George Harrison All Things Must Pass Remix REVIEW and Splatter Vinyl

[@bryanlea8115]

I was blown away by The Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp remix. I bought the original album back in about 1975 and in all the intervening years, I'd never noticed the 'Oh Sir Frankie Crisp' buried deep and quietly in the mix. I listened to the original straight afterwards and yes, it's there, but barely noticeable. Bringing it up in the mix just adds to the surreal jollity of the track. I tend to agree that the quieter tracks are served best, I always liked the feel of the original 'Wah Wah', with everything trying to squeeze out of the speakers at the same time. I didn't feel short changed by 'My Sweet Lord', but it didn't feel to me to be sufficiently different. For me, the saddest part is that the drums still sound like they've been filled with sand on many of the tracks, but short of re-recording them, I don't know what you'd do to remedy that.

[@Ian_Jules]

Personally, I really enjoy hearing George's vocals on My Sweet Lord remixed, sincere and warm. I can definitely hear where it loses some of the majestic scope of the original, but I think an argument can be made for either mix. My other favorite is Wah-wah, especially on 5.1 blu-ray. A lot more of the O'Hara-Smith Singers audible! In general, it's going to take some getting used to hearing the album differently after all these years. It's a "don't throw away your originals" situation, but lots of fun as an alternative.

[@kylethor0]

I will always favor the Spector mixes. I find them brilliant.

[@TomMcBaum]

There's an obvious audio problem with Isn't It A Pity Version 2 at the 02:18 to 02:45 mark. The organ/flutes track goes out of sync (a full beat!) for about 25 seconds. No previous official release has this problem. This error affects all official 2020 editions of the album. They should recall the defective discs and re-release them. This would make the collectors who already own this version happy, no doubt. :-)

[@МихаилСергопольцев]

I'm thrilled how many people love George and his music. With love from Russia.

[@trublu71]

Got the 5 CD Deluxe set yesterday . And I can’t say how pleased and amazed my ears are .

[@davidtellett179]

I’m loving the demos day 1 and 2. Absolutely superb, especially disc 3 with Klaus Voorman and Ringo, fabulous stuff. Just like sitting in on the sessions. Much prefer this demo version of I Dig Love.

[@TASSOS1965]

The demo of "I Dig Love" is also my favorite from the complete new CDs!

[@paulaelizabethg]

Great review! I have such mixed feelings about about these remixes. Excited to hear My Sweet Lord, but the original is such genius, its like re painting the Mona Lisa. Its perfect already.

[@leesanna7835]

Andrew, I find it interesting you noticed a piano timing discrepancy at around 2:20 on Isn't It A Pitty version 2, for the last 50 years, I've always heard, what I think is a piano flub at 1:19, right after the line: "some things take so long", and I can't unhear it, but it's not as noticeable on the new mix, so maybe that's why it's version 2, ...great review, Andrew

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Thanks Lee, I'll have a listen for that other mistake!

[@FrankEPotts]

I hope by the time Let It Be/Get Back comes out you are able to get a chair and a desk.🥳

[@WilG082]

My splatter copy isn’t coming till tomorrow. Ive been listening to the remix on Apple Music and I think it’s fantastic

[@gbirving]

Yes my splatter not here today but hey ho I've waited 50 odd years suppose 😂🕉️

[@fwnfaa]

Listen 2 it today , dissapointed thought the remix had been more like a new mix,but no , not much, but the album itself is a masterpiece.

[@graham2189]

Just in case anyone is interested, the TOC (table of contents) on CD disc 2 has no data except, “ Track 1”, “Track 2”, “Track 3” etc. The CD 2 is the only CD of the set where this happens.

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

That's annoying!

[@brendans8648]

I enjoyed the remix, but I miss the mystical power of the original. Some songs do not benefit from the lack of reverb/echo. That being said it is a very nice package and I’m glad it has a release.

