Homemade CUSTARD RECIPE - Super Easy To Make!

This classic custard recipe is the perfect dessert to enjoy year-round. It's silky smooth, perfectly sweet, and much easier to make than you think. Serve it up warm, drizzled over cake or a fruit crisp, or chill it and top with berries. It's up to you!
Custard has a special place in my home. My dad (as a New Zealander) always preferred it warm and drizzled over some sort of cake. While my mom (an American) preferred it chilled and more pudding-like. And that's not surprising, because based on my travels I'd say that many people in the US think of custard as a pudding, while many people in the UK enjoy it served as an accompaniment to another dessert. I'll gladly enjoy custard either way!
🖨 Printable Custard Recipe: downshiftology.com/recipes/cu...
Sign up for weekly emails (never miss a recipe!): mailchi.mp/downshiftology/you...
Join the private Facebook group of fellow Downshifters around the world: / downshiftologycommunity
► ORDER MY COOKBOOK!!!
Get 100+ make-ahead and quick-assembly recipes in my NEW Healthy Meal Prep cookbook: downshiftology.com/cookbook/
► ALWAYS IN MY KITCHEN:
Counter Stools: bit.ly/2tUNvZG
Vitamix Blender: amzn.to/2NjFp75
Spiralizer: amzn.to/2N37WRy
Tea Kettle: amzn.to/2uuNSMp
Utensil Holder: bit.ly/2tVfGaH
Flour Jars: amzn.to/30UZESn
Salt Cellar: amzn.to/2UUyK9r
Knife Set: bit.ly/2tUGzMa
White Chef's Knife: amzn.to/3rwocy9
Cutting Board: amzn.to/2Vskgv9
Magnetic Measuring Spoons: amzn.to/2YIeKYT
Magnetic Measuring Cups: amzn.to/3hAJu6A
Food Scraper: amzn.to/3B3ki3w
For everything else I use in my videos, check out the SHOP page on my website: downshiftology.com/shop/
► TIMESTAMPS:
00:00 Intro
00:25 Separate the egg yolks and whites.
01:11 Heat the cream and milk on the stove.
01:32 Temper the eggs with the cream.
02:11 Simmer the custard until it thickens slightly.
02:56 Serve the custard warm over cake or other desserts.
03:39 Chill the custard to firm it up and serve with berries.
04:38 Taste test.
06:04 How to store leftovers.
► WHAT I'M WEARING
Top (similar): bit.ly/3MeHaTP
Jeans: bit.ly/3O6ycbg
Linen Apron: bit.ly/3KEmEvL
The music I use: bit.ly/2Ms5nF2 - Great music for KZbinrs!
Disclaimer: product links may include affiliate links.
#custard #dessert #custardrecipe

[@Downshiftology]

So which do you prefer.... warm or chilled?? xo - Lisa

[@johnjakeup13]

Chilled

[@rlroblox6583]

Chilled definitely

[@patriciazoerner]

Warm!

[@bessredzz]

Both!

[@nicolenarr3886]

Both!😅

[@kitchenmom]

I love all the versions. Warm, cold or frozen. Knowing how to make a custard opens up so many new recipes and options for dessert. I hope people try it, and with your version they should have no problems. It's such a basic recipe with so many flavor combinations that everybody should find a version they will love.

[@Downshiftology]

Agreed! It really is such a versatile dessert and knowing how to make a simple custard is always good to know 😉

[@Karen-lj6jf]

I LOVE warm custard on gingerbread! Warm is also good on warmed up banana nut bread. But mostly, I like it cold the next day -just on its own as a pudding with a little sprinkle of nutmeg on top. YUM!

[@Downshiftology]

Oh yes! Custard drizzled on banana bread is super delicious.

[@mimiscountrycooking1607]

Yum❤

[@user-dianejcml]

Those sound so good!

