HOLLOW// Mapleshade PMV

get it....hollow...because she's dead inside....
who did what?
-CLIMB-
Sketch, Lines, Backgrounds, Coloring
Deviantart: climbtothestars.deviantart.com/
Tumblr: / climbstudio
-HOXAU-
Storyboard, Shading, Editing*
Deviantart: hoxau.deviantart.com/
Furaffinity: www.furaffinity.net/user/toxi...
-RORIIKA-
Coloring, Character Design
Deviantart: roriika.deviantart.com/
*everyone put thoughts&critique into the final production!
-----------
Warriors belongs to Erin Hunter
Hollow belongs to Cloudeater
Programs Used
Adobe Photoshop, Paint Tool Sai, Adobe After Effects, Adobe Premiere
________________________________________________
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.

[@Olivia-ie3xk]

i feel like we needed more crookedstar in the books. he literally lost everything and i think it kinda flew over everyone's heads. he just, he lost his mother and father early on, his brother, his mate, his kits, and yet he had a clan to lead n well .. whatever, this animation and song is amazing.

[@raccoonmistress7708]

ikr? Its why I like him more than Bluestar. I feel like he lost more than Bluestar, and yet still was a excellent leader. while Bluestar didnt listen about the obvious th ing of Tigerclaw being a evil cat and instead basically went insane.

[@lovllaby1249]

. +Raccoon Mistress I agree with you a lot. I do personally like bulestar and yeah she went insane basically but I can get why, her deputy, one she truster very well turned on her(crookedstar didn't have that happen I think but his past was still tragic). tigerkit was also her sisters (snowfur) kits friend whitekit, and bluestar really did trust him a lot. She had to give up her kits, and thats like super freaking hard to even do and think about, including if you loose one on the way.She had lost a lot she cared about like crookedstar did, and she still lead her clan to become stronger than it was until the last of her lives. She felt like star clan hated for what she did and then she begun to hate herself even more. She also was the one who brought rusty to the clan and look where the clan is now :). anyhow, sorry for my long ass rant lmao and I do agree w you xD

[@marvelousatrocity3047]

Raccoon Mistress I like crookedstar bluestar tallstar and yellowfang all the same

[@blixblox-left]

Sammy C same

[@Angelique-ot5nf]

Agreed!

[@ningaella4267]

I feel like Mapleshade isn't just dead inside, she's pretty much dead in general.

[@scaredsharks1819]

whoa, that's deep. right from the heart. *sniffle*

[@kedamono639]

The burn! xD

[@sleepy5591]

mind Blowing

[@foxpandagames3598]

lol

[@starryheart8962]

That's deep xD

[@mangle_coconuts9354]

Crookedstar's kits *exist* Mapleshade: hippitty hoppitty Your child previlges have gone wackitty

[@dvalimariam2785]

True xD A cat: *has a part in Crookedstar’s life* Mapleshade: your free trial of life has ended, pay up to continue living.

[@mapledrizzle8024]

Everyone’s saying how they feel bad for mapleshade but I feel bad for crookedstar. He did nothing and yet it was cause of his ancestor’s mistakes that he had to suffer so much :c

[@Icouldliveinhope]

What she did to him was wrong. He was completely innocent and had no idea about what happened and who Mapleshade was. i agree it was wrong, but Mapleshade was so angry and desperate, she missed her kits so much and even in death she couldn’t see them even once. The problem was she couldn’t let go of her anger, and took it out on poor Crookedstar

[@kashmoney6344]

Mapleshade is actually kind of refreshing from cats taking a mate from a different clan and nothing really happening, she actually went through a lot of suffering and was exiled because of it.

[@alyssag8099]

KASH MONEY Ya but it’s also unfair she’s the only one punished for it.

[@alyssag8099]

Or at least the only one severely punished for it.

[@morningrosie3684]

@@alyssag8099 well I can understand why. If I remember correctly Appledusk killed her leader’s son so I am not surprised.

[@prehistoricorchid3455]

Right? Like she's treated as the norm (cause that's whats supposed to happen) but like Greystrip got off Scott free. Leaf and crow got off Scott free aside from "we can't trust you now >:(" dovewing was a teenage romance mess and got literally no punishment. Like forbidden romances could be so interesting and spicy but they're so blank and predictable.

