Germany: Between needing foreign workers and growing anti-immigration views | DW News

A look into the struggles migrants are facing in Germany, with a particular look at Dresden.
Subscribe: kzbin.info...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#germany #migration #integration

[@marcushenning3594]

You can get foreign workers through controlled migration, you don't need to completely open the floodgates. So there is obviously something else at play, and I'm glad to see Europe finally starting to wake up to this

[@livelife5947]

There’s definitely an agenda going on & we’re all being gaslit about it 👀

[@klausschumacher7126]

Do you really believe that the anti immigrants racist know the difference between controlled and uncontrolled immigration? They only see the color of the skin and that's enough to hate foreigners.

[@SonsofThunder1234]

Controlled migration, watch them closely, give them 3 years, then replace them. Give them no rights to stay.

[@AS-ty7nc]

​@@SonsofThunder1234👍

[@wanderer2246]

@@SonsofThunder1234 And almost nobody will come then Then there will be reputation of "free" country for years. Maybe this is the plan of far-right

[@moken79]

Seems like a way to muddy the waters, immigration is a huge area. In typical DW fashion, they are only showing off the successful immigrants. Hardly anyone, even in Saxony, will have an issue with the two in the video, this is misleading. The ones people are concerned about get a total of 13 seconds of footage in a 6min video. It's intellectually dishonest to present two highly educated and successful immigrants as if they were representative of all immigration, essentially using them as a shield from all criticism.

[@glowiedetector]

there is no way on earth you think immigrants who sre successful could calmly exist in east Germany without sentiment against them. You really think they could walk at night in an all German area in Dresden when they have a PhD in Dentistry and help people all day? You just did what you accuse DW of, just in the other way around lol.

[@axoloneidolon4702]

​@@glowiedetectorI agree with him. DW is dishonest and deliberately tries to manipulate public opinion.

[@Toulkun]

@@glowiedetector True, it doesnt matter successful or not, East Germans hate anyone non German even themselves, but Western germans also hate them because they need to pay taxes for them. All thanks to cold war.

[@gavinhou3261]

I think when you migrate to another country, you should respect the indigenous culture and also be ready to change your own lifestyle instead of trying to change the new environment to avoid clash. Immigration is not a threat, but immigrants not willing to respect others especial the natives are.

[@MohammadJamalMunaeem]

You are absolutely , right. My daughter and son-in-law live in Germany. Both of them are highly educated persons. I think most alyssum comes without proper skill and education. I visit them . I have learnt the basic German in order to communicate with Germans.

[@pajeetsingh]

Immigration should be seen with a lens of liability. The elite capital owners don't care about indigenous culture and don't care if workers assimilate or not. Forcing lifestyle changes would just increase the friction. Remember these immigrants do work for less than half the pay.

[@syedhasanabbas859]

yeah tell that to the Indians

[@token3462]

@@C.BraganzaLoL, No 😂

[@izzyrov5814]

​​@@C.Braganza I don't think so. Some don't even know how to use the toilet. 😒

[@urimtefiki226]

I agree with locals, uncontrolled immigration is not good.

[@cornishsea]

Nice how the elite see "countries" as a economic zone and not the volk and culture of the native culture 😢

[@Freyja_M4106]

You mean the Saamí Ofcourse right?

[@cornishsea]

@@Freyja_M4106 the ethnic group that arrived in Northern Europe after the Europeans?

[@jdd5886]

where have you been?

[@mysterioanonymous3206]

It's because they internationalised (both their finances and the places they spend time) and don't have firm roots in these places, unlike the working population. So they simply don't identify with either the place or it's population.

[@bahshas]

why ppl have no culture

[@iloveSUVs]

"You cannot simultaneously have free immigration and a welfare state." - Milton Friedman

[@RS-rz9lw]

lol then how are you going to maintain welfare state with aging population and low fertility? Who is going to pay old Germans' pension?

[@incurableromantic4006]

"Needing foreign workers" is a euphemism for "Keeping wages down" They *could* employ Germans - but they don't *want* to because then they would have to pay more.

[@geoffoakland]

Like I mentioned in my earlier comment, Germany should encourage the hundreds of thousands of ethnic Germans who immigrated to South America decades ago to come back to Germany. This way Germany would get its workers it 'needs' while keeping its culture.

[@flippe555]

Exactly, this should be common knowledge by now.

[@peter_meyer]

@incurableromantic4006 Utter BS. There are not enough germans who _want_ to or _can_ work in these jobs. Your claim shows that you do not have a clue of the german economy.

[@ramdev9578]

@@geoffoakland Germans don't have the brains to work in IT jobs. They need Indians.

[@greegorygrimlee5487]

​@@peter_meyermaybe they would want the jobs if they paid better.

[@krollpeter]

I like to believe that the majority of Germans are not generally against immigrants. Many are against people who do not want to integrate, culturally and socially. This is a different subject that needs to be differently addressed.

[@Alpha-vb3to]

Most of then failed to integrate in every single country, do not expect every people that cannot read at old age being capable of integrate or even learn the basics. And do not expect they changing their religious basis.

[@krollpeter]

@@Alpha-vb3to That is what I am saying. If they are not willing or able to find their place in another society, do not go there. Whoever that is, wherever that is. If I go to the US I can not expect the Americans to become Germans. They would not let me bomb the Times Square, because I hate US junk food, or their extreme Christianity.

[@adelinarizescu5363]

I encourage you to be more specific. What kind of immigrants come to Germany by boat and who screams "Allahu Akbar" all over Germany? There are bomb throreads in the country. Who makes them? 🙃

[@krollpeter]

@@VEPM.cogent so you did.

[@bahshas]

@@VEPM.cogent maybe dont destroy their economy and pipeline then

[@izustun9851]

As a Turkish who works and lives in Germany, I would say Germany needs skilled workers, who wants to work. What Germany does not need, random people lack of any ability to work or skills, only wants to get “Bürgergeld, elterngeld…” and also who does not know how a secular democracy works. There is a distinct difference between two types of people. I wouldn’t be happy if this kind of people comes into my country. From this point of view I totally understand the Germans.

