Game Theory: Rosalina UNMASKED pt. 2 (Super Mario Galaxy)

MISSED PART 1? ►► bit.ly/Zg1DgQ
Was Mario 3 staged? ►► bit.ly/YADYaY
So based on genetics and in-game lore, it seems like Rosalina's parents MAY be Peach and Mario. But Rosalina's mother is dead, and Peach doesn't seem to be. Not to mention Rosalina and Peach look to be the exact same age. So what's the deal? Are they actually related? The answer is YES. Super Mario Galaxy explains how...even if it is a little difficult to decipher.
Tweet me ► / matpatgt
F'book me ► / gametheorists
Check out some more of our awesome video game content:
Game Theory: bit.ly/1zz3t7E
Culture Shock: bit.ly/1sw7aZ8
Digressing and Sidequesting: bit.ly/1rxBUgz
Crossover: bit.ly/1t9AclA

[@gbadspcps2]

You know who's also left handed? Link You know who's also blonde? Link You know who's also got a telescope? Link. (Wind Waker and Majora's mask) You know who's also Green? Link.

[@darrenmacqueen9884]

No mustache though. Damn, so close!

[@meganice52]

Darren MacQueen Who says he can't grow one when he's older?

[@SilentForceX]

MelodyStyx OoT says. He grew 7 years in the timeskip and doesn't have a single whisker of a beard or moustache.

[@meganice52]

***** He's still very young in OoT (maybe twenty, at the most).

[@SilentForceX]

MelodyStyx Guys start growing facial hair when they hit puberty at like 13. A guy not having a single whisker by the age of 20 or hell, even 18 is nuts.

[@justsomerandomartist3897]

Him, 4 years ago: *Realizes that Luigi could be the father* Peach in Super Mario Odyssey: *rejects both Bowser and Mario* Me: HmMmMmMmMmMm

[@rihannacarey7727]

Ohh

[@DarlingRose1]

Oh

[@xx_kayla_xx7079]

Oh

[@KAZUN0s]

*O H*

[@boxman7044]

ITSA LUIGI TIME ;D

[@mrchimpinski1411]

Checkpoint for those who are here after the goodbye video

[@YunciiOffical]

Me

[@JC_Cali]

Do I get booklet stamped here or...?

[@Forbillion]

Same

[@Eye_of_Cthulhu]

a little late but still here

[@azeeata]

@@Eye_of_Cthulhusame😅

[@chsbob9]

Not gonna lie, even 8 years later, still probably one of my favorite theories (including pt 1) to this day. Have re-watched it many times

[@LycanLink]

Nice to know I'm not the only one still rewatching this classic. 👍

[@Krazy4Becky]

Same

[@THEKILLERMUSHROOM1]

Same !!!!!!

[@alexgreer6336]

I can debunk it with 1 thing, it says "at one point" meaning not anymore

[@blakebrannan9889]

Same here

[@persephonereverie8937]

"Luigi without a mustache isn't real. He can't hurt you." Luigi without a mustache: "I'm the father."

[@isabelleborja1066]

Please don't

[@gratefulxandria1366]

I-

[@etps4444]

😂

[@cannoxgd7391]

I read this before watching the whole video... Mental note: Don't read the comments before watching the whole video

[@shadowthekitten9269]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@douglastaylor4562]

These guys need to be lawyers. They'd dance circles around any crime.

[@7andr0meda73]

Ikr they would be such good lawyers

[@thegirlgamer8639]

yes they should be

[@johnnywu7612]

But the thing is they take days ,weeks and months to make 1 episode when during court u have only a couple days or weeks

[@dannymcneela364]

+Unknown Person That's cuz they're doing things like photoshopping and editing which is obviously not required.

[@bruh-tu1sr]

+Road-Kill Catz - Cat and the scripts too

[@amandastinnett8084]

Alternative theory: Princess peach actually had a twin sister who fell in love with Luigi and had Rosalina. It would explain why her mother looks like peach but wears different clothing, why she would have lived in the castle, why Mario's the one constantly saving Peach and not Luigi (and why there isn't any weird issues between the two there) and could potentially explain why Luigi ends up with a HAUNTED mansion

[@violetrose674]

I think Peach wearing blue in the future would be a sign of maturity and regality

[@lilyung3203]

I believe in this theory a lot, GG

[@SparklyTwinkleT0es]

But she’s also the only royalty in the mushroom kingdom and the dress color doesn’t matter because doesn’t it say that the kingdoms get rebirthed

[@A3N.A2B]

could the castle also be daisy's because she has all of the features ticked off -has the same ears as peach -has the same hair -is a princess meaning she could have the same castle -the mother in the book has orange hair like daisy -her ear ring match to because daisy's ear ring is blue (with petals on the side) and the mother also had a blue ear ring

[@SparklyTwinkleT0es]

@@A3N.A2B doubt it because the descriptions of the castle are peaches castle not daisys castle plus she might not have blonde hair gene

[@kolbeinnheiaroskarsson2000]

It's so wierd to hear this intro 8 years later the nostalgia is infinite

[@LycanLink]

Nice to know I'm not the only one still rewatching this classic. 👍

[@emmamoffat-_-]

He'a retiring now so I came back to watch and weep.

