HARRY POTTER AND THE SORCERER'S STONE Movie Reaction! | First Time Watching

[@toodlescae]

In the books Hagrid was a little over 11 foot tall. Ron was also on the floor of the chessboard just like the other 2 and got smashed over the head by the queen knocking him out. Guess the movies thought people would assume that Ron getting off the horse chess piece would be considered an illegal move. Harry also didn't crumble Quirrell into dust and kill him. Quirrell died when Voldemort left his body that had been weakened by Voldemort's possession. Hagrid sent letters to all of the school friends of Harry's parents to get a bunch of pictures for him.

[@joshandcasey]

Thank you for sharing! Had been a minute since reading the books

[@ChelseaChfy-ex1po]

@toodlescae No Quirrell died because he had 3rd degree burns all over his body Voldemort left Quirrell’s body when Dumbledore showed up and tried to pry Harry and Quirrell apart by that time Harry was in the process of passing out and Quirrell was on the verge of death. So Voldemort had literally no good reason to stay.

[@garybassin1651]

Nicholas Flamel was a real person. He lived during the Middle Ages in Paris. His house still stands and has become a restaurant. Because of the popularity of the books and movies, they have created a Harry Potter menu for children. I had lunch there during my last trip to Paris. As for Maggie Smith, she has won 2 Academy Awards and many accolades through a most distinguished career. I would highly recommend your reacting to a few of her movies. Some of the best are "The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie", "California Suite", "Hot Millions", "Evil Under The Sun", and "Death On The Nile".

[@joshandcasey]

Thanks for the recommendations and background! We will definitely check them out

[@dawnmarieallenkent2495]

My best guess about the chess game... If Ron jumped off, landing on another space, it would constitute another move, thus messing Harry's move.

[@joshandcasey]

That would make sense

[@tamarasmith9060]

Yes & in the book it's a bit more obvious that the magical game knows Ron is the knight, not the horse. In the book, the queen hits Ron in the head with the flat side of the sword, it doesn't stab at the horse.

[@resathe6760]

@@tamarasmith9060 I'm also pretty sure Ron is standing in for the knight statue in the books just like Harry and Hermione are in the movies. He's not sitting on the horse. They probably wanted to ramp-up the action for the movie and it would be pretty hard to do if the queen had to hit Ron with the same force all the other pieces are hitting each other with.

[@sersastark]

yep

[@AdamNisbett]

The publishers apparently thought Americans would find the word “philosopher” too highbrow and uninteresting for a story about magic for kids so they changed it to “sorcerer” for the U.S. edition.

[@joshandcasey]

@@AdamNisbett haha of course that’s why

[@ezradanger]

We all like to think that we wouldn't have cared what the book was called, but I'm not convinced that the publishers didn't't make the right call.

[@AdamNisbett]

@@ezradanger I don’t know about the vast majority of the general public, but it definitely wouldn’t have mattered to me. I didn’t start reading them until they were already bestsellers and I didn’t hardly pay attention to the “and the ….” part of the title. For all I cared they could have been Harry Potter Book 1, Harry Potter Book 2, etc.

[@joshandcasey]

@@ezradanger Which title do you think it should have been?

[@ezradanger]

​@@joshandcaseyI don't think it probably mattered. But I do remember an entire generation of kids quitting rollerblading because of a gay joke. And philosophy really does sort of have a negative connotation in the US. People literally use things like "philosophy major" as an insult. So while I would like to think that it wouldn't have mattered, it's not beyond the scope that it could have.

[@livb6945]

The match is not Harry's second time flying. They practice every week during the school year but they don't show everything in the movies

[@joshandcasey]

Ah that makes more sense, the jumping through time is kinda confusing

[@Melissa-wx4lu]

The reason Vernon didn't want Harry to get his letter was because they knew about harry's parents being magic (ie. Strange and unusual) and they didn't want Harry to be the same and bring gossip about the family that might impact them negatively.

[@joshandcasey]

Ah ok. That makes sense.

[@grahamgresty8383]

Also Petunia knows there are protective charms which protect both Harry and the Dursleys. If Harry leaves for more than 50 weeks/year, the protection breaks and Petunia knows the damage dark wizards and witches can do!

