How Israel came into being ‘at the expense of Palestinians’ | Roy Casagranda | UNAPOLOGETIC

[@komarchucky3456]

Polish man named Milikowsky changed his name to 'Benjamin Netanyahu' for look like jewish.

[@BeeBee-ck8bc]

An Egyptian born in Cair0 on August 1929 by the name of - Mohammed Abdel Rahman Abdel Raouf Arafat al-Qudwa al-Husseini. Before he migrated to the H0ly-Land, he chg his name to Yasser Arafat and later he claimed he was the indigenous people of the H0LY L@nd😂

[@PodcastCentral333]

he is jewish, and has semitic feature, looks a bit like bashar al-assad.

[@PodcastCentral333]

also, the only reason they had those European names was because they had lived in Europe for 2000 years after the romans had kicked their ancestors out of the Middle East to Europe during the Jewish-Roman wars and Bar-Kokba revolt.

[@thurmansmithjr3149]

I suppose you don't know that during the Jewish holocaust half of those killed were living in exile in Poland. Did that mean that Hitler killed them for being poolocks ?

[@Obit0bi]

​@@PodcastCentral333if im from south India and my ancestors 2000ya were in iran,can I claim my land in persia back??😅😅

[@travelingjohn69]

As a black american I said the samething. Why Do a cowardice move and take land from people who did nothing to you when for over 2000yrs, you've been oppressed by Europeans?

[@andycaroll9977]

I asked this question many times in many platforms, Muslims welcomed Jews who were expelled from European cities, and under ottoman rule all faiths lived in peace for 401 years, just after zionists decided to take palastine that all this mess and apartheid started

[@alexross5518]

@@travelingjohn69 not sure where you get your history from, but Jews were second-class citizens in the ME. And they weren't "accepted" by the majority of the land when they came back in mass. There were numerous massacres and pogroms against them until they started to fight back. Their first leader there even tried to have Jews sent to Auschwitz. You should really do some reyon the history of modern day Israel and the events leading up to it's independence, as well as it's the first number of decades as a sovereign state. The Arab side has always wanted it's destruction, well before any "occupation" or settlements. Back then they were at least honest that they just didn't want Jews on any part of Mandate Palestine, even tho most of the Arabs who would reside there came after British rule and the influx of Jews had created more jobs, which they migrated for. Also, the Arab countries did fight with Hitler in WW2 and even expelled every Jew living in the entire Middle East, continuing their intolerance of any minorities in the area. Ex. There is a section of Gaza called "Slave Square."

[@Jasonb-b8q]

Evil

[@TheBreusty]

Jews were living on that land the entire time alongside the Muslim population. It therefore was not stolen

[@camrob1973]

@@TheBreusty They continue stealing Palestinian land to this very day. Illegal settlements everywhere. And now Trump wants to "clear out" the population of Gaza to Egypt and Jordan. Ethnic cleansing of Palestinians has been the consistent goal of Zionists.

[@jamamohamoud2665]

Any kind of religious you believes, whatever cultural norms you have, or what type of ideas u have all of it doesn't stop you to Saying "Israeli committed a genocide in qaza".

[@mikkayosef8008]

100%

[@arcane4848]

That’s a hard argument to make when Gaza provoked Israel since 2007 and even harder when the Palestinian population has not stagnated or decreased.

[@iska788]

Yawn

[@adhuna1009]

​@arcane4848 really? Oh look there's 2 million of them, so killing 40+k isn't really murder? Person A killed my family, so I can go on a killing spree and kill everyone? What law school did you go to?

[@adhuna1009]

​@@EGF1000 by that idiotic reasoning, the holocaust/genocide in WW2 never happened because there are still Jews in the world? what kind of nonsense is that? good lord you people will deny everything up to the point of lunacy.

[@LibanDohdhe]

Who else is addicted to roy casagranda ?

[@pazdylan1873]

i am ...please keep making videos that feed my prejudices...it makes me feel good about myself...

[@kriosgr]

@@pazdylan1873 All muslim shit are his fans. Have a good day.

[@KatherinePopham]

Me!

[@celestialknight2339]

“Most Zionists don’t believe that God exists, but they do believe that he promised them Palestine.” - Ilan Pappe, Israeli Historian

[@victormeidan1062]

@@celestialknight2339 Most Israelis know that Pappe is an unhinged lunatik. But those foreigners who read his books, think he is a real historian.

[@celestialknight2339]

@ Most Israelis don’t know ZILCH about their own history, so your brain-dead propaganda won’t work here. It’s sad that you have to blubber Ad Hominem attacks just to make a point, even though he is a seasoned expert historian whose statements (including this one) are widely verified & true. It’s funny that you mention Israelis, who Pew Research has confirmed are 65% atheist or irreligious, thus confirming his point. Go learn something before commenting, “Victor”.

[@celestialknight2339]

@@victormeidan1062 You know nothing. Also, most Israelis are atheist which only prove his point. Sad that all you have is Ad Hominems; I suggest you do better, and embrace facts.

[@bernhardschaefer5740]

@@victormeidan1062I think the unhinged lunatic is someone you know quite well…

[@BeccaBow010]

Thisbis actually funny b.c it's so true!!

[@Simon-gv6uh]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="638">10:38</a> my fathers family were part of this mass fleeing and my grandmother still had the front door key to this day

[@janmortimer1758]

😢❤

[@FreePalestine07.10]

My Uncle also has the key.

[@toktammovahedi827]

😢

[@scottloffman6141]

My grandmother had the key of the house that she had to flee in Poland. She never got her house back either. That's what happens in war. Suck it up.

[@noragutberg]

I also have the key to my family’s house in Lithuania - so what?

[@OliveTree-dd5vp]

Free Palestine 🇵🇸

[@echoe4806]

It’s Israel today and there is nothing you can do about it.

[@bm_wuratli6883]

@@echoe4806 it's what?* idk even YT don't allow me writing LUL how ironic*

[@andrewgraham9593]

​@@echoe4806 The world has woken up to the crimes and lies of Israel, and to the arrogance displayed by pathetic persons like you. Israel will not last.

[@olivetree633]

​@echoee4806 nothing built on a weak foundation stays around for long. The foundation is definitely crumbling

[@echoe4806]

@ Agree.After 1400 years of Arab colonialism it did happen and the Jews came home.Usually big empires are crumbling not small tiny countries…..

[@مينون4456]

Anyone in their right mind would never stay submissive and silent while their land is being invaded.

