GLOCK 30SF VS XD-m 45 Compact

[@johnfrie7273]

30sf is a monster. Been carrying it for over 25years 365 days a year. Awesome weapon.

[@danjones3402]

Amazing, original same gun??

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Agreed, the 30sf is an amazing firearm. One thing that stands out for me, it somehow has the softest felt recoil out of any 45 I’ve fired. Not sure of the logic behind it, knowing the weight & size would typically not agree, but feels great nonetheless. As far as carrying, that’s where I have found comfort in other models. Myself being a fairly large person, the thickness of the slide - was a tad too much for my liking.

[@Trump_is_a_Criminal]

You’re a liar the G30SF came out in 2008

[@johnfrie7273]

@@Trump_is_a_Criminal You are correct and a smart mouth. Should have said I’ve been carrying for over 20 years and the G30SF since it came out. You feel better now your panties are untwisted. Buffoon.

[@whodat5047]

@@Trump_is_a_Criminal😂😂

[@rustythrombosis5417]

Could you imagine, in this day and age, a cleaning lady or someone else discovering you in that hotel room with all of those pistols? Dear Lord!!!!!!!!!!! Nice vid, BTW.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Shhhhhh!😅

[@ray.d.oeaux1230]

This is a thoughtful, no-frills review. Well-done. Both are fine, dependable guns, but I would go with the Glock 30S.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Thank you

[@irish1695]

You give an exceptional breakdown of both weapons, more so than most other videos Have seen when comparing these two excellent pistols. Bravo!

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Thank you

[@shamarmiller1281]

I love both lines as I own both.. I absolutely love the xdm . It's just a challenge to carry due to its being so top heavy

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

I have no affiliation with this company, but if interested in appendix carry, check out holsters from Shooter Industries. I am a big guy, and can comfortably appendix carry any of my firearms, even during long drives. If looking for the holster for the XDM, I found that the holster designed for XD 4” fits the XDM 45 compact like a glove. Just fair warning, be patient with the shipping. They take a while. But the price is very reasonable (around $30). Like many people, I have bought holsters ranging in prices, from extremely high, to low. These are the best by far. It may change your thoughts on carrying the XDM. My personal favorite of the options they offer - are the appendix holsters that include the claw (which holds the grip closer to your body when tightening your belt).

[@NormanPOlt]

Although this XDM 45acp magazine has the last witness hole at 9, it is actually a 10 round magazine. Warranty-wise, GLOCK does take care of their customers.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

I’m not sure if the mags are different with the newer models, but I tried this out, after reading this comment. For the life of me, I can’t squeeze the 10th round into the mag😂. Not the biggest deal though. I have a few compact (California XD model) mags, that are 10 rounders. The options leaves a slight gap at the bottom of the mag when inserted. But the discomfort just requires a little creating, using Talon grip tape around the exposed mag area.

[@alfonsorj70]

The new Springfield 3.8 Elite 45acp comes with a ten round magazine the base pad is a little longer to hole that tenth round..

[@StevenRogers-hw9dj]

@@alfonsorj70 The mag in the video has the flush baseplate. That limits it to 9-rounds.

[@Vladpryde]

I have small hands, so for me the XDM would be my choice. I had a first gen XD-45 way back in 2006-07, and I loved it. I stupidly gave it away for free to a coworker who needed a gun to carry on duty, but I loved that thing and it never failed to go bang. Accurate as hell too. The XD-lineup has always been the only double-stack .45 that fit my hands. Glock just doesn't cut it for me......way too thick, whereas Springfield has found a way to trim a little off of the width and LOP. I'm currently looking at the XDM Elite Compact, but I don't know which one I want: 9mm or .45. I've dismissed 10mm.....my current carry gun is a Glock 22, and I don't want another snappy recoiling gun. That and 10mm is too much power (in my opinion) for self-defense on 2-legged predators, and I have a 4" .357 Magnum with 180gr. hardcast loads from Buffalo Bore that I can carry out in the sticks if I need protection from the local 4-legged predators. Seeing as how I also want the full-size version with the 4.5" barrel, then I'll probably get the compact in 9mm to have compatibility with mags and ammo, unless Springfield does the right thing and releases the full-size version in .45. That gun in .45 is definitely appealing. Thanks for the review!

