Haley Reinhart American Idol 2011 Milwaukee Audition

[@lukusblack6442]

Still the most remarkable vocalist I've heard to date. That includes established artists.

[@jamesstout6006]

I don’t know how she didn’t win it’s crazy

[@TooChillery]

Wow you got to listen to more music

[@lukusblack6442]

@@TooChillery Ok, so she's no Demi, but she's got a great voice.

[@theblackdog2399]

@@TooChillery Obviously, you hurt your head some kind of way and never fully recovered. Tell me, who appeared on American Idol over the years that has a better voice and that can sing like this: kzbin.info/www/bejne/o2TPd2WneqZlmdk&ab_channel=PostmodernJukebox or like this: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qXOZeYxup55racU or like this: kzbin.info/www/bejne/laaxoXiYqZyqldE&ab_channel=MikeRonkoske or like this: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pZWvfKCOorSBY9E&ab_channel=HaleysTusk or like this: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pZ7XpHt7qJeaZtk&ab_channel=WesleyNotttradingas%27It%27saBoomerang%27 Go ahead make my day. In fact, back it up by posting links. Otherwise, see a doctor about your brain damage before it becomes permanent.

[@theblackdog2399]

@@lukusblack6442 Haley can easily sing circles around Demi and if you were a true fan familiar enough with Haley, you'd know it too.

[@davidhill8565]

Haley Reinhart is the real winner of American Idol season 10.

[@grandmaster_gus]

She's the real winner of American Idol full stop

[@Sg4809]

Yes that was the year I stopped watching

[@davidhill8565]

Shiena Gossar You missed out on Jessica Sanchez.

[@stevebradbury1914]

The SLAYER is the best singer to come out of A.I. PERIOD!

[@laurenxperryx]

Who even won it ?? Like nobody knows !?

[@babaspector]

Best singer in Post Modern Jukebox in my opinion, so I went searching for these auditions :)

[@TubetakerBHV]

I like Morgan James more, but Haley definatly is great too.

[@kawskipropaganda]

Omg same

[@AuntieFa]

Same!

[@Kasino80]

Morgan and Hayley are great together also. Have you heard their Dear Prudence?

[@wiggy123abc]

To be honest they are all good in different ways

[@disenocorporacionsentir9546]

It must be wierd for jennifer when the contestants sing better than her ;)

[@lizklosowski6487]

Most of them did!

[@spacecowboy364]

Someone needs to do a Haley Reinhart vs. JLO video. It would be very enjoyable and at the same time very gratifying to watch Haley completely destroy her. Inevitably it would become a very popular KZbin video.

[@ber420mgd]

For fucking real!

[@BeaulieuTodd]

I highly doubt she is that pettty. Nobody is the best and performers understand that.

[@jamesstout6006]

So true

[@spacecowboy299]

Haley turned out to be the best American Idol contestant in all 15 seasons.

[@davidhill8565]

Space Cowboy Haley Reinhart is a great contestant, but that title belongs to Jessica Sanchez.

[@spacecowboy364]

I want what you are smoking. Haley is a world-class vocalist and performer. Sanchez, on the other hand, is Bush League at best. Haley turned down every major record label last year to sign with Concord. Sanchez wishes just one major record label would sign her, while Haley, on the other hand, can sign with anyone she wants at any time. Haley has a wider vocal range than Sanchez and astronomically far more vocal dexterity. As Haley can sing all genres of music, while Sanchez is primarily a R&B and a Soul singer. However, Haley can even sing R&B and Soul better than Sanchez. Not to mention, Haley has generated astronomically far more views on KZbin and Facebook relative to Sanchez too. Apparently, you are virtually unfamiliar with Haley Reinhart, but like a loon you are dumb enough to proclaim Sanchez as being better, when she is not close to being in the same league as Haley Reinhart. Anyway, when Sanchez can sing like the following, then come back and see us. :m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/f3iaoZ2Eidt6apY

[@spacecowboy364]

://m.youtube.com/watch m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/r4GnpWuvaKignNk m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/g3rTqaCMetR6gdU ://m.youtube.com/watch m.youtube.com/watch?v=hmmq m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/b4SlhKCmaZhqaas m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/rZKZqpaVhdGJe6s m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/d6aompWQd9B1naM ://m.youtube.com/watch m.youtube.com/watch?v=ek3uyC m.youtube.com m.youtube.com/watch?v=XaC955 ://m.youtube.com/watch m.youtube.com m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/ime3eoyYZrSXmtk m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/hovIhmqJZ91-pqM m.youtube.com m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/l3aVo5aigL6AbaM

[@davidhill8565]

Space Cowboy When you said about vocal range, you must be saying that Haley Reinhart is some Mariah Carey. Haley Reinhart may be more experienced, but Jessica Sanchez has more potential. However, based on what you’ve said about record labels, Haley has higher IQ than Jessica.