[@nonstickpansexual]

Please don’t show me Luigi without a mustache ever again.

[@craftbrothers8754]

Plz don’t

[@vdubden10]

It makes Luigi look like a teen...

[@ashleysears8154]

Put that thing back where it came from or so help meeeeeee

[@basiek9685]

L U I S

[@ThisaintAnni]

It's very wierd

[@rosesareredvioletsblue5438]

Theory: The reason why that text wasn't in the English version was because Nintendo knew MatPat was going to make a theory about this, and they tried to avoid it and just add it in the French version so he wouldn't find it. Except it didn't work

[@ChadetteIsDead]

So true!

[@ryah6248]

Valid

[@pavelwali5208]

Not true

[@theonethatlovescartoons3196]

Yup that is true 😂😂

[@gigikju9934]

But hey, that’s just a theory *a NiNtEndO tHeoRy*

[@BarbieFlesh6928]

You know at this point I'm pretty certain that every Mario character has connected earlobes

[@lializofficial]

my first ever theory almost 10 years ago. i love this theory. thank you, matpat, for a decade of love and entertainment. you’re an incredible guy with great ideas. we’ll all miss you🤍

[@RavenLikesCheese]

I was like, in the first part "What about Luigi? He seems more like the father" then the end "I WAS FLIPPING RIGHT, YES!"

[@minaminastheanimationfan7909]

Angry Mario Noises

[@afellowpotato]

Here before this comment blows up

[@CeramicSunflower]

*Angry spoiler noises*

[@aceofspades8169]

And it can also exist without breaking the original thought of peach and Mario. Since the galaxy recycles, in that version where Rosalina is born he father would be Luigi.

[@maxrichards3881]

@@aceofspades8169 This exactly! And that might also be the cycle where Mario rescues Daisy, and the two of them end up together.

[@nikki8237]

doctor: Mario you are not the father Mario:ಠ_ಠ doctor:its Luigi Mario:NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[@naga5707]

raven gaming YT BUM BUM BUM

[@sargentobertram5555]

Jerry jerry jerry

[@pinkietrigger7468]

Sora Haruka Lol

[@clau9689]

Lol 😂

[@copcnofficialchannel5424]

Sora Haruka I bet Mario went to Dr.Phil

[@mtvgamer2479]

7 years and he sound the same, like literally the same, this man is immortal.

[@frosted_glaceon5513]

this is still honestly one of his best theories.

[@maxiboy8217]

In art, Luigi strokes his mustache. Mario NEVER DOES!

[@trapattack9661]

Luigi is the true adult

[@lmited880]

By that standard waluigi could be the father, he strokes his mustache, and he's taller than Luigi and Mario. Wait...

[@boingus5922]

@@trishoxley1123 like sans and papyrus

[@Ahayrksv123]

2r2rik .... NANI!?

[@moochistoochi7621]

My brain isn’t strong enough to keep all of this in mind.. This makes me kinda Shookeeh

[@jovanvita2010]

Luigi: Mario never told you what happened to your father Rosalina: he told me enough, he told me you killed him Luigi: NO I am your father Super mario theme plays

[@Plutoless]

Star wars refrences

[@foxeon6496]

Obviously

[@microwave8931]

I imagine she's in shock, and then the ground theme plays

[@KevinPlayzReal]

The mario theme really increase the dramatic effect

[@mahtpav6389]

F you for the edit. F you.

[@mochajocabed8303]

Can you imagine if this happens in the Mario sequel movies ?!! Matpat called it a decade earlier

[@MT-br6fz]

6 years and I still enjoy this vid , I loved it in my childhood and I enjoy the content so much

[@TrailerDrake]

So Luigi, fed up with living in his brother's shadow, goes out, steals his brother's girlfriend, and knocks her up?! Luigi, you dirty dog!

[@obiehn276]

Not necessarily stole her lol, she might just not have liked Mario. But you should know that more than anyone lol

[@MinecraftSheepGod]

lol but luigi was always better!!!!!!!

[@thatpokerking]

i know right damm

[@alexmansfield3268]

wait what about daisy?

[@iDoom9]

no man you've got it wrong, luigi likes to be in the shadows. Thats where he gets his work done in secret.

[@1B1ueyedwo1f]

The fact that Luigi is Rosalina's father could couple well with the fact that Mario is a sociopath. Peach starts dating Mario. At first they're happy, but then Peach starts seeing Mario as he truly is: a controlling sociopath. Peach starts seeking an escape and eventually find comfort in the arms of Mario's kinder brother, Luigi. Peach decides to leave Mario for Luigi, but Mario, with his mind and ego wired the way it is, can't handle the rejection. He views his brother as a monster who "kidnapped" his love and thinks that it's his duty to "rescue" her. In his mind he always finds that "his princess is in another castle". In reality, he is a crazy stalker and Peach and Luigi are just having to constantly move to get away from him. Okay, I might've gone a little bit overboard.