[@victormeidan1062]

Yes. That is the very lesson that Jews have learned from their history. A very welcome point !

[@londinromani6407]

@@victormeidan1062 You can come and live as a Palestinian, as it was always, but coming and taking the land, cuz thus was 3000 years ago, and killing its inhabitants that's called genocide in modern times..! it's interesting, that you hyenas want to live "democratically" in modern times but with a mindset 3000 y.a.

[@JacobRothman]

Who invaded what land jerk

[@thetruthunveiling]

Jews always have to be the victim in every scenario 🙄​@@victormeidan1062

[@SM-B1]

@@victormeidan1062🤮🇮🇱🤮

[@ahmednaji7501]

Very well delivered. Greetings from Palestine.

[@Mr.SharkTooth-zc8rm]

The ugly raw truth.

[@octaviodovalle6550]

Thank you!

[@criticalthought7527]

This talk needs to be converted into an illustrated explainer video, complete with footnotes. That video would be a tremendous tool that could be used to shut down the whole, 'well... its complicated' narrative. Regardless of my pipe dreams, I am ever so grateful for this talk and Roy's efforts to teach us about the genesis of what I call, New Israel. I will be studying and sharing this video whenever possible. Peace, Love, Health, and Freedom, to all who are fortunate enough to strive for these goals. 🙏 ct

[@starsian]

Thank you for sharing the truth. I wish I could like this video a thousand times.

[@JacobRothman]

Sharing the truth what utter rubbish

[@starsian]

@@JacobRothman You can go cry in the corner now.

[@scottloffman6141]

@@starsian Why do you accept this as truth? Have you studied this conflict? Have you read the Bible? You would benefit from some independent research.

[@celestialknight2339]

@@scottloffman6141 You sound like a pseudo-intellectual. Anyone who seriously deep dives into the history of that diabolical nation will realize that it’s nothing more than a European atheistic ethnocentric military base who literally caused the Iraq War, the assassin. of JFK, and most of America’s other troubles-as they squeeze the soul out of their taxpayers’ wallets to fund their ongoing ethnic cleansing of the Palestinians, and the gradual erasure of the Middle East (which they fanatically believe belongs solely to them, and will usher in the Messiah’s coming). On top of this, they are a nation which is 65% atheist/irreligious (according to the best polls), and who hold the #1 largest annual LGBT+ parade in the Asian continent, while their religious books slander the Virgin Mary as a dirty harlot and call her son Jesus a fraudulent sorcerer who was rightfully hung. This is their narrative-and yet they have successfully duped & tricked 99% of American Christians (ostensibly including youn) into supporting their ill-conceived oppressive & evil cause, under the wing of your naive ignorance of their true plans & motives. All the while, it is the OTHER side (the Palestinians), who are ethnically, culturally, and religiously closer to Jesus himself; and who do not call him a fraud, but faithfully accept him to be the true Messiah sent by God, and born to the blessed Virgin Mary. And it is their land which has been unjustly stolen from them. “Most Zionists don't believe that God exists, but they do believe that he promised them Palestine.” - Ilan Pappe, Israeli Historian

[@Аида-х2г]

Он просто еврей.., ничего отличного,

[@BradLevangie]

And now at the expense of the world......

[@JacobRothman]

Really go back to school

[@walterpal7248]

@@JacobRothmanoh don’t b such a Q l KE

[@chadwhitfield6946]

Lmao

[@adukabu]

He is on point here, 100% on point factually

[@EGF1000]

Actually it's total deliciously fact free boule sheeet

[@JacobRothman]

Moron

[@SM-B1]

@@EGF1000 You mean the supremacy ideology that’s imbedded in you head??🤮🇮🇱🤮

[@hiphopotal]

From the first sentence you could see hos full of shit. History did not start "after ww2"

[@onanysundrymule3144]

​@@EGF1000I believe Professor Roy, I do not believe you.

[@ytbmQC]

Roy is a true historian

[@JacobRothman]

Why because he feeds the Jew haters this guy is either a fraud or an idiot masquerading as an historian peddling HS got fools

[@JacobRothman]

I know that this Jew hater is peddling nonsense visit your local library

[@BenjaminBartelstein]

Palestine was born in Nazi germany do your research Arab never called there self Palestinians they called there sell Arabs the only people that called them self Palestinians were Jews. This guy is just a flat out liar with

[@danielsilverstein2522]

He is definitely either simply uninformed or antisemitic​@@JacobRothman

[@johnk4121]

Roy is a true historian of mainstream muslim anti-jew narrative.

[@cristinachirila5633]

Brilliantly explain. The world must open the eyes

[@cristinachirila5633]

Explained

[@jameshodgkins559]

The Balfour Declaration had a massive effect on the end of WW1, the biggest single thing. The Germans on the western front went home believing they were defeated at home by the strikes & the Zionist influenced politicians. Herr Hitler & his followers called it the stab in the back. The seeds of the Balfour Declaration ended WW1. It started WW2 & will most probably start WW3.

[@EGF1000]

Actually absolute nonsense by a nonentity that does not even warrant a Wikipedia entry

[@barneadror2405]

The only problem it’s not true….

[@alexten9961]

@@barneadror2405 I posted it above: "I know how to stop the world's and Arab's outrage against Israel. The Jews have to convert to Islam. Then the Pals and world would not care. The same way they did not care when Gaza was occupied by Egypt and the West Bank by Jordan. Nobody cared including the Palestinians. Actually, it will be funny. Jews convert to Sunny Islam. There will be home warming parties, "welcome to the neighborhood" signs. I can even imagine Arab Leaders whispering with a voice of Don Corleone: "Welcome to the family". Just turn on your imagination. It is a religious war."

[@Hawaiihawaii1423]

Thanks!

[@Nickg3486]

Yep. And how conveniently the West ignore this!

[@KingForever-zu5jl]

"Since 1948, we have been demanding the return of the refugees to their homes. But we ourselves are the ones who encouraged them to leave. Only a few months separated our call for them to leave and our appeal to the United Nations to resolve on their return." - Khaled al-Azm, Syrian Prime Minister, 1948-1949 "The Arab exodus from other villages was not caused by the actual battle, but by the exaggerated description spread by Arab leaders to incite them to fight the Jews." - Yunes Ahmad Assad, Palestinian refugee as told to a Jordanian newspaper in 1953. As an israeli arab i concur. We live near the Jordanian border. Mt grandfather was instructed to leave his home by the jordanian army, my grandad told them to get "f****d" and stayed. AND THAT IS WHY WE ARE STILL HERE AND OTHER ARABS ARE NOT. @rafewheadon1963 May 2024

[@joophoekstra8246]

The West initiated it. The Isrealiens were just Eastern European fortune seekers with empty pockets.

