Helloween "Keeper of the Seven Keys" REACTION & ANALYSIS by Vocal Coach/Opera Singer

Alrighty, everyone. We're trying this again! Around 6 months ago, this video was taken down due to a copyright claim. We're so happy to finally re-instate it, this time when it's not Halloween! Look at those fuzzy ears. . . Red Panda ears for Red Panda hair! Let's also talk about how amazing Michael Kiske's vocals are in this piece, they are absolutely legendary!
Join professional opera singer Elizabeth Zharoff, as she listens to Helloween for the very first time, performing "Keeper of the Seven Keys” live.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Performed by Helloween - Words and Music by Helloween
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I definitely recommend watching the original video without interruptions, here's the link: • Helloween - Keeper Of ...
Show Helloween some love: / @helloween
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WE HAVE MERCH! Check-out the full line-up here: thecharismaticmerch.com
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🎧 Elizabeth’s favorite headphones 🎧 : imp.i114863.net/zayoEM
Music Gear Questions? 🎤 See my list of recommendations: imp.i114863.net/yRyGoV
WANT MY CHAIR? I don’t blame you…and here’s a link to make it even sweeter:
secretlab.co/?rfsn=4692958.b2...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🎙️Podcast: thecharismaticvoice.com/podcast/
🌐Website: thecharismaticvoice.com
📸Instagram: / thecharismaticvoice
🧑‍🤝‍🧑Patreon: / thecharismaticvoice
📺Twitch: / thecharismaticvoice
📰Our FREE Newsletter: eepurl.com/gz7Z_z
-------------------------------------COURSES------------------------------------------
🎵MUSIC APPRECIATION COURSE🎵
Want to understand how to listen to and appreciate music more? My Music Appreciation course is now live. Take a look at thecharismaticvoice.com
🎶DEMYSTIFYING SINGING🎶
My intensive 7-week course on vocal foundations includes weekly group sessions and private lessons. Learn more at thecharismaticvoice.com.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Elizabeth Zharoff is an international opera singer and voice coach, with 3 degrees in voice, opera, and music production. She's performed in 18 languages throughout major venues in Europe, America, and Asia. Currently based somewhere between Los Angeles and Tucson, Arizona, Elizabeth spends her days researching voice, singing, teaching, writing music, and recording TONS. She also plays Diablo and Dungeons & Dragons.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Want a free voice lesson? Sign-up to WIN at mailchi.mp/thecharismaticvoic...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
Non-profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#Helloween #Reaction​ #ElizabethZharoff

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

We just released merchandise! Check out the full line-up here: thecharismaticmerch.com

[@jimmyhassel1908]

I think the video game your looking for is Bubble bobble 😊.

[@gachacookie769]

Love this channel I love your break downs can you look at biffy clyro great songs

[@gachacookie769]

Look into biffy clyro

[@gachacookie769]

Death angel love to see that review

[@gachacookie769]

Brrak down some ozzy rhandy Rhoads

[@borislavtodorovic6331]

Michael Kiske has one of the most well-preserved voices in metal. You should definitely check out the studio version as well and compare how he sounded when he first recorded the track when he was 19 and now when he's in his mid 50s.

[@marcelopires711]

Exactly what I thought. Something like "I Want Out" would be very nice, there's even an official music video.

[@kevdmiller]

I think he might even sound better. He was always great, but wow.

[@Tony-hg9kc]

You’re absolutely right with this comment.

[@jedinightwing]

I think some of that might have to do with the 90's and his "leaving metal". When he came back with Avantasia it was fantastic and his voice has held up amazingly. It's just weird seeing him bald and looking like one of my old friends (Ironically who introduced me to Helloween)

[@gabrielstern4992]

He sounds better now vs then kai is still my favorite hellowern vocalist and I love kai's stuff with gamma ray. But I like that micheal kiske has a lot more chest voice now and feeling. He still holds back to much on the highs. But is a lot better singer now. And its the holding back on the highs or unwillingness to do clean screams. Which is what always annoyed me. About Micheal kiske. And I don't want to hear it throws out your clean voice excuse either. Which is his excuse. Rob Halford would literally scream live and in the studio and not throw out his voice. Geoff tate did some screams too without throwing out his clean voice. He just never mastered or figured out on how to do it properly.

[@gabrin80507870685]

Considering that the Keeper of the Seven Keys is over 30 years old and still blows the mind to this day, it is fair to say that this is a masterpiece in metal music!

[@stephanefarnes6398]

In any music!

[@anthonyz5671]

meh.

[@mirkomayer2601]

A masterpiece in musik, not only metal

[@nerdleituras2242]

Up

[@juniordaddyman]

When I first heard this song, I thought it was Iron Maiden. Great band, great song!!

[@nberedim]

24:37 Wow, I really love these two guys together. - Every Helloween fan ever.

[@luisnunes3863]

The return of Michael and Kai is about the best thing that could have happened to Helloween.

[@giasson91]

Deris, Kiske and Kai we're born to sing together.

[@carlosanderwald2360]

Yes. Just perfection.

