullivan9087]

Well you do get a gun and kill that lamp lady at some point, maybe not for a while but still you do get one. But in the end I liked the main game better.

[@brandona9326]

if you played the game and understood the story. You will understand the reasom there is no-one in the city. Also you would understand the radio situation as well. At this point he is really still connected to the brain.

[@casthedemon]

No you understand a lame explanation.

[@garytaylor3880]

@@casthedemon oh look someone who's to lazy to pay attention getting mad at facts

[@casthedemon]

@@garytaylor3880 oh look someone whose IQ is lower than their age.

[@kuwakaney2443]

Cas The Demon someone obviously was too stupid to figure out the story after it was basically presented

[@mike19832301]

@@casthedemon but the city was empty? Ruvik had killed or made the rest of the people zombies, and at the start they were already connected

[@SlaveDanLevi]

"Anemic cousin" Anemic is not astmatic. Anemia does not make you a worse runner. Sebastian is an alcoholic and a smoker. He's also reaching his 40's. That's his excuse.

[@DefinitelyStephanie69]

He also got hit with a fucking chainsaw in the leg

[@truewalter4193]

As someone who wears glasses i appreciate that scene where Sebastian goes back for Josef's glasses. Because that feeling as a wearer of glasses when you lose your glasses...

[@judahfrankel9742]

Actually, the game makes a lot more sense once you realize that everything in it, including the drive up to the hospital, is part of the dream. The main characters came to the hospital, were knocked unconscious, and were hooked up to the machine before the game even started. The opening sequence is sort of a live-in recording of their last memories, before Ruvik became aware of their presence and started trying to kill them.

[@pedroguilherme868]

Exactly my thoughts

[@tjdunagin]

"Discount Markiplier" oh man that's rich, I take back what I said on your other video, you're actually a pretty funny guy

[@Astrela1]

Kaitlyn Renee hater alert, KZbin, do your shit

[@paranidherc]

+tjdunagin yeah, i lolled really hard at that one

[@paranidherc]

Kaitlyn Renee thats almost words there.

[@noreehix5714]

Fun fact Markiplier got freaked out because the character resembled him.

[@Aziz-fk4qb]

We all know it's much much much better then resident evil series on everything

[@isaacwellborn]

You do realize the whole game you're in your subconscious with other people's subconsciouses right? Nothing makes sense in your dreams, so why should it in another person's dreams?

[@TheFluffyWendigo]

Isaac Wellborn Discord: Make sense? oh what fun is there In making sense?

[@woofwoof7226]

what other person's dreams?

[@liamitodavis1713]

one man the whole game from beginning to end takes place is ruviks head. Did you even play the game?

[@isaacwellborn]

@@liamitodavis1713 No shit Sherlock, but you gotta BE your own head to be inside his head

[@isaacwellborn]

@@nohigherbeing In reality nothing really happened. They were all hooked up to the machine and shared each other's consciousnesses

[@Zyxz]

Minus a shit load of sins because you guys apparently never actually finished the game. Tons of those first sins make sense once you know you've been hooked up to a mind sharing device.

[@matthewvader3002]

That's the game's fault...

[@whisperhawkmoonspecialist9203]

I feel like if the game does something that doesn't make sense until a piece of information is revealed later, it doesn't make it the game's fault that they aren't giving all of the information as to why certain events are happening in the way they are. This is because the horror genre relies on mystery to be scary (though in this game it's mostly the gore), and if a game or any piece of media for that matter doesn't explain something strange or that doesn't initially make sense in the pretense you see it under, it doesn't really make it a problem does it?

[@casthedemon]

Doesn't mean it's not a shit explanation for a lack of funding lol.

[@garytaylor3880]

@@matthewvader3002 No its the modern gamer's fault for expecting to be spoon fed everything and needing their hand held so they bitch about the plot not being presented on a silver platter and make no attempt to pay attention or read.