[@davidhill8565]

Space Cowboy Jessica Sanchez has way more Twitter followers than Haley Reinhart. Jessica has 1.5M, while only has 205K.

[@vidpie]

In 2017, Randy Jackson started podcast. Surprisingly, given their history, Haley was his first guest (promoting her 3rd album). He told her something he never expressed to the Idol audience: "You are one of the ones that I really thought would have a career because doing that stuff you do with the jazz stuff is not easy. It's hard to do, and you sing it with more melody than a lot of the songs on the radio today. Some of them I love, but they're like four chords. So with four chords your melody is always going to be limited. With the jazz stuff, it's about singing through multiple chord changes. It's a very different thing, so your ear has to be trained so acutely, and then you also love the rock side. So I always thought it was a really interesting thing." He also told her, "If they remember you, you won." She really seemed to appreciate that.

[@wagonerstreeexperts7890]

I’m on my husband KZbin, but I loved Haley the moment I heard her on idol. Don’t hear much from her now, but I still can’t get some of the songs she sang out of my head. Her versions of the songs. Rolling in the deep. House of the rising sun. Benny and the jets, and more. I loved her!!!

[@vidpie]

​@@wagonerstreeexperts7890 Haley's probably better known now for her work with Postmodern Jukebox (PMJ), and a rendition of "Can't Help Falling in Love" accompanied by Casey Abrams on the piano. PMJ features different vocalists each week, and she is their most-watched. Dominates the top 10. #1 is their rendition of "Creep." with 105M YT views. After a six-year hiatus from recording with PMJ, she returned to perform "Don't Speak" (original by No Doubt/Gwen Stefani). Her "Can't Help Falling in Love" cover has 310M Spotify streams.

[@joehohmann6015]

In 2024 we definitely remember !!!

[@whimsicaltraveler7811]

You can really tell that JLo has a problem with even getting out some mild praise for Haley.

[@babydaddy4886]

Jlo just seems really nasty ngl

[@tutle7507]

Mad because she’s better than her

[@willclancy4731]

I was about to say it’s cause she can sing better than Jlo 😂😂😂😂

[@twinklydoor5752]

She’s just a horrible person in general

[@ForeverSweetx3]

Yes she is a narcissistic

[@233roz]

Now that's a Star, that's The Haley Reinhart, amazing singer, and a real beauty.

[@maxafshar]

man her voice is shaky and so fucking beautiful I cant wait for her new songs

[@kanezim1135]

She has better voice of all 3 judges together

[@bentul7422]

Wait a minute, can I laugh?

[@Kevin.Kelly.]

It’s funny because it’s true.

[@jamien.5528]

Maybe that’s why they didn’t let her win

[@jiminsluna13]

Not against Steven Tyler!

[@da324]

But she'll never write songs as memorable as Tyler's

[@stevenmorris3181]

From "Come back next year" to greatest singer on the planet. What a trip

[@missdee4927]

Should have been a superstar. I still watch videos of her singing these days because I just adore that voice.

[@bertjones3010]

Superstar. Makes me wonder just what that is. Someone the industry dresses up to do their bidding or someone who makes music for themselves and shares it with the world. She has done a lot outside of strictly music, with voice acting and actor acting. I'm not sure people who really appreciate what she's done over the past dozen years would be that big of fan had she had her soul sucked out of her to represent a label. I'm not saying she couldn't have done what she wanted (Bonnie Raitt did) but her experience around both AI and her recording contract certainly did nothing to bolster taking that route.

[@shesfatale]

The judges were awful to her throughout the competition. American Idol lost all credibility for me when Haley was voted off. She's clearly the most diverse and talented singer that's ever been on Idol.