[@l1minal02]

lol that sounds like a plot to a fan fiction or something

[@kaja3780]

That will be true in at least one galaxy reset later

[@violetrose674]

Will Leigh Thanks a lot, now I wanna make that a fanfiction

[@abartey1441]

Will Leigh That is actually a really good theory in itself. How do you come up with this!?!

[@dkrbdenoch]

Yes you did

[@slay-sister]

He failed miserably at speaking french- Me: laughs in fReNcH

[@rastas4766]

This still gives me chills.

[@gayfish9238]

I’M SORRY BUT DID YOU JUST PROVE TIME TRAVEL FOR A MARIO GAME!?

[@witheredbonnie9268]

Yes. But partners in time was the first one to do it

[@INeedsMeANap]

Yes, Yes He Did..

[@dixilfrancis7711]

But now I can show this vid to my teachers and prove dem wrong

[@Pfpcheck]

Shhhhh yes my child yes it happened shhhh

[@ch_4665]

I guess so

[@kindapeed]

WAIT MATPAT SHE SAID that every cycle is different maybe the one that rosilina was born in had luigi and peach together It doesnt mean every cycle luigi ends up with peach Maybe every other cycle mario is with peach

[@zerocrashmurilo]

or maybe... peach is actually... whit sonic

[@user-qy5fi9uf7j]

ItsDan wow...

[@makes58]

But peach just rejected Mario in Odyssey

[@HGmolotov]

@@makes58 different cycles bby My birdo x king boo fanfic is technically canon now

[@justsomechairwithoutamusta8275]

ItsDan okay you have the learn with change its is possible for every other one for Mario to end up with peach but every single one is different it would be a complete well not really there would be millions of alternative realities each with a slight change for instance in one Luigi might only find one coin is his mansion in another two and so on no one really knows how many there are

[@blankjester8126]

Day Two, so many classics rewatching after all these years, I still highly enjoy a lot of the ones I watched today, some outdated, some too accurate to today, might rerewatch a few from this batch, can't wait for Day Three for the start of the FNAF era. Personal favorites were definitely the Companion Cube, Rosalina Two Parter, and the Majora Mask's Two Parter. I know not a lot would read or care but this is more for me, it makes me happy.

[@michelleelliott9746]

This was the first game theory i ever watched and even though i know matpat is leaving i will never forget him or this video so all i have left to is sayonara matpat

[@angelchan6398]

I used to think Rosalina and Peach were sisters but after this I yeeted them being sisters out the window

[@justsomechairwithoutamusta8275]

why do i exist YEET IT

[@Hunter87788]

It's just his theory but it's up to you to decide

[@think_of_a_storyboard3635]

I mean the sister theory could work with their genetics being similar

[@luv_strawberriez]

Lol and me too

[@PeachyCatty]

Ok, but Nintedno literally said that they aren't related at all. Lol

[@tristandunn9954]

*Luigi and Peach...* Childhood ruined.

[@jaydreamie5413]

Online winner ! I didn't know you watched game theory!

[@jaydreamie5413]

***** I love all his theories! I don't care if they have flaws, they're all awesome! Yeah, his COD theory was cool! The first one I watched was his TF2 Pyro theory

[@jaydreamie5413]

***** I saw that one cuz I was bored and searched up TF2 Pyro ( cuz Pyro is my fav class) Yeah , it's a really funny one. I was really disappointed it wasn't a girl tho cuz I always play that one, and , being a girl, it would be amazing if it was a girl class I was always playing.

[@mastermarkus5307]

Childhood _improved_.

[@john5.joe5.48]

Mario has chemistry with Peach, but Luigi does not have chemistry with Peach, but Luigi does have chemistry with Daisy, So take that.

[@projekttaku1]

so basically... Super mario galazy pulled a pucci made in heaven and rebirthed the whole universe with everything being slightly different and only one character remembering the old universe

[@necrozma4029]

"Oh, say it again, MatPat!" "(the entire Rosalina lore in French)"

[@TuffleG]

I get the ref

[@necrozma4029]

@@TuffleG nice

[@Bathykolpian_goddess]

I wonder if Nintendo is watching this and laughing

[@lavinia115]

Same lmao

[@alistiayoung7329]

@@lavinia115 No Nintendo would be like F*** you to the creator of this video for busting the biggest secret of all time!

[@lavinia115]

@@alistiayoung7329 They should actually be happy that someone finally discovered their secret ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[@espynews1718]

the green hat in the picture tho.. it has to be there on purpose otherwise why would it be there?