[@erikthegamer8727]

Because this youtuber only seeks rightfullness joke in his content 😂

[@p0kiipanda]

This was really funny but the game was amazing nonetheless, haha. Plus you kept calling Joseph "Jonathan." 11/10

[@Chrizzy210998]

You do know that Discount Markiplier's name is Joseph and not Jonathan, right?

[@xSaraxMxNeffx]

dartigan sins: Forgetting that physics dont apply in dreams/thoughts

[@TrueUnderDawgGaming]

I'm surprised that he didn't bring up how the very first playable area has 3 dead bodies that are the exact same. Same position, same character model, etc. That's just lazy. Especially for the first area of your game.

[@goofiestgoober4272]

Lol maybe it's a glitch in the...stem

[@MoralsInSongs]

Jonathan?Fucking Joseph mate!!

[@MoralsInSongs]

+I_know_I_have_somewhere_to_be_but_I'm_too_buisy_watching_Jacksepticeye_and_Markiplier I love your profile pic! Was I the only one really annoyed rewatching this? Most of the stuff he said was kinda obsolete...

[@TwinSnakes89]

I don't claim to know this story well (because its written so poorly) but I can safely say I believe the moment the game begins you're already in the machine, there is no people in the city and they don't reference it outside of "they all must be dead" and Ruvik was able to kill those 3 policeman because they're not in the 'real world' at that point. Notice how the female detective doesn't flinch like everyone else when they hear the static over the radio, because she knows exactly whats going on and knows she is in Ruviks brain. But I suppose trying to make sense of this mess of a game is giving it too much credit.

[@Dartigan]

That's pretty much the only way you could conceivably explain the beginning. It still doesn't fill in all of the wholes and in fact creates new ones such as why would some police detectives be hooked up the STEM in the first place?

[@brentc8189]

Dartigan They started kidnapping people and hooking them up to Ruvik's mind with the STEM machine. They mentioned that the people investigating the kidnappings also went missing which would explain why there were police alive in the beginning, since they were all hooked up to STEM when the game started. I believe it was mentioned at some point that all of the monsters encountered in the game were people trapped in Ruvik's mind.

[@Dartigan]

Brent C Must have mentioned that in a note I never found.

[@perranpope7466]

If you read sebs journals they help you understand the story a little and why Seb is in STEM. At least TEW has a better story than destiny 😄

[@Dartigan]

Destiny has a story?

[@Evil_gremlin]

All these sins can be explained

[@janchrtan8639]

Z0mb1eslayer 98 Even the discount Markiplier one?

[@bipstymcbipste5641]

What about the repeated audio track?

[@placeholder4988]

Hunter Or the Chainsaw one

[@sonofodin1044]

Ethan Johnson not boring

[@kuwakaney2443]

Ethan Johnson if you found it boring, you probably lost the ability to release any chemicals in your brain

[@uniporndev8390]

Most of these sins were invalid, Ruvik did t kills those cops in the real world for starters so that eliminates about 10 of your sins, towards the end of the game shortly before the final boss fight Sebastian became the host of the world, explaining why he was able to get so "Lucky" with the rpg and the pistol, I suggest playing the game before you judge it P.S Kidman is in the dlc

[@scorch2155]

Kurt Ironmonger from what I've gathered he plays all of these games through once, then plays them a second time to make the sins videos.

[@AidenDoesVideos]

How funny, they did come up with a DLC coming up with Kidman's backstory.

[@ssrodrigo29]

Did you play the game until the end? A lot of answers to your questions...

[@brianforsyth2225]

You continue to sin loading gates like that isn't intrinsic to a game, having to load the next section. If you're implying that the entire game map should be loaded up at once, you know that'd be shitting on anything less than god-tier computers to play modern games anymore, and the only other alternative is some sort of mini-game that fits the theme, which isn't always viable or even imaginable to create.

[@magnaesca165]

Maybe he sins them because they are too blatant.