[@nicholasmorales24]

That’s so true! I was hoping for a Lauren vs Haley finale.

[@nzs316]

And looking at her today boy they must be eating crow. I have such a profound respect for that girl. It was probably the best thing for her to have been voted off. They could no longer tether her or take advantage of her talent to their profit.

[@trailerparkcryptoking5213]

🎯💯. She should have won! It was Simon that gave her a lot of 💩! I think she is the best female vocalist out there!

[@tombritt5223]

Well not Steven! His crush was 2nd only to Paula's for Adam Lambert! :-)

[@JruGordon]

What an amazing voice for 18 years old

[@delg1211]

Negative. An amazing voice, full-stop.

[@BuffyFluffy123]

I love Steven he is so cute

[@cpynch]

If you haven't, listen to her sing "Creep" by radiohead... it might be the best thing I've ever heard.

[@childofthesun8889]

That's what sent me on the binge of checking out all her videos, she's SO great

[@lenafoxy7674]

If you haven't listen to her "Don't Speak No Doubt" one. Even better.

[@stephanyjaramillo-mata1650]

Lmao 2019, she used to be my neighbor and she gave me a free cd and I took a pic with her! Her sister is the nicest and also Haley!

[@tracybranch2955]

She was my pick for season 10. Actually --- the best of all of seasons. Most versatile etc, etc.

[@johnholzhey8149]

Love Haley. She is a great blues and jazz singer. I think she's been a mentor on the Voice too.

[@vidpie]

Haley has been a mentor on American Idol twice. Last year, 2022, she mentored the “Soul” genre during Hollywood Week. In Feb 2016, she mentored and performed with two contestants. She did: - "Can't Help Falling in Love" with Adam Lasher - "Bennie and the Jets" with Kory Wheeler

[@1969MARKETING]

crazy how much she's improved from then until now

[@theblackdog2399]

Not vocally, but performance wise she has.

[@1969MARKETING]

@@theblackdog2399 oh no i mean both. def. both. her vocals are more polished now.

[@theblackdog2399]

@@1969MARKETING You're absolutely wrong. Her vocal skills are exactly the same as they were when she was on American Idol. However, she has polished up her performance skills a great deal. Obviously, you were not familiar with her back then as you are today. So you are assuming what in reality is a myth.

[@1969MARKETING]

@@theblackdog2399 sorry you don't get to tell me my own opinion is wrong. it's an opinion just like yours is and everyone is entitled to have their own. Yes i am very familiar with this artist. You're simply making a lot of assumptions.

[@theblackdog2399]

@@1969MARKETING Okay, your opinion based on very fictitious information and utterly stupid assumptions sucks to high heaven. I hope you like this response far better.

[@stevebradbury1914]

Best singer to EVER come out of Idol, PERIOD!!!

[@TubbaTubba-em2tm]

Not even close

[@stevebradbury1914]

@@TubbaTubba-em2tm who's better?

[@bbmac4able]

She was robbed back then. I quit watching really after that because she was the best singer that ever came out of that show IMO.

[@musicallyliliana9096]

Me and my piano teacher listened to some of her covers, he told me Haley Reinhart used to be his student! He helped her to get here!!!

[@nelsdanburg5407]

One of the greatest contestants to ever be on Idol. And in the top three best to not win along with Joshua Ledet and Adam Lambert.

[@Jeweleye62]

Agreed, but Casey Abrams was also pretty cool.

[@nelsdanburg5407]

@@Jeweleye62 Oh Casey Abrams was excellent! Such a great and interesting guy tbh. Season 10 was in general, an extremely talented and diverse season which I loved. He's for sure in the top five, but I definitely wanted Haley to win, she was my absolute favorite, and I desperately wanted a finale with her and James Durbin, that would've fucking SLAPPED.

[@Jeweleye62]

@@nelsdanburg5407 James was also pretty fabulous....it was a particularly good season with some very interesting characters and an eclectic array of voices. Honestly as much as I wanted Adam Lambert to win on his season I actually think now that the shackles would have limited his potential to soar. Who was and where is the winner now?! (Rhetorical question). 😊

[@nelsdanburg5407]

@@Jeweleye62 That's a very valid point. Adam has a rare career in his back pocket and if he won Idol, I think that his options would've been limited like those of Kris have been, even tho I think he's also excellent, for sure one of the better guy winners. Just not quite Adam Lambert lol.