[@georgekirchev9728]

"I really love these two guys singing together" - we all do , we all do ! It was the best thing ever to happen to this band.

[@Ejtan]

Agreed!

[@stumartin702]

Stunned me to hear them together. Kiske is one of my favorite vocalists, and the combo of hm and Andi is incredible. (Plus having Kai is incredibly awesome)

[@HaloAndRocknRoll]

amen

[@myhorseisamazing5883]

Too bad album is just average :(

[@fernandomedeiros744]

Elizabeth, take note that this song was performed as the last song of a 3 hour concert. Michael was destroyed at this point.

[@LuisMiranda-ww1ko]

I don't know. Here in Portugal it was the last of the first encore and they did 2 more on the second, Future World and I Want Out. Still, 3 hour+ long and they are not getting any younger

[@desape]

Not true they played 2 more songs after this one also to be more specific Michael Kiske was sick on this madrid concert and many songs got a lilttle studio help same goes for kai on the medley.

[@kalkman.]

Also keep in mind that Kiske did not sing all the songs and that there was a pause of about five minutes between each song that was spiced up by a video clip.

[@yotambraunshtein9786]

Wait seriously omg omg

[@FuckGoogle2]

Not to mention this looks like a recent live performance, how about the version of it when it came out back in the 80s?

[@tristramcoffin926]

My favorite thing about Elizabeth's reactions is how infinitely curious she is. She craves wonder and explodes with glee at every discovery. A lot of people who are 'experts' in a field of study shift their sense of personal worth and importance to highlighting that expertise. They become, for lack of a better term, snobs because of their extensive knowledge about the subject. Elizabeth doesn't do this. There is no pretense. She remains like a child excited to learn more. That is invaluable in a person far beyond merely what makes their KZbin channel interesting.

[@gawain6645]

I tend to overthink things too

[@robertmotsinger7599]

Agreed. It is like a comment I saw when she did one of the Dio episodes. I can’t remember the exact words but this is the gist. -we spent so much time trying to share the music we loved which those we spent time with and only got polite smiles and nods with “yeah, that’s cool” while watching her enjoy the discovery of something that I like and is important to me is awesome!

[@MikeMcD-sm2ds]

Michael Kiske is just as amazing in Unisonic!!!!

[@ricardoslhenriques]

There's something incredibly charming about pretty women getting geeky about nerdy stuff.

[@jimmurphy3287]

Plus what have they ever written or composed????

[@Zino027]

You should hear the 18 year old Kiske. Outstanding.

[@rodrigo1914_]

Both music and lyrics in this song were composed by Mr. Michael Weikath, one of the guitar players. Such a genius.

[@ricknesar1627]

I cannot believe how well, Kiske´s voice has aged. First time I went to a Helloween concert was back in 1988 in Stockholm, Sweden. They opened up for Iron Maiden

[@eduleal]

Good reason for it, he had a 20 year break from touring.

[@ThomasTallant]

@@eduleal True. But outside of his teenage lungs he sounds road ready!

[@frodbolf]

I sat here and whished I'd hear Helloween live..... and you reminded me that I already HAD! Same tour but in Gothenburg

[@bars2020]

Yeah. And listen how Iron Maiden sounds now...

[@olavkarlsson6430]

I was also where at that concert. I went to see maiden and bought the helloween album the next week. I still remember future world.

[@subbielover9374]

Helloween and Iron Maiden are both very nice example of great musicianship played by bunch of very nice people, loving it , enjoying it and loving their fans as well . That's why all the fans love them. There is still so much Helloween material to react to.

[@mattiaswibom4788]

Simple people with simple pleasures and both feet on the ground. Great fans too

[@Fortunabandofficial]

That’s just perfect comment. Exactly what i think - these two bands bring me joy everytime

[@jermicah]

This might sound almost unbelievable but I've thought Iron Maiden is the best rock ever since the early 80's yet I'd never listened to Helloween until now. I'd heard the name but assumed they were a joke like Insane Clown Posse. Now I have a whole "new" to me band to chase down the rabbit hole and see what I missed. Fire up the bong!

[@paladinminipedro707]

you are not wrong. Up the irons from the USA!! I love Helloween but i just adore Iron Maiden!!

[@efrenbencomo5198]

what a bad comparisson Iron Maiden > hellowern

[@Drewboo1968]

I'm 53, I remember seeing Helloween at Donington 1988. I was a snot faced lad of 20. Michael Kiske was a machine then, and still is. Love hearing this, I didn't even realise he had rejoined The Pumpkin Army. Very cool!

[@Siegdrifa]

Yhea, Kiske and Kai are back in Helloween, and they just released their new album simply named "Helloween", and they totaly delivered.

[@facuancla967]

Viste a maiden también?

[@jamesmccormick875]

The Keeper of the 7 keys albums are metal masterpieces. Kiske is the without a doubt the best singer Helloween had. He’s just simply amazing.

[@bottishg]

Kiske is the without a doubt one of the best singer the whole metal world had.