[@valk6138]

Wolf Plays or saying HA HE GOT IT WRONG HA HA HA HA I don’t know if he did...

[@TheLonelyGoomba]

I'm surprised you didnt mention the ending to Mario Galaxy 2. Rosalina says "There is a force that binds us, defying even time and space...not even the laws of the universe can stop it" The game then shows Peach stood on her own as Rosalina says "It is the desire to be reunited with someone who is important to you, that pull is what brought us together. We have come through so much to meet again. This is not some mere whim of the stars, I am sure of that" Now take that into the context she is talking about Peach being her mother from another time.

[@abcdefg98765]

Oh wow are you the real lonelygoomba? Im too lazy to check :P

[@TheLonelyGoomba]

aydin200084 yes, I'm not famous enough to have imposters yet lol

[@OnlyAMan]

***** Weren't you in smash run as an enemy?

[@Tawrus_]

aydin200084 Well when you hover over his name it says he has 999+ subscribers so i do believe he/she is

[@emilthedigger472]

***** My my Iove your videos my friend

[@kaplantynsky7264]

Goodbye mat thank you so much for everything you’ve done

[@RC-1840]

I've spent years making sure Mario and Peach end up together, and you're telling me that it was all for NOTHING!!

[@josephpentony4804]

Rosalina could also somehow be immortal, which explains how she has knowledge of how the timelines work.

[@madelaine1702]

Agreed

[@teruyafine]

Or maybe she’s just sans lmao

[@piccafrickinchooo271]

There literally all immortal

[@teruyafine]

@@piccafrickinchooo271 Ikr

[@brodenm2024]

“Rosalinas brother has a green hat” Wait.... so that means... no... it couldn’t be......... Mario is luigis father..... *sweet home alabama intensifies*

[@capt.bellamy]

This us perfect Edit sorry i sound as inbred as mario mario and luigi mario

[@EndOfAHoldiay]

Sweet home alabamaaaaaaaaaaaaa

[@nomorejellybeanflower6659]

oof 😂

[@user-kn3ss4ps1s]

O.O

[@gothic_ace2037]

XD omg

[@MrPug1162]

Who’s here after he announced he’s retiring :(

[@JAPANESE_MAPLE]

i was revisiting every game thoery and man i remember this one so vivid

[@slightlypsycho9346]

I don't think Einstein planned on you using time travel to figure out a video game.... but I think he respects it.

[@hahagoatfunny1477]

XD

[@audbugaudbug3527]

Slightly Psychotic I fear that our society will turn into a generation of idiots, wow. Einstein was not having his day.

[@outkast58]

it already is.

[@emojihearts7328]

Slightly Psychotic yep to his dead body and his eyes in a New York City's bank

[@riaanduplessis1413]

You revealing Nintendo's secrets have secured your name on top of their hitlist.

[@thatguy8122]

This is still enjoyable 6 years later

[@aldwhynsnumber1452]

LOL YEAH!!! I was thinking about this last night and was like Welp. Gonna watch that one again.

[@Tmitric]

It's hard to beleve he quit. Wow, life goes fast, huh?

[@shreyas4907]

Me rewatching the first episode i saw from matpat on the day he retired I saw this episode when it was out for 2 weeks 9 years ago

[@lhsbandfreak11]

Something that just came to mind watching this: When you do the final Bowser level as Luigi, compare how Rosalina says "Go Luigi!" compared to "Go Mario!" The difference in enthusiasm definitely is another subtle support of the theory that Luigi is her dad. On a happier note, as tragic as Rosalina's story is, the end of Super Mario Galaxy 2 when you beat Bowser for the last time is so satisfying since not only does she get reunited with her Luma...SHE GETS TO SEE HER MOM AFTER MARIO RESCUED HER!!!

[@curlycat_studios]

Wow, that's just.... lOvElY

[@infamouse9263]

It also kinda sounds like they don’t care for Mario but when they say Luigi they do sound excited I agree

[@lordofthunder4065]

Oh, good. Someone else noticed the "Go Luigi" v.s. "Go Mario" difference. I tried to tell my family about it, but they didn't believe me. They just thought I was misremembering. I had to play through the game again as both mario and luigi and record both before they would believe me. Nice to know I'm not alone.

[@apocalypseofplush]

*but her brother will never exist ever again*

[@apocalypseofplush]

Yeah, she’s so sassy when saying “Go, Mario” but with Luigi she isn’t.

[@Bowling4986]

Maury: Mario, in the case of Rosalina... YOU ARE NOT THE FATHER! Luigi: *writes in his diary* FINALLY I'M-A NO LONGER IN YOUR SHADE! Mario: MAMA F**KER, NOW I GET DAISY!!!

[@cordeliajackson8615]

Daisy: oh H E L L no

[@artisticbloomingrose1780]

Why does this comment have less likes? xD

[@puppetandbrocken8278]

Lol this deserves more likes 😂😂😂!

