HoloEN Justice Debut Song Reactions | 'DATTE BOKU STEP ON MEEE'

[@Schyph]

If you wish to support RC, she has a ko-fi page (link in description). There's some great perks - you can either: 1. upvote a song already on the recommended list to push up the priority 2. Recommend a new song to react to The next analysis song on the agenda is Fubuki's KINGWORLD (we slightly mentioned it in the video too, RC is cooking, may take a while because of the crazy time signature changes 😂).

[@blackfirehedgehog7725]

Oooh Kingworld? Nice. I like Fubuki's music but I wasn't expecting an analysis 'cause I wasn't seeing it recommended much. Looking forward to it!

[@axledestrl8172]

Nice, Kingworld has to be one of my favorite Fubuki songs.

[@YouAreSleepyToo]

ERB is the first holomember to get the permission to cover and release a beatles song, she just released blackbird, so her singing janus is possible

[@AzarelDaichi]

According to Calli, they recorded Start Again when ERB hadn't debuted yet, so she was only listed as "new talent". At the second verse there is a section where ERB and Rissa harmonize right before a part Calli was assigned. When Calli heard the two pop off she ended up recording her part over 40 times to get a take she could be satisfied putting beside those two powerhouses.

[@SherlockONI]

Ironically up until now calli dont think she Is a great singer but well she was able to put up with those 3 AND not only with rap

[@kookoo9235]

What's so weird about it? 40 takes on a small part is maybe 30minutes at best. 🤔

[@chipmunkstyle007]

The song at the end "Start Again" was only animated up to that point to make it like an anime OP for their ENReco project. That's why it was so short. The full version is on Calli's channel with just the music, no animation

[@mrmxypltk]

Fun Fact about the last song - there's a part where ERB and Nerissa are harmonizing, followed by a Solo bit by Calli - Calli was so determined to live up to their harmony and not bring the song down (as she feels she is in no way at the same level as ERB and Nerissa) that she did something like 45 takes of that line. What she may lack in natural singing talent she more than makes up for in sheer determination.

[@Blue_OnBlue417]

There is a full version of the song aswell with no MV.

[@herpingyoshi]

Some little fun facts about Raora: She only learned English like 3 years ago, since her native language is Italian, and she’s only been learning Japanese for probably nearing a year at this point. For her recent 2 covers she did all the illustrations for the MVs (I don’t know if she did for the debut one). When her eyes go blue that’s when she is using her “God Eyes” and that’s where her powers are from.

[@Deilwynna]

she did the art for her debut cover as well, only of her songs she didnt do the art for was the group song, above below, with the other justice members

[@herpingyoshi]

@ bet bet, her debut cover was from before I was into holo so I had no idea LMAO

[@ItMeDom]

Calli had ERB on her music show HoloMelo Radio 2 weeks ago, which is definitely worth a watch if you want to know more about her musical background. Calli is planning on covering Libera me from Hell from Gurren Lagann with her as well, and anyone who knows the song knows you need some SERIOUS vocal chops to cover the opera parts of that song. The only other person she's proposed this to is Ironmouse, who has a background in opera.

[@borotorob]

Oh god... I've been hoping for a cover of that song for years! Fingers crossed they can actually make it happen!

[@yeshevishman]

I would LOVE to see an ERBxIronmouse cover of ANYTHING, but Liberate Me From Hell would be AMAZING! (BTW, just a technical term: Ironmouse has a background in classical voice training (which includes opera), but saying she has a "background in opera" means she actually performed in fully staged operas, which is not the case as far as I'm aware. (Feel free to let me know if I'm wrong about that.)

[@butterkukki]

“I want her voice to step on me” I can’t lmao 😆 tbh understandable lol

[@buggart]

She said the same thing when she listened to Suisei's cover of King. Can't really blame her though since I too would like to be stepped by their voices.

[@Bobbias]

Above Below's lyrics were done by monii, not r2pc, they did the logo. Monii has worked with Kiara before on several songs, even releasing her own version of them and having been a guest on Kiara's stream. She speaks English, and likely wrote the lyrics in English, although I wouldn't be surprised if management had given her some Japanese lyrics as a starting point or requested some changes here and there that resulted in a few odd lines. She's also worried with the kpop group LOONA, &Team (a japanese boy band based in both japan and korea) and Raon, a korean singer who started off doing covers on youtube and has since debuted in japan and korea under UMG.