[@rupertgregory6416]

Hi Andrew- I hardly ever post comments on KZbin, I just kind of 'lurk', but really enjoy your videos & reviews. There was just something you said here & you weren't sure that people would get what you meant. It was what you said about the individual tracks often scoring higher than the original mixes, but the album as 'a whole' not matching the original. I've listened to the new mix A LOT now & I like it, but I agree with you. I think it's probably because every track has probably been worked on almost like a separate project- different EQ here- drums boosted there etc. Sorry for rambling, but in a nutshell- it now sounds like a compilation (a very good one). I'm also really glad I watched your video showing the 'super deluxe' set before I received my copy- it saved me from having a nasty shock when it arrived. Maybe it was produced with gnomes in mind? Hope that makes sense & keep up the good work :-)

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Thanks Rupert, I'm glad someone understood what I meant! 🙂👍

[@TheSchemel]

I remember when Paul McCartney started his McCartney Collection. They started around $60 and they were much more elaborate. Now they are over $100, but they are still very nice. Although, I bought the George Harrison Deluxe Box set for the music, for $143.00 I expected more. I like seeing unreleased pictures, and maybe a DVD etc. Although there is a ton of music, and I am grateful, it is way over priced. I am a huge fan of George Harrison, but I am not rich.

[@Jyw008]

Received my 5 LP Deluxe Version of ATMP from Amazon today. When I first opened it I was disappointed that all 5 vinyls were the regular black vinyls rather than the splatter vinyl.

[@iainblack8662]

I've only listened to disc 1 on splattered vinyl. And I agree with your comments. The epic tracks suffer while the quieter songs sound fab. My Sweet Lord - my heart sunk on that. It needs the epic touch - but that's been through years' of hearing the original. Like IMAX to 14 inch CRT. I've only listened to it once so it's a first impression. Then If Not For You and Behind That Locked Door are fantastic. Looking forward to listening to the rest of the tracks and watching your review.

[@Mandrake591]

The repackaging formats of ATMP circa 2021 is, in some cases, beyond ridiculous. I just want to hear about the remixes and the music itself. That, and the the unreleased tracks are of fascination to me, so thanks for focusing on the actual music. Thank you.

[@pepparchips7609]

Nice to open a beer and to listen to your feedback of this on the Friday evening! Really enjoying your videos! Still waiting for these boxes to arrive... Interesting that you say that you prefer to listen to the standard version of i.e the White Album. My view is that I have listened so many times to the original versions since the 70's. So now for probably a couple of years the remixed versions of most Beatle related records released with these boxes is what I will play.

[@johnnypocknee2842]

Hi there i got this back in 70 it was great back then

[@ephrimvael]

Overall the remix version has better sonic range, especially in the bass and drums, but sadly 'My Sweet Lord' (vocals) have been pasteurised and lost its magic. thanks for your review!

[@wingsdgm60]

Thanks Andrew .listening to mine today....ps..I love that Kate album..got the 2 boxes few years back....and kind of rediscovered it..it's awesome..

[@Falkpappa]

Good to have you back and your in depth-review didn't disappoint, thanks a lot! Perceptive (and true) view about the experience of the entirety of the album, comparing the original with the remix. And I hope your back survived the lack of chair.👍🏻

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

The knees are suffering!

[@candelise]

Musician Bobby Whitlock, who was at every session for this album and played on virtually all the songs and was given a copy, at the time of the release, back in the day, by George Harrison himself, has received a copy of this current release and he says that the mix is crap!!!! He says that it sounds like the worst thing he has ever heard and it sounds like it has been mixed by people who have never mixed anything before. I get the feeling that this has been worked on for whippersnappers used to streaming and iPhones while those who love vinyl and CDs are being short-changed. They probably spent more time on the package design! I think that I will save my money. Phil Spector did the best job, end of story!!

[@gregodonnabhain3655]

I suggest you give it a listen before relying on someone else's opinion... I love both versions and for someone to say the remix is the worst thing they have ever heard is baffling...

[@candelise]

@@gregodonnabhain3655Guess what? I've now heard it and the thoughts still stand. Now what?

[@gregodonnabhain3655]

@@candelise Then that's great... you've heard it and decided you don't like it for yourself not relying on someone else...were all different and that's what makes life interesting.... keep smiling 😉

[@candelise]

@@gregodonnabhain3655 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😁

[@hansmjakobsen6865]

Great review, thanks

[@demonsbutterfly]

Never liked the Phil Spector mix. So i love this new “clean” Mix I can hear everything, which is what i like! The Spector “Wall of Sound” was great in the early 60’s in Mono But it was a technique that was never good in Stereo The Remix is a breath of fresh air

[@CWAdventures1968]

The Apple Jams I just love..maybe it's the long track Pink Floyd in me..I could listen to out of the blue for 20 minutes!!..I love the remixes a lot..I've got the 5lp box as it dropped by £10 on Amazon..great review 👍👍

[@JohnnyAlegre]

Honestly, I bought my 5LP for the outtakes, and the fancy extras. My pre-50th copies sounded great.