[@testerwulf3357]

@@morningrosie3684 I'm not 100% sure but I've heard her thing with apple was before that death happened, as well as the death was an accident. Even if they were mad at the father of the kits, exiling innocent defenseless kits was a horrible thing to do..they were too young.

[@MapleSpyder]

This is so beautifully drawn! I love the pacing on each of the drawings with the beat of the music. djuikisjkjh

[@mythicalmagic5501]

hello maple spider

[@akiren485]

I agree,I love the animated pictures! :P

[@keira8025]

dhdhuffh

[@thebiggestmonkey9172]

Weeaboo

[@jaydemcmillan]

MapleSpyder whats with thefngkgkbk

[@gix.y]

This is my favorite mapleshade PMV

[@blunnythelionbunny5569]

+Supernova45 Ikr it goes with Mapleshade so well, and I like the song as well xD

[@gore4332]

Same

[@xxemeraldeyexx4628]

I like this and Marshall deer by Ali cat

[@xxemeraldeyexx4628]

***** oh yeeeeaaaa...sry

[@davidwest9041]

mine too

[@hannaoleson2570]

But Mapleshade totally should have gotten a Super edition! It could have started right from when she was a kit until when she died

[@CatoftheStorm]

She should have two editions. I'd like her point of view after she died, because reading these comments reveals she did a lot of damage afterward. I only read Crockedstar's Promise and I've forgotten what happened there, but I've just read in the other comments that other editions and ebooks had her a lot more involved in the Clans.

[@jupiter3470]

Hanna Oleson I agree! It would be so good to have a story in her perspective!

[@somersetshat7810]

the "Mapleshade's vengeance " novella written by the Erins is about how Mapleshade lost her kits and killed three cats, including Appledusk. she then died from the fight with Perchpaw, Appledusk's apprentice and went in the Dark Forest. There isn't really anything more to write about, her whole story is explored in Crookedstar's promise , Tigerclaw's fury, Goosefeather's curse and the Omen of the Stars arc where we see her training Ivypool in the Dark Forest. She died in the great battle, while fighting Sandstorm, i think, after she killed Spottedleaf. As for starting from when she was a kit, her real problems ( Appledusk, Dark Forest) only started when she was a young warrior, so there really isn't anything extraordinary about her kithood. Sorry to crush your dreams but i really don't think we're getting another Mapleshade book. But you can always read Mapleshade's vengeance and the other books i mentioned, if you want more of her.

[@Dragonemperess]

She didn’t die. She was chased off by Sandstorm. Meaning she is still out there, lurking, waiting to try again.

[@thundrstormy]

Mapleshade is actually dead, so she just went back to the Dark Forest. She was killed by Perchpaw, Appledusk's apprentice, I believe.

[@Griffinilla]

Where do you find all these cool songs?

[@RawrRawr0221]

Meishy The album this song is in is called Purge, by Cloudeater.

[@ANZAKA_ACROMNIA]

Fandroid MUSIC! Oh hey! Ur a warriors fan??

[@TheEnderFox433]

Fandroid MUSIC! HAI

[@godoyrush902]

DJ Loud Spike in Argentina the third saga has not arrived yet

[@lunearr]

angel rhythm **PMV

[@TennelleFlowers]

So beautiful! I'm so glad I stumbled across your channel and watched this! Aaa, it's great!

[@lieutenantgraysquirrel2602]

TennelleFlowers Tunnelled Flowers! Hi!

[@veroniqueracine8317]

TennelleFlowers Hello!

[@parssley6]

It is great!!!

[@sunchaser6801]

TennelleFlowers hi hi hi

[@sunchaser6801]

TennelleFlowers what is your favorite part of this vid

[@rubellite6846]

While Broken and Tiger die, Mapleshade in still in the depths of the Dark Forest. Good job, Maplebae, you ran away!