[@hanna_ar]

38:13 actually a spot-on Gigi impression!!! A genius gremlin 😂😂😂 (she has an infamous unarchived stream we're she sang September by earth wind & fire for 8 hours straight which very much impressed and traumatized her fans😂) As for Cece she will be having a Violin karaoke this coming Saturday as a part of her birth week celebration!! 🎉🎉 Very much looking forward to that. Btw there's a full version of Start Again where Nerissa and ERB'S parts are if you're curious (Their group is unofficially called "N.I.C.E", for Nerissa Irys Calli and Elizabeth)❤❤❤

[@mrmxypltk]

I remember. The 21st night of September. We were changing the minds of pretenders. Dancing the night away....... BAAA DEEE YAAAAA!

[@ashenblood]

​@@mrmxypltk crazy? I was crazy once.

[@redemption2]

I happen to know ERB's entire portfolio. However, rules of engagement state that unless the past life is acknowledged by the talent, we don't speak of it openly. So I'll go with generalizations. She has done voice acting in anime professionally. She also does voices in youtube animation projects, and has participated in major fandom productions over the years. She is potentially one of the biggest talents Hololive could have picked up. For more specifics, Ina was her first Oshi, but she has stated that Ollie is her Kami-Oshi.

[@Bobbias]

Yeah it didn't take long to recognize that voice, and I didn't even listen to much of her past life stuff. As soon as I heard the impressions I knew exactly who it was. I'm still kind of shocked that she's actually in Hololive.

[@redemption2]

@@Bobbias My exact moment of realization was when she introduced herself in the jazz club before singing Violet. I remembered that specific voice she used.

[@GMSTRrules]

She's been at it for a while! I'm happy that she found a stage that works for her.

[@5boxes]

"JUSTICE, JUST LIKE THAT!" (Justice when they commit warcrimes when ERB is out flirting with Nerissa.) I think this song was made as an antithesis to Rebellion. They definitely would be great if the lyrics aren't some kind of preset creation.

[@Pears_on_Fire]

Fujikura Uruka is another vtuber violinist, she sometimes does violin streams and I believe she provided some of the instrumentation for one of Cecilia's covers

[@Shrimp4Gura]

Cecilia's violin cover of Pippa The Ripper when?

[@emmanonn]

By the way, there's a high version of the Bunny Girl short cover that Liz did and there are also a few edits combining both low and high versions if you're curious about that There's also a full version released of Start Again where Liz has more parts too!

[@megamcee]

I dropped everything as soon as I saw this in my subpage. Can't wait for some nice analysis for these girls. And that intro clip is absolutely valid

[@Keithlynd_]

Liz is the Ollie of EN, she's simping everyone, is everywhere on everyone's chat, including reaction channel livestream like velo city.

[@Bobbias]

Not just them, G.O.T. Games, Koefficient, and even smaller channels too.

[@Keithlynd_]

@@Bobbias true, it's just I just watch velo's video and my single cell brain can only remember that far

[@Bobbias]

@@Keithlynd_ yeah I just wanted to add to the list.

[@culade]

Maybe soon we could also lump in her appearing in everyone's karaoke like she did with Maid Mint's redebut to everyone's pleasant surprise.

[@yeshevishman]

Her interactions with smaller channels is actually more of a networking strategy than "simping", IMHO. (This is NOT to say she doesn't respect the HELL out of them). This is based somewhat on "forbidden knowledge", but I followed her PL for years and she has always said that one of the most important things she learned as an online content creator is to raise up those inspired by your work and those you admire. She has always said her success online is because others did the same for her, so she is always looking to "pay it forward". This is VERY much what Ollie always did as well, btw, so she's STILL the Ollie of EN, but that's separate from "simping" which is what she does for the other girls in Hololive.