[@Valicore]

I find it so odd that they did the interview with her in Hinglish (informal mix of Hindi and English) instead of German since she's been there for ten years. Especially since she's supposed to me an example of a dedicated immigrant that will stay in Germany. One would have thought a German broadcaster would use German, the common language of Germans.

[@serebii666]

DW is not the German state broadcaster. That would be Das Erste and ZDF for TV networks, and Deutschlandradio. . Deutsche Welle is Germany's international broadcaster. DW does not even do broadcast TV in German anymore from this year.

[@dennykeaton9701]

She probably doesn't know German

[@TheExard3k]

If she's more comfortable in talking english and english being the language of DW, why enforce German? DW isn't there to enforce German supremacy on the world. This was to tell a story and to provide a perspective.

[@bonnychacko]

At 5:00 DW says she knows fluent German, but they wanted to do it in Hinglish for more views from the AfD guys :D

[@bratwurstmitbiryani]

I disagree. I actually like this approach. As an immigrant she expressed herself as what she is in her own language. They did mention that she speaks fluently. Why should she try to prove she's German enough in every goddamn situation. This is good. Germans should know what Hindi sounds like. Maybe some of them will take interest and learn Hindi at some point.

[@Basicguy1798]

I am an immigrant, an Indian, who came to Germany on an invitation to study my masters at Uni Stuttgart. I entered Germany in the most legal way possible(at least I think so). I have never faulted on my Visa(student or work), never broken a law, never disrespected the culture(in fact I genuinely love and try to internalize it into my day to day life) and as a bonus love the German bakery(also the dishes might I add). I want to list how Germany(esp. Stuttgart) has been to me: 1. I have never faced racism. At least not any overt racism at all. No human is perfect and I dont care if someone on the street is a racist unless that harms me in any way. My colleagues, boss(es), teachers/professors, the people at the bakery, restaurants, supermarket have never been racist. 2. I have never been denied of any rights or service by the authorities. 3. I have never faced disrimination in getting an apartment for rent. I have had vermieters who were almost of my age(relatively young) as well as those who were in their 80s. 4. I have never been disrminated when I needed help in shops or when I had to solve an issue with my internet connection at the Telekom store etc. etc. etc. Thing to note here is that I am still not fluent in German, I am improving, yes!! but not fluent. So if someone is racist they coould have easily been. Instead, everyone was super welcoming and helping. And the a comment/compliment that I have time and time again received from many of them, especially my vermieters, was that I seem to be very "Sympathisch". Now, when I first heard this, I was not sure what that meant(like in 2018 or so) but now I know what they mean. So reflecting on it, it does make sense. When you, as an immigrant, have a mindset to appreciate the local culture, like the local way of life, to assimilate as much as you can, to contribute to the society, and genuinely have no made up pre-conceived notion, then that comes out on your expressions(the way you greet someone, talk to them, ask for help etc etc). I have many acquaintances who, by default, think of some German things to be below/lesser than their culture/system/way-of-life. That, for me, is really really upsetting. When you have such notions, you will not, inherently, assimilate. Thats where a friction starts. I have seen many many many many immigrants who just want to milk the German system but not give back. Thats absolutely sad! Now, this doesn't mean there aren't racists, or that I will not ever come across one, or that there are no victims of racist behaviours. And the law needs to take care of that. What I want to highlight is that a common or mass feeling of animosity develops when a majority of immigrants dont respect the culture or the law of the land. P.s. all racist comments in reply to this comment are to be ignored

[@GreaterAfghanistanMovement]

@@C.Braganza Because brown latinos sometimes can look Indian.

[@GreaterAfghanistanMovement]

@@C.Braganza Basically, its a plan to make Afghanistan united like it did before the British came in the region and created the Durand Line. Most of the Afghan areas occupied are now in North-West Pakistan which was once part of the Kingdom of Afghanistan. This is why Afghanistan and Pakistan have beef and the governments are not on good relations.

[@GreaterAfghanistanMovement]

@@C.Braganza I speak Pashto but i have a bit of understanding of Dari though not fluent.

[@camilo6859921]

I love your comment, you are an smart guy with a really good common sense!!

[@Gunhed507]

Yes we do need immigration, but not the kind that comes over via boats and can barely read. But great job combining both and don't differentiate in this news article.

[@neilc4544]

When hate flows through the streets, it doesnt discriminate

[@simba8665]

Yeah right. Even some Germans don’t wanna live in your country

[@jasonmiller3011]

I am from India 🇮🇳 , I am IT graduate , have drivers license, speak proper English and German , mind my own business , am I welcome?

[@neilc4544]

@@jasonmiller3011 am afraid you will not be very soon.

[@Joelmonterrey]

It doesn't matter because immigrants expand and grow your GDP regardless. They can skill up and get an education after they arrive and then Germany is stronger. A bunch of unskilled, poor, illiterate Germans washed ashore here in the USA and look at us now.

[@Archeaon]

She doesn't speak the language...

[@MissSarahGM]

and she goes to the protest to understand... what did she expect? People have the right to protest she should have respected that.

[@okman9684]

5:01 The report literally said she now speak fluent German. Are you dumb?

[@soundscape26]

She does.

[@ricardoxavier827]

Musl1ms are againts atheism and sexual freedom, with violent reaction from the religious book. Its not just the imigrants the issue, but what type, if they are 1sl4mic or not. The terrorist rel1gion cannot live in europe. Periode. For the liberal future of our scientifical and atheist children future.

[@darkmage4648]

She is fluent

[@andreiunghie]

It is your job as an immigrant to integrate and try to fit in and not the other way around. A country can import their workforce based on their needs not just let millions in. You will probably get some decent people, doctors, IT specialists etc. but then the other vast majority of them will contribute little to nothing and they will be the ones needing doctors, houses etc. and not the native Germans themselves….When your county changes right in front of your eyes within a few years, high crime rates, unsafe areas, violence, longer waiting times to see a doctor or to get a home you get there will be a anti-immigrant sentiment.