[@pigtoast43]

*Mario has left the chat*

[@johncadena4684]

Why do some think Luigi is the father?

[@Way2windy4u]

Rewatching this

[@Sans_Official.]

The first 16 seconds are pure gold

[@crincheddar7028]

Me: Mom, can we have a Luigi? Mom: No, we have a Luigi at home. Luigi at home: 6:36

[@friskdreemuur7006]

5 likes? More like 5 Quadrillion likes!!! (It was four and then I made it 5)

[@randomppl6380]

someone telll me how to link the super crown/bee queen video to this (ded peach) SO TOADS CREATE THE PLOT AND KILLED PEACH AND TOADETTE BECOME PRINCESS

[@bardwitch]

Hahahaha

[@mattrachnid]

*luis*

[@craftbrothers8754]

LOL LOLOLOL

[@DonutToast]

Ahahahhahahahahha omfg mario tries so hard to get peach and she's just like " neh bitch I'm going with da green guy " I can't i am officially dead

[@boatea106]

rachel van capelleveen xD

[@kateenthusiast9340]

rachel van capelleveen Luigi be likeJust datin your girlPeach be likeNeh im gonna go wit hhis brother

[@twilightfan-ys7me]

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

[@A1varoRubio2004]

Then screw her I guess

[@DerNiko]

rachel van capelleveen green is the much cooler color anways

[@OKN163]

This kind of connects with Mario odyssey when peach rejects Mario and bowser maybe it connects with the whole Luigi being Rosalina’s dad thing.

[@Tolinar]

Your best work to date

[@KingOreo2017]

i love it how he talks about his french teacher watching him screw up french but then right after says it in a "sexy" accent

[@Yourfavtogo-gurllala]

Peach dead???

[@KingOreo2017]

@@Yourfavtogo-gurllala what

[@-.starfilled_galaxy.-]

#PUNCTUATION

[@Loveof_MMA]

Hey Mattpat remember mister L when Luigi was hypnotized he confesses his love for peach and giving that Rosalina is tall connected ears blue eyes that makes it even more of a possibility that he is Rosalina’s dad

[@drxtreme7779]

True

[@SmallFriesLol]

u son of a gun noo my childhood memories shattered

[@Dragonlady141]

I love going back to these Mario theories, but Matt this is making me crave another Mario stream! Would it be possible to request a Mario RPG stream or a Mario Galaxy stream? 🥰

[@aaronacosta5765]

Mat I like visiting your old Theory’s when I know you will be gone soon😢💔

[@GCHEP]

7:46 wait... so that means... if I travel at the speed of light... My Nintendo switch battery will never die

[@JKozlovable]

You would need to stay still while the switch travels at the speed of light, meaning that you would have to touch it right at every instant that it passes through your hands... Which makes me wonder... would einsteins theory still apply for objects vibrating at the speed of light?

[@SirenOfStyxx]

Graeme Hepoenstall omg thats great😂😋😂

[@oscarhuete6701]

Jonathan Reyes knowledge 😂

[@eventseen7317]

for everyone else (not traveling at the speed of light) the battery would last incredibly long. But since you cant play with it without also traveling at the speed of light it would last as long for you as it would with normal speed !!! 1ll00m1n4T1 cuntirm3d !!!

[@brandonmassey9746]

Robert Joyce s

[@dirtbillionaire7555]

You know my childhood has been destroyed, my life is now one confusing wreck but you know what... Its so worth it! These videos are so fun to watch and now I can go to my mum and give her a heart attack showing her face time. Oh and telling her about peach, luigi and roselina. But in all seriousness thank you MatPat for giving us game theory. It brings joy to us all and we love what you do. Thank you!

[@luluferri5527]

Dirt Billionaire so true thanks matpat

[@itzjasp4401]

Dirt Billionaire well said comment

[@kittylynn8487]

dirt!!!

[@nancyceballos36]

Dirt Billionaire .

[@desireanddecay3583]

YEZ

[@TheOneWhoKnocc]

Would love a new TF2 theory, more based around any lore that could be found and isn’t already solved

[@VictoriaMcIntyre694]

omg the intro 0:04 *dies of laughter*🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@bytz4742]

Has it really been six years since this came out dang

[@desv1red]

oof i watched this like 3 yrs ago-

[@user-ti6us2br4x]

Yep

[@nomorejellybeanflower6659]

oof

[@mommymilkers6302]

I remember as a kid I was afraid to watch it because of the thumbnail but wow 6 years...

[@donnyshields4450]

7 now

[@lovellrockyspeechanddebate6055]

Well, Luigi and Peach could have gotten together in another timeline and had Rosalina. I personally think that that makes sense, because well, MatPat himself said that there were multiple timelines, so there could and possibly are alternate timelines. Ones where PeachxLuigi are a, Mario and Daisy, and all the others. The thought of multiple timelines with different outcomes combined with the thought of alternate realities, gender-benders, and everything else just ties together for me. If it doesn't for you, then that's fine. It's just what I think.