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

The XD 45 compact is one firearm I regret letting go. But after purchasing this XDM, I really didn’t find the need to continue owning the XD. But it is still missed nonetheless. It was an excellent shooter.

[@scottstoddard6282]

I love my glock 30s I carry it daily. I carry it with the 10 round mag and other days I either carry it with the Glock 21 magazine or the 41 magazine just depends on my feeling that day. I have to say that out of all of my guns and I have several my go-to everyday carry is my 30sf with a couple of 10 round mags or a couple of Glock 21 mags.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

The SF is amazing. I regret removing it from my Conceal Carry rotation. After shooting for the first time in a while the other day, I fell in love with it all over again. It truly is an amazing shooter

[@scottstoddard6282]

@@californiahigh-desertconce7999 absolutely that's why I cannot take it out of my rotation and it seems to be the one I go to everyday LOL. Don't get me wrong I love all my other ones but this one is just so compact but it packs such a punch I'm not worried about anyting.

[@hugostiglitz9864]

My 30S had a lot of FTF's out of the box. Glock customer service was not as good as I thought they would have been...tried blaming me for the malfunctions but finally sent me a shipping label. They replaced the slide lock spring and spring load bearing. Better so far.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

I’m glad they took care of you. Glocks are great running firearms, and extremely easy to work with. I had a recoil spring issue with another Glock I had, producing the same issue. Once I replaced the original guide rod - I haven’t had a hiccup since

[@hugostiglitz9864]

@@californiahigh-desertconce7999 Did you stick with the stock spring tension on the new assembly?

[@C_AVATAR]

Good comparison! Your vid is the only one that I've found that showed that! I'm planning on getting both. Appreciate it.

[@regality78]

Try the G30s. Slide is slimmer like the xdm

[@douglasphillips24]

Glock 30S for me all day cause you get a 36 slide on a 30 frame.

[@bishopgeorge1333]

I have the XD-m Elite Compact 10mm and love it I'm also want the XD-m Elite Compact .45 acp but I'm waiting for it to come out.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

I am truly Jealous. I want the 10mm compact, but will sadly need to wait until I retire, and relocate out of California. The 10mm XDM compact is not available on the California roster. I was fortunate with the 45acp - by being in the right place at the right time. Consignment purchases of off roster handguns can be bought from an LEO, which of a rarity. This XDM was my once in a lifetime opportunity, so I jumped for it.

[@jamesharris6336]

I won't take anything from Glock they're good guns. But for me it's the Springfield xdm 45 3.8 I've been carrying it for a couple years now and to this day it works perfectly and still comfortable

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Agreed. The XDM has been amazing, as far as reliability. But the Glock continues to fire as well. The one thing I do have to say, in regards to the Glock 30sf. The recoil is definitely one of the softest shooting 45’s I have fired. I imagine a lot has to do with the thick slide.

[@jhs8496]

Gun porn usually isn't the kind of porn recorded in inexpensive hotel rooms.

[@buttchunksofdoomd4939]

Atleast we know we should be able to be allowed to legally hold firearms in our hotel rooms with us

[@cbwelch4]

I have a G19 and an XDM Mod 2 Compact .45 3.3. Have to say the XD points better IMO. Also the trigger pull on mine is a bit lighter. Both are rock solid reliable. I had to replace my recoil spring on my Glock and not on my XD. The internal build is nicer on my XD. Both are bet you’re life reliable.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

I agree. All of your points are pretty spot on with my same opinions

[@gutadin5]

you mean the XDM has lighter trigger pull?