[@val-schaeffer1117]

Rubbish. One cannot shake hands with a closed fist. Do you have any proof that perfectly integrated second generation visible minorities do not face discrimination? My cousins born and raised in Frankfurt, work in Nestle and SAP respectively. Have zero German friends. One of them is gay, and he says 90% of the German gay men write "no African no Asian" on profile.

[@eti-om2gh]

You need to look up demographic crisis to understand the impact of having more elderly than young. The pension funds, the ponzo scheme housing market and the consumer power will decrease to the point where the local intetnal economy will collapse and than the fraud of the banking/financial system will b laid bare for all to see. But hey lets create another classical western political scapegoat to please the masses…

[@smokiman673]

There are people who would like to come to Germany to live, work and be part of their society. For example, I have my C1 certificate but cannot easily enter Germany legally, the bureaucratic hurdles are extremely strict. But I see how others find it easy to do so illegally. This means that Germany doesn't have a problem with emigrants, but rather with the filtering to those who are really interested in Germany, who want to commit themselves to the country and want to help build a future in it, in which everyone would win, and of course you got the other side of people, the majority, who simple see Germany, just as a mean of exploiting social welfare system to the fullest, with no wish to adapt and become part of society

[@Juzzyjuzzy]

Germany must prioritize skilled workers who contribute significantly to the economy.

[@ramdev9578]

The German economy is dead. Was buried along with the Dollar. And the rest of Europe. Bye bye Barbarians, its been nice knowing you for 2000 years. Good riddance.

[@greegorygrimlee5487]

Why stop at immigrants? Why not do the same for birth control and only allow skilled and wealthy Germans to have children?

[@SolomonSunder]

@@greegorygrimlee5487 the rich do not want to send their children to war.

[@joeysal007]

even that will replace germans with other nationalities in future. Why not just encourage your population produce more children?

[@greegorygrimlee5487]

@@joeysal007If they replace Germans, then they are Germans, no? Or do you mean replaced by people who are 'different' in a racist kind of way?

[@mahanshuchaudhari2676]

Simple as is it , enter the country legally after learning some skills, learn German, and try to contribute to the society, follow the rules and try not to change them as per your needs ! I'm in Germany since 1 month i learnt german till B1 before even coming here because i knew how important it is to be a part of culture.

[@Raven28Pisces]

true, as I was an apprentice myself, I found so many people just want to 'barg' into Deutschland but doesn't have respect for the culture itself!

[@Cent-130]

Even if one entered legally people feel immigrant workers are threat to Nation

[@spookyargument7537]

Let me see whether you hold on to the same opinion after 2 or 3 years

[@user-th5ui4ib3y]

Welcome. Wish you all the best! Hallo. Wünsche Dir nur das Beste!

[@michalschade7734]

You won’t be ever the part of our culture

[@SandeepSingh-or7jr]

I understand Germany's frustration when your resources, jobs, land, politics, businesses, indigenous identity and local population, culture ,history and identity are being wiped out by immigrants with competitive cheap labor and wages.

[@mysterioanonymous3206]

😂 You troll... 👍

[@yippiyaying4375]

@@mysterioanonymous3206 colonizer

[@MaxStudy-qn4vk]

They dont work tho?!? Xd

[@attilaaluhut6250]

If only they would work… There are so many open positions in retail, gastronomy, construction. But they just want the unemployment benefits, free housing and health care.

[@dylanschulz9118]

The labor market is not an issue though? In Germany there is a deficit of workers not of jobs!

[@jerloxcool6671]

I cant wait for next EU elections, because I will vote the most far right its possible. Hope we will get Europe back.✊️

[@Britta_no_filter]

Hopefully voters will get Europe back from ignorant xenophobes like yourself. Shame to see racism poison the continent.

[@DummyUseless-er3dn]

Shove off. Countries for their citizens. Not Europe, not planet Earth, etc

[@shailendulenka1894]

There is a difference between Immigration and Illegal Immigration.

[@pratikagrawal8742]

Always remember no matter how well integrated you are, "You are just one incident away from loving your country again."

[@nandhan6637]

true words!

[@TheAryanKnight]

true, a french woman was living in Mumbai and she said she felt safer on the streets of Mumbai than in Paris. I guess the grass is always greener on the other side.

[@rahulvats95]

True True Facts.

[@glowiedetector]

wym by that quote?

[@DummyUseless-er3dn]

One incident away from forced to return back. Not loving the country. Indians who say they love their country probably never had to deal with bad Indian laws whoch useless politicians like modi are not fixing

[@erase_ego]

Countries where you can succeed as an immigrant are US, US, US in that order.

[@patbenz4327]

Quite true, but in Europe, immigrants can become middle-class quite quickly as well.

[@shabbirocks123]

5:56 She moved from India because as a women she wasnt feeling safe. NOW AS A WOMEN SHE IS NOT SAFE IN GERMANY. SHE IS CONFUSED AND SICK.

[@rubiconklbrutorowman7577]

Yes, INDEED AFD has quite legitimate concerns indeed! NOT only original Germans might become minority but also other severely degrading German or European culture! US

[@mahdedarmo]

culture schmulture.. original Germans hehe

[@EricReno20]

Absolutely not! Do you legitimately think that German culture is under threat just because the number of immigrants is rising? How should that even work? They won't stop Germans from being German.

[@greegorygrimlee5487]

who are original Germans?

[@klausschumacher7126]

What culture? Drinking beer and eating Sauerkraut? The western world has lost its culture already and replaced it with McDonald's, Burger King , Starbucks, Iphone, Mercedes, BMW, Oktoberfest being pissed and vomiting 🤮 everywhere....

[@klausschumacher7126]

@@greegorygrimlee5487Die Bayern ....😂

[@LaxmikantKachhap]

Islamophobia in many cases is common sense and common sense is what must prevail.

[@camilo6859921]

I love your comment!!