[@itsahullabaloo]

Really excited that you reviewed Justice's debut and their various releases. I absolutely love all of their voices and seeing another really strong vocalist join holoEN. Honestly id be interested in seeing you review the entire holoEN cover of Mind Craft as includes everyone and i think Bae did a really good job of showcasing all of the girl's voices.

[@Darkonlore]

Liz debut stream was in the middle of the night. Singing like that at 2-3a.m, hope her neighbours didn't mind. lol

[@sya2711]

considering her background i highly doubt she doesn't have a soundproof room , which she most likely also streams from.

[@sya2711]

so i just got to the part were rc references it, i didnt realise you were joking along with it xD

[@punpundit5590]

ERB, in one of her unarchived karaokes, sang "I know it's today" from Shrek the Musical. If you're unfamiliar, it's sung by a woman at three different stages of her life. Liz seamlessly changed the color and weight of her voice *during a sustained note* to give the impression of changing the age of her voice when switching between the different parts.

[@FantasiA2K]

38:13 Your analysis of Gigi's personality is absolutely spot on

[@luckyjc8702]

Lmao, the "(not Flow Glow)" killed me. Hopefully you'll check out flow glow too though eventually, someday, their debut was also really fun. But either way thanks for the upload.

[@Shanahra-ok1ne]

@ravenclaw reacts 01:02:36 That song is "Otonablue" from the japanese female group "Atarashii Gakko!". They are a really good, funny and fresh group of very talented singers with a very unique style. They got a really great version of this song on "The First Take". I think you would enjoy reacting to their songs as one can feel, see and hear how they have so much fun with every second they sing and dance. Also, Suzuka's voice is probably one you would like to step onto you aswell 😉

[@3ulax]

wanted to throw in 43:35 it was actually a mix of the beat of stellar stellar but she actually Sang Violet from ina!! (～￣▽￣)～.

[@Karanthaneos]

Came for this. Violet is such a beautiful song

[@CobaltKuma]

I like that you pointed out the similarities in how EN's green women stand out musically/thematically.

[@Kimcirac]

about group songs being for the big stage, you have an example with Advent group song in the free video hololive uploaded of their latest concert: breaking dimensions day 2. There you can see the song performed live.

[@Zolfried]

note that the art in Raora's song was her own illustration.

[@dcresistance]

On the model question, its a bit of both nowadays! Raden of ReGLOSS said that her model was already in progress when she was hired, and there were changes made once her artist was told about her personality and interests (rakugo and the arts) Also, Cecilia might do some rock songs in her upcoming violin karaoke this week! Also also, there's a full version of the EN Reco song on streaming services! This MV one is a short version

[@kimchi-p31w]

Cecilia is the one I watch the most. And she is really talented. She speaks German, English, French and a tiny bit of Norwegian and is learning Japanese. She plays Violin, Piano (and I think in her debut mentioned also Viola). She can also produce music (she did a few streams producing jingles for herself and her genmates). And she can rig (for example she rigged the Cecilia plushie model she used in her birthday stream) and she can program (she programmed the game she plays with her viewers during her debut). Btw she said she is not really a good singer (I quite like her voice) Just don’t let her drive a car… or any vehicle for that matter But I want to say… all the Justice girls are crazy talented and I really like alle of them.

[@danthanhhuynhpham685]

Im still impressed how she managed to not only drive a piano but also crash it moments later just for a skit

[@kimchi-p31w]

@danthanhhuynhpham685 yeah same. It's fascinating and terrifying 😂

[@avsbes98]

Didn't she also say that she also drew the plushie-CC? That and her singing... She's seriously downplaying her drawing and singing skills. Sure, she doesn't have the drawing experience of Raora or the singing experience of Elizabeth. But she has talent and incredible potential.

[@Flugmorph]

my prayers have been answered. ravenclaw is finally basking in the glory that is ELIZABETH ROSE BLOODFLAME hahaha. Haven't missed a single of her karaoke streams since she debuted. what a singer.