[@lovellrockyspeechanddebate6055]

*PeachxLuigi are a thing

[@ClaytonBTyler]

I was thinking the same thing xD

[@jacksongreen4107]

Aaaand...cue fanfiction!

[@noahwood2620]

IF YOU SHIP MARIO WITH SOMEONE THAT'S NOT PEACH, YOU'RE NOT A REAL MARIO FAN

[@jacksongreen4107]

Noah Wood ...dude. That was totally uncalled for. You can be a fan of a franchise regardless of who you ship.

[@SmallFriesLol]

my childhood memories shattered destroyed why must you do this matpat whyyyyyyy

[@augustoherrera3126]

"Your special one" Butcher:" they are f*cking" The female:"*nods in agreement*"

[@UltraVast]

Here's a thought. What if the reality Rosalina was originally from didn't have the Mario BROTHERS (emphasis on brothers) but still had Mario and Luigi, and that the woman that became Rosalina's mother wasn't Peach, but Daisy. Daisy has blue eyes, attached ear lobes and can use both hands. "But what about the hair?!" You ask, blond is a recessive gene so the possibility for them to have blond haired children is there. "But in the book, her mother was visualized to have belong hair!" Actually the picture uses shades of brown, not yellow. "The book has Rosalina's mother in a blue dress." Well that was ignored in both videos so fashion isn't really a factor here, or at least a factor big enough to count. So maybe Miyamoto didn't said to keep the reference that Rosalina and Peach being related because they actually are not. Maybe Rosalina is related to Daisy. And understanding genetic science started using peas, and then other plants, like flowers. Daisy. Rose. Well, that's just a theory. A comment theory. Thanks for reading.

[@UltraVast]

Sorry if the beginning confused any (probably most) of you. I thoughts started off on something different before coming to the conclusion of the princess that our dear head theorist forgot. (For whatever reason.)

[@zamissocool]

mind blown

[@GaryKertopermono]

Wait. You strike a point. Maybe... Rosalina's mother... IS ROSALINA ZOMG MIND BLOWN!

[@AriZonia]

That's a much more convincing argument than the one Mat put up. A+

[@Tyler-sy7jo]

Yes if blonde hair is a recessive gene, then they COULD still have it and jsut not show it, but that's assuming they have that recessive gene at all. And even then, both of them need to have that recessive gene and even THEN it's a 25% chance at best the kid get's both the recessive genes from both the parents and gets blond hair.

[@JulianTheJedi]

Who else is watching this in 2020 and the intro gave flashbacks to their childhood

[@desv1red]

omg meee

[@cybeleschannel3502]

my dad

[@emperoricy3598]

Yep

[@waimunlaiwai2668]

Im still young...

[@pat_gamez_596]

Not me I'm a child

[@gingertea3778]

It would kind of make sense with the Luigi and Peach thing. Since Luigi is often described as clumsy and the such, it would make sense he’d ask his more capable brother to save his lover/love interest for him hence why it’s always Mario who’s often the main character in the games (though you can switch to Luigi)

[@y0gafire]

lol. but luigi just as capable as mario and has better jumps too. its just his cowardly side gets the best of him... 😔

[@colehaugen6391]

Well, if time is slower for Rosalina, wouldn’t that mean Peach would be way older than Rosalina?

[@amandagardner3059]

yeah :0

[@GoThroughTheLookingGlass]

That's where the whole 'galaxy resets every 100 years' thing comes into play.

[@Criken]

Well played, Mattpat, well played.

[@matthewmcmahon2168]

indeed criken

[@Devin-ul4ho]

Oh damn what are you doing here criken

[@hatakekakashi3385]

Never thought id see you in a youtubers comment section criken. Keep making those awesome vids!

[@carlo7493]

CRIKEEN!

[@markwoods7416]

Why are you here? ah whatever I still love you, keep up those vids!

[@cwispy1812]

Luigi without a mustache makes me uncomfortable

[@yourlocalfurry4274]

IisBeCwispy • same

[@sophiacantanimate9629]

same....

[@basicallygrey]

yep same

[@suni7728]

i wonder how mmario would be without a mustache

[@evalynnesnow7312]

it makes me very uncomfortable too.

[@CreekSong.warriors]

Rewatching every video since he’s quitting… :(

[@jordanvienneau9178]

still, this (including both part 1 and 2) and your 'bowser' is adopted and isnt evil' theory are my favorites to date, and I doubt they will be beaten for a long long time!

[@Ebola_Cola]

Matpat: finds out that Peach and Luigi are married or used to be Me: so that means that... Mario isn't a womanizer?

[@alicetulia8688]

WAIT U RIGHT

[@clairegee822]

Or Peach left because he is one

[@clairegee822]

@Eileen Wang Peach figures out she is just one in a long list and gets sick of Mario's nonsense and dumps him

[@joseantonioferreiracomplet2097]

@@clairegee822 that... Might work

[@SuperMarioNinja.]