[@marybeckham4495]

My Mother born in turn of century 1900's always made custard for Christmas. Using her Mother's recipe. ❤

[@sgayles11]

Hi Lisa! I just came across your channel a few days ago! I’m a Registered Dietitian and I think it’s a blessing that you are able to manage your Celiac disease by changing your diet to Whole Foods/gluten-free. The recipes and your channel are beautifully done. All the best! 🥳🎈🎈🎈☀️

[@YaraPNdeSa]

These look wonderful! And the fact that you use healthy ingredients is even better.

[@erikamolano3359]

Just like you I don’t discriminate, warm or chilled both ways incredible. Thank you for this recipe ❤

[@Downshiftology]

Both ways are so delicious! Hope you enjoy 😉

[@JenFlutterby]

This looks so delish Lisa! I will be attempting this soon for my family. I can’t tell you how much I appreciate the amazing recipes you share. Would love more low/very minimal natural sugar dessert recipes! ❤

[@Downshiftology]

Aw, thanks so much for your feedback! Hope you and your family enjoy this custard 😉

[@Lunaocean22]

This Custard looks delectable! Such a great idea, I've never made custard before. I got excited when you mentioned the apple crisp recipe! Looking forward to it!

[@kathleenmillet4182]

I do like it hot,and cold for company. Thanks.😊

[@jtsmith4800]

I love it either way. Mom use to make it warm for us when we were sick. Soooooo good.

[@reginalechleitner6685]

Frozen!! In a cone!! Yummy. Chilled for sure!

[@TheKathybarth]

Thank you!!! Excellent recipe.

[@dawnkritsiotis7613]

Love them both. Thanks for the amazing recipe.

[@MarshaCaughill]

Thanks again for sharing ❤❤❤

[@emmanuelavarvaressou8161]

Mouth-watering and also healthy!!! ❤️❤️ Perfect!😊

[@traceybryan3024]

Chilled for sure...love it with fruit.

[@syl1382]

I’ve only had chilled and I LOVE it! Huge custard fan. Crème brûlée is my favorite dessert too. 😋 I’ll need to try the warm version bc it looks good too.

[@Downshiftology]

Yes, definitely give it a try and let me know what you think!

[@PawPawMountain]

Amazing job! They both look great!

[@_healthycleanrecipes_]

Great recipe! I love the cold one. It’s so delicious. I grew up eating this tasty dessert. Thank you for sharing!!!🤗

[@diananovelo5657]

Delicious and easy ! Thank you ! ❤❤🌷🎉❤

[@anitas5817]

My favorite is baked egg custard. But this stirred custard looks delicious too!! Love lots of fresh grated nutmeg on it.

[@shangrilahomestead9930]

Looks delicious. My mom has been wanting custard and now I have an exciting new recipe! Thank you.😊

[@Downshiftology]

What perfect timing! Hope you both enjoy this recipe 😊

[@helenguingab2499]

I love all the version. Thanks for showing this Liza. I didn’t know it’s this simple 😊love love it❤

[@Downshiftology]

Yes, so simple and easy! Enjoy 😉

[@CS-zw5im]

This looks soooooooo delish!!!!❤

[@vylia]

It looks delicious. I must try this recipe! Thanks for sharing it, Lisa!

[@Downshiftology]

Can't wait for you to try this custard!

[@user-zb8iz4oj3h]

i love pena cotta and custord and your kitchen lisa , thank you

[@Downshiftology]

Hope you enjoy this recipe!

[@robinknauth1586]

I like both. Of course I never had homemade custard before. I have had warm vanilla pudding poured over pound cake, my dad introduced to me growing up. His grandmother served it to him as a child. Grannie was from England. My mom loves chocolate but then most people do. I can't wait to make this myself. Thank you. I'm enjoying your book so much. 🍧🥧

[@Downshiftology]

Excited for you to make this custard then! Gotta love nostalgic recipes.

[@Cookathome.Christina]

It’s delicious. Simple and easy. ❤

[@mimiscountrycooking1607]

One of my favorite desserts ❤

[@adadavis6908]

That looks delicious. I have always loved vanilla custard and haven't had it in quite a while because boxed can't possibly be the same. I'm definitely trying this. Thank you! I ❤ your channel!!