[@dadarcanon7825]

They born in the west

[@MuhammadAwais-l2j]

not ignore/ The West is complicit in genocide

[@christianlibertarian5488]

This statement contains too many falsehoods to not ignore.

[@facturacionborquez6341]

Roy Casagranda is God sent! So well read and his understanding of history is so well mapped out.. when he gives his opinions he says so and makes sure it doesn’t come off as factual… please please please make more videos of your lectures, for man kind!

[@steveseaman7794]

For someone so well read he makes an amazing number of factual errors, not to mention his unrelenting anti British bias, he certainly never let's the facts get in the way of a good story.

[@matthewleaman9326]

I knew this at school in history, it still makes me sick how israel was created, genocide and it still goes on today.free Palestine 🇵🇸

[@louisearon8520]

@matthewleaman9326 there's no country called Palestine it was an area known as trans Jordan ACTUALLY NO P SOUND IN ARABIC !!! JEWS HAVE BEEN LIVEING IN THE LAND FOR OVER 5THOUSAND YEARS ISLAM IS 15HUNDRED YEARS OLD !! YOU HAVE TO LIVE IN THE AREA THEN YOU WILL KNOW THE TRUTH FROM THE LIES !!

[@caomh6168]

Glad that it was taught in your school, where are u from?

[@louisearon8520]

@matthewleaman9326 very strange comment as over 2million Palestinians live in the state of Israel through choice !! You certainly don't live in either areas or have been to either areas islam is 15hundred years old and Judaism is over 5thousand years old !!

[@CarlosJohnTorres]

Israel has existed since before most states in Europe or even islam. So it was never created it was taken back from the ARABS

[@user-sc3gn6be3h]

You should also learn how Pakistan was created in religious lines and by expelling and killing millions of indegineous non Muslim population.

[@nikkibradley7280]

Love Roy. I watch all his stuff. What a breath of fresh honest air he is. Geeky and normal with a huge brain to contain all the information his does.

[@joes20]

Dr. Roy Casagranda is a great person, a great historian, and a great scholar in earth history.

[@michaelw2288]

Except for all the verifyable facts he gets wrong.

[@lamoitte1]

@@michaelw2288 You're right. Some, as Casagranda is, people's mind are set. They're easily confused with fact. Their solution to avoid confusion? Leave facts aside, then fabricate own's 'opinionated narrative'.

[@stevenlevy6119]

A great fiction writer.

[@stevenlevy6119]

Jews bought land. Jews always lived in Judea and Samaria. Arabs didn't welcome them. Arabs killed Jews in Palestine. Arabs were not designated as Palestinians at the time. They were call Arabs. The Jews were called Palestinians before 1948.

[@JOjibwe]

@@michaelw2288 I notice you couldn't list even ONE!

[@nureke-dp1nw]

Brilliant solution from the professor! 😂 Bravo, Sir 👏 Free Palestine 🇵🇸

[@DebbieMinzly-en2nb]

Free Israel from the antisemite.

[@baldndesi]

Sir Roy always showing bravery in his answers and lectures. These are the types of historians we will always need and always respect!

[@hala-alkhalili]

Please world open your eyes to the truth !!

[@EM.K024]

Fun fact almost all the EU infiltrator ministers changed their names to sound more Jewish Benzion Netanyahu instead Bensyjon Milejkowski, Shimon Peres instead Szymon Perski, David Ben Gurion instead Dawid Gryń, Golda Meir instead Golda Mabowicz, Yitzhak Ben-Zvi instead Izaak Szymszelewicz, Zalman Shazar instead Szneur Zalman Rubaszow, Ben-Zion Dinur instead Ben-Zion Dinaburg, Moshe Sneh instead Moshe Kleinbaum, David Raziel instead Dawid Rosenson, Yitzhak Shamir instead Icchak Jaziernicki, Eliyahu Ben-Elissar instead Eli Gottlieb, Aharon Amir instead Aharon Lipec, Israel Eldad instead Izrael Scheib, Shlomo Ben-Yosef instead Szalom Tabacznik

[@PodcastCentral333]

the only reason they had those European names was because they had lived in Europe for 2000 years after the romans had kicked their ancestors out of the Middle East to Europe during the Jewish-Roman wars and Bar-Kokba revolt.

[@BeeBee-ck8bc]

@@EM.K024 An Egyptian change his name From Mohammed Abdel Rahman Abdel Raouf Arafat al-Qudwa al-Husseini. To Yasser Arafat

[@EM.K024]

They were descendants of Khåzar Ukrainian converts from 6th century 😂 plain and simple, then they were kicked out all over EU 109 times for their corruption.

[@alizakessler]

And so? What is wrong with that??

[@alizakessler]

@@EM.K024 The Khazar myth has ben debunked many times.

[@darkweaverlp]

Thank you Professor. You are gem we treasure. Please keep spreading the ugly truth of Zionism.

[@victormeidan1062]

The professor is a typical academic swindler, sophisticated fraudster & intellectual conman. I really enjoy listening to high quality lies and elaborate half-truths. He is a very warped, Nutjob who vomits a steady stream of offensive nonsense.

[@louisearon8520]

@darkweaverlp interesting comment !! But what's a zionist ?.I lived in Israel and met many people from all religions and cultures but never met any zionists!! Ugly truth of zionism !!-could say the same about islam but I certainly don't have tunnel vision !!

[@onemessage5462]

Dr.Roy is so knowledgeable i love hearing his lectures to know history so we can understand the present situation

[@JacobRothman]

So knowlegible who administered the test

[@LuckyM83]

You clearly don't know shit. But you can still keep pretending to know stuff after watching a KZbin video..

[@victormeidan1062]

A Confused Conman vomiting out his lies. In other words - a typical academic.

[@JacobRothman]

The British did not Want the Arabs to gain combat exp Really is that why the Arabs fought against the. British in the Balkans whilst in the German army

[@SM-B1]

@@JacobRothman Surely AIiP@K influence-free minds and hearts The izr@hellli false narrative has been exposed everywhere now, 🤮🇮🇱🤮

[@UndoEverything]

Roy is very vocal and from a few who are not afraid of speaking the truth. I hope he will live longer.