[@budlikycz2445]

Sniper Ghost Warrior 3 did it and its an open world

[@TylerDurden-hh1sb]

We're about to be living in the future, the next gen.. ps5 is almost here and it's said loading screens will be almost non-existent

[@Razhork]

Huh, I really liked the Laura/Spider lady boss fight. I wish she didn't instantly kill you once she grabs you, but I didn't find her difficult. She was probably the creepiest boss in the main game for me, which sort of outweighed the negative of her being one big instakill mechanic. I was surprised as fuck to see you didn't tax the retarded wolf boss fight (sentinel). That was actually such a bad and annoying fight. It had a slightly interesting gimmick with hiding behind bushes, but it would charge your shit and knock you down constantly. I mean, the beginning of the game and Ruvik appearing in the real world is not directly explained, but it's beyond heavily implied as you progress the game. **SPOILER** At the beginning of the game, you're actually already connected with the STEM machine along with every other person appearing in the game. At 0:45 pay close attention to Kidman. Out of all 3, she is the one who is unaffected by the noise. That is because she works for an organisation called Mobius, which are the ones who hired the doctor and Ruvik to make the STEM machine. From this scene alone we can already deduce that they've already been connected to STEM. There isn't any people on the streets because the people of Krimsom City aren't connected. I'm sure there was technical issues that contributed too, but it does 100% make sense story-wise at the very least.

[@dough1595]

The only thing that deserves praise in this game is the tense ambient. The moment Sebastian starts destroying waves and more waves of enemies, you realize: "oh, it's just a gory RE4."

[@athest7]

dough1595 Being "just" an any kind of RE4 is a positive, and that's more or less what the game is supposed to be in the first place.

[@DrakoVongola11]

+dough1595 More games should be like RE4. RE4 was a masterpiece. Also this is the guy who made RE4, so of course there's gonna be similarities.

[@Ch50304]

+DrakoVongola11 I agree I love RE4. Its awesome.

[@matthewsullivan9087]

Leslie is a boy

[@tarapapi]

you say taht like its supposed to be a negative

[@bloodlightning]

Annnnd subscribed. Time to go watch more vids, good work, man.

[@Henry-po8rj]

#discountmarkiplier

[@LukeDude759]

"Scientists have the worst fight or flight response whenever they come to a big realization." Or, in the case of Half Life, ever. Excluding Gordon Freeman. Anyone who has played Half Life 1 or seen Freeman's Mind knows exactly what I'm talking about.

[@your_buddy_ryan]

LukeDude759 Amen to Freeman's Mind

[@VisualGourmet]

3:38 That chainsaw now could just scratch a zombie's upper skin at the most, so... it's more ballast than useful. 3:48 "Losing online"? "Losing on mind"? "Losing all mine"?

[@carpmmtal]

Well, did you make the video step by step while you were playing it? The empty city and the problem with the radio is completely explained later, when you realize that Sebastian is already connected to Ruvik's brain.

[@kylemalley5280]

I don't think this guy really played the game because in beginning u are already in stem which is why the intro is the way it is , and the game is a collective of all the minds of the people in stem that is why the settings change so drastically

[@Simon-fc9hg]

I'm going to clear up a few plot points for you. Note that I'm not saying they remove sins, because they actually replace current sins that you have in place already with newer ones: 1 - The headache at the beginning is the same type that the characters get throughout the game. That's because when the game starts, they are already inside of Ruvik's head, and they are NOT in the real world. This also explains why there was no one out on the street, and how Ruvik was able to kill the security guards. It's because it was already the "dream" world. Also, at the end when Sebastian finally leaves the asylum and is greeted by the cops, he gets another headache, meaning he still isn't out yet. 2 - Ruvik is not all powerful in this world. Sure, he is able to consciously control it, but he isn't the only one who is changing things in it. The doctor does say at one point that everyone who is trapped inside of it is contributing to it subconsciously, which is why there are weapons, and why Sebastian is constantly warping back to the asylum. 3 - The reason the narrative is disjointed is because Sebastian is going through the warped memories of Ruvik. The memories are not in chronological order, and they are twisted and unreliable. 4 - The constantly shifting memories are also the reason why they keep warping from one location to the next. Now that I've listed those things, I think it's pretty obvious which sins get replaces with new ones. For example, if the game already starts off in Ruvik's head, how come no one remembers getting there? How did they get taken there to begin with? Anyway, I just wanted to clear a few things up. It was a great video either way!

