DID IT SUCK? | Doctor Who [THE DOCTOR'S DAUGHTER REVIEW]

[@dubliam8064]

This episode does matter if it didn't exists David Tennant wouldn't have met the Doctors daughter who would turn into the Doctors Wife and the Doctor wouldn't become the Doctors son in law

[@melodyfuri1004]

we just need one of his kids to play the doctor and then the doctor will be his own grandpa

[@bowmanc.7439]

Timey whimy?

[@tomisalone5987]

Harry’s definitely got to review Waters of Mars at some time.

[@liamjones1867]

When I went to rewatch doctor who, that was the first one I watched, it’s the one that stuck out for me as a kid. I think the villains are some of the scariest of all time and the ending is honestly so dark, it blew me away. 9/10 from me.

[@theharvinator7935]

Anything less than an 8 out of 10 and I unsub /s

[@theonionsystem7779]

I remember when I was a little kid when I saw it and it scared me the most and I was so scared and the last bits made me cry in terror especially the suicide part where I was crying a lot and my dad picked me up and held me and unfortunately I've tried too many suicide attempts mostly because of my father these days. Then the next time part showing the master with the whole skull face made me burst into tears and made me cry even more

[@jemstar63]

The Onion System, I’m glad you’re still with us ❤️

[@rs666devil]

My favourite ep, been wanting a review of it for ages

[@sernoddicusthegallant6986]

You, a normie pleb: This episode is so Cheesy Me, an intellectual: This episode is *Saucey*

[@DanTheMan2150AD]

How have you been Harry? *Haven’t seen you for days.*

[@CyberDoctor-tc8tc]

DanTheMan 2150AD HAHAHA

[@nicolebee3283]

Hi dan!

[@MatthewsStopMotions]

Been away.

[@DanTheMan2150AD]

Nicole Bae hello

[@carealoo744]

199th Like!

[@piplup2009]

Had a massive crush on the doctor's daughter when I first saw this episode, blows my mind that the doctor married his daughter

[@piplup2009]

@@Leon_the_wildcat *banjo music intensifies*

[@kingepicgg906]

Alabama 100

[@QuokkaCore]

Is it bad that I thought the death of Martha’s Hath was more emotional than Jenny’s?

[@j1fr79]

No I thought so too

[@Trinidad413]

No, it wasn't. I thought the same.

[@GoogleUser-dwcy]

Well, it would be confusing if the Doctor's daughter who is also the Doctor's wife and gave birth to the Doctor's daughter and the Doctor's granddaughter knew the Doctor's other relatives. And I disagree with your opinion that it wouldn't have mattered if this episode never happened, it matters for the memes.

[@creeperslayer241]

The doctors daughter, who is also the doctors wife, also happens to be the doctors granddaughter

[@ethanhunter8763]

If this episode never happened, David wouldn’t have even known about his now wife as this is when they first met

[@jonathanskinner7647]

"the weakest episode of the season" Dude. In series 4 that could mean anything below amazing

[@rkah6187]

Agreed. Series 4 had been one of the best ones. It's certainly the most consistent in terms of the quality, acting and such.

[@drd2121]

British One yeah, this episode was the worst in my opinion of s4. But I loved it! So what does that say to ya?

[@linkofvev]

The Unicorn and the Wasp says otherwise. That episode was just embarrassing to watch.

[@drd2121]

Elvynd nah mate, honestly, that episode is hilarious and just fun all round. It’s the type of filler episode I just thoroughly enjoyed being entertained by what it had in store. Loved that. I loved this one too but because there’s so many good ones in this series, this had to be the worst of the great.

[@ThePhantomLK]

@@linkofvev Unicorn was great, the first and last episodes were the big let downs of this series.

[@DannyHodge95]

"Gendry from Game of Thrones"... Nahh Harry mate, that's Chris from Skins.

[@MrGreaves]

I see an intellectual in the comments section

[@steelbarber]

My favorite thing about this episode was the commentary over what it means to be a Time Lord and how the doctor made Jenny feel like she was less than that because she didn’t understand what that title could mean. Also the little hints to the doctors family in this episode was really nice too, like when he talked about that he had a daughter before but that life is behind him now.