[@Downshiftology]

Hope you enjoy this recipe!

[@McCulleyJr]

Looks yummy and easy to make, thanks!

[@Downshiftology]

It really is such an easy dessert! Hope you enjoy 😊

[@mirzasanchez7635]

Both please!! Thank you !

[@daniellejones2027]

I love both! ❤

[@euniemin1334]

I made the flourless chocolate cake before and it was heavenly 😋 This looks amazing.. can't wait to try it chilled. Thanks Lisa!!

[@Downshiftology]

Glad you love the flourless chocolate cake! Hope you enjoy this custard next 😊

[@theresataylor1565]

I actually love the skin of custard or cooked pudding. It's much easier to snag a "cook's share" by peeling off the skin than trying to scrape it off the cling film.

[@barbaraburrough1492]

My mom uses this in banana pudding. So good!!

[@homemadefood99]

Awesome job! Your recipes are always innovative, unique and awesome 👌 Very interesting to watch the entire process. Directions are simple and easy to follow. Perfect techniques are used to execute the process superbly .Incredible job done. 👍🙂Thanks Chef for marvellous job🙂🙂🙂 God bless you enormously forever! 🙂

[@basm620inbelair9]

Just lovely ❤ As for warm or chilled… 🤔 Hmm… Warm. No wait! Chilled. NO, WARM! Ok, both!!

[@gloschmitz7468]

Made this. Turned out great. Reminded me of my mom's recipe

[@sakurahannah546]

Wow😮it's look so delicious dessert. Thank you for sharing🙏

[@Downshiftology]

Most welcome! Hope you enjoy 😊

[@cavenavasagam6461]

Oh! My my!! I like the rolly polly pudding and the black berry pie. 😂 I like custard warm or cold. I love Crème Brulé

[@kathyhelmold7358]

Looks delicious ❣️

[@rainy1216]

Custard is one of my favorite things in the world!! I love mine chilled. Your flourless chocolate cake is now a staple on our Jewish holidays - either when I'm cooking a feast, and need a delicious/addictive, easy dessert or during the holiday where we don't eat leavened foods (Passover) And I'm so excited for the apple crumble! I think I asked you to make one in the future!!! I cannot wait!!

[@Downshiftology]

I'm so glad you love the flourless chocolate cake! ❤️ And can't wait for you to make the apple crumble next. But first, this custard!

[@beckiingawanup8130]

Shabbat Shalom!

[@patschilling3166]

Love your cookbook and will tey the cake with this!!! ❤ thank you

[@Downshiftology]

Can't wait for you to make this! 😊

[@SJ47668]

I’m with you. Either way. Hot custard drizzled over a fruity pudding or chilled in a trifle. Both delicious.

[@lilyg4925]

Delicious 😋 as it is everything you make❤

[@solangecardona7421]

I love both warm and cold! This looks delicious Lisa, but now we really need the apple crisp recioe!! 😆

[@Downshiftology]

Yes!! stay tuned for the apple crisp recipe 😊

[@ceilihmcgrady4125]

I prefer it chilled but honestly love them both 😋 and will definitely be making this soon! thank you!!

[@Downshiftology]

Can't wait for you to make this custard dessert!

[@krekruska]

My favorite childhood dessert was dukat cakes/buns with warm custard. I still make it nowadays for my family here in US. Recipe is from Slovakia.

[@Downshiftology]

It really is such a nostalgic recipe 😉

[@user-cd7fs2hh2u]

Love both. Love custard with port wine jelly….warm custard with boiled fruit cake

[@mimiscountrycooking1607]

Sounds delicious!❤

[@esraabrolosii8067]

Love ur recipes!

[@Downshiftology]

Thank you so much 😊

[@judybesse4058]

Looks easy will give it a shot....oh and looks delicious!!!!😀

[@Downshiftology]

Can't wait for you to try this!

[@luvmyferretz]

This would be a great donut filling ❤

[@usmanghumman2483]

Amazing recipe video

[@Downshiftology]

Thanks so much!