[@MsAppassionata]

And they didn’t want him to learn magic that could potentially be used against them and their son.

[@AtheistNihilist]

John Williams score is kinda outrageously amazing. I feel we don't get scores of this quality these days at all.

[@joshandcasey]

@@AtheistNihilist for sure! His score always elevates the film!

[@MI-hz1cp]

The giant 3 headed dog is from greek mythology. Called CERBERUS; the guardian of the gateway into the underworld.... Take the house test you guys.

[@tamarasmith9060]

The "restricted section" is only for older students who have been taught basics & supposedly also understand the seriousness of the danger of dark magic, extremely difficult higher level magic (dark or not), & magical creatures & plants which could be dangerous if handled wrong. The students do have to get permission from the librarian to read individual books in the restricted section, & as you can see if a student sneaks in there somehow & opens a book off the shelf without permission then the books themselves have a built in alarm. The magical chains also prevent a student removing a book to view/copy without supervision.

[@joshandcasey]

Ah this makes more sense, thanks!

[@resathe6760]

Hagrid wrote to friends of Harry's parents and asked them for photos of them so he could make an album for Harry.

[@joshandcasey]

@@resathe6760 aw that’s awesome! Got to love Hagrid!

[@iulia.bianca.b]

56:30 Both actors for Dumbledore died. Michael Gambon passed away September of last year as well 💔 So much loss...

[@joshandcasey]

@@iulia.bianca.b yes! It’s very unfortunate. So many of them recently too

[@theDrasher1]

The chess scene: The kids are the pieces, Ron was the knight, he was sitting on a horse.

[@joshandcasey]

Oh ok, that's why!

[@beautybysaranwrap]

Welp the algorithm doing it’s thing!!!👏🏽 my favorite franchise EVER!! So excited for this journey

[@joshandcasey]

@@beautybysaranwrap let’s go!!

[@LostInTime93]

Mine too🎉

[@ceciliadsa7073]

I can't wait..for the next episode....please..continue 🎉

[@joshandcasey]

Thanks! Will be out shortly so stay tuned

[@jgmartin307]

Maggie Smith had a long career before Harry Potter. Before HP she appeared in a TV version of David Copperfield with Daniel Radcliffe (he played Copperfield) and actually recommended him for Harry Potter. The casting of the kids was phenomenal. By the 7th and 8th movies it becomes obvious they did not waste their time working and learning for nearly half their lives from some of the best actors in Britain.

[@joshandcasey]

Oh that's crazy! Didn't know that.

[@angelkendall9425]

@@joshandcaseyshe was also in the “sister act” movies with Whoopi Goldberg and “first wives club” with Diane Keaton, Goldie Hawn and Bette midler (i hope I spelled their names right) if you know those.

[@weezerfan084]

"The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie" is where I fist saw her. great movie.

[@joshandcasey]

@@weezerfan084 Will have to check it out.

[@ChelseaChfy-ex1po]

@jgmartin307 The director of HP Chris Columbus said at the HP anniversary interview that he simply saw Daniel Radcliffe playing an orphan boy on a TV show in his hotel room and thought he would be perfect for the role. Where are people now getting that she recommended him. I’ve only started hearing this after Maggie smith died. Is there a credible source or are people just making stuff up to glorify Maggie smith due to her passing.

[@dinodasbunce6224]

Many of the actors had impressive careers. Robbie Coltrine, among many other films was in two James Bond films, "GoldenEye" and "The World is not Enough". Richard Harris won an Academy Award for best actor in "Titanic" and appeared in two films which won the Academy Award for Best Picture: firstly as the gunfighter "English Bob" in the revisionist Western "Unforgiven" (1992); secondly as the Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius in Ridley Scott's "Gladiator" (2000). Harris also made it to the number 2 spot on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1969 with his recording of the Jimmy Webb song "MacArthur Park". Rupert Grint was a punk rocker in the movie "CBGB" which starred Alan Rickman. I could go on and on but I am too lazy.

[@joshandcasey]

Wow interesting, thanks for the background!