[@mattg3789]

The guy literally botched up about half of the Israeli history explanation. It was horrible. I googled his name and found out that he has a reputation for glaring errors, and teaches at a community college in Texas.

[@warrenross011]

I totally agree. Total twisted story. ​@@mattg3789

[@MaxielleSplash]

@@mattg3789u right whatever the little hat guys say is correct

[@christianlibertarian5488]

He did not speak the truth here.

[@bravovas334]

he speaks his truth!

[@lisalisa1656]

Then they steal their land culture and food and try to deny their existence

[@simko8665]

How did they managed to steal their land and when?

[@Badgerbeard]

@@simko8665 Read "The ethnic cleansing of Palestine" by Ilan Pappe and the Balfour declaration. Its mostly there.

[@barbarag.269]

What culture? Name one Arab Palestinian writer, leader, artist, scientist??????? Especially one not living in Israel?

[@mikelynch-zeroviewz2507]

Pakistan was created much like Israel.. partitioned from India to protect the Muslim minority .. 12 million displaced and almost 1 million were killed during this process... 22 new Muslim countries were created after WWII.. but Israel is not ok ? ... despite all being passed by a valid UN vote mandate ? .. their hypocrisy is astounding 😢

[@johnstergioulis8366]

Exactly , 🇮🇱 the Evil Zio’s steal 🇵🇸 their land , food and culture then deny their 🇵🇸 existence .

[@donnrutherford7059]

The question Why didnt the western colonial powers not stop this as it was in violation of the UN charter The UN should have saved all these years of the fascist occupation of Palestine from ever being the cruel ongoing genocide its been US UK France and Germany You all have the guilt and blood on your hands for this

[@bobnto]

The UN at the time was controlled by Europe and countries of the Anglo-American diaspora. They didn't want to have to accept any of the Jewish displaced persons languishing in Europe and were indifferent to the ethnic cleansing of the Arabs, so Israel was accepted as a "peace-loving" member of the UN in 1949.

[@donnrutherford7059]

@@bobnto the mindset or propaganda over collective guilt for the holocaust of the west was a powerful political tool for israel and its actions in Palestine

[@echoe4806]

@@donnrutherford7059The land was called Judeea anyway so they went back home.

[@bobnto]

@@echoe4806 😂

[@raufjaleel8317]

​@@echoe4806😂

[@TruthFound]

Be careful Roy, You will no doubt be labelled an anti-semite 😂😂😂

[@bernhardschaefer5740]

Be proud to be an antisemite if that term relates to Zionists and their sick fascist agenda.

[@user-k4t8z]

you guys really are poor people. you should be sad that these are the best guys you have. yes, he may seem funny to you, but this is the exact reason why you are just marxists and muslims vandalizing through streets and a couple arab states making use of their UN majority. no one takes you seriously because you make clowns of yourselves the whole time. this is why you have achieved nothing. jokes and lies wont help you. you need genuine honesty and good faith attempts at solving the issue of jihadists, otherwise Israel will always control the West Bank and Gaza.

[@JacobRothman]

This Roy is an out and out liar read the history if a high school kid wrote this on an exam he would get an F Minus What a farce

[@JacobRothman]

He. Is a liar big time and an absolute crackpot

[@rigelb9025]

I thought 'anti-zionist' was the new expression.

[@norandomness]

Before the jews came from Mesopotamia land of Canaan was part of Egypt We claim western Arabia, Palestine, Levant and southern Turkey in the name of Amun Ra, the ever present. To deny us is antikemetic

[@LuckyM83]

Romans conquered the land are you really that dumb going back that much? Jesus was a Jew , born in a Jew land . do you understand this simple thing? Jews where already there 2k years ago.

[@charleswatts3810]

Are you saying these lands, including Lebanon, were a part of Ancient Egypt?

[@janapender4989]

😅❤

[@enverbeganovic106]

So I can just walk in to your house and claim it because My god told me I could? Ohhhhh I get it. That makes sense. NOT!!

[@LuckyM83]

@@norandomness well history happens, war happens and land are lost. Make peace with it. Countless of kingdoms and nations had that land and passed the ownership over the next one. Other wise roman empire was still here and that land under the law of Rome. Would you want that?

[@frederiquecouture3924]

Hopefully, everyone understands that finally and financially.

[@patgallagher6814]

Whilst I find him relatively fascinating to listen too, I believe that his view on why Britain's voted for Brexit is a gross oversimplification of a very complex subject in terms of why perhaps people voted the way they did, take a long hard look at the way the ECB treated the Greek people's own personal finances within their own banking structure, Trudeau pre Trudeau in their approach, read Yananoppolis's book, increase your knowledge on the subject a bit more perhaps professor ,before castigating aspersions on our democratic vote against a mightily un democratic institute.

[@Jone4f]

This history teacher fails to say that Palestine was so named after the area was called judea. The Roman Empire changed the name to Palestine. Arabs and Jews lived together. Palestine was much larger than it was even in 1948. The Jordanians and Egypt took large swaths of that land for themselves. No one says a thing about that right now.

[@ucouco78]

Correct, Arabs either practiced Judaism or polytheistic religions before Islam. Palestine is a Roman name given to the area to destroy Jewish identity.

[@richarddeturner]

Nice try but Egyptian writings from the 12th century BC used the name Palestine to depict a region of the Canaanites land. The ancient Greeks then used it again in the 5th century BC, roughly 400 years before what you allude to. This is ACTUAL history not the fictions from the torah and the old testament.

[@ucouco78]

@richarddeturner nope, you are confusing with the ancient philistines. Palestine is a Roman name. You are wrong.

[@ucouco78]

@richarddeturner the ancient philistines and the so called Palestinians are not the same people. Arabs in those times either practiced Judaism or worshiped tribal deities. Islam didn't come around until 650 years later.

[@richarddeturner]

@@ucouco78 Nope, no confusion here me old mucker. Philistine is what the the peoples of Crete called it. Yes some nomadic 'Arab' tribes worshiped Judaism but we call them hebrews or jews now but most of the Canaanites worshiped El and Ba'al and many other gods. I never touched on Islam but hey thanks for playing.