[@shadowx2652]

Good question. How did they get there to begin with? Most likely ruvik injected seb and that's how he got there. But in the other sin video its a sin because ruvik cant be a god in the outside world. It doesnt make sense.

[@bonbonnie1347]

1:14 The texture popping on the officer's/driver's entire model. +1 from me.

[@namelessstranger1270]

In a genre where it's becomingly alarmingly acceptable to simply feature cheap jumpscares and explosions instead of any actual horror, Evil Within was a desperate need for the horror-survival IP.

[@anthonytrevino3191]

Looking back there were some stuff I noticed like they made stealth A component in that first village chapter and sharply abandon it rest of game lol.

[@Jack-pp2ng]

Yeah they add sneak attacks bit there is literally no reason to use them since you become so overpowered with weapons by late game

[@KATinBLACK]

Cliche: evil looks downright sexy Come on, Ruvik is kinda...hot...

[@victorkercado8595]

The "losing our minds" repetition only reminded me of an episode of billy amd mandy where billy would yell from his fear of clowns "DESTROY US ALL, DESTROY US ALL, DESTROY US ALL? DESTROY US ALL"

[@ANINIMOUSE.]

7 years later and still no Silent Hill 2 sins video. Sin Dartigan for getting our hopes up.

[@behinddoornumber1606]

"Discount Markiplier" made this video 10x better lol

[@TheSilentHamish]

0:41 Not really sure being a video game character who looks kind of like someone on KZbin who plays videos games counts as a sin? Don't youtube outsiders have to know who 'Markiplier' is first?

[@Dartigan]

It's not really a sin, sometimes I just say and put in whatever strikes me or that I think is funny. These vids should not be taken as a series review. This is just entertainment.

[@TheSilentHamish]

I dig the videos. It was one of those 'Oh yeah, that guy'. But I was watching this with a friend and he was like "Who is Markiplier?". He's not cool like the rest of us.

[@Dartigan]

I envy him and his youtube innocence. If only I could go back to not knowing anything about the youtube Let's Players.

[@TheSilentHamish]

Yeah, he's one of those people who like the 'real' world. What ever that is? I've stopped my self from buying a game, just because i watched a guy play the entire thing on KZbin. I was like, "I should get this...yet now I've spoiled the twists in the story...Damn". (I still play games for the story content)

[@DitisEmile]

I rewatched this one after watching your more recent one for the Evil Within 2 and the fact that you call Joseph Jonathan makes me laugh so hard. xD

[@andywayne2154]

Ok I don't know if this has already been said but in defense of the sadist locking seb in the room rather than killing him outright it's the fact his name is the sadist he enjoys sebs suffering that can also be defend the hall chase I believe the sadist is intentionally going slower to enjoy sebs suffering

[@tenzer0]

"Ruvic" *DING!*

[@coconuthead1361]

So there are three Gaming Sins channels. GamingSins, GCN, and Dartigan. Which one is "official"?

[@DrakoVongola11]

+Steve Stevenson None of them, they're all just shameless ripoffs of CinemaSins. Not that that's necessarily a bad thing.

[@lightinxeno4541]

cinemasins is the original these guys just liked the idea of GamingSin so they tried it them selfs and honestly i don't watch cinema sins i watch these three guys ...

[@bigbruno2232]

+Steve Stevenson 4 theres also Charriii5 who also sins bad games like sonic boom rise of lyric

[@gfaDiaspa]

Man, this one was really good! I'm waiting for the Indigo Prophecy one!