[@floricasferdian4384]

Thank you. 🌺

[@Downshiftology]

Enjoy this delicious vanilla custard!

[@bessredzz]

Would you believe that this morning I made some drinking custard which is currently in the refrigerator chilling, with a vanilla bean and a half of a teaspoon of almond extract! I thought about making this thick chilled version but wasn't sure of the proper measurements... Now to see this notification! 😅 I will be trying this one though! Thanks! ❤

[@Downshiftology]

What a coincidence! Now you can try the chilled version now without fail 😉

[@Susan-nn1ib]

@bessredzz Recipe link?? I’ve been trying to replicate my grandmothers Boiled Custard for years. This vanilla custard recipe seems very close! ❤

[@immanoctopus]

Yay! This will be perfect to put inside mini pavlovas or Pavlova Cakes 👐

[@helengreen6724]

Both, warm and chilled. Lisa, I like creme Brule as well.

[@Anita-wh4vr]

Mmm 😋👍🏼 In Austria 🇦🇹 they serve it warm over a room temperature apple strudel with some vanilla ice cream 😊😉.

[@Downshiftology]

Sounds delicious! Thanks for sharing.

[@cydkriletich6538]

I love vanilla custard. Prefer it warm, but will eat it anyway. Thanks for this recipe. I’m subscribing and checking out your website. I like the way you present.

[@Downshiftology]

Thanks so much for your feedback and welcome to the Downshiftology community!

[@sharonroth626]

Could you make a custard with coconut cream? I love your recipes and make MANY! Love your cook book❤

[@chrystallopetridou8034]

Μπράβο Λίζα!! 😊

[@ThuvarakaMahenthiran404]

I will try the vanilla custard.

[@Downshiftology]

Hope you love this new dessert!

[@cindypye578]

We’re beginning our journey cutting out refined sugar, flour, and some grains. My husband has a sweet tooth so it’s harder for him. I will be making this recipe soon, and trying your flourless chocolate cake soon, too. Thank you!

[@Downshiftology]

Hope you enjoy both desserts! 😉

[@lilacjay]

Yes, being British definitely warm every time. Although I wouldnt say no, to the cold, I mean, who is going to turn down desert? He he.

[@lydiavalletta6501]

Thanks will try and will let you know the outcome.

[@Downshiftology]

Do report back! 😉

[@godsgurl2231]

I like that you don’t need to bake this in the oven with a water bath! Most creme brûlée recipes call for that. Will try making this today🥰

[@Downshiftology]

Hope you love this custard recipe!

[@matthewbrummer8691]

DOUBLE BOILER!!!!!!!

[@annemorison4052]

Love them both! 🇨🇦 warm over Christmas plum pudding, chilled with berries, as creme brulle ❤❤❤

[@Downshiftology]

So many ways to enjoy this!

[@mimiscountrycooking1607]

Sounds wonderful!❤

[@fernandom9220]

Oh, that's easy... YES (both) 😊

[@lauriemclaughlin6589]

Thank you for a delicious gluten free recipe!❤

[@Downshiftology]

Of course! Hope you enjoy 😊

[@MeeganMakes]

To be honest, I haven’t ever eaten warm custard. But you have definitely sold me on it. I just had crème brûlée for dessert last night. I am excited to make your custard recipe!

[@Downshiftology]

Definitely give it a try and let me know how you like it! 😊

[@mjrh45]

Definitely would have to be the chilled custard.

[@Downshiftology]

I personally like it chilled as well, but both ways are delicious!

[@TheKickshaws]

I think I’ve only had custard a few times in my life, and it was always chilled (I’m American). But when I took a trip to the UK, I fell in love with having chocolate cake served with cream drizzled over it, so I definitely want to try the warm version!

[@Downshiftology]

You'll definitely need to try this recipe then!

[@sydneybristo22]

Lovely! Thank you. As an American I prefer it cold and thick hehe. But as a topper I do like it thin and warm so I like both? But over all def cold is my go to for eating.