[@staciroberts5779]

Alan Rickman also played the Sheriff of Nottingham in Robin Hood Prince of Thieves. He was a great villain in that. He also played Colnel Brandon in Sense and Sensibility- a really heroic character. And in Love Actually he played a husband and father. If you haven’t seen those, they are worth watching (if you can stomach Kevin Costner’s bad British accent as Robin Hood). Great reaction! Enjoy the ride.😊

[@staciroberts5779]

Yes, I’m replying to my own message. I forgot to say that if you ever need a vacation to the Oregon coast, Newport Oregon has a bed and breakfast called The Sylvia Beach Hotel. Every room is decorated like an author. I stayed in the JK Rowling room. It was great! Like stepping into Hogwarts. They have journals of what people experienced during their stays. The best was four girls who wrote as if they were students attending Hogwarts. Fun place!

[@joshandcasey]

Thanks for all the recommendations! We will definitely check those movies out as Alan Rickman is always great. Have never been to Oregon but if I do I will look into that!

[@MadMax-cg6gh]

He also played Laura's father in Perfume : the Story of a Murderer ✨🇨🇵

[@genny5309]

And Die Hard! He was fabulous as the villain in that one.

[@yflanders]

Omg I can’t wait for this!! The potter lore goes so deep so I’m stoked to hear both your insights as the series goes on from a well versed potter head & by someone who’s never seen the series before 🙌🏻

[@joshandcasey]

Glad you share the excitement! We have a lot of good things coming up!

[@livb6945]

You know better than to say "they could have picked a better family", surely?! There's a very vital reason he's there. He's protected there - and Dumbledore didn't give them a choice.

[@joshandcasey]

Trying not to reveal too much haha

[@Lestat13]

I was just going to point that out 🖤🌹🖤🧛🏻‍♀️

[@rpiranthowski6239]

​@@joshandcaseyadmit it you forgot about that...😂😉

[@joshandcasey]

@@rpiranthowski6239 I will definitely admit it’s been a minute (as mentioned) since I read the books haha. There’s a lot of things that are easy to forget

[@nmknomad]

man....stop with a spoilers

[@Roomfordesserts]

Dang I’m way too early. I hate waiting 😅😅😅 New sub. Thanks ! ❤

[@joshandcasey]

Thank you! Next one will be out soon

[@johnmoreland6089]

The first film is so well made, but still pretty much more an introduction to the characters and world. Starting with the 2nd and especially the 3rd films, they get more plot oriented and richer in the storytelling.

[@joshandcasey]

Good to know! Guess we’ll have to see when we watch them

[@gunnfredriksen]

6:55 This is so well described at the beginning of the fourth book, when Harry is asked to come and spend the last part of the summer holiday at the Weasley's - Vernon is really conflicted between wanting to be rid of Harry and not wanting Harry to have a good time😅

[@joshandcasey]

such a tough choice haha

[@mr_yoru5834]

A lot of people have already talked about why Harry has to go back to the Dursleys, but that is technically a spoiler that doesn't get explained until much later in the series. In the beginning, it has a lot more to do with Harry's circumstances as a whole. He's not allowed to stay at Hogwarts during the summer. He doesn't go to stay with Ron or Hermione because he doesn't want to be a burden to them, especially Ron's family which is already quite large. He decides on his own to continue to deal with the Dursleys and, as Hagrid implies, their fear and ignorance of the magical world would likely get him some better treatment because they would be afraid of what he could do back to them.

[@joshandcasey]

@@mr_yoru5834 very possible! I’m sure more will get revealed

[@MsAppassionata]

Well, technically he could have offered to give the Weasley’s some money to stay with them. He’s not exactly poor.

[@mr_yoru5834]

@@MsAppassionata The thing about Harry is that after splurging on the trolley he really doesn't like to show off his wealth. The Weasleys probably would not have accepted his money either, even if it was meant to allow him to live with them. This was all covered in the books at various points.

[@MsAppassionata]

@@mr_yoru5834 I read the books awhile ago but I don’t recall any of that, but then again, I’m not a HP expert. Why would he want to hide the fact that he has money? No one would have to know about it except the Weasleys. And I think that paying for room and board would have been very fair, considering the Weasley’s circumstances.