[@shrimpchild]

Mapleshade be like: Who tf is this human calling me Maplebae? lol

[@RomanceGirl6666]

Crookedstar's last face-off with Mapleshade was so powerful. Crookedstar endured so much tragedy in his life, lost everyone he loved but he STILL stood up to her and told her she didn't win. She never would. Mapleshade tried so hard to destroy him, but he proved he was nothing like her. Loyal and true to himself to the end.

[@asteroidartistry9297]

this may sound weird, but I feel REALLY bad for Mapleshade, and I feel like she could've gone to Starclan and become a better cat if she had been reunited with her kits yeah, she killed some cats, but so did Hollyleaf and Ashfur almost killed kits as well as Squirrelflight not to mention, she was driven to insanity after a situation that wasn't really her fault Ravenwing was an absolute d--k Frecklewish watched kits drown, like wtf Appledusk abandoned her, their kits, and promises he made Mapleshade never lied about who the father was, she never confirmed or denied it freaking Thunderclan banished 3 helpless kits and their mother I just- GAH THESE CATS CAN BE SO STUPID I bet if Mapleshade had gone to Starclan and seen her kits, it would have brought her back to reality, because oh ho ho, she was kinda insane, starving, drained, and so on, she couldn't control herself, but having peace would've mended her... bleh, if you still find her evil or whatever, thats fine, but she feels a bit like a wasted storyline that could've been fixed Edit: okay its been three years, and lemme just say that I don't think her murders were completely justified, nor that she deserved to go Starclan. It think if she HAD gone to Starclan, she would've been at peace, and yes, she did say that she was happy to be in the dark forest after she died, but idk, I don't think she was really thinking straight at that point, plus revenge was basically all she had going for her by then. Also, out of the three she went after, I feel like Appledick was the only one who shouldve gone to the dark forest, Frecklewish and Ravenwing received punishment through being killed. The most Freckle could have done was call for help, and Raven overreacted, yes, but he didn't mean for them to be straight up exiled, I believe. I also think that the leader at the time, Oakstar, Shouldve had major repercussions ANYWAYS- canon Maple wasnt a good cat, but she could've been helped and was wronged by a lot of cats. In a different universe, she shouldve gone to Starclan and gotten that closure she desperately needed

[@desiarts9797]

MarkyNyanChan .w. I agree, and instead Appledusk goes to the Dark Forest.

[@DeviantCinnamonfur]

I've heard that they regretted sending Ashfur to StarClan and that most StarClan cats hate him anyway

[@lottie5807]

Ravenwing was being a loyal medicine cat. He had an omen from STARCLAN... was he meant to ignore this?? Was Frecklewish meant to heroically jump into the lake to check if the kits were okay?? Like seriously, what did Mapleshade to expect her to do...?? (Also Frecklewish even stated that she thought the kits had gotten out of the lake) Appledusk never abandoned the kits. He actually tried to save them. And let's not forget they were HIS kits as well. He going to be as equally as upset as her, but at least he didn't try to freaking murder her for it. But anyways, that's just my opinion.

[@myriahkeays3846]

IvyFrost It's been ages since I read Mapleshade's book, so I can't speak on any of that, but I was just curious about your reason for hating Jayfeather? This comment's a bit ancient by now, but oh well here I am ^^

[@kidshaldeman2091]

I sort of agreed. The way mapleshade was treated was unfair. She could’ve responded better, and it doesn’t much justify her actions, but it’s ridiculous that appledusk went to starclan. After everything that appledusk caused, it’s unfair that he’s still seen as an innocent cat that shouldn’t be blamed.

[@kittycatstudios3802]

i absolutely love your art!

[@Lanius5]

I know this is about Mapleshade, but I just want to point this out. Crookedstar had to go through so much cruelty, he literally had to watch his entire family die right in front of him, but in the end he stayed strong and didn't let it make him cruel. That is one hell of a strong cat. [not speaking English normally. Sorry for wrong grammar]

[@lassie3592]

that moment you realize mapleshade caused everything.

[@Netrioid]

Chloe L mapleshade knew that thoose cats or kits were going to die. So she tried to make crookedjaw/star feel like its all his fault.