[@carolinaking45]

For those who are complaining about her language - this interview was taken by DW Hindi channel originally , for hindi speaking subscribers and then dubbed in english, that's why it is not in german.

[@vivekjk6729]

i have no idea why DW did this. even the person translating her hindi to english is so bad. she could have just talked in english or german.

[@MissSarahGM]

A country is not only its economy, culture can't be denied and needs to be protected. Immigration is ok under certain limitations. I understand the concerns these German people have, same issues we have in France.

[@arnodobler1096]

France and UK had colonies for centuries, work on it! It's rich and poor, not race or anything.

[@MissSarahGM]

@@arnodobler1096 I was talking about culture, not race. Anyway, not because our ancestors had colonies (and built there infrastructures as well) does it mean we ought to be invaded as a fair retaliation.

[@arnodobler1096]

@@MissSarahGM Empire, Commonwealth, Kingdom? Actions have consequences, live with them, others will too. You also benefit when it comes to the cuisine , right?

[@MissSarahGM]

@@arnodobler1096 Past is past, and future generations should not pay for it. European nations have the right to want to protect their heritage and culture. Immigration is ok until it has become massive and doesn't fit with the local culture and create more problems.

[@ricardoxavier827]

Musl1ms are againts atheism and sexual freedom, with violent reaction from the religious book. Its not just the imigrants the issue, but what type, if they are 1sl4mic or not. The terrorist rel1gion cannot live in europe. Periode. For the liberal future of our scientifical and atheist children future.

[@Zzzooooppp]

It is annoying that some legal immigrants feel personally attacked when natives have concerns about uncontrolled mass migration. It’s fine if you don’t agree it’s a problem, but if “negative feelings and hate” is your only explanation for why people can take part in these marches, and you can’t even imagine a legitimate reason to worry….then maybe a passport isn’t the only thing it takes to be a real citizen.

[@hNdru96]

i think you would see thing very different if you were an immigrant. Qualified or not we still face so much discrimination by ignorant people. The question is where does the far right will stop? Afd has more moderate right wing politicians as well as Neonazis in their ranks. But its all a game and a "protest" for people with the privilege of seeing it from where you stand

[@asmirann3636]

​@@hNdru96The end which Far Right dreams of is a civil war in which they will kill all the immigrants.

[@Zzzooooppp]

Yes, so because we are so different, we shouldn’t share a country. You can’t see it my way and I can’t see it yours

[@greegorygrimlee5487]

hmmm. If thousands of people attended marches to say they don't want you here, how does this make you feel? Maybe it isn't not being able to conceive of legitimate reasons, maybe they even agree with the reasons, but it will still sting to be told you aren't wanted. And to think people around you feel that way would make many people feel afraid. On a different scale, even if she or he says 'it's not you, it's me' when she dumps you, you still feel dumped.

[@greegorygrimlee5487]

​​@@Zzzooooppp hows things there in your world where everyone is just like you? Do you live in a country full of clones? do people even have genders where you are? How is it that everyone in your world experiences that world the same way as you? Or do you share your world with nobody, just you by yourself? 😮 I hope not, that sounds sad.

[@poopoppy]

There is no "need" for foreign workers.

[@MuratOner666]

ah yes that's why two Turkish immigrants developed the Covid vaccine in Germany and worked with Phizer whose founder was a German immigrant in the US.

[@balsdsa]

there is a need if you want to pay peanuts and pocket the difference

[@okman9684]

Then start having 3 kids. If not you don't have any say in it

[@ricardoxavier827]

Musl1ms are againts atheism and sexual freedom, with violent reaction from the religious book. Its not just the imigrants the issue, but what type, if they are 1sl4mic or not. The terrorist rel1gion cannot live in europe. Periode. For the liberal future of our scientifical and atheist children future.

[@human8454]

Majority of indians move to Anglo American countries.nobody wants to learn a new language & the salaries & opportunities are also less in Europe I saw so many German companies & Universities wants Indian people because we spend more on our education & jobs

[@TheYoutubeUser69]

maybe we can get safe spaces for german women first? i think we have enough "guests" for now ^_^

[@Cyril_Sneer]

Now we just need a safe space for Germans in Germany... 👀

[@markmcnicholas9475]

Where does this acceptance of immigration to fill job vacancies come from? Germany is an exporting country, like Japan. However Japan decided to move the factories to places with population to fill vacancies. The exports produce profits that are paid to their Japanese companies in Japan. So everyone’s happy. It also gives the time for the native population to recover. Free trade allows this to occur. Move the factories, not the people.

[@nhatrang10139]

Free trade is good.

[@eisbeinGermany]

There is an article on Google about the big problem arising with bakeries and butchers, Young German people do not want to become apprentice bakers or butchers anymore as it is long hours and hard work and the salary is very low, Many Bakeries/butcheries are closing down when the original owner goes in rent as there's no one to take over, and another reason is that the supermarkets sell meat and cakes and bread,

[@juanmartin1729]

Australia as well.

[@arnodobler1096]

Japan is the most indebted country. With the oldest population and 0 policies to change that.

[@asdasdasddgdgdfgdg]

​@@eisbeinGermany This has a lot to do with supermarkets, less so with the wishes of young people. For decades now, supermarkets have been displacing bakers and butchers.

[@FernandoPerez3h]

Why do indians migrate to Germany?. India is peaceful and "developed" countries according to modi?.

[@FernandoPerez3h]

.

[@benitzers8858]

❤

[@vikramaditya47_]

We generally dont. We prefer other better countries to live and study. Indians are very less in DE if you are educated enough to read statistics

[@Mr_ravee_]

People in india will eventually wake up to the "According to Muddy" stunt...and those webseries like khalistan-canda episodes to polarize the majority to get them to vote to a side.

[@Nameles305]

It’s. NOT Indian s Germany facing threat Those from Syria Pakistan Bangladesh Iraq whom Germany gave asylum Generally. PAECEFUL s 😃

[@obi0914]

This looks very poorly that you didn't have her speak the same language as her "country"

[@verycherryberry3752]

it is her country. no need to quotation marks.