[@KevKrieger32]

I really like this concept you're doing. Schyph, the more knowledgeable one, shows ravenclaw about hololive and their music and both can review, analyse and rate the music. It reminds me a little bit of Nagzz' Vtuber discovering series, which has a similar concept, but with vtuber clips. Please more in the future! Maybe you could go through many hololive musicians, like Sora, Matsuri, AZKi, or even some underrated singers, like Flare, Mio and Watame. You could also do non-hololive singers, like Ironmouse, Maid Mint, or even Neuro-sama :D

[@Desinole83]

Cecilia quickly became one of my personal favorites in hololive musically, not only does she play the violin beautifully but her voice is so soft and warm. It's unbelievable that this woman has the audacity to say that she's a bad singer. sure she's not as technically extreme as people like towa nerissa suisei elizabeth etc., but her voice is truly unique among the hololive members and she should be proud of that.

[@Bobbias]

She's one of my favorites but not so much for her singing as for... Everything else. Although I love that she covered wasureji no koto no ha. It's such a beautiful song.

[@Mr_Hoppykwins]

She has the Green Woman buff

[@avsbes98]

Yeah, i think the main problem for her with singing is that she lacks confidence. I think in one of her Karaoke's it was also noticeable that she was significantly more confident when singing in French than in English and the French songs she sang thus sounded far less like a person who tries to hide in a choir or something like that.

[@dawnevergarden]

didnt expect to watch the whole vid! great vid as always!

[@tigrenchik]

I feel the best parts of Start Again sadly didn't get into MV :( Definitely reccomend to listen to the full song on Calli's channel, it is about twice as long.

[@am_frog]

The full version of Start Again has more ERB but she's still more in the background than I'd prefer. It's still nice.

[@Esca_Ch]

As a Eurobeat-inspired song, Above Below is a cut above from a lot of the HoloEN group songs for me. Maybe it's not just your cup of tea. The lyrics are fine too, and if you paid attention more, they're essentially threatening Advent. Rebellion talks about escaping and being freed into the open blue sky, and then Above Below talks about "what goes above, goes below". Advent actually released a song as an aswer to this, which is Siren (which I didnt really like at all). You should definitely watch some of Liz's karaoke songs. I recommend the Skyfall one. (seriously, her karaoke streams are more or less concerts to me 😅)

[@RyanXander06]

1:17:27 Additional Note: There is a full song of START AGAIN on KZbin (Callie's channel iirc) and on Spotify (again, i think it was Calli's page)

[@rinoakirova1548]

1:18:18 Speaking of concerts and acapella. During hololive 4th Fes, Suisei took the holo*27 stage with an acapella song called Planetarium. Just imagine all the girls going full steam with pop/rock songs and hype dance choreography, then Suisei steps in with nothing but her mic and a soft lullaby. If you hadn't heard Planetarium I really recommend it.

[@darkflames9039]

I highly recommend you her cover in Minto's birthday, you'll love it.

[@kweassa6204]

ERB is an interesting addition to the team, because we've seen a lot of great singers in hololive -- but no one with the chops for stage performance/live jam style singing with techniques with such ad libs and scat, improvisations. So I don't know any info about her PL but it does seem like a very likely guess that she had at least some stretch of career as stage singer. Because, like mentioned in the vid, you can't sing like that without actually having sung in front of a live audience, and have done it often enough to feel confident to add in your own improvs and ad libs to go with the flow instead of "stick to the notes." Something tells me she's going to be the gem of every Holofes or other Live3D concerts that involve Justice.

[@HowardAltEisen]

"having great socials skills would make Raora stand out in hololive" You can't just say these things! Even if they're definitely true! 😂😂

[@Bobbias]

I think someone pointed this out on the last one of these videos but if not deco 27 is pronounced deco nina, because 2 = ni and 7 = nana.

[@MagiaBased]

I listen to Above Below everytime I drive and that shit goes hard af but if you like softer songs it's understandable that you don't like it.

[@Zolfried]

In a banter between Liz and Polka, she tested her range against some app and said that her vocal range is from E3 to F6... which didnt tell me much untill i searched for ppl showcasing that and it was amazing.