[@rkah6187]

Meanwhile, Yaz and the Thirteenth Doctor: "It's complicated." "Yeah. Dads are. So I've heard." Like she hasn't been a father before.

[@DanTheMan2150AD]

Nobody: General Cobb: *Sauce?*

[@nightowl8477]

Martha's so mistreated, man. Best companion. There is a lot of cringe this episode tho.

[@QuokkaCore]

Almost seems kinda racist at times with how black characters were treated during the RTD era tbh.

[@nightowl8477]

@@QuokkaCore - kinda??? As much as I like to see racism tackled in episodes like The Shakespeare Code or Human Nature, it's just gets you screaming "Give the woman a break!" It's realistic at best, but just plain uncomfortable at worst. I mean, the Master enslaving the Jones's...too far, man, too far. Regardless of her gender or revealing clothes, you don't see Rose getting so mistreated! Overkill is the word for Martha.

[@patrikmiles9342]

@@nightowl8477 I agree with your point that martha was overshadowedbut Thier are some errors in your comment.1. You act like the master enslaving the Jhones was just them when the entire plannet was enslaved.2.Rose got mistreated such as her dad dying Infront of her and being separated from her love of her life twice.Also Russel clearly isn't a racist he treats minority characters with such respect in years and years

[@pyromaniac2104]

4:10-4:13 WHY does everyone think that dislocated is the same thing as broken. dislocation means a joint has moved form where it's supposed to be hence dis-locaton, broken is exactly what it sounds like, the bone has been split or broken.

[@Dantick09]

What bothers me is that the doctor's daughter should have been a titanically important character but nope she gets a one-off. They should have used this formula to introduce her as the new companion so much room for character development WASTED Plus she is super hot I mean cmon dammit, we could have had the samus aran of doctor Who >:(

[@Arkegox]

Who wrote this? David Tennant?

[@gloreaf1850]

Good news is: she had a role in "The lost dimension" comic series.

[@cherblairbear]

......She's hot? I-

[@cherblairbear]

"I'm the Doctor's Daughter."

[@RealCryptoTest]

Ya know how the Doctor married his daughter and named their child after his companions granddad

[@TombstoneSyrup]

And the fact that the doctors daughter was actually played by the 5th doctors daughter. So the doctors father in law is him in the past. Isn't time travel fun

[@gamer65688]

What

[@mjm3091]

@@gamer65688 they are talking about actors. Tennant and actress playing Jenny are married, she also is a daughter of fifth Doctor

[@evanlight2550]

Tenant just can’t escape the Doctor, can he?

[@TvReferences]

2:28 I never realised Chris from Skins was in this episode

[@drd2121]

Ngl, love this episode. It’s got some good aspects. Quite sad too. Haven’t watched the review yet but I bet you rate it 6/10. Edit: ngl though, the fire coming out of those guns at the start is hilarious and always confused me. But the overall message of the story is quite nice.

[@bigbritgaming930]

The thing about the guns is even better when you watch some of the behind the scenes footage from the time with the crew biging up how great they looked whilst evidently not really believing it.

[@DJVaughan]

I’m just going to say, as some who became familiar with old who later than new who, I enjoyed this episode well enough. The only thing I’d change would be making the Doctor threat to kill more genuine and terrifying and make apparent to the audience that it’s not the Doctor’s better nature stopping him, but his darker and more manipulative side telling him it would have more effect on the 2 factions not to kill him. And I also think anything with the Doctor family at this point ( outside of a tragic backstory for the Doctor ) would create a lot of plot holes ( Season 12 ), making it kind of untouchable at this point.

[@DJVaughan]

Just got towards the end of the review, and I have to say I disagree. I never believe the Doctor would’ve shot him, even as a kid. I know they had an orchestra but sometimes subtle music or even complete silence can be more effective.

[@maxthommesen9315]

@@DJVaughan i also liked the concept of this endless clone war that in reallity only went on for a week

[@DJVaughan]

Max Thommesen A game of telephone, but instead of whispers it’s legends of the dead.

[@maxthommesen9315]

@@DJVaughan yeah i liked it

[@DJVaughan]

Max Thommesen Ditto.