[@Ad.Dd.James.]

My splatter vinyl will take weeks to get to Australia. I’m glad there’s people like you Andrew who can share their love of music with all of us while we wait…and wait….still waiting🥱

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Hopefully worth the wait for.you!

[@Ad.Dd.James.]

@@AndrewDixonMusic well after immersing myself in the digital streaming versions it’s going to be well worth it.

[@stevenjones57]

You are a top-geezer Andrew, I wasn't going to buy this release, but based on your review I've just ordered the Super Deluxe edition. Keep-On-Keeping On, my friend!

[@storytime8156]

Great video. Looking forward to listening to my 5 cd set, when it arrives.

[@westfield90]

I totally agree with your analysis

[@theStranger666]

I've heard the new remixes in Dolby Atmos and to my eardroves it sounds fantastic. I played the old mix, and after a deep fawkus, I decided this recent release is deep joy of a fun load. 🕉

[@theStranger666]

@TunesDoneByOne I haven't played the 5:1 remix yet, just the Atmos which sounds great on my system. It might be a bit of a risk to fork out a hundred quid or so, only to discover that you might not be impressed. Perhaps give it a bit of time to read some more reviews on the 5:1 remix. On Andrew's video, he claims that on one song the blu-ray sounds better than the CD. As soon as I get the house to myself again, I will give the 5:1 a good blast!

[@lewisreading47]

Down to the river on disc 5 is a Rocking Chair in Hawaii from Brainwashed but 31 years earlt

[@carljpgr]

Great video mate. I love the new mix, it sounds so much better on vinyl though. It’s like the CD is a remix and then the vinyl is an even better remix! Jumps out of the speakers! Yes the day one demos are a particular highlight. Still a little disappointed with the day two demos the way they have cut them slightly. But on the whole very pleased with it all.

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Cheers, looking forward to playing my vinyl very shortly 🙂👍

[@rossgregor4817]

Thanks Andrew for your detailed analyses.

[@mazzysmusic]

Agree that My Sweet Lord is the biggest failure of the remix. Just a majestic record has had the life sucked out. Overall I enjoy the album remix as an alternative but I prefer the original album. An album that I don’t feel really need to be remixed. This revisionist anti Spector wall of sound that some have now amuses me.

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

I can watch your review now, I'd avoided it so I didn't get swayed by any other opinions...

[@Vanderstein950]

Phil Spector more like Phil Smegma

[@MeanMrMayo]

Mazzy, George himself never liked the Spector mix. I am generally a fan of Spector's work, but some of ATMP was just TOO muddy.

[@mazzysmusic]

@@MeanMrMayo yess i’ve heard him say that thirty years after it came out. He loved it until he didn’t. He finished off the album without Spector and had the biggest Beatles solo album of 1970/71. Nobody complained about the production when the album came out. And then George loved Jeff Lynne’s production in1989 until he didn’t years later and was not a fan of the over ELO-ing. I guess our taste evolve and change. I like some of the new remixes and some I don’t. But it’s a fun alternative. But I do love all the demos and outtakes.

[@MeanMrMayo]

@@mazzysmusic Fair enough, but at least now I can decipher more of the words without needing to consult the lyrics sheet!

[@luckyjacksonsreveals2251]

I don't know, nice to have a new mix, but I am old School and miss the echo...always made me feel like George was in a cathedral or ancient cave...adds an another world feel....

[@ronmartin4212]

Nice it's on splatter,too!!!Only other Beatle splatters I know of are the original Greek lavender label Parlophone 45's,which I've had a few of!Ticket To Ride,All You Need Is Love,Lady Madonna,and I think a few others.Definitely a cool look!!!

[@petermustonen5620]

Thank you for an honest review. Now I know what to expect. A little bit nervous now because I love the original so much. But there can be no way to make these sensational songs seem minor. Propably will be an interesting listening experience bringing depth to understanding true genius of George Harrison.