[@PipHalsey]

That seating arrangement looks more like the kind you would see in a public bus, rather than a school bus.

[@giovporto6475]

One of the best horror games created its so creepy.idk why they hating on this game so much.

[@Executioner02]

There’s no one in the city because it’s set inside STEM

[@jondoe-nc9qo]

The question I have is if they were sucked into stem while driving how did they not all die in a car crash?

[@Executioner02]

@@jondoe-nc9qo the whole opening sequence with the mental hospital was inside stem as well

[@jondoe-nc9qo]

@@Executioner02 Yeah but as far as I know the hijacking happened when the radio made that sound. I think it says in the DLC Stem was activated remotely while htey were on the way there. Then again DLC should never be used to explain a story so what do I know?

[@angelicanuta115]

Conelly says "I'd have waited, but..." Not that he did wait. But I'm so enjoying these.

[@udowurf7597]

Somehow I always return to these videos, no matter how old they are.

[@joeyq4970]

you should get a sin for calling Joseph Jonathon

[@Tw1s7]

You're getting so much better, Dartigan. Good Job :)

[@Dartigan]

Thanks Tw1s7. And thanks for commenting so often. I love reading everyone's reactions.

[@Tw1s7]

Dartigan Of course. You deserve the love you get with all the work you put in to the videos. :)

[@incotheghost6243]

"So it's just like very JRPG ever." Gotta give credit where credit is due, that made my day. *Slow clap*

[@raymondstpaul4913]

I really like these videos your explanations actually make sense for certain games or movies that are too numerous to list. Hey can you please do one for IN THE MOUTH OF MADNESS MOVIE SOONEST?

[@TheZebigboss]

The story explain most of the sins... but nice vid nontheless

[@galacticscalepenguins6092]

Please actually do the video on Silent Hill 2. That is my all time favorite game and I genuinely believe it to be perfect. I would like to see if you can find some legitimate issues with it beyond just nit-picky stuff). This is of course assuming you actually understand the lore and don't just rant about how stuff doesn't make sense like most people do if they don't like the game. And you clearly can't use overused cliches and sins that were not overused at the time because it was around before most of this stuff became common-place.

[@andalyn555]

Yes, exactly, I would love that too! Since so many people have done video's on the positive things, it would be great too see someone pick it apart where they can.

[@dartmaxwell]

Really enjoy the videos. Just a note on this one though, a lot of your sins, such as why the city was empty at the beginning and the random character teleporting, are because the entire game (minus possibly the ending) take place in the bad guy's mind. Your character went missing before the events of the game and was plugged into the machine along with kidman and the others who are "alive" with you. It's not directly explained, but you can gather it from the missing posters in the save area (your guys 'missing' poster shows up your first visit in NG+). People were being kidnapped and plugged into the machine for testing.

[@sadisticgamerpodcast1186]

its amazing just how manby things you listed i noticed while i played this game. and before watching this video haha, this is great, keep it up

[@whippyice5420]

and despite all the sinse, i love it

[@Dartigan]

I did to. It had some rough edges here and there but I had fun with it. Hopefully a sequel will get everything right next time and get closer to how good Resident Evil 4 was.

[@perranpope7466]

I don't think the bad taste chapter 11 and 12 left will ever leave me. Apart from them 2 chapters I love this game and look forward to the DLC, but please no more instant kills

[@Dartigan]

Yeah, that part with Ruvic hunting you through the mansion was just terrible.

[@perranpope7466]

Yea I think that's chapter 9, correct me if I'm wrong. I love and hate the mansion scnario it's fun but also a bit cheap at a couple times. When you leave the master bedroom after the brain puzzle he is waiting for you outside and you don't really have anywhere to hide because he will see you do it (I learnt my lesson the hard way in that room) but then a few chapters later you fight him and find out he is a pussy that is easier than any other boss in the game. The city part sucks because so many enemy's have guns and they NEVER miss, chapter 13 on the bus is just fucking terrible, if I have to ride that bus again in the Kidman dlc I'm going to throw my ps4 out of the window😡. Anyway keep up the good work I'm glad I found this channel.