[@Squantle]

I really like the idea that the war has only been going on for a week. Adds some gravity to the bloodshed of clone warfare, but they just gloss over it in this episode.

[@sernoddicusthegallant6986]

For anyone asking what happened to the daughter, isnt it obvious? Gendry took her away on his rowboat of forgotten plot lines

[@GiubileiFernando]

The row boat came back though

[@sernoddicusthegallant6986]

@@GiubileiFernando Shh, season 7 and 8 never actually happened, it was all just a bad dream... *Rocking in corner* A bad dream that happened to every fan at the same time. Its not actually real... It cant hurt me.

[@mrflibble1259]

It's weird cos I really like this episode, and usually when you negatively review an episode that I like I tend to come round on your way of thinking and see its flaws. But here I'm hearing these critisms, registering them, but I don't find them significant. I still love it

[@theblackarrow1373]

I actually really like this episode. At least a 6/10, great performance from Tennant and appreciate all the scenes with Jenny. Don't mind the sets at all and think the music is solid as always in series 4

[@KhornMarkOfSlaanesh]

So doesn't the fact that she's cloned from the Doctor make her a god now as well? So there're now 2 timeless children?

[@jemimajust827]

That "hello dad" I had to mute for a second because I still find it cringey to this day

[@xenon8117]

I don’t think any of the others see people as parents so it’s really odd.

[@stekenxu]

At least she didn't say "daddy" because that would make one wonder.

[@colonelcider8292]

Why is it cringy?

[@danielwilliamson6180]

One of my favourite episodes from the revived series of Doctor Who. The episode which David Tennant met his wife Georgia Moffett. The casting of Georgia Moffett as Jenny was brilliant because Georgia Moffett is the real life daughter of Peter Davison (The 5th Doctor). I met Peter Davison in 2009. It's a shame Jenny never got her own spin-off show as the ending did leave it open for a possible spin-off and I hope one day Georgia Moffett will make a possible return as Jenny in a future season.

[@nack287]

"I never would..." Cut to the countless clips of the various Doctors blowing dudes away with countless types of weapons.

[@Rognik]

I had forgotten that Martha was even in this episode, that's how important she was to it. Then again, I had also forgotten what the enemies looked like, so there ya go...

[@pixelhavoc4950]

I know this is probably going to get lost in obscurity/written off as a lie but I've actually met the guy who wrote this. I forget how but my Stepmum knows him in some way (I believe they're related). So yeah. I've met the guy technically responsible for David Tennant's current marriage.

[@TheFlyingPannier]

First haven't seen you in ages last week and now sauce, there's a new Benni every week

[@FortoFight]

How can you not like the guns? They built practical guns with actual IRL muzzle effects, pretty cool tbh.

[@5nipebite]

Plot twist: this episode is really set in 2017 and was about the great long war for the McDonald’s Szechuan sauce

[@johnnyvanguard8978]

I think this video is overlooking the main point of the episode which is the Doctors daughter is a massive cutie

[@TheSmart-CasualGamer]

There's a few weird bits in this, but it's not TERRIBLE. The acting is great, I like the Hath (Always been the good guys in my mind) and the ending is FANTASTIC. And the reason the clones don't look the same is because the machines can't do DNA, just replicate tissue and bone and stuff. It's not really cloning, it's more like copying a Human's basics and letting it develop. I wonder what the lifespan is? Can't be too long.

[@ryanratchford2530]

Jo Dempsy (the guy who plays Gendry) is a family friend so it's always great to see him in things. He was the reason I watched BBC's Merlin & Skins

[@alfiethomas5632]

He was in Merlin? I don't remember that

[@ollyclass]

Look at that a woman time lord (kind of) and she's already got a more compelling story and is more developed than the new doctor over a season. I always thought that the doctor would die because he only has 12 regenerations and then it'd pick up with her at the funeral.

[@magua9563]

I was always kinda confused why some of the later seasons never brought the Jenny character back since we have the weird ending where she shoots off into space wanting to do what her father does? I was never aware they wanted to do a spinoff tv show, bleh...

[@davidbray5982]

I think this episode IS necessary because of the end scene. He chooses to not execute the soldier with the gun, even though he had support from the other men to do so. This is why it is so moving when he takes the gun from Wilf in the finale. The guns look identical, and it shows his rage at the master when he won't take revenge on a man even when is daughter has been killed, but he would still kill the master.