[@yeshevishman]

I mean, it's pretty standard for a trained Soprano voice (although it DOES take a lot of work, so I'm not knocking it). Her most impressive vocal quality is her dynamic control at all ends of the spectrum. Basic breakdown: there are many techniques to help stretch your vocal range on higher or lower notes, but some singers tend to stick to the easy ones unless they've practiced that particular phrase relentlessly. The mark of someone who has put in SO much singing work is someone who can be extremely dynamic on the higher or lower notes of their range. Liz constantly shows a high end voice control which shows she has an almost flawless understanding of vocal mechanics that I don't think we have EVER seen before in Hololive! She'll switch from straight voice to vibrato in the blink of an eye, use power mixing in a way that shows classical singing proficiency, and perform runs that are like vocal acrobatics! While there are plenty of Sopranos with a MUCH more impressive range, there are few as controlled as she is at wielding their voices like a fine-tuned weapon. (Thank you for coming to my TED talk.)

[@HoscoFelix]

Gigi is an interesting case of the person behind the screen being much deeper than the gremlin persona. Somehow through sheer charisma she's becoming all the EN girls' husband lmao

[@borotorob]

She's like a social chameleon, blending in perfectly with anyone in a collab. Her improv skills are a joy to watch!

[@penopocalypse]

Just to let you know you know, Start Again has a full version which has another verse. The video for the even was just like anime opening.

[@penopocalypse]

Oh and if you wanna know someone that "sounds" like Liz I would checkout EileMonty

[@caretakerITA]

Just to add the credit needed: Cecilia violin part on her debut was on a base done by another violinist vtuber, Uruka Fujikura of Phase Connect. Plus, Cecilia can play piano too (she has done the piano part in the more "dark" part of her debut).

[@blackfirehedgehog7725]

Couple random thoughts... It's worth noting that Raora drew the art for her cover. Elizabeth's karaokes are amazing, she really has fun with the songs and using her voice in different ways. She's said something about it being a lot more fun if you change things up - it's always a unique experience.

[@LethalShadow]

Thank you for the upload.

[@Tengokujin]

There's a joke that Gigi's debut stream was so low budget because it went all into the music video lol The Liz clip with Bunny Girl also has a version where she sings the high part :p Marine's cover of Atarashii Gakkou no Leader's Otona Blue is also nice

[@SherlockONI]

The mv of start again Is the opening versión of the song there Is a full versión in callis chance AND well in Spotify XD

[@mrmxypltk]

For Council/Now promise, I'd argue the current gremlin is probably Mumei, yeah, but there have been some points where Bae was a bit gremlin-ish. But really, the one who was always teasing everyone else, and being a cinnamon roll while doing it, was Sana, who unfortunately retired.

[@borotorob]

Speaking of Sanana, sometimes I get hints of her voice from Raora. She's got a similar "thick" voice (best way I can think to describe it) with a bit of a nasally sound. Very warm and playful.

[@mrmxypltk]

@borotorob yeah. She also called Kronii kronini in a collab

[@cyb0nics]

Gigi's second cover is equally as crazy

[@protato4034]

Just from observation, i think the violin tracking maybe connected to her head orientation. I could be wrong but it makes me exited for her 3d! (As im sure many are)

[@mysteryinc6720]

Your thoughts and the way you explain things is cool and fun to listen to! Thank you for taking time sharing this video. The gremlin creature Gigi's song seriously did break people in the first few seconds XD, but out of all the cover songs of this group, she felt the most unique. ERB, or Liz, is a powerhouse. Her history online is amazing with the songs and voices she did literally over a decade ago still being talked about today. Hololive bringing in Liz is a genius move. Raora has been called the Towa singer of English, and that fits but also doesn't. Raora is a fun person to listen to. Her laughs are contagious XD CC is a mixed bag, fun to root for. Not many Hololive members are known for sticking to an instrument as much as CC. She has a sense of humor that is fun to listen to.

[@Bobbias]

I absolutely love how goddamn weird Hitomania is.

[@Lortius]

If you want your Holo Orchestra, and expand it to the Stars too, Regis Altare plays a mean Cello

[@Diabolicalism]

oooo been waitin for this one

[@genwilbolandres980]

Sorry guys, I closed the vid after the first comment 😅

[@ravenclawreacts]

fair

[@genwilbolandres980]

@@ravenclawreacts i kinda lied there, great video

[@ravenclawreacts]

@@genwilbolandres980 I know 🤣 but still.. FAIR. I'm obsessed. ERB, my god

[@hoangtau98]

@@ravenclawreacts En Reco do have a full version, pleaseeee check it out.