[@TE5LA-GAMING]

Uh... Jennifer Hudson? She came in 7th on Season 3.

[@gusromanalucero8082]

Amazing vocals.

[@alanmeyer2699]

Just look at her now. She's amazing

[@ChrJahnsen]

She is the most talented singer to hit the music world in decades. Absolutely flawless and ridiculously good looking to boot. 💝💖 A female Elvis! The fact that Haley finished third in American Idol says a lot about the quality of judging.

[@brianstrange7942]

Just remember, America votes. It says more about how the average person doesn't realize talent, and appreciate someone as gifted as her. To me, she has the whole package. I don't get it either, but there are people out there that like rap better than singers, so what can you do?

[@bertjones3010]

Only she didn't finish third because of the judges - though granted 2 of them did nothing to encourage people to realize how great she was. The feckless country voters voting along party lines, so to speak, placed her third.

[@Michael-cr2rn]

Still my favorite Idol contestant...

[@TheMoonandBack]

I found out she use to come to my school and use to be in my English

[@pixiefairy0455]

Mochi's Jams did you ever speak to her? And is she sweet?

[@SpaceCattttt]

Is your English different than mine?

[@bagellover1203]

i live near wheeling and when i found out where she came from i was like damn

[@jerryqueer]

omfg army-

[@davidhill8565]

I’d rather see Haley Reinhart in concert at a rundown theater than to see Scotty McCreery in concert at a state-of-the-art arena.

[@tomsmithnosky3408]

I am so glad that she did not win and get roped into that contract . She is one of the greatest singers i have ever heard

[@bertjones3010]

well she did have a contract after the show, cut an album, had the record company bail on her.

[@eva_pruiett]

Boy the moment Haley walked into that auditon room, those judges had NO FREAKIN IDEA what a TALENT Haley is and what she would become.

[@pipsqueak9292]

I love her personality

[@davidhill8565]

Haley Reinhart should've won instead of Scotty McCreery, who relies on fanbase rather than talent or perseverance. She is one of the greatest contestants, but not the greatest (that title belongs to Jessica Sanchez). Artists like Haley Reinhart and Jessica Sanchez are a rare commodity. Artists like Scotty McCreery and Phillip Phillips are a dime a dozen. Jessica Sanchez is the greatest singer I've ever heard in my life.

[@spacecowboy364]

With all due disrespect Sanchez is not even close to being in the same league. Educate yourself first before you make a complete and utter fool of yourself in public next time.

[@davidhill8565]

Space Cowboy I don’t think so. It sounds like you’re saying that Jessica Sanchez is a mediocre singer who shouldn’t have made it to the live shows. There are many lesser known singers who are in a higher league than already famous singers (most of them autotuned). Maybe Jessica Sanchez is the greatest singer on American Idol who never got famous. She doesn’t need autotune for her vocals. Last year, she showed what she’s really capable of during the American Idol season 15 finale.

[@lenafoxy7674]

​@@spacecowboy364 Commenting so you remember this utterly embarrassing comment you made 😂.

[@spacecowboy364]

@@lenafoxy7674 Sanchez is a good singer but not good enough to get signed by a major record label and become a major star as she has demonstrated already. Meanwhile, all the major record labels have been trying for years already to sign up Haley Reinhart who in stark contrast to Sanchez, is a world class vocalist. and song writer. As the only reason why Haley isn't a major star today is due to her own personal choice to remain independent. Meanwhile, Jessica Sanchez, on the other hand, would gladly sacrifice her left breast to get a record deal with a major record label. Meanwhile, I like Jessica Sanchez as a female vocalist. Nonetheless, she isn't in Haley Reinhart's league. She's not even close. Not to mention that Haley is a multi-platinum selling independent artist. How many independent artists are multi-platinum selling artist on a par with Haley Reinhart? As I don't know of any other independent vocalist who as an independent artist that has even reached the gold standard, let alone the multi-platinum standard.. Haley also has KZbin videos with more than 100 million views. How many KZbin videos with more than a 100 million views does Sanchez have? Zero. Why? Because she simply is not in Haley's league as a female vocalist. Moreover, Haley is an astronomically far better song writer relative to Sanchez, who makes her living singing covers only. Here you go, here's an example of Haley's song writing skills. "Don't Know How To Love You" kzbin.info/www/bejne/qqPVkmivgsh6ppI&ab_channel=Sp0ngeB0b "Honey There's the Door" kzbin.info/www/bejne/aaeWgaathLh1Z5o&ab_channel=HaleysTusk Those are just two examples of Haley Reinhart's own music. As both those tunes would be major hits had Haley released them via a major record label, as opposed to independently. Haley has written many more tunes that are just as good. As Haley, unlike Jessica, is a hit writing song writer .Whereas Jessica doesn't write her own music. Plus, Haley is a world class vocalist and Jessica is Bush league at best.