[@pcarr3127]

I didn't vote for Brexit to get rid of Poles, but to get out a imperialist technocracy, just saying)

[@BeutyTruth67]

It’s amazing how one can sound knowledgeable and flip the story on its head. For example the comparison to “Austria relocation” well, Austria was in existence, but Palestine at that time was never a country nor a national movement. Also it was 90% empty with only 10% of the population living now. There is no mentioning of the Jews inhabiting vast areas, including dessert, swamped land and empty sands like tel aviv it can clearly be seen with areal photos from these days. Also the dynamics of 48 war are distorted

[@steveknight878]

However you look at it, there were far fewer Jews in the area than Arabs. But the Jews were given a far larger percentage of the area.

[@PatrickByl]

Truth spoken.

[@MashaDunna]

And senator in america said palestine doesn't exist only israel? Or did he mean AIPAC exist?😂😂

[@DrumHead23]

Wait till he finds out about a place called Palestine in Texas or East Palestine in Ohio

[@moudzy1446]

Great historical narrative. Thanks professor Casagranda. We’d love to hear more from you.

[@abealasto9043]

Until you hear the history narrative from the other side!

[@ObserverMan-i1e]

​@abealasto9043 he's not Palestinian so what other side 😅

[@DK-ss1vu]

This shouldn’t be controversial. Israel literally stole the land.

[@HisMessenger-wf5qd]

Israel stole the land of Israel?

[@shams8395]

​@@HisMessenger-wf5qd😂😂😂😂😂 That's what you think, not us. You know what we're seeing now.

[@victormeidan1062]

@@DK-ss1vu how can the Jews stole Judea ,? Did the French steal France ?

[@imbored1179]

@@HisMessenger-wf5qd there was no land called israel pre 1948. israel is the name of a man and later became the name of a tribe whom the vast majority of early zionist settlers have no blood relation to

[@viviano07-j9o]

oversimplified take on a complex history. Jews have a historical connection to the land going back thousands of years, and modern Israel was established through a UN resolution in 1947 that proposed two states-one for Jews, one for Arabs. The Jewish community accepted it; Arab leaders rejected it and declared war. Yes, the conflict resulted in tragedies, including displacement, but it’s not as simple as ‘stealing land.’ Both sides have suffered deeply, and peace requires understanding the full history, not reducing it to slogans.

[@BooglestationTermoil]

As a 1/4 Buddhist 1/4 Christian, 1/4 Muslim and the other 1/4 from my mum´s dad´s side are Hindu,, in theory I get a free house in most of the world.. God told me i can have a Valley in Tibet, a Farm in Congo, an island in Indonesia and a Tea plantation in Kerala.. I´ve decided to raise my kids Jewish so they can get a water front condo on Gaza beach. God said it !! Not my fault.. Go n argue with God about it, n leave me out of it !! Iff you don´t like the plan that´s just because you don´t like GOD.. god hater!!

[@white_orange]

Exactly the Zionist logic. It would've been witty if it wasn't true. 😓

[@behuman3801]

Faith is not inherited race is You are not Muslim at all if you are even 0.00001 percent of the other Don’t confuse your self Religion cannot be inherited Yes when are born , regardless of to which family, we all are born in Islam Then as we come of age we decide what our religion is according to our conditioning or our thinking and contemplating And to search and research and think and study and compare then decide is right way

[@BooglestationTermoil]

@@behuman3801 😊Exactly..

[@EM.K024]

I know, logic of a godless thief 😂 and now murderer, rapist, all in the name of a myth.

[@hassoeni21]

😂

[@charlesmrader]

This is incredibly one sided and it quite different from what I have heard. Now to be fair, I was ten years old when this was happening. But I remember the Jews in the holy land (as it was then called) thinking that it was unfair that they were given (by the UN) almost all the Negev Desert and not give any of Jerusalem, but accepting that anyway. I also remember Arabian countries NOT in the holy land deciding that they wanted to get control of pieces of the holy land, and encouraging local Arabs to flee, to get out of the way of their invading armies. I remember very clearly, even though I was just a little boy, than nobody thought the Israelis could defeat the Arab invaders because they were too few, had minimal weapons, no heavy weapons, no clear authority over one another, no money, etc. It does look as if the Arab invaders were ultimately incompetent but the first few months of the war were all Israeli defeats. And I remember very clearly that in the subsequent decades, the surrounding Arab states did NOT give the Palestinian refugees any help, such as letting them freely leave the refugees. There's another thing I remember very well. England had, just a short time before leaving Palestine, left India, not because they didn't want to rule India, but because India, led by Mahatma Gandhi had, by nonviolence, shamed England to leave. I remember this so clearly, even though I was a little boy, that after WWII, all the adults I know were sick of wars and saw in inspiration in Gandhi's non-violent method. In the holy land, the adversary from before the war was the same country, England, which had been shamed into leaving India, but nobody in the holy land seemed to think Gandhi's idea was appealing.

[@LibanDohdhe]

All u wrote is irrelevant point nothig have to do wit topic......let me make simple for u where were isreal before 1948 ?

[@michaelethnan9822]

@@LibanDohdhewhere it has always been bro

[@donaldleider7382]

Great historical narrative, if only it were true!

[@RedXlV]

That bit about Dreyfus is very inaccurate. He was not in any way an ethnic German. He was ethnically French. And the anti-Dreyfus faction in France was quite open in declaring that they considered him guilty despite all proof to the contrary solely because he was Jewish.

[@Meirstein]

The thing about Dreyfus was that he was from Alcase, which is a part of France that was captured by the Germans in 1871, and had a strong German aspect to its culture. Alcasians in the army did have some suspicious placed on them, but with Dreyfus, the responses especially from the general public were dripping with overt antisemitism.

[@RedXlV]

@@Meirstein At the same time, the fact that Alsace populated predominately by Frenchmen who also spoke at least some German made Alsatians actually preferred to become officers in the French Army, since they had more familiarity with the nation's primary enemy. And Dreyfus in particular was known to be ultra-patriotic toward France. Which was also common among Alsatians, who didn't appreciate being conquered by Germany.

[@adebayoemmanuel911]

The moment he said Egypt tanks are ill-equipped. I became lost 😂. That’s a big fat lie.

[@samuelnguru6311]

Egypt was powerful at that time

[@michaelethnan9822]

I was wondering the same thing. He was good at concealing his intentions until it got to that part. How could he said that the Egyptian tanks couldn’t turn well 😂

[@flimbar]

He portrays things as if the Jews never had any connection with the land of Israel. It's their ancestral homeland, there have been Jews living there for thousands of years.