[@Luthfihidayat-y6t]

@@ravenclawreacts Why don't you ever react to ado song?🤧

[@bishopwerst]

Above below is one of my favorite hololive songs. The beat is so hype and it gets me a good pump in the gym. I think the lyrics are sick. I’m not the type of person that listens to the song for the lyrics. So I guess that’s why I love this song. Someone once stated it best, lyrics in music is just more sounds that complement the song. Word in music sounds like beeps and bops so it’s not my main focus.

[@Koreanpally]

Just a heads up there is a full version of start again on cali's channel

[@raymond_cartagena]

I'm happy to hear you talk about KINGWORLD during the Hitomania section. I'm hoping that the fact that you've heard that song means we can see an analysis/review/breakdown thingy in the future. As far as ERB's past, it's generally considered taboo to discuss a vtuber's past life unless they say it's okay to do so. So of course, I won't be doing so here... \*cough* kzbin.info/www/bejne/eWXHiYWBocqDi6s \*cough* Whoopsie, how'd that link get there? Don't click that.

[@yeshevishman]

I mean, it's generally a bit different with Hololive since it's NOT up to the talents themselves to choose, but it's Cover's policy that they themselves cannot outright say it acknowledge any PL or alts. However, she's an OG online and anyone who knew her before would recognize her voice. It's like Cali. It's no secret who she actually is and she has put so many hints out there that it's impossible to believe she doesn't want people to know.

[@danielbarte9927]

You should react to the full version of the Start Again cause there are more acapella parts in the continuation of the song that you might like

[@haozheheng]

So this is just my own guess but I think a lot of people are wrong on cecillia's violin tracking. It is, I think, tracked on to the y position(up-down) of the model to move the hand. Evidently, if you try to match the timing of her bobbing up and down, the stick(?) will move accordingly or in fancier words, linearly. Also if they really needed to track the hand movement, they would need a high framerate camera to reduce motion blur, hence easier tracking. Or if you are good enough, code a frequency matching system to then track onto whichever position the violin is supposed to be.

[@ravenclawreacts]

interesting, even if it's beyond me. thank you!

[@yeshevishman]

Yeah. Well, we KNOW her 3D tracking is gonna be fire! We've already seen Altair's cello skills in 3D, so I cannot WAIT to see how CC's violin skills translate there.

[@LukasJampen]

Raora is a literal pink panther also my favourite nickname for her is ponthera because she is a bit of an airhead.

[@TheOwlet22]

The first western song that she covered was Blackbird by the Beatles, and I would argue its her best official cover due to how it showcases her precision, control and artistic direction for how she uses her voice like an instrument. A lot of people talk about Liz's range and power, but for me, truthly, what makes her stand apart are those three qualities. We have powerful singers in Moona and Kanata, singers with long ranges such as Risu and Polka, and beautiful and crystalline vocals in many of the multiple Divas. But for me personally, I don't think we've seen a singer as well knowledgeable of their own voice quite as well as Liz (except Towa probably?) And its not much of a pure talent thing from what I can gather, but its mainly through years and decades of training, natural vocal quality probably helped, but overall, you don't get a singer like this based on natural born singing. I haven't looked at her PL but from convos alone, she talks about being trained since she was a young girl and being surrounded by music and art all her life. She’s learned instruments and have taken vocal lessons for specific genres of music such as opera, jazz, rock, metal, etc.

[@benpurcell4935]

I mean there are, in my opinion, those that are equal in those categories namely Sora and Nerissa come to mind. I mean there’s also Watame.

[@TheOwlet22]

​@benpurcell4935 okay I can agree for Sora, tho for Watame and Nerissa, for me they stand out to me for different reasons compared to Liz and the other members of holo. Honestly I can make a whole essay on them as well since I do love their voices as equally, but since we're in a video involving Liz and not them, I decided not to elaborate as much. I will say tho in terms of what unique stuff they offer vocally, its still impressive, just in a different area altogether.