[@kristinbrotherton1557]

its just like mapleshade killed lots of cats pinestar didn't kill his son so now his son is evil yellowfang gave birth to a demon child who murdered children and blamed it on her mapleshade, tigerstar, and brokenstar started to work together to kill the clans sol came back hollyleaf came back sol plotted with some of windclan sol attacked in the tunnels with windclan sol didn't help them hollyleaf almost killed sol but let him go because of the warrior code hollyleaf was kill by Hawkfrost saving ivypool the dark forest retreated mapleshade didn't die from the battle ivypool gave birth at a gathering bata bing bata boom mapleshade helped cause everything

[@alyssag8099]

Kristin Brotherton Why did you write it like that? Sorry it’s just kinda hard to understand but if I recall correctly Starclan Actucally reached out to Yellowfang and told her to try and be a “mother” to him. Not necessarily telling him but she let Brokenkit hang around the medicine den and she was “his friend” until Brokenstar got upset at something his adopted littermates said and pushed Yellowfang away. We can’t necessarily know what would’ve happened without Mapleshade interference because we only see what happened when she interfered. Mapleshade even whispered it Tigerstar ear pushing him to commit murder in Tigerstars novella. Tigerstar was destined to be a bad cat, so was Brokenstar prophecies were sent about them from the beginning but would they of been as bad without Mapleshade?

[@Rhinny_Rin]

@@alyssag8099 if they destined to be bad Cats then If Maple didnt Do it... They'll still bad cats tbh :/ I mean... You cant change Future or Things that are already destined like that- But I respect ur opinions

[@Rhinny_Rin]

That moment When U realize if the Clan doesnt do that to her, If her Mates didnt cheat, If Her kits Didnt die Everything'll not be like this... She isnt the only one who caused everything

[@shrimpchild]

I feel like Mapleshade actually pushed the rocks onto Oakheart. I have since I read Crookedstar's Promise.

[@greekcity1507]

Yeah, probably.

[@Meowcatkittykat]

Yea cuz I don't know how the rocks just fall 💀

[@greekcity1507]

no one does

[@Donnegail]

I'd just realize that MapleShade actually killed the all Appledusk's family, seeking for revenge. Because honestly I think even if she's a dark forest cat she can have impact on the "real" world (She's enough evil to x3). Applesusk's family was over with the death of Oakheart and Crookedstar. Or at least it's what she thought because she probably ignored that Oakheart actually had kids, thanksfully for them. This PMV is amazing because it fit her so perfectly :3

[@pridelandsqueen77]

I don't think she forgot Oakheart's or Crookedstar's descendants.

[@Donnegail]

pridelandsqueen77 Crookedstar's descendants clearly not but I guess she ignore that Oakheart actually had kits with Bluestar

[@pridelandsqueen77]

+coeurdor28 I don't mean to be rude, but I think your a bit wrong on this case. If you will allow me to explain why I have come to this conclusion in these next two comments, then you can criticize and see if it actually hold up. I always open to opinions.

[@pridelandsqueen77]

+coeurdor28 (1/?) this is what i know about Mapleshade: 1) in mapleahade's book she first swore revenge on ThunderClan as a whole for kicking her out. Then in last few pages of the book, she said she would punish EVERY descendants of Appledusk, and she would never stop. Ultimate guide said her goal eventually spread to all the Clans. 3) Her idea of punishment seem be if you suffer as much as she did, this can mean death or could mean losing everything 4) in Tigerclaw's e-book she is shown helping him to become a Shadowclan leader and get revenge on Thunderclan, and his b enemies, Fireheart and Bluestar. She said she been with since the day he was born and with Tigerclaw never questioning why he is had a FEMALE voice talking to him in his head until she appear to him, shows she has more hand in his life than we think. 4) don't think it is odd that tigerstar want to make one large Clan but then hold a execution of known RiverClan halfclans. Wouldn't it be beneficial to promote

[@pridelandsqueen77]

+pridelandsqueen77 2/?) ... The halfclans then quietly kill them off. This is what I think, what if Mapleshade was able to convince Tigerstar to hold a trails where the halfclans would have to fight each other to the death to prove their loyalty and if the refuses or fail, one of ShadowClan Warriors can take care of it. Since only known halfclans are Featherpaw & Stormpaw (crookedstar 's grandkids) and Mistyfoot & Stonefur (Oakheart's kids), she could kill the entire line in one move. If for some reason it doesn't work, they would carry either great guilt for what they done (like Mistyfoot) or may not longer trust RiverClan at all (like Stormfur) This would leave only Mistyfoot's kits. In Mistyfoot's book, leopardstar ask Mistyfoot why she didn't hatred her for what she did to all mixed Clan cats. Why would she say that, when only four half clans ? unless even the kits of half clan were included as well.