[@mountart2]

Not sure I am seeing the value of comparing the Paul Hick remixed release to the original Phil Spector release. Bit like comparing apples to oranges. If you like the original, fine, knock yourselves out and don't listen to the new remix. If like me, you like the original but would love an alternate addition, this new album is fantastic. If I had to choose, I'd pick the remix release. yeah the vocals on some of the tracks are too far forward and they lose a bit of their warmth, but overall, it's like removing 50 years of dust from the original and getting a much more honest contemporary mix. Well done Paul hicks and team!

[@geraldinho4092]

The whole album doesn't have the same impact the original, especially on sweet lord and hear me lord. Awaiting on you all and let it down sounded weird, like they'd removed one instrument from the loud parts and left the rest as is, strange

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

I've enjoyed the vinyl version of My Sweet Lord tonight, so much better than on CD

[@fernandoperdomomusic]

My opinion on ATMP50 is the same as my opinion on Let It Be Naked... its a different look at a masterpiece... its never gonna replace a recording that is in your DNA...

[@jdguitarmusic]

Got my 5CD/Blu Ray box. I will say listening to the Blu Ray in Dolby Atmos is pretty amazing. I see what you’re saying about “My Sweet Lord” Andrew - but the Atmos treatment does get it closer to the power of the original. The “Wall-of-Sound” productions sound glorious on the Blu Ray. (“Wah-Wah” really sounds like a Derek & The Dominoes song in the new mix - at least the guitars). Happy ATMP Day!

[@wolfgangschafer8592]

I bought the first version of "All Things Must Pass" in 1970. Sold as a three-record album, it was strictly speaking a double album; you listened to the third record once and then never again. Musically, it was quickly clear: this was not Beatles music (with the possible exception of "Apple Scruffs). Earth-heavy bombast resounded towards us, lacking any lightness or cheerfulness. But the purchase was a must for an almost twenty-year-old at that time - after all, it was the music of a "Beatle". In 2001 it was the turn of the second version. The expectation that the digitalized remix and remastering would clean up the sound and make the beauty of the melodies and vocals clearer was disappointed. It is no different for me when listening to the third version of 2020, sonically hardly a change. Ironically, one could say that the winners of the new remix are Klaus Voormann and Carl Radle. The only gain beyond the double CD is the demos and unreleased takes on the additional CDs. All in all, the new release is an overpriced third release that nobody really needs. I would have been happy if Jeff Lynne had taken over the project. He proved with "Brainwashed" how to make an appealing album out of beautiful melodies and meaningful lyrics.

[@mrg1911]

See what Bobby Whitlock said about the mix….

[@BeatleJohn813]

Hi Andrew , I have heard on the grape vine , that there is going to be an announcement regarding the Let it be Audio on August 26th which is 2 weeks & 1 day away , and a release date of October 15 for the let it be soundtrack , so thats something to keep an eye on . John

[@chaddunn9621]

I did a and b listen with two cd players. Had the new remixed version on a and the original mix on b. I like the remixed version on a lot of songs and there is a few songs that I prefer the original mix has well. Its a great alternative if you want to listen to the reverb or not. So far I love both.

[@FORMATFIZIKAL]

I actually really like the new mixed. It sounds cleaner and has better imaging. I play it sightly louder and you'll feel like you in the studio.

[@ChromeDestiny]

I got the high res digital version on sale today from Pro Studio Masters. I think I prefer the content on discs three - five vs. the remix. I think what I'll do is make a playlist of my favourites from the bonus material along with my favourites from the demos and rehearsals bootleg I already had and that'll be my All Things Must Pass Naked sorted.

[@bilguana11]

I prefer the remixed album. Most of the "new" songs have been bootlegged and many have appeared on KZbin. I hope you have a high resolution sub as the bass is deeper and cleaner on the new mix than on the PS one.

[@michaelharrington75]

I think a big part of the problem with these post Beatles solo albums is those who have the final say. If they would hand the project over to someone very capable of doing the mix, and let them do their job the projects would probably sound better all the way through. But, you have Beatles kid's and wives wanting things done their way, which leads to the engineers not properly being able do their jobs.

[@bretvyon2336]

It's ironic how everyone talks about this album being De-Spectorised but the songs that suffer the most in the new mix are the ones that had the most wall of sound.

[@mrmjb1960]

The Chant "Poor Sir Frankie Crisp" is louder and more up front!

[@beatxt]

You're clearly suffering for your music without a chair Andrew! Excellent overview.