[@plutoreturns9630]

We all know that if this episode had been in Season 12 it would have been the best and highlight of the series.

[@oliverelliott2956]

How long u gna keep ur halloween channel name?

[@TheAstip]

My biggest issue is that it seems like someones self-insert fanfiction where they get to be the hot badass daughter of the main character without having to deal with canon.

[@thebruhninja0211]

David Tennant's wife play's David Tennant's daughter, as he plays an older version of her Dad...woah.

[@Thunderbolt-Racing]

My room has EIGHT corners!!!

[@kingepicgg906]

I cringe when Jenny says hello dad now I know she's married to tennent

[@alliebenson4653]

I thought it wasn't that she regenerated, but that she had inhaled some of the terraforming gases and that was why she came back to life? Maybe I got that wrong.

[@ramblesrandom]

This episode is basically just clickbait in 2008 before it was cool

[@MnAcqui]

I agree this episode is not the strongest, but I loved the Doctor and Donna dialogues in it. I've only watched it once years ago, yet to this day I remember the moment when Doctor admits to having children before and Donna says "you talk all the time, but you don't say anything". I think it's such a great description of the Doctor

[@johnbool6938]

Please do a review of life on Mars, one of my favourite shows.

[@barry1369]

2:19 what happened to the chair XD

[@qayyuma9622]

The irony of gendry being in this episode (someone who was revealed to be the son of an important character but ultimately that reveal isn’t important ) if only kit Harrington has a cameo

[@minipisa7595]

The Hath are the cutest and most innocent aliens in Doctor who and no one can convince me otherwise

[@looe9195]

I edited a video of the Doctor shooting General Nob.

[@Cobb_innit]

I used to love this episode when I was younger, purely because general Cobb has my surname and I’ve always been known just as ‘Cobb’ so it was cool for me as a kid for someone to have the same name as me in my favourite tv show, even if he wasn’t exactly a good guy

[@jedwisner6038]

Lucy Cobb

[@Cobb_innit]

Jed wisner yep that’s my name

[@thelasttimelord7550]

I hate to put Brian to Shame here but there was a spin off to Jenny but didnt come out until 2019 in BF ):

[@xersei5316]

wasnt it like an audio book? or was there actually a show?

[@CovertFilmer]

YES! I was going to say as much but you beat me to it. It is audio, but most of Big Finish is considered canon anyway. Also that audio series is brilliant!

[@TheStrongVirus]

To be fair when I showed my American friends clips (of Jenny) of this episode they also asked for the “Sauce”. Maybe it’s a gun thing?

[@hobbabobba7912]

I actually really like this episode

[@xentiment6581]

Its my favorite in all 12 seasons

[@amelialikesfrogs5778]

i thought the condensed time thing cos of the cloning was actually a pretty clever twist, it's a shame it didb't really affect anything and the idea was in an episode already crammed with too much sci fi nonsense

[@carealoo744]

Episodes still to review: The Unquiet Dead The Long Game Boom-Town Born-Again The Christmas Invasion New Earth The Idiot's Lanturn The Runaway Bride The Infinite Quest The Lazerus Experiment Time-Crash Voyage Of The Dammed The Unicorn And The Wasp Silence In The Library/Forest Of The Dead Midnight Turn-Left The Stolen Earth/Journey's End The Next Doctor Planet Of The Dead Dreamland The Waters Of Mars The End Of Time (Parts 1 & 2) The Eleventh Hour Meanwhile In The TARDIS (#1) The Beast Below Victory Of The Daleks Time Of Angles/Flesh And Stone Meanwhile In The TARDIS (#2) Vampires In Venice Amy's Choice The Hungry Earth/Cold Blood The-Lodger The Pandorica Opens/The Big Bang Space/Time A Christmas Carol The Impossible Astronaut/Day Of The Moon The Curse Of The Black-Spot The Doctor's Wife The Rebel-Flesh/The Almost-People A Good Man Goes To War Night-Terrors The Girl Who Waited The God-Complex Closing-Time The Wedding Of River-Song The Doctor, The Widow, And The Wardrobe Asylum Of The Daleks Dinosaurs On A Spaceship A Town Called Mercy The Power Of 3 Angles Take Manhattan P.S. The Snowmen The Bells Of Saint John's The Rings Of Akkatan Cold-War Hide Journey To The Center Of The TARDIS The Crimson Horror Nightmare In Silver The Name Of The Doctor An Adventure In Space And Time The Night Of The Doctor The Fiveish Doctors Reboot The Last Day The Day Of The Doctor The Time Of The Doctor Last Christmas Hey, if anyone's interested, I'm reviewing all the Doctor Who stories on my channel, with me just having finished the Jon Pertwer era! No pressure, of-course; Just if you're ever bored. :)

