GRINGA IS NOT CRYING! - BAND-MAID - PUZZLE ACOUSTIC LIVE - REACTION

[@reenster7768]

Kanami, the Guitarist is a fenomenal Human Beeing. Half time of the day is practise, the other half composing. She is just a genuis!

[@bruceveary1758]

Proof that you don't need to know what is being sung for music to touch your soul.

[@TJandTheGringa]

YES~!

[@Nomad59696]

Kanami’s backing vocals destroy me every time too. You’ll probably be asked to do Anemone by a few folks and it’s definitely right in the feels just like this version of Puzzle

[@himbo754]

It really shows off Saiki's ability to express emotion when singing. Kanami is perfect in support.

[@bigbrutalbassbeer410]

If she teared up during Puzzle, she definitely wouldn’t be able to keep it together during acoustic Anemone! Now THAT was performed with high emotions!💪🏻🤘🏻

[@britwill72jp]

This acoustic version made many reactors cry. Please try "Anemone" acoustic, next!

[@GaryHolloway-810]

Shout out to Kanami. Her haunting backing vocals compliment Saiki's vocals perfectly. "Anemone" acoustic next from the same concert, please.🤗

[@starocean62]

Hello hey there's a short video when miku and kanami are checking out a 12 string zemitis guitar miku is trying to tune it and kanami sings the note for her to tune to and miku say human tuner it was awesome check it out it's very short

[@GaryHolloway-810]

@@starocean62 No i haven't seen that, thx Star ocean i'll check it out :)

[@amgerth]

Its Tony Visconti's guitar (1 of 3 made at the time) that he brought to the NYC show in 2022.

[@GaryHolloway-810]

@@amgerth And it sounded awesome. Pity the maids let him get his hands on "TDC".🤭

[@cygnetseven]

Puzzle Acoustic brings me to the edge of tears but Anemone Acoustic pushes me over the edge.

[@BillHallisey]

Tequila Jimmy and Gringa, first of all, I love the background on your reaction video. Secondly, Gringa, don't be embarrassed about shedding a tear to this acoustic version of "Puzzle". Even grizzled old men, like me, shed a tear at Saiki's beautiful, sad, heartfelt singing. It says something about a vocalist when they can cross language barriers, age, and even gender to make the listener feel and respond to what they are singing. Saiki is one of those vocalists.

[@TJandTheGringa]

Perfectly Stated! Thank you so much!!

[@lartranslation6929]

goodness, your wife is a godess, and your musical taste is impeccable, great reaction

[@TJandTheGringa]

Thank you so much ♥️♥️

[@RobinC63]

Glad you mentioned the guitar tone. When I first this oh so long ago it was the first thing that hit me. This version is a punch in the gut feeling, not in a violent way but a feeling of loss and unrequited love. Never be worried about shedding a tear Gringa, I wish more reacters would let it out rather than holding it in. ❤ Jimmy, When you mentioned how they look on stage it showed your knowledge and understanding of Japanese culture. To me anyway.

[@TJandTheGringa]

Robin you are always so great and insightful with all of your comments. Much love from the both of us!

[@RobinC63]

@@TJandTheGringathank you ever so much. That means a lot to me! 😊

[@BM4-Life]

Amazing how 2 musicians can silence a crowed so you can hear a pin drop. *BAND-MAID* Rock On! 🤘🤗

[@TomClark-Futoura]

No matter what venue or band format, Band-Maid always brings something unexpected and special to the eyes and ears... and heart! 💝🎀 Thx, Jimmy & Gringa!

[@TJandTheGringa]

Thank you so much for watching!! ❣️💖

[@TomClark-Futoura]

@@TJandTheGringa 🙏

[@leekebot1802]

As emotional as this song feels (And I do love it), the song that affects me the most of theirs is "About Us". During the lockdowns they were unable to be on stage for too long a time. The fans missed them, and they missed the fans right back. And one day out came "About Us". A love letter to their fans, that really showed that they cared deeply about them. And of course the song itself is amazing. It always has a place in my ever changing top 10 Band-Maid songs list.

[@tanitatt]

The rock version gives off defiant vibes while the acoustic version is melancholy

[@TJandTheGringa]

Agreed!