[@kamziik5612]

Mapleshade shoud be the actual angel of the death in Warriors lol

[@lillygrace7511]

YeS! sHe ShOuLd!!! ;P

[@candiednyx]

This is perfect for Mapleshade

[@frosteelynx1754]

Mapleshade may be evil and crazy but her FLOOFY TAIL THO!!!

[@kirstengamingyt6564]

"Aw, look, their playing," Moonflower said as Mapleshade murdered Crookedkit.

[@rubellite6846]

It would have been great if Crooked and Oak were Reedshine's kits, it would be awesome!

[@Noodlers]

they are reedshine & appledusk's grandchildren

[@rubellite6846]

Noodlers oh! Thanks for telling me! I haven't read CP yet, but thanks!

[@thatsahoot4011]

Noodlers Actually rain flower was their mother remember? I know they are related however, and it takes place 9 years after Mapleshade death so I'm thinking Reedshine died as their grandmother or she was their great grandmother

[@kittens4life165]

Charles Wylie yeah

[@shadowflowers7182]

Appledusk and Reedshine had Shellheart. Shellheart and Rainflower had Crookedstar and Oakheart.

[@scrimblo6706]

I love how you did crookedstars jaw, most people just make a tooth stick out, but you got it perfect

[@sonnyvee2065]

I just love how eerie this is. She was there, all the time in each book until Crookedstar's death. She was ALWAYS...there.

[@gamakichisora]

EVERYTHING ABOUT THIS IS ABSOLUTELY GORGEOUS... i'm in awe (especially of your grasp on color, wow)!

[@MortifiedMoth]

I hc that Mapleshade genuinely likes kits but her hatred for Appledusk was beyond that

[@Onyxseyes]

She doesn’t like kits 💀

[@bob1997]

Love how the text isn't so overbearing as in some other videos. Perhaps it's because the song is faster than you usually see in PMVs, but the movement is great and it feels fluid. Great tail for Mapleshade, btw.

[@bonedustt]

I am the only one who feels like early on, after Crookedkit first got abandoned, that he and Mapleshade had a bit of a Mother-Son relationship? I just feel like it would work so well! Crookedkit lost his mom and Mapleshade lost her kits. Its a perfect match! Either way this is my new AU...

[@JayJayHorray]

song: hollow- cloud eater you're welcome. AWSOME ANIMATION BTW!

[@laundrysauce354]

WhatTheFlubberNuggets nice name

[@spicethefox8273]

It just gives me shivers when I think about how he is chained to Mapleshade and can never escape because of his promise

[@gore4332]

Cause I'm hollow. Hollow.

[@nutmegforever4018]

ikr

[@pearlytheegg3838]

Mapleshade is one of my favorite Warriors characters.

[@jaidalassi731]

beautiful work. I honestly never realized how strong Crookedstar had to be. He lost litterally ALL his family except stonefur (silverstreams kit) and Mistystar.

[@Sundrown630]

you mean stormfur?

[@amym8551]

MapleShade is my favorite dark forest warrior

[@snebzz]

beautiful as always!!

[@dawnshadows4419]

When I first saw this I thought the blue cat was bluestar and the brown cat was oakheart and mapleshade was the only cat who knew about them and then killed bluestar and when I read the first book I was like 'where is mapleshade?"

[@playfulltriceratops6421]

I realized something while I was watching this, all 'bad cats' in warriors (that i know of) are gotten rid of, via death. Mudclaw: killed by falling tree. Hawkfrost: killed by Brambleclaw. Tigerstar: killed by Scourge. Scourge: killed by Firestar. Bone: killed by raging apprentices.