[@obi0914]

@@verycherryberry3752 the quotation marks are there to show skepticism

[@MissSarahGM]

@@obi0914 She did compare Germany to "her country", that says it all

[@PAVANZYL]

If you go to a country illegally - that is, the very first thing you do when you get there is to break the law, how do you expect things to get better from there onwards?

[@asmirann3636]

Most human migration has been illegal.

[@TanmoyBiswas]

don't generalize.

[@MrRickalba]

The biggest question is if government is able to provide properly assimilated, integrate and give immigrants means to economically contribute to the country, just take immigrants and leave them to be would only leave to a situation similar to Sweden..

[@philippvoid1800]

the issue is the lack of competence of the politicians

[@greegorygrimlee5487]

Ah, but sadly they get elected by being good at politics, not for being good at running things. So the problem might be that they're too competent 😂

[@kakhaval]

No matter what, we are foreigners and a problem and always reminded as such. I ended up in the west and have full respect for their mindset but my dream is going back and not feel foreigner but it is an impossible dream now partly because I cannot stomach the mindset of my original people.

[@arnodobler1096]

Understandable! Will happen to you in any country. Sad. I'm on the bus in the morning with 10 different nationalities, and I like it. I live in a 3k suburb. But not every one of my fellow citizens.

[@wuokmayangjanguan1591]

That is relatable. Where are you originally from?

[@ricardoxavier827]

Musl1ms are againts atheism and sexual freedom, with violent reaction from the religious book. Its not just the imigrants the issue, but what type, if they are 1sl4mic or not. The terrorist rel1gion cannot live in europe. Periode. For the liberal future of our scientifical and atheist children future.

[@johnlinton5427]

i was in mosul in 2008 the area north of the city is a beautiful part of the world@@kakhaval

[@robertskolimowski7049]

Bro, u have no idea how many emigrants can relate to what u said there, myself included, peace out and God bless🤝✌️

[@aramin111]

After 10 years Fatima doesn't speak German?

[@hhKJgf1M8a0rzt8hP]

she speaks fluent German.

[@hmvollbanane1259]

I don't think the population has turned anti immigration perse but against unregulated mass immigration. It has put everything on hold as every town is overburdened, the children service of my neighbouring city is forced to house children in hotels as all capacities are overfilled, housing has become increasingly expensive/ impossible to get, schools have to adjust to massive proportions of foreigners unable to speak German, kindergarten spaces are hard to impossible to come by. Immigration for the labour market is a short term solution but the strains it puts on our social system makes it extremely difficult for anyone wanting to start a family as they are simply unable to afford it and get the support needed, short term it may solve the problem but long-term it will worsen it

[@mahyar2727]

Immigrants = The never ending issue everywhere

[@babajikaghanta8842]

Funny! Bcus Europeans themselves were immigrants all over the world after WW2 .

[@atix50]

Illegal Immigrants.

[@darkmage4648]

Going back to the time of the colonists. For sure.

[@AS-ty7nc]

​@@darkmage4648no more kanaken

[@wanderer2246]

@@atix50 In this report everything was about legal migration

[@spookyargument7537]

Germans dislikes all immigrants

[@seriouslycoolful]

Why exactly does Germany NEED foreign workers? And why specifically foreign workers from outside Europe?

[@soundscape26]

I don't think it's specifically from outside Europe, an immigrant is an immigrant.

[@seriouslycoolful]

@@C.SBraga I reject the assumption that a population cannot shrink and also maintain an economy. Mass importing alien populations is far more destabilising and reckless. If you want increased population the only good solution is incentivising your current population to have children

[@human8454]

Majority of indians move to Anglo American countries.nobody wants to learn a new language & the salaries & opportunities are also less in Europe I saw so many German companies & Universities wants Indian people because we spend more on our education & jobs

[@firstname3343]

@@C.SBraga I am a Latino of 88% European descent, it doesn't matter Germans or Anglos will still see us as half monkeys. If you talk to them in secret they will likely open up about looking down on Southern and Eastern Europeans too. Unless they are Liberals they would not want you to marry into their family. We can have kinship with our Southern European brothers as we share culture with them but we are not Europeans. Europeans do not even consider the whiter North Americans as one of their own. They will not respect you for trying to act like one of them either they will just tolerate you as a pickme. We do not belong in Europe our home is in the New World, we have been here for too long and it has changed us even if we are biologically identical. We should strive to better our situation here not flee for Europe, besides from the looks of it Europe doesn't seem like a place worth fleeing to anymore.

[@seriouslycoolful]

@@human8454 That is a terrible reason to import foreigners. I think the real reason is not some specific positive trait of Indians, it's simply that Indians are not White

[@imaketherules9316]

"Hey Fatema, instead of bashing Germany...how about going back to India🤷🏽‍♂ There, you have all things India. But Germany is German, period! The audacity to bash a country; that is nothing like yours...and NEVER asked you to visit nor live in!"😂🤣

[@imaketherules9316]

@@PodlejskiGame9 --->If you say so👍🏼

[@terribrad24]

well there is a difference between skilled workers coming to Germany, and between an Iraqi family of 20 seeking asylum, not working, and then while on asylum, goes back to Iraq for vacation twice a year ...

[@CugnoBrasso]

Ok so, is anybody going to do anything for all the bot comments on here???

[@aliancemd]

KZbin doesn’t care. I’ve seem the same bots spamming for over 1 year and I personally kept reporting them all the time

[@sailesh1144]

​@@aliancemdReporting isn't doing anything either. I've seen the accounts which I reported for spamming a few months back still actively spamming.

[@nigelleyland166]

Please increase audio levels, My PC and Monitor are set to max sound level but the vid is inaudable.

[@eksbocks9438]

"Grug no like foreign workers!" "Okay... We still need food and artillery shells." "No! It's too much work, loser!"

[@zinjanthropus322]

Automation exists.