[@mr_yoru5834]

@@MsAppassionata Because the Weasleys, like most normal people, know that there would be something very morally and socially unacceptable about making an arrangement like that with a little kid, even if he offered and even if he had the money. They would let him stay for free, if Harry asked, but Harry did not want to be a burden to them. The important point I was trying to make is that Harry initially continued to live with the Dursleys for his own complicated emotional and moral reasons, not because he was made to by the protection spell. If you want to poke holes in the reasoning then I suggest you at least reread the books because most of this is brought up and answered.

[@theDrasher1]

A less confusing title would be ”The Alchemist's Stone" . From Philosophy 101, the ancients who dabbled in alchemy, are called Philosophers.

[@joshandcasey]

Thats what I thought! No idea why they picked philosopher

[@Aeroldoth3]

​@@joshandcasey The Philosopher's Stone was a "real" concept from the past; it wasn't made up for these books. Alchemists back in the day were basically scientists, trying to figure out chemicals worked. The biggest dream was to be able to turn lead into gold, and the PS would allow you to do just that. It also had something inside like a geode (alternatively described as a powder or liquid), that would grant immortality. Just as people have heard of Excalibur or the Grail, people have heard of the Philosopher's Stone, so changing the name rankles for those who know what it's supposed to be. Imagine a movie where King Arthur holds his sword Shiny, or christians go looking for the Big Cup.

[@MsAppassionata]

I’m afraid that a lot of Americans wouldn’t know what an alchemist is either. 🤷🏽‍♂️😂

[@joshandcasey]

@@MsAppassionata Sadly, you are probably right haha

[@Xeno_Solarus]

​@@MsAppassionata Eh. I can't agree with that

[@tamarasmith9060]

The trio & Draco all got 50 points taken from them because they left the castle after nightfall. Basically the same as if a muggle kid snuck out of the house after dark & went blocks away to a friend's house without parental permission. So they had to be taught that this was a big important rule, not a small rule. Despite still being on school grounds, they are 11 year olds running around unsupervised & it's possible an animal might come out of the woods or the kids might do something dangerous & there wouldn't be an adult to get them to the hospital wing, etc.

[@joshandcasey]

Right seems like a valid punishment, though the points seem pretty arbitrary at times

[@patriciaalvareztostado8170]

@@joshandcasey I always think thay especially after the troll incident, and this, like they dont fit, they should recibe more for that I think so. But 50, is too mch

[@ChelseaChfy-ex1po]

Draco didn’t get 50 points off he got detention only.

[@patriciaalvareztostado8170]

@@ChelseaChfy-ex1po No he did get 50 points taken, McGonagall said 50 points each, that include Draco, she would just give them points to Gryffindor, and all get detentions

[@shirleydurr411]

#2 probably cost less than #1 because the world -- most of the sets --- was already built. I never had a favorite movie because the ones following the first ones wouldn't make much sense without the exposition we have in the the first two; #3 can jump faster into action because we already know the characters and much of the wizarding world. That's probably why many people consider it their favorite. But I'm more into story than special effects, more about characters than action (though I like action, too).

[@joshandcasey]

That makes more sense!

[@Melissa-wx4lu]

For Quidditch, the team with the most points at the end of the game wins. The game does not end until the Snitch is caught. The snitch gives 150 points. The team that catches the snitch is not necessarily going to be the winner, but are most of the time due to the huge award of points.

[@joshandcasey]

Hopefully the seeker can catch the snitch in a reasonable time then haha

[@flugsven]

The actors may not be famous in the US, but they really are the British creme de la creme. (I actually lolled when I heard you)

[@joshandcasey]

@@flugsven you are right. Silly comment. Everyone especially knows Emma Watson

[@littleogeechee223]

I know! You’d think that Harry would be the one kid Hagrid would want to keep close to him in a situation like the Dark Forest!

[@joshandcasey]

Right!? Not sure what happened there.

[@angelkendall9425]

Great reaction guys❤

[@joshandcasey]

Thank you!!