[@jamesmccormick875]

@@bottishg I completely agree. When I was a teenager I bought both Keeper of the Seven Keys cassette tapes and listened to them none stop. As a guitarist I was amazed at the Neo-Classical shredding Kai and Michael did. I sat down and tried to learn everything they played. The entire band are incredible musicians. They never got enough credit in the US for how incredible they are.

[@Figu69]

@@jamesmccormick875 orginal LPs

[@carstenhedwig4423]

To those of you wondering what was going on there: It was not exactly "Helloween" it was "Pumpkins united" performing keeper of the seven keys. Michael Kiske (the bald one) famous singer of Helloween back in the 80s and 90s lost his way and left the band. Kai Hansen, Mr. "German Heavy Metal" (the one with the red guitar with eyes) left the band in 1988 to form Gamma Ray. These two met again at T. Sammets project "Avantasia" (A metal opera that Eliisabeth should check out as well) after a couple of years going their own ways and found out they still have it... They contacted Helloween with the idea of going on a reunion toour in 2015. So thats why there are 3 guitars und 2 singers on stage. Fun fact: that reunion tour was so successful that Hansen and Kiske remained in Helloween, latest song is "Skyfall", just published a couple of weeks ago. kzbin.info/www/bejne/nX25ZmZmo5ieg9k

[@swabia1554]

defnitely necessary to go through avantasia as well as gamma ray though! Also Primal Fear might be interesting.

[@cvanette]

Hansen, Kiske, and Deris all currently handle lead vocals, while Maiden has had three guitarists (Murray, Smith and Gers) for 20+ years. Who says you can't have three of everything? Maybe Judas Priest should look into getting Simon Phillips and Les Binks to join Scott Travis on drums.

[@Dirty-Viking-Audio]

inaccurate ... Kiske and Hansen never lost contact and had always remained friends after Hansen left and Kiske was essentially fired from Helloween. Gamma Ray's classic album "Land Of The Free" from '95 had 2 songs with Kiske performing vocals on it and on Kiske's 1st solo album "Instant Clarity" from '96 Hansen made guest guitar appearances. At that time Sammet was busy with the band Edguy. The 1st Avantasia album didn't come out until 2001. Sammet definitely helped Kiske get re-interested in performing metal again though, as for several years prior he had slipped into more singer/songwriter type stuff, having become somewhat disenfranchised with the metal scene in general

[@chilesuicmez]

cheers mate, im an spanish native speaker, how is KISKE pronounced? kees-keh? or kees-kee? and would it be michael as in michael jordan or mee-shell? or mee-kah-el? since they are from germany.

[@der6beinigehund]

@@chilesuicmez kzbin.info/www/bejne/nYatqmWKbKZ5r7s ... right at the beginning you hear the german pronunciation ...

[@robertgriffith3139]

This song is part 2 of a trilogy. It starts out with "Halloween", then "Keeper of the Seven Keys", and ends with 'King for a Thousand Years". Every song is between 13-15 minutes. Every song is epic on this scale.

[@chrism4522]

This guy is old and he knows. \m/

[@elicapps6585]

Is this true?

[@txukoo]

king for a thousand years is just sublime

[@sejuanisupportonly7385]

@@elicapps6585 Of course it is. Metal bands do have mega-epic songs that span albums telling a tale. E.g. Rhapsody of fire or Ayreon

[@wesleyfilms]

I’ve noticed that several other songs by Helloween make reference to Keeper as well. My Life for One More Day, for example,

[@josephbeguhl5224]

It's amazing that Michael Kiske can still belt this one out after more than 30 years

[@kristofvandebroek9435]

Maybe you can do a reaction on Savatage!! Gutter ballet or When the crowds are gone are great songs. On streets or Gutter ballet there are a lot of fantastic songs from John Oliva!

[@apixphotographystudios]

How interesting that KZbin gives the chance to people who listen to different styles of music listen and enjoy music of other kinds. And Michael is 53 years old and his voice still sounds so young.

[@martinbenko2728]

Making this kind of channels become a trend. Everybody wants to react to something he or she haven't heard yet and get views with it. But this channel just stand out from the line. You don't just react, but analyse and understand the music too. You aren't doing this, because this is a trend. But because you love music. It's easy to see how passionate you listen to it. More reaction channels should be like this. It's a prime example of good reaction channels.

[@blatherama]

She's been on a metal journey for a while. It's been a lot of fun.

[@martinbenko2728]

@@blatherama I know, this isn't the first time i saw her video. :) But this was the first time when i felt that this channel is somehow outstanding for me from the ocean of review channels.

[@blatherama]

@@martinbenko2728 This is the only "reacton channel" to which I've subscribed.

[@Shortokeiki]

@@martinbenko2728 You may wanna check out Key of Geebz too, he's a composer who has a lot of cool insight to how the music ties together

[@smurray71]

Possibly the best choice for an first listen to Helloween. It's a shame that many people just dismissed them as a 'cheap copy of Iron Maiden'... they really should have been recognized for their musicianship & uniqueness. Most of what they do is nothing like Maiden

[@Selynn.]

I've listened to Helloween for more than 25 years and I've never ever heard anybody saying that about them. Who are these "many people"?!

[@jsmithers.]