[@Jim-oo7dk]

I'd take that Springfield in a second, if you could find them. The accessory rails, the grip safety.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Most definitely. This firearm will never part from my hands. If I did let it go, I would definitely never see one again. Here in California we have a Roster of handguns we are allowed to purchase. The XDM doesn’t qualify. The only way an XDM can be purchased from a California resident, is through a Father, grandfather, or son (who reside in a different state). Or if luck is found, you can buy an off roster firearm from a Law Enforcement Officer, which ended up being the route I found success.

[@357mag84]

PSA has them clearanced right now for $370

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

That is an incredible price

[@357mag84]

Sorry, $350

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Even better!

[@jimseaman2558]

Great job on the video. Well done and informative.

[@MarvLegacy]

The 45 acp compact xdm Springfield elite has a 9,10 and a 13rd magazine option. However, you can also buy an extension sleeve that makes your handgrip full size if needed. Though, you want to make sure its compatible with your base plate because you can modify each base plate for seasonal concealment as well.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Yes, since this time, I’ve seen different options. I’ve always known if the 13 round full size mag. But over recent months I had found the elite mag bottoms, which allow for one more round, making the XDM 10+1. In addition, it provides a full grip to handle, if people are not comfortable with the two finger grip

[@MarvLegacy]

@californiahigh-desertconce7999 - Exactly, although I like glocks better, because they are proven by police forces nationwide. Furthermore, glocks are like ar's because there are just so many things you can modify from finding easy parts. Last but not least, the safety lever is like a 1911 on the Springfield xdm elite's, which brings comfort with one in the chamber for me

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

@Cabron444 yeah, I’m sort of a fan of both. Actually all guns for that matter. The only knock on Glock that I had, especially going for the Glock, 30, or the 29, is how thick it was inside the waist. I tend to appendix carry, so it left a little discomfort, compared to my others. I can’t attest though, both have fired thousands and thousands of rounds, and never failed me yet. I do agree, Glock definitely has the long track record.

[@MarvLegacy]

@californiahigh-desertconce7999 - Likewise, I agree

[@dimassalazar906]

My G30 was the most accurate 45 I ever shot. The grip and balance was just too odd for me.

[@davidt5085]

Nice comparison, always like seeing side-by-side and length comparisons with the different size mags. Regarding the slide width comment, have you considered or tried the 30S? Same frame as the 30SF but a thinner slide (1”) and I read that many G19 holsters will actually work for it. The 30S is on my very short list of next pistol purchases.

[@thomaseynon6205]

Unfortunately the 30S is not available in my area. California has a restriction on which firearms can be purchased

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Within a different video I posted, I ended up purchasing a Glock 36. Finding that it had the same slide as the Glock 30s, I installed that slide to the Glock 30 frame. Went to the range, and it performed with the same Glock reliability we’d all expect. Upon my return, I called Glock, to ask about the mix. The man on the phone confirmed that this was exactly what Glock had done. They renamed it the 30s, but California wouldn’t accept it for the Roster. Definitely a shame. The mix generates an outstanding handgun

[@jorges2000]

I keep telling myself I need a 30sf. Already own the 21

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

The 30sf is an amazing handgun. As funny as it sounds, it is one of the softest shooting 45 I’ve fired. Oddly enough, even shoots softer than the 21 (speaking from the generation 3 platform. And best of all, it is concealable.

[@pic6162]

Had the XDM 3.8. Awesome weapon.But love the Glocks, so I switched.

[@Xander_Park]

Springfield Armory for the win 🏆

[@jamesjones4309]

Lol, the only thing better than Glock is hk

[@JP-yt3nk]

I shot a 4.6 9mm XD-m, P30L and a G19, I chose the one I shot the best groups with. Which also was the best deal. Wanted that P30L, but it was 300 more, and needed a $200 trigger.

[@cfbodman2]

I just bought the XD-m today with 2-10 rd mags very good price new in box. Glocks are great for some just not me, salesman was trying to sell me a Glock but for $399.99 SA won out plus I also CC a Kimber Pro TLE II so size was not a concern. for me.