[@tonygriffin_]

I've been moved to tears by Band-Maid a few times over the years and bless them for having the ability to do that. They invest so much emotion and thought and hard work into all they do and it is reflected in their performances every time. After this rendition of PUZZLE, Kanami and Saiki then performed another song in the same duet style, ANEMONE, which always - and I've watched it a lot over the years - but always moves me to tears. For some unknown reason they removed it from their YT channel about 4 years ago and now it is only freely available on that Chinese site (though you can, like me, always buy the DVD!). The finale to their 10th Anniversary gig last November in Yokohama Arena is one that will have you crying - and all of us watching - but it's for joyous reasons as the song is ENDLESS STORY and, while the lyrics are beautiful and moving, it's the performances and the rawAF emotions pouring from every band member as they perform the 33rd song of the night and say goodbye that hits hardest. Then there's ABOUT US, the song they wrote for the fans in the middle of the plague years and which tells of how they miss live gigs and us and how they know we miss them too. They livestreamed a few gigs during those times and premiered it for us at one of them. Saiki gave the most moving speech before they performed it and when they played it, it was, for me, a moment of catharsis of all the pent up emotions I had from being cut off from friends and family for so long and losing 6 friends in 18 months. I sobbed but it was with relief; a real catharsis. I never listen to it now as the first few chords are enough to make me tear up but (if you need a good cry once in a while!) I'd recommend it very highly. And there's the wonderful and moving performance by Saiki, alone on the piano, performing CHOOSE ME at Yokohama Arena - kzbin.info/www/bejne/apy1iYeJj5ycq9Usi=l_pyC-WUISNdlTlk

[@thisismadness6962]

The puzzle was coming apart. Thanks for the reaction.

[@TJandTheGringa]

🍻

[@Prober61]

Yeah, I've heard it 20 plus timesand when she had tears so did I. Still.

[@emeryharrison9325]

I believe these ladies can do just anything they want and it would be great.

[@wolfscoat6207]

The five phases of sorrow. denying, anger, dispute, depression, acceptance. Saiki was able to show this with only her voice...an incredible singer.

[@roumiaou]

Oh.... Good choice. I'd suggest "Daydreaming" next. An all time classic. With emotions :-)

[@armynurseboy]

Normal Puzzle is an argument. Acoustic Puzzle is a lament.

[@philcalvino884]

I know you saw the live full band version a while ago, but it's worth seeing the lyrics again. They are some of Miku's best, and Saiki wrings every bit of emotion out of them. PUZZLE Your first "hello", The sound of a puzzle piece falling into place. I'm sure you don't recall, But that's fine with me You gave me a shelter, where your light Scatters the shadows of my despair. Keep your innocent smile, you said. Even if my love is not returned, Don't care what number I am! Aaah...those are just lies. Mustn't look, mustn't know, It'll only give me pain. But I long to know, Can't resist. Even if it is just for a moment. Eroding my defenses, You knew, one word, and I couldn't resist any more, Then embraced me. Step outside and we seem just strangers. Only me longing... Like sweet candy melting away, Someday you'll disappear too Leaving just your sly look, your smell. But that's fine with me On my own at night- Where are you? What are you doing? The more I think, the more I can't sleep. I shouldn't be selfish, But just wait patiently for you? The answer is clear. I can't do it! I can't say it! Really I know, Seizing my desire just can't be. Yet, as my fingertips touched you, I'm sure, I felt love. Don't think to apologize. Enchant me, I will look away. This incurable wound I crave, cuts deeper. I'm falling for you again. Lighters I don't use, Glasses in line, Even new clothes. Don't cry! All mementos of you. I just want to remain In this dream with no end. Will I ever wake up? Don't cry! Let me believe. Mustn't look, mustn't know, It'll only give me pain. But I long to know, I can't fight it, Even if it just this moment. Eroding my defenses, You knew, one word, and I couldn't resist any more, Then embraced me. Step outside, we seem just strangers. Leaving me longing... The puzzle is breaking, Memories aren't enough. I close my eyes and, again, Again, I'm falling for you.

[@TJandTheGringa]

Beautiful

[@artomatt]

I'm glad I'm not the only one who gets teary-eyed when I hear this song. Even though Saiki keeps singing "don't cry" 😉 My sense from the lyrics is that the narrator knows she will never have this man for herself only, but she can't help herself. Honestly, Miku's lyrics, even in translation, make me cry too.