@@Selynn. I don't dismiss them as a cheap copy, but when I first heard this band I absolutely thought of Iron Maiden. I'm sure a lot of people do. It's not crazy.

[@DerEchteBold]

@@Selynn. I agree, I have never heard that back then and I never thought it!

[@DerEchteBold]

@@jsmithers. Do you remember when this was, what phase of Helloween?

[@jsmithers.]

@@DerEchteBold It was maybe like 5 years ago. I forget the album though. Probably was an older one

[@MrAndrebatera]

The coolest thing about this perfomance is to see how Kiske is aware that its a very difficult song to sing and therefore he starts singing knowing that he can't use his voice like 30 years ago. But also he knows he has to sing ir like 30 years ago. He uses an increrible techniche and slowly but surely gets confortable with the song, till the moment 8:49 he is able to use his voice ecxatly like in the album version of the song. He is a master singer. Really one of a kind.

[@MatthewGClarke]

It's happening! It's finally happening! One of my all time favourite vocal performances

[@sethkaicer319]

I love it when a plan comes together

[@fzoulcmbyl2134]

Only since it's the recent live version, it's not the same as the all time vocal performance of the studio album, oh well.

[@steekbaard84]

#worth

[@pedropulido2571]

I was in that concert and I swear it was the most mind blowing experience of my whole life

[@rafarequeni822]

I have the impression that all of the spanish metalheads over 30 were there. It's the only concert I've been where everybody that I know that likes heavy metal was also present. :)

[@MrsVRKotsk]

This album has been my favourite for 30 years (I'm 36), I can never articulate just how much this is my absolute perfect album. I'm in love with every note and beat of it, if it were a person I would marry it. How is Kiske's voice still the same?? My god, Hansen, Kiske and Slash need to collab 😮 fuucccckkkkk I just musicame

[@TrueDeathblacK]

Gal, I'm 28 and I was mesmerized by the original, or so I thought, but then I heard the reunion. Kiske's performance when he was only 19 was astonishing, no doubt, but it's even more impressive that he can still hit these notes and sustain them now. Of course, I'm not nearly as good as they are, but if I can keep my voice in shape when I'm 50, I'll probably be the happiest man alive, unlike my SO or neighbours.

[@magnificusB]

I was there, was insane, one of the best live perfomances i've attended.

[@jimmyggs91]

Good this got out of the copyright strike "limbo", so to speak! Next one, "I Want Out" I guess? It's a Power Metal classic.

[@DocHogan]

Listen to KZbinr Raphael Mendez’ “What if Bruce Dickinson Sang for Helloween - I Want Out” cover. It’s phenomenal

[@josipkomes401]

@@DocHogan thank you man 🤘🏻 Super cool cover of I want out

[@RedBeardAnubis]

That or Eagle Fly Free or How Many Tears. lol

[@stevesperling1489]

I want out is a rock classic, absolutely should be reviewed

[@glandilovsky7061]

@@DocHogan wow, thanks for the recommendation, that guy is amazing and his voice is really close young Bruce's

[@andreaspedersen3952]

The most interesting part is that he recorded the vocals to the original before he was 20! Such a vocal talent!! ...also... So sad that "Mr. Smile" isn't here.. R.I.P Ingo

[@gilfamaertarsatir8497]

R I P Ingo 😔

[@ibrobaifett7493]

This was the quickest 30 minute video I’ve watched lol. Love watching you break down my favorite metal vocalist. Kiske is a gem. Andy is also super amazing and watching them together was the culmination of 30 years of Helloween

[@realhellzicke3661]

This is my new favourite channel. You have so much knowledge in not only voice techniques but also in music and composing in general. So fresh to hear your comments on different styles and pieces of music. Also, I'm a long time Helloween fan and you gave me new insight to this masterpiece even after 35 years listening to it. Thank you and great work!

[@Suddsy.]

The godfathers of power metal. 🤘🤘

[@Rimpianto]

Power metal is basically Helloween and various cover bands.

[@Dreamdancer11]

Basically its Kai Hansen and most of his bands.....

[@josehernandez2638]

Long Live Kai!

[@MetaleroNui]

Don't forget Dio

[@MattSamma]

I bring you another Helloween suggestion: "March of Time". Is probably one of the most vocal-demanding songs of the band. Kiske recorded the voices for that song when he was 18, but he did a great job singing it back again during their last tour. The Kiske-Deris combination was something that no one was expecting 5 years ago, but they complemented very well. I have high expectations for the upcoming album with them on the voices. Also, if you liked power metal and it's classical music influence, I think you definitely should check Rhapsody of Fire.

[@enriquesotelo7739]

How'bout We Got the Right lad?

[@jerrybrown1446]

I played this song in the car for my mother, who was raised on Spanish and gospel music, not being exposed to much rock or metal. She yelled from the back seat “Who is this? This is really good!” That made me happy because she’s very picky about vocals.

[@jonathangimenez3061]

At the minute 24:39 of the video.. I can hear into my head the EPIC solo coming after that drums beat and the tempo changing.. Btw I LOVE the way you analize the song but what I love the most is the way you react to every detail or changes on the song. Awesome videos, I'll keep watching them 🙌

[@renatoshimabukuro8037]

The lyrics, the melody, Michael's voice...Keeper of the seven keys is a masterpiece!