[@kingowolf9477]

How did you get the XDm in cali? I believe only the standard Xd's are the the bs roster.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

I happened to be in Gun store at the same time an Officer was attempting to trade his XDM in for store credit. They couldn’t come to an agreed price. I stepped in, and asked how much he wanted. The moment he said $550 - I jumped on it.

[@desalvothedon]

I've never owned a glock but I've shot quite a few in different chambers. Tbh I didn't like the way any of them shot. They all felt uncomfortable to me. I've shot several Springfields and they all felt very comfortable and they were all accurate. So I side with Springfield. No hate on glock though. They're very good guns but they're just not for me

[@chltmdwp]

That's because glocks don't use the US grip angle.

[@localgunguy4992]

Every Springfield I’ve shot always had more snap than it’s competition…always! I’ve owned several and had several others shoot side-by-side. They all agree. The XDM is easier to carry, but that’s about it. My Kahr PM45 is badass, but less rounds and the trigger takes a lot of practice to get use to. Glock hands down…

[@Lee-rq1ek]

Not a Glock fanboy but the standard Glock 30 is the great ! You do your part for accuracy, and the pistol will deliver.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Agreed. I just brought it out for the first time in months the other day. The felt recoil is noticeably smooth, when comparing to other 45’s I own. I had forgotten how great that firearm truly is.

[@joewest1972]

Nice review but geez you never mentioned weights. To me for an EDC this is a pretty significant consideration. I'll just search this elsewhere. Seems lots of reviewers talk about all the dimensions down to the thousandths of an inch, but neglect weight differences. I don't get it, you're not alone.

[@chevyvega6622]

i have never understood why someone would buy an auto that only holds 6, one could just get a snub nose revolver for 6 shots. the glock holding 10 is the no brainer here

[@bradlaurence5323]

This xdm holds 9. The newer versions hold 10. Idk where you got 6 from?

[@10init]

They have an xd compact that is single stack its only got 6 rounds i believe. Thays probably what this guybis talking about​@bradlaurence5323

[@oneboyscout3653]

Great comparison

[@GOTCHAPARK]

Good review. Thanks for sharing

[@2ndAdvent888]

Give me the Glock everyday and twice on Sunday

[@chillios2222]

the block gun carried everyday definitely digs in the side, actually had to buy a new barrel on my block, block mags are usually ok to locate, xd takes down easy, replacement parts on block are easy, xd been around long now

[@steveosmonson6535]

Nice review, anywhere to get some night sights for a xd9 sub? Thanks

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

I found a great deal on Amazon

[@infamousnova]

Still in the HD?

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Yes. Been here for almost 7 years

[@infamousnova]

@@californiahigh-desertconce7999 sweet, im here now

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

@@infamousnova it’s a great place. You’ll definitely find a fair amount of BLM areas to shoot.

[@rickdavid1795]

I have both in 9mm, I want both in 45acp

[@marklott8235]

The spinfeild comes with a 13 round magazine

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Yeah, but the 13 round mag is much more difficult to conceal. I’ve heard the newer XDM elite compact has a 10 round flush fit mag which would be great. But in order for it to fit on this models, a bit would stick out, knowing the standard XDM compact doesn’t have the Magwell added.

[@lucabrasi5070]

I have 9, 10, and 13 round mags for my G30s. All depends on what I’m wearing and how I’m carrying it. As with any gun, the bigger it is, the more it prints. I’ve owned both of these guns and they’re both fine weapons. No problems with either. I sold the SA because the G30s was the one I preferred to shoot and would pick up every day. Just fits my fat paws better but that’s different for everyone.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

The G30 is an amazing firearm. I wasn’t too fond of the thickness of it while carrying, but the magazine options were nice. Although the XDM can provide the same magazine benefit, the one undeniable benefit of the G30 is the soft recoil. Out of all my firearms in 45 acp, the G30sf shoots extremely soft

[@paulcoffey1784]

Glock feels to fat next to my waist all day. I prefer the slim outline of the XDM Springfield.