[@josephsirchia65]

Hi Andrew I received both the 5 x CD Deluxe Box Set and 3 SHM from Japan today. Overall, I prefer the remix vs the original Phil Spector. My only disappointment was the size of the Deluxe box set which I know was widely discussed. Overall I’m satisfied with the remix. Appreciate your reviews. Keep them coming.

[@ccpbass2032]

Listened one side at a time tonight with a listen to my original LP straight after. Side 1 was a clean sweep to me with the original having wider dynamics and a more vibrant mix. Phil knew what he was doing after all! There are a few tracks I like the new mix on but overall I’d say it loses some of it’s atmospheric magic. I’ve got the splattered vinyl, side 4 is strangely warped.....has anyone had this issue?

[@erniefernandez1927]

Greetings Andrew✌, Great review 👍 Over the weekend Ive been listening on my headphones several times to the 50th anniversary edition of ATMP and comparing it to my other versions of this album and one Highlight that is pleasing and relieving to me (and to my ears)is this new 2021 remix is Wah Wah, to me I hear more separation of the instrumentation of this Wall of Sound (more líke noise on this track) I hear more clarity with this song. -As for the dismal reviews of the 2021 version of My Sweet Lord its pretty unanimous among the Beatle community such as TJR, Norman Maslov ,Barry Robinson, (Paul) Fit To Be Tie Dyed.

[@johnknox3282]

I prefer every remix to the original. I've always wanted them to get rid of that Phil Spector crap since the first time I heard it. My Sweet Lord sounds so much more angelic and unshackled.

[@timholt9948]

I got the three cd set yesterday I love it thinking about upgrading and a tip of the hat to the wallflowers for a really good album to

[@iangallager4091]

Yes Andrew what you really need in life more than anything else is a chair.

[@johngill277]

Great review Andrew, I always trust your opinions. I think Bobby just wants to hate it for some reason, but I like the new mixes. Just putting it out there, but maybe an Oasis Live at Knebworth listening party at some point, just ordered the triple vinyl for November.

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Cheers John, I think the likelihood is that with Bobby having first hand memories from being there, that he is able to have different expectations than the rest of us, perhaps? Oasis: Yes that would be fun! I think I'm in for the 2CD and also the blu ray, I want that Sunday concert as I was there that night.

[@johngill277]

@@AndrewDixonMusic Yes , I guess everyone has their own opinion on it. Yes I'll have to get the Oasis blu ray too. My local record shop asked me if I'd like a vinyl copy saving, he was taking pre orders. I didn't get chance to see Oasis till 2000 when they headlined Leeds Festival, managed to see them 7 times between 2000 and 2009.

[@martintaylor769]

Hi Andrew, how does the Splatter records sound? Does the splatter affect the sound quality? Great Videos by the way.

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

@@martintaylor769 Thanks Martin, I hear no difference between the splatter colour and the regular black that I also now have. It's not a picture disc so doesn't come with the hiss that can be associated with those.

[@anthonyh8153]

Just finished listening to the remix+apple jam and really enjoyed it but I’d have to listen more to make a decision on what’s better the original or remix. For me though songs like if not for you,Art of dying and All things must pass really stood out and overall I really enjoyed the remix. I plan to dive into the two discs of outtakes tomorrow

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

You'll love the day 1 demos... What did you think of My Sweet Lord?

[@anthonyh8153]

@@AndrewDixonMusic when I first heard it I could tell a quite a noticeable difference the instrumentation especially the acoustic guitar seemed so smooth and clear but it felt like the song was missing something quite significant

[@anthonyh8153]

@@AndrewDixonMusic also I got the 5LP edition so I think there is a few day 1 demos on the two vinyl discs but not all of them it’s a wider selection from all of the outtakes

[@patmeadows4759]

Most Collectable: all things must pass - ecommerce exclusive 3LP color vinyl - now sold out.

[@skee19]

I got the 3 cd set today and also standard 3 album set 😀. The splatter is coming Monday too 😀

[@DrOz-007]

Best use of the song What is Life ? Goodfellas soundtrack.

[@closetkrishna]

Great idea to do the scoring system between the original and new, really liked that though with the new remix winning 11-7 can’t understand why you’d rate the original as being better as a whole and something you’d play more than the new remix, could it be no matter the score it’s what we are more used to hearing and being George’s original vision of how it should be, (even though he did express thoughts of wanting to remove much of the reverb and Spector’s wall of sound years later?). I do think George would have preferred the new remix more than the original though perhaps with the more epic tracks they should have done less with them as you said.

