How Bengal Lost ₹760 Crores to TATA GROUP

The Tata Nano Singur controversy was a controversy generated by land acquisition of a proposed Tata Motors automobile factory at Singur in Hooghly district, West Bengal, India. The factory would have been used to build the compact car Tata Nano.
Tata Motors started constructing a factory to manufacture a car, Tata Nano which was estimated to cost $2,500 . The small cars were scheduled to roll out of the factory by 2008.
The state government of West Bengal created the controversy by citing the 1894 land acquisition act rule to conduct an eminent domain takeover of 997 acres (4.03 km2) of farmland on which Tata Motors was supposed to build its factory.[1] The rule is meant for public improvement projects, and the West Bengal government wanted Tata to build in its state. The project was opposed by activists and opposition parties in Bengal.
Leadership positions within the Singur Krishi Jami Raksha Committee ( SKJRC - The Committee to Save the Farmland of Singur) were held by the locally dominant Mahishya community, who are the chasjami malik (landholder) or owner-cultivators of the region
🔔 Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @powertrain
OUR OTHER CHANNELS
⚪VLOG CHANNEL - / @aakashbhavsar2342
⚪FOOTAGE DEMOCRACY - / @footagedemocracy3663
⚪SHORTS CHANNEL - / @powershorts1068
FOLLOW US ON
⚪INSTAGRAM 1 - / aakash_rb
⚪INSTAGRAM 2- / powertrain_yt
⚪FACEBOOK - / powertrainofficial
⚪TWITTER - / powertrain_yt
⚪DISCORD - / discord
_____________________________________________________________________
INTRO MUSIC IF PRESENT - LEMMiNO - A THOUSAND YEARS
• LEMMiNO - A Thousand W...
CC BY-SA 4.0

[@bhikariman-sigmamale]

As a Bengali I think Bengal is beyond repair because of commie mindset. Now we know why Gujarat is soo much more industrialized than West Bengal.

[@agonnoga6100]

You are no Bengali but a Bengali hating bhaiyya from BIMARU states. If Gujarat is so developed then why Bengal has far more bhaiyyas than Gujarat??

[@agonnoga6100]

@Harrappa if India breaks up into 30 independent economies, then condition of Gujarat and much of BIMARU states will be like Pakistan. Out of 9 crores population of Bengal there are 2 crores whose mother tongue is Hindi and not Bengali. There are 30 lakh Nepalis. There's large Jharkhandi, Odiya, Punjabi, Marwari population in Bengal. If you remove the large migrant and immigrant population from the population of Bengal then per capita GDP and HDI of Bengal will be among the best in the union of India. Right after 1947 West Bengal has only faced discrimination and economic embargo from the government in New Delhi just like East Bengal used to face from Islamabad prior to 1971. After Bangladesh gained independence from Pakistan it is leading on every front and left both Pakistan and India far behind in almost every indicator and parameter. India was not supposed to be governed centrally by one political party but as a federation of autonomous states. This is what the 1946 cabinet mission plan was all about. Both Congress and Muslim League accepted this plan but this plan was vehemently opposed by business houses profiteering under centralized British rule. Since Congress was basically a puppet of these business houses it had to withdraw its consent to the cabinet mission plan. Withdrawal of Congress from the cabinet mission plan led to the partition of India and not Hindu Muslim divide as we have been led to believe. So, 1947 was not independence but transfer of power from the British to the allies of the British. Real independence will only happen when power moves from New Delhi to the states.

[@JackBoys-tm7oo]

And mr bhikariman bengali, go to Gujarat, shame on people like u who defame their own home state

[@VALAR_Morgulis.]

Vote to BJP and make suvendhu adhikari CM... Then bengal will not just repair but it will run like super car...

[@VALAR_Morgulis.]

​@@agonnoga6100so much bhakwas and non sense... Why should india break into 30 different economies in the first place and you are in your own delusion Bengal is suffering with over educated idiots with woke mentality and BJP will get power in next elections

[@Tir2002]

Now i got it why mumtaz said " Bangal ko gujrat banne nahi denge " 😭

[@mayberishabh]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@tukaidas1272]

Her real plan to make greater bangladesh 😭😭😭😭

[@vikha2182]

​@@tukaidas1272and she is gradually progressing towards that goal, but hindus of WB and central government sleeping

[@Dipankarr_]

​@@vikha2182ha. West Bengal er hindu ra pagol na. Jedin amader gola kat te suru korbe sedin bujhte parbo amara? Btw BJP lost because of Kolkata area. We North Bengal supported

[@sauron2000000]

@@Dipankarr_ North Bengal used to be Naxal Bari. Now it is Amit Saha ka goshala.

[@Hey1234Hey]

Bengal didn't just lose TATA. They sacred away all other potential MNC to set up manufacturing in Bengal. The loss is beyond thousands of cores. Thanks mamtaji

[@AT-vq6nu]

calling that bitch ji lol ?

[@Lusyhong]

West Bengal per capita income $1500 Gujarat per capita income $4350 😢

[@nirmalyamisra]

what is the median income instead of the average income? One ambani income can screw up the average

[@nitya5120]

​@@nirmalyamisraAmbani income is just 1 dollar. He has major shareholding that's why he is rich.

[@metatron-scribeofgod6572]

​@@nirmalyamisraamabani is in Gujarati but he lives in Bombay

[@demoon45]

​@@nirmalyamisrabro are you insane ambani has wealth, salary doesn't mean anything to him That's avg "income" ambani has negligible income

[@dholakpurkirakhi434]

​@@nirmalyamisrahis income effects in Mumbai not In gujrat 😅

[@rudrasingh883]

ha ha Now, when Bengalis switch on their lights at home, they can truly say that the money goes to Ratan Tata's pocket. 😂😂😂😂

[@BOSS_OFFICIAL_atheist]

Dot hate bengali 😡😡😡, only a political party do this

[@dealchemyst]

You mean Tata Motors’s bank account

[@rameshwarsingh6192]

​@@dealchemyst I think he say about electricity tata power😊

[@SujitLama-ud9np]

Bhai bengali na bolke Bengal ka cm ke bare Mai bolne se acha hota pura koom ko kiyon bol Raha hai

[@SujitLama-ud9np]

@@Parvultraobtusa tum konsa qoum se ho ek baar batana fir mai tumhare quom ki history bolta hu

[@AstonishingBuffer]

I'm from Odisha and I have a Tata Nano CX model and a Tata Punch. When I was in my school many of my classmates troll my Tata Nano due to its small size body and it's sound like an autorikshaw and call it's a Turtle. I'm a proud Tata owner and I support Mr. Ratan Tata ❤ and his way of modernising India and its netizens.

[@LtMewS]

same bro but we have sold our nano now and only have punch .. we want nano back i want to buy nano not just because of its great experience in city but also to honor the brand.

[@adeysarkar6089]

I'm from Westbengal. I sadly confirm that one of the reason why Westbengal is behind at this point of time was this singur case. If tata operated their factory here then Westbengal would have grown faster. Because of this tragedy a lot of brands doesn't want to come here in Westbengal as they fear this will happen again

[@sauron2000000]

Bigger investment lost was from Selim group.

[@debdeepmukherjee1373]

Titagarh say high...

[@sauron2000000]

@@debdeepmukherjee1373 High Chota Bihar Tittu Gore.

[@Robert-sb8ew]

Now vote for mamata banarjee 😂😂😂

[@AT-vq6nu]

good you deserve it now they are begging other states for investments

[@bot609bot]

Ironically bengal infra related pages and channel spreading lies that mamata wasn't related in TATA exit from bengal. Had TATA been there, state would have earned money and provided jobs rather than paying back TATA as compensation. Also a lesson to be learnt: Arundhati roy is more dangerous than snake.

[@DarthV-wy3mj]

Truth said in clear words.

[@ghananath3556]

Bad decisions by the government in the past can be easily seen in the current scenario west bengal which was one of the richest states in the past is far behind gujrat in terms of gdp and some people still could not accept the facts.

[@dhruvilkumpavat6037]

Yep kaha 1500 per cap or kaha 3000, kaha desh ka 30% Industrialization or kaha 5

[@sauron2000000]

Waste Bengal was never rich.

[@koushikghosh4105]

​@@sauron2000000bengal nearly hold 25 percentage of world gdp during Bengal sultanat...

[@sauron2000000]

@@koushikghosh4105 Waste Bengal formed in 1947.

[@koushikghosh4105]

@@sauron2000000 But United bengal is immortal....

[@PradhanmantriBruhh]

These Marxists policies have harmed Kerala as well. No big industries are there in Kerala today and almost every malayali works outside Kerala to earn money.

[@rushabh.parmar]

damn!!

[@blazingguyop]

Bro full debt here bro And cm says to come here and do business

[@proudKGF112]

@@blazingguyop are you a malayali

[@subhashishbagchi3191]

@@proudKGF112 I am Bengali and I can confirm that Bengal became poorest state of India because of communist mindset and anti business mindset.

[@proudKGF112]

@@subhashishbagchi3191 But still Bengal has more factories & Kolkata is the 3rd richest city by GDP I belong to Odisha & here we have same issues no major industries & IT companies

[@subhashishbagchi3191]

I am Bengali and I now I feel ashamed to introduce myself as Bengali. I do not understand why Bengalis are so anti Business and anti industry?? Bengal's economy is the example how not to run a state, it is a failing state and now it has turned into one of poorest state after Bihar and Odisha. This truly horrible to live in Bengal in your productive year. Bengal has economy like Venezuela and Wokeness like USA that is why Bengal is one of the under developed state of the country.

[@rohitsawant5805]

Are there any Hindus left in West Bengal ? Every Bengali I have met in Mumbai is either a leftist atheist with commie leanings or Some random big orange beard muslim having surnames like Alam ( I have doubts they are all Bangladeshi but they all have aadhar cards from Malda, WB ). The only Hindu Bengali I have met are from Tripura. 🤔

[@subhashishbagchi3191]

@@rohitsawant5805 Most muslim Bengali you meet in Mumbai, Delhi or Kerala are illegal Bangladeshis with fake Indian ids. There exist huge chunk of Intellectual leftist elite in Kolkata but yes there exist a huge proportion of true Hindus but they are not vocal or influential like lefty loonies from Kolkata. Remember one thing Woke people from Delhi doesn't represent whole North India similarly Kolkata lefty loonies won't represent Hindus from Bengal.

[@अभय_अग्रवाल]

Don't say this bro, we are all Bharatiya. Rather feel proud to be a Bharatiya 😊 Aaj gujarat aage hai kal bengal aage hoga. We all have our own problems. Ultimately Bharat hi aage badh raha hai.

[@mkgaming990]

​@@अभय_अग्रवालbahut sahi bro but we should help Bengal state as they have everything just need some management

[@shashikant3150]

Bengali bulla community unitedly vote for mumtaj begum. As we all know nothing matters for bullas except jannat and 72 hoors but Hindus want to see development in India. So, why don't Bengali hindus vote unitedly for BJP??

[@Saptarshi_Das_]

Tata Nano Exit from Bengal was one of the key factor of West Bengal De-Industrilization which is why Startups and even large companies also doesn't want to come to Bengal till date in 2023.

[@sumandutta4834]

De-Industrialization started since Communist rule. Nano project was a golden opportunity provided by Ratan Tata to re-industrialize West Bengal. But West Bengal chose to remain de-industrialized.

[@marathi_manus467]

bengal is Bihar 2.0. idk why these people dont vote for good parties. dont they want development.

[@axel3895]

They have superiority complex without any superior trait

[@agonnoga6100]

Condition of Marathis in Mumbai the capital of Maharashtra is that of dalits and untouchables. Without Mumbai, Inner parts of Maharashtra are worse than Bihar. No wonder Maharashtra leads in farmers suicide.

[@sarthaksingh7217]

Bengal has economy like Venezuela but wokeness like USA

[@subhashishbagchi3191]

we have 30% peaceful people and 20% Leftist loonies so Bengal is a poorest state in the country.

[@physicsonline8853]

@@sarthaksingh7217 Very good comment!!

[@ninjamrtal6510]

My respect for Maharashtra on development basis increases a lot,,,who maintain the top position in gdp lasted 70 year's

[@kashyappatel2640]

Gujarat State Always Welcome Tata.👍🏻

[@karanmadan1048]

Relationship.

[@b.v.437]

​​​@@karanmadan1048you are right Tata have good relationship with gujarat and Gujarat don't have so much communist influence and gujarat government trying to invite companies and people of Gujarat is more business friendly compare to West Bengal.

[@karanmadan1048]

@@b.v.437 thanks thou would prefer both correct on their own grounds.

[@user-wn8ib1dx4r]

​@@b.v.437your Gujarat is amazing business manufacturing

[@dejikay2564]

Fact is that this WB/Mamta fiasco caused Tata Nano to be delayed massively which made people lose interest and then the Indian lower middle-class also rejected it and kept buying the Maruti Alto or 800 till it was discontinued. Tata Nano was a solid product but aimed at the wrong Indian audience whose mentality is to look rich no matter what.

[@_dyson]

True

[@bekindfornoreason5246]

I am from ODISHA,i had gone kolkata for 1 month and what i had seen ,it is completely differ from reality.Everywhere was corruption,peoples are job less,humantarian index is low,living standard was very bad and that public transport bus it was a garbage.In my 23 yars age,i have not seen that type of bus,very bad how people are living there.i appeal to WBs youth that PLEASE CHANGE YOUR STATE. And i was looted by govt. officials there,that day i swear,i will not go WB anymore.

[@sigma_beta007]

We don't care 😂 Don't come

[@bekindfornoreason5246]

@@sigma_beta007this is heartbreaking.this mind set will bring you down,this is not progressive mindset.i am not your enemy brother.I really want you to be a develop state.we are one country,If one part is defective then whole country can't grow. so.please take at positive and accept the truth.

[@Crispr_cas9th]

Transport part is so true.. Its trash... So dirty and broke

[@akashnayak5778]

​@@sigma_beta007hamba hamba like your Mamata Begum😂

[@dhruvilkumpavat6037]

Sometimes I think its better to have dictatorship like China so they can focus on thing, these protesters see one thing and take away so many positives away. Glad I am Gujarati and I love Tatas. Industrialization here is unreal, thanks Modi Sahab ❤

[@pabitraproblemandsolution4833]

Bengalis are a nation who never want their own good.

[@Hey1234Hey]

Really? China's fake house of card is collapsing right now. All it takes is one insane retarded dictator to destroy everything. It's very easy to destroy but harder and slower to build. Democracy does a decent job.

[@b.v.437]

Gujarat don't have so much communist influence and gujarat government trying to invite companies and people of Gujarat is more business friendly compare to West Bengal.

[@varun2250]

From Andhra, I resonate with you more or less the same. Sad to see my own province going the West Bengal and Kerala way from a once progressive, Capitalist friendly past.

[@SumanMondal-tk4fk]

Kindly correct your statement -- No big or small company has set up its plant in SINGUR .. it is a barren land .. if you want to check the reality come to Singur and have a look by your self .. The investor summits that happens every year our WB Govt has not been able to attract one single anchor investor in the state ...

[@alap1983]

The Video creator appears to have a soft corner and bias towards the Current West Bengal Government. There has been no improvement. Only deterioration of the State. The Current Government Murdered any possibility of industrialisation and is now survomg because of Relgion Politics.

[@DailyHacksAlpha]

Coz m0mta aint gonna lick after spitting..

[@koushikghosh4105]

Currently Rhagnatpur industrial corridor is attracting good investments....like -shree cement,captin steel,rasmi mettalics, shyam steel etc..

[@user-wn8ib1dx4r]

​@@koushikghosh4105those are msme only little jobs no development not mncs or big industry manufacturing iT etc whatever. I have no hope for west Bengal till completely you people change anti business poverty loop mindset

[@civilengineermanojkumar2436]

Mai 4 years tak West Bengal me job kiya tha. Aur mujhe pata chala ki yaha ke logo ki kitni gandi aur ghatiya soch hai. Communism ne Bengal ki economy ko destroy kar diya lekin yaha ke bina dimag ke logo ko yah baat aaj bhi samajh nahi aayi. Aaj bhi maximum log communist mindset ke hai. Mamta didi aur kuch nahi balki communism ka latest version hai. Yaha ke log sarb kuch government se expect karte hai. Bengal ke politics me nahi yaha ke logo me kami hai. Yaha ke log bina mehnat ke haram ki khana chahte hai. Hath me lal katora aa gaya lekin lal salam dimag se nahi gaya. Dusre States me jakar sasta labour work kar rahe hai lekin apne gande se dimag me ab bhi momta didi hai.

[@SayakMunshi]

Bangalis love to criticize when it comes to Politics. Being a 28year old, I have seen the CPM era, the ongoing TMC era and I am certain, no matter which Political party replaces this one in Bengal (if they do), the situation of political enmity and violence will still remain the same. Its the same people changing party colours when it suits them.

[@chintansolanki2852]

Someone like Yogiji can change the state

[@mayberishabh]

This video being made purely on facts is being called propaganda against bengal by some people? Why?

[@zeus-no2hv]

superiority complex, bengalis is always right syndrome, our state gave so many freedom fighters bla bla bla, do you want more resons?

[@sb-bw4lp]

Show them same video made by BBC also 😂at the end BBC is there dad😂😂

[@b.v.437]

@@zeus-no2hv Gujarat don't have so much communist influence and gujarat government trying to invite companies and people of Gujarat is more business friendly compare to West Bengal.

[@AlphaSierra380]

Rs. 1500 cr is tax payers money. Govt ko koi farak Nahi padega.

[@AR-ug1cm]

Govt. ke budget kam hoga aur wb govt. ke beurocrats ko ghar le jaane ke liye appx. 1425 cr kam melange 😂

[@Amit.AP26]

Wb deserves this happy bengal is going in drain.... govt is elected by ppl so govt is like its voters😂😂😂

[@SwastikKumar-nx3bw]

Tata means Trust 😊😊😊

[@munnatripathi1972]

Do you know tata have direct link with the group who control the whole world (us deep state/Bilderberg/illuminate)!

[@kaushiksarkar7837]

If it's so why it opened new battery plant in Britain

[@agonnoga6100]

Tata Birla made their wealth through opium trade under East India Company/British rule. This no one mentions in our history books.

[@munnatripathi1972]

@@kaushiksarkar7837 masters of tata british east India Company, yessss! in 1800s tata and many parsi trades traded opium with Britishers! Wonder? Tata bought JLR but didn't shift the manufacturing line to India why because JLR was gifted to tata by the US DeeP State mainly Bilderberg!

[@arpan9937]

It is a private company. The only thing they trust is money. But the WB govt. did a moronic deed.

[@soumadeepmondal4549]

We need those kind of leaders who has long vision for the future such as pm narendra modi.

[@sayantandas7063]

Chalo aaj Mumbai se bahar aaya hai ye ladka 😅

[@vishalkumar-ic2cq]

Modiji to tata : do din toh gujaro gujrat main ❤

[@youngs80s]

really West Bengal need new positive CM like Yogi ji''' for speed developments n security of state as other sates doing very well''' ,,,lets vote for new CM of WB soon''' make better state n best WB capital Kolkata'''

[@godx4gaming262]

Jab Tak woh rendi Nehi hategi tab Tak kuch nehi hoga sali rendi hamare bangal koh khatam kar Rahi Hain ... madarchod Pakistan bana Rahi Hain

[@ramizhossain3443]

Yogi or accha CM 😂😂😂😂 . Koi kaam nahi kiya hai yogi dongi baba ne 😂😂

[@godx4gaming262]

@@ramizhossain3443buslim spotted opinion rejected ...bhag bsdk

[@AtheistNationalist]

illegal bangal kangludeshi spotted@@ramizhossain3443

[@thepritamshaw]

​@@ramizhossain3443aur K2A jal gyi?

[@SaikatMaji2000]

As Bangali, i feel very disappented because of mamtaz government.

[@kdentertainment9706]

You should be disappointed for cpi too jyoti basu started the destruction of bengal during cpi era

[@SaikatMaji2000]

@@kdentertainment9706 agree with you

[@charvaka5705]

@@user-yi4jy1uh6d chutiye, ek inssan ke vote se koi fark padta hai? Napunsak centre ko bol na President's rule lagane? BJP bengal ne to bola tha.

[@jdjjdd620]

Tata trust on महाराष्ट्रा स्वागत आहे महाराष्ट्रात

[@VirginSellerGod]

Mamta didi did khela hobe with ppl of Bengal...😂😂😂😂

[@vishwanathsharonp9045]

Now CPIM is ruining Kerela 🙂

[@Shadowcat561]

But isn't CPI M the one which brought TATA to bengal.It was mamta bannerjee who destroyed bengal

[@Dipankarr_]

CPIM is better than TMC

[@kdentertainment9706]

​@@Shadowcat561no brother The destruction of Bengals started when CPI came in the power in 1977 TMC is destroying more

[@piyushtekade3915]

Yeh sab mamta didi kr wajah se hua, pahile unko hatao aur bjp ko lao fir development work karna wb mein.

[@agonnoga6100]

Yes just like they have done in Maharashtra.

[@KnowledgeEnthusiast]

​@@agonnoga6100I'm from Maharashtra, and my state is in far far better position in infrastructure economy industries compared to ghatiya WASTE BHIKARI KANGAAL aka WASTE BENGAN BENGHAAL

[@axel3895]

​@@KnowledgeEnthusiastit takes forever to set up a factory in maharashtra, it's the most corrupt state in country. Even basic stuff like getting noc takes years. Only super rich industrialist can setup their factories in maharashtra

[@KnowledgeEnthusiast]

@@axel3895 fake news peddler spotted 🤣

[@axel3895]

@@KnowledgeEnthusiast speaking from experience, don't believe me visit your local SDM office

[@Amritpro_21]

I live near by west bengal singur and i m in Mumbai I love tata motors ❤❤❤

[@itzbridze]

West Bengal needs military force for the 2024 vote Because most of the state police are corrupted.

[@AryanChawla-my3ew]

Mamta Banerjee should be kicked off From Chief Minister Post

[@KoushikPaulliveandletlive]

You are wrong. Tata is not the biggest looser. It is us, people of west bengal.

[@Dipankarr_]

Ekhono ki lok jon bujhbe na? Tao to sei Mamata kei vote diye jacche

[@HelloMedicAnkit]

To bhy 2011 te Oke anachile kano?? Ki dorkar Chilo...ami 2011 te TMC ar against a chilm , vote ar por amake oneke onek kotha bole Chilo...but ajj bujhte pari ami tokhon oo thik Chilam akhkono thik acchi...ami Mamta ke khub ghenna kortam ...kano jano?? Sudhu ay Singur ar incident tar jonno ar ghenna ta ato choto Bala thake Chilo ja ajj oo jayni moner moddhe thake😂

[@knighthacker2307]

Gujrati is 2X richer than Bengali....Many Bengalis are working in Gujrat....It's a shame

[@MukulPande-gh7pm]

×2.5

[@ChandanMishra-ql1bi]

Cos Bengal doesn't manufacture anything and it doesn't have any resources and the government is worse, bribery and corruption is very abundant too

[@techdevloper2340]

And fir log bolte hi sare projects gujarat maharshtra and karanataka me hi kyu jate he 🤥 Agar policy hi sahi nahi hoga to companies kaha jayegi ha achha policy and industrial environment he

[@abhishekyadav2008]

this shows how politician can destroy a state even if businessman want to develop the state

[@anishagarwal5853]

1st time didi looking decent .your thumbnail 👍👍 I am from Bengal and l know how she is 🙏😭

[@shreyashnikam6043]

Aur lao romba romba government west bengal me😂

[@pabitraproblemandsolution4833]

পশ্চিমবঙ্গের বাঙালি লোকের থেকে গুজরাটি লোকেরা অনেক দক্ষ।

[@apurvaazadnande1190]

Agreed With everything but the allegations that courts take 2 months of Vacation which is delaying the matters is Wrong, Coz the quantum of Productivity of Indian Judges of SC is higher than any other country's judiciary, plus the matter was decided by an Arbitral Tribunal not by a Court of Justice.

[@rushabh.parmar]

thanks for the info

[@harshgupta_india]

no other country has so much cases pending and such a large population.Even if the productivity is high it needs to be even higher(several times higher)

[@Drxyz-tk6le]

Arbitral Tribunal courts.... Doesn't mean... Lack of justice. Let the govt go to the court. They will lose like anything. Because Remeber this is not about govt of West Bengal vs Tata. Not TMC vs Tata.

[@karanmadan1048]

Saw sardarji selling kerala really cheap in hotel. Saw a film showing problem between agriculture & industralist. Worker of singur plant puzzled to answer with the transfer of factory possible.

[@Drxyz-tk6le]

Arundhati Roy, Medha Patkar.... 🤣... If their names comes up, they are the worst kind of people in the world.

[@nikhilpatil8149]

And now she is dreaming to be a prime minister 😂

[@anandkumarsharma9380]

Bangal and Bihar are Same.

[@shoo8873]

Bengali hate Bihari

[@SOCKETBHAI12]

Mamata Banerjee and there party members have lots of money 😂😂

[@jec_ecart]

Nah. Taxpayers lost. 😡

[@BarisonMega]

🌟🌟The only thing which I can say is Mamata Banerjee photo used in thumbnail was photoshopped and cleaned 😅....rest what u said is 100% true 😭 and we bongs are facing the grunt 😥😢😢😓😓

[@parvadhami980]

Didi OoO didi 😂

[@bengalelectrical4375]

Joto bar aai topic ta dekhi Kanna pai

[@sujoy6116]

Still today Bengal failing to attract mejor industry's.. infact last 15 years in major business conference we didn't see any Big investment.. Trinomuler created a major eyewash for people 🙏

[@friendshipcharging7657]

Why be progressive When you can be communist ~every bengali ever

[@sksaifuddin4864]

Tata nano phir se ana chahiye...

[@JojoBoy-gh4gb]

Bengali politicians themselves have destroyed Bengal, single-handedly 😂😂😂😂

[@ankitghosal9324]

So she basically pushed Bengal 10 - 12 years back for no concrete reason, just for her political gains 😒

[@user-zl3ju7pj4w]

How can you write in thumbnail Bengali people lost... please correct it..

[@joydeepboruah1083]

Hamba hamba ramba ramba😊

[@testmail9065]

Lavde na bhujyam

[@dipjyotibarman2837]

See the difference between singur and swanand after these years

[@aniketmehta1]

Main gov ne galat land diya agr land fertile thi wha 2-3 crops lgte the ek season mai...so it was a big deal..

[@sb-bw4lp]

Nah tata company gets are not fertile land but you know you can't find fully non fertile land in West Bengal it's all happened because of commie and Marxist thinking

[@aniketmehta1]

@@sb-bw4lp actually mai ek documentary si dekh rha tha wha wo bol rhe the ki jo land allotment huyi thi wo 3-4 crops vali thi. Baki total infertile land to nhi milegi wo to sahi hai.

[@sb-bw4lp]

@@aniketmehta1 hear in Maharashtra midc is is Allocated in fertile land it's all about what you want you can't only pick farming both industries and farming are important but commies are totally socialist mindset we know what happened with our countries economy when socialist ruling our country thank god because of 1991 situation got critical and because of imf government started capitalism

[@sb-bw4lp]

@@aniketmehta1 yah land will be fertile and we are talking about West Bengal . Bengal ki maati bohat fertile hei

[@aniketmehta1]

@@sb-bw4lp ha bhai wo to muje pta hai yh apne time ki sabse bdi news thi.... Or iske parinam unko kudh mil rhe hai.... Maine visit kiya hai bengal ke kuch areas i know

[@VOID_24.]

West Bengal ko UT bana dena chaye

[@jitpaul9489]

Bengalis are happy with ciggerate and chai and obviously adda

[@ashiqdey]

Being a bengali I am ashmed, I wonder why didi keeps wining? people sre so stupid that they dont know the pros and cons of industry. BTW I am from assam

[@kartikvohra25]

Humba Humba Bumba Bumba

[@arkadas1110]

Bro some of the information you told that is wrong. TATA group left wb because of political reason. Compare other states which surrounds west bengal you can get to know how much we developed and how much wb.

[@sumansarkar6984]

Ekta golpo balo 1st rank kara students Jkn 20th rank kare tkn o 10 Jon r age thake but ota ke celebrate karar kichu nei. Jdi Bangla r karun abostha dekhte chau tahle kno din Chennai train ta dhoro tahle bujbe bengal r jubo samaj kothai jache kaj r sandhane. R last 20 years odisha ka developed kareche r Bengal at present state a developed karle dekhben odisha agiye geche. Assam o developed karche ble rakhi Assam ekta land log state Bengal r mto port pain ni. Bihar o ekta land log state. Ekn bengal ke other land log state r sathe compare karleo bujte parbe Bangla kothai.

[@Nontouristicindia12err]

Remove kolkata population and and gdp from your state u will get tje result..bengal is just like bihar jharkhand..cuz of kolkata being old metropolis its give little edge..othewise visit village of bihar bengal..jharkhand condition same..u r in fools paradise if u think bengal is deceloped than up bihar..still in bengal ppl wash their pots from nearby pond can be seen through train easily..and kolkata was for complete bengal presidency ..ppl from migrated their from all this eastern region of country from 21st century ppl have stopped going kolkata cuz there r not much opportunity their ppl prefer..mumbai delhi banglore.

[@AmishKumar-lc7zs]

No need to compare with other states. Just compare with East Bengal from 1947 and see how much west Bengal is fu*ked up.

[@user-wn8ib1dx4r]

Bihar = west Bengal 😅 very soon

[@ChandanMishra-ql1bi]

​@@user-wn8ib1dx4rBihar is better than wb

[@pvr10]

22k views 4.5Lakh likes 😂

[@debdeepmukherjee1373]

Can someone please explain why in Singur why not in Durgapur industrial area where you can found 1000 acres with relative ease. Durgapur is well connected with road, rail, near to jamshedpur, having good auxiliary industrial base, educational institutions, water from damodar, and very reliable power source and land is not that fertile. But in sigur where land is very fertile. This place are not to far at all...

[@user-wn8ib1dx4r]

You people be less income farmers with 10% commission in apmc till earth ends 😅 we don't care 💯 🤷

[@AIGMateYT]

Expect a Party Everyone needs Jobs but .... Everything is History now.

[@bidsvon6379]

That same person who opposed tata is now begging her way to industrialists to set up in Bengal but mostly in Kolkata It’s a sham and Bengalis in Kolkata are proud of it at the expense of vast impoverished rural hinterlands in the state Due to this the entire eastern India suffered. The only major city post independence which suffered downfall is Kolkata and is continuing to do so.

[@prateekSpace]

neno is a great car

[@testmail9065]

Spelling seekh ke aao

[@kaushiksarkar7837]

Still Shen tata collided with ciaz it crap the hell out of ciaz a car which is 7 times costlier

[@amarjitkumbhar]

Ek yeh bhi karan tha nano ka fail hone ka

[@ninjamrtal6510]

West Bengal= indian Mexico

[@sumandutta4834]

Unlike West Bengal, Mexico is attracting industries due to global supply chain restructuring.

[@HRaj-zl7in]

Such Mr yarr congress k jamane ki glti pure deah ko ek tarah sr bugatni parr rahi hai, "Andha Congress Party".

[@jayaramnarayanan8752]

Mamta banerjee strongly opposed Tata as a result of which they left West Bengal and is now reaping the benefit of minus 760 crores + Interest to be shelled out to Tata.

[@Parvultraobtusa]

🤣🤣

[@evkagyan8598]

Now Tata Bought Ford Plant Is Sanand

[@mechanicaldesignhubforu]

Shame on the gvt

[@jaspritbhumra...kingofyork8470]

Mahesh dwalle gann main ek sahi lyrics tha.......*mamta mamta motherboard, Mamta mamata motherboard 😂😂

[@brokendevil2150]

Mamata hai to mumkin hai.

[@i.sapnadip]

I am a Bengali. And i want democracy

[@sanurawat1651]

This shows not every protest is credible

[@Aditya-gm8uf]

Mamta - humba humba rumba ramba

[@rushabh.parmar]

this is a good case study for other states and poeple to elect goverment on their way of working. this is my and your money😢

[@quietprofessional9928]

Mumta begum screwing Bengal as ever ...😂😂

[@avikchakraborty2286]

Actually it was just a political game to grab the power in West Bengal. Mamta Banerjee just thought only about her own political future not the Bengal's future.

[@brunbarbatista]

basically let them be a farmer so that politics could happen.

[@OFFICIALCOOPERSUN]

Ma khud Bengal ma raha ke a baat kehe sakta hu ki itna faltu government mane aj tak nehi dekha.

[@adivmt]

WB ppl responsible for there future

[@subratadas2395]

This hurt me and not only me but generation..that time this project was dawn of West Bengal but current CM Mamata Banerjee ruined it all turned into a nightmare which is still going.. can't believe people still vote for her..but this nightmare will end.

[@aryanbarnwal5645]

Dada, then why do you vote for mamta didi

[@kz-zd6lf]

west bengal totally waste becase of some leader

[@Mallikarjun-g]

Mamatha attacked tata employees, 40 were injured .

[@swapnadeephaldar5751]

BENGAL IS NOTHING NOW A DAYS IF COMPARED TO WHAT IT WAS IN PAST…

[@swapnilmalshe]

West Bengal is unfortunately the worst state of India for any business from every aspect.. let it be land acquisition, safety, infrastructure, skilled hardworking manpower, burocracy, corruption... everything!

[@AnOrangeOrange1000]

What A Tight Slap To anti-Hindus!!!

[@studentknowledge123]

Isi kaand ki wajah se bengal me koi investment nahi karta.

[@SouravDas-ru1ou]

west bengal awful corrupt goverment and ngos i have seen over 10 years its really pity i don't think current governmet can develop west bengal and i hate west bengal cm

[@aryanbarnwal5645]

Dada, then why do you vote for mamta didi

[@somenathroy2014]

Left govt wanted to built everything near to Kolkata. Once CM Buddhadev said all Industrialist's first preference to build their factories in Durgapur areas they don't want to see other areas. Left govt had force TATAs to build at Singur. What Mamata did wrong! See said Why govt should acuare lands? why tata not doing itself? why factory on highly furtile land? why 400 acares forcefully captured? If govt gave up 400 acares, they will purchase its against. but they never talked to mamata due to their egos. My question, why Congress and BJP both fuelled Mamata's protest? That time CPIM was wrong and all were right, now TMC is wrong but all are right.

[@souviksikdar1864]

The government needs to acquire lands before hand , because scattered land over a large area is difficult to individually negotiate. Plus the government can subsidize the land cost ,in return for certain developmental commitments. This is a win win for both. Gujarat has this model. It is fast and efficient. But you people will not get it. Your minds have been brainwashed. Step outside and look at other states. You will come to know of the kind of poverty that WB holds. I wish to come to WB , but my relatives tell me to stay away. My father went back there ,he said his city looked the same as it was 20 years ago. That is your so called development. Mamta Banerjee knows only one thing ,that is to protest, she is not a visionary. 21st century WB needs progressive leaders not Rudimentary 90s Dharna specialists.

[@tanmoyco.8218]

Both CPIM and TMC were responsible for Singur Issue.