[@SonnyDarvishzadeh]

Germany performs quite poor in rankings among developed countries for foreigners to immigrate to. Similar to Japan, many will have their bubble burst after arriving here. Amazing country for elderly locals and asylum seekers.

[@contra18765]

Why is she talking in Hindi for a German documentary?? If she migrated here a decade ago and still can't speak German or express her views in a global language, you can see where exactly the problem lies!!

[@mihirpingle5067]

If she is Indian then for sure she is fluent in English and they mentioned that she is fluent in German. Maybe interviewer encouraged her to speak Hindi. Maybe you are trying to search for the problem when there is no problem.

[@arpanmandal7244]

Another puslim from Hyderabad

[@hersh1818]

I did my master in Hamburg from 2010-2012. I could sense already the anti-immigration feeling there, if someone was a non-white student/person. Outside the university nobody spoke (or wanted to speak) English. Luckily I learnt German before moving there, so it was ok, but decided to move out in 2013, because I had an image of Germany far from what in reality it really was. All this happened before the big immigration wave of 2015. Always blaming the foreigners.

[@cnnc1707]

That's the easiest thing, blame the other. Locals do it to get rid of any personal responsibility and politicians take full advantage by fuelling anti-immigrant sentiment to earn cheap votes. Then they are not doing anything to solve the 'problem', of course.

[@_bhargav229]

The lady almost certainly speak in fluent English, but lets get her to speak in Hindi and overlay a translation to give the whole thing a more ethnic 'feel'. Ridiculous

[@soundscape26]

She spoke Hinglish.

[@user-pe8ez8mg3w]

I have a bad feeling that it wont just be Saxony. More like the whole of Germany! 😢

[@looker999997]

Yeah, I don't think the average German is concerned about Fatima from India. Ahmed from Morocco on other hand...

[@adolft_official]

when the nazees comes in hoardes, all browns are same

[@alvarotorres9057]

Is Germany safe for a tourist to visit? I am American but of Mexican decent. I plan on visiting Germany for 1 week. The only issue, I don’t speak German and was hoping on getting by speaking English.

[@alvarotorres9057]

Why are you so mean 😡

[@TanmoyBiswas]

are you seruously asking this question? Is it safe to visit Mexico as the country is ruled by cartels?

[@alvarotorres9057]

I guess I need to rephrase my question. I know my life will not be in danger in Germany. However, I want to know if people will be rude to me because of my skin color?

[@TanmoyBiswas]

@@alvarotorres9057 now it's an even worse type of entitlement. And I have a bit of doubt about your skin color. I am brown - we know what we deal with to live REGARDLESS of where we are - in one way or another. As a short-term tourist, you are making a big deal out of a wonderful country and its very generous people.

[@Kartoffelnfritieren]

​@@alvarotorres9057es kommt drauf an, in Gebieten im Westen sollte es keine Probleme geben, in teilen der ehemaligen DDR schon, gehen Sie einfach nicht in den Gebieten wo damals die Kommunisten waren, dann sind sie sicher

[@timothypeterson1903]

Hate to say it but this is going to be a big problem because the governments are ignore their own citizens. The US is trying not to let the news out but I could get very bad here very soon. As for myself I am planning on migrating out of here by next year. This place is falling apart at an accelerated rate

[@SuperCOCOPANDA]

Where will you go?

[@dhanyrafael]

Girls are awesome too. Prices are cheap indeed. Best internet in Europe. Gigabit networks. Perfect for remote work.

[@greegorygrimlee5487]

What's going to get real bad there?

[@timothypeterson1903]

@@greegorygrimlee5487 pretty much everything crime, cost of living, etc.... twenty years ago the small city near me maybe had a shooting every five years or more. Now it's several times a month. Car theft was almost non-existent now every few days. This city has less than 30k people in it. Retail theft, home invasions, burglaries, assaults are all going through the roof. This city has made it into the top ten most dangerous places in New York state.

[@mysterioanonymous3206]

​@@timothypeterson1903hmmm... Where are you going?

[@vamoskerala4762]

As far as I know they want to stop illegal immigration which is obviously a threat to the country. Secondly, it’s important for the legal immigrants to integrate with local culture and people. I have seen many immigrants stay away from Germans due to cultural barrier such as language, food, style of mingling and many other reasons. If you are an immigrant make sure you will not show your culture outside of your house, otherwise don’t immigrate.

[@bulthaosen1169]

Skilled workers will never choose germany as a top destination. The racism in germany is quite widespread. A friend of mine said she felt like living in a society where humans don't interact because people avoided her in pretty much everything. She moved to UK couple of years later.

[@minglee9288]

competing tax rates dont help much either

[@realnikhilpatil]

well it depends on person to person, I am a skilled worker with Blue card and me and my family are staying in Germany.

[@asmirann3636]

​@@realnikhilpatilYou are staying and that's it. You will never have real friends and you will never be accepted.

[@sweetmagnolia4990]

@@asmirann3636exactly, no matter how much you assimilate or integrate, Germany will never accept you

[@bugra320]

@@sweetmagnolia4990 No any other country accepts in this regard, not just Germany

[@PoliteCactus]

''After a decade in Germany she speaks fluent German'' and yet not a single word of German in her interview😂

[@amberleach5501]

Immigrants are nothe problem , it's illegal immigrants that are...I'm South African not even European

[@FredSveru.]

In my view, Germany should discern between attracting skilled individuals who are eager to engage with and assimilate into the liberal cultural values of the host nation, versus inviting individuals from a specific religious background (commonly associated with a peaceful faith) who may not share the same level of work dedication. Additionally, they may hold more traditional perspectives towards the LGBTQ community and women, potentially seeking to influence the host culture, including dietary preferences related to pork.

[@FredSveru.]

.

[@CugnoBrasso]

Yeah, of course protecting the LGBTQ community is the reason why you want them out.

[@willempasterkamp862]

with a car industry in decline (it has grown oversized) and a recession on the brink ? germany should give priority to its own population

[@helios7212]

Uhhhh what? Your post reeks of Islamophobia bro, maybe don't demonize people and treat them like garbage and they would be on your side and help your country grow and fill its labor shortages 🙄 as to the point of the video

[@CugnoBrasso]

@@helios7212 Don't waste your time, it's a bot.