[@Dartigan]

Thanks perran. I agree, the city part was hard to swallow after spending the game in rustic villages and decrepit buildings. Thanks for watching and subbing.

[@Knightess]

Why do you keep calling him Jonathan?

[@satanicdude]

Good stuff !

[@jorgyputraverdana2962]

From the very beginning of the scene, Sebastian is already in Ruvik's brain and the only "real" world scene is in the ending of the game where Sebastian saw Leslie walking out of the hospital area. So pretty much that can spare several sins or maybe all of it, considering the logic in imagination doesn't apply in real world.

[@baphydevil3830]

so this entire game could jsut be a long hallway and its acceptable?

[@winterknight5923]

Discount Markiplier!!!! 😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆

[@toaLewanuva]

there's one thing that bothers me about one of your "sins": when you said about the scene where Sebastian goes into a lot of blood, shouldn't you have said hemophobiacs (or however it's pronounced) instead of hemophiliac? Because -philic means you like or love something, while -phobic means you fear that thing.

[@Dartigan]

Hemophiliac mean someone who suffers from hemophilia. It's not the same as the other categories of philiacs which are sexual fetishes.

[@Darksky01]

Am I the only one who noticed that Sebastian fell into a pool of blood with an open wound which could lead to serious infection and there Is no possible way it's all the same blood type just pointing it out

[@SpearM3064]

+FaeSky Actually, you *can* receive a blood transfusion from someone who has a different blood type... BUT ONLY ONCE. After that, you'll have an immune response to it. (The exception, of course, being people with type O negative, who are universal donors, and people with type AB+ blood, who are universal recipients.) Though you make a very good point about infection.

[@Bloodhurl67]

Well you do know that he is hooked up to a stem it didnt matter at all

[@Darksky01]

Taylor Sparks I understand that but If he's in a stem where he can die why is that not a thing?

[@Bloodhurl67]

Tbh i have no clue.

[@barbracain6270]

I love this channel

[@PHDand30]

AFTERMARKET SINS! GAME JOURNALISM & REVIEW EDITION! 1. Dartigan , did....did you just steal a joke form Markiplier? 2. People were expecting this to function with the scare factor like Outlast or Slender, these reviewers glazed over the fact that this is a love letter to RE4. 3. Journalists and Reviewers are still using the term "survival"-horror, not action-horror. I assume by that logic, Mario wanting to not die in the mushroom kingdom makes his games "survival-platform". 4. Reviewers treat this game like Marmite. They think its gods gift or hate it like its the sequel to Ride to Hell. Not really any grounded reviews, so good luck getting informed properly folks! 5. How do so many people miss the "its all in your head" plot to this game? or that Joseph is a figment of your imagination? The game is about a vague as it is obvious at many points. 6. Apparently in the day and age of P.T. and 5 Nights at Freddy's, we can have a game with horror themes anymore. It MUST have a shit ton of jump scares and slow paddind build-up of tension as well. 7. Many are complaining about movie visuals in games, especially with letter-box. Yet will turn around and bitch up a flame war the moment these are gone saying the "graphics aren't as good anymore". Can't eat cake nor even have it in the same fucking room.

[@Dartigan]

Hey PHD. Good to see you in the comments again. I don't watch Mark so I don't know which joke are you referring to? I assume the one where I compare them visually. If Mark played the game I would assume he saw the same thing that I did there. Kind of hard to miss.

[@PHDand30]

Yeah the "discount mark" joke form the intro scene. He made a similar joke. I thought the same thing when i got my copy as well. Yeah I haven't had a moment to myself in weeks, working a haunt theme park in Las Vegas so October has been slammed for me. I'll try to keep up on your videos, very entertained by them your doing an awesome job.