[@thegoatcarnival]

That's pretty much how all bad guys are supposed to be sent away before they try to do something worse. It's not just Warriors, Scar was gored by hyenas, Farquaad was eaten by a dragon, Syndrome was shredded by a jet engine. It's not a trait exclusive to Warriors, it's a common cliche.

[@playfulltriceratops6421]

Oh, didn't realize that

[@kuku8846]

Playfull Triceratops Tbh it's not like death is something uncommon. Everyone dies; it's how they die that differ, but yeah villains are usually killed and thus defeated (or exiled or they lose all their powers if the series can't kill them, etc). xD

[@starlingale]

Well its just rare for a villian to change sides or not be kicked to the side without dying. Death is just the most likely and reasomable way to remove the villian

[@MinoesTrashRat]

Playfull Triceratops Sol didn't die tho, just banished from clan territory. :)

[@xspicymsp5070]

Mapleshades design has changed a lot

[@Henkiwashere]

im on mapleshades side who joins?

[@scaredstiff7176]

Mwa

[@dollieheads5515]

Me, I love Mapleshade. All she wanted to do was love but then her life got ruined

[@mattssonderek4870]

Kutahti Me!

[@its.halcyonne]

SHE JUST WANTED TO LOVE SOMEONE

[@sootthecat2336]

Can we make a club?! 😂

[@faitho3o120]

I can feel her evil in this, holy shit.

[@sadiemcdonald8372]

i loved this video!!!

[@caffeinegremlin3237]

Mapleshade is personally my favorite Warriors character. At least half of my music playlist is Mapleshade maps(including this one).

[@peachyking321]

omg and i just finished reading Mapleshade's vengeance and Goosefeather's curse 😻😻

[@foxpandagames3598]

most of the cats that die are grey/silver to Mapleshade/starclan: RAcisT mUCH

[@subtleshenanigans5983]

Awesome! From my favourite SE no less :) Mapleshade's vengeance was amazing (though I liked Goosefeather's curse a little better) This captures her perfectly and is great in explaining the Mapleshade and Crookedstar arc.

[@doodledove3669]

MapleShade is m favorite character in the series, and this does her justice! It's so beautiful and Badass

[@aname4399]

mapleshade is the most capable villain in the entire series like imagine if she was alive??? the damage she could do??? she is wonderful i love her

[@toshsyizo824]

I feel so bad for mapleshade

[@dreamii8870]

I feel so bad for everyone Mapleshade killed lmao

[@milanes4queen975]

Dude, same

[@Just_stoptalking]

I just discovered your channel and I just absolutely adore your art style! I've got many favorite warrior cats artist but you are definitely on the top of my list

[@lilyingabrand4424]

Two people run noodlers

[@snoopypal1]

+Jack AJ your can be plural, i.e. when referring to two or more people. people got it. stop commenting about it.

[@lilyingabrand4424]

I only commented once, It was a harmless note. Seriously.

[@signeartz6950]

Mapleshade is my favourite villain. The taste of seeing revenge in fictional characters is beautiful

[@ArrowsSpecter]

I love this pmv, i'd often put it on loop while i play a roblox warriors rp, I JUST LOVE IT

[@anna_mac1507]

Man I love this.... Skews me have a replay button to break.

[@Natalia-bx2lw]

i cant stop feeling bad for mapleshade): she only did what she did because of her love for her kits

[@Khaoscntrl]

Okay yo I loved this before but since I've been out of the series for so long I didn't understand who some of the other cats were. After watching the Oakheart video I'm just like OHHHH, OHHH, AND THAT WAS, OHHHH! Like super realization made this 10 times better, like obviously everyone who knows the books better then me already knew but for me this is like a 'wtf' inception moment lol

[@dognuggets5230]

I have never been so hyped over a WC amv

[@papajoolia]

aaaa so much effort must have been put into this wow !! great job to the three of you!