[@tejanihiren2834]

If i like i can stay in foreign country otherwise leave it I don't want criticize host country , i will leave silently without criticism

[@PAX777]

I am a Non White immigrant myself and the rule is very simple. In Rome, do as the Romans do. If I, by my own volition ( as opposed to any coercion) have decided to uproot myself from my home nation/ culture and migrate thousands of miles to another nation/culture then the onus falls on me & my ilk to conform , respect, adhere to and integrate into the host society which has so graciously accepted me and given me a better shot at life than my own home base which FAILED me. Now imagine if I bring along the same cultural norms and attitudes that failed me & my ilk in the first place and then force the natives of my host nation to adopt and tolerate it? How do you think thats gonna work? Badly. Also, are the new entries into your land actually contributing a lot of positive or are they a huge burden on your welfare system? Are they law abiding or are they causing a lot of crimes, terrorism and mayhem? These are important questions to ask yourselves before you open the flood gates. Western Leftists or Liberals ( as they call themselves) have unfortunately greatly affected this process which is now causing a blow back. For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. If people could only apply honest logic and commonsense instead of utopian delusions, I believe things would have been a lot better in recent years.

[@patbenz4327]

Left wing romans or right wing ones?

[@PAX777]

How about Romans who transcend Right or Left. Besides, by todays standards the Romans could not have been leftist woke lunatics - just sayin'@@patbenz4327

[@faselfasel2864]

What this video slanderously calls anti-immigrant-sentiment is actually an anti-ILLEGAL-immigration sentiment. Thats a huge difference. Everybody, who is willing to work here, learn the language and accept and integrate into the culture is welcome to do so legally. That is even the stance of the AfD. So stop trying to slander germany with intentionally misleading statements.

[@jamestk656]

I personally have no problem with immigration whatsoever only as long as they integrate well. The ones who don't even try should leave. However, some cultures don't adapt as well as others and people use a very broad brush to paint all immigrants as the same. If only the government hadn't been so lax with their requirements before, there wouldn't be so many of these problems today.

[@Rx_VV]

We understand concerns about German society, we respect Germany 🇩🇪and ideas of German people, the main issue is here Radikalismus und Es ist eine richtige Krankheit der Zivilisationen ☹️😡the Guests should obey the rules of owner of the house uncondinitionally ✋🍻🍻🍻🍻 wer möchte jetzt Bier trinken ??

[@ivanhelmut1043]

DW says she speaks fluent German but all throughout she speaks Hindi. And she even says the word "integration", but how can you prove integration when during the interview she spoke Hindi and English, and not German. Hmm

[@Spright91]

If I move to Germany they should expect me to become german in my custom. Its not fair to expect the country to change their culture.

[@RoadstersRegistry]

THE PROBLEM WITH INDIA IS OVER-POPULATION

[@rmrrao2675]

Europe is stealing professionals from India. Go get your immigrants from other EU countries. Indian companies are losing talent.

[@SonsofThunder1234]

Yes, which is why they have to live, study and work in every western country. They need to learn self control.

[@RoadstersRegistry]

@@SonsofThunder1234 We must give them free condoms

[@JhilmilBasu]

​​@thenakedtruth7136 and you have a sick mentality. The population increase is mostly because if illegal immigrants from Bangladesh! Get your facts right!

[@NaSaSh1087]

​@@SonsofThunder1234India fertility rate is below 2.1 , next please

[@p382742937423y4]

Please stop replacing us!!!!

[@alidanish6303]

Germans need to read more on their demographics especially their native birth rates. Then they need to learn a bit more about commercial aspects of their industries, exports and labor markets. When the native population will dive to see the actual need of the country they will realize its culture vs economy. And its not just Germany its the future for everyone on the planet either save the culture or save the economy. Sorry for the dream breaker in advance.

[@saureld2229]

This would never have been an issue if it was only legal immigrants, when politicians are putting illegals ahead of locals because they serve their interest better obviously the settled people will protest because their concerns are not heard.

[@neilc4544]

Its GERMANY mate, they are famous for it. Why would anyone want to migrate there?

[@cowubl]

They never changed from WW ..They are still same. N words

[@brendatenorio5721]

Isn't Germany her country?

[@lailumahhassamkhan277]

I would feel the same sentiment towards so many outsiders

[@007vissa]

She is running a business there and saying all about integration but in the entire interview she was using a language thats not German. Thats the problem. If Europe takes in only skilled people who can speak their language, who have the capability to earn their own money, pay their taxes and completely assimilate, no one would have problems.

[@human8454]

Then who are going to pay their pension bills 😂😂😂😂

[@Tamilclan]

She in 10 years in germany im sure she with indian passports, why she talking bloody hindi talk in german

[@soundscape26]

That's Hindi? If so it has a lot of English words...

[@anishsawant]

​@@soundscape26these new age indians use a language called hinglish which is a mixture of English and hindi

[@soundscape26]

@@anishsawant Thanks for the info.

[@abhi2511768]

Illegal immigration poses a threat to any country, while legal immigration can be a blessing, especially for nations with an aging population. Prioritize preventing illegal immigration!

[@itsmejohnson5931]

If she speaks fluent German why isn't she speaking in german or even attempting her best German to the DW reporters? Why some female voice is translating ? Remember you can only fool yourself.

[@jayantdrummer]

I think a view-point which lot of American and European media missed out is that a LOT of people from the Indian subcontinent are desperately looking for any way to settle in a developed country - largely NA or Western Europe. There is no such thing as "Went for studies and 'happeened' to stay back". In fact, it'd be seen as a defeat (by the individual, by the family, by friends) if they returned to work in India after studying in NA/Europe.

[@pajeetsingh]

Now this is truth combined with Western blocks willingly giving lenient entry.

[@AbhiAnand-vn4rq]

100% truth

[@cerveauy8782]

This is changing rapidly with the economic growth of India. More & more people want to head back or stay in India.