[@grundlewizard1775]

You should really consider partnering with Cinema Sins as a spin off channel so it's out there and official.

[@Dartigan]

Trust me, I have considered that a whole lot. The problem is Cinema Sins themselves has to consider that. I have no say in that matter. I've sent them tweets of my work so I'm sure they are aware. I'm not going to go begging them though. If they ever want to I would be happy to join up.

[@grundlewizard1775]

Dartigan Clearly. But yeah games are a large market that are tailor made for their review format so it's definitely an addition they should consider. Especially given that, according to the related videos sidebar, there sure are a lot of people who agree.

[@MrEvldreamr]

i agree with about 40 of these sins bc kidmans DLC explains about half of these, which includes the repetition of certain areas and objects, why ruvik wont kill them outright, leslies importance, sebastians past and why thats important, how ruvik killed those cops in the "real world", and a whole slew of other things you mentioned like "wtf is going on?". However the DLC also opens up a slew of new questions like... who is the agency kidman works for? What is ruviks plan now that he escaped from stem? etc etc The rest im pretty sure was explained in the original game, you just didnt bother paying attention.

[@LordRaven256]

The reason there is static on the radio and the streets are empty during the intro scene is that all characters are already inside the "simulation".

[@dt05]

also, 1 sin for the doctor looking exactly like krieger from archer.

[@TheRiisingSun]

Is this a sister channel to the original Sins? I know it says "inspired by Cinema Sins" but simply taking every single bit of what makes Cinema Sins Cinema Sins isn't "inspired by", it's more like "stolen from". I'm just curious as to why you didn't come up with your own creative way of counting "sins". It could've been any other negative word worth counting horrible ideas in games with.

[@Dartigan]

Unfortunately no. I have no relation to Cinema Sins. As to why I used Cinema Sins format it's a simple matter of it being effective and straight to the point. Put simple: it works and it sort of fits how I like to give information to other.

[@soulinterpol]

Dartigan But you couldn't have found a way to do that without whole-handedly stealing? I mean, you could say what you wanted in smart, original way right?

[@PopularNobody]

No, cinema sins knows nothing of this channel.

[@Dartigan]

I'm sorry you feel that way. If only I had the boobs of a Reply Girl, then I would be going places.

[@Dartigan]

I've sent tweets

[@poisonedappleforyou]

Great video, man! This actually came off like an actual sister channel! Some people complained about the "Discount Markiplier" joke being obscure, which I don't understand because Markiploer is one of the most popular KZbin gamers, and, fun fact, Markiplier himself said that Joseph looked like him in his play through! Nice vid, bro.

[@User_1767]

When The High Pitch Sounds Is Heard In The Car At The Beginning They Are Already Inside The STEM, The DLC Explains It

[@mswishwashstoning8450]

Can someone explain discount markiplier for me please??

[@Dartigan]

That character looks very similar to a popular Let's Player on youtube.

[@mswishwashstoning8450]

Dartigan In what way haha

[@Dragon-ku7dt]

MswishWash stoning His face looks like him.

[@anonymouswriter5]

Dragon 122 The face, the Asian-ness, the glasses, the hair, the body type. Just about everything but voice. XD Mark himself spent the entire game calling him his double.

[@jier_null9071]

anonymouswriter5 Jojo lol

[@lucasasullivan]

I want very much to like this channel, but... this isn't right. The concept of sinning a game in and of itself is fine, but blatantly ripping off CinemaSins audio and visual style isn't cool. There are better ways to do this than by taking someone else's creativity and passing it off as your own. And it's a bummer because the parts of this that were authentically original are very good. I just wish you'd change the style up and make it your own.

[@kensley94]

+Lucas Sullivan cinemasins are a group of seperated people with own channels lawl

[@datdamnmegabusta5604]

...Really?...Seriously!?