[@brianbadonde8700]

3000 yr history......that began in 1948

[@steveknight878]

And there have been Arabs living there for thousands of years - many or most of which are Semitic.

[@7frodo7]

@@brianbadonde8700yes because nobody ever found any ancient artefacts from the kingdom of Israel that existed before the romans even brought the name of Palestine into any existence. 🙄

[@brianbadonde8700]

@7frodo7 the Jews living in Israel today 98.5 percent do not have Semitic DNA 🧬, they have no "blood ties" to the land, the Religion we practice was also practiced by the people who lived here 2000 yrs ago soooooo we're just gonna take it, you know why ? because we can and we know you're not strong enough to prevent us, the Jews can come up with every excuse they want according to their God their book, they're the chosen people bla bla bla, it's just one group taking land from another with force and keeping it through force

[@johnstergioulis8366]

⁠@@brianbadonde8700Exactly 👍, 3000 years of Israel 🇮🇱 established in 1948 and Palestine 🇵🇸 was erased from Wikipedia Maps by Google Israel 🇮🇱.. lol 😂 Vampire thieves Israel 🇮🇱

[@coincrazy3563]

I love how academics have convinced themselves that Jews are entitled to sovereignty at the expense of everyone else

[@RobertSmith-lg7jp]

If you studied the history of this area even just a little bit you will know this guy is spot on. If the Jews decided that they should have the same amount of land as their population compared to the Palestinians, Israel might have worked. Even that wouldnt have kept conflicts to zero, because far right extremists on both sides have always been the problem.

[@JacobRothman]

Smith you do not know what your talking about visit you local library this guy is an evil liar read my comm ents before they are erased please

[@TheBreusty]

WRONG! If Arab neighbours hadn't attacked Israel on the day it came into existence as a country then Israel wouldn't have had to push them back and ensure its security. You can't start a war and then complain when you lose - as has happened many time since the 1940s.

[@joeypeleg152]

Twisted logic

[@ThunderxBoy]

This channel is literally the definition of "No jews No news"

[@Rosamrisen]

Doesn't change the facts though, not even slightly.

[@shuelahmed9392]

It's amazing

[@mikeg2306]

I did Notzi this coming!

[@adirabinovich]

BTW, he's not a hiatorian but an academic of government, and he sucks at that too.

[@user-jw2bk1ny3m]

Dr Roy a good hearted man... And a real historian...

[@steveseaman7794]

Anything but, he is great self publicist who rarely let's the facts get in the way of his biased narrative.

[@lesking6541]

British person here. I need to point out that the assertion us British voted for Brexit in order to get rid of Poles (or any other ethnicity) is incorrect (as well as being disrespectful). Do a bit more research.

[@JacobRothman]

You can’t take this guy seriously He is totally wrong in fact laughable The British did not want the Arabs to receive military training rubbish the Arab s fought British troops in the Balkans wearing German uniforms whilst Jews fought under Gen Montgomery in North Africa as well as in Italy under their own flag

[@milanm403]

Well i was there for years leading to brexit. YES. you did vote to get rid of Poles and Eastern Europeans. OK, half of the voters in UK are from INDIA and they voted for the same reason(but to bring more Indians). Now you will have the other half from Africa. You treated blacks better than Poles, so suck it now.

[@JOjibwe]

It was an example. Anti-immigrant, or nativist, sentiments had many sources. They were fueled by economic competition over jobs, housing, and public services, but also by religious, cultural, and political biases. Those beliefs were often intertwined with racist views of immigrants that saw them as debased, immoral, and criminal. Remember that the subject of this discussion was not BREXIT.

[@Binic2]

Professor Roy Casagrandra, Ph.D.. teaching at Austin Community College, is clearly misinformed. Alfred Dreyfus was NOT a Jewish German officier in the French Army. He was a French officer, born in Mulhouse, a French city, educated at the elite Ecole Polytechnique, in Paris. His family fled Mulhouse when it was annexed by Germany in 1870, that does not make him a german.

[@calbudd2838]

Very well said and explained

[@JacobRothman]

Very well said this guy is a liar read the history

[@boscodeoliveira5752]

It started well before the holocaust. The British betrayal of King Hussein was despicable. The Balfour declaration was a lot more important.

[@haimsuslew1212]

I enjoy learning from you. All I learned here is how to twist facts to fit an imaginative narrative.

[@JC-sd3vh]

The "British wanted to evict Polish immigrants" !! Well that is a sweeping misunderstanding right there!

[@InformedGlobe]

He just talked about the only "democracy" in the Middle East 😂

[@echoe4806]

Is there any other demogracy in the Middle East?

[@InformedGlobe]

@echoe4806 There's none. There has never been one. Not even in the Western world, what there is, is a kleptocracy.

[@echoe4806]

@@InformedGlobe Still better then the desert stuff.

[@InformedGlobe]

@echoe4806 Right, just like jews don't want war, just genocide.

[@HAMISHEASTONMACKAYDAWSON]

Apartheid and democracy is an oxymoron, so the idea that Israel is a democracy is patently ridiculous and untrue. A Brooklyn Jew can come and go, but an indigenous Palestinian has no right of return.

[@tmi9074]

So this dude felt the appropriate Jewish homeland is Austria? Okay dude.

[@gwarlow]

A state born out of a religious myth and a whole bunch of Western guilt. What could possibly go wrong? 😮

[@refiperetz8542]

Omg what a BS history leasson i

[@christianlibertarian5488]

The statements made about Palestinians being welcoming to Jews after WW One has no basis in fact. Arabs were shooting and bombing Jewish settlements in 1923. The idea that Israel created the war in 1948, not the invasion by surrounding Arab states, is preposterous.

[@jeremyy8509]

I was gonna say the same thing. He conveniently skipped some important events. Also, how is the idea of forced relocation of Austrian citizens better than relocating any other population??

[@boxerfencer]

As an aside, the Austrians speak a form of German, but they're primarily the descendants of Celtic tribes, not Germanic ones.

[@JacobRothman]

This Roy is a fraug read my comments before they are erased

[@Markunator]

It doesn’t matter if their ancestors were “Celtic” or “Germanic”; those demographic terms are completely obsolete and haven’t been relevant for millennia. What _is_ relevant is that Austria _was_ a part of Nazi Germany during the entirety of the Holocaust and World War II, and that Austrian men served in the Wehrmacht and were Nazi party members and overrepresented in the SS; and also, both Adolfs - Hitler _and_ Eichmann - were Austrians!