[@Downshiftology]

I think I'm with you there, but both ways are honestly so delicious 😊

[@rickykalendarov1176]

Thank you Lisa. Is there a way to sub the dairy ? Which milk should i use to make it dairy free but still yummy?

[@anaksunamun1888]

This looks delicious! Can this custard recipe be used for making bread pudding that needs to bake in the oven?

[@ranupassi9544]

Very nice 🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@Downshiftology]

Hope you enjoy 😊

[@ManinderjeetN]

How would I modify this recipe to make a white chocolate creme brulee? Great job love your channel ans cook book. Keep it up, keeping us healthy

[@girlonaswing9439]

Definitely warm

[@angelicahewston4672]

Amazing as always!! We are in the search for homemade gluten free gingerbread house! I'm thinking my basic cashew frosting to keep it dairy free but have no idea on the colorings

[@susannenadeau9894]

Chilled!

[@Downshiftology]

Chilled custard is always a win!

[@wondersofcrim]

Hello love your recipes. Do you have a carrot cake one? ❤

[@Downshiftology]

Yes! I have a carrot cake recipe here: downshiftology.com/recipes/gluten-free-carrot-cake/

[@wondersofcrim]

@@Downshiftology Thank you! I'm going to try it out. 💕

[@brendafarris7350]

YUM! Terrific options. ummm....I guess I would prefer the warm, but both look amazing. Tho I love all your vids, It was fun to see/hear you speaking at the end of the video.

[@Downshiftology]

Thanks for your feedback and glad you enjoyed the talking at the end! 😊

[@dorothyelizabeth1559]

I’ve never made custard using honey, always with sugar so happy to give this a go. Will make them tomorrow along with the flourless choc cake!😅

[@Downshiftology]

Hope you enjoy both desserts!

[@VioletTakacs]

I like to mix everything up while everything is cold and bring to simmer while constantly mixing and of course till it thickens. This way I cut out the xtra step of adding hot mixture first to the egg mixture.

[@VioletTakacs]

and I prefer it warm but love it cold as well. I also like it in my crepes

[@lauraellen189]

Both ways 😉

[@Oykyou]

We don’t have heavy cream in Turkey but just cream ( which we use for soups or making creme Shanti for example) what do you recommend to replace? :)

[@Susan-nn1ib]

Could you easily modify it to be a Boiled Custard (for drinking) for Christmas? Thank you!!!!! ❤

[@jessicae1314]

Do you have any suggestions for making it without dairy

[@godsgurl2231]

Just made this and it is good and pretty fast to make. The only thing i added was a pinch of salt that made it all the better IMHO☺️ Next i want to try a baked custard using a bain marie inthe oven…how would you describe the difference?? Edit: Unfortunately my custard did not set up even after chilled😔 I followed recipe exactly...still tasted good though, just prefer a denser custard, so I will also try a recipe that's baked but also calls for a few whole eggs and 2 yolks

[@carmenn5609]

looks delicious, is this like the British custard?

[@suzisaintjames]

10:10 I have pyrex bowls, but the lids don't have that tab... is that new? Or something else?💖🌞🌵 😷

[@janetthompson1372]

The custard & cake sounds yummy. I have made your mug chocolate cake which is lovely if you want something quick & yummy for one person.

[@Downshiftology]

Yes! This would be great with my chocolate mug cake as well.

[@jenniferharris7633]

Lisa, when I was little, my grandmother always made my favorite dessert: baked cinnamon raisin rice pudding with a cold pourable vanilla custard on top. She's been gone many years and I never got the recipe, and I cannot figure out how she kept the custard from "congealing". It was an egg based cooked custard like yours, but stayed pourable when cold. Any ideas what she did different from yours?

[@heikeferdinandt7258]

❤❤❤

[@sophieg8522]

Will this work with canned coconut milk for dairy-free?

[@_solange]

Replacing milk for coconut milk could work?

[@naturallygorg85]

My custard is still liquidy how do I thicken it up? Should I place in freezer?