[@PsychesFlora]

I legitimately don’t know how you can watch such a beautiful and genius story and not be impressed or moved. Such a weird reaction to be honest.

[@joshandcasey]

I am slowly finding out that I may not be the biggest fantasy fan. Although, Josh lives for this series. To each their own! I’m sure there are some movies you may not like that I do which I could say the same about

[@PsychesFlora]

@ for sure :) I was just surprised because it is such a human film.

[@acac92]

Nice Reaction! :)

[@joshandcasey]

@@acac92 thank you! 🙏

[@darleencarter3485]

Rupert Grint has roles in several shows, but hasn't done much with movies. He did the ABC Murders and Servant.

[@joshandcasey]

Interesting, thanks!

[@Jacismiles4u2]

So many of reactors do not understand that the reason he was left with them is his Aunt's blood protected him from being 'found' by Voldemort or his followers.

[@joshandcasey]

@@Jacismiles4u2 well admittedly, while we haven’t finished the series yet, they could explain it better. It’s difficult though when there’s so much material to get thru

[@anitasmith7764]

I don’t think it went fast really. It wasn’t 5 min for any transition. It just goes fast bc it’s actually entertaining instead of dragging on and on

[@nebulousreactions]

I generally don't subscribe until I've seen a few videos from a channel, but I like the cut of your jib, guys! Subbed :) There's no way to really know it from the movie, but if Ron had jumped off the horse, it would have forfeited the game. I haven't followed much of Rupert Grint's career, but I do know he's devoting time to raising his kid, because Ron's a daddy now :D

[@joshandcasey]

Thanks for the sub! That is what I figured but didn’t seem like there was a reason for it in the movie

[@nebulousreactions]

@@joshandcasey Overall this series is a very good adaptation, but yeah, there are certain things movie-viewers have questions about that are only covered in the novels. So if you have questions, let us know! We book-readers don't need much of an invitation to bury you in lore if you want it :D

[@joshandcasey]

@ haha will do! I’m sure we will have many questions

[@Diablo22967]

YOU NEED TO REACT TO THE 20TH ANNIVERSARY CELEBRATION SPECIAL ASWELL. The red carpet premiere for the last movie is here on KZbin and shows the reach this franchise has

[@joshandcasey]

@@Diablo22967 we will do it when we finish the series

[@ally_m]

The Dursleys are portrayed from Harry's point of view - a family who never wanted him, who he reminded about a lost sibling. But let's face the facts: they took him in, they brought him up, they guarded him from anything "strange" and "funny", they went to enormous lengths to protect that unloved nephew from getting into Hogwarts because wizarding world is dangerous. In the first book they are a normal family, or rather one that strives to be normal. Because abnormality, apparently, kills. Hated them as a kid. Starting to relate to them now when I'm an adult myself =)

[@joshandcasey]

Interesting perspective. I guess the actors just did such a good job as jerks that it's hard to overlook.

[@tommywalker3746]

Spoiler alert. Norbert the baby dragon that was sent to the reserve in Romania where Rons brother Charlie works is actually a female dragon, "Norberta". And is the same dragon Harry has to fight in book 4

[@krissmith800]

The question is have you seen Team StarKids' musical trilogy that parodies the films and books? The three shows are more than just stage adaptations with comedic flair and great songs. They are . . . well, hard to put into words. Sure, subtitles help due to university stage mics that are not the best quality (and audience noise as well) and yes, there is strong language and "adult" content. However, if you are a fan of all things Harry Potter, you should see them at least once. It would be fun to grow your KZbin audience and there are some cool surprises in the shows as well (including a cameo by one of the actual cast members from the movies). I hope you consider it.

[@joshandcasey]

I have not haha but now I’m going to go check it out!

[@krissmith800]

@joshandcasey It's different and you may find yourself liking StarKid in general and accidentally falling down that rabbit-hole, haha. Seriously though, I think you will appreciate the trilogy for what it is. Also, if you ever watched the TV show Glee, you may recognize a familiar face. I hope you enjoy!