[@rayetaye3822]

Tbh, I kinda prefer your design for Rainflower here rather than the one in wait for it, but with that being said I still like both of your designs! ^^

[@Noodlers]

we gave our team free reign with bg characters (aka not oak, crooked, blue), but i think both designs work

[@rayetaye3822]

Ah, that makes sense then. ^^

[@Smurfetka161]

That is so purrfect for MapleShade DID YOU KNOW HOW BRUTALY MAPLESHADE KILLED SPOTTEDLEAF I AM SO MAD AT HER AND I HATE HER SHE IS MY WORST ENEMY

[@Smurfetka161]

if i would see her i would shred her into pieces

[@remingtomi8212]

+Smurfetka161 oh no, she so horrible because she killed an ALREADY DEAD CAT. You know, she is terrible now because her kits were killed and she was blamed for it and may as well have been killed because her life was torn apart. Spottedleaf had a MUCH WORSE life, being a medicine cat loved by ALL.

[@baconaxolotl]

hollow hmmmm... ik holo! great vid love it

[@user-bn3jf5uu5n]

The improvement from this to the new mapleshade video is so incredible! Especially when this one was already so good

[@telekitnetic3517]

This is also a good song for Sol.

[@sphxx1727]

Scourge*

[@paiges.4201]

Yes

[@seasonalsprout]

iT IS OMG SOL IS MAH FAV VILLIAN *hugs sol*

[@cean_skies4351]

Honestly, I can relate to Mapleshade. I kinda feel bad for her

[@mixedkweh7684]

I don't know why but I love the frame where the kits are swarming at her paws.

[@melonpie33]

Mapleshade's tail is sooooo FLOOFY

[@slimybeast7646]

Even though this was made 2 years ago I have a Warriors Music Video Idea: No Promises, Graystripe and Silverstream :3

[@lunarsnake2467]

how did MAPLESHADE die I forget xD

[@Noodlers]

Appledusk's apprentice killed her

[@AutumnLynx]

+Noodlers how would a apprentice kill a full grown killer cat X'D

[@lursauu]

no one knows :O

[@starryheart8962]

+Noodlers bangs head against keyboard, an apprentice. Really my favorite character died liked that

[@Noodlers]

+Lokii to be fair I'm pretty sure it was after she fought appledusk? So she was already kind of weak the apprentice just made the wound that made her run off and die alone

[@skoogert6967]

This is song gives me so much chills! I love it, great job.

[@briannay5231]

WAIT WAIT WAIT SOMETHING IS WRONG... This doesn't have a million views yet

[@konamurphy]

“I awaken with the thunder”.... But what if there is no thunderstorm Mapleshade?

[@hollowdout1230]

We're all dead inside. HAHAHAHAHAHAH...HAHAHAH...Ha......ha..........someone end me

[@reddesttempest9108]

*Shtabs* there.

[@shadowflowers7182]

*stab*

[@caelinx08]

im not dead inside

[@alphasbite8826]

LOVE UR ART AND UE CREATIVITY!!!

[@squishypeach1014]

Am I the only one falling in love with Mapleshades tail?

[@aheyzabrosheno8768]

What is name song? I'm sorry, but i russian girl and I bad know English language. And.. I like it video, I like it music, and want know name it music. Sorry.

[@miseryfell6417]

The song is Hollow by Cloudeater

[@aheyzabrosheno8768]

+EqqTart Thank's

[@greysess5146]

Мм, русские.

[@sootthecat2336]

It's called 'пустотелый'

[@chickennuggets1990]

*HEAVY BREATHING* Hollow

[@cass7049]

She's trying to make Crookedstar understand how she felt, in a way she's trying to heal herself inside.

[@cass7049]

***** Thus why she is in the Dark forest. It's all about vengeance and making others see how she felt to watch their loved ones disappear,

[@isaac-gg6qq]

mapleshade was such a good villain and this just made her even more badass ah,

[@atlasmoreas5684]

This is low key one of my favorite pmv's you two have done

[@aspenfaye]

I just came accross your amazing channel. I'm so suprised you don't have more subscribers. Let me help you with that. *Subscribes*

[@lilyingabrand4424]

Two people run noodlers

[@aspenfaye]

Jack AJ Cool?