[@cperret47]

PLEAAASE DO "HOW MANY TEARS" IN THIS CONCERT, it features the 3 singers in the same song, ITS PURE JOY

[@koponny3287]

Yes Kiske, Hansen and Deris in one Song! I think this is the very fucking best Version of this Song!

[@devilalienuproar]

Kiske is still the only metal singer I have ever seen do a vocal solo live. And his voice is still as powerful as ever! The Pumpkins United concert was amazing in Vegas

[@MrKawika64]

I was at that show too!

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

Want to support or hang out with me and the community? Join our Patreon. We have an amazing Discord, do 2 live chats per week (usually), play video games, get behind the scenes footage and content, masterclasses, polls and pick content for me and this channel, and soon to be merch deals. It’s a ton of fun, and I hope to see this community grow! www.patreon.com/thecharismaticvoice

[@user-kt8mg3kd3h]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/paDXXouogrmmmqM

[@davidnaturopata4259]

Please comment “Your Turn" of Helloween live.

[@macm3081]

better than the highly overrated ronnie james dio

[@pabloyacomini326]

@@macm3081 YOU DON'T LOVE MUSIC. WE ARE STUPID AND DISRESPECTFUL. YOU DON'T NEED TO DEPRESS RONNIE JAMES DIO'S 35-YEAR CAREER TO SPEAK GOOD OF KISKE. BECAUSE YOU DON'T ENJOY BOTH. ASK KISKE WHO THEY ADMIRES AS A SINGER OR WHO HIS MODELS WERE. ON THE OTHER HAND KISKE IS AN EXCELLENT SINGER. BUT THEY ARE DIFFERENT STYLES, SO BECAUSE YOU DON'T LEARN TO ENJOY THE DIFFERENT STREAMS OF MUSIC. PEOPLE WHO GENERATE DICHOTOMIES IN MUSIC MISS A LOT AND VERY GOOD MUSIC. IT IS NOT ONE OR THE OTHER, YOU DO NOT HAVE TO BE A SECTARIAN. YOU HAVE TO ADD AND LEARN. I HOPE LIFE WILL TEACH YOU AT SOME TIME

[@pabloyacomini326]

@@macm3081 APART DID YOU KNOW THAT ELIZABETH HAD ALREADY MADE THIS REACTION TO HELLOWEN MONTHS AGO, AND DUE TO MUSICAL RIGHTS THEY MADE IT DOWNLOAD. THIS IS NOT A COMPETITION OR TO MAKE YOU JEALOUS BECAUSE I REACTED TO DIO FIRST AND HELLOWEN LATER. THERE IS MUCH MORE MUSICAL VARIETY IN DIO'S CAREER THAN KISKE'S. BUT IT IS ONLY A DETAIL. THE TWO ARE EXCELLENT. LONG LIVE ROCK AND ROLL, AND ALL THE MUSIC.

[@NaglfarCommando]

Classical music was just Heavy Metal before electricity.

[@consonaadversapars]

Except classical composers could develop a piece in one million and hundred ways while all the metal guys are doing is 4 times Riff A, 4 times Riff B, rinse and repeat. 😄

[@enricomadrigal9168]

Bach, Beethoven, Mozart and Vivaldi🤘 would have been all metalheads for sure!

[@lucyferina]

That needs to be a Tshirt

[@Darkhound_]

Heavy metal musicians just use phrases and styles back from the classical era. Cool though.

[@kalmansilai336]

​@@consonaadversaparsyeah that's the difference between 20-50 people with every possible type of isntrument vs 4 guys with guitars and drums

[@keeponlivin81]

A Symphony X reaction is a must! Russell Allen can melt your face and bring you to tears in the same breath. Kiske is still a wonder after all these years.

[@mapinguarimonster]

Russell is the best vocalist the world has ever had, in my opinion

[@jorgeluz9560]

Russell Allen is probably the best metal singer out there, these days. The dude is the closest we ever got to having another Dio. Unfortunately there aren't a lot of professional videos of Symphony X performing live.

[@kuhne]

Symphony X was never my thing but I respect them

[@mapinguarimonster]

@@kuhne You can say the band don't make your taste, but it's impossible to deny that Russell Allen isn't a monster in vocal abilities. Check out his work with Star One, a project of progressive metal from the Mastermind Arjen Lucassen, the same behind Ayreon. It's killer in every way

[@kuhne]

@@mapinguarimonster they are very talented, it was just never a band I got into. Not really my style. But of course they are great.

[@mudvi]

please do more on helloween . one of the most talented singers in the world and their studio hits are timeless. i was introduced to this german band by my japanese mother from hiroshima and it’s incredible how his voice stands the test of time and touches from around the world

[@nachoherrera9792]

I love that she is in a path that will lead her, sooner or later to Avantasia. And dude, I cannot wait to see that reaction

[@mtaffer]

Yes Avantasia!