[@tobythesuperfasttram]

its just a regular railway tunnel, not a tube tunnel

[@forzeferrari2668]

Compared to Dr Who now this is a really good episode, I’d much rather watch this than the shitty team tardis and their political agenda.

[@ByddinRhyddidCymru]

Harry do you like ska & would you like to see more ska in doctor whose

[@katokianimation]

I like the concept of the Doctor having a daughter who is not really his daughter while he already lost his real child and being very contradicted with his feelings. But it is not something that you can build up in 10 minutes and it is not something that you can do as comedy. It is like if the episode that called Dalek was trying to force comedy into the drama of being the last of yours. That why it is cheesy and melodramatic. Also the resolution of the story, Jenny being dead, renders everything into pointless.

[@rkah6187]

It really would have been better if the Jenny-Doctor relationship had been built over multiple episodes. We would see the Doctor conflicted but still taking Jenny along out of a sense of obligation, then watch him slowly warm up to her and accept her. Losing her would have had more of a punch that way.

[@katokianimation]

@@rkah6187 agree

[@ali-ej6rv]

I’ve never liked or disliked this episode, it’s just sort of there for me. The only saving grace for me is that knowing David Tennant would meet the woman who would make him happy and a father.

[@stardustnation2480]

She really is gorgeous, honestly

[@elevatorelevatorelevator8486]

So inturn this dr who has less parallels to sci-fi but more so with the Jeremy Kyle show?

[@Labyethan]

So was General Cobb being fueled with drugs off screen?

[@robindavda8967]

@@Labyethan what do you think he meant by "sauce"?

[@Labyethan]

@@robindavda8967 Rick and Morty joke here

[@elevatorelevatorelevator8486]

Freedom Crusher of course, as “the sauce” as he puts it is known slang for crack cocaine

[@Labyethan]

@@elevatorelevatorelevator8486 *THE SAUCE*

[@chiisuigintou]

A Jenny spin off show, would have been so much better, than series 11 and 12 combined and watching Tennant interact with the daughter from Peter Davison (the 5th doctor) in real life, not to mention his future wife, was awesome for me at least to watch.,.

[@MitchCyan]

I think that because series 4 has such a strong start and end, that episodes 4-7 are a bit weak in comparison.

[@QuokkaCore]

Eh, I liked the Sontaran 2 parter.

[@mattwyant3415]

The jail scene is a standout moment in this episode for me showing David tennant's great acting talking about the time war

[@elonmusket5676]

Are there any episode that are going to be skipped or are you reviewing them all

[@jackhunter8009]

Will turn left be included as the series finale review

[@mb2000]

Assuming it wasn’t stupid that the Doctor’s clone daughter emerged fully clothed, what part of the fashion cloning process took green combat clothing from a pin stripe suit and trench coat? And for that matter, female from a male?

[@alextheanimator2395]

so when will we see that fathers day episode or do you need to be a patreon only member to watch it

[@aaronbrown8377]

I was thinking of this episode the other day, wishing they did something with her. Well... her and the waters of Mars. I think I saw The Doctor's Daughter through slight Rose colored glasses.