@@clairegee822 that happened in sml.

[@RakkiOfficial]

that rosalina is luigi's daughter explains also why she's saying 'you special one' about peach to Mario, because she's not approving it or something likely...

[@gayflower900]

I’d be weirded out too if I traveled to a different timeline and my mom was in a relationship with my uncle

[@siryarianthefirst3360]

Rakkī It’s cause she knows that Mario and her mom USED to be a thing and since Luigi is her dad she knows that their thing ended

[@sik3xploit]

Mario always did like keeping Luigi under his heel. Well just a bit of "right back at ya".

[@neolithiumproduction]

Makes sense. If its not Peach, saying the name would shock or confuse Mario. Best keep it vague.

[@joshhunt1724]

Rakkī I

[@alirezaghorbani-cp5gy]

it's beyond just a game theory physics. genetics. lore..... and a lot more great video❤❤❤

[@oxymore13]

Mind-blowing from start to finish... I am speechless this is just unfathomable

[@KSprites]

If this is the case, then maybe Mario killed peach in the other timeline. He didn't like the relationship between Luigi and peach, and when he found out about their daughter, that was the last straw. So he teamed up with Bowser, and together they killed peach. I mean, it works if Mario is as evil as you've theorized him to be so far.

[@aetherdestroyer2317]

Kenny Sprite This actually makes a lot of sense. 1+ for you!

[@TheICKMAN7]

I was thinking that too -_-

[@sandroanggada7714]

Mind blowed

[@UnicornFilms2001]

And then when the galaxy resets and Rosalina isn't there anymore, Mario doesn't remember Peach being with Luigi OR that Rosalina ever existed. However, Peach's death left such an impact on Luigi that he remembered and decided not to be with her right away and to let Peach come to him on his own, and in the meantime, he'd come up with a safe way to tell Mario from the beginning so he wouldn't kill her. This probably involves something like the planned kidnapping mentioned in one of The Game Theorists other videos, except this time it's Luigi, Daisy, and Tangata getting together because Daisy had been crushing on Mario from afar, much like Mario with Peach. As Mario goes through rescuing Daisy, he realizes how much finding her means and eventually starts to fall for her, etc. until he chooses her over Peach and Peach and Luigi can finally be together in peace.

[@KSprites]

*****​ yup. And I like Unicorn Films​ explanation, too

[@shadowstriker6506]

Luigi gets the girl. Childhood complete Which is kinda ironic given what channel this is

[@trapattack9661]

That an Mario is apparently a sociopath

[@boingus5922]

Mario is jealous😂

[@glycerox]

Scientists: I guess there's no way this is possible. MatPat: actually... *Aggressively opens research tab*

[@nr6916]

Scientist: we can’t seem to figure out the solution MatPat: *pulling out his laptop* give me two hours

[@PunkMarioBros]

1:04 MatPat casually foreshadowing with that Luigi head

[@theneierlings1811]

Rosalina’s actual dad is Luigi. A single dad raising her star child with Peach dead under the tree.

[@bryanjackson6306]

That can't be true because that means Daisy is her mom

[@vincentromain4340]

@@bryanjackson6306 Why would it be Daisy ? It has never been confirmed that their dating. And even if they are dating, it's a alternate universe, so some things are different

[@bryanjackson6306]

@@vincentromain4340 Daisy is dating luigi

[@vincentromain4340]

@@bryanjackson6306 Nintendo never confirmed it

[@vincentromain4340]

@@bryanjackson6306 And even if she is, it's an alternate universe. So maybe that in the universe of Rosalina's childhood, they weren't dating, and Luigi was actually dating Peach.

[@r0sy_maple_m0th]

*my six year old self always thought that luigi was dating rosalina* *if he were her dad though... oh god*

[@bruhmunson5445]

*SWEET HOME ALABAMA*

[@DeeDee-cn2qr]

I thought Luigi had a thing for Daisy

[@diamondsrubies1964]

@@bruhmunson5445 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@mako34392]

What is mario is the mother YYYYEEEEEEYYYYYEEEEEEYYYYYYEEEEEE

[@sherrybryant261]

Holy gachomoly

[@jakeetter2822]

11:46 For a counter argument. Mario and Luigi are brothers. Meaning it was reseive genes. And the telescope might be from her... Uncle.

[@XJstarX]

OH MY GOD LUIGI THAT WAS AN AMAZING TWIST AND TRUE

[@gxbinddd]

The 3 smartest people on earth: 1. Albert Einstein (RIP) 2. Stephen Hawking (RIP) 3. Matthew 'MatPat' Patrick Edit: thnx for 100 likes

[@screeps6071]

4.Elon Musk

[@ashtonrigg7976]

5.Kanye West

[@d.d8486]

6.kwite

[@takethetips6741]

7. None

[@dannyl7602]

8. The Potatoes

[@oliverqueen4317]

I'm sorry did you just say "TIME TRAVEL EXISTS" and then just go back to the Rosalina theory like nothing happened.