[@benpurcell4935]

@@TheOwlet22 Watame is the one who pioneered the consistent karaoke as she did them for a long time. It felt wrong to not mention some of the talents that came before that are arguably just as talented as Liz. Nerissa and Watame for me have the know how in using their voices. Liz is definitely the singer for her generation for sure but it feels disingenuous to say that almost no other talent is similar to her or she doesn’t have contemporaries in the company like Suisei or Sora.

[@TheOwlet22]

​@benpurcell4935 you're missing my point tho? I never said Liz is the most talented or the best out of all of them, just that she offers something new, just like Nerissa, Watame and the others have offered something new to holo as well. Bro I never even mentioned karaokes in my comments 😂😭 My comment here was never to diminish, thats why I deliberately avoided the term best or talented, because I think it's unfair to just say that when they have very unique backgrounds and training, and that is reflected by what kind of music they sing or produced. My oshi is Nerissa of all the talents so of course I consider her one of the best. Don't put things on my mouth that I never said. Do I really have to spill all my thoughts on other talents just to share my thoughts of another? Lmao this is just my opinion, I'm just a nobody thats into musicals and the performing arts, I don't need to put a thesis on my thoughts on the internet and you're free to take it or leave it.

[@benpurcell4935]

@@TheOwlet22 I was just giving an interpretation of what you were saying. I was just pointing out that the way you worded it could be taken a certain way. I was basically just playing devils advocate here because of the vagueness of your statements. ERB is an incredibly talented person don’t get me wrong but she’s surrounded by talented people. ERB reminds me of Polka with her voice acting skills but her singing rivals Suisei and others. I got into Hololive because of the music. I have seen Towa and Noel grow as singers. I have watched Myth grow in confidence and develop into such a tight knit group. I have watched a few talents get terminated or graduate. I have watched Hololive as a company go through trials and tribulations that helped it develop into a company the fans can be proud of.

[@ムャlechat]

38:45 well almost like with mumei. its not like they are saying something off. after close consideration you realise that what is off is your understanding, your knowledge, your ethical values, your life choices, your taste in art, your favourite clothes, etc i think gigi is among top intelligent and sharp members of holoen. which isnt that hard tbf.

[@kidyeilkurosaki]

"I want her voice to step on me" -ravenclawv2024 Very understandable though. Mint's Karaoke of Die with a smile with Liz still makes me kneel.

[@yeshevishman]

With the song Gigi is doing, I've seen some analysis/breakdowns of it that basically call it "freedorm Jazz disguised as EDM". The melody is very structured and stays within the boundaries of a basic pentatonic scale, but the chord structure is all classic freeform Jazz structures - relying on weird transition chords, to get you to restructured 7ths and 9ths bringing you to your "home" key. It's the production on the more electronic elements - what producers often call "ear candy" - that give it it's more "microtonal" feel.

[@ravenclawreacts]

Fascinating, I’ll have to look deeper into this, ty!

[@rubyyy911]

Man, i wish Liz someday cover Hana ni Natte (Be A Flower). It must be great to hear

[@ScottomanEmpire]

Always love seeing your reactions to the Holo girls. ERB is really something else. I'd recommend checking out clips of ERB singing "Die with a Smile" with Maid Mint (indie vtuber) for a karaoke stream.

[@Gerrymon]

Talk bout ERB she recently records a song for duet with Maid Mint karaoke of Bruno Mars & Lady Gaga - Die With a Smile And... lets just say after hearing it I was dead with a smile

[@deviant324]

The Gigi song is insane, was that hardbase in there? lol

[@KrazyTrumpeter05]

Yep, knew you were gonna love ERB

[@mafukas1432]

For the last song you guys just did the teaser there is the full version it just don t have the mv

[@isimpsfornerissaravencroft]

YOU SHOULD REACT TO THE FULL VERSION OF START AGAIN

[@Touma_S]

I think there are 4 of them cause advent was intended to be 4 members but got 5 with fuwamoco

[@ddmaster08]

ERB says that everyone is her oshi, but her kamioshi is actually Kureiji Ollie from holoID

[@SpdrdDno]

Nerissa's Lilium cover would've been great to listen to if you're looking for a Nerissa song with harmonies and acapella. Sadly her upload was taken down but someone reuploaded on KZbin so it won't be lost.