[@cacam54]

Just got done watching the latest Clone Wars episode and now this, today is a good day

[@terracottafred5126]

Same

[@theblackarrow1373]

The clone wars ep was incredible! Can't wait for the final two

[@cacam54]

@@theblackarrow1373 I know right!! All I'm thinking about is Order 66

[@theblackarrow1373]

Carlos Campos It’s gonna be so brutal to see the clones turn on Ahsoka and probably Rex

[@cacam54]

@@theblackarrow1373 I know right, especially after seeing them do all that stuff for her

[@nightowl8477]

Fun fact! Peg was actually played by - *HAVEN'T SEEN YOU FOR DAYS*

[@craigh5624]

Great review but he glossed over the political and religious statements of the episode a bit the way that humans can forget and warp so much of their history, creating religions out of explainable "stuff" and forming such strong ideologies and connections to these misconceptions that they feel justified in killing a perceived "other" over disagreements this was a major theme explaining how religion can so easily motivate war and how short human memorys can be in terms of history, which i realy liked... or maybe im over thinking this and giving the episode to much credit.... even if i am, i liked donnas bit with figuring out the dates, that was always pretty damn cool to me

[@CheezePieWithChipz]

If I see one more gun... I'll point one at someone's head in the next episode?

[@RachelLittle2010]

Do you get the bonus videos even if your a lower dollar patreon? For example 1 dollar, 3 dollar, 5 dollar. Just curious.

[@flameflamedramonva]

The funniest part is if you apply roles IRL, you get some form of incest

[@jmace2424]

Would totally have watched spinoff series about Jenny and later on about Clara and Me having adventures!

[@charliemaline223]

Jesus, after season 3 Martha just keeps getting kidnapped... Even in Torchwood she was captured on trapped

[@plutoreturns9630]

If I see ONE MORE bloody skillshare sponsorship I'll

[@BigBrosFilms]

They say sauce more often in this episode than in a KZbin poop

[@marlzz92]

Episode gets a 4 but surely Georgia Moffat gets a 10? 🙄😂

[@dutchmansmine9053]

Georgia Tennant always gets a ten. Heck, she married a Ten.

[@emlynperson3976]

it's not about what you enjoy but what improves your chances in the game called staying alive.

[@ruthalber6236]

The doctor's daughter absolutely one hundred percent did not suck it was beautiful every line every frame every moment every sentence was absolute gold

[@kezmsfilms1300]

Im surprise he didn't mention more about a Daughter of a Doctor Marrying a Doctor and playing a Daughter of a Doctor

[@thewhovianwithasmallcollec7319]

all these millatary guys are just rick and morty s3 fans after episode 1 was relelsed (shesquan sauce(cant spell)

[@Lalerato]

Doctor don’t like guns, except if River Song is the one holding it

[@domnolan4286]

This would be the best episode in any of Jodies seasons

[@ThatCringeCalledIggleboz]

I thought the change to "Harry's Haunted House" was just a halloween thing?

[@williamrufatobotura2545]

They are not clones… they are made by parthenogenesis, like bees… it’s why they are not all the same

[@mahfuzurchowdhury2765]

I remember you really not liking Heaven Sent, so I was wondering, would you ever consider rewatching some episodes you've reviewed years before and re-review them?

[@beansinasippycup]

He is not Gendry from GoT, he is Chris from skins!

[@OblivionWalkerVerified]

join us for a benny? did i hear that right?

[@charleswa547]

The fact you refer to him as Gendry from GOT and not Chris from skins is a true crime

[@jedwisner6038]

Imallexx simp

[@samuelbarber4154]

Personally, I think of her as Susan's mother.

[@SpectraMoth]

I can’t wait to see you do midnight

[@dubliam8064]

Doctors Daughter more like the Doctors Wife

[@jedwisner6038]

Got em

[@CrimsonKnyght]

Funny thing is, The Doctors Daughter should of been our first female time lord protagonist and not what we got instead. I would of loved to see her explore the galaxy not in a time machine but as someone trying to find herself outside of being bred for war and to kill and she comes to terms that with the fact she can do anything but must learn what it is to be a timelord. Would be a great way to explore the Timelords lore a bit more all the while she goes through some hard times and eventually achieves the lesson of being the best you can be and to help others who need it... but no we got some dumb ass SJW bullshit. Used to love this show years back.

[@dutchmansmine9053]

I think there is an audio series. Might be worth checking out.

[@stephaniepage4334]

I'd like to see dove Cameron play jenny if she regenerates?

[@fairsaa7975]

I'd loved to have seen an episode where the Doctor meets his Granddaughter