[@kellymarie6031]

All I know is I'm glad the way everything turned out! Pmj is unlike anything anybody has ever done & Hailey is a HUGE part of it!

[@kuceracm]

I really liked Steven Tyler as a judge. Seems like he was really having a good time and has a passion for music. He was also very encouraging too.

[@vidpie]

Steven Tyler made an effort to be encouraging. His father was a music teacher in his later years. His father was also the son of a music teacher. He died in September of 2011. Steven Tyler: "The gifts that he gave me during his life, and (to) others, will go on for another lifetime. He died living. He lived to a ripe 95,” said Mr. Tallarico’s rocker son. “I’m getting calls from hundreds of people that he’s touched by virtue of passing on his music, knowledge of music to others at school and the songs that he played for people. He celebrated life in such a way that he’ll never die. I’m just grateful for what he passed on to me.”

[@musicismyreligion5213]

Haley has more talent in her pinky than JLo or Randy could even dream of having. And they judge her?...absurd.

[@petewylde6592]

Come on, it´s a scripted, directed and produced tv show, it´s entertainment that brings in money to the network that shows it. Its all bout the money. Haley is on such a high vocal level that most people can´t understand her skill set anyway, that is the nature of the beast with todays music listeners. They want musical "fast food" and that´s what they get.

[@theblackdog2399]

They weren't judging her. They were deliberately sabotaging her at the behest of the show's producers. Nonetheless, in the end they all miserably failed. As it was the almost unlimited power voting that American Idol permitted, as opposed to one vote per individual voting, that caused Haley to be ripped off.

[@dyanaavendale8810]

She’s so amazing. Catch her with Jukebox!

[@shelbyfraiser1817]

She is m favorite singer in the world

[@Madmen604]

Amy Is FANTASTIC!!! Absolutely. Great.

[@thecartoonistguy9843]

Automatic winner. No questions asked.

[@Lourenco1975]

Haley Reinhart é um FENÔMENO.

[@Vortex-gz8se]

I still don't understand why she isn't a huge megastar. I know she is having a decent career singing at smaller venues, but she should be a megastar.

[@huntress1013]

I guess Haley didn't know that Jazz is her true calling. I I love her she is an amazing Jazz artist.

[@vidpie]

Haley loved jazz even then. She was the first person to ever sing with her high school's accomplished jazz band. They performed at the Montreux Jazz Festival in Switzerland. She studied jazz at Harper college and performed with the college's Jazz Ensemble and Jazz Lab.

[@racketman2u]

What a great year that was for Idol - surely it's apogee.. Scotty, Lauren, Casey, and yes, Haley, who got better as the series went on. I thought Casey was by far the most outstanding musician of the lot, and it's great to see them performing together still.

[@dickinson509]

I was glad Steve Tyler was there on this season - he seemed to be the only one who realised how brilliant Haley was.

[@davidhill8565]

American Idol season 10 was a true popularity contest.

[@cappiece3786]

Best it's ever been done

[@williamburdon6993]

Girl can sang!

[@DanAnkers]

Her music is great

[@OFBI7]

MII FAVORITAAAAAAAA.

[@realemmcee]

0:57 Randy how dare you

[@asaruxiii3026]

Looking for the audition they turned her down on, unless it wasn't aired. You guys tell me

[@davidhill8565]

Artists like Kris Allen, Scotty McCreery, and Phillip Phillips (all shouldn’t have made the top 2) are a dime a dozen. Artists like Adam Lambert, Haley Reinhart, and Jessica Sanchez (who are all world class singers) are a rare commodity.