[@axxaryllis]

+Jack AJ we get it dude

[@nugeneho1387]

u guys should work with blixemi!!! you'd make a great team

[@ShadowedKing]

THIS IS SO INSANELY GOOD!!! THERES SO MANY PICTURES IN THIS ITS CRAZY i love your art/pmvs and i hope you make more

[@partydad1978]

the breathing in the song is just everything

[@blondetapperware8289]

hello! great video btw! would you mind telling me how long it took you to nake this video and what program you used? I'm very interested in make videos like these myself

[@Noodlers]

a little over a month and a half! and we used photoshop cc for the art & adobe premiere for the editing :)

[@blondetapperware8289]

+Noodlers thank you so much! :)

[@danlester2289]

Why did Mapleshade go to the dark forest because she was very reasonible for the deaths she caused and Crookedkit was bullied and abused.Mapleshade was like a mother to him because Rainshit had to fucking abuse him.

[@gore4332]

FYI best PMV I've ever seen for Warriors 11/10

[@alyssafernandes1595]

Uh no 1000000000000/10

[@baguette7073]

This deserves more likes, common ppl

[@reddaughter8314]

wait. 1:26 why isn't TigerClaw there? I remember him being there.

[@Noodlers]

+Crystal Heart at the gathering? This was when bluestar was still deputy, we didn't think it would be important to throw him in there- since the focus was on blue and oak

[@reddaughter8314]

no silverstream's death, isn't that silverstream's death?

[@Noodlers]

+Crystal Heart ah- I was on the wrong vid- let's say he was behind the branch. I wasn't the one to lay out the frame so it was probably just compositionally not looking right with tiger there :3

[@reddaughter8314]

ok :3

[@Noodlers]

+ıIıIİıİIıımusic it's in the title

[@axgxst715]

I love maple shade brave strong and cool it's not her fault she turned ugly (him in some peoples cases) One like for Mapleshade

[@fructosefather2162]

I also am loving the Dixie boy maple shade animation!

[@wintersnowwillow3834]

Hardly anyone does anything about Maple thank you so much for doing one about her. She has a really sad story but nobody ever does her. Good job. :)

[@gcollz_]

Damn I have forgotten how did mapleshade die against its bugging me!

[@karenwong4261]

DEMONDOG she was killed by an apprentice

[@savannahgallagher8463]

DEMONDOG An apprentice (I forgot who) split her belly, and she then bled to death.

[@gcollz_]

+SapphireCat Gaming oh yeah thx!

[@gcollz_]

+Opal The archer thx as well

[@vicgame7169]

DEMONDOG it was Appledusk's apprentice who killed her

[@ashlieparham6753]

Mapleshade is one of my favorite cats (besides Ivypool #Ivystar) and this most certainly gives her justice. You drew her perfectly.

[@mysticalmagicart8722]

I can’t get over how well made this is. Just... perfection.

[@ChloeIHill]

Omg I love the events that u showed and they r so good!! Crookedstar's Promise is my favorite Super Edition!!!

[@_world7970]

Hi, what apps u use to make videos?

[@Noodlers]

+Lerchik_ Man Adobe Photoshop, after effects, and premier

[@frankiewolf8786]

Why is it pink blood?

[@thegoatcarnival]

that's either the lighting or a scar

[@juliamurphy4418]

Because we used a color palette

[@youranimemangaaddict7343]

Good work man!

[@ugly-organist]

AHHHHHH Crookedstar's Promise was so freaking sad but it was a really good book ;-;

[@blehbluh9606]

wait...did croockedstar go to dark forest?

[@Noodlers]

+Aimi Mazaya no, but he trained there with mapleshade

[@blehbluh9606]

Noodlers oh, thanks for the information

[@Benrobles14]

Aimi Mazaya Crookedstar's promise, it's good!

[@cperrino2353]

Aimi Mazaya no he didn't.

[@bluestar8784]

Aimi Mazaya nope

[@Takami_Angel]

I just realized every time it says i'm hollow in my mind i'm like HOLOSEXUAL ugh my youtube life

[@user-pr7if9qy3d]

lol

[@jademcfarlanewright9366]

DAAAMN whoaaa! amazingjob on makin it look eerie and spooky o0o

[@PantheraOnca]

So many feels! This work is INSANELY GOOD! Keep it up!