[@mistahsuzuki250]

The xdm shoots nice

[@wtpence4731]

All videos Should include Weights ! Otherwise good video !

[@jamesjones4309]

My dx firing pin on my 9 and 45 go bad. My Glock is so much reliable.

[@themudshark1106]

Everyone know's better.

[@paulgladden2444]

Glock has a lifetime warranty

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

They have switched to a one year warranty a couple of years ago. This is the link: us.glock.com/en/own/warranty

[@dmgthree6051]

Not really !!!

[@thebusterdog6358]

The XDm holds 10 rounds in the mag and one in the pipe. At least every one I have seen does. The choice is easy for me. The XDm hands down. I don't own, have never owned and never would own a pistol manufactured by any company that knowingly, and willingly sold to terrorist originization which Glock did. Google it!

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

The original XD compact 45 offers a 10+1. This XD-m 45c was one of the first gen models, which came with a 9+1 round mag. I can fit the 10 round XD mag inside the XDM, but it leaves a little extra mag below the grip. From what I understand, the newer XDM 45c models offer the 10+1. But living here in CA, these things are difficult to confirm, due to the limited firearms we are approved to purchase. This particular model, I was fortunate to buy from a LEO. Which - to those unfamiliar with California law’s, their are two ways to purchase an off roster firearm. Buy from an LEO, or you can purchase through an intrafamilia transfer, which is buying from an immediate family member (Parent, Grandparent, or child). I had received a different comment a while ago, claiming to have seen the XDM models, equipped with 10 round magazines.

[@macaddict73]

I'll take most anything over glock the. Canik!

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Everyone definitely has their preferences. I’m a fan of both. But I’d say overall - my heart belongs to the 1911 platform.

[@ep6606]

California??

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Yes. In the high desert (between Victorville and Barstow area).

[@G61100]

Check out the XDS

[@kevinrichardson8859]

XDS is a BEAST!!! Nice little pocket 45!

[@KsooTheYouTuber]

I'll have my xd taken apart before you even get the tabs down on your glock

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Most definitely. Both are extremely easy to break down

[@primsolllineguy8689]

Nice video, but the word quality is being used incorrectly. Thicker is not necessarily better! Quality is conformance to a standard. If the Glock component was thicker it would demonstrate poor quality. Reason being that is how it was designed. After SA is around as long as Glock, and enjoyed the same market share then and only then can your point be proven. Additionally alloys and internals are made from different metals as well. As a metrology professor I would suggest that a deeper dive is required with respect to quality. One thing not mentioned is the grip safety. Great Idea until it fails! I do not have a horse in the race but with Glock having a market share with police and the military we need to . ask why? Me thinks there is a reason for the scales being tipped in the favor of Glock.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Thank you for the reply. But I didn’t want to go into too much of the metallurgy aspects of each, knowing it may provide a loss of interest from a traditional gun review. Especially knowing we are talking about handguns. But for a better breakdown, the gen 3 Glock parts are made from 416 stainless steel, along with the barrel being 416r stainless. The Springfield XDM parts are made from Billet steel, which I believe in comparison is known to be a much stronger steel. The XDM 3.8” barrel is made from hammer forged 4140 steel. Which although both the stainless (Glock) barrel, and the (XDM) 4140 hammer forged barrels can provide benefits for one over the other, barring rust treatment needs for the XDM barrel requiring a bit more attention, in theory the 4140 forged barrel will produce longer life. The stainless barrel used in Glocks however, may produce better accuracy. But where that margin can be minimized, is knowing the XDM barrel has been cut to better tolerances, being a match grade barrel. However, with all that said, we are talking about handguns. The chance that an average shooter can shoot the parts out from either gun, the cost of the ammo needed, would make the subject irrelevant, knowing what that individual could likely afford. As far as the grip safety, I personally have not had any experiences with the failures I’ve read about in the past. But considering the design of the 1911 providing the same safety mechanism, and the longevity those handguns have provided over 100+ years, I haven’t felt any concern. At the end of the day, it’s about what the shooter enjoys more. Their are Glock fanatics, and their are Springfield fanatics. Whichever preference an individual has, they should feel confident they have a pistol that will likely pass through generations. With regards to contracts, that can be a suspect topic, which can be misleading at times. Many, if not all contracts are influence by money, and overall costs. It is a no brainer that Glocks provide less expensive parts, less parts, and the brainpower to bring one back to life, a competent 8 year old could piece one back together. Springfield, not so much. A good example of a handgun that had won the FBI contract for the Hostage Rescue Team, came down to being the Springfield HRT 1911. Manufacturing in mass quantity essentially granted Springfield the contract. But the gun that beat Springfield in nearly every category was the Les Baer S.R.P. However, keeping to the one Gun, one Smith mentality that has been the trademark for the Les Baer 1911’s, they admittedly could not keep up with the demands/requirements needed for the FBI. Another good example was the FBI switching from the 40 s$w ammo, back to the 9mm. When reading through the entire report, they clearly mention the bigger diameter bullet of the 40 was still greater than the 9mm. However, with the progress made over the years with the 9mm, it had developed enough to fit within the requirements needed to be an affective round. Again, justifying the savings in cost.