[@benholmes7501]

Shelter from the Rain damn that would be awesome

[@shyguy6185]

She will end up in prog eventually

[@luisnunes2010]

If she is still avoiding nuclear blast as much as possible, there's always Shaman ft. Tobias Sammet.

My fav forever

[@TheDVM1]

I love how giddy you get when something awesome happens.. The sign of a true musician.

[@Fiat_Lux_23]

I lived right across the street from Michael Kiske back when we both still were kids, and I can attest to the fact that he's taken more than one page from Geoff Tate's playbook by listening to a lot of Queensryche before catching his big break with Helloween, but hearing him now, his voice has aged so much better.

[@damage.0776]

I've been following your channel for many months and i've always thought i really love your sincere smile, 'cause i think you are one of the few people I still see being truly and sincerely moved by listening to music. Thanks for your emotions. Greetings from Italy and sorry for my english

[@joe-zj8js]

Her smile and laugh are very infectious

[@Fenry]

There were three singers of helloween: first kai hansen sang (the founder and solo guitarist, he left helloween and founded gamma ray where he currently sings and is a solo guitarist), secondly kiske, which gave the group world fame, and finally Andy deris arrived, who managed to maintain the quality and progress of the group. The 3 are very great singers and very particular, they are very special voices.

[@CheeseNacho_]

this is one of the best songs ever written! and i also love so much the combination of Kiske's and Deris's voices, they both are incredible amazing

[@helloween76]

So awesome that you can appreciate a band/song/singer that I've appreciate for the past 30 years!!!! Thank you soo much for this great video

[@crazywolf5177]

This band has a very very special place in my heart. They got me into metal. One of the highlights of my life was seeing them at Wacken Open Air in 2018. Thank you for doing this. I'm sorry that I can like this only once.

[@ericwilliams1031]

A really good American band named Savatage is worth some reactions. Some of their members formed The Trans Siberian Orchestra. Songs: Hall Of The Mountain King Strange Wings Gutter Ballet When The Crowds Are Gone

[@rafaelcabraldelacerda9874]

'Alone You Breathe' too! So hard to pick when it's savatage!

[@markuskrueger1197]

We know Sagatage in Germany....gutter Ballade is a great Album....but WE have great Albums too...so ....what?

[@MrJbone1973]

I live in the Tampa area and they were a great band my favorite album is Streets A Rock Opera.

[@gringochucha]

Michael Kiske's voice is simply magical. He just takes you to another dimension.

[@geraldramirez3486]

This song is truly a masterpiece. Every detail, every harmony, every word in the lyrics. I enjoyed the video just as I enjoy every minute of this song. Thanks Helloween for such a demonstration of pure art. I've seen it live twice in 2017 and 2022 (less than one month ago) and it's impressive how 7 guys can put this epic song together on stage.

[@lordhypnos8360]

Helloween and Gamma Ray have a special place in my heart, they broke me out of my pure Death Metal phase in the early 00's and introduced me to the wonderful world of Power Metal. So this video along with bonus Elizabeth growl is a instant thumbs up from me, just glorious.

[@kayl8351]

So so glad you mentioned Gamma Ray. Such underrated power metal!

[@zipponline]

You need to check out Queensryche’s Operation Mindcrime album. The entire album tells a story and the vocals are spectacular.

[@dawnpelz8570]

Absolutely. I saw them do Mindcrime opening for Metallica in 1988 and it was amazing.

[@codecat8430]

Yes! Breaking the Silence is my favorite song from the album. But the entire album is a masterpiece!

[@Danimal77]

Geoff's vocal's were much better on The Warning and Rage For Order album.

[@DarKodama]

I totally agree

[@russellsmithers2794]

Yes please cover this song :-)

[@darrenhitchcox6345]

What a brilliant review and I loved the way you instantly picked up his stance and power. The studio version of the track, that end note still makes me say damn after 30 years, one the most impressive note holds in metal.

[@christophercowan1645]

I love how happy their talent makes you! I saw them in oak. CA in 88. I was blown away by Kiske. AMAZING, how he has kept his voice. The new album is amazing!

[@chrisoceanfield8551]

"Keeper of the seven keys" is one of the greatest songs of all time ❤️

[@vanessaexga]

Eagle Fly Free is a Helloween great song ❤️

[@tomp4812]

Yes…👌👍💪

[@demus89]

That song got me away from an evil woman in my life.

[@alfiewenn9440]

Great song my favourite by Halloween

[@gawain6645]

Sim

[@nicki12345]

Mine too !

[@vidopliasov]

Thank you very much for your reaction. I remembered my youth. Ocean, starry sky and "Keeper of the seven keys".

[@hzg8943]

Came for the vocals dissections...enjoyed the side of musical appreciation, too! It's amazing that one of my favourite songs has layers to admire that my untrained ears have no idea about! >_< Love this lady!!! ♥

[@toxsin2207]

I love how you enjoy the music as if you were a kid in a candy store.

[@MattSamma]

A 'Keeper of the Seven Keys' reaction it's an insta-like, but a reaction of this song by Elizabeth it's like I need to give a thousands likes

[@enricomadrigal9168]

One of the best metal songs ever made hands down.