[@jayantdrummer]

@@cerveauy8782 Oh yeah? Can you share some numbers to support this claim?

[@umakantapradhan5745]

​@@jayantdrummerIT is growing rapidly in india you can check by your self so many people are coming back to india to work in india

[@sassan7278]

I am from Asia and married to a German. Most of the family support AfD, so I was afraid at first. However, they are very nice to me. They even volunteer with their own money in Asia and Africa almost every year to construct infrastructure since decades. That's much more impressive than just saying everyone is welcome but doing nothing concretely. Their opinion was not let them come to a different culture, if they can't have German mind, but let them build their own state where they are culturelly close to by helping them.

[@TanmoyBiswas]

building "their own state" ? where exactly? enough land has been given (actually forcefully taken) for this particular cultur's expansion already.

[@Old....school866]

Compared to other countries in Europe Germany is better and safe to live for Indian immigrants. We have good dialogue government to government

[@steffen6987]

The fact that she isn't even speaking German after 10 years is a perfect example of why immigrants are getting so much hate.

[@ryanscottlogan8459]

Germany needs to encourage childbirth among its citizens with tax cut incentives.

[@Freyja_M4106]

A man Can and Has been medically made to create and cary a child to full term (surgically removed ofcourse), soooo... You First

[@asmirann3636]

There is already Tax incentives. You pay less tax if you have children.

[@dave_sic1365]

​@@asmirann3636no. You pay less tax as a married couple as it is expected that you will have children sometime

[@kitchens222]

😂

[@user-hz4gh7ig9b]

European white should produce more children. Downfall of western civilisation is low birth rates

[@quxintai1391]

I don’t think they are against Indian or Asian ..we all know who they are against for

[@anm3037]

Please tell us those people… romanians?

[@Average_Bruh]

Perhaps making integration a bit easier. There is a lot of bureaucracy and paper work. Not to mention just arriving. Not knowing German. Go to integration course and German is taugh in German. That doesn't work for everyone. Getting employed and having to deal with jobcentre is another issue all in itself. Until one has obtained a b1 certificate or higher. Jobs are quite limited. Then when you do get a job, possibly being paid minimum wage and then having to inform jobcentre knowing that they're going to cut all benefits and then start sending you bills to pay back the support you received. That's all a lot for someone who just got a job, to deal with. Bills, transportation, groceries and paying back jobcentre all from minimum wage, on top of having to continue with language lessons. Being an immigrant isn't easy. And those who were born here think that it is. They just see foreigners and think they are basking in support. Nope. Not so. And I'm not talking about illegal immigrants either. And then on top of all that, y'all acting as if racism and micro aggression aren't factors. The solution is get rid of those who are here illegally. But also make it easier for those who are legal to integrate. Specifically, more intuitive and understanding language classes doesn't expect you to know German, but rather expect you to learn it. If I know German enough to understand instructions being given. I wouldn't need to be attending beginners class.

[@JoshKell7163]

Keep singing about needing foreign workers (legal immigrants.) It is not "anti-immigration views" but "anti-mass illegal migration views." Get it right DW!

[@netiturtle]

I doubt there would be large rise in anti-immigration views, if there wasn't such a mass forcing themselves in. Latter are also not "skilled workers" DW, don't degrade your journalistic standards over ideological views. But those entering legally, may indeed receive spillover effect, at no fault of their own

[@user-cj7xk1vi8u]

Welcome to Germany hahahaha the people here in Germany will see you as eine Ausländer egal was du machst alter ist so

[@bloom1934]

Germany doesn't need immigrant workers

[@nicholashanson9508]

Europeans have the right to preserve their own culture

[@randomguy4116]

Hopefully Germany can take Indians in Canada. Danke Germania!

[@cowubl]

Canada is also Na ccii people and terrorr fundingg

[@Drganguli]

They want your labor but not you…

[@darkmage4648]

My thinking exactly. But India is in such a bad shape for women, what can we do? Lol

[@cowubl]

Your finding is not true babe@@darkmage4648

[@asmirann3636]

​@@darkmage4648Most rapes in the world happen in US, South Africa. And Europe is a hub for pedophilia. Have you ever heard these Russians who are always ranting about Europe spreading pedophilia. The reason they do it is because it's the truth. Just check the statistics for child sexual abuse in Germany or any major European country. Then you will realise that it is a serious problem. Still the Politicians are unwilling to address because many of them are also active abusers of children.

[@-GostuS-]

Maybe the lady from the beginning of the clip has forgotten what happened during the new year a couple of years before.

[@yippiyaying4375]

Most nations in the world today are based on language. Germans speak German as their first language. Obviously, mass migration will erode the linguistic status of Germany. I can speak 10 different languages but my identity will always remain French, Russian, Ukranian British etc, etc. Now coming to the American continent, today's Americans have no idea that the country stands on the blood of 100 million native Americans which preceded the multi-cultural society. But other than the US, most countries are formed on a linguistic basis.

[@leakyabstraction]

To be honest Germany is a nice country, it just has too many Germans, plus a weird language, but we're working on fixing it (jk)

[@lucasrodrigues9766]

Do Germany really immigration? And if so, why exactly these ones? I am sure many people from Eastern Europe and the Balks would want to go work in Germany is they need more people

[@harshasatyaratna4606]

Fatima feels unsafe wherever she goes.... ignore her

[@story-zm3kh]

I lived in Germany for 6 years and i feel discrimation is there. personally i was pushed 2-3 times intentionally while walking on road.

[@brokencliche]

Sorry to hear that. Where r u from btw ?

[@myigity]

the same thing happened in Düsseldorf, at least two times...

[@asmirann3636]

​@@myigityYou should push the other person back as well. Its simple. Someone pushes you, you push them back.

[@stringplayer2992]

I think that would lead to an all out fight. @@asmirann3636

[@ericzong1189]

@@asmirann3636 this is perhaps bad advice. some of this bullies could be dangerous.