[@lucasasullivan]

kensley94 not really. CinemaSins folks might have individual channels, but they work together on creating CinemaSins and their other sins channels (Music and Brand sins) are also "official" CinemaSins channels.

[@kensley94]

Lucas Sullivan thats what i said 'a group' of seperated people with own channels. dont be that guy ';) you already made an error by saying its a rip-off

[@lucasasullivan]

It is a rip-off though. The CinemasSins team aren't doing it separately they're doing it together. They might have a lot of people working for them, but they still have a business. Sins Media is the name of the company that operates the CinemaSins channels. That's why at the bottom of their website it says "Sins Media All Rights Reserved."

[@oggaming7362]

4:16 You get 1 sin for saying hemophiliacs when you should have said "someone suffering from haemophobia"

[@dah3071]

the officer said id'a waited like I would have waited not I waited, subtitles are a handy tool my freind

[@SiavashPoorshafagh]

This game bored me to death :|. Fanboys gonna attack now :))

[@propheci]

Siavash Poorshafagh eh, it's not so bad. the production value is admittedly low, but I liked the creepy vibe.

[@nothanks1239]

Siavash Poorshafagh I liked this game. I'd have attempted to platinum it if the trophies hadn't glitched XD it is badly written. I think I completed it a couple of times before I finally understood what was going on.

[@kujalakalle8531]

WOAH.

[@propheci]

the dlc and patch make it a bit more bearable...

[@qclass64439]

Never seen a school bus with that seating arrangement? Come to my city.

[@Slyzr332]

you forgot to sin the fact that sebastian fell into several pools of blood simultaneously but his white police uniform has no traces of blood at ALL and the convienant rocket happens to have more than that 1 bullet loaded into it

[@DrakojanOne]

I have another two sins for this game. After you escape the meat grinder death trap room, your character with his still injured leg falls into a pit filled with blood, guts, and dismembered body parts, then he dives into a sewer... yeah, that leg is SO infected.

[@wesleyvalk9129]

Not really, as it isn't the real world.

[@wh3nderson95]

The RPG joke really got me. I would have asked for this Inside Out gun from Machete.

[@masterfulmoonlighter5402]

Yo you better do the second one when it gets here!

[@Simonsavvi]

I know this is 8 years too late but theyare called chainsaws not because they can break chains, but because they use a chain, like motorbikes.

[@daruddock]

I agree that just because it's some sort of dream world that you can get away with some of the questionable plot 'devices' you mentioned, but it's very clear from the ending that the entire game took place inside the STEM, which answers why Ruvik could do all that stuff in the 'real world'.

[@paige2773]

0:33 discount Castiel (front passenger seat)

[@C6evolution2008]

I was so excited for this when it came out because Shinji Mikami was behind it. I was so excited throughout the entire game. Until the very end. Really killed it for me.

[@siriusa4905]

Half the sins in this are explained quite clearly! Ruvik could manifest outside the machine but not outside the asylum therefore he was looking for hosts to use so he can leave! Also, she didnt shoot you in the head, she shot Ruvik behind him.

[@siriusa4905]

TopOdyssey Also, the ending sequence was in Sebastians mind. Ruvik already left through Leslie and Seb was just creating a world due to him controlling it. How can he amazingly land on a car with a machine gun or how can a missile launcher land right beside him? Finally, how can it only take one shot to kill him? He created a satisfying end to it with him killing him like that...

[@matthewsagliocco4458]

Since the ending basically says that it wasn't real, Sebastian surviving many of the impossible to survive events makes sense.

[@seiban8455]

I fucking love this channel and i don't care how many other people call it a blatant copy of cinema sins. you gave credit to them.

[@derkurier2710]

He has the semi pistol at the end because that is what he used if Bethasda dident change it

[@EmpressWolf]

I don't know about you man, but damn those wheelchairs were scary. I mean, they went the extra mile and put four more in there! Unbelievable!

[@taylorbriggs6741]

1:35 But it's not a mansion; it's an insane asylum.