[@bradmenpes809]

Don't worry about crying, La Gringa ... I cry when I hear this song, and I'm certain many others do, too. Only the hard-hearted would not feel the pain in Saiki's voice. The beauty of every Band-Maid song is revealed in acoustic performances. Another great reaction.

[@TJandTheGringa]

💓💓

[@markmathewssgbcpenaltyboxs6389]

Love them acoustic. It really shows the beauty of their voices.

[@MusicMike747]

Saiki delivers the emotional message in any language.

[@billmcleangunsmith]

This is my favorite performance of any song by any band at any time.

[@Pigeonholed-Po]

🤘Band-Maid🤘

[@cius2112]

i see several people suggesting Anemone acoustic, which i support but def also do the studio version too to see the differences. (and maybe the BAND MAIKO version Ansen 😀)

[@daft73games]

😃👍

[@geoffb5]

Love this version. By the end of it I just want to tell Saiki I'll do anything to make her feel better. Whatever these ladies do it is always great.

[@franciscojavierfernandezmo1974]

Cualquier canción de BAND-MAID podría ser la mejor canción que hayas escuchado en tu vida. Tomátelo cómo te de la gana, pero es así. No BAND-MAID, no Life ¡¡¡¡¡ BANDMAIDHEAD !!!!!

[@laughingbuddha2948]

Here on the other side of the world, seeing this reaction, and got teary eyed too. Thank you for this reaction! Also, same concert, they sung "Anemone" together. You will love it.

[@TJandTheGringa]

Thank you for watching!

[@daveminers3404]

Another wonderful acoustic version of a BM song that gets my eyes a little damp is "Smile", specifically the Online Okyu-Ji Feb 11, 2021 version. It's on YT but it's not an official video. I think they did it on their Christmas acoustic show, too. Nemophila's "Life" does it to me too, but you have to turn on the subtitles to get it.

[@BlahBlah_13]

Nice reaction. Saiki does a fantastic job of expressing the emotions of unrequited love through her singing, much more so in the acoustic version, IMO. And Kanami's backup vocals help elevate those feelings. While I still prefer the live, non-acoustic version, both are great performances.

[@rossmudie9298]

We're a big bunch of softies us Band-Maid fans because when you cry we also cry 🤘🤘

[@JK-tz6kk]

The acoustic version is one of "sadness" and "lament," even closure of this puzzling relation vs the ANGRY/Confused version of the "third railed" Lover's viewpoint in a Puzzling relationship scenario. Band Maid piercing the heart through their storytelling, Po! Both are masterpieces, Po! 🦍🍌

[@K.H.D710]

This is one of my fav Saiki's singing performances. She was also an actress before joining Band-Maid.

[@schelin1447]

It's a beautiful version of the song!

[@Paul247to]

Hi guys as always I love your reactions, especially the Gringa setting the mood with the maid outfit. you know that half your audience were teary eyed, though some will claim they were just cutting onions lol Puzzle is such a masterpiece composition, whether it's full band or just a simple acoustic, it's awesome either way! I really hope we see you guys back on Aug 7th when Band-Maid release the collaboration video with The Warning called "Show Them" lots of teasers on YT and IG right now and it's going to be awesome with 2 full bands playing together bridging the best of the east with the best from the west. cheers

[@TJandTheGringa]

Thanks for this awesome content!

[@zer0tzer0]

As long as you're doing the softer side of BAND-MAID, they did an entire set of acoustic stuff for the Christmas Show. The real stand out for me was a Miku song, 'Sayonakidori', which means Nightingale. It's well worth checking out. There is an Electric version, but the acoustic version is pretty special. And though it's cool to see Kanami sing back up for 'Puzzle', it's not nearly as rare as seeing Akane sing backups, which as far as I know, 'Sayonakidori' is the only song she sings backups in. And you get to see how far Miku has come as a guitarist.

[@nagyalex5310]

You should check out the next song right after this one. It’s anemone acoustic! Greetings from Romania

[@Charles-ce7ev]

The brilliance of Band Maid. To take a song like Puzzle, an absolute rocker and do a beautiful ballad that hits the soul, is just incredible. But they do this all the time. That is what makes them the best band, rock or otherwise, out there. Just a little aside. I think the original electric version is an angry Saiki blaming the dude for deceiving her. But the acoustic version seems like she is hurting and blaming herself for falling for his lies. Just saying.

[@realdocloco]

Lyrics are by Miku, so no personal experience from Saiki. And Miku always say she find inspiration in movies, mangas, anime ...