[@Billthemusicman]

haven't gotten to the cds yet anyone finding the vinyl bass heavy?

[@gbirving]

Why not put " I live for you" on main box set ? Is it remixed on new CD set ?

[@timmdoolen5041]

Not only is "I Live for You" not remixed, it's only available in demo form on this new compilation (from what I can tell). So if you want that song in it's more finished form, you have to get the 2001 or 2014 remaster.

[@timmdoolen5041]

@Mahki Mahkila I agree. "I Live for You" should have been remixed and included here. Apparently the Lennon estate is being more inclusive (or generous) with the bonus tracks than the Harrison estate. As I mentioned in a different comment, 3 of the 5 bonus tracks from the 2001/2014 ATMP remaster are not included on this very expensive set. Also omitted are a different demo of "Isn't it a Pity" (Let It Roll itunes bonus track), 5 versions of songs from ATMP on the album Early Take: Vol 1, and the Anthology 3 version of "All Things Must Pass". On this new set, CDs 3-5 are 51, 43 and 67 minutes long. So there was ample unused space to include the few missing tracks and make it a complete, all-encompassing definitive edition.

[@timmdoolen5041]

@Mahki Mahkila We still have the original Spector produced version - it's not going out of print anytime soon. So people can enjoy whichever version they prefer. For me, I'm more interested in the bonus tracks than the remix of the old tracks.

[@georgeprice4212]

On this new mix of Awaiting On You All, can you finally understand the last. prechorus compared to the original 1970 mix?

[@Zholobov1]

Hi, Andrew! What do you think about the synchronization mistake in 2020 Remix of "Isn't It A Pity (Version 2) starting from 2:18?

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Hi, I do mention it in the video, it just feels like it's presumably an error, and if so, it's a very careless one to slip through the net.

[@Zholobov1]

Oh, I'm sorry, I was asking before starting watching your review, actually. That’s really strange they didn't notice that mixing mistake. That means it went onto every type of the new release - LP, CD, BluRay and download. Isn't it a pity? By the way, why don't you simply tilt your camera a little bit lower and sit comfortably on the floor? 😉

[@steviebarr7353]

@Andrew Dixon how do you mean the way the Apple Jams were recorded? Were they only recorded with ambient room mics?

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

According to John Leckie the jams were recorded direct to stereo tape so there are no individual tracks for each element to be able to do a remix.

[@manolokonosko2868]

One disappointment about "I'd Have You Anytime" is that the wobble at around the line "All I have is yours" has not been corrected. The original record has a slight pitch wobble that was slightly improved upon on the 2014 remaster, but it hasn't been completely corrected here on this 2021 release as I had hoped they would have.

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Good point! I actually noticed it more here than I have previously, but maybe that's because I was listening more closely!?

[@bretvyon2336]

Wow, I've just somehow only noticed that wobble on the new mix and thought there was something wrong with my copy. So I'm glad to know my copy is ok but it's a shame they didn't fix that!

[@ConglomerationCat]

I agree Andrew, after hearing My Sweet Lord the 2021 remix, it really was lacking the epic, cathedral feel the original contained. It's like seeing a mini skirt revamped into a dress below the knees.

[@darrenmcgowan3932]

New mix in hi-res for me but 2014 mix of my sweet lord🤓

[@robertcole5562]

I like your scoring for remix versus original with one, maybe two exceptions involving my favorite tracks. I agree that the wall is sound is more suitable for Wah-Wah, Awaiting On You All and What Is Life. I can’t decide which version of Run of the Mill; still leaning toward the original but that may be because I’ve really liked that one since I bought the album in 1970. The main exception however is The Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp. Too much guitar in the intro and the “Oh Sir Frankie Crisp” refrain ruins the atmosphere, which for me is one of a medieval ballad that might have been well placed on the Beatles White Album. Finally which original did you use for the comparison: the 1970 or the 2001 remaster?

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Thanks, my comparison is to the 2014 remaster.

[@andreaschlapek780]

I got the standard edition of the remix. I listened to the other disc's on Amazon music. I still prefer the original sound. But it's good.