[@theblackdog2399]

@David Hill...I see Jessica Sanchez wasted another year of her life going nowhere. When is she going to go on tour and make some money? She needs to expose herself and impress people if she ever hopes to get signed. Meanwhile, Haley is not only a platinum-selling artist that has well over 2 million followers on Spotify, but she is also a well-known songwriter. If she isn't touring, she is always writing or recording in the studio. She puts her nose to the grindstone and never stops working. In fact, she has two songs out right now at the same time, as she performed the following tonight on The Jimmy Kimmel Live Show with Jeff Goldblum: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aZrTiXRvoa-tmZI As she is featured on two tracks on Goldblum's new album, which has been number one on the USA and UK jazz charts for the past two weeks since it was released. Then she is also featured on a new Vicetones tune called "Something Strange", which she wrote for another artist, but the Vicetones came back to her and wanted Haley to sing it. So she did. It sounds very much like an Avicii vibe. It's a dance vibe. kzbin.info/www/bejne/o4vWpXpppdRrgrc&ab_channel=Vicetone Then she also recently finished recording a new album for herself that is going to be titled Lo-Fi Soul due out in January and this will be the first track released to the radio waves in January: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aoqqoGRmYsSUesU That song called "Don't Know How to Love You" will obviously become a very big hit song for Haley when it is released to the radio waves this coming January and per her manager, the whole album is filled with very iconic songs very similar to that one. If true, that album will launch Haley all the way up into the big time of music artists. In fact, her manager is hoping for several Grammy nominations from that album. Which will not be until the 2020 Grammys because the album is being released too late for this year's Grammy Awards. I hope he is right, we'll see soon enough. Anyway, here is a Vevo promo featuring Haley for Haley's new upcoming Lo-Fi Soul album. kzbin.info/www/bejne/rmaWlaxseblkgrs&ab_channel=HaleyReinhartVEVO It looks like her record label is going to go all out to promo Haley and her new album

[@BeastieBoy350z]

Haley is HOT!!!!!!

[@Andy224]

And THAT was her AUDITION?!?! Damn !

[@zoylist8]

2019??

[@oldguyblues]

Steven Tyler was a great judge

[@LauraJBrown-xe1jm]

I don't know what they were thinking putting J-Lo amongst talent like that. It's almost a joke.

[@ladyfox6705]

I am here because of the wave of YT recommendations I'm suddenly getting for Haley singing with the excellent Postmodern Jukebox. I realized I remember this girl from when I watched American Idol! She was fantastic back then, but boy, has Haley improved since. Seriously good, full of charisma & sultryness 🙌 J-Lo always seemed quite snarky imo.

[@Rials22]

she kind of reminds me of Steven lol(:

[@Taikyaa]

Mariah Riley they had great chemistry

[@chilzmapewwep2671]

Im here after watching more videos of her after she sang "habits" with modernjukebox and was popularized by tiktok or smthng uwu

[@minamladenov2085]

How Steven digs her and when she said lets rock it right; he looks at her a curious snake who is about to devour her :D :D

[@bouboullcd5879]

Une star , tout simplement

[@dangolfishin]

This woman is just so fine

[@michaelking9444]

Thank u for saying the obvious..no idea how more people dont see

[@dianahaus1456]

Why Englands X factor cannot be like that. Steven is very nice-a sunshine in there bringing good mood effortlessly

[@bronsoncashiola1426]

Boy Steven on point too!!!❤️❤️

[@thomasnappo6309]

Very talented😊

[@harrycrowe1803]

I want to see her audition from season 9! It’s remarkable to me that she didn’t make it passed the auditions

[@theblackdog2399]

Simon Cowell deliberately undermined Haley to sabotage American Idol because he was starting the X-Factor in the fall. He also did the same thing to Tori Kelly.

[@cmarq817]

Here after hearing Haley in PMJ!

[@davidhill8565]

Scotty McCreery won on the strength of his fanbase and power voting alone. With her impressive talent and stage presence, Haley Reinhart is the real winner of American Idol season 10.

[@sinjon]

And one of the best voices to come from AI was born

[@acehays]

Love the comments and couldn't agree more

[@Marieq]

I love Steven Tyler

[@willclancy4731]

She has improved so much tho

[@theblackdog2399]

No she hasn't. Vocally, she was just as good on American Idol as she is today. However, performance wise, she has very significantly improved.