[@throwaway9389]

...and books she's reading.

[@daveminers3404]

No personal experience from Saiki - at least, not that we know about.

[@fernandoNovo59]

Kanami's angelic voice really enhances this song! - I would really love to see her sing lead on just one song.....I would be in heaven....Thanks for this great reaction - Peace & Respect from Canada!

[@Chatwin78]

Lovely reaction. Thanks.

[@TJandTheGringa]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@EliseAutoXr]

It really is amazing how music crosses language. Great song and reaction, well done! Thanks and looking forward to the next one.

[@TJandTheGringa]

❤️

[@BRO-HI808]

As good as Saiki's lead vocals are, and they are fantastic, I think Kanami steals the show on this song. The sound of her voice, especially when she's holding it sustained...WOW! Goose bumps every time! It's amazing how Band-Maid impresses in the acoustic setting, whether it's 5 Maids, 3 Maids, 2 Maids and now even a single Maid. PO!🕊 🤘😆🤘

[@donaldbohn3183]

Mincho singing with Saiki🥰

[@realdocloco]

Fact: Kanami don't like singing! But she learnt to do it properly as she thought it was necessary for a professional artist ...

[@GaryHolloway-810]

Spot on Doc. And as you know all the Maids can sing but some enjoy singing more than others :)

[@realdocloco]

@@GaryHolloway-810 Kanami Tono: plays like a devil, sings like an angel.

[@GaryHolloway-810]

@@realdocloco You know what, that would make a great quote on a t-shirt.🤔

[@RahimRahmat]

It also helps that Kanami feels she needs to do her best to complement her beloved Saiki in this song....

[@realdocloco]

@@RahimRahmat "if Sai-chan say jump, I jump" 😁

[@haggaisimon7748]

There’s an older version of Puzzle, 2017 Coast version which I like even more than the official version.

[@Willywin]

I believe the lyrics were written by Miku who is the Rhythm Guitarist (the one with the red rose - Kanami, lead guitarist, is playing guitar in this video) I have been told that Miku will often take her inspiration from things she sees around her and not necessarily from personal experience.

[@moscatodasti1]

They perform some very beautiful acoustic versions of their songs. They are really, really good. The acoustic version of Sayonakidori is one of my favorites, you even get to hear Akane sing!

[@donaldbohn3183]

Mincho adores Saiki, and it really comes out here!

[@brunobryant4846]

Gringa is not crying and neither am I 😢 so gorgeous Po 👍🍻

[@grahamreed8774]

This is so beautiful. Try Anemone acoustic from the same show- Saiki has an even deeper voice. Can't say any more right now. I'm back now you've finished. Said before- If Saiki sang like this in English, she would be internationally famous by now. Not to forget kanami's beautiful back vocals.

[@barrycounts490]

All of Band-Maids acoustic and traditional songs are awesome ! Please check out Band-Maiko "Secret Maiko Lips" MV for another side of The Maids =) Thanks

[@starocean62]

I told you to bring tissues

[@TJandTheGringa]

You warned us ! lol

[@sugaanessena3143]

I'm DAYDREAMING of a Saiki/Kanami🥰sideproject.

[@daft73games]

Beautiful version of Puzzle. There is a second song that follows this one called *Anemone* I suggest you watch this one as well. 🤘❤‍🔥🤘

[@akatzukianlun]

Thank you for supporting BANDMAID..❤❤,, new subs coming up..

[@TJandTheGringa]

Thank you so much!!

[@threemonkeysk]

Get's me too... every time😥

[@throwaway9389]

Oh ya, you'll love "Anemone" acoustic.

[@bandmaidfanATL]

🧩Po😢

[@ichinov]

🤘🤘🤘

[@Puyax01]

I need that shirt

[@TJandTheGringa]

haha..THE CRITES!

[@chakouyang2545]

Kanami should sing more

[@Kissthetoad321]

Some say that the lyrics of Band-Maid songs are rather positive. In a certain sense, yes, but when Saiki sings them with emotion you feel their deep meanings. Isn’t that the Gringa? You haven't said which version of Puzzle you prefer? THANKS.

[@TJandTheGringa]

They are both great although this one really strikes the emotion and turns on the water works lol

[@kakqu]

I have an allergic reaction to this song.....Po..😭 ☕⚾....🕊🍌🍻

[@RogerChance5309]

🍺🥲