[@gerbiks45]

Enjoyed the review,Been playing the “splatter vinyl” and looks like I will be sending it back sadly.There is bad surface noise on last 2 tracks on side 2 “let it down and run of the mill”was putting up with noise in between songs but after cleaning a couple of times can’t put up with noise going through the last 2 songs.Shame as it looks nice but I’d rather it sound good.

[@diamonddog7613]

As usual a great video - interested to know apart from all the Beatles what other artists are you really into and other music -- also is there anyone you rate higher than the Beatles as a group or solo - what do you think of the stones

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Thanks Alan. The Beatles are number 1 for me, no doubt. But am also a big fan of plenty of others: Bob Dylan, Oasis, Kate Bush, The Beach Boys, The Housemartins, U2, REM, The Cure, Radiohead, Queen, Bowie, Nick Drake, Blur, Paul Weller and lots of others! I like a lot of Stones songs but have never been a proper fan.

[@mars7934]

It's not for me I'm afraid. Just goes to show Phil Spectors genius. People like to judge him on what happened much later in his life but back in the day he was brilliant at what he did. Producers don't just mix the recordings they make the recordings! It's revisionism at the end of the day and an ugly attempt to cash in. I'll keep to the remastered version and save myself a small fortune. Sorry Dani and Olivia you'll just have to shop at Aldi this month 😅

[@superfuzzymomma]

I agree in every regard my friend. Thank u!

[@jackiepuppet9289]

I’m not wowed by this remix at all either. I was NEVER getting that Uber or Super Deluxe but was going to pick up the 2 CD. Not so sure now. Also hearing how the vinyl sounds better but I just cannot pay 65 dollars plus tax ! That stupid apple jam unnecessarily jacks up the price !

[@superfuzzymomma]

@@jackiepuppet9289I'm hearing from people those who think the vinyl mix is awful. Please visit Bobby Whitlocks channell on here. He played on the damn recordable! All personal taste at end of the day I guess and mine is not to trust substitutions. Peace all.

[@jackiepuppet9289]

@@superfuzzymomma I’m not going by Whitlocks opinion. His wife has been propping him up on KZbin (like a puppet!) for months now. I think they just want a slice of the pie from this reissue

[@superfuzzymomma]

@@jackiepuppet9289 I respect your opinion friend. And love the Jackie puppet too. Prace

[@rorylane4069]

I really, REALLY like the remix. It could be my go to version. But I gotta admit the messed Isn't it a pity version two puts me really off. I mean, how they missed that? I can't believe it! This release deserves to be at total perfection.

[@ernestmaurizi7668]

The softer numbers sound better on the remix but the rockets are better on the original.overall the drums have been pulled back.The bass tracks are better..over all a nice job...

[@thomasminarchickjr.7355]

Ringo used tea towels taped to his drum heads and then tuned them with the towels taped to them. That may be what you’re hearing too

[@nowhereman_uk7700]

How does it compare to the 30th release?

[@stepheng8779]

From dark horse to flogged horse. Ker-ching!

[@lewisreading47]

Loved the video, i agree with my sweet lord, especially in the hare krishnas georges vocals were quiet. Both versions of isnt it a pity were great too

[@vinyl_marmalade]

How does the splatter vinyl sound? And in comparison with the cd's?

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Splatter vinyl sounds way better, it's not even close.

[@vinyl_marmalade]

@@AndrewDixonMusic thank you! I bought the 8 vinyl box, but didn’t have time to listen to it yet…. Hopefully today!

[@vinyl_marmalade]

@@AndrewDixonMusic 8 Box Vinyl Set: LP‘s 1 + 2 and 2nd LP (Side 3/4) of Day 1 Demos are all very dished - will send them back for replacement. No joy and fun at all

[@hansout2831]

I enjoyed your review as per usual. Sets up my expectations well, and makes me want to own it (in spite of the price!!) I see what you mean wrt the ‘epicness’ of the wall of sound songs. Wonder what you make of the 2000 mix. What struck me on there was the improved clarity all around, gradual, not radical. The Apple Jams were definitely improved there. I could imagine therefore that you’d all around prefer the 2000 mix to the original and the current remix. Could you comment?

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Hi Hans, The release in 2000 I believe was a remaster than a remix. It's definitely the loudest of the masterings I've heard and it's not one I particularly enjoy, although I did like Apple Scruffs on that release (While being able to look beyond how loud it was!)