[@Keithrone]

Liz is the missing keys for Holo EN in terms of sounds for me, and fill the powerfull part. There's Risu & Moona in Holo ID, and bunch of them in Holo JP. I hope Liz gonna have good original songs because she is have the talent & trained, well sounds like very experienced singer.

[@natethegreat8888]

during one of Liz's karaoke's she had a duet with herself imitating one of her gen mates.

[@ZyphisV]

54:10 other way, iRYS is more pop, Nerissa is classically trained.

[@gergo32]

Have you watched Bocchi the Rock? I can't recommend it enough!😊 Would be fun to watch your reaction, just like with K-On.

[@KatoGrinsihara]

As far as I know, Hololive gives the model in orders after the talents are set, and the talents have a certain amount of influence on the model. That's why it takes about half a year from the time of recruitment to the first appearance of the talent. the only exceptions are Miko and Suisei who start as independent vtubers and AZKi when she was still in InoNaka Music

[@ZyphisV]

Just don't ask Raora for a jetpack

[@theuserofthissite]

If you're not already familiar with Atarashii Gakko, the group that Liz covered here, they could make for a great reaction/analysis video of their own. I think they're most known for their dancing, but their music is very interesting too.

[@ItsDeefer]

If you ever only listen to 1 thing Elizabeth has done please listen to her sing Unchained Melody. Its absolutely beautiful

[@avsbes98]

I'm pretty sure Raora's first name comes from "Roar", but name-ified i guess. And her last name... well, she's literally a Pink Panther.

[@avsbes98]

Cecilia actually will have a Violin Karaoke Stream (with guests) this Saturday 10 pm CET as part of her birtday week.

[@avsbes98]

Also, at this point i'm pretty sure that during her Debut Cecilia didn't just play the Violin. I'm pretty sure that at the point during the Nier Automata song where she wasn't actively playing the Violin, she was accompanying the song on the piano.

[@avsbes98]

19:47 Afaik that was partially the case with the Myth debuts and possibly those before Myth, with Myth only having a limited say in their models (at least that's what i recall Kiara saying, that her model was like 80% done when she joined and mostly things like hair colour, height and some facial feaures were still adjusted a bit?) but i think after that they transitioned to talent first, model second?

[@avsbes98]

28:29 I'd actually argue that Mumei shoots right past being a Gremlin and is directly an outright Menace. A role i'd actually also assign Cecilia and possibly Fuwawa.

[@yeshevishman]

I'm pretty sure the 'a' is to make it sound Italian...

[@Railgun_Enjoyer]

If you wanna listen to ERB singing something completely off her ballpark, watch her karaoke cover of Feed Good Inc.

[@sulkgred8856]

38:08 she nailed gigi there

[@gilgamesh34]

Yes. Raora is italian.

[@moffant4916]

She may need to see ERB doing different voices in her older stuff.

[@kittyangymumeiworshipper7556]

Oh she discovered Elizabeth. We are cooked

[@corrinflakes9659]

IIRC Liz’s oshi was actually Bettel (Holostars EN).

[@nootnoot2299]

Gigi caught my eye a lot

[@ちっか-j5m]

42:33 49:19 55:10 これを見るためにサムネにつられて来ました！ナイスリアクション！

[@ZeroShrimpy]

yeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[@HasPotatoAim]

The song Otanablue that ERB sang is from a Japanese band called ATARASHII GAKKO! I highly recommend checking out some of their stuff, the songs are all great and they plan their own choreo that is extremely unique. They preformed a version of it on The First Take channel that you saw Suisei do Stellar Stellar on before. Also either the video version or the Jimmy Kimmel performance of Tokyo Rising (both have English CC if you won't the lyrics). I see most of your channel is dedicated to vtuber songs and anime, so it might not fit the theme of your channel but the next time you're looking for something different to listen to.

[@Kradss]

28:32 who's Bijou?? I only know Biboo 😂

[@JL_Loki]

Listen to Mint and Liz's Die with a smile cover! It's so good!

[@sya2711]

talking about big group songs, did RC react to hoshimatic project ?