[@jcoats150]

I won’t buy a Glock with finger grooves.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Out here in California, that is the only option we have. Unfortunately with what is known as the California roster, we are only allowed to buy Glock Generation 3 models. Their are ways to buy Gen 5’s used. But because they are such a rarity, they sell for extreme prices. A few weeks ago my local firearm store had a gen 5 on sale, priced at $2,100 - on a consignment deal. A week later it had been sold for $2,000. Although I do like Glock, I’d never pay that much for one.

[@alexskillz45]

They are so east to take off.

[@calvinnelsonjr6465]

I like my Glock 30sf !! I don't do grip safeties . Imma point and shoot guy

[@-Cold-World]

SA lifetime warranty because you'll need it, they break, you'll send it back.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Maybe🤷🏼‍♂️. Or it could be possible that they believe in the product they sell so much, that they offer the lifetime warranty, knowing it will likely last the persons lifetime. I don’t have experience having issues with either firearm. Both have been fed thousands of rounds, and have held up extremely well so far.

[@boostedbilly7308]

You forgot one SIG p220 legion 45 APC

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

I’d love too include that one. Unfortunately that is another off roster firearm in California. I have yet to see one on a consignment sale.

[@giancaaleandri4253]

Non sente nulla indi non si capisce nulla!!!!

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

Mi scuso. Questo video è stato registrato in una stanza d'albergo. Non volevo avvisare i miei vicini che avevano armi da fuoco.

[@dmgthree6051]

XD sucks !! Glock is far superior!

[@themudshark1106]

Prove it!

[@timmckenney6981]

I quit watching when you said the xdm has a 9 round mag. You don’t know what your talking about.

[@californiahigh-desertconce7999]

You may want to research your comment, before going keyboard Commando Bud. The original flat plate XDM 45 acp 3.8” compact magazine is 9 rounds. If you are referring to the XD 45 compact, then that my friend would be a 10 round Magazine. But those are two different models, as you likely know. Can they both take the full size 13 round service model Mags with the proper grip extension for each model? Well yes - both can (assuming you fit the assigned grip extension to the chosen model). But hey, don’t just trust me. Go ahead and do a bit of research. You may learn a thing or two😉

[@matthewsniff]

Tim McKenney, if you want to tell someone they don't know what they are talking about you should know the difference between "your" and "you're".

[@1stFlyingeagle]

Spring change out is because when you cycle a springs that wears a spring out. Like leaving a mag fully loaded does not damage the spring. But load and unload a mag does wear the spring out. Cycles.

[@buddysumner4022]

The glock is not in the xdm league,

[@themudshark1106]

I agree having both.

[@KsooTheYouTuber]

I'll have my xd taken apart before you even get the tabs down on your glock