[@tamarasmith9060]

Hagrid is only half human. His dad was a wizard but his mom was a giant. Not giant as in a human with a growth hormone malfunction. Giant as in the species. His mom abandoned her husband & son when Hagrid was a toddler, as he was a "runt" that wouldn't grow so she was ashamed. In HP world, giants are typically not bright, quite selfish (& some are outright mean, though not all). So...we are not really given any details into why a wizard would be attracted to a female giant or exactly how coitus & conception work in such a relationship. However in book 4 we meet another character that is half giant also, but she is too ashamed to admit it when Hagrid asks her about her own childhood after he talks about his own childhood with his dad. She just keeps insisting she's fully human but big. I guess she was afraid of discrimination based on the reputation of giants, & as headmistress of another magic school it's understandable. After all, the parents must trust her with their children's safety just as others trust Dumbledore with the safety of the kids at Hogwarts.

[@joshandcasey]

See that makes more sense, I feel like I don’t remember them explaining he was half giant. He shouldn’t be allowed in the muggle world haha😂

[@chris...9497]

Average height of a giant is 20ft. They are low intelligence and rely more on emotions, which is most often displayed through violence. Average height of a half-giant is half the height of a giant, 10ft. Hagrid's father was a very smart and kind wizard, but remarkably small in stature. Hagrid inherited his father's magical ability, an intellect capable of reading but challenged by spelling, and a height of only 8ft. Hagrid also has his father's kindness.

[@kathybowles495]

I have ridden the real train, in Scotland. It was wonderful day trip.

[@joshandcasey]

Bucket list for sure!

[@DragoX7]

Her name isn't Rawling.... Regardless of the w in her name, it's pronounced Rolling. (Roll-ing)

[@jiruribakachan365]

Who cares? Everyone just calls her terf.

[@xhelan131]

@@jiruribakachan365 so what? nothing wrong with being a TERF. I love Rowling so much.

[@tenesaravula4038]

it's not world building or a mini world model. It's actually a real place and that is in Scotland where they filmed the train scene.

[@joshandcasey]

Sorry I was more talking about the world building of the story/wizard world not where they filmed

[@drooney9]

Everyone had to stay in their places, if Ron had jumped off, he would have forfeited the game.

[@ThePharaz]

My opinion is the US publisher was an idiot to change the name. I chose not to read it cause I had no idea what a sorcerer's stone was. Had they left it as it originally was I would have read it as I know what a Philosopher's Stone is.

[@joshandcasey]

Yeah that was definitely a strange choice

[@theshadowfax239]

The guy on the right is a Potterhead yet but doesn't know what house he's in? 😒

[@joshandcasey]

@@theshadowfax239 gryffindor of course! Hence the white shirt and red and yellow tie

[@Sayitlikitiz101]

Good luck. You are good and have decent reactions, but your editing of the video being played needs a lot of work.

[@joshandcasey]

Thank you! We are working on it. It can be tough navigating copyright issues. What specifically about the editing bothered you?

[@tothelakes]

Can you React to my lady jane please

[@joshandcasey]

We will add it to the list!

[@tothelakes]

​@@joshandcaseythank you💜

[@jiruribakachan365]

Can someone answer me if they're a gay coupe? Cuz if not i dont want to watch.

[@joshandcasey]

We are not lol but why would that make you not want to watch?

[@xhelan131]

you're a very weird person, the other comment you left under this video proves how backwards your thinking is. This is not the place for you, bye!

[@xhelan131]

@@joshandcasey please do not respond to comments like this. it's very awkward and people like this don't deserve a response. don't get yourself into trouble with this nonsense.

[@jiruribakachan365]

@@joshandcasey Because very simply I do not want to watch more straight people than I naturally HAVE to. As part of the LGBTQIA+ community you are constantly forced to watch straights everywhere, movies, shows, youtube, twitch every medium is littered with straight people and you do not have a sliver of understanding how life for someone in this community is. All I want is to support people who have a similar lifepath than mine nothing against you two personally I just don't want to watch yet another straight say "uuhh thats gay" or some bullshit akin to that.

[@jiruribakachan365]

@@xhelan131 What is akward is that you have no fucking idea of the reasoning why someone might ask this. maybe if you don't know shit you might want to shut your mouth.