[@boxerfencer]

@Markunator oh I understand obfuscating the true ethnicity of Austrians is important to your agenda, but my comment is simply in protest of the categorization of Austrians as genetic Germans. As I understand it, they're are demonstrably not so. Let's bring some more context to non German participants in the German war effort. There were approximately 1 million foreign volunteers and conscripts who served in the Wehrmacht during World War II. These individuals came from various countries including Belgium, Czechoslovakia, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Ukraine, and the United Kingdom. Additionally, there were many Soviet citizens who joined the Wehrmacht forces as Hiwis (or Hilfswillige). So does that mean demographic differentiation between European nations whose citizens participated in the Wehrmacht "completely obsolete and" not "relevant"? If so, are we to assume all these nationalities are German? It's obvious and more to the point that what has your knickers in a twist is a presumptuous idea that differentiation between Austrian and German ethnicity suggests absolving Austrian citizens of WWII war crimes and crimes against humanity culpability, which is premised on the idea of collective punishment by way of casting guilt onto a broad and arbitrarily fictional ethnic group. Your line of thought solidifies as "you did the crime, and made up offenders in great numbers, therefore you're German!". All quite Shakey and fallacious thinking, since it doesn't function as a syllogism. Neither numbers, nor criminal activity make you German, nor are these factors idiosyncratic to being German. Don't pretend to be able to decide for me what's important. I can do that without patronizing paternalistic hasbara. Thank you.

[@Markunator]

@ Yawn! Nothing I said was “hasbara”; it’s obvious that you just use that as a synonym for “Jew-shit”. This is a truly pathetic comment. Austria was factually a part of Germany during the Holocaust, all the other countries you listed were not. It’s that simple, and you’ve also just unmasked yourself as an antisemite by calling my comment “hasbara”! So, you can pretty much forget all about me treating you with literally anything other than utter contempt and condescension from this point onwards, by the way…

[@JackDazey]

Roy is the best. Highly knowledgeable and passionate about history!

[@pazdylan1873]

yeah he's a real tasty geezer.

[@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings]

Mind Begs the Question: ▪︎If God exiles a people from a land ▪︎For their Transgressions,Wickedness ▪︎To reestablish State with Messiah ▪︎If reestablish State without Messiah ▪︎Righteous or Wicked?

[@rose-mariemukarutabana9001]

Neither. Neither here nor there. The god of Israel is a nasty spirit, not the God of the universe. It's just a local version of Baal .

[@AntiZiocrusader]

As an Arab Mizrahi Jew from Babylonian Origins, I doubt the so called kingdom of Israel in Christian Bible.

[@realdeal7074]

ZIONAZIS/Romans probably twisted the bible to benefit themselves

[@alp2ccc138]

As a Texan Ottoman born in Constantinople, I never doubted One True God. Join Muslims against prpht kllers, Muslim means believer of One True God.

[@KuttuSan-k3g]

Israel is a prophet not a land.

[@realdeal7074]

@KuttuSan-k3g eyy?

[@realdeal7074]

@@AntiZiocrusader the bible was twisted by ZIONAZIS/ROMANS

[@sundownerII]

😂 imagine living with such blinkered deluded hate.

[@pazdylan1873]

Until the 1960s, the term Nakba was used by the Arabs themselves as a disgrace, a catastrophe for the Arabs because they lost the war and drove their own people into misery.

[@ahmadyusof2480]

Its the Zionist who drove everybody to misery. Without the help of US and Britain they will not win. US and Britain are their slaves.

[@uncledrew192]

It is an extremely lucid and concise account of the actual history. I commend you, sir!.

[@cbs63]

"The Jewish people are theonly people I know of who in thesame language, worship the samefaith, on the same land, in the samecountry, as they did 3000 years ago.That is a true indigenous people."

[@JacobRothman]

Lucid read my comments

[@marcratner9477]

Uncledrew - it is concise at the expense of truth and history. But Dr Roy is entertaining.

[@aremuola9464]

I would have loved to hear about the archeology of the land and its relevance to the whole issue.

[@williamThomas-fj3ju]

Wow this guy can spin. Distort galore

[@EmsThaBreaks441]

So the professor of history explains Brexit by saying it's about the British hatred of the Poles?

[@JacobRothman]

This guy is a fraud a cracpot and a liar visit your nearest library don’t take my word for it

[@JOjibwe]

But the original goal wasn't to kill them. It was just to evict them. You know, in the same way that, there's a there's a portion of the United States population that wants to evict undocumented immigrants, or that the German population wanted to evict undocumented Polish immigrants, or that the British wanted to evict the Polish immigrants, and that's why they voted for Brexit. Right? It's that mentality. Maybe reading will help your comprehension.

[@BeutyTruth67]

If he would dare to flip from his pro Palestine view to a pro Israel view he would lose his academic career

[@hadarrottenberg8743]

So ridiculous. Anyone ever wondered how Africa and Israel became arabized at the expense of all the indigenous nations that were there?

[@Adrian-S.]

What he said was essentially true in part but not correct: 1) there was always a presence of Jews in that area, since the bible time. Small numbers (so say 5000 souls). 2) Jewish emigration started in 1881-1882 from Russia and the Yemen. It was not "Illegal" as he suggested; people were free to come and go from the ottoman empire. 3) The problems between the Arabs and the Jews started around 1905, not 1917, as many Jewish settlements - perfectly legal - were attacked by Arab armed gangs. 4) The Ottomans started to harass the jewish population during WW1. for example - they kicked all the jews from jaffa which were left to die from hunger. 5) the Jews in europe were not ílligal immigrants'- they were certainly part and parcel of the countries which they lived in. He has a very twisted prism of the situation.

[@WhittakerAndy]

...even the Quran acknowledges that this tiny piece of land - the land the Quran calls 'The Holy Land' belongs to the children of Israel and, interestingly, never once is the name 'Palestine' even mentioned in the Quran.