[@hansout2831]

@@AndrewDixonMusic I shouldn’t have said remix, as GH himself said it wasn’t in his liner notes. But I thought it was a bit clearer without losing the epicness. That’s why I’d have thought you might prefer it. I also own the first CD issue and thought 2000 an improvement. Taste comes into it

[@MarcusMaximus909]

Great video Andrew, mine from the official website arriving tommorrow a day late!..splatter vinyl and hi res deluxe set. How does my sweet lord/ isn't it a pity RSD single versions compare are they different?

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Cheers Marcus. The RSD My Sweet Lord was a remaster of the original mix, so it's very different to what you'll hear on the new version. My Sweet Lord sounding so much better on the splatter vinyl than it does on CD

[@roywatson8133]

many fans dont care about the apple jam side out the blue is top stuff

[@colemanmufc]

Hi Andrew. I was wondering if you could clear something up that has been bothering me. It's to do with the song I Live for You. I don't have the CD or Vinyl. I listen on Spotify or KZbin. In the middle of the song there's a vocal that suddenly disappears. Seems like an editing error. On the demo that doesn't happen. So my question is. Is this error on the CD and Vinyl versions also?

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Hi Rob, are you referring to the Day 1 Demo on the new box set? Just had a listen now to the Hi Res download I bought from Qobuz, and also the CD and I can't tell any part in either where it cuts out. There's a part around 2 minutes 20 where he's sort of humming along a verse then stops for the remainder, not sure if that's the part you mean?

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

Not had chance to listen to the vinyl yet....

[@colemanmufc]

Sorry I should've been much more specific. That demo on the 50th ATMP is actually perfect. The one I'm on about is the much more finished version of the song on the ATMP 2014. So at time 1:45 on I Live for You the vocal drops quiet on Spotify. I love that version but its spoilt by this. I understand you might not have the 2014 ATMP for you to check. So sorry if I've wasted your time.

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

@@colemanmufc No problem, just had a listen to that from my CD (I don't think that's ever been released on vinyl? Could be wrong...) the vocal does go quite for a second or two, not sure if it's a mixing issue or maybe more likely George might have just turned away from his mic for a second while singing. If that's the case I wonder if that explains a reason why the recording wasn't considered for the album, it would have been a fine addition!

[@colemanmufc]

@@AndrewDixonMusic Oh well. That's the end of that mystery. I was hoping the CD version was perfect. I would've bought it if it was. I say mystery solved, but I wonder what actually happened. Maybe a question for Dhani one day. Anyway, thanks for looking in to it for me. And yes, it would've been a great addition on the original Album.

[@Customsaberparadise]

Great review, I wonder if the vinyl will be less compressed than CD

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

It definitely is. Vinyl sounds really good

[@Customsaberparadise]

@@AndrewDixonMusic I listened to the new Mix on Spotify and agree the background instrumentation has been bought more upfront and the vocals clearer its good !! especially the OH SIR FRANKIE CRISP lol I never noticed that in the original mix. But I feel the new mix is too quiet its well balanced but not Dynamic and loud enough for me.

[@Customsaberparadise]

wow did you see the Bobby Whitlock Video he really doesn't like it !

[@hendrix9230]

I never really like this album until I heard the remix.

[@matthewbuzzell8601]

Any thoughts on the 5.1 mix, Andrew?

[@AndrewDixonMusic]

I don't have a 5.1 set up Matthew so I've not heard it

[@matthewbuzzell8601]

@@AndrewDixonMusic Thanks for getting back to me.

[@edwardrussell5989]

I agree that my sweet Lord has lost some of its impact but I love the rest ,

[@ChrisHallNewbury]

I’ve created a playlist of both original and remix so you can compare them easier

[@Beatleboy]

Uber box is hopefully arriving today

[@TheSchemel]

Are you going to open it up? I am also getting the Uber box set, but I don't know if I want to open it up. I have been a Beatles/ex-Beatles fan, but I am also collector. I don't sell anything, I just like knowing that it is valuable, and can go up in value.

[@Beatleboy]

@@TheSchemel I don't sell either but i had to open it as its so nicely done, ill leave the vinyl sealed as i collect sealed vinyl but i had to display George and the Gnomes on top of the box

[@TheSchemel]

@@Beatleboy I just lifted the lid, but I am tempted to do what you did.

[@trevordixon1427]

Got 2cd yesterday.in post ta