[@Grifftronic]

Welcome to Game Theory.

[@riyar1499]

Dont talk about witchcraft that way. Its a legit thing. Im a wiccan and actually practices Magick

[@squidis1938]

I don't think "magick" is helping you with your spellings...

[@riyar1499]

Research the difference between Magic and Magick then come back to me AHEM DONT SASS ME

[@riyar1499]

Sorry I just wanted to get that out there simply

[@the_gay_rainbow]

I just want you to know the impact you had on me I’m 20 years old I’ve watched you since I was 10 half of my life you helped me this is the second video that I ever watched you deserve to live life and I’m excited to see where this new adventure will go

[@SMZProductions]

11:33 If We’re Going By That Logic The Father Could Be Wario Or Waluigi 🥴🥴🥴

[@liamdalemon1525]

Or Toadsworth!

[@pepijn2456]

'But Wii know now better' 10:04 Nice matpat, nice

[@kadi00z32]

Heh

[@celestewoodworth5627]

Nintendo is no doubt cursing Game Theory for finding their secrets and exposing them.

[@paperplanegamer5947]

Most likely

[@toastiestbread4668]

totally

[@grahamfyfe8845]

I love your new theory so much

[@SkidTheDumbFox]

Luigi being the father might also be proven by the 'resets' of the galaxies, in the timeline in Rosalina's story he might have been with Peach but not in the current one, but her lack of enthusiasm could be explained because she still likes Luigi more than Mario she might have been with Mario in one of the timelines in the past but that's just speculation, I don't think anyone can know what happens in all the different timelines (maybe except the game creators but I can't be sure) That's the conclusion my brain came up with in under 5 seconds so it could be wrong but there's always the possibility- But that's just a theory about a theory- Thanks for reading- And yes I did reference you on your own video-

[@Fawnyiie]

OR Luigi 2 (from saving Luigi 2 when he was trapped in this weird metal cage) could be rosalina’s brother and the true Luigi being her father...

[@aka.crystal56]

👁👄👁

[@alessandracarbonari3971]

SWEET HOME ALABAMAAAA

[@ImSalimShady]

Ok I know this is late but that Luigi is Rosalina Dad. Because when you beat bowser Rosalina said everything would go back to normal but not the same way. So when the galaxies restarted itself again and again, it changed from Luigi and Peach being together to MARIO and Peach being together But Hey that’s just a THEORY A SIMPLE THEORY

[@Eduardo-lo2vs]

Eduardo Could actually be true and we have the same name but my brother change my and when I try to change it bake it says name change to recently

[@royalteaanimations]

Eduardo this deserves more likes

[@emosp1t]

Eduardo But Mario doesn't stay in the Kingdom with Peach he stays on the Starship with Rosalina

[@KeVsPIXEL]

and in addition @11:59 the pic where Rosalina is running to her father, the silhouette of the father is tall and looks like without a hat (google them without a hat Luigi & Mario pretty much have the same hair style) and Luigi is tall, taller than Mario. Then next Rosalina's brother with Luigi's hat (green hat as said in the video). Just a small detail i noticed.

[@arct1cvort3x81]

Eduardo lool

[@jackepong6300]

Shrek: You're gonna be a father. Luigi: Itsa Me. Shrek: What?

[@rowiewowie]

I need to see this fanfic

[@fireblaze3368]

If SM Galaxy is about the galaxy resetting itself with different elements, does that mean that the theory saying that every copy of Super Mario 64 is different is somehow... plausible?

[@thisgirlsings4388]

Luigi + peach Would be like Ferb + Isabella

[@skillz8000]

But it’s true

[@skillz8000]

I did research

[@yael5497]

YAAAS XD IM LAUGHING SO HARD

[@bearlover1984]

:0

[@tjk2825]

Ikr

[@FeroKaiAnimations]

They give us this great theory, and what do the comments section come up with? >Rosalina's father was a tree >Luigi is waluigi's son

[@AP-fo5cf]

HAHAHAHAHA, what are the chances of finding you here.

[@AP-fo5cf]

FeroKaiAnimations Hey. Things are ok.

[@ethantobias3336]

FeroKaiAnimations actually luigi being waluigi's son and mario being wario's son could be a thing, what with the parallell universes and all.

[@gavinlaster5909]

Roger White I better get a tardis for xmas

[@AP-fo5cf]

***** Yes, but there are more videos than people on Earth. Sure, there\s obviously some overlap with other people, but the stuff I watch is generally not the same as other people I know.

[@blakebrannan9889]

I can't believe I rewatched both part of this series because I don't remember what the theory was and now I do is I rewatch this yeah

[@holdenellington7852]

I randomly found this video in my recommended and I have to say matpat used to be way crazier than he now like wow and he still manges to make it pretty believable.