[@lenafoxy7674]

​@@theblackdog2399Bruh really went to every comment that says she's improved just to disagree with them. Seemed a little obsessed. If you actually pay attention you can see she actually has improved her technique and control a lot. She had potential and she capitalized on it. If it's really about "performance to you, then listen to her sing an older song vs a newer one with your eyes closed and you can tell her voice now is more polished and she has an outstanding amount of control.

[@adamdent6292]

Randy with the perverse mind😂😂😂

[@denis9450]

This is the first time I saw Haley on this show I have seen her many times after this and she is so much better than hear. I thought that she Yodeled to much like Maria Carey but when she does not do this style she is outstanding

[@mikco99]

Randy pretending that he remembered her. H doesn't remember yesterday.

[@danniellejohnson448]

The way Mariah is so humble and chill as a judge compared to the one who can’t sing 😂

[@nazemm5342]

It's Bill Murphy singing... 😁😂

[@jasonfoster9118]

I think she's gotten a lot better since back then.

[@theblackdog2399]

Not vocal wise, but performance wise.

[@amylee021]

HOW did they pass on her the year before this audition?

[@poppycock288]

It was Simon's final year and he was deliberately sabotaging the show. He screwed over Haley and then he screwed over Tori Kelly as well.

[@FabiolaRodriguez-xs6ts]

Espectacular

[@gustavomontoya3005]

Desde un principio excelente!!!

[@SophiaPetrillosBuddy]

Steven Tyler is giving me creepy vibes...

[@MalloryNewcomb]

He is a flirt but I think he had a personal connection with Haley. She was a rock and roll girl & he loved that

[@asquare9316]

Haley has more musicality than all 3 of these "judges" put together.

[@bebeboi3230]

Was it Lee DeWyze's portrair beside Kelly Clarkson's ?

[@ErinSchoeman]

I hope she stays stronger and stronger in Christ's name 🙏

[@EdwinJ1O]

I go to the high school she attended. Haha so weird seeing Wheeling on TV 😄

[@panduadikara9078]

sure you do

[@Delta-gx4fm]

1:22 to 1:29 my heart just melts.

[@bigguys45s29]

Hey, it’s Bill Murphy.

[@hafsaxvi4027]

Am i the only one who thinks she looks like Alessia Cara, even the raspy voice...she looks like she could be Alessia's long-lost sister

[@theblackdog2399]

Yep. Meanwhile, Haley is a far better vocalist relative to Alessia.

[@calvinbiggs9296]

Haley & Pia should've been the final 2

[@theblackdog2399]

At the time, Pia was only a one trick pony who was not close to being in Haley's league. Since then Pia, thanks to her husband, has become a far better performer. However, she is still not close to being in the same league with Haley. Pia was the third best female on the show that season.

[@footrugist7657]

i like the song he sang with pity puddles called "mad world"

[@Y-Soightnie]

You could tell even then that JLo hated Haley for her outstanding ability and beauty. JLo would go on to sabotage her through unfounded criticisms, especially during the finale. JLo is a hateful person defending, what she perceives, as her territory.

[@MICHAEL_MAY_8]

Whoever rejected her first attempt on AI needs to lose their job.

[@theblackdog2399]

Simon Cowell. As it was Simon's last season because he was starting his new competing talent show also on Fox called the X-Factor. Hence, at the time, Simon was deliberately undermining American Idol in favor of his new upcoming show. In fact, he not only rejected Haley, but he also rejected Tori Kelly as well. Season 9 would have been outstanding with both Haley Reinhart and Tori Kelly competing. Instead, season 9 was one of the most boring seasons of American Idol ever.

[@alfudhalla]

Haley the slayer is my favorite contestant in idol history No matter how randy and Jennifer tried to sabotage her during the competition. I still consider her the winner

[@c431inf]

HR second to none

[@gracysiteny1412]

she is in a better place now ;)

[@theblackdog2399]

She is in the same place today, i.e., nowhere.

[@vamama100]

What is Jlo dpin here anyway

[@trishhall4522]

Fn awesome

[@rustynales6610]

How did lose the finals?=[x[