[@1969bones69]

Wow I remember picking up this cassettte when I was 15 haha. Good times.

[@phosstheboss04]

Lol no blast beats detected, but hearing you say "blast beats" brought so much joy to my heart!

[@albarry5444]

Hahahahaha. Yup.

[@tommy5675]

This Man Plants Himself stronger than Trees can. He is Solid. Perfect platform for projection

[@CarlosSanchez-CRSZZZ]

Una de las canciones más icónicas. Excelente análisis, como siempre. 🙂🙂🙂

[@Bigwoody95826]

I love this song, I cry every time I hear it. It just hits something in the soul.

[@AlRozon]

That pitch-bend that he has is Kiske's signature .. you cannot mistake his voice simply because of that little detail.. simply love this guy's voice... and it hasn't changed in 30 years... that performance is near perfect to the original record, without all the fancy sound fx they put on the album version.

[@Breeg2011]

"Keeper of the Seven Keys" is still giving me goosebumps. Even after all these years!

[@ocaceresg86]

Love watching your metal journey, can't stop watching your reactions

[@ergoliat]

Thank you for give me old memories back with this song. Great comments about kiske's technique and voice. Cheers from Chile.

[@krea_knaegten]

I just realised iv'e been listening to Helloween for 35 years 😮🤘

[@linusfotograf]

31 years for me.

[@krea_knaegten]

@@linusfotograf we are getting old my friend....😉

[@linusfotograf]

@@krea_knaegten Yes we are

[@RaulDiazG]

27 here! We are really getting old hahahaha

[@MetalGildarts]

Only few months for me but frick it they’re awesome.

[@alanclarke8117]

Awesome vocal display by Michael. Never quite understood why they didn't explode in the US like they did in Europe. The first two Keeper albums are, well... Keepers. Both were arguably top-10 metal albums in their release years, and there's a ton of good albums to follow.

[@oglschmitt]

The U.S. metal scene was different. A bit grittier I think, dominated by NWOBHM and Bay Area Thrash types. Michael is amazing though. The fact that he is 53 and still killing it is a testament to his talent. Also, there is a multi-lane rabbit hole opening for Elizabeth here with Helloween and their various vocalists (Hansen era, Deris era, Gamma Ray, Kiske's solo work).

[@dpjb78]

The numerous changes of lineup and style between 84 and 93 made the band style very unstable. Cameleon album came to destroy all the work accomplished in the Keepers era. The Deris era is full of cheap songs, it’s another band for me and I’m not surprised that the US public did not support it so much. Another big problem was that in the Keepers era they became famous so rapidly that their ego was big enough to disrespect Iron Maiden and Metallica declaring that these bands would disappear soon in the beginning of 90’s.

[@ryanb6454]

@@dpjb78 I was a hardcore fan in the 80’s and 90’s and dont remember Helloween dissing I.M. ?? I mean, they were/are friends and ‘Ween supported Maiden on several tours.. Adrian and Kai and Kiske have contributed on each other’s solo projects. Kiske has named Dickinson/Maiden a huge early influences many times in interviews. IF they ever said it, it surely would’ve been in jest and taken out of context. To top it all off they were managed by Maiden/Smallwood in the 90’s (though they had a big falling out with Rod later). To be fair though, Metallica *Did* disappear in the 90’s and haven’t been the same since ;-)

[@dpjb78]

@@ryanb6454 I was also a hardcore fan (heavy-metal fan I mean :D) … I read a lot of interviews in specialized magazines. All you say is true but I don’t remember they were laughing when they said that maiden was over and would replace them. I wish I could read this interview again! :) It’s also true that Maiden and Metallica had a hard time in the following decade but for me Helloween did not escape to this fate. It’s funny to realize that Kiske almost took the artistic direction in post-Hansen albums but just destroyed the band, left it and years later come back in grace in Helloween neighborhood with an aura that a few can pretend. :) I’ve listened to the single track of the new album and I’m not in extase for that sound that I think I always knew since the beginning of Deris era. Metallica creates something new on each album since Saint Anger and I like that, for me they were back with that LP. :) About Maiden, I’m not a big fan of their studio sound since Brave New World but I think they reached the goal they aimed as being the Rolling Stones of heavy metal. Helloween can just compete with Scorpions :D ;)

[@robbyrob1834]

Seen them a few years ago in berlin, pumpkins united tour, 3 hours of great music by a great band, it was fantastic. I,m listening helloween for nearly 40 ! years and today I'm getting goosebums listening to Kiskes voice !

[@wind-upboy939]

It's 30 years for me, but I also still get goosebumps.

[@MrsVRKotsk]

If I were at this gig I would have been in floods of tears I think, it just...makes my soul feel complete

[@ShredmasterScott]

Every Halloween I listen to Helloween's song Halloween muhaha

[@watakoe]

Shredmaster!!

[@Godlobber]

Me to

[@stephenmustard8388]

@@Godlobber me three

[@l.l.8369]

It's a tradition man! 🤟🏻

[@myoutdoorlife3833]

Lol same here! Glad I'm not the only Helloween Halloween freak! 😂

[@SlashHN]

That's what I like about Kiske, his voice sounds like he's 18, so powerful, with good highs and lows... Omg I love when professional singers hear his voice and notice about these details

[@artierenfroe7205]

I haven't heard this song in years. Great review!

[@stephanefarnes6398]

I used to listen to this at 13-14 years old I'm turning 40 this year 2021.... it's still epic rock opera, much-loved, and unbelievable!!!!

[@kirbys1370]

Hi Elizabeth, I'm glad that you were able to re-instate this video. I don't remember my original comment from October 2020, but Michael Kiske's vocals were incredible and the band put on an amazing performance. Thank you, Elizabeth, for ALL your hard work, patience, and persistence! You're the BEST!!! 💙

[@wellesongoncalves1382]

Finally, I was waiting for that day, one of the best songs I've ever heard in my life, in the voice of the impeccable michael kiske, this song is incomparable.

[@jasondornford1832]

One of my favorite bands from my youth, 5/23 I will see them live for the first time at 57 years old better late than never, so stoked.

[@ripcordjack]

Always love when my mom tells story's of going to school with some of them. And how they always practiced in one of the music rooms, let my mom stay there and made sure she was safe and chill cause she couldn't go home/was bullied a lot at the time

[@edusszfx]

Sweet baby Jesus, Kiske and Andi sing so well together! I love there's no ego fight between them.

[@Kreontas]

Yeah ever since they met they've been good friends and the fact they genuinely like each other so much is the reason the Pumpkins United line up works so well! Once Weiki sat down and talked with Kiske again the chemistry was complete.

[@jimipane2013]

Hi, I'm so happy that you finally reacted to this performance. I've been listening to Helloween since i was a little boy. These people never get old 😅😅😅. Michael Kiske has been singing for decades, and his voice never aged a bit! Great reaction as always!!

[@TempleOvBlackLight]

One of the best things to happen in metal in many years, seeing past singers of Helloween united on stage! Love your reaction vids!

[@sappyhead]

His voice sounds just as amazing as it did when he was 19. Incredible.

[@oglschmitt]

Same thing happened to my ears when I first heard Helloween! First Gloryhammer, now this! You're delivering the goods, Mrs. Zharoff! (As is Kirk, that thumbnail is ADORABLE!)

[@markuskaufmann3515]

I swear you’re right that metal has much in common with classic music! The violinist Nigel Kennedy said many years ago that metal is the classical music of the future!

[@stevenskogen3624]

Helloween is my second favorite band of all time. First being Life of Agony. Thank you for doing these. Your technical knowledge and passion really shines through.

[@edwingionzago]

Excellent reaction. One of my favourite bands of all time. You nailed it.

[@pauloamw]

Kiske kept his vocal power but aged beautifully, smoothing the edges and gaining a lot of chatacter. Fun fact: he is a big Elvis fan.

[@IRISHguitarist777]

KISKE/SOMERVILLE "City of Heroes" an absolutely epic tune,well worth a video as it's a duet too so might be a novelty for that alone.

[@4isteven58]

I first listened to helloween a few months ago. I could have been listening to them since I was 2, but it took me 36 years to pull my head out of my butt. Thanks for the analysis, I really enjoyed it!

[@jan-assarlaine8312]

I just love watching how excited you get about metal vocalists.

[@masternovahlavoie998]

Hands down, one of my favorite songs/albums of the 80's. ❤️

[@pandemonikussuperbus4590]

Back then kiske and Dickinson were the 2 strongest voices in metal. This song is the epitomy of prog power metal. It's a fking masterpiece

[@sunn_bass]

Kiske, Oliva, Dickinson, Tate and Dio all had great talent and powerful voices.

[@ryanb6454]

@FatalPies I’m a huuuge fan of all those guys.. but 30 years later can they still hit the notes like our Kiske ? No. But it isn’t a contest so anyways.. P.S. when I was a teenager I got VIP backstage to Queensryche and spent a few minutes doing cartwheels around the band . I told Geoff to his face that he had the second best voice in metal. He looked at me with a slight curl of his lip and said “well who’s the best then?” Of course I told him Michael Kiske. Chris D and Michael W started to giggle at Geoff who had a pissed off look (fan meet n greets werent his thing anyway). LOL man I had some nerve !

[@enekoaritzaorreaga]

Marc boals, mike vescera, ralph shefers, rob rock,mat leven,jeff scott soto,fabio lione,henning.basse.

[@davegnarlsson4344]

Back then? You mean two years ago?

[@11DNA11]

Kiske and Halford.

[@alistairblair2992]

Saw them in Chicago last month! Absolutely brilliant!

[@zackbumm1943]

Love this analysis, even though I’m two years late with catching up on it. As a kid, I was totally into Helloween (with Michael) and was also an fan of Andy. He sang with Pink Cream 69 by the time, based in my hometown Karslruhe. Being a musician myself, we often ran into these guys at various gigs or when we’d go hit the clubs at rock-nights. Couldn’t you do a tea-time interview wir Michael&Andy, sure would be a really great thing to happen 😀