[@abdulkhalidnashwan2072]

Qur'an also mentioned them being a cowards nation, because when they were told to fight, they disobeyed and leave Moses alone to fight for himself, even after all the favor God has given them. The results? They are being forbidden to enter that land for 40 years. God did promise them, if they obeyed His command though. But they didn't. Israel also is not a country in Qur'an, nor it is a kingdom. It is a nation, specifically, Children of Israel. Israel was never mentioned individually, it is always accompanied by "Children of" to make sure that it is basically a nation of descendants of Israel, which is Jacob. They aren't just Jews. Some of Palestinian are like an actual descendants of this people. Israel kind of strict with it's DNA testing, so we never know of the one who are Israelis today are truly Children of Israel Well, my point is, you might don't want to use just one verse from other's scripture to prove a point, especially when the consequences is you have to accept other verses that went and nullified against it. Have a nice day sir

[@malorix1164]

The question is..did israel died in front of the world in 2024..!!

[@ytearosh]

This guy just flat out lies non stop. This is unbelievable

[@ahmadyusof2480]

Everybody who discovered the truth knows it was not a lie.

[@GullyFoyle-s6q]

This an historian? Lol, Dreyfus never been a German. He was born as French and died as French. When the Germans in 1870 took the city. His family moved to Paris. You can't be more French than that.

[@generallee5330]

why when European Jews share their DNA results it’s show all European DNA? Lastly Ashkenazi in Genesis chapter 10 labels them as gentiles and a descendant of Japheth. Having some middle eastern blood doesn’t make you a Hebrew.

[@Libertà-r3y]

E una Bibbia falsa scritta tra 6⃣ e 9⃣ secolo D.Cristo soltanto 11 secoli fa .una coppia delle scritture Sumeri .per ulteriori dettagli cerca Mauro Biglino traduttore della Bibbia ebraica .

[@yayayabm]

You cannt build mountains of mountains based on lies and half-truth

[@TheologyWithLogic]

I made a video on this topic, there are astonishing similarities between Pharaoh and modern day J3wz - and the Israelites and today's Palestinians. The story told in Quran will give you goose bumps. It's shocking how Israh3|| is behaving/acting exactly the same as Pharaoh did. I have tried to provide all the verses from the Quran. That's the first ever video on my channel.

[@Flashh2124]

do you have a link i cant find it

[@TheologyWithLogic]

@@Flashh2124 It's on my channel. The very first video. KZbin won't allow links in comments section.

[@thurmansmithjr3149]

Which Pharoah ? If it's in the quaran then a story is what it is, a product of a pedophile war lords imagination.

[@alizakessler]

You are lying

[@TheologyWithLogic]

@@alizakessler I am not

[@michaelw2288]

Dreufus was not an ethnic German, he was a French Alsation Jew.

[@JacobRothman]

Dead on this guy is a lying creep his narrative is absolute crap

[@chadienlynda4076]

The Jews are very generous to share their land with Arabs from Jordan (Palestinians).

[@johnstergioulis8366]

The Jews are very generous ?? The mad moustache would completely disagree

[@TheBreusty]

The glaring omission from this story is the hundreds of thousands of Jews who already lived in Israel before the First and Second World Wars . When the British controlled the land, both Jews and Muslims were known as Palestinians. The distinction between Israelis and Palestinians only developed after the State of Israel was officially formed.

[@phillipmullis]

That is not the order of the 48 war

[@rst6592]

"The Palestinian population welcomed them [the Jews]"? Are you kidding? 1936-39? Hello? What an ignoramus.

[@shams8395]

Will you deny that documented and the arrival of refugees on board a ship

[@marcratner9477]

rst. Many muslim arabs of british mandate palestine did welcome jewish refugees. Of course many in the region were newcomers as well. And some from were jews, christians, bedouins, druze, etc

[@JOjibwe]

@@shams8395 Some people cannot imagine peaceful relations between Jews and Muslims...despite hundreds of years and hundreds of places that this happened. The propaganda they spread to justify the oppression requires a mythological history to support their hatred and sin.

[@_Z.K_]

Your dates are like 40yrs after the event. By this point the true colours, of the terrorist invasion, had shown

[@sharononeill6477]

Israel came into being in 1948 as a result of Lord Rothchild's letter to Balfour.

[@martinoneill5804]

Balfour never consulted with the people of Palestine before he announced the Balfour declaration. Zionists demanded that the declaration was not to be kept secret, the whole world should know. Balfour was also a strong supporter of the Aliens act an act that prevented Jews from entering Great Britain. Do people think that the Palestinians were so stupid that they did not know what a homeland for Jews really meant. A dim with, with half a brain could see that this was a recipe for conflict. The declaration of Independence by Israel, was also a declaration of war on the People of Palestinians, this is no longer your country now, we are now going to rule it.

[@juandeleon1665]

Jews where in Israel first Muslims built mosc on top of Solomon temple

[@eugeniohernandez5783]

I know plenty of Jews and Christain's who would disagree with always living in peace with Muslims in Arab countries, Just ask the Yemeni jews or Iraqi minority

[@hellblazersharif]

Anecdotal garbage

[@ephilippos]

Wow ! sounds like what Turkey did & still does now…i.e Syria for one!!

[@1031985]

“The Palestinians had nothing to do with the Holocaust.” That’s true. Because there were no Palestinians then, they were just Arabs. They identified as Arabs, and they STILL identify as Arabs to this day. There was no talk of a Palestinian states when Egypt and Jordan ruled those territories. Also - calling Israel a “colonial enterprise” shows you to be intellectually dishonest. Colonialism was when a European state created “colonies” under their rule in other territories, to take advantage of the area’s natural resources and send them back to the homeland. Israel does not fall under this definition and has no “homeland” that sent Jews there. It has nothing to do with colonialism.

[@steveknight878]

I'm unclear what it matters whether it is called Palestine or any other name. It is an area of land that was occupied by Jews, Christians, Druze, Arabs and others, living in reasonable peace. It is now a total mess. Good job, Zionists.

[@makalipo]

It was not only at the expense of Palestinians, but also in defiance of God’s will for the Jews. Even the Jewish Rabbi’s opposed Herzl & his plans to form a State of Israel.

[@MargaretKlassen]

Palestine land shouldn't have been taken from them and handed to the Jews. The Jews were Holocausted by the German Nazis. The land should have been taken from Germany.

[@johnstergioulis8366]

So did Albert Einstein he rejected the establishing of a Jewish state on Palestine 🇵🇸

[@danbendel7957]

A complete distortion of history

[@davidburke2697]

How can we view your podcast?

[@admanpaulandrew]

is this primary school history? This man is so simplistic it is a joke.

[@shiptube7836]

He tells so many lies his hair won't sit down.

[@JacobRothman]

I think this guy is a raving lunatic What